arxiv: v1 [gr-qc] 27 May 2018

Transcription

1 The gravitational clock compass in General Relativity Dirk Puetzfeld University of Bremen, Center of Applied Space Technology and Microgravity ZARM, 8359 Bremen, Germany Yuri N. Obukhov Theoretical Physics Laboratory, Nuclear Safety Institute, Russian Academy of Sciences, B.Tulskaya 5, 59 Moscow, Russia arxiv:85.673v gr-qc] 7 May 8 Claus Lämmerzahl University of Bremen, Center of Applied Space Technology and Microgravity ZARM, 8359 Bremen, Germany and Institute of Physics, University of Oldenburg, 6 Oldenburg, Germany Dated: May 9, 8 We show how a suitably prepared set of clocks can be used to determine all components of the gravitational field in General Relativity. We call such an experimental setup a clock compass, in analogy to the usual gravitational compass. Particular attention is paid to the construction of the underlying reference frame. Conceptual differences between the clock compass and the standard gravitational compass, which is based on the measurement of the mutual accelerations between the constituents of a swarm of test bodies, are highlighted. Our results are of direct operational relevance for the setup of networks of clocks, for example in the context of relativistic geodesy. PACS numbers: 4..-q; 4..Cv; 4.5.-g Keywords: Clock comparison; Reference frames; Normal coordinates; Approximation methods I. INTRODUCTION The question, how the gravitational field can be determined in an operational way, is of the fundamental importance in gravitational physics. In this paper, we demonstrate how clocks may be used in a general relativistic context. In ] we derived a generalized deviation equation by employing the covariant expansion technique based on Synge s world function, 3]. In particular we showed, how the deviation equation, and one of its generalizations, can be used to measure the curvature i.e. the gravitational field by monitoring the mutual accelerations between the constituents of a swarm of test bodies. This led to explicit prescriptions for the setup of the constituents of a device called gravitational compass 4], i.e. a realization of a gradiometer in the context of the theory of General Relativity. On the experimental side, modern clocks reached an unprecedented level of accuracy and stability 5 ] in recent years. An application of clocks for the determination of the gravitational field represents an interesting issue. In analogy to our previous investigation ], such an ensemble or network of suitably prepared clocks may also be called clock compass, or clock gradiometer. In this work, we show how an ensemble of clocks can be used to determine the gravitational field from the mutual frequency comparison of the clocks. dirk.puetzfeld@zarm.uni-bremen.de; obukhov@ibrae.ac.ru claus.laemmerzahl@zarm.uni-bremen.de The structure of the paper is as follows: In section II we workout a suitable set ofcoordinates which allows for the description of events in the vicinity of a world line. In section III we show how an ensemble of clocks has to be prepared to find physical quantities, such as acceleration and velocity, through mutual frequency comparisons of the clocks. In particular, in Sec. IV we determine explicit configurations for clock gradiometers which allow for a measurement of all independent components of the curvature tensor. We draw our conclusions in section V. Appendix A contains a brief overview of the notations and conventions used throughout the article. II. REFERENCE FRAME: INERTIAL AND GRAVITATIONAL EFFECTS Our previous work ] on the gravitational compass based on deviation equations made clear that a suitable choice of coordinates is crucial for the successful determination of the gravitational field. In particular, the operational realization of the coordinates is of importance when it comes to actual measurements. From an experimentalists perspective so-called generalized Fermi coordinates appear to be realizable operationally. There have been several suggestions for such coordinates in the literature in different contexts, 35], for a timeline of the corresponding research see table I. In the following we are going to derive the line element in the vicinity of a world line, representing an observer in an arbitrary state of motion, in generalized Fermi coordinates.

2 Year TABLE I. Timeline of works on coordinates. Spacetime Curved Flat Acceleration 9 Fermi, ] x x 93 Walker 6] x x 96 Synge ] x x 963 Manasse & Misner 7] x 973 Misner et al. 8] x 977 Ni 9] x x 978 Ni & Zimmermann ] x x 978 Li & Ni ] x x 978 Ni ] x 979 Li & Ni 3] x x 8 Klein & Collas 3] x x Delva & Angonin 34] x x Results in special backgrounds PN, Kerr, etc. 986 Ashby & Bertotti 5] x x 988 Fukushima 7] x x 993 Semerák 8] x x 994 Marzlin 9] x x 5 Bini et al. 3] x x 6 Chicone & Mashhoon 3] x Klein & Collas ] x x Turyshev et al. 35] x x A. Fermi normal coordinates Following 4] we start by taking successive derivatives of the usual geodesic equation. This generates a set of equations of the form for n d n x a ds n = Γ a dxb b...b n+ ds dxbn+, ds where the Γ s with more than three indices are defined by the recurrent relation Γ b...b n a := b Γ b...b n a n Γ cb...b n a Γ bn b n c from the components of the linear connection Γ a bc. A solution x a = x a s of the geodesic equation may then be expressed as a series x a = x a +s dxa ds = q a +sv a s + s d x a ds Γbc a v b v c s3 6 + s3 6 d 3 x a ds 3 + Γbcd a v b v c v d, 3 where in the last line we used q a := x a, v a := dxa ds, and Γ... a := Γ... a for constant quantities at the point around which the series development is performed. Now let us setup coordinates centered on the reference curve Y to describe an adjacent point X. For this we consider a unique geodesic connecting Y and X. We define our coordinates in the vicinity of a point on Ys, withpropertimes, byusingatetradλ b α whichisfermi transported along Y, i.e. X = s, X α = τξ b λ b α. 4 Here α =,...,3, and τ is the proper time along the spacelike geodesic connecting Ys and X. The ξ b are constants, and it is important to notice that the tetrads are functions of the proper time s along the reference curve Y, but independent of τ. See figure for further explanations. By means of this linear ansatz 4 for the coordinates in the vicinity of Y, we obtain for the derivatives w.r.t. τ along the connecting geodesic n : d n X dτ n =, dx α = ξ b λ α b, dτ d n+ X α dτ n+ =. 5 If other words, in the chosen coordinates 4, along the geodesic connecting Y and X, one obtains for the derivatives n Γ b...b n+ a dxb dτ This immediately yields dxbn+ dτ =. 6 Γ β...β n+ a =, 7 along the connecting curve, in the region covered by the linear coordinates as defined above. B. Explicit form of the connection At the lowest order, in flat spacetime, the connection of a noninertial system that is accelerating with a α and rotating with angular velocity ω α at the origin of the coordinate system is Γ = Γ αβ c =, Γ α = a α, Γ α = a α, Γ β α = ε α βγω γ. 8 Hereafter the spatial Greek indices are raised and lowered with the help of the Euclidean 3-dimensional metric, in particular a α = δ αβ a β and ε α βγ = δ αδ ε δβγ. For the time derivatives we have Γ = Γ αβ c =, Γ α = a α =: b α, Γ α = b α, Γ β α = ε α βγ ω γ =: ε α βγη γ. 9

3 3 see also the general solution given in the appendix B of ]. C. Explicit form of the metric In order to determine, in the vicinity of the reference curve Y, the form of the metric at the point X in coordinates y a centered on Y, we start again with an expansion of the metric around the reference curve g ab X = g ab Y + g ab,c Y y c + g ab,cd Y y c y d +. Of course in normal coordinates we have g ab Y = η ab, whereas the derivatives of the metric have to be calculated, and the result actually depends on which type of coordinates we want to use. The derivatives of the metric may be expressed just by successive differentiation of the metricity condition c g ab = : FIG.. Construction of the coordinate system around the reference curve Y. Coordinates of a point X in the vicinity of Ys s representing the proper time along Y are constructed by means of a tetrad λ b α. Here τ is the proper time along the spacelike geodesic connecting Y and X. By choosing a linear ansatz for the coordinates the derivatives of the connection vanish along the geodesic connecting Y and X. From the definition of the curvature we can express the next orderofderivatives ofthe connection in terms ofthe curvature: α Γ = b α a β ε β αγω γ, α Γ β = R α β ε β αγη γ +a α a β δ β α ω γω γ +ω α ω β, α Γ β = R αβ a α a β, α Γ β γ = R αβ γ +ε γ αδω δ a β. Using 7, we derive the spatial derivatives α Γ βγ d = 3 R αβγ d, g ab,c = g da Γ bc d, g ab,cd = d g ea Γ bc e + d Γ ca e g be,. 3 In other words, we can iteratively determine the metric by plugging in the explicit form of the connection and its derivatives from above. In combination with 8 one finds: g, = g α, = g αβ, = g αβ,γ =, g,α = a α, g α,β = ε αβγ ω γ. 4 For the second order derivatives of metric we obtain, again using 3 in combination with 9,, and 4: g, = g α, = g αβ, = g αβ,γ =, g,α = b α, g α,β = ε γ βδη δ g αγ = ε αβγ η γ, g,αβ = R βα +a α a β δ αβ ω γ ω γ +ω α ω β, g α,βγ = 4 3 R αβγ, g αβ,γδ = 3 R γαβδ. 5 NotethatR βα +R αβ +R βα, inviewofthericci identity. Since R βα =, we thus find R βα = R βα. As a result, we derive the line element in the Fermi coordinates up to the second order: ds X y,y α = dy +a α y α +b α y α y +a α a β δ αβ ω γ ω γ +ω α ω β R αβ y α y β] +dy dy α ε αβγ ω γ y β +ε αβγ η γ y β y 3 R αβγy β y γ] dy α dy β δ αβ 3 R γαβδy γ y δ] +O3. 6 It is worthwhile to notice that we can recast this result into ds X y,y α = dy +a α y α +a α a β δ αβ ω γ ω γ +ω α ω β R αβ y α y β] +dy dy α ε αβγ ω γ y β 3 R αβγy β y γ] dy α dy β δ αβ 3 R γαβδy γ y δ] +O3, 7

4 by introducing a α = a α + y a α = a α + y b α and ω α = ω α + y ω α = ω α + y η α which represent the power expansion of the time dependent acceleration and angular velocity. 4 III. APPARENT BEHAVIOR OF CLOCKS The results from the last section may now be used to describe the behavior of clocks in the vicinity of the reference world line, around which the coordinates were constructed. There is one interesting peculiarity about writing the metric like in 6, i.e. one obtains clock effects which depend on the acceleration of the clock just integrate along a curve in those coordinates and the terms with a and ω will of course contribute to the proper time along the curve. This behavior of clocks is of course due to the choice of the noninertial observer, and they are only present along curves which do not coincide with the observers world line. Recall that, by construction, one has Minkowski s metric along the world line of the observer, which is alsothe center ofthe coordinatesystem in which 6 is written all inertial effects vanish at the origin of the coordinate system. A. Flat case We start with the flat spacetime and switch to a quantity which is directly measurable, i.e. the proper time quotient of two clocks located at Y and X. It is worthwhile to note that for a flat spacetime, R ijk l =, the interval 6 reduces to the Hehl-Ni 36] line element of a noninertial rotating and accelerating system: From 6 we derive ds X y,y α = +a α y α dy δ αβ dy α +ε α µνω µ y ν dy dy β +ε β ρσω ρ y σ dy +O3, 8 ds X dy = δαβv α v β +a α y α +b α y α y +y α y β a α a β δ αβω γ ω γ +ω α ω β ds Y ds Y +v α ε αβγ y β ω γ +y y β η γ] +O3 9 = + aα δ αβ v α v β y α +b α y α y +y α y β a α a β δ αβ ω γ ω γ +ω α ω β +v α ε αβγ y β ω γ +y y β η γ] +O3. Here we introduced the velocity v α = dy α /dy. Defining V α := v α +ε α βγω β y γ, we can rewrite the above relation more elegantly as ds X dy = +aα y α δ αβv α V β] +O3. ds Y ds Y Equation is reminiscent of the situation which we encountered in case of the gravitational compass, i.e. we may look at this measurable quantity depending on how we prepare the C y α,y,v α,a α,ω α,b α,η α ds X :=. 3 ds Y B. Curved case Now let us investigate the curved spacetime, after all we are interested in mapping the gravitational field by means of clock comparison. The frequency ratio becomes: ds X = + aα ds Y δ αβ v α v β y α +b α y α y +y α y β a α a β R αβ δ αβ ω γ ω γ +ω α ω β +v α ε αβγ y β ω γ +y y β η γ 4 3 vα y β y γ R αβγ + 3 vα v β y γ y δ R γαβδ ] +O3. 4

5 Analogously to the flat case in3, we introduce a shortcut for the measurable frequency ratio in a curved background, denoting its dependence on different quantities as C y α,y,v α,a α,ω α,b α,η α,r αβγδ. Note that in the flat, as well as in the curved case, the frequency ratio becomes independent of b α and η α on the three-dimensional slice with fixed y since we can always choose our coordinate time parameter y =, i.e. we have Cy α,v α,a α,ω α and Cy α,v α,a α,ω α,r αβγδ respectively. 5 IV. CLOCK COMPASS We now consider different setups of clocks to measure physical quantities by means of mutual frequency comparisons. For example, we could question ourselves: Can we detect rotation just by clock comparison, i.e. can we measure all three components of ω α, by a suitable setup of clocks w.r.t. to the clock on our reference world line Y? Here our strategy is similar to our analysis of the gravitational compass in ]. We start by labeling different initial values for the clocks: and y α = 4 y α = v α = 4 v α = and a α = 4 a α = and ω α = 4 ω α = c c 4 c 4 d d 4 d 4 e e 4 e 4, y α =, 5 y α =, v α =, 5 v α =, a α =, 5 a α =, ω α =, 5 ω α =, 3 y α = c c 5 c 53 d d 5 d 53 e e 5 e 53, 6 y α =, 3 v α =, 6 v α =, 3 a α =, 6 a α =, 3 ω α =, 6 ω α =,,5 c c 6 c 63 d d 6 d 63 e e 6 e 63,, 6,, 7,. 8 Here the c s, d s and e s are real-valued parameters. A. Linear acceleration determination Now let us search for a configuration of clocks which allows for a determination of the three components of the linear acceleration a α of the observer. Assuming that all other quantities can be prescribed by the experimentalist, we rearrange 3 as follows a α y α +a α a β y α y β = By α,v α,ω α, 9 where all the measured frequency ratios, as well as all prescribed quantities are collected on the rhs By α,v α,ω α := v C y α y β ω α ω β δ αβ ω v α ε αβγ y β ω γ. 3 Note that for brevity we suppress the functional dependence on parameters of the measured frequency ratios on the rhs. Taking into account 5-8, we end up with the system a α n y α +a α a β n y αn y β = B n y α, m v α, p ω α = n,m,p B. 3 Insertion of 5 yields the set redundant equations not displayed a +a =,, B, 3 a +a =,, B, a 3 +a 3 = 3,, B, 34 a +a +a +a = 4,, B, 35 a +a 3 +a +a 3 = 5,, B, 36 a +a 3 +a +a 3 = 6,, B. 37 This system does not allow for an extraction of the linear accelerations, but this can be achieved by the introduction of clocks at the positions 7 y α =, 8 y α =, 9 y α =. 38 This yields a set of three equations like 3-34, which can be subtracted from each other, leading to a α = α,, B α+6,, B. 39 4

6 6 FIG.. Symbolical sketch of the explicit solution for linear acceleration 4. In total 6 suitably prepared clocks hollow circles are needed to determine all acceleration components. The observer is denoted by the black circle. In terms of the C s, for which we use here and in the following the same shortcut notation as for the B s, we have a α = 4 c α,, C α+6,, C. 4 Hence we need 6 clocks to determine all components of the linear acceleration a α, see figure for a symbolical sketch of the solution. FIG. 3. Symbolical sketch of the explicit solution for the rotational velocity 45. In total 6 suitably prepared clocks hollow circles are needed to determine all velocity components. The observer is denoted by the black circle. or explicitly in terms of the C s ω = c c c c c ω = c c ω 3 = c c c c c,, C,3, C + ], ] 3,3, C 3,, C +, ],, C,, C +. See figure 3 for a symbolical sketch of the solution. 45 B. Rotational velocity determination Analogously to the strategy in the preceding section, we rearrange the system 3 as follows: C. Linear velocity determination Again we rearrange the system 3 as follows: v C v α ε αβγ y β ω γ = By α,a α,ω α, v α ε αβγ y β ω γ y α y β δ αβ ω ω α ω β = By α,v α,a α, 4 where 46 where By α,v α,a α := v C a α y α a α a β y α y β. 4 Taking into account 5-8 we end up with m v α ε αβγ n y β ω γ n y αn y β δ αβ ω ω α ω β = B n y α, m v α, p a α = n,m,p B. 43 Consequently the rotational velocity can be determined with the help of 6 clocks, an explicit solution being ω =,, B,3, B, c ω = 3,3, B 3,, B, c ω 3 =,, B,, B, 44 c By α,a α,ω α := a α y α +y α y β a α a β δ αβ ω +ω α ω β. 47 This yields δαβ v α v β n,m,p C v α ε αβγ n y βp ω γ = B n y α, m a α, p ω α = n,m,p B. 48 From this system we can determine the linear velocity as follows: v = ],,3 C A d +e d, e v = ],,3 C A+d e e +d, v 3 = ],, C A d +e d, 49 e where the common factor is given by A := d +d,, C. 5

7 v 3 = ],, C A+e, 5 e 7 FIG. 4. Symbolical sketch of the explicit solution for the linear velocity 5. In total 4 suitably prepared clocks hollow circles are needed to determine all velocity components. The observer is denoted by the black circle. In other words, 4 clocks are necessary to determine all components of the linear velocity, see figure 4 for a symbolical sketch of the solution. D. Curvature determination An alternative, and slightly simpler, solution for the velocity reads as v = ],,3 C A+e, e v = ],,3 C A+e, e Now we turn to the determination of the curvature in a general spacetime by means of clocks. We consider the non-vacuum case first, when one needs to measure independent components of the Riemann curvature tensor R abc d. Again we start by rearranging the system 3: where n y αn y β R αβ 4 3 R γαβ m v γ + 3 R αγδβ m v γm v δ = B n y α, m v α, p a α, q ω α, 5 By α,v α,a α,ω α := v C a α y α y α y β a α a β δ αβ ω γ ω γ +ω α ω β v α ε αβγ y β ω γ. 53 Analogously to our analysis of the gravitational compass], we may now consider different setups of clocks to measure as many curvature components as possible. The system in 5 yields please note that only the position and the velocity indices are indicated: : R =, B, 54 : R = 3 4 c c 4 c c 4, Bc, Bc 4 +, Bc 4,4 Bc, 55 3 : R = 3c c 4 c c 4, Bc, Bc 4 +, Bc 4,4 Bc, 56 4 : R 3 = 3 4 c c 63 c c 63, Bc, Bc 63 +,3 Bc 63,6 Bc, 57 5 : R = 3c c 63 c c 63, Bc, Bc 63 +,3 Bc 63,6 Bc, 58 6 : R 3 = 3 c 5 c 53,5 B +R 4 3 R c R 3c 53 3 R c 5 3 R c 53, 59 7 : R =, B, 8 : R = 3 4 c, B R + 3 R c 6, 6 9 : R 3 = 3 4 c c 53 c c 53, Bc, Bc 53 +,3 Bc 53,5 Bc, 6 : R = 3c c 53 c c 53, Bc, Bc 53 +,3 Bc 53 5, Bc, 63 : R 3 = 3 c 6 c 63,6 B +R R c R 3c 63 3 R c 6 3 R c 63, 64 : R = 3,3 B, 3 : R = 3 4 c 4 : R = 3 4 c 3, B R + 3 R c 3, B R + 3 R c 65, 66, 67

8 5 : R = 3 c 4 c 4 6 : R = 7 : R 3 = 8 : R 3 = 3,4 B +R R c R c 4 3 R c 4 3 R c 4, 68 4, B R R 4 3 R c 4 3 R c + 3 R c, 69 5, B R R 4 3 R c 4 3 R 3c + 3 R c, , B R R 4 3 R c 4 3 R 3c + 3 R c Introducing abbreviations K := 3 4 c 4,3 B +R +R +R 4 3 R 3 +R 3 c ] 3 R +R +R c, 7 K := 3 4 c 5, B +R +R 3 +R R +R c ] 3 R +R 3 +R c, 73 K 3 := 3 4 c 6, B +R +R 3 +R 4 3 R +R c ] 3 R +R 3 +R c, 74 8 we find the remaining three curvature components 9 : R 3 = 3 K 3 K, 75 : R 3 = 3 K K, 76 : R 3 = 3 K 3 K. 77 See figure 5 for a symbolical sketch of the solution. The B s in these equations can be explicitly resolved in terms of the C s, B = c, C, 78, B = c, C, 79,3 B = c,3 C, 8,4 B = c 4 c 4,4 C, 8,5 B = c 5 c 53,5 C, 8,6 B = c 6 c 63,6 C, 83, B = c, C, 84, B = c, C, 85,3 B = c,3 C, 86,5 B = c 5 c 53,5 C, 87,6 B = c 6 c 63,6 C, 88 3, B = c 3, C, 89 3, B = c 3, C, 9 3,3 B = c 3,3 C, 9 FIG. 5. Symbolical sketch of the explicit solution for the curvature In total suitably prepared clocks hollow circles are needed to determine all curvature components. The observer is denoted by the black circle. Note that all...6 v a, but only...3 y a are needed in the solution. 3,4 B = c 4 c 4 3,4 C, 9 4, B = c 4, C, 93 4,3 B = c 4, C, 94 5, B = c 5, C, 95 5, B = c 5, C, 96 6, B = c 6, C, 97 6, B = c 6, C. 98

9 9 E. Vacuum spacetime In vacuum the number of independent components of the curvature is reduced to the components of the Weyl tensor C abcd. Replacing R abcd in the compass solution 54-7, and taking into account the symmetries of the Weyl tensor, we may use a reduced clock setup to completely determine the gravitational field. Note that all other components may be obtained from the double self-duality property C abcd = 4 ε abefε cdgh C efgh. : C =, B, 99 : C = 3 4 c c 4 c c 4, Bc, Bc 4 +, Bc 4,4 Bc, 3 : C = 3c c 4 c c 4, Bc, Bc 4 +, Bc 4,4 Bc, 4 : C =, B, 5 : C 3 = 3 4 c 6 : C = 3 4 c With the abbreviations 7 : C 3 = 3 c 5 c 53 8 : C 3 = 3 c 6 c 63 9 : C = 3 c 4 c 4 K := 3 4 c K := 3 4 c K 3 := 3 4 c,3 B +C 3 C c, 3, B C 3 C c, 4,5 B +C C c C 3c 53 3 C c 5 3 C c 53, 5,6 B C C c C 3c 63 3 C c C c 63, ,4 B C 4 3 C c C c 4 3 C c C c 4 4,3 B C +C +C + ] 3 C C C c, 8 5, B +C +C 3 +C + ] 3 C C 3 +C c, 9 6, B +C C 3 C ] 3 C C 3 C c, the remaining three curvature components read : C 3 = 3 K 3 K, : C 3 = 3 K K, : C 3 = 3 K 3 K. 3 A symbolical sketch of the solution is given in figure 6. can be determined at best: : R = B, 4 : R = B, 5 3 : R = 3 B, 6 4 : R = 4 B B B, 7 5 : R 3 = 5 B B 3 B, 8 6 : R 3 = 6 B B 3 B. 9 F. Constrained clock compass Itisinterestingtonotethatin thecaseofaconstrained compass, when the relative velocities of the clocks to each other are vanishing, only six components of the curvature V. CONCLUSIONS & OUTLOOK Here we proposed an experimental setup which we call a clock compass, in analogy to the usual gravitational compass, 4]. We have shown that a suitably prepared set of clocks can be used to determine all components

10 TABLE II. Directory of symbols. FIG. 6. Symbolical sketch of the explicit vacuum solution for the curvature In total suitably prepared clocks hollow circles are needed to determine all curvature components. The observer is denoted by the black circle. Note that all...6 v a, but only...3 y a are needed in the solution. of the gravitational field, i.e. the curvature, in General Relativity, as well as to describe the state of motion of a noninertial observer. We have worked out explicit clock compass setups in different situations, and have shown that in general 6 clocks are needed to determine the linear acceleration as well as the rotational velocity, while 4 clocks will suffice in case of the velocity. Furthermore, we gave explicit setups which allow for a determination of all curvature components in general as well as in vacuum spacetimes by means of and clocks, respectively. In view of possible future experimental realizations it is interesting to note that restrictions regarding the choice of clock velocities in a setup lead to restrictions regarding the number of determinable curvature components. Further special cases should be studied depending on possible experimental setups. In summary, we have shown how the gravitational field can be measured by means of an ensemble of clocks. Our results are of direct operational relevance for the setup of networks of clocks, especially in the context of relativistic geodesy. In geodetic terms, the given clock configurations may be thought of as a clock gradiometers. Taking into account the steadily increasing experimental accuracy of clocks, the results in the present paper should be combined with those from a gradiometric context, for example in the form of a hybrid gravitationalcompass which combines acceleration as well as clock measurements in one setup. Another possible application is the detection of gravitational waves by means of clock as well as standard interferometric techniques. An interesting question concerns the possible reduction of the number of required measurements by a combination of different techniques. Symbol Explanation g ab Metric g Determinant of the metric δb a Kronecker symbol ε abcd Levi-Civita symbol x a, y a Coordinates s, τ Proper time c Γ ab Connection R d d abc, C abc Riemann, Weyl curvature α λ b Fermi propagated tetrad Ys, Xτ Reference world line ξ a Constants in spatial FC v α, ω α, V α Linear, rotational, combined velocity a α Acceleration b α, η α Deriv. of linear, rotational acceleration v α, ω α Velocity C Frequency ratio A, B, K,,3 Auxiliary quantities Operators i, i D = ds d ds = Partial, covariant derivative Total cov. derivative Total derivative Power expansion ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank Bahram Mashhoon for fruitful discussions and advice. This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft DFG through the grant PU 46/- D.P.. The work of Y.N.O. was partially supported by PIER Partnership for Innovation, Education and Research between DESY and Universität Hamburg and by the Russian Foundation for Basic ResearchGrant No A. We also thank the DFG funded Research Training Group 6 Models of Gravity, as well as the Collaborative Research Center 8 Relativistic Geodesy geo-q.

11 Appendix A: Notations and conventions Our conventions for the Riemann curvature are as follows: The Ricci tensor is introduced by R ij = R kij k, and the curvature scalar is R = g ij R ij. The signature of the spacetime metric is assumed to be +,,,. Latin indices run from,...,3, and Greek indices from,...,3. T c...c k d...d l ;ba] a b] T c...c k d...d l k c = R i abe T c...e...c k d...d l i= l R e abdj T c...c k d...e...d l. j= A ] D. Puetzfeld and Y. N. Obukhov. Generalized deviation equation and determination of the curvature in General Relativity. Phys. Rev. D, 93:4473, 6. ] J. L. Synge. Relativity: The general theory. North- Holland, Amsterdam, 96. 3] B. S. DeWitt and R. W. Brehme. Radiation damping in a gravitational field. Ann. Phys. N.Y., 9:, 96. 4] P. Szekeres. The gravitational compass. J. Math. Phys., 6:387, ] C. W. Chou and et al. Frequency comparison of two high-accuracy Al + optical clocks. Phys. Rev. Lett., 4: 78,. 6] N. Huntemann and et al. High-Accuracy optical clock based on the octupole transition in 7 Yb +. Phys. Rev. Lett., 8:98,. 7] J. Guéna and et al. Progress in atomic fountains at lnesyrte. IEEE Transactions on Ultrasonics, Ferroelectrics and Frequency Control, 59:39,. 8] S. Falke and et al. A strontium lattice clock with 3 7 inaccuracy and its frequency. New J. Phys., 6:7, 4. 9] B. J. Bloom and et al. An optical lattice clock with accuracy and stability at the 8 level. Nature, 56:7, 4. ] M. Schioppo and et al. Ultrastable optical clock with two cold-atom ensembles. Nature Photonics Letters, 3:, 6. ] E. Fermi. Sopra i fenomeni che avvengono in vicinanza di una linea oraria. Atti. Accad. Naz. Lincei Cl, Sci. Fis. Mat. Nat. Rend., 3:,5,, 9. ] E. Fermi. Collected Papers. Eds. E. Amaldi, E. Persico, F. Rasetti, E. Segrè. Vol.. University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 96. 3] O. Veblen. Normal coordinates for the geometry of paths. Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA, 8:9, 9. 4] O. Veblen and T. Y. Thomas. The geometry of paths. Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 5:55, 93. 5] J. L. Synge. A characteristic function in Riemannian space and its application to the solution of geodesic triangles. Proc. London Math. Soc., 3:4, 93. 6] A. G. Walker. Relative Coordinates. Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh, 5:345, 93. 7] F. K. Manasse and C. W. Misner. Fermi normal coordinates and some basic concepts in differential geometry. J. Math. Phys., 4:735, ] C. W. Misner, K. S. Thorne, and J. A. Wheeler. Gravitation. Freeman, San Francisco, ] W.-T. Ni. On the proper reference frame and local coordinates of an accelerated observer in special relativity. Chin. J. Phys., 5:5, 977. ] W.-T. Ni and M. Zimmermann. Inertial and gravitational effects in the proper reference frame of an accelerated, rotating observer. Phys. Rev. D, 7:473, 978. ] W.-Q. Li and W.-T. Ni. On an accelerated observer with rotating tetrad in special relativity. Chin. J. Phys., 6: 4, 978. ] W.-T. Ni. Geodesic triangles and expansion of the metrics in normal coordinates. Chin. J. Phys., 6:3, ] W.-Q. Li and W.-T. Ni. Coupled inertial and gravitational effects in the proper reference frame of an accelerated, rotating observer. J. Math. Phys., :473, ] W.-Q. Li and W.-T. Ni. Expansions of the affinity, metric and geodesic equations in Fermi normal coordinates about a geodesic. J. Math. Phys., :95, ] N. Ashby and B. Bertotti. Relativistic effects in local inertial frames. Phys. Rev. D, 34:46, ] A. M. Eisele. On the behaviour of an accelerated clock. Helv. Phys. Acta, 6:4, ] T. Fukushima. The Fermi coordinate system in the post- Newtonian framework. Cel. Mech., 44:4, ] O. Semerák. Stationary frames in the Kerr field. Gen. Rel. Grav., 5:4, ] K.-P. Marzlin. Fermi coordinates for weak gravitational fields. Phys. Rev. D, 5:888, ] D. Bini, A. Geralico, and R. T. Jantzen. Kerr metric, static observers and Fermi coordinates. J. Math. Phys., :479, 5. 3] C. Chicone and B. Mashhoon. Explicit Fermi coordinates and tidal dynamics in de Sitter and Gödel spacetime. Phys. Rev. D, 74:649, 6. 3] D. Klein and P. Collas. General transformation formulas for Fermi-Walker coordinates. Class. Quant. Grav., 5: 459, 8. ] D. Klein and P. Collas. Exact Fermi coordinates for a class of space-times. J. Math. Phys., 5:5,. 34] P. Delva and M.-C. Angonin. Extended Fermi coordinates. Gen. Rel. Grav., 44:,. 35] S.G. Turyshev, O.L. Minazzoli, and V. T. Toth. Accelerating relativistic reference frames in Minkowski spacetime. J. Math. Phys., 53:35,. 36] F. W. Hehl and W.-T. Ni. Inertial effects of a Dirac particle. Phys. Rev. D, 4:45, 99.