Axiom of Choice, Maximal Independent Sets, Argumentation and Dialogue Games
|
|
- Marsha Robyn Harmon
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Axiom of Choice, Maximal Independent Sets, Argumentation and Dialogue Games Christof Spanring Department of Computer Science, University of Liverpool, UK Institute of Information Systems, Vienna University of Technology, Austria London, September 5, 0
2 A minor example Example (Games played on Argument Graphs) Can you defend an argument a beyond doubt, i.e. defeat any attackers without running into conflict with your own argument base? Who has a winning strategy, you as the proponent or your oponent? a b c d Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation / 5
3 The Why? of Infinities I Question How many prime numbers are there? Question How many rational numbers p q are there? Question How many decimal numbers are there? Question Is there a set of all sets? Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation / 5
4 The Why? of Infinities II Example ( Q = N ) There are only as many rational as natural numbers. Example ( N < R ) There are more real than natural numbers. i = 0. i, i, i, i, i = 0. i, i, i, i, i = 0. i, i, i, i, i = 0. i, i, i, i, Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation / 5
5 Set Theory Definition Zermelo-Fraenkel Set Theory (ZFC-Axioms) Extensionality x y ( z (z x z y) x = y) Foundation x ( a (a x) y (y x z (z y z x))) Specification z v v v n y x (x y (x z ϕ)) Pairing x y z (x z y z) 5 Union x z y v ((v y y x) v z) 6 Replacement x v v v n ( y (y x!zϕ) w y (y x!z(y w ϕ)) 7 Infinity x ( x y (y x (y {y}) x)) 8 Power Set x y z (z x z y) 9 Choice x ( x f : x x, a x (f (a) a)) Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation 6 / 5
6 Choice and Companions Example (The Axiom of Choice) Every set of non-empty sets has a choice function, selecting exactly one element from each set. Example (Basis Theorem for Vector Spaces) Every vector space has a basis. Example (Well-ordering Theorem) Every set can be well-ordered. Example (Zorn s Lemma) If any chain of a non-empty partially ordered set has an upper bound then there is at least one maximal element. Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation 7 / 5
7 Determinacy Example (A number game) Some well-known set of sequences of natural numbers S N N, defines the winning set. Move i selects a number for position i, two players alternate, proponent starts with move 0. Proponent wins if the played sequence is an element of S, otherwise opponent wins. Definition (Axiom of Determinacy) Every number game of the above form is predetermined, i.e. one of the players has a winning strategy. Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation 8 / 5
8 Possibly infinite Games Example (Some number game) Two players alternate stating moves. Moves are decimal digits 0,, 0. Proponent wins if 0.i 0 i i i Q. Example (A slightly simpler number game) Two players alternate making moves i 0, i, i, i, Moves are binary digits 0 or. The winning set (for proponent) consists of sequences where for some n > 0 we have i j = i j+n for all j < n, i.e. the initial sequence is repeated at least once. For instance in 0,, 0, 0,, 0,,, 0, 0, 0,, 0,, 0, 0,, 0,,, 0, 0, 0,, proponent wins.who wins? Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation 9 / 5
9 Choice andvs. Determinacy Question How do the axioms of choice (AC) and determinacy (AD) relate to each other? Theorem (AD implies countable AC) (AD) (AC) fin Theorem (AD implies Consistency of ZF Set Theory) (AD) Con(ZF) Theorem (AC implies not AD) (AC) (AD) Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation 0 / 5
10 Abstract Argumentation I Definition (Argumentation Frameworks) An argumentation framework (AF) is a pair F = (A, R). A is an arbitrary set of arguments. R (A A) is the attack relation. For (a, b) R write a b, and say a attacks b. For a b c say a defends c against b. Example a b Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation / 5
11 Abstract Argumentation II Definition (Argumentation Semantics) Some AF F = (A, R) and some set E A. E is conflict-free (cf) iff E E. E is admissible (adm) iff E cf (F) and for all a E also E a. E is a preferred extension (pref) iff it is maximal admissible, i.e. E adm(f) and for any E adm(f) with E E already E = E. Example a b cf (F) = {, {a}, {b}} adm(f) = {, {a}} prf (F) = {{a}} Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation / 5
12 (AC) prf (F) Definition (Zorn s Lemma) If any chain of a non-empty partially ordered set has an upper bound then there is at least one maximal element. Definition (Partial Order) A partial order (P, ) is a set P with a binary relation that fulfills reflexivity: a a, antisymmetry: a b b a a = b, transitivity: a b b c a c. Definition (Axiom of Union) The union over the elements of a set is a set. z y x u(x z u x) u y Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation / 5
13 ( Fprf (F) ) (AC) Definition (ZF-Axioms) Comprehension: we can construct formalizable subsets of sets. Union: the union over the elements of a set is a set. Replacement: definable functions deliver images of sets. Power Set: we can construct the power set of any set. Selecting Nodes/Elements: a choice function Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation 5 / 5
14 References Devlin, K. (99). The Joy of Sets: Fundamentals of Contemporary Set Theory. Undergraduate Texts in Mathematics. Springer, Springer-Verlag 75 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 000, U.S.A., nd edition. Dung, P. M. (995). On the acceptability of arguments and its fundamental role in nonmonotonic reasoning, logic programming and n-person games. Artif. Intell., 77(): 58. Gödel, K. and Brown, G. W. (90). The consistency of the axiom of choice and of the generalized continuum-hypothesis with the axioms of set theory. Princeton University Press. Kunen, K. (98). Set Theory An Introduction To Independence Proofs (Studies in Logic and the Foundations of Mathematics). North Holland. Mycielski, J. (96). On the axiom of determinacy. Fund. Math, 5:05 II. Walton, D. N. (98). Logical Dialogue-Games. University Press of America, Lanham, Maryland. Christof Spanring, ICCSW 0 Choice and Argumentation 5 / 5
Axiom of Choice, Maximal Independent Sets, Argumentation and Dialogue Games
Axiom of Choice, Maximal Independent Sets, Argumentation and Dialogue Games Christof Spanring 1,2 1 Department of Computer Science, University of Liverpool http://cgi.csc.liv.ac.uk/~christof c.spanring@liverpool.ac.uk
More informationDialogue Games on Abstract Argumentation Graphs 1
Dialogue Games on Abstract Argumentation Graphs 1 Christof Spanring Department of Computer Science, University of Liverpool, UK Institute of Information Systems, TU Wien, Austria LABEX CIMI Pluridisciplinary
More informationSection 0.7. The Axiom of Choice, Order, and Zorn s Lemma
0.7. The Axiom of Choice, Order, and Zorn s Lemma 1 Section 0.7. The Axiom of Choice, Order, and Zorn s Lemma Note. In this section, we state the Axiom of Choice and two statements equivalent to it (Zorn
More informationTHE CANTOR GAME: WINNING STRATEGIES AND DETERMINACY. by arxiv: v1 [math.ca] 29 Jan 2017 MAGNUS D. LADUE
THE CANTOR GAME: WINNING STRATEGIES AND DETERMINACY by arxiv:170109087v1 [mathca] 9 Jan 017 MAGNUS D LADUE 0 Abstract In [1] Grossman Turett define the Cantor game In [] Matt Baker proves several results
More informationMath 5801 General Topology and Knot Theory
Lecture 2-8/24/2012 Math 5801 Ohio State University August 24, 2012 Course Info Textbook (required) J. R. Munkres, Topology (2nd Edition), Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 2000. ISBN-10: 0131816292
More informationInformal Statement Calculus
FOUNDATIONS OF MATHEMATICS Branches of Logic 1. Theory of Computations (i.e. Recursion Theory). 2. Proof Theory. 3. Model Theory. 4. Set Theory. Informal Statement Calculus STATEMENTS AND CONNECTIVES Example
More informationIncompleteness Theorems, Large Cardinals, and Automata ov
Incompleteness Theorems, Large Cardinals, and Automata over Finite Words Equipe de Logique Mathématique Institut de Mathématiques de Jussieu - Paris Rive Gauche CNRS and Université Paris 7 TAMC 2017, Berne
More informationChapter 2 Axiomatic Set Theory
Chapter 2 Axiomatic Set Theory Ernst Zermelo (1871 1953) was the first to find an axiomatization of set theory, and it was later expanded by Abraham Fraenkel (1891 1965). 2.1 Zermelo Fraenkel Set Theory
More informationWHY ISN T THE CONTINUUM PROBLEM ON THE MILLENNIUM ($1,000,000) PRIZE LIST?
WHY ISN T THE CONTINUUM PROBLEM ON THE MILLENNIUM ($1,000,000) PRIZE LIST? Solomon Feferman CSLI Workshop on Logic, Rationality and Intelligent Interaction Stanford, June 1, 2013 Why isn t the Continuum
More informationSet Theory and the Foundation of Mathematics. June 19, 2018
1 Set Theory and the Foundation of Mathematics June 19, 2018 Basics Numbers 2 We have: Relations (subsets on their domain) Ordered pairs: The ordered pair x, y is the set {{x, y}, {x}}. Cartesian products
More informationArgumentation-Based Models of Agent Reasoning and Communication
Argumentation-Based Models of Agent Reasoning and Communication Sanjay Modgil Department of Informatics, King s College London Outline Logic and Argumentation - Dung s Theory of Argumentation - The Added
More informationSELF-DUAL UNIFORM MATROIDS ON INFINITE SETS
SELF-DUAL UNIFORM MATROIDS ON INFINITE SETS NATHAN BOWLER AND STEFAN GESCHKE Abstract. We extend the notion of a uniform matroid to the infinitary case and construct, using weak fragments of Martin s Axiom,
More informationWeak Choice Principles and Forcing Axioms
Weak Choice Principles and Forcing Axioms Elizabeth Lauri 1 Introduction Faculty Mentor: David Fernandez Breton Forcing is a technique that was discovered by Cohen in the mid 20th century, and it is particularly
More informationArgumentative Characterisations of Non-monotonic Inference in Preferred Subtheories: Stable Equals Preferred
Argumentative Characterisations of Non-monotonic Inference in Preferred Subtheories: Stable Equals Preferred Sanjay Modgil November 17, 2017 Abstract A number of argumentation formalisms provide dialectical
More informationUnsolvable problems, the Continuum Hypothesis, and the nature of infinity
Unsolvable problems, the Continuum Hypothesis, and the nature of infinity W. Hugh Woodin Harvard University January 9, 2017 V : The Universe of Sets The power set Suppose X is a set. The powerset of X
More informationSTRUCTURES WITH MINIMAL TURING DEGREES AND GAMES, A RESEARCH PROPOSAL
STRUCTURES WITH MINIMAL TURING DEGREES AND GAMES, A RESEARCH PROPOSAL ZHENHAO LI 1. Structures whose degree spectrum contain minimal elements/turing degrees 1.1. Background. Richter showed in [Ric81] that
More informationMath 5801 General Topology and Knot Theory
Lecture 3-8/27/2012 Math 5801 Ohio State University August 27, 2012 Course Info Textbook (required) J. R. Munkres, Topology (2nd Edition), Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 2000. ISBN-10: 0131816292
More informationContents Propositional Logic: Proofs from Axioms and Inference Rules
Contents 1 Propositional Logic: Proofs from Axioms and Inference Rules... 1 1.1 Introduction... 1 1.1.1 An Example Demonstrating the Use of Logic in Real Life... 2 1.2 The Pure Propositional Calculus...
More informationThe Reflection Theorem
The Reflection Theorem Formalizing Meta-Theoretic Reasoning Lawrence C. Paulson Computer Laboratory Lecture Overview Motivation for the Reflection Theorem Proving the Theorem in Isabelle Applying the Reflection
More informationJónsson Properties for Non-Ordinal Sets Under the Axiom of Determinacy
Jónsson Properties for Non-Ordinal Sets Under the Axiom of Determinacy Fifth NY Graduate Student Logic Conference The Jónsson Property For κ a cardinal and n ω, [κ] n = {(α 1,, α n ) κ n : α 1 < < α n
More informationSets and Games. Logic Tea, ILLC Amsterdam. 14. September Stefan Bold. Institute for Logic, Language and Computation. Department of Mathematics
Sets and Games 14. September 2004 Logic Tea, ILLC Amsterdam Stefan Bold Mathematical Logic Group Department of Mathematics University of Bonn Institute for Logic, Language and Computation University of
More informationarxiv: v1 [cs.lo] 19 Mar 2019
Turing-Completeness of Dynamics in Abstract Persuasion Argumentation Ryuta Arisaka arxiv:1903.07837v1 [cs.lo] 19 Mar 2019 ryutaarisaka@gmail.com Abstract. Abstract Persuasion Argumentation (APA) is a dynamic
More informationZermelo-Fraenkel Set Theory
Zermelo-Fraenkel Set Theory Zak Mesyan University of Colorado Colorado Springs The Real Numbers In the 19th century attempts to prove facts about the real numbers were limited by the lack of a rigorous
More informationESSENCE 2014: Argumentation-Based Models of Agent Reasoning and Communication
ESSENCE 2014: Argumentation-Based Models of Agent Reasoning and Communication Sanjay Modgil Department of Informatics, King s College London Outline Logic, Argumentation and Reasoning - Dung s Theory of
More informationStrategic Argumentation under Grounded Semantics is NP-Complete
Strategic Argumentation under Grounded Semantics is NP-Complete Guido Governatori 1, Michael J. Maher 2, Francesco Olivieri 3, Antonino Rotolo 4 and Simone Scannnapieco 3 1 NICTA Queensland, Australia
More informationHandbook of Logic and Proof Techniques for Computer Science
Steven G. Krantz Handbook of Logic and Proof Techniques for Computer Science With 16 Figures BIRKHAUSER SPRINGER BOSTON * NEW YORK Preface xvii 1 Notation and First-Order Logic 1 1.1 The Use of Connectives
More informationComputational Aspects of Abstract Argumentation
Computational Aspects of Abstract Argumentation PhD Defense, TU Wien (Vienna) Wolfgang Dvo ák supervised by Stefan Woltran Institute of Information Systems, Database and Articial Intelligence Group Vienna
More informationReferences A CONSTRUCTIVE INTRODUCTION TO FIRST ORDER LOGIC. The Starting Point. Goals of foundational programmes for logic:
A CONSTRUCTIVE INTRODUCTION TO FIRST ORDER LOGIC Goals of foundational programmes for logic: Supply an operational semantic basis for extant logic calculi (ex post) Rational reconstruction of the practice
More informationUltrafilters and Set Theory. Andreas Blass University of Michigan Ann Arbor, MI
Ultrafilters and Set Theory Andreas Blass University of Michigan Ann Arbor, MI 48109 ablass@umich.edu Ultrafilters and Set Theory Ultrafilters and Set Theory But not large cardinals (Itay Neeman) Ultrafilters
More informationThis section will take the very naive point of view that a set is a collection of objects, the collection being regarded as a single object.
1.10. BASICS CONCEPTS OF SET THEORY 193 1.10 Basics Concepts of Set Theory Having learned some fundamental notions of logic, it is now a good place before proceeding to more interesting things, such as
More informationThe Absoluteness of Constructibility
Lecture: The Absoluteness of Constructibility We would like to show that L is a model of V = L, or, more precisely, that L is an interpretation of ZF + V = L in ZF. We have already verified that σ L holds
More informationInfinite Argumentation Frameworks
Infinite Argumentation Frameworks On the Existence and Uniqueness of Extensions Ringo Baumann 1 and Christof Spanring 2,3 1 Computer Science Institute, Leipzig University 2 Department of Computer Science,
More informationEssential Background for Real Analysis I (MATH 5210)
Background Material 1 Essential Background for Real Analysis I (MATH 5210) Note. These notes contain several definitions, theorems, and examples from Analysis I (MATH 4217/5217) which you must know for
More informationArgumentation Theory and Modal Logic
Argumentation Theory and Modal Logic Davide Grossi ILLC, University of Amsterdam Preface Argumentation in a nutshell Arguing Arguing The Economist: Mr. Berlusconi is unfit to lead Italy because His election
More informationUltrafilters with property (s)
Ultrafilters with property (s) Arnold W. Miller 1 Abstract A set X 2 ω has property (s) (Marczewski (Szpilrajn)) iff for every perfect set P 2 ω there exists a perfect set Q P such that Q X or Q X =. Suppose
More informationThe Uniform Distributions Puzzle
The Uniform Distributions Puzzle Luc Lauwers Center for Economic Studies, K.U.Leuven Naamsestraat 69, B-3000 Leuven, BELGIUM Luc.Lauwers@econ.kuleuven.be July 17, 2007 In the usual, countably additive
More informationINTRODUCTION TO CARDINAL NUMBERS
INTRODUCTION TO CARDINAL NUMBERS TOM CUCHTA 1. Introduction This paper was written as a final project for the 2013 Summer Session of Mathematical Logic 1 at Missouri S&T. We intend to present a short discussion
More informationR E P O R T. The cf2 Argumentation Semantics Revisited INSTITUT FÜR INFORMATIONSSYSTEME DBAI-TR
TECHNICAL R E P O R T INSTITUT FÜR INFORMATIONSSYSTEME ABTEILUNG DATENBANKEN UND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE The cf2 Argumentation Semantics Revisited DBAI-TR-2012-77 Sarah Alice Gaggl Stefan Woltran Institut
More informationPart II Logic and Set Theory
Part II Logic and Set Theory Theorems Based on lectures by I. B. Leader Notes taken by Dexter Chua Lent 2015 These notes are not endorsed by the lecturers, and I have modified them (often significantly)
More informationFrom Constructibility and Absoluteness to Computability and Domain Independence
From Constructibility and Absoluteness to Computability and Domain Independence Arnon Avron School of Computer Science Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv 69978, Israel aa@math.tau.ac.il Abstract. Gödel s main
More informationExplaining Predictions from Data Argumentatively
Explaining Predictions from Data Argumentatively Explain AI@Imperial Workshop Ken Satoh 1 Oana Cocarascu Kristijonas Čyras Francesca Toni April 25, 2018 Department of Computing, Imperial College London,
More informationADVANCED CALCULUS - MTH433 LECTURE 4 - FINITE AND INFINITE SETS
ADVANCED CALCULUS - MTH433 LECTURE 4 - FINITE AND INFINITE SETS 1. Cardinal number of a set The cardinal number (or simply cardinal) of a set is a generalization of the concept of the number of elements
More informationX = { X f X i A i : (œx, y 0 X)[x /= y œi[ x i /= y i ]]}.
CARDINALS II James T. Smith San Francisco State University These notes develop the part of cardinal arithmetic that depends on the axiom of choice. The first result is the comparability theorem: every
More informationR E P O R T. On Rejected Arguments and Implicit Conflicts: The Hidden Power of Argumentation Semantics INSTITUT FÜR INFORMATIONSSYSTEME
TECHNICAL R E P O R T INSTITUT FÜR INFORMATIONSSYSTEME ABTEILUNG DATENBANKEN UND ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE On Rejected Arguments and Implicit Conflicts: The Hidden Power of Argumentation Semantics DBAI-TR-2016-102
More informationThe Metamathematics of Randomness
The Metamathematics of Randomness Jan Reimann January 26, 2007 (Original) Motivation Effective extraction of randomness In my PhD-thesis I studied the computational power of reals effectively random for
More informationFINITE BOREL MEASURES ON SPACES OF CARDINALITY LESS THAN c
PROCEEDINGS OF THE AMERICAN MATHEMATICAL SOCIETY Volume 81, Number 4, April 1981 FINITE BOREL MEASURES ON SPACES OF CARDINALITY LESS THAN c R. J. GARDNER AND G. GRUENHAGE Abstract. Let k < c be uncountable.
More informationHow Philosophy Impacts on Mathematics
.. How Philosophy Impacts on Mathematics Yang Rui Zhi Department of Philosophy Peking University Fudan University March 20, 2012 Yang Rui Zhi (PKU) Philosophical Impacts on Mathematics 20 Mar. 2012 1 /
More informationKönig s Lemma and Kleene Tree
König s Lemma and Kleene Tree Andrej Bauer May 3, 2006 Abstract I present a basic result about Cantor space in the context of computability theory: the computable Cantor space is computably non-compact.
More informationALMOST DISJOINT AND INDEPENDENT FAMILIES. 1. introduction. is infinite. Fichtenholz and Kantorovich showed that there is an independent family
ALMOST DISJOINT AND INDEPENDENT FAMILIES STEFAN GESCHKE Abstract. I collect a number of proofs of the existence of large almost disjoint and independent families on the natural numbers. This is mostly
More informationClassical Theory of Cardinal Characteristics
Classical Theory of Cardinal Characteristics Andreas Blass University of Michigan 22 August, 2018 Andreas Blass (University of Michigan) Classical Theory of Cardinal Characteristics 22 August, 2018 1 /
More informationOutside ZF - Set Cardinality, the Axiom of Choice, and the Continuum Hypothesis
Outside ZF - Set Cardinality, the Axiom of Choice, and the Continuum Hypothesis Tali Magidson June 6, 2017 Synopsis In June 2002, "Two Classical Surprises Concerning the Axiom of Choice and the Continuum
More informationOn the Semantics of Simple Contrapositive Assumption-Based Argumentation Frameworks
On the Semantics of Simple Contrapositive Assumption-Based Argumentation Frameworks Jesse Heyninck 1 and Ofer Arieli 2 Institute of Philosophy II, Ruhr University Bochum, Germany School of Computer Science,
More informationSOME ADDITIVE DARBOUX LIKE FUNCTIONS
Journal of Applied Analysis Vol. 4, No. 1 (1998), pp. 43 51 SOME ADDITIVE DARBOUX LIKE FUNCTIONS K. CIESIELSKI Received June 11, 1997 and, in revised form, September 16, 1997 Abstract. In this note we
More informationDr. Bob s Axiom of Choice Centennial Lecture Fall A Century Ago
Dr. Bob s Axiom of Choice Centennial Lecture Fall 2008 Ernst Zermelo, 1871 1953 A Century Ago Note. This year (2008) marks the 100 year anniversary of Ernst Zermelo s first statement of the currently accepted
More informationINFINITY: CARDINAL NUMBERS
INFINITY: CARDINAL NUMBERS BJORN POONEN 1 Some terminology of set theory N := {0, 1, 2, 3, } Z := {, 2, 1, 0, 1, 2, } Q := the set of rational numbers R := the set of real numbers C := the set of complex
More informationarxiv: v1 [math.lo] 14 Jul 2017
THE CLASSIFICATION OF COUNTABLE MODELS OF SET THEORY arxiv:1707.04660v1 [math.lo] 14 Jul 2017 JOHN CLEMENS, SAMUEL COSKEY, AND SAMUEL DWORETZKY ABSTRACT. We study the complexity of the classification problem
More informationFoundations of Mathematics
Foundations of Mathematics L. Pedro Poitevin 1. Preliminaries 1.1. Sets We will naively think of a set as a collection of mathematical objects, called its elements or members. To indicate that an object
More informationMATH 3300 Test 1. Name: Student Id:
Name: Student Id: There are nine problems (check that you have 9 pages). Solutions are expected to be short. In the case of proofs, one or two short paragraphs should be the average length. Write your
More informationRelations. Relations. Definition. Let A and B be sets.
Relations Relations. Definition. Let A and B be sets. A relation R from A to B is a subset R A B. If a A and b B, we write a R b if (a, b) R, and a /R b if (a, b) / R. A relation from A to A is called
More information1. Propositional Calculus
1. Propositional Calculus Some notes for Math 601, Fall 2010 based on Elliott Mendelson, Introduction to Mathematical Logic, Fifth edition, 2010, Chapman & Hall. 2. Syntax ( grammar ). 1.1, p. 1. Given:
More informationAbstract Dialectical Frameworks
Abstract Dialectical Frameworks Gerhard Brewka Computer Science Institute University of Leipzig brewka@informatik.uni-leipzig.de joint work with Stefan Woltran G. Brewka (Leipzig) KR 2010 1 / 18 Outline
More informationAn introduction to OCA
An introduction to OCA Gemma Carotenuto January 29, 2013 Introduction These notes are extracted from the lectures on forcing axioms and applications held by professor Matteo Viale at the University of
More informationNONSTANDARD MODELS AND KRIPKE S PROOF OF THE GÖDEL THEOREM
Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic Volume 41, Number 1, 2000 NONSTANDARD MODELS AND KRIPKE S PROOF OF THE GÖDEL THEOREM HILARY PUTNAM Abstract This lecture, given at Beijing University in 1984, presents
More information1 Introduction. Math Sci Net numbers(msc2000) Primary = 06-02; Secondary = 06A05, 28A12, 54F05 draft of
Well-ordered Sets, Ulam Matrices, and Probability Measures by Harold Bennett (Texas Tech University, Lubbock, TX 79409) and David Lutzer (College of William and Mary, Williamsburg, VA 23187) Abstract In
More informationMassachusetts Institute of Technology 6.042J/18.062J, Fall 02: Mathematics for Computer Science Professor Albert Meyer and Dr.
Massachusetts Institute of Technology 6.042J/18.062J, Fall 02: Mathematics for Computer Science Professor Albert Meyer and Dr. Radhika Nagpal Quiz 1 Appendix Appendix Contents 1 Induction 2 2 Relations
More informationThe Continuum Problem
The University of San Francisco USF Scholarship: a digital repository @ Gleeson Library Geschke Center Mathematics College of Arts and Sciences 2002 The Continuum Problem John Stillwell University of San
More informationWeighted Abstract Dialectical Frameworks
Weighted Abstract Dialectical Frameworks Gerhard Brewka Computer Science Institute University of Leipzig brewka@informatik.uni-leipzig.de joint work with H. Strass, J. Wallner, S. Woltran G. Brewka (Leipzig)
More informationON A QUESTION OF SIERPIŃSKI
ON A QUESTION OF SIERPIŃSKI THEODORE A. SLAMAN Abstract. There is a set of reals U such that for every analytic set A there is a continuous function f which maps U bijectively to A. 1. Introduction A set
More informationChapter 18: On the Nature of Argumentation Semantics: Existence and Uniqueness, Expressibility, and Replaceability
1 Chapter 18: On the Nature of Argumentation Semantics: Existence and Uniqueness, Expressibility, and Replaceability Ringo Baumann abstract. This chapter is devoted to argumentation semantics which play
More informationDeterminacy of Infinitely Long Games
Determinacy of Infinitely Long Games Draft September 2018 Donald A. Martin The main subject of this book is games in which two players are given a set A of infinite sequences of natural numbers and take
More informationMeta-logic derivation rules
Meta-logic derivation rules Hans Halvorson February 19, 2013 Recall that the goal of this course is to learn how to prove things about (as opposed to by means of ) classical first-order logic. So, we will
More informationSUBSPACES OF COMPUTABLE VECTOR SPACES
SUBSPACES OF COMPUTABLE VECTOR SPACES RODNEY G. DOWNEY, DENIS R. HIRSCHFELDT, ASHER M. KACH, STEFFEN LEMPP, JOSEPH R. MILETI, AND ANTONIO MONTALBÁN Abstract. We show that the existence of a nontrivial
More informationCharacterization of Semantics for Argument Systems
Characterization of Semantics for Argument Systems Philippe Besnard and Sylvie Doutre IRIT Université Paul Sabatier 118, route de Narbonne 31062 Toulouse Cedex 4 France besnard, doutre}@irit.fr Abstract
More informationThe Vaught Conjecture Do uncountable models count?
The Vaught Conjecture Do uncountable models count? John T. Baldwin Department of Mathematics, Statistics and Computer Science University of Illinois at Chicago May 22, 2005 1 Is the Vaught Conjecture model
More informationComplexity-Sensitive Decision Procedures for Abstract Argumentation
Complexity-Sensitive Decision Procedures for Abstract Argumentation Wolfgang Dvořák a, Matti Järvisalo b, Johannes Peter Wallner c, Stefan Woltran c a University of Vienna, Faculty of Computer Science,
More informationRestricted versions of the Tukey-Teichmüller Theorem that are equivalent to the Boolean Prime Ideal Theorem
Restricted versions of the Tukey-Teichmüller Theorem that are equivalent to the Boolean Prime Ideal Theorem R.E. Hodel Dedicated to W.W. Comfort on the occasion of his seventieth birthday. Abstract We
More informationSets, Models and Proofs. I. Moerdijk and J. van Oosten Department of Mathematics Utrecht University
Sets, Models and Proofs I. Moerdijk and J. van Oosten Department of Mathematics Utrecht University 2000; revised, 2006 Contents 1 Sets 1 1.1 Cardinal Numbers........................ 2 1.1.1 The Continuum
More informationCantor and sets: La diagonale du fou
Judicaël Courant 2011-06-17 Lycée du Parc (moving to Lycée La Martinière-Monplaisir) Outline 1 Cantor s paradise 1.1 Introduction 1.2 Countable sets 1.3 R is not countable 1.4 Comparing sets 1.5 Cardinals
More informationLöwenheim-Skolem Theorems, Countable Approximations, and L ω. David W. Kueker (Lecture Notes, Fall 2007)
Löwenheim-Skolem Theorems, Countable Approximations, and L ω 0. Introduction David W. Kueker (Lecture Notes, Fall 2007) In its simplest form the Löwenheim-Skolem Theorem for L ω1 ω states that if σ L ω1
More informationNotes for Math 601, Fall based on Introduction to Mathematical Logic by Elliott Mendelson Fifth edition, 2010, Chapman & Hall
Notes for Math 601, Fall 2010 based on Introduction to Mathematical Logic by Elliott Mendelson Fifth edition, 2010, Chapman & Hall All first-order languages contain the variables: v 0, v 1, v 2,... the
More informationA BRIEF INTRODUCTION TO ZFC. Contents. 1. Motivation and Russel s Paradox
A BRIEF INTRODUCTION TO ZFC CHRISTOPHER WILSON Abstract. We present a basic axiomatic development of Zermelo-Fraenkel and Choice set theory, commonly abbreviated ZFC. This paper is aimed in particular
More informationOn Recognizable Languages of Infinite Pictures
On Recognizable Languages of Infinite Pictures Equipe de Logique Mathématique CNRS and Université Paris 7 JAF 28, Fontainebleau, Juin 2009 Pictures Pictures are two-dimensional words. Let Σ be a finite
More informationMath 144 Summer 2012 (UCR) Pro-Notes June 24, / 15
Before we start, I want to point out that these notes are not checked for typos. There are prbally many typeos in them and if you find any, please let me know as it s extremely difficult to find them all
More informationMathematics 220 Workshop Cardinality. Some harder problems on cardinality.
Some harder problems on cardinality. These are two series of problems with specific goals: the first goal is to prove that the cardinality of the set of irrational numbers is continuum, and the second
More informationON THE EXISTENCE OF PRIME IDEALS IN BOOLEAN ALGEBRAS
LOGIC, ALGBRA, AND COMPUTR SCINC BANACH CNTR PUBLICATIONS, VOLUM 46 INSTITUT OF MATHMATICS POLISH ACADMY OF SCINCS WARSZAWA 1999 ON TH XISTNC OF PRIM IDALS IN BOOLAN ALGBRAS JÖRG FLUM Mathematisches Institut,
More informationArgumentation among Agents
Argumentation among Agents Iyad Rahwan 1 Masdar Institute of Science & Technology, UAE 2 University of Edinburgh, UK 3 Massachusetts Institute of Technology, USA I. Rahwan. Argumentation among Agents.
More informationMath 4603: Advanced Calculus I, Summer 2016 University of Minnesota Notes on Cardinality of Sets
Math 4603: Advanced Calculus I, Summer 2016 University of Minnesota Notes on Cardinality of Sets Introduction In this short article, we will describe some basic notions on cardinality of sets. Given two
More informationInfinite Strings Generated by Insertions
Programming and Computer Software, Vol. 30, No. 2, 2004, pp. 110 114. Translated from Programmirovanie, Vol. 30, No. 2, 2004. Original Russian Text Copyright 2004 by Golubitsky, Falconer. Infinite Strings
More informationMAGIC Set theory. lecture 6
MAGIC Set theory lecture 6 David Asperó Delivered by Jonathan Kirby University of East Anglia 19 November 2014 Recall: We defined (V : 2 Ord) by recursion on Ord: V 0 = ; V +1 = P(V ) V = S {V : < } if
More informationVI I : The Axiom of Choice and related properties
VI I : The Axiom of Choice and related properties Near the end of Section V I.4 we listed several basic questions about transfinite cardinal numbers, and we shall restate them here for the sake of convenience:
More informationABOUT THE CLASS AND NOTES ON SET THEORY
ABOUT THE CLASS AND NOTES ON SET THEORY About the Class Evaluation. Final grade will be based 25%, 25%, 25%, 25%, on homework, midterm 1, midterm 2, final exam. Exam dates. Midterm 1: Oct 4. Midterm 2:
More informationA CONTINUOUS AND NOWHERE DIFFERENTIABLE FUNCTION, FOR MATH 320
A CONTINUOUS AND NOWHERE DIFFERENTIABLE FUNCTION, FOR MATH 320 This note is a demonstration of some of the details in Abbott s construction of a nowhere differentiable continuous function. The discovery
More information4 Choice axioms and Baire category theorem
Tel Aviv University, 2013 Measure and category 30 4 Choice axioms and Baire category theorem 4a Vitali set....................... 30 4b No choice....................... 31 4c Dependent choice..................
More informationSet Theory History. Martin Bunder. September 2015
Set Theory History Martin Bunder September 2015 What is a set? Possible Definition A set is a collection of elements having a common property Abstraction Axiom If a(x) is a property ( y)( x)(x y a(x))
More informationAn Iterated Forcing Extension In Which All Aleph-1 Dense Sets of Reals Are Isomorphic
San Jose State University SJSU ScholarWorks Master's Theses Master's Theses and Graduate Research Summer 2010 An Iterated Forcing Extension In Which All Aleph-1 Dense Sets of Reals Are Isomorphic Michael
More informationThe axiom of choice and two-point sets in the plane
A.Miller AC and 2-point sets The axiom of choice and two-point sets in the plane Abstract Arnold W. Miller In this paper we prove that it consistent to have a two-point set in a model of ZF in which the
More informationHandout: Proof of the completeness theorem
MATH 457 Introduction to Mathematical Logic Spring 2016 Dr. Jason Rute Handout: Proof of the completeness theorem Gödel s Compactness Theorem 1930. For a set Γ of wffs and a wff ϕ, we have the following.
More informationSection 7.1 Relations and Their Properties. Definition: A binary relation R from a set A to a set B is a subset R A B.
Section 7.1 Relations and Their Properties Definition: A binary relation R from a set A to a set B is a subset R A B. Note: there are no constraints on relations as there are on functions. We have a common
More informationThe uniform distributions puzzle
The uniform distributions puzzle by Luc LAUWERS Econometrics Center for Economic Studies Discussions Paper Series (DPS) 09.06 http://www.econ.kuleuven.be/ces/discussionpapers/default.htm March 2009 The
More informationEvents Concerning Knowledge
Events Concerning Knowledge Edward J. Green Department of Economics The Pennsylvania State University University Park, PA 16802, USA eug2@psu.edu DRAFT: 2010.04.05 Abstract Aumann s knowledge operator
More information