arxiv: v2 [hep-ph] 1 Nov 2016

Transcription

1 UCI R 06 4 Sarching for spin-/ lptons Mohammad Abdullah, Kvin Baur, Luis Gutirrz, John Sandy, and Danil Whitson Dpartmnt of Physics and Astronomy, Univrsity of California, Irvin, CA 9697 A modl of spin-/ vctor-lik lptons is introducd, which srv as an altrnativ prob of possibl lpton compositnss. Possibl signaturs at th Larg Hadron Collidr ar xplord, and currnt data ar usd to constrain th masss of th hypothtical nw lptons. PACS numbrs: arxiv: v [hp-ph] Nov 06 INRODUCION A major opn qustion in modrn particl physics is whthr th standard modl frmions ar fundamntal particls, or whthr thy ar composit, such as stabl stats of mor fundamntal particls [][][][4][5]. Such compositnss could b idntifid by th obsrvation of xcitd stats, which has bn studid in dpth [6]. Hr, w propos an altrnativ possibility, th xistnc of vctor-lik spin-/ copis of th standard modl frmions, in which th lft- and right-handd frmions hav idntical chargs. In this papr, w propos such a modl, discuss th potntial signals at th Larg Hadron Collidr (LHC) and apply xisting LHC data to calculat constraints on th mass of spin-/ lptons. HEORY W assum that th nw spin-/ lpton filds ar chargd idntically to th standard modl lptons but ar vctor-lik; spcifically, th right- and lft-handd filds coupl idntically, for othrwis th modl would b havily constraind by a combination of constraints from lctrowak prcision data and Higgs boson obsrvabls [7]. his still lavs two options: th lptons can b SU() doublts, which mans thy will coupl to all lctrowak bosons, or SU() singlts, which mans thy will only coupl to photons and Z bosons. h doublt modl will b th focus of this work du to its richr structur; w will supplmnt it with ffctiv oprators that allow for dcays. h Lagrangian for such a modl can b writtn as: L = L fr + L gaug + L vctor () h first two trms contain th mass and kintic trms and ar givn by L fr +L gaug = ɛµνρσ L µ γ 5 γ σ D ν L ρ+im L L µ γ µν L ν () whr D is th covariant drivativ, l can b ithr, µ, or τ and th dnots th spin-/ lptons. If w xpand th drivativ trm, th fr part of th Lagrangian will b L fr = ɛµνρσ (l + µ γ 5 γ σ ν l ρ + ν lµγ 5 γ σ ν νlρ) +im L l + µ γ µν l ν + im L ν lµγ µν ν lν () Not that th chargd and nutral componnts hav th sam mass (m L ) du to SU() gaug invarianc. Expanding th covariant drivativ w gt th intractions with th standard modl vctor bosons which, aftr lctrowak symmtry braking, look lik L gaug = ɛ µνρσ ( [i W W + ν ν lµγ 5 γ σ l ρ + Wν l + µ γ 5 γ σ νlρ ) + i( + s W ) Z ν l + µ γ 5 γ σ l ρ s W c W i + Z ν ν s W c lµγ 5 γ σ νlρ W + ia ν l + µ γ 5 γ σ l ρ ] (4) whr all couplings ar wll masurd lctrowak paramtrs givn approximatly by = 4πα 0. W s W 0. s W sinθ W 0.5 c W cosθ W 0.9 Nxt, w mov to th ffctiv oprators without which th nw filds would b stabl; not that th chargd and nutral componnts of th nw lptons hav idntical masss. Sinc th compositnss scal is highr than th lctrowak scal, it maks mor sns to writ down oprators that rspct th undrlying SU() symmtry of th thory which rducs th numbr of allowd trms and paramtrs. For concrtnss and simplicity w will assum only th following ffctiv oprators

2 COLLIDER PHENOMENOLOGY L vctor = i B µν ( L Λ µγ ν L + Lγ ν L µ) B + i W µνa ( L Λ µσ a γ ν L + Lσ a γ ν L µ) W i g BB µν ( L µγ ν L + Lγ ν L µ) + i g W W µνa ( L µσ a γ ν L + Lσ a γ ν L µ) (5) whr Λ B and Λ W ar scals gnratd by som UV physics to which w ar oblivious. Othr oprators that w could hav considrd ar 4-frmion oprators involving both nw and standard modl filds, in which cas th final stat lptons ar dirct dcay products of th spin-/ filds rathr than scondary particls making thm asir to dtct. Altrnativly w could hav chosn lctrowak symmtry braking oprators that lad to mass splitting btwn th nutral and chargd filds allowing on to dcay to th othr. W lav an xploration of such possibilitis for futur work. BOUNDS Sinc th nw filds ar vctor-lik and do not coupl to th Higgs at tr lvl, thir lctrowak charg causs no conflict with masurmnt of S,, U paramtrs [8][9] (or, ffctivly, th lctrowak bosons slf-nrgy). h ffctiv oprators ar, in principl, constraind by masurmnts of th anomalous magntic momnt of chargd lptons, spcially that of th muon []. Such constraints can asily b avoidd if th couplings g B and g W ar sufficintly small. Ensuring that ths couplings ar small also nsurs that th ffctiv oprators do not compt with th gaug intractions in th production of th nw frmions. On th othr hand, if th couplings ar too small th nw filds would corrspond to particls with long liftims and would b svrly constraind by long-livd chargd particl sarchs [][][]. h rang 9 GV < g B, g W < 4 GV satisfis ths rquirmnts and w will assum such valus for th rmaindr of th work. W mphasiz that th xact valus ar, for a givn ratio of g B and g W, unimportant sinc thy modify nithr th branching ratios nor th production rat. Collidr bounds on spin-/ vctor-lik lptons ar potntially applicabl. Howvr, du to diffrnt choics in ithr th production or dcay channls, non of th analyss in th litratur ar dirctly applicabl. Morovr, it is possibl that th diffrnc in kinmatics du to th highr spin ar significant nough to altr th limit, so it is worthwhil to study this particular cas in addition. h production of th nw filds is prdominantly through Drll-Yan pair production with lctrowak gaug bosons as mdiators, and th cross sctions ar fixd by standard modl couplings for a givn mass. As xplaind arlir, th couplings of th ffctiv oprators ar chosn to b small nough to contribut subdominantly to production vn at th highst mass considrd. W+ *+ FIG. : Production mods of th spin-/ lptons via standard modl lctrowak bosons. h pairs that can b producd ar l + l, ν l ν l, l + νl, and l ν l, with th last two bing th most common sinc W production at th LHC is th largr of th thr bosons. As for dcays, th ffctiv oprators opn up a varity of channls. h allowd dcays ar shown in th tabl blow. ABLE I: Allowd dcay mods for spin-/ lptons l and ν. l Zl γl W ν l W Zν l W γν l W + W l νl Zν l γν l W + l W + Zl W + γl W + W ν l By contrivd choics of g W and g B w can turn off on of th dcays in th first two columns. All th othr columns dpnd only on g W and can only b turnd off by stting it to zro, in which cas th dcays in th first two columns must ithr b all on or all off. On good fatur of this st of dcays is that thr will always b som visibl dcay products, vn if w produc a pair of spin-/ nutrinos. In this work will limit ourslvs to -body dcays including lctron and muons, which rsults in promising signals; w lav th photon channls for a futur work. W will plac th limits on th bnchmark points listd in abl II whr th forbiddn dcay channl is indicatd in ach cas. LIMIS FROM LHC DAA Assuming production via an intrmdiat lctrowak boson and th dcays givn in abl I, thr ar tn dis-

3 Bnchmark Point g W : g B Forbiddn Channls : Non c W : s W ν γν c W : -s W γ 4 s W : c W Zν 5 s W : -c W ν Zν 6 0 : All dcays including W s ABLE II: h ratios of g W and g B and th main dcay fatur of ach bnchmark point Fraction of vnts tinct production mods for th LHC: W l ν ZlZν, W νzν, W νw l, ZlW l Z l l ZlZl, W νw ν, ZlW ν 4 5 For l* = * and ν* = ν * l*, ν* mass = 00GV l*, ν* mass = 400GV l*, ν* mass = 600GV l*, ν* mass = 800GV l*, ν* mass = 00GV lptons H [GV] Z ν ν ZνZν, ZνW l, W lw ν which gnrat final stats including many chargd lptons, which offr low background rats at th LHC. W apply slctions from th sam-sign l [4] and l [5] sarchs at ALAS. W provid a brif summary blow of th signal rgions considrd. For th l sarch, th final stats ± ±, ± µ ± and µ ± µ ± ar considrd in catgoris dfind by th dilpton invariant mass. For th l sarch, vnts ar classifid using th thr highst-p slctd lptons, distinguishing btwn thos that do not contain an opposit-sign sam-flavour pair (dnotd no-ossf) and thos that do contain an OSSF pair, which ar furthr subdividd into on-z and off-z basd on th dilpton and thr highst-p slctd lptons invariant mass. For ach catgory, thr ar svral signal rgions usd to charactriz vnts basd on th quantitis: H lptons, th scalar sum of th transvrs momntum p of th thr lptons usd to catgoriz th vnt; p l,min, th minimum transvrs momntum p of th thr lptons usd to catgoriz th vnt; E miss, th missing transvrs momntum; m ff, th scalar sum of E miss, Hjts, and th p of all idntifid lptons in th vnt; and m W p = l Emiss ( cos( φ)), dfind only for on-z vnts. For th transvrs mass, p l corrsponds to th transvrs momntum of th highst-p lpton not associatd to a Z boson candidat and φ is th azimuthal angl btwn th highst-p lpton not associatd to a Z boson candidat and th missing transvrs momntum E miss. Simulatd sampls of spin-/ lptons wr gnratd with madgraph5 [6][7] and th dcays wr prformd through pythia [8] for a varity of l and ν masss undr two scnarios. First, w considr th simpl cas in which l = and ν = ν ; scond, w xtnd to th Fraction of vnts 4 5 For l* = *, µ* and ν* = ν *, ν µ * l*, ν* mass = 00GV l*, ν* mass = 400GV l*, ν* mass = 600GV l*, ν* mass = 800GV l*, ν* mass = 00GV lptons H [GV] FIG. : Distribution of H lptons for simulatd spin-/ lpton sampls; th slction rquird H lptons > 500 GV. h top pan shows th cas whr only lctrons ar considrd; th bottom pan shows th cas whr lctrons and muons ar considrd. scond gnration and allow l =, µ, ν = ν, ν µ. For both, w st m = m v = m µ = m v µ. W gnratd sampls of production cross sctions and dcay widths for a rang of masss and combind thm according to ach of th six coupling bnchmarks dscribd in abl II. From among th signal rgions in th two ALAS sarchs dscribd abov, w choos th SR which givs th most powrful xpctd limits: H lptons > 500 GV for OSSF off-z. Distributions of H lptons in simulatd sampls aftr all slction rquirmnts ar mad ar shown in Fig.. Slction fficincy is shown in Fig.. Obsrvd and xpctd limits ar drivd according to th prscription providd in Rf. [5] shown in Fig. 4

4 4 otal fficincy ar ruld out at th 95% confidnc lvl for masss up to about 560 GV for on nw fild with lctron flavor, and up to about 60 GV for two nw, mass dgnrat filds, on with lctron flavor and on with muon flavor. W xpct to gt mor stringnt limits if w includ th photon channl. For l* = * and ν* = ν * All dcay channls opn ν* γ ν dcay forbiddn l* γ l dcay forbiddn l* Z l dcay forbiddn ν* Z ν dcay forbiddn Dcays to Ws forbiddn ACKNOWLEDGEMENS h authors ar gratful to im ait, Bartosz Fornal, and Jordan Smolinsky for hlpful discussion and commnts. MA is particularly thankful to im ait for his guidanc in constructing th modl. his work is supportd in part by U.S. National Scinc Foundation Grant No. PHY 679. otal fficincy For l* = *, µ* and ν* = ν *, ν µ All dcay channls opn ν* γ ν dcay forbiddn l* γ l dcay forbiddn l* Z l dcay forbiddn ν* Z ν dcay forbiddn Dcays to Ws forbiddn * FIG. : Ovrall fficincy of th slction dfind in Rf. [5] which rquirs H lptons > 500 GV for OSSF off-z, as a function of th spin-/ lpton mass. h top pan shows th cas whr only lctrons ar considrd; th bottom pan shows th cas whr lctrons and muons ar considrd. and Fig. 5. CONCLUSIONS W invstigatd th snsitivity of xisting LHC data to a modl of spin-/ lptons. Such filds ar possibl within th contxt of frmion compositnss which is wll studid in th litratur. W focusd on a scnario whr th nw filds ar dominantly producd by Drll- Yan procsss through lctrowak bosons and promptly dcay through ffctiv oprators to lctrowak bosons and standard modl lptons of th sam flavor as th nw filds. W lookd at final stats rsulting in sam-sign l or l and found comparabl limits for ach. h nw filds [] E. Eichtn, K. D. Lan, and M. E. Pskin, Phys. Rv. Ltt. 50, 8 (98), [,69(98)]. [] R. Contino,. Kramr, M. Son, and R. Sundrum, JHEP 05, 074 (007), hp-ph/0680. [] B. Lilli, J. Shu, and. M. P. ait, JHEP 04, 087 (008), [4] R. S. Chivukula and H. Gorgi, Phys. Ltt. B88, 99 (987). [5] M. A. Shup, Phys. Ltt. B86, 87 (979). [6] D. A. Dicus, D. Karabacak, S. Nandi, and S. K. Rai, Phys. Rv. D87, 050 (0), [7] A. Lnz, Adv. High Enrgy Phys. 0, 975 (0). [8] S. Schal t al. (SLD Elctrowak Group, DELPHI, ALEPH, SLD, SLD Havy Flavour Group, OPAL, LEP Elctrowak Working Group, L), Phys. Rpt. 47, 57 (006), hp-x/ [9] M. E. Pskin and. akuchi, Phys. Rv. Ltt. 65, 964 (990). [] J. Bringr, J. F. Arguin, R. M. Barntt, K. Copic, O. Dahl, D. E. Groom, C. J. Lin, J. Lys, H. Murayama, C. G. Wohl, t al. (Particl Data Group), Phys. Rv. D 86, 000 (0), URL /PhysRvD [] S. Chatrchyan t al. (CMS), JHEP 07, (0), [] G. Aad t al. (ALAS), JHEP 0, 068 (05), [] G. Aad t al. (ALAS), Eur. Phys. J. C75, 407 (05), [4] G. Aad t al. (ALAS), JHEP 0, 04 (05), [5] G. Aad t al. (ALAS), JHEP 08, 8 (05), 4.9. [6] J. Alwall, R. Frdrix, S. Frixion, V. Hirschi, F. Maltoni, O. Mattlar, H. S. Shao,. Stlzr, P. orrilli, and M. Zaro, JHEP 07, 079 (04), [7] N. D. Christnsn, P. d Aquino, N. Dutschmann, C. Duhr, B. Fuks, C. Garcia-Cly, O. Mattlar, K. Mawatari, B. Oxl, and Y. akasu, Eur. Phys. J. C7, 580 (0), [8]. Sjostrand, S. Mrnna, and P. Z. Skands, JHEP 05, 06 (006), hp-ph/06075.

5 5 For l* = * and ν* = ν *, all dcay channls opn: For l* = * and ν* = ν *, ν* γ ν dcay forbiddn: For l* = * and ν* = ν *, l* γ l dcay forbiddn: For l* = * and ν* = ν *, l* Z l dcay forbiddn: For l* = * and ν* = ν *, ν* Z ν dcay forbiddn: For l* = * and ν* = ν *, dcays to Ws forbiddn: FIG. 4: Obsrvd and xpctd limits as a function of l and ν mass, in th cas of l =, ν = ν

6 6 For l* = *, µ* and ν* = ν *, ν µ * ; all dcay channls opn : For l* = *, µ* and ν* = ν *, ν µ * ; ν* γ ν dcay forbiddn: For l* = *, µ* and ν* = ν *, ν µ * ; l* γ l dcay forbiddn: For l* = *, µ* and ν* = ν *, ν µ * ; l* Z l dcay forbiddn: For l* = *, µ* and ν* = ν *, ν µ * ; ν* Z ν dcay forbiddn: For l* = *, µ* and ν* = ν *, ν µ * ; dcays to Ws forbiddn: FIG. 5: Obsrvd and xpctd limits as a function of l and ν mass, in th cas of l =, µ, ν = ν, ν µ