arxiv: v2 [cond-mat.str-el] 10 Jan 2018

Transcription

1 Dirac Composite Fermion - A Particle-Hole Spinor Jian Yang, arxiv:7.85v [cond-mat.str-el] Jan 8 Te particle-ole PH symmetry at alf-filled Landau level requires te relationsip between te flux number N φ and te particle number N on a spere to be exactly N φ N =. Te wave functions of composite fermions wit orbital spin, wic contributes to te sift in te N φ and N relationsip, are proposed, sown to be PH symmetric, and validated wit exact finite system results. It is sown te many-body composite electron and composite ole wave functions at alf-filling can be formed from te two components of te same spinor wave function of a massless Dirac fermion at zero-magnetic field. It is furter sown tat away from alf-filling, te many-body composite electron wave function at filling factor ν and its PH conjugated composite ole wave function at ν can be formed from te two components of te very same spinor wave functions of a massless Dirac fermion at non-zero magnetic field. Tis relationsip leads to te proposal of a very simple Dirac composite fermion effective field teory L = i ψγ µ µ+ia µψ+ π ǫµνλ A µ νa λ, were te two-component Dirac fermion field is a particle-ole spinor field coupled to te same emergent gauge field, wit one field component describing te composite electrons and te oter describing te PH conjugated composite oles. As suc, te density of te Dirac spinor field is te density sum of te composite electron and ole field components, and terefore is equal to te degeneracy of te Lowest Landau level. On te oter and, te carge density coupled to te external magnetic field is te density difference between te composite electron and ole field components, and is terefore neutral at exactly alf-filling. It is sown tat te proposed particle-ole spinor effective field teory gives essentially te same electromagnetic responses as Son s Dirac composite fermion teory does. PACS numbers: Cd, 7..Pm I. INTRODUCTION One of te most remarkable results in te area of te quantum Hall effect QHE is predicted by Halperin, Lee, and Read HLR in a pioneering work some twenty year ago [], were tey proposed tat te two-dimensional electrons in a strong magnetic field at exact alf filling of te lowest Landau level beave like a compressible Fermi liquid at zero magnetic field. According to te HLR teory, te composite fermions are formed by attacing two flux quanta to eac of te original electrons. In te mean field approximation, te attaced flux cancels te external magnetic field exactly at alf filling, resulting in a Fermi liquid description of te composite fermions. Despite of its many successes, te HLR teory is not explicit if not completely lacks particle-ole PH symmetry [] [3] [4]. On te oter and, te twobody interaction Hamiltonian wen projected onto te lowest Landau level is invariant by an antiunitary PH transformation at alf-filled Landau level, and te finite size numerical results seem to confirm te PH symmetry of te ground state [5] [6]. It is wort noting tat te PH symmetry on gapped QHE states relevant to te fractional QHE at ν = 5/ ave also been extensively studied [7] [8] [9] []. Tis long-standing PH symmetry callenge of te HLR teory as been recently met wit a rater remarkable resolution proposed by Son [3] [4]. In te new picture of Son, te composite fermion is a massless Dirac fermion caracterizedby aberrypaseofπ, wit te PHsymmetry built in at te outset. Te Dirac composite fermion proposal as generated a great new interest in tis rater old field [][][3][4][6][5][6][7], wic lend strong support to te correctness of tis very insigtful proposal. In tis paper, we will start approacing te subject from a microscopic wave function point of view, and conclude wit a similar but distinct effective field teory. We will use Haldanes sperical geometry [8]. Tis geometry as been used widely as an efficient tool to perform te numerical finite size studies for te bulk property of te quantum Hall system, mainly because it is free of boundary effects. Tere is anoter advantage of using te sperical geometry, as was recognized by Wen and Zee [9] in teir study to relate te so called sift to a topological quantum number orbital spin of a quantum Hall state. Tis orbital spin induced sift would not be manifested in geometries suc as a torus. We will begin wit te following composite fermion wave function proposed by Rezayi and Read [], and by te present autor [3], to illustrate te PH symmetry problem of te HLR teory e N e u i v j u j v i dety lim i were u j,v j = cosθ j /e iφj/,sinθ j /e iφ / are te spinor variables describing te coordinates θ j,φ j of j t electron occupying te sperical armonics function state Y li,m i θ j,φ j, and e is te electron lowest Landau level projection operator. Loosely speaking, tis wave function can be regarded as a wave function version of te HLR teory in tat te Jastrow factor Ne u i v j u j v i is effectively attacing two flux

2 quanta to eac electron, and te Slater determinant dety li,m i builts a Fermi sea at zero magnetic field, occupying sperical armonics function Y l,m state from small to large values of angular momentum l. It is clear from Eq., te flux number N φ and electron number N e relationsip is given by N φ N e = However, tis breaks particle-ole symmetry condition. Te correct flux number N φ and electron number N relationsip tat satisfies te PH symmetry condition is N φ N e = 3 One can easily verify tis by noting tat for a system of N φ flux number and N e electrons, te number of empty electron states or te number of ole states is N φ + N e since te lowest Landau level degeneracy is N φ +. EquatingtisnumberofemptyelectronstatesN φ +N e to te electron number N e will result in Eq.3. II. PH SYMMETRIC WAVE FUNCTIONS WITH ORBITAL SPIN AT HALF-FILLING By comparing Eq.3 wit Eq., a straigtforward solution to meet te correct N φ and N e relationsip is to modify Eq. by replacing dety lim i wit dety,li,miθ j,φ j Ψ e = N e Pe LLL u i v j u j v i dety,li,miθ j,φ j 4 were Y,l,mθ,φ is te monopole armonics wit a unit Dirac monopole carge at te center of te spere. On te surface Eq.4 appears to imply tat attacing two flux quanta due to Ne u i v j u j v i to eac electron would not cancel te external magnetic field even in te mean field approximation, and instead te composite fermions still experience a non-zero magnetic field generated by a unit Dirac monopole at te center of te spere. However tis non-zero magnetic field, as a result of te sift on te difference between N φ and N e depends on te curvature of a curved space, and is vanising on a flat space suc as a torus. Following Wen and Zee[9], we attribute tis sift of to a topological quantum number representing a alf-integer orbital spin degreesoffreedom ofte composite electrons. Te total flux seen by te composite electron is te sum of te magnetic flux, wic is effectively zero at alf filling, and te coupling of te orbital spin to te curvature of te spere spin connection. Tis orbital spin is also consistent wit requirement to obtain te correct value for te coefficient of te q correction to te Hall conductivity [6] troug a relation between te Hall viscosity and te orbital spin [][]. We propose te composite ole wave function Ψ obtained from te complex conjugate of te composite electron wave function Ψ e N Ψ = u ivj u jvi dety,li,miθ j,φ j 5 were N = N e, and is te composite ole lowest Landau level projection operator. Tis wave function describes te same alf-filled Landau level system in terms of te composite oles. To validate te composite wave function Ψ e, we will present te numerical results of finite size systems of 7 electrons and 8 electrons at te alf-filled Landau level satisfying Eq.3 in te sperical geometry. For a system of N e = 7 electrons, te total flux number is N φ = N e = 3. Tere are N φ + = 4 states in te lowest Landau level wit angular momentum l = N φ = 3 and m = 3,,9 3,...,. Witout a loss of generality, we will coose te Hilbert space to be sectors aving te smallest values of te total z-component angular momentum L z, wic is eiter L z = or L z = for odd number of electrons suc as N e = 7. All te states are doublydegenerate,witeacstateinonesectorasaph symmetric state in te oter sector. On te oter and, te Slater determinant dety,li,mi in Ψe is formed wit 6 electrons occupying Y states wit l i,m,li,mi i taking values of,,, 3,3,3,,3,,3, 3 6 and one electron occupying one of te following states wit l i,m i 5,5,5,3,5,,5,,5, 3,5 5 7 For te sector of total z-component angular momentum L z =, state5, will be occcupied, andforl z = sector, state 5, will be occcupied. Forasystem ofn e = 8 electrons, te total fluxnumber is N φ = N e = 5. Tere are N φ + = 6 states in te lowest Landau level wit angular momentum l = N φ = 5 and m = 5,3,,..., 5. Again we will coose te Hilbert space to be a sector wit te smallest value of te total z-component angular momentum L z, wic is L z = for even number of electrons suc as N e = 8. In contrast to N e = 7 case, all te states are non-degenerate, and are PH symmetric wit temselves. On te oter and, te Slater determinant dety,li,mi in Ψ e is formed aving 6 electrons occupying Y,li,mi states wit l i,m i specified in Eq. 6, and electrons occupying states specified in Eq. 7.

3 3 In Fig. a, we plot a lower part of te energy spectrum in an arbitrary units of a N φ,n = 3,7 finite system in te lowest Landau level versus angular momentum L in L z = sector. Te two numbers.999 and.9998 below te energy bar at L =.5 are respectively te overlap te top number.999 between Ψ e and te corresponding exact numerical state, and te overlap bottom number.9998between tephconjugateofψ e and Ψ, using identity Y S,l,m = S+m Y S,l,m. In Fig. b, we plot a lower part of te energy spectrum for N φ,n = 5,8 finite system in L z = sector. Te numbers.9975,.9987, and.9989 rigt below te tree energy bars at L =,,4 are te overlaps of te 3 wave functions described by Ψ e wit teir corresponding exact numerical wave functions. Te numbers.9958,.9996, and.999 under te same energy bars are te overlaps between te PH conjugate of te 3 wave functions described by Ψ e and temselves or Ψ, as Ψ e = Ψ for even number of electrons. From tese results, we conclude tat Ψ e and Ψ in Eq. 4 and Eq. 5 provide accurate description for te exact low energy states, and Ψ e and Ψ areph symmetric wit eac oter in te sense ΘΨ e = Ψ, were Θ is te PH conjugate operator Fig a Angular Momentum L Fig b Angular Momentum L FIG. : A lower part of te energy spectrum, overlaps top numbers below energy bars between Ψ e and te corresponding exact numerical states, and overlaps bottom numbers below energy bars between te PH conjugate of Ψ e and Ψ, are plotted in Fig. a for N φ,n e = 3,7 system, and in Fig. b for N φ,n e = 5,8 system. Te monopole armonics function Y,l,m in Eq. 5 describes a positive carged particle experiencing a negative unit magnetic monopole at te center of te spere, te corresponding Hamiltonian H can be obtained from te following Hamiltonian wit S = [4] H S = QS+ Q S + + S 8 were te particle mass is set to for convenience, and te operators Q are defined by Q S + = θ Scotθ+isinθ φ Q S = θ +Scotθisinθ φ Wen setting S =, we ave 9 H = Q Q + 4 On te oter and, te wave function Y,l,m describes a negative carged particle experiencing a positive unit magnetic monopole at te center of te spere, te corresponding Hamiltonian can be obtained from te complex conjugate of H H = Q + Q 4 It is straigtforward to sow H + 4 H + 4 = HDirac were H Dirac is te Hamiltonian of a massless Dirac particle at zero magnetic field S = H Dirac S = iq S+ iq S + 3 Tis means te original single composite electron wave function and composite ole wave function are identical, wit different coordinates, to te two components of te same wave function of a massless Dirac particle at zero magnetic field φ,l,m φ e,l,m = Y,l,m iy,l,m 4 We will only use te positive energy wave functions, as te negative energy wave functions are te same wit a sign cange for te lower component [4]. We can rewrite Ψ and Ψe into a two-component compact form using te Dirac wave function at zero magnetic field Ψ P N LLL u i v j u j v i detφ,l i,m i Ψ e = N e u i v j u j v i detφ e,l i,m i e 5 were N = N e. Te key conclusion is tat te manybody composite electron and composite ole wave functions at alf-filling can be formed from te two componentsoftesamespinorwavefunctionofamasslessdirac fermion at zero-magnetic field. Of course, in Eq. 5 te composite electron and composite ole ave different coordinates, and te two component form of wave functions sould not be considered as te many-body wave functions of te composite Dirac fermions.

4 III. PH CONJUGATED WAVE FUNCTIONS AWAY FROM HALF-FILLING In tis section, we will move away from te alf-filling. First let s modify te matrix equation Eq. to te following HS S H S + S + 6 = HDirac S were te Hamiltonian H S describes a positive carged particle experiencing S magnetic monopole carge in addition to a negative unit monopole carge due to te orbital spin, and H S, formed from te complex conjugate of H S wit te sign of S monopole carge flipped, describes a negative carged particle experiencing te same magnetic field, and HS Dirac is te Hamiltonian of a massless Dirac particle at non-zero magnetic field of S given in Eq.3. Tis means te original single composite electron wave function and composite ole wave function at a magnetic field of S, are identical to te two components of te very same wave function of a massless Dirac particle at a magnetic field of S, wit different coordinates and different energies. In te presence of a magnetic field, te massless Dirac particle forms zero-energy and positive energy Landau levels we ignore te negative energy Landau levels for te same reason as before. Te n t positive energy Landau level wave function can be written as φ S,n,m = φ e S,n,m Y S,S +n,m iy S+,S+ +n,m 7 wit degeneracy S + n were n is a positive integer. Te zero-energy wave function is φ S,,m YS =,S,m 8 φ e S,,m wit te degeneracy S. We extend te two-component wave functions Eq. 5 to non-alf filling Ψ P N LLL u i S v j u j v i detφ S,n i,m i Ψ e = N S e u i v j u j v i detφ e S,n i,m i e 9 Again we empasize te composite electron and composite ole ave different coordinates, and te two component form of wave functions Eq. 5 sould not be considered as te many-body wave functions of te Dirac composite fermions. We can calculate te flux number N φ from eiter Ψ S or from Ψe S. From Ψ S we ave N φ = N S, and from Ψ e S we ave N φ = N e +S. From tese two results, we ave N N e = S and N +N e = N φ + Since te minimum value of N e is zero, Eq. requires te minimum value of N to be equal to S, wic is exactly te degeneracy of te zero-energy Dirac fermion Landau level. In fact, since te lower component of te zero-energylandau level wavefunction φ e S,,m =, wen only te zero-energy Landau level is completely filled by te Dirac fermions, we ave N e = and N = S wic is consistent wit Eq.. Tis describes an empty electron system. On te oter and, Eq. reflects te fact tat te wave functions in Eq.9 describe two PH conjugated states in te Lowest Landau level. If in addition to fill te zero-energy Landau level wic is a minimum requirement to satisfy Eq., we also fill n more non-zero energy Landau levels. In tis case, we ave S = N n+ n for Ψ S total flux N φ = N + N n+ to filling factor ν = n+ n+ were te Dirac field ψ is a spinor wit upper componentdescribingtecompositeolefieldψ, andte lower component describing te composite electron field ψ e ψ ψ = 3 ψ e 4 composite ole state, and te +n. Tis corresponds. On te oter and, we ave S = Ne n n + for te composite electron state Ψe S wic only fills n non-zero energy Landau levels since φ e S,,m =. Te total flux for Ψe S is ten given by N φ = N e + + Ne n n +, wic yields te filling factor ν e = n n+. In fact, te wave function Ψe S at n n+ and Ψ S at n+ n+ in Eq. 9 are respectively identical to Jain s wave functions at te same filling factors [5], wic are known to be PH conjugated wit eac oter. IV. EFFECTIVE FIELD THEORY Based on te results of te previous sections, it is natural to postulate te following effective field teory L = i ψγ µ µ +ia µ ψ + π ǫµνλ A µ ν a λ and a µ is an emergent gauge field, and A µ is te external electromagnetic field. Te term π ǫµνλ A µ ν a λ is required in order to satisfy Eq. and Eq.. Tis can been seen from te equation of motion for a ψ ψ = ψ ψ +ψ eψ e = B π 4 were B is te external magnetic field, wic is noting but Eq.. On te oter and, by differentiating te action wit respect to A, and equating te result to

5 5 ψ ψ ψ e ψ e since ψ and ψ e ave opposite electromagnetic carges, we can obtain ψ ψ ψ eψ e = b π 5 were b is te emergent magnetic field, wic is exactly Eq.. From Eq. 4 and Eq. 5, we can obtain and ψ ψ = B 4π + b 4π ψ e ψ e = B 4π b 4π 6 7 and use tem to relate te electron filling factor to te composite electronor ole filling factor in te same way as was done in Section III. Finally, we would like to make a few comments on te relationsip between Eq. and te following effective field teory of Son [3] [4] L v = i ψ v γ µ µ +ia µ ψ v + 4π ǫµνλ A µ ν a λ + 8π ǫµνλ A µ ν A λ 8 In addition to obviously te same Dirac fermion nature, bot teories do not ave te PH symmetry breaking Cern-Simons term. Furtermore, tey give te same electromagnetic responses. In fact, similar to te carge density equations Eq. 4, Eq. 6, and Eq. 7, one can obtain te current density equations from te equation of motion for a i j i = j e i +j i = π ǫ ije j 9 by differentiating te action wit respect to A i j i je i = π ǫ ije j 3 and by combining Eq. 9 and Eq. 3 j e i = 4π ǫ ije j e j 3 were j e and j represent te current densities of composite electron field and te composite ole field, e and E are te emergent and external electric fields, and ǫ ij is te antisymmetric unit tensor. Since our Dirac spinor currentdensity given in Eq. 9 is twice aslargeaswat is in Son s teory, we can write j i = σ D ij e j were σ D ij is Son s Dirac composite fermion conductivity tensor. On te oter and, te electrical current coupled directly to te external electric field given by Eq. 9 is exactly te same as obtained from Son s teory Eq. 8. As a result, te electron conductivity tensor obtained from Eq. 9 and Eq. 3 will be te same as tat given by Son s teory [7]. V.CONCLUSION Te PH symmetric wave functions of composite fermions wit a orbital spin are proposed and validated wit exact finite system results. Te orbital spin plays an key role to relate te composite fermions to te Diracparticles, andtoleadtoteproposalofacomposite particle-ole spinor effective field teory wic is sown to give essentially te same electromagnetic responses as Son s Dirac composite fermion teory does. Electronic address: jyangmay@yaoo.com; Permanent address: 543 Cesapeake Place, Sugar Land, TX 77479, USA [] B. I. Halperin, P. A. Lee, and N. Read, Pys. Rev. B 47, [] S. A. Kivelson, D.-H. Lee, Y. Krotov, and J. Gan, Pys. Rev. B 55, [3] D. T. Son, Pys. Rev. X 5, [4] D.T.Son, Prog. ofteor. andexp.pys.c36. [5] E. H. Rezayi and F. D. M. Haldane, Pys. Rev. Lett. 84, [6] S. D. Geraedts, M. P. Zaletel, R. S. K. Mong, M. A. Metlitski, A. Viswanat, and O. I. Motrunic, Science 35, [7] G. Moore and N. Read, Nucl. Pys. B36, 36. [8] M. Levin, B. I. Halperin, and B. Rosenow, Pys. Rev. Lett. 99, [9] S.-S Lee, S. Ryu, C. Nayak, and M. P. A. Fiser, Pys. Rev. Lett. 99, [] J. Yang, arxiv:7.356 [] C. WangandT. Sentil, Pys.Rev.B 93, 85, 6. [] G. Murpy and R. Sankar, Pys. Rev. B 93, [3] C. Wangand T. Sentil, Pys.Rev. B 94, [4] C. Wang, N. R. Cooper, B. I. Halperin, and A. Stern, Pys. Rev. X 7, [5] M. Barkesli, M. Mulligan, M. P. A. Fiser, Pys. Rev. B 9, [6] M. Levin, D. T. Son, Pys. Rev. B 95, 5 7. [7] A. Potter, M. Serbyn, and A. Viswanat, Pys. Rev. X 6, [8] F. D. M. Haldane, Pys. Rev. Lett. 5, [9] X. G. Wen and A. Zee, Pys. Rev. Lett. 69, X. G. Wen, Advances in Pysics 44, [] N. Read and E. H. Rezayi, Pys. Rev. B 84, [] D. Nguyen, T. Can, and A. Gromov, Pys. Rev. Lett. 8, [] E. Rezayi and N. Read, Pys. Rev. Lett. 7, [3] J. Yang, Pys. Rev. B 5, [4] K. Yonaga, K. Hasebe, N. Sibata, Pys. Rev. B 93, 35 6; K. Hasebe, arxiv: [5] J. K. Jain, Pys. Rev. Lett. 63,