Summary of Findings and Recommendations

Transcription

1 ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Popo o Auhoz Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo o Op h Popod Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 Oob Ch hoo Inu Uny of Nw Yok UNY Pz 353 Bodwy Abny NY (518) UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 1

2 xu ummy h bod of u of Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo ( OWN o h duon opoon ) no-fo-pof h hoo duon opoon uhozd by h Uny of Nw Yok Bod of u (h UNY u ) o op wo hoo k h uhoy o op on ddon h hoo o b od n pub o p fy n Nw Yok Cy Communy hoo D ( CD ) 30 n Qun. h duon opoon ubmd h popo fo uhoy o op Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 ( OWN 3 ) o h UNY Ch hoo Inu (h Inu ) on Jun n pon o h Inu Rqu fo Popo (h RFP ) (b : hp:// d on bhf of h UNY u on Jnuy h popod nw hoo w opn n pmb 2019 wh 156 udn n Kndn 1 d w dd on d p y nd umy 480 udn n Kndn 5 h d dun f h m. OWN 3 w f h bom b houh on n d houhou h hoo y. OWN 3 w p h hhy ff nuon pom mpmnd fhp Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo ( OWN 1 ) whh opnd n 2002 n h Ao nhbohood n CD 30. Infomon dn h nw hoy dm pfomn nd udn dpn fo h hoo pnd n Appndx A. h Inu fnd h h popo fo OWN uhoy o op OWN 3 oouy dmon h dd n h Inu 2018 RFP whh onn wh h Nw Yok Ch hoo A of 1998 ( mndd h A ). Bd on h popo mndd by h ppn nd h foon: h Inu ommnd h UNY u ppo h popo o uhoz Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo o op Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3. UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 2

3 Fndn Bd on h omphn w of h popo nd nw of h ppn nd h duon opoon bod of u h Inu mk h foown fndn. 1. h h hoo dbd n h popo m h qumn of A 56 of h Nw Yok duon Lw ( mndd) nd oh ppb w u nd uon fd n (mon oh hn): h nuon of ppop po nd podu fo h poon of nd pom fo udn wh db nd nh nu n ( LL ); h qud po fo ddn h u d o udn dpn ponn m nd hh ; n dmon poy h omp wh h A nd fd w; nd h nuon of n ny of h pojd f nd pomm mp of h hoo on uoundn pub nd p hoo. 2. h ppn h dmond h by o op h hoo n n duony nd fy ound mnn fd n (mon oh hn): h poon of n duon pom h m o xd h pfomn ndd; h uon of uu of f-uon nd ounby boh h dmn nd bod ; h udn hmn o ud by h ppn; n ppop o of duon ponn; ound mon mn; omphn mn pn; h poon of ound -up f-y nd f-y bud pn; pn o qu omphn n by nun o nud ny h mpoy nd popy; dn of dqu ommuny uppo fo nd n n h h hoo uffn o ow h hoo o h npd nomn; h nuon of dpon of pomm nd ndpndn f ud wh f ud oun nnuy; h nuon of hoo nd nd hoo dy hdu h pod muh nuon m dun h hoo y qud of oh pub hoo; nd h nuon of mhod nd fo n udn wh db n ompn wh fd w nd uon. 3. Gnn h popo ky o: ) h nfn duon bnf o h udn xpd o nd h popod h hoo; b) mpo udn nn nd hmn; nd ) my fuh h pupo of h A. h fndn uppod by (mon oh hn): xndd nn oppoun wh 540 mnu of nh nu ( LA ) 405 mnu of mhm 135 mnu of n nd 135 mnu of o ud h wk; UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 3

4 on ommmn o n h mo -k udn wh mup pom o dd h nd of udn k of dm fu nudn udn wh db nd LL; h nuon of obu pofon dopmn pom fo nuon ff po h of h hoo y nd houhou h y; n onzon uu h pod mp nuon dhp o dop h pdo k of h; nd dp ommmn o ombnn h dopmn nd oou ouwok o podu hh of udn nmn nd xpon dm ouom. 4. h popod h hoo woud m o xd nomn nd non pbd by h UNY u of udn wh db LL nd udn who b ppn fo h fd F nd Rdud P Lunh ( FRPL ) pom qud by duon Lw 2852(9-)(b)(). 5. h ppn h ondud pub ouh fo h hoo n onfomy wh hoouh nd mnnfu pub w po pbd by h UNY u o o ommuny npu dn h popod h hoo nd o dd ommn d fom h mpd ommuny onnn h duon nd pomm nd of udn n onfomy wh duon Lw 2852(9-)(b)(). 6. h Inu h dmnd h h popo oouy dmon h nd b f h obj onnd whn h RFP nd hfo qufd ppon whn h mnn of duon Lw 2852(9-)(d) h houd b ubmd o h Nw Yok Bod of Rn (h Bod of Rn ) fo ppo. h Inu dopd h RFP n mnn h f[d] houhfu w of h hoo ppon ond[d] h dmnd fo h hoo by h ommuny nd [ouh] o o h hoo n on o on wh h my b k of n nd o h hoo woud pod nw n whn h o pub duon ym h woud off h duon bnf o udn n odn wh duon Lw 2852(9- )(b). h Inu o pod h df RFP fo pub ommn nd pondd o m. h Inu ondud oou uon of h popo und ondon nudn dm nd f oundn nd w. In ddon h Inu nd ndpndn onun o u h dm f nd onzon oundn of h hoo bd on h foh n h RFP. Puun o pooo h Inu w u Joph Buk Chmn of h UNY u Ch hoo Comm ondud nw wh h ppn h bod of u nd ky dhp fom OWN. Bkound nd Dpon OWN fhp hoo OWN 1 opnd doo n 2002 ny n 400 udn n Kndn 5 h d. h hoo uny n 17 h y of opon hn d fu f-y m nw fom h UNY u n nd I mo n nw nd on Mh nb h hoo o op houh Juy UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 4

5 Dun h hoo y OWN udn n Kndn 8 h d wh pon o nomn of 779 udn n h fn y of h h m. h hoo od n py d p wo h Anu Ao NY nd h Ao NY OWN 2 opnd doo n wh Kndn 2 nd d nomn of 153 udn nd w umy 477 udn n Kndn 5 h d. h hoo od h Howd Bh NY OWN k hd hoo o m h onn dmnd fo hh quy duon opon mon fm n CD 30. O h p h y OWN 1 h d mo hn n m mny ppon h b fo boh Kndn nd 1 d. OWN o dnf on dm pfomn o d on wh o bh hd hoo. In fouh h m OWN 1 h pon o b n dm u. h hoo h onny m o xdd ky Aounby Pn o houhou h h m. R o hoo houhou h non m onnon of onomy ddnd udn OWN 1 pfomd hh hn xpd o d dun y y n h h m. In 2017 h hoo LA nd mhm o xdd CD 30 o by 15 pn pon h. Mon Phoophy nd Ky Dn mn h mon of OWN 3 k h mon of h fhp OWN 1 o: du ou udn o bom ndpndn-hnk nd fon n. W ommd o n duon phoophy bd on nquy nd xpn nn nd o ju. houh y-bd nd nd ndd-dn uuum h nou ommuny nd hono dy Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 udn w h bod duon hy w nd o m h dm nd o hn of ufuy nn nd ompn on hh hoo pom nd ndd o h n ody wod. OWN 3 modd f h fhp hoo OWN 1 wh d h bhd nd mnnd ommuny foud on nn nd dm xn. houh h nw hoo h ppn nnd o p h ufu mn of h OWN mod fo h hdn nd fm of OWN 3. A wh pdo OWN 3 w h h foundon of dm pom oou ndd-dn uuum h pod mup oppoun fo d mn h nfom nd nhn hn nd nn houh h po of f p nd mbddd pofon dopmn. OWN 3 w mpmn h foown ky dn mn: mph on y o h uuum. OWN 3 uuum w h n unwn fou on y. h by o pk d w nd undnd h nh nu h o of u n ubj fo udn. h uuum w mphz h non of nn pkn dn nd wn k n ubj nd d nd nopo op-ppop d d n dy on pn n n nd o ud. A OWN 3 y o h bod mnn: udn w b xpd o bom mh- UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 5

6 n- nd wod-. h nd udn w h o h hnoo oo h ny omponn of nn n h 21 nuy. hnoo oo w o uppo oppoun fo bndd nn whn h oom. U of h du of ponby nuon mod (wokhop mod). OWN 3 w u h du of ponby mod ommony known h wokhop mod ohn nuon mod n onn. h mpmn h ppoh houh h foown fou ommon on omponn: opnn; mn-on; udn wok m; nd dbfn. h n h wokhop mod hf h on od owy nd pupofuy o udn duy um nn ponby fo h nn nd bom ompn ndpndn n. h p nn p of h mhodoo hhy ff n wokn wh oom of honou udn nudn udn wh db LL nd I udn w d n h wok m omponn of h wokhop mod pod h oppouny fo h o dffn nuon. U of mn o nfom nuon nd dop nd dju nddu nn pn fo udn. Onon mn n n omponn of h wokhop mod. OWN 3 w mb ounby nd ponby n mn udn hmn o. A uh onon mn nd h ny nd u of y of mn d on n nd dd b w nfom uuum nd nuon OWN 3. Ld nd ff w mpmn omphn pom of mn nd wh boh h uuum nd h Nx Gnon Lnn ndd. h hoo w u mn d o dop dju nd mono po n obj n udn nddu nn pn. Impmnon of obu nnon pom. OWN 3 mn nuon mody h wokhop mod w b hhy ff n wokn wh honou oom of udn nudn udn wh db LL nd I udn. h wokhop mod onn wh h ommmn o bnd nuon ppoh nd bud py n h o dffn nuon houh h u of mn d o dnfy udn nd nd nfom nuon. In ddon OWN 3 w mpmn obu dm nnon pom dnd o uppo udn wh db LL nd I udn. h hoo w h on Rpon o Innon ( RI ) po o dnfy un udn houh d nd oom obon nd bh obo dn-bd nnon uppod by p duon ff LL nd dn p nd o wok An mph on b duon. OWN 3 w off fon nu nuon bnnn n Kndn w obu uuum n h nudn u nd mu. Phy duon nd hh ud o n mpon p of h uuum; OWN 3 w mpmn ddon pom k Mo o Impo oom-bd phy y pom dnd by h Nw Yok Cy Dpmn of duon ( NYCDO o h d ) nd h Nw Yok Cy Dpmn of Hh nd Mn Hyn o n phy y mon udn houhou h hoo dy nd pomo phy hh nd wn. Inmn n Inuon ff. OWN 3 w mk h ny nmn n wh w b hhy qufd nd xpnd h nd d wh xn xpn boh h nuon nd dhp. h hoo w pod onnu uppo n h owh of duo houh mbddd pofon dopmn. OWN 3 UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 6

7 h w xmn wh hy do n h oom hnk bou why hy dd nd hnk bou f wokd. By on nfomon bou wh o on n h oom nd by nyzn nd un h nfomon h w dnfy nd xpo h p dn o hn nd mpomn n hn. Admno w uppo h n h po. P of po ommuny. OWN 3 w b h dy of h ommuny by nn h uu hn of h ommuny wh h on of h oom nd h onn of h hoo. A unqu omponn of h OWN mod P of Po Communy ( P ) uuum. P h ohn hoo uu pom dnd o mp o udn h hd u of h ommuny. h n onp (p) kndn fndhp ou p uh ponby f-dpn fn pn nd znhp. Wh d nd ff w mn fhfu o h n p OWN 3 h hoo w o o h xn P uuum o m h unqu nd of ommuny. A Lon hoo dy nd y. OWN 3 w h on hoo dy nd y hn don d hoo. h ddon m on k w h nh of OWN 3 oou uuum nd uppo nuon mod. h nh of dy nd y w ow h hoo o h mnnfu bok of m h udn n do o h udy of no ony o ubj bu o mu phy duon nd fon nu. oo-onom dy. h dy fd n h ommun h omp CD 27 mpon o h hoo mod. h OWN mod u dy nd o h d pob d o ommun wh h no ony nd hn dy bu onom dy w. Cnd nd hdu OWN 3 w off 190 dy of nuon h y. h f dy of nuon fo h hoo y w b on o ound Auu nd h dy w b on o ound Jun ubqun hoo y w foow m nd. h hoo dy w bn h monn 7:50 A.M. nd nd 3:00 P.M. OWN 3 w pod udn wh o of 1178 hou of nuon p y n n of mo hn 30% o h mnmum of 900 hou mndd by duon Lw 2851(2)(n) nd 8 NYCRR fo 1 6 h d nd podd h mjoy of hoo whn h d. Adm Pom OWN 3 w bnf fom by o dw upon h bhd uuum ou of OWN 1 nd OWN 2. h hoo w bn wh nd h o h xn OWN uuum m wh mnnn h fxby o dp o h pf nd of h hoo popuon. Lk pdo OWN 3 nnd o mpmn n dm pom foundd on h pnp of h Undndn by Dn ( UbD ) fmwok. UbD uz h-p bkwd pnnn ppoh n whh h bn h uuum dopmn po by dnfyn h dd nn u hn dmn how hy w know f udn h hd h u nd fny pn nn xpn nd nuon odny. OWN 3 nnd h o b UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 7

8 obo po n whh h nd nuon d wok oh o dop nd onnuy mpo h hoo uuum. h hoo w mpmn dm pom foow: LA (Rdn nd Wn) OWN 3 w pod udn wh 540 mnu of LA nuon h wk. LA nuon w foow h h Co Rdn nd Wn Poj ( CRWP ) wokhop mod. In h mod h pn on bd on mn of udn dn nd wn b. Dun LA nuon h w mpmn who mn-on h nopo y of on uu nudn hd dn nd wn d-oud n wn m-oup udd dn nd wn on nd foud ndpndn dn nd wn. OWN 3 w o mpmn Hnmnn Un of udy h-bd omm wn pom nd wh h CWRP uuum h fou on opnon nfomon nd n wn. mn of h nny uuum w uppmn OWN 3 LA pom nd h w pupofuy n h opn-ou ndd-nd modu no h LA nuon bok. o uppo un d h hoo nnd o uz Won Fundon pom whh pod xp nuon n foundon dn k uh wod onon funy nd omphnon nd Foun nd Pnn Ld Ly Inuon ho-m dn nnon h pod dy nn moup nuon h uppmn oom y hn. Mhm OWN 3 w pod udn wh 405 mnu of mhm nuon h wk. h hoo w dw fom wo ou fo mhm pom: nny/uk Mh modu nd Go Mh! nny/uk Mh n opn-ou ndd-nd uuum h nud mup modu fom whh h n hoo hu own hm o o nuon o h pf nd of h udn. pf op whn nny/uk Mh nud ounn nd b numb n n Kndn nd ddn nd ubn dm nd fon n 5 h d. Go Mh! omm uuum b fom Houhon Mffn Hou h nopo op fom n hnooy nnn nd mhm ( M ) nd p pu mph on h u of hnooy n h oom. kn oh h uu uppo OWN 3 phooph ppoh o mhm nuon whh po h fy wh b k knowd of ndd ohm nd my of mhm onp nd k houh h mpmnon of d nd p ny puo o udn nn n hh od hnkn nd ny k. n OWN 3 n uuum w pod udn wh h n k nd knowd ndd o undk dnd n ouwok n mdd hoo hh hoo nd byond houh ombnon of wo omm uu Fu Opon n ym ( FO ) k nd D n Modu nd OWN h dopd uuum. h wdy mpmnd FO pom nd wh h Non n duon ndd Nx Gnon n ndd nd Nw Yok n ndd. I o nd wh h hoo wokhop mod of nuon h pdo uzd n h FO pom nud nquy hnd-on nn mu-noy mhod udn-o-udn non dou nd f hnkn. Lkw D n Modu nodu mny UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 8

9 udn o op n onomy wh of m nd omnm houh xpn nd hnd-on h mu wod nf xpoon. o ud OWN 3 w u ombnon of nuon m fom h h Cuuum Inu ( CI ) OWN h-dopd uuum nd d by book o d o ud uuum. CI ou uz x y yp o n mup nn: u doy o k bud xpn x wn fo undndn pon oup nd pobm on oup wok. h o ud uuum OWN 3 w nb udn o dop h ho oph nd honoo hnkn k w h undndn of ho pp nd h dffn bwn f nd opnon. o ud w o nopo dy joun wn o pod udn wh ddon oppoun o dop h dn nd wn k. pnh A OWN 3 pnh nu nuon w bn n Kndn o h y udn h h oppouny o pp dun h opm y of ond nu quon. OWN 3 o fo y hd o qu funon pofny n on nu oh hn h udn n nu. pnh nu w xpo udn o uu dffn fom h own nd m o dop po ud bou nu nd uu kpn nd wh ou mon nd h n of h P uuum. h w uppmn pnh nu nuon n h oom wh h Mno pom ompu bd nu nuon pom. Vu A Mu nd Fm OWN 3 udn w udy u nd mu n d Kndn 5 h d nd by 3 d d udn w o nuon n fm p of h uuum. A ud OWN 3 w u Nw Yok Bupn fo h A whh pod ndd-bd oou ppoh o hn h. Phy duon In ddon o onbun o udn phy hh h phy duon pom OWN 3 w hp udn dop phy nd h k mk fnd h fun py mmb of m x on n nddu n h u of pyn dop pomnhp nd mpo f-m. houh h ppon n phy duon OWN 3 udn w h h ny knowd nd k o bh nd mnn phy fn pp n phy y nd mnn pon hh. xn hoo Pfomn P Appndx A fo Infomon dn h nw hoy dm pfomn nd udn dpn fo h hoo. UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 9

10 hoo Cuu nd Dpn OWN 3 o o hoo uu h ppu joyfu hh-pfomn udnnd nn nonmn. A dud pouy h P uuum w undpn h hoo uu nd mp o udn h u of h hd ommuny. A hoo h oo-onomy nd hny d ommuny OWN 3 w u h n of h P o nu h pop f wom mmb of d hoo fmy. OWN 3 w dfn dpn hpn hdn dop f-ono nd f-moon n hoo ommuny h f fo mmb. OWN 3 w odfy of u h dd pop udn bho nd mnnn of od whn h hoo houh od of ondu known h Cod of Cy. OWN 3 ff w nu h pn nd udn undnd h po dun udn nd pn onon. Onzon Cpy OWN h fd houhfu onzon uu h nud nwok C-u xu mnmn nd xn ff w nddu hoo dhp. Moo no ff mmb h wokd oh ufuy fo om m wh h hf xu off ( CO ) n p n h hoo npon nd h hf fnn off ( CFO ) nd do of xn on n p fo dd. Po o h opnn of OWN 3 OWN w xpnd no dhp m o nud hf dm off ( CAO ) nd hf opn off ( COO ) who w pomo dm nd uu onny o hoo. OWN w uz hd mod nd h pnnd fo h popoon oon of n off ff o h of h hoo. h CO nd CAO w oh h pnp nd nu OWN 3 uuum n o h ndd nd o of OWN. h CO w d o h pnp ponby fo h o dmnon nd mnmn of h hoo' opon nd nuon pom. h pnp w mn h mhm nd LA nuon oh nd p duon oodno who w uppo h pnp wh nuon mnmn. Gonn h by-w of OWN nd h h duon opoon bod w on of no fw hn f nd no mo hn 15 on mmb. h un mmb of h bod of u foh bow. 1. Jn Bnou Ph.D. (Ch) D. Bnou h bn n OWN bod mmb n 2003 nd n h ffh y bod pdn. A no pdn m Wokhop h d nd d U.. o mp h-bd y nd duon n nudn n hoo dn hh hb food nuy non my fm non ny y p nd (um) nd oh mpn unb youn hdn nd h ky du nfun n h. D. Bnou hod doo of duon n p duon fom h Co Coumb Uny m n ph nd nu phooy fom Hof Uny m n bnu dn/p duon fom. John' Uny nd bho of fom Hb H. Lhmn Co Cy Uny of Nw Yok. UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 10

11 2. M Chn (V Ch) M. Chn h pdn duon do nd found of Kd Kzy Phoo nd Dy n Ao Qun whh h bn n udn n h h m d n y hdhood duon fom Hun Co. M. Chn h bn bod mmb n Mu Fzd (y) M. Fzd pdn Hn K Innon wh h d h ob humn ou funon of h nnon nonpof ddd o pnn bndn nd dun mnuon n h wod. Pouy h w do of dmnon Doo whou Bod UA. h h bho of d fom h Lwn Co. M. Fzd h bn bod mmb n Ch Gudnoo (u) M. Gudnoo poj mn wh o Boh dopmn fm pzn n budn dn poj nonwd. Po o jonn o Boh n 2013 M. Gudnoo w pdn of h fmy dopmn bun h foud on dn poj. Pouy M. Gudnoo w pdn n h opon d of B n. H h bho of n d fom Con Uny nd m of bun dmnon d fom Buh Co. M. Gudnoo h bn bod mmb n Rhd. Bo q. (u) M. Bo n ony wh mo 30 y of xpn n on. H uny no ony Nonwd Inun wh h nod n on n by nd ompx Nw Yok bo on mon oh. H d h ju doo fom Fodhm Uny hoo of Lw nd h bho of fom UNY Abny. M. Bo h bn bod mmb n Oubunm m q. (u) M. m uom nd mkn mn wh Und Pn Goup In. Po o jonn h ompny n 2014 h wokd fo 13 y wh fm uh hu Roh nd Zb LLP; Pu W Rfknd Whon nd Gon LLP; nd MGu Wood LP. h h bho of w fom An Rukn Uny n nnd. M. m h bn bod mmb n Mnu Bhn Ph.D. (u) D. Bhn p on modn Ind foun on h wnh-nuy -oon nd pooon pod wh pu n n humn h (n)nonm nd quon of ony. H pofo of hoy Hun Co nd n unddu do. D. Bhn pouy d h of h ndpny humn h pom bd h Roo Hou Pub Poy Inu. D. Bhn h bn bod mmb n F OWN 3 w b od n CD 30 n Qun. OWN 3 nd n po o dnfy h oud n nubo p fo h f wo o h y of hoo opon w UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 11

12 h oud h hoo py. OWN 3 xpon xn budn h hoo oud nudn ho bn dopd by p dop nd fom Cho hoo budn. OWN 3 w ubm qu fo o-oon n NYCDO fy n CD 30; how h ppn undnd h n p mon ky h NYCDO w dny h qu o h ppn pn o ppy fo n n fo p fy. F Imp h f mp of OWN 3 on h d of oon h Nw Yok Cy hoo D ummzd bow. Ch Y Y 1 ( ) Y 5 ( ) Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 (A) (B) (C (D) () (F) (G) xpd Numb of udn B Ch hoo P Pup Ad Pojd P Pup Rnu (A x B) Oh D Rnu (PD Food Gn.) o Poj Fundn fom D o Ch hoo (C+D) Nw Yok Cy hoo D Bud Pojd D Imp (/F) % % *h NYCDO bud w dd fom h NYCDO wb: hp://hoo.ny.o/abouu/fundn/ow. h Inu fnd h h f mp of h popod hoo on h d pub h pub d nd nonpub hoo n h m oph w b mnm. In h n h h hoo opn wh hy hh nomn h Inu h dmnd h h f mp of h popod hoo on h pub d pub h nd nonpub hoo n h m oph w o b mnm. h Inu wd h h hoo popod up nd f pn fo h y of h popod h m nd uppon dn w h duon opoon bud fo h oh hoo op. h Inu o wd OWN bun pn nd f nfomon o dmn py o uppo n ddon hoo n Nw Yok. h Inu fnd h bud nd f pn o b ound nd uffn -up fund w b b o h nw h hoo. h duon opoon fnn pof b on h UNY F Dhbod Nofon nd Pub Commn h Inu nofd h d w pub nd p hoo n h m oph of h popod hoo bou p of h popo nd h popo w pod on h Inu wb fo pub w. h d hdud pub hn pnn o h popod hoo fo Oob Infomon bou pub ommn pnn o h popo podd n Appndx D. h Inu fuy w nd ond pub ommn d po o UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 12

13 fnzn ommndon. Pfn on duon Lw 2852(9-) qu uhoz o bh nd ppy pfn o ppon mn boh u nd uhoz ndd. h pupo of h o poz popo n h n h h numb of popo mn h UNY u qumn xd h mxmum numb of h o b ud n h RFP dnfd h mnmum by qumn nd pfn qud by duon Lw 2852(9-) dbd n d bow. OWN 3 popo m h by qumn dnd by h foown: h popo w uffny omp.. nudd nm h Popo ummy nd pon o RFP qu pbd by h Inu; h popo nudd b pn o m h nomn nd non bhd by h UNY u fo udn wh db LL nd udn who b o pp n h FRPL pom ( dd n Rqu No. 15); nd h popo podd dn of pub ouh h onfom o h A nd h po pbd by h UNY u fo h pupo of on nd nopon ommuny npu dn h popod h hoo nd dm pom ( dd n Rqu No. 3). A OWN 3 popo ubmon m h by h Inu uon onnud wh fu w of h popo n nw of h foundn m nd popod bod of u nd qu fo fon nd/o mndmn o h popo. h w po hn onnud wh n uon of h popo n on o h 10 Pfn C onnd n h RFP fo whh popo n n d dbd n h RFP Pfn on Gudn. In h n of fo h h boh popo w b jd un on ppn o whdw h o h popo fo ondon n ubqun RFP. h pfn whh n ddon o by nd h o hh ndd bhd by h UNY u nud h dmonon of h foown n ompn wh duon Lw 2852(9-)()()-(): nn udn hmn nd dn udn hmn p n dn/nu nd mhm; nn hh hoo duon nd foun on n pf hh hoo udn popuon nudn bu no md o udn k of no obnn hh hoo dpom -nod hh hoo dop-ou nd udn wh dm k bow d ; foun on h dm hmn of mdd hoo udn nd ppn hm fo ufu non o hh hoo; uzn hh-quy mn dnd o mu udn' knowd undndn of nd by o ppy onp houh h u of y of m yp nd fom; nn h quon dopon nd u of o nuon mpomn ym h pod h pnp nd dmno wh h nfomon nd ou hy nd o nfom nd mpo h nuon p don-mkn nd o ffn; pnn wh ow-pfomn pub hoo n h o h b duon p nd nnoon; dmonn h mnmn nd dhp hnqu ny o oom n - UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 13

14 up pobm o bh hn fnny b h hoo; nd dmonn h uppo of h hoo d n whh h popod h hoo w b od nd h nn o bh n onon onhp wh uh hoo d. h popod hoo nd o of 22 pfn pon ou of o of 45. Bd on h o nd h oh nfomon nd fndn foh hn h Inu ommnd h h UNY u ppo h uhoy of Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo o op h Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3. Aumn h Bod of Rn do no u ny h po h o numb of h uny ommndd by h Inu houd no xd h 17 h b fo un n Nw Yok Cy puun o duon Lw 2852(9)(). Conuon nd Rommndon Bd on w nd fndn h Inu ommnd h h UNY u ppo h popo o n Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo h uhoy o op Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 o opn n pmb UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 14

15 APPNDIX A duon Copoon Ow OuWo dn hbo hoodch hoo Qun CD 30 NGL I HL ANGUAGAR ACCOUNABI L I YPL ANGOAL 100 Comp M u : D Comp on. h y hp n of ud n h hoo n h ondy p f o m n o bo p ofi n y n L Aw b h n h of ud n n h m d d n hd. Comp D hoo Y G d % % : Y G d ff z :0. 3 Comp M u : ff z. hy h hoo w x d p d d ofp f o m n by n ff z of0. 3o bo n L A o d n o on n y on o nf o onom yd d n d ud n mon pub hoo nn wy o k. 0 Comp G ow h M u :M ng ow h P n. hy h hoo ' un dj u dm n 60 ow hp n f o ud n n d 48w b bo h ' un dj u d m d n ow hp n n : M d n L A. Y hoo M ng ow h UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 15

16 OuWo dn hbo hoodch hoo Qun CD 30 MA H MA I CACCOUNABI L I YPL ANGOAL 100 Comp M u : D Comp on. h y hp n of ud n h hoo n h ondy p f o m n o bo p ofi n y nm h m w b h n h of ud n n h m d d n hd. Comp D hoo Y G d % % : Y G d ff z :0. 3 Comp M u : ff z. hy h hoo w x d p d d ofp f o m n by n ff z of0. 3o bo n m hm o d n o on n y on o n f o onom y d d n d ud n mon pub hoo n N wy o k. 0 Comp G ow h M u :M ng ow h P n. hy h hoo ' un dj u dm n 60 ow hp n f o ud n n d 48w b bo h ' un dj u d m d n ow hp n n : M d n m hm. Y hoo M ng ow h UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 16

17 OuWo dn hbo hoodch hoo Qun CD 30 CI NCACCOUNABI L I YPL ANGOAL n :Comp M u. hy h p n of ud n h hoo n h ond y p f o m n o bo p ofi n y n n w x d h of ud n n h m d d n h d. D % hoo% :75 50 P CI ALPOPUL A I ONP RF ORMANC n o mnr n Mnd dadm don xm hoop np of non LAxm D P np of n LLn o mn donnylaxm hoop n ' Commnd n'omk n P o onnyla h d m ou omd bou hp f o m n of ud n n p du on nd L L bo no d o p o n h hoo ' f o m A oun b yp n. hny L A hn wy o k n h ondl n u A h m n nd d z d x m. " M k np o " d fin d mo nup on ofp ofi n y. ud n o f n ofi o / p ofi n y : n n ; m n ; n on n ; x p nd n ; nd Comm nd n. UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 17

18 OuWo dn hbo hoodch hoo QunCD30 %of ud n u p nd d 25 hoo I R hoo O R D O R A hou hcommun y hoo D ( " C D" ) nd hoo u p n on p n don h m ph d omp on b w n h nopo b f o h p m y on.a b C Dd n ud K nd n h ou hh h hoo d nd hoo d n ud on y h d dby h hoo.c Dd no b h howmup n n of u p n onof n ud n ho numb of u p n on hdu onof u p n on o h mofy wh n h hoo dm n d h u p n on.c Dd how n hd ff n b w n n hoo ndou of hoo u p n on no b. hp n hownh u du n hm hod mp oy dby hn wy o kc yd p m nof du on( " NY CDO " ) : h o hnumb of ud n n n n hoo oouof hoo u p n on ny mdu n h hoo y d d dby h o n o m n h nmup dby100. P n n n o mn : hp n of ud n b o u nf omp ouy whod d u n x pu on :hnumbof ud n x p d f om h hoo hy OuWo dn hbo hoodch hoo ' n o mn ndr n on u : D hoo ud n w h d b onom y d d n d n h n u n ud n w h d b onom y d d n d n h n u n o mn n R n on UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 18

19 APPNDIX B F Dhbod OUR WORLD NIGHBORHOOD CHARR CHOOL CHOOL INFORMAION Opnd BALANC H A Cun A o N A o Lb nd N A (255188) (542637) (38251) (198858) (478651) Ch nd Ch qun - GRAPH 1 Gn nd Con Rb Aoun Rb Ppd xpn Conbuon nd Oh Rb o Cun A - GRAPH 1 Popy Budn nd qupmn n Oh A o A - GRAPH 1 Lb nd N A Cun Lb Aoun Pyb nd Aud xpn Aud Pyo nd Bnf Dfd Rnu Cun Mu of Lon-m Db ho m Db - Bond No Pyb Oh o Cun Lb - GRAPH 1 L- Db nd No Pyb n un mu o Lb - GRAPH 1 N A Und mpoy d ACIVII Opn Rnu Rdn udn nomn udn wh Db Gn nd Con nd o Fd - nd IDA Fd - Oh Oh NYC Do Rn An Food /Chd Nuon Pom o Opn Rnu xpn Ru duon PD Ru duon & PD (ombnd) Oh o Pom Mnmn nd Gn Fundn o xpn - GRAPH 2 3 & 4 upu / (Df) Fom hoo Opon uppo nd Oh Rnu Conbuon Fundn Mnou Inom N d fom on o uppo nd Oh Rnu o Und Rnu o mpoy Rd Rnu o Rnu - GRAPH 2 & 3 Chn n N A N A - Bnnn of Y - GRAPH 2 Po Y Adjumn() N A - nd of Y - GRAPH 2 UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 19

20 OUR WORLD NIGHBORHOOD CHARR CHOOL CHOOL INFORMAION - (Connud) Funon xpn Bkdown Ponn Admn ff Ponn Inuon Ponn Non-Inuon Ponn Ponn (Combnd) o nd ff Fn Bnf & Pyo x Rmn Mnmn Compny F Budn nd Lnd Rn / L ff Dopmn Pofon F Conun & Puhd Mkn / Rumn udn upp M & Dpon Oh o xpn CHOOL ANALYI NROLLMN Pmy hoo D: NYC CHANCLLOR' OFFIC P Pup Fundn (Whd A of A D) In o po y K-8 - On Chd nomn Fn Chd nomn (nud ny on) Au nomn - GRAPH 4 Chd Gd Fn Chd Gd (nud ny on) K K K K % % % % % % 18.4% 2.2% % 18.5% -1.8% % 18.9% -4.2% % 20.1% 0.4% % 19.0% 3.4% PR UDN BRAKDOWN Rnu Opn Oh Rnu nd uppo OAL - GRAPH 3 xpn Pom Mnmn nd Gn Fundn OAL - GRAPH 3 % of Pom % of Mnmn nd Oh % of Rnu xdn xpn - GRAPH 5 udn o Fuy Ro Fuy o Admn Ro Fnn Rponby Compo o - GRAPH 6 o Fy on / Fy Adqu / Fy Nd Monon < 1.0 Wokn Cp - GRAPH 7 N Wokn Cp A % of Und Rnu Wokn Cp (Cun) Ro o Rk (Low 3.0 / Mdum / Hh < 1.4) Rn (xn 3.0 / Good / Poo < 1.4) Quk (Ad ) Ro o Rk (Low 2.5 / Mdum / Hh < 1.0) Rn (xn 2.5 / Good / Poo < 1.0) Db o A Ro - GRAPH 7 o Rk (Low < 0.50 / Mdum / Hh > 1.0) Rn (xn < 0.50 / Good / Poo > 1.0) Monh of Ch - GRAPH 8 o Rk (Low > 3 mo. / Mdum 1-3 mo. / Hh < 1 mo.) Rn (xn > 3 mo. / Good 1-3 mo. / Poo < 1 mo.) Fy on Fy on Fy on Fy on Fy on % % % % % 2.6 MDIUM MDIUM MDIUM MDIUM xn Good Good Good Good xn xn xn xn xn xn xn xn xn xn MDIUM MDIUM xn xn Good Good xn UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 20

21 OUR WORLD NIGHBORHOOD CHARR CHOOL GRAPH 1 GRAPH 2 Ch A nd Lb Rnu xpn nd N A Do Do Ch Cun A Fo h Y ndd Jun 30 Cun Lb o A o Lb h h u h onhp bwn nd b nd o wh xn h mk up un. Idy fo h ub ub 2 houh 4 (.. un. un b) h oumn on h f hn h mmd oumn on h h; nd ny pkn h b h p h b. GRAPH Rnu & xpn P Pup Rnu xpn Fo h Y ndd Jun 30 N A - Bnnn N A - ndn h h u o nu nd xpn h y nd h onhp ho ub h on h n/d of n on y-o-y b. Idy ub 1 nu w b hn ub 2 xpn nd u ub 3 n - bnnn w n h y budn mo fy b hoo. GRAPH nomn. Opn xpn Do nomn Opn xpn Fo h Y ndn Jun 30 R. - R. & p D R. - Oh uppo xp. - Oh Pom R. - Oh Opn xp. - R. & p D xp. - Mnm. & Oh h h u h bkdown of nu nd xpn on p pup b. Cuon houd b xd n mkn hoo-by-hoo ompon n hoo n dffn mon o udn popuon ky o h ubny dffn duon o b. Compon wh m hoo wh m dynm mo d Fo h Y ndd Jun 30 Pom xpn o xpn nomn Mnmn & Oh h h u o wh xn h hoo' opn xpn h foowd udn nomn pn. A bn umpon h h d h opn xpn n wh h ddon udn d. h h o omp nd on owh nd of boh n nh no wh onb xpon mh b n m of onom of. UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 21

22 OUR WORLD NIGHBORHOOD CHARR CHOOL Compb hoo Ron o Nwok: A UNY Auhozd Ch hoo (Inudn Cod hoo) GRAPH 5 GRAPH 6 % Bkdown of xpn 100.0% Compo o % % 1.00 o Pn 60.0% 20.0% % % Fo h Y ndd Jun 30 Pom - hoo Fo h Y ndd Jun 30 Pom - Compb Mnmn & Oh - hoo Mnmn & Oh - Compb Fy: on = / Adqu = / Nd Monon < 1.0 RV. xdn XP. - hoo RV. xdn XP. Compb Compo o - hoo h h u h pn xpn bkdown bwn pom nd mnmn & oh w h pn of nu xdn xpn. Idy h pn xpn fo pom w f xd h of h mnmn & oh xpn. h pn of nu xdn xpn houd no b n. m uon mnond on GRAPH 3 houd b ud n ompn hoo. Wokn Cp & Db o A Ro GRAPH 7 Bnhmk h h u hoo' ompo o bd on h mhodooy dopd by h Und Dpmn of duon (UDO) o dmn whh p no-fo-pof o nd un fnny on nouh o pp n fd on pom. h o n b d fo obn h f nd of pu hoo nd ud oo o omp h u of dffn hoo. Monh of Ch GRAPH 8 WORKING CAPIAL RAIO - Rk = Low > 3.0 / Mdum / Hh < 1.4 DB O A RAIO - Rk = Low < 0.50 / Mdum / Hh > Compo o - Compb Wokn Cp Db Monh Fo h Y ndd Jun 30 Wokn Cp - hoo Wokn Cp - Compb Db Ro - hoo Db Ro - Compb h h u wokn p nd db o o. h wokn p o nd f hoo h nouh ho-m o o mmd b/ho m db. h db o o nd wh popoon of db hoo h o. h mu n d o h of h hoo on wh h pon k h hoo f n m of dbod Fo h Y ndd Jun 30 Ch - hoo Ch - Compb Id Monh of Ch h h u how mny monh of h h hoo h n. h m o mu ony h hoo' by o py db nd m hy om du. h om d of how on hoo oud onnu onon opn o whou ppn no om oh non-h fom of fnnn n h n h nu w o fown o h hoo. UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 22

23 APPNDIX C Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 B Idnfon Infomon Ld Appn(): D. Jn Bnou Mnmn Compny: Non Pn Onzon: Non Loon (D): CD 30 udn Pop./Gd pn : Kndn 8 h Opnn D: pmb 2019 UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 23

24 APPNDIX D ummy of Pub Commn Rd Dun h UNY Pub Commn Pod houh Oob On o bou Juy n odn wh duon Lw 2857(1) h Inu nofd h d w pub nd p hoo n h m oph of h popod hoo bou p of h popo o bh OWN 3. h no mndd h d h h Nw Yok Common of duon uon qu h hoo d o hod pub hn whn 30 dy of h no fo h nw h ppon. A dd opy of OWN 3 popo w o pod on h Inu wb fo pub w : hp:// h d hdud pub hn pnn o h popod hoo fo Oob A ummy of ommn fom hn podd o h Inu by h NYCDO nd h fou ommuny mmb ndd h hn. wo pn of un OWN udn pok n uppo of h popod hoo hd h po xpn wh h xn hoo nd nod h nd fo ddon hh-quy hoo n CD 30. h Inu h d no ndpndn pub ommn n o h popo o d. UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 24

25 UNY Ch hoo Inu UNY Pz 353 Bodwy Abny NY ACADMIC PRFORMANC: OUR WORLD NIGHBORHOOD CHARR CHOOL A ACADMIC Pf PRFORMANC UPDAD PRFORMANC OCOBR 2018 h ddndum o h Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo ( OWN ) ummy of Fndn (dd pmb ) pod ddon nfomon bou h hoo dm hmn dun h h m. Wh ondun hn w of h mn u h Nw Yok duon Dpmn ( NYD ) dyd h of h nh nu ( LA ) nd mhm ouom d fo udn n 3 d 8 h d un pmb Fo h pupo of h upd nd pnn o h hmn d h of h d md h Inu o nfomon ny o nyz wo qud pfomn mu ypy nudd n n ny of hoo nmn of LA nd mhm o. h Inu w no b o qu h d ny o xu omp ff z ny po o wn h ddndum. h dy o dowd m fo h Inu o nyz h hoo pfomn n ompon o mu of nm po p of h ny ppod y udn ud A ( A ) ounby ym. Nowhndn h mon h ddndum pod n ny of h b ouom d fom h 3 d 8 h d LA nd mhm xm fo OWN. In OWN onnud o po hh pofny hn d ompon hoo n LA nd mhm hd n y oh y of un h m. Wh 62% of h hoo udn nod n h ond y on o bo pofny n LA h hoo xdd h d by n pn pon. In mhm 59% of h hoo udn od o bo pofny xdn h d by h pn pon. OWN w h numb of udn pfomn bo d xpon n boh ubj. Fom o h hoo nd pn of udn on pfomn 4 n LA nd mhm by x nd n pn pon py. MAUR NGLIH LANGUAG AR MAHMAIC Comp Mu: D Compon. h y h pn of udn h hoo n h ond y pfomn o bo pofny n LA nd mhm w b hn h of udn n h m d d n h d UNY Ch hoo Inu ummy of Fndn nd Rommndon Ou Wod Nhbohood Ch hoo 3 25