arxiv: v2 [q-fin.cp] 23 Mar 2018

Transcription

1 Modlling stock corrlations with xpctd rturns from invstors Ming-Yuan Yang a, Sai-Ping Li b, Li-Xin Zhong c, Fi Rn a,d,, a School of Businss, East China Univrsity of Scinc and Tchnology, Shanghai , China b Institut of Physics, Acadmia Sinica, Taipi 5 Taiwan c School of Financ, Zhiang Univrsity of Financ and Economics, Hangzhou 3008, China d School of Scinc, East China Univrsity of Scinc and Tchnology, Shanghai , China Rsarch Cntr for Econophysics, East China Univrsity of Scinc and Tchnology, Shanghai , China arxiv: v2 [q-fin.cp] 23 Mar 208 Abstract Undrstanding stock corrlations is crucial to asst pricing, invstor dcision-making, and financial risk rgulations. Howvr, a microscopic xplanation basd on agnt-basd modling is still lacking. W hr propos a modl drivd from minority gam for modling stock corrlations, in which an agnt s xpctd rturn for on stock is influncd by th historical rturn of th othr stock. Each agnt maks a dcision basd on his xpctd rturn with rfrnc to information dissmination and th historical rturn of th stock. W find that th rturns of th stocks ar positivly (ngativly) corrlatd whn agnts xpctd rturns for on stock ar positivly (ngativly) corrlatd with th historical rturn of th othr. W provid both numrical simulations and analytical studis and giv xplanations to stock corrlations for cass with agnts having ithr homognous or htrognous xpctd rturns. Th rsult still holds whn othr factors such as holding dcisions and xtrnal vnts ar includd which broadns th practicability of th modl. Kywords: Minority gam; Stock corrlation; Corrlation modling; Agnt-basd modling. Introduction Stock corrlations ar high during financial criss, i.., th stock prics mov up or down togthr. This is a phnomnon in stock markts worldwid, which has drawn th attntion of many scholars (Ast t al., 200; Didir t al., 202; Sharma and Banr, 205; Kim t al., 205; Liu and Ts, 202). Undrstanding this phnomnon is vry important for invstors and rgulators. Pindyck and Rotmbrg (993) first found that stock rturn corrlations among US firms ar too high to b ustifid by fundamntals only, whil company siz and dgr of institutional ownrship could also influnc stock corrlations. Latr on, scholars hav xplaind stock corrlations from th macroscopic prspctiv, i.., th markt and industry lvl. Som studis focus on th corrlation of stocks in markts (Morck t al., 2000; Didir t al., 202; Dang t al., 205; Li and Png, 207). Morck t al. (2000) and Dang t al. (205) found that stock corrlations tndd to b highr in poor and mrging markts with poor institutions and proprty rights. Didir t al. (202) found that stock pric comovmnts wr drivn largly by financial linkags btwn markts. Li and Png (207) notd that conomic policy uncrtainty wr abl to affct th comvomnts of both Chins and US stocks. Som studis focus on th Corrsponding author. Addrss: 30 Milong Road, P.O. Box 4, School of Businss, East China Univrsity of Scinc and Tchnology, Shanghai , China, Phon: addrss: frn@cust.du.cn (Fi Rn ) corrlation of stocks in industris (Kallbrg and Pasquarillo, 2008; Antón and Polk, 204; Huang t al., 206; Png t al., 207). Kallbrg and Pasquarillo (2008), Antón and Polk (204) showd that firms in th sam industry had corrlatd arnings and thrfor rturns. Huang t al. (206) showd that th information dissmination through firms in th sam industry would caus a stock pric co-movmnt. Png t al. (207) adducd a strong vidnc of siz ffct on stock pric synchronicity in Chins oil firms. Othr studis hav xplaind stock corrlations from th prspctiv of firms. Svral studis hav shown that a firm s spcific information is th primary caus of stock corrlations (Hamd t al., 205; Liu t al., 205). Othrs hav xplaind stock corrlations with complx ntwork mthods (Qiao t al., 206; Zhang t al., 205; Li t al., 202). Qiao t al. (206) hav found that stock ntwork linkags could xplain stock corrlations. Zhang t al. (205) simulatd information dissmination on a firm ntwork, and prdictd th stock pric comovmnts with th ECM (Enrgy Cascading Modl). Li t al. (202) hav found that th prics of stocks movd togthr along with th sharholdr link ntwork and th dirctor ntwork. All ths studis suggst that th mor closly firms ar linkd in th ntwork, th highr corrlations thy hav. Rcntly, scholars hav also studid stock corrlations from th prspctiv of invstors actions (Li t al., 20; Eun t al., 205; Li and Zhao, 206; Frins t al., 207; Filzn and Schutt, 207; Vldkamp, 2006; Mondria, 200). Som mpirical studis show that invstors sntimnt and irrational actions will caus stock corrlations (Li t al., 20; Eun t al., 205; Li and Zhao, 206; Frins t al., 207). Prprint submittd to Elsvir March 26, 208

2 Li t al. (20) found that invstors irrational actions could caus stock pric co-movmnts by studying th Chins A- shar markts. Eun t al. (205) found that cultur influncs could caus stock pric synchronicity by affcting invstors trading activitis and a country s information nvironmnt. Li and Zhao (206) found that invstors prfrrd to trad th stocks of firms which stayd in thir own city, and this bhavior could caus stock pric co-movmnts. Frins t al. (207) found that stock rturn comvmnnts wr drivn by th non-fundamntal part of rturn, which was mainly th invstor sntimnt. Othr studis focus on information dissmination through invstors (Filzn and Schutt, 207; Mondria, 200; Vldkamp, 2006). Filzn and Schutt (207) found that stock pric would co-mov whn invstors could acquir low cost information about othr firms by mpirical analysis. Mondria (200) provd that asst prics would co-mov whn agnts could simultanously gt th pric information of th both assts to forcast asst prics through analytical analysis. Vldkamp (2006) proposd a thortical modl to dmonstrat that whn rational agnts could gt information of stocks simultanously, stock prics would co-mov with no corrlation btwn stock fundamntals. To dat, only fw studis ar dvotd to xplain th microcosmic rason of stock corrlations from th prspctiv of agnts actions, most of which ar basd on thortical analysis. Our study is motivatd by rsarch on stock corrlations with agnt-basd modls and rval its microcosmic mchanism by modling th trading bhavior of individual agnts. Minority gam is a highly succssful agnt-basd modl that can b usd to xplain most stylizd facts in financial markts (Challt t al., 200b). Th standard minority gam was first proposd by Challt and Zhang (997) basd on th El Farol bar problm (Arthur, 994). It dscribs a systm in which htrognous agnts adaptivly compt for scarc rsourc, and it capturs som ky faturs of a gnric markt mchanism and th basic intractions btwn agnts and public information. As a succssful agnt-basd modl to simulat th stock markt, minority gam has bn undr rapid dvlopmnt and largly usd in mmory siz (Johnson t al., 999), volution mchanism (Challt t al., 200a), stratgy slction (D Hulst and Rodgrs, 999; Zhong t al., 2005), stock markt simulations (Yung t al., 2008), markt impact (Barato t al., 203) and agnt bhavior (Zhang t al., 206). On of th most important applications of th minority gam is its modling for multi-assts. Bianconi t al. (2008) first studid th minority gam in which agnts might invst two assts to invstigat spculativ trading ffcts in stock markts. D Martino t al. (2007) introducd a multi-assts minority gam to solv th stratgy frquncy problm. Inspird by thir works, w hr introduc a nw modl basd on minority gam in which agnts may trad two stocks, and focus on its xplanation to stock corrlations. This xtnsion maks th modl closr to th ral stock markts, and can b widly applid to asst pricing, invstor dcision-making and financial risk rgulations. W propos that an agnt s xpctd rturn on on stock is influncd by its own historical rturn and th historical rturn of th othr stock. This xpctd rturn is modld 2 with rfrnc to studis on th thory of information dissmination and th facts that xist in ral stock markts. Som studis on information dissmination thory imply that stock pric movmnts ar influncd by th sprad of information among invstors (Bordino t al., 202; Hibrgr, 205). In addition, Zhang t al. (205) and Chuang (206) found that th stock pric co-movmnt is du to th dissmination of information btwn firms, and Chn t al. (205) proposd that for th firms shard common information in th sam industry thir stocks had th sam pric movmnt. Marct (207) also proposd that whn information dissmination through analysts, thr would b pric co-movmnt across Latin Amrican stocks. Ths studis dmonstratd that information from diffrnt firms could b obtaind and sprad by invstors, and th sprad of information could lad to th changs of stock prics which in turn could affct th pric movmnts of othr stocks. In a ral stock markt, w can s that invstors trad stocks by rfrring to th prformanc of othr stocks in th sam industry. Somtims thy vn rfr to th prformanc of othr stocks in th comptitiv industry, and trad according to th opposit sign of th pric changs of rlvant stocks. Ths invstors bhaviors will ultimatly hav an impact on th stock corrlations. Th information dissmination thory proposd in litratur and th abov phnomna xist in ral stock markts provid th thortical and ralistic basis for th stablishmnt of th xpctd rturn in our modl. W also propos that an agnt maks a dcision basd on his or hr xpctd rturn and historical rturns of th stock in th minority gam. Th simulation rsults of our modl suggst that th stock rturns ar positivly (ngativly) corrlatd whn th xpctd rturns ar positivly (ngativly) corrlatd, and th corrlation of stock rturns is proportional to th corrlation of th xpctd rturns of th stock. Compard to prvious studis, this papr maks two contributions. First, w propos a nw modl basd on th MG modl to xplain th corrlations btwn stocks from th prspctiv of agnt-basd modling. Scond, w thortically dmonstrat that invstors xpctation of on stock influncd by anothr stock ssntially lads to th corrlation btwn th two by both numrical simulation and analytical analysis. Th rmaindr of this papr is organizd as follows. W prsnt our modl and basic assumptions in sction 2. Th rsults and analysis of th simulation ar givn in sction 3. Finally, w conclud in sction Modl and assumptions To study th corrlation btwn individual stocks, w assum th simpl cas whn thr ar only two stocks tradd by agnts. Our modl taks th form of a rpatd gam with an odd numbr N of agnts who must choos an indpndnt dcision of buying or slling actions according to thir stratgis. A stratgy is a way of dcision-making in which an invstor maks a dcision according to th information availabl, including th historic rturns in last m tim stps and th xpctd rturn for a spcific stock. Sinc thr ar 2 m possibl bit strings of historical rturns, two possibl options (up or down) for ach

3 Tabl : A stratgy of agnt i for stock. Hr r (t m) ( =, 2) dnots th historical rturn of th stock ( =, 2) at tim t m, and r,i (t) ( =, 2) dnots th xpctd rturn of agnt i for stock ( =, 2) at tim t. + ( ) mans th rturn is positiv (ngativ). σ i (t) ( =, 2) dnots th dcision that agnt i (i=,..., N) maks for stock ( =, 2) according to th history and xpctation. ( ) mans buying (slling) unit of stock. History Expctation Dcision r (t m)... r (t ) r,i (t) σi (t) agnt s xpctation, and two dcisions of buying or slling actions, thr ar a total of 2 2m+ stratgis. Tabl illustrats an agnt s stratgy for th transaction of stock in our modl. As sn from Tabl, th history of a stock is th stock rturn sris in th last m stps, which can b accssd by all agnts. Expctation in th tabl is an agnt s xpctd rturn, which is dtrmind by th agnt himslf/hrslf. Th agnt mploys a spcific stratgy to dtrmin th trading dcision according to th currnt history and th xpctd rturn. Th dcision is dnotd by and - rspctivly in th tabl, rprsnting buying or slling unit of stock. Sinc th agnts do not hav cash in our simplifid modl, which maks it difficult to calculat th trading capacity of ach agnt, w assum that ach agnt has a trading capacity of on shar of ach stock in ach transaction. W also considr th cas whn th agnt can tak a holding position, making a dcision not buying or slling, which is a common practic to study incntivs of th agnts to participat in th markt (Yung t al., 2008; Challt t al., 200a; Giardina and Bouchaud, 2003). As on will s in th rsults, th holding dcision dos not chang th main rsults of our modl. Th xpctd rturn is dfind as follows. Th xpctd rturn of agnt i for stock is r,i (t)=a r (t )+b,i r 2 (t ), () and th xpctd rturn of agnt i for stock 2 is r 2,i (t)=a 2r 2 (t )+,i r (t ), (2) whr r,i (t) ( =, 2) is th xpctd rturn of agnt i for stock ( =, 2) at tim t, and r (t ) ( =, 2) is th rturn of stock ( =, 2) at tim t. a ( =, 2) is th firstordr autocorrlation cofficint of th stock and b,i ( =, 2) dnots th impact of th first-ordr lag rturn of th othr stock on stock for agnt i. W propos th xpctd rturn with rfrnc to othr studis on th information dissmination thory. Zhang t al. (205) and Chuang (206) both dmonstratd that th dissmination of information btwn firms causd stock pric co-movmnt by constructing th ntwork of diffrnt firms. Chn t al. (205) proposd that stocks in th sam industry shard common charactristics, which rsultd in th synchronous prics riss and 3 falls. Sinc stock pric rturn is on kind of th most important information that diffuss in stock markts and studid by scholars, w hr introduc th stock pric rturn. Mondria (200) found that changs in on asst affctd both asst prics and might lad to asst pric co-movmnt whn invstors could choos linar combinations of asst payoffs to updat information about th assts. Basd on ths studis, w propos that th xpctd rturn of agnts to b in th form of a linar combination of stock rturns in our modl. W can also s that invstors trad stocks by considring th prformanc of othr stocks in ral stock markts, and this provids ralistic basis for th assumption of th abov xpctation. Th undrlying rason for th invstors bhaviors that focus on th prformancs of multi assts may li in th fundamntal corrlations btwn ths stocks, which hav businss rlationships btwn ach othr. For xampl, invstors will rfr to th prformanc of othr stocks in th sam industry whn thy trad stocks. In particular, invstors would tnd to pay attntion on th prformanc of th lading stock, spcially whn th lading stock has ust xprincd a boom or crash. Somtims thy vn rfr to th prformanc of stocks not in th sam industry but in th sam industry chain. Ths bhaviors will ultimatly affct invstors xpctations. To bgin with, ach agnt i randomly picks S stratgis from th full stratgy spac, sticks with thm throughout th gam, and kps track of th cumulativ prformanc of his or hr trading stratgy s (s=,..., S ) by assigning a scor U i,s (t) ( =, 2; t=0,,..., T) to ach of thm. Th initial scors of th stratgis ar st to b zro. Initially, agnt i randomly slcts a stratgy s i among his/hr S own stratgis, and th trading dcision is also randomly slctd sinc thr ar no historical rturns and xpctd rturn at t=0. At tim stp t>0, ach agnt i adopts a stratgy s i with th highst scor. If U i,s i (t) is th highst at tim t, th dcision of agnt i to trad stock is σ i (t)=σi,s i (t) corrsponding to th currnt historical rturns and th xpctd rturn of stock. Aftr all agnts hav mad thir dcisions of actions, th xcss dmand of stock at tim t is calculatd as A (t)= N i= σ i (t). (3) A (t) masurs th imbalanc btwn buyrs (dmand) and sllrs (supply), which rprsnts th forc of driving th pric up and down rspctivly, and is commonly usd to updat th pric of th stock (Yung t al., 2008; Challt t al., 200a, 2000). Th pric of stock at tim t is updatd according to P (t)=p (t )+ sgn[a (t)] A (t) 0.5, (4) whr th squar root in th formula is commonly usd in th pric dynamics of th MG modl (Yung t al., 2008; Challt t al., 2000), which is also supportd by th vidnc of mpirical studis (Zhang, 999). Th rturn of stock at tim t is r (t)=log(p (t)) log(p (t )). (5)

4 Th scor of stratgy s (s=,..., S ) holding by th agnt i is thn updatd as blow U i,s (t)=u i,s (t )+g i,s (t), (6) whr th payoffs g i,s (t) to stratgy s is g i,s (t)= sgn[a (t)]σ i,s (t). (7) Th payoff is calculatd with th xcss dmand, which is in lin with th pric updat. Suppos th xcss dmand is positiv (ngativ) and th dcision of th stratgy is to sll (buy), th agnt slls (buys) a unit of stock with a transaction pric at t, highr (lowr) than th currnt pric at t. Thrfor, th stratgis which hlp th agnts buy stocks at chapr prics and sll stocks at highr pric ar rwardd, and vic vrsa. Th rul that th agnts in th minority group would win is th so-calld minority gam modl. Th agnt thn rpatdly chooss th bst stratgy from his/hr fixd S stratgis according to thir updatd scors, and maks th dcision of buying or slling action according to th nwly updatd historical rturns and xpctd rturn. Th xpctd rturn of agnt i for stock is updatd according to Eqs.() and (2). Th stock pric and scor of th stratgy ar subsquntly updatd following Eqs.(4) and (6). Th modl volvs by rpating th stps listd abov. 3. Simulation rsults and analysis For simplicity and th computational fficincy of th modl, w choos th cas whr N = 00, m and S ar rlativly small.g., m= and S= 2. W also prform a simulation for m=2and S= 2, and th simulation rsult is similar to that for m= and S = 2. Th simulation rsult bcoms stabl whn T 000. Thrfor, w choos T to b 000. Th initial pric of our modl is st to b 2000, larg nough to nsur that th pric is positiv throughout th ntir volution priod, and th rsults ar robust to diffrnt initial prics. W also nd to dtrmin th valus of a ( =, 2) and b,i ( =, 2; i=,..., N). W know that a is th first-ordr autocorrlation cofficint of th stock, and b,i is th impact that th first-priod lag rturn of th othr stock on stock for agnt i. Thus, w st th valus of a ( =, 2) basd on th first-ordr autorgrssiv cofficint of th stocks in th ral markt. W study 5 A-shar stocks trad on th Shanghai and Shnzhn Stock Exchangs from January 4, 20 to Dcmbr 3, 205. Th data sourc is from Biing Gildata RESSET Data Tchnology Co., Ltd, s Th calculation rsults ar shown in Tabl 2. As sn in Tabl 2, whn th tim window incrass to fiv yars, th first-ordr autorgrssiv cofficints of all stocks ar gratr than 0. Thrfor, w tak th valu of a ( =, 2) to b btwn 0 and in th modl. Indd, w hav vrifid that th first-ordr autorgrssiv cofficints of th simulatd data undr th rstriction a (0, ] ar consistnt with thos of th mpirical data. W considr nin combinations of diffrnt valus of a, namly a ={0., 0.5, } and a 2 ={0., 0.5, } in 4 Tabl 2: First-ordr autorgrssiv cofficints of 5 A-shar stocks trad on Shanghai and Shnzhn Stock Exchangs from January 4, 20 to Dcmbr 3, 205. Stock Cod our simulation. Givn th valus of a, w now st th valus of b,i ( =, 2; i=,..., N). W will st th valus of b,i in two cass: all agnts with th sam xpctation and agnts with diffrnt xpctations. Whn all agnts hav th sam xpctd rturn, w hav b,i = b (i=,..., N). W hr assum that th valus of b,i ( =, 2) ar btwn - and, and th intrval is 0.. Th cass in which b,i ( =, 2) ar gratr than and lss than - will b prsntd in subsction 3.2. Aftr dciding th valu for ach paramtr, on could now obtain th rturn sris of stock ( =, 2). To discuss th corrlation btwn two stocks, w calculat th Parson s corrlation cofficint. Th Parson s corrlation cofficint btwn two stock rturn sris r (t) and r 2 (t) is dfind as ρ r = Cov(r, r 2 ) Var(r ) Var(r 2 ), (8) whr Cov(r, r 2 ) is th covarianc of th two stock rturn sris, and Var(r ) and Var(r 2 ) ar th variancs of th two stock rturn sris rspctivly. W prform 50 runs and tak th man corrlation cofficint as th final simulation rsult. 3.. Simulation rsults and analysis for all agnts with th sam xpctation 3... Simulation rsults Whn all agnts hav th sam xpctd rturn, w hav b,i = b ( =, 2; i =,..., N). W hr assum that th valus of b ( =, 2) ar btwn - and, and th intrval is 0.. Th simulation rsults for a = a 2 and a a 2 ar shown in Figs. and 2 rspctivly. From th simulation rsult in Fig. (a), w can s that th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns ar positiv (ngativ) whn b > 0 and > 0 (b < 0 and < 0), and th absolut valus of th corrlation cofficints ar larg whn b and ar nar or -. W also s that th simulation rsult for m= and S = 2 in Fig. (b) is not much diffrnt from th rsult for m=2 and S = 2 in Fig. (a). Hnc, w only

5 Figur : Th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns for: (a) m = 2, S= 2 and a = a 2 =, (b) m=, S= 2 and a = a 2 =, (c) m=, S= 2 and a = a 2 = 0.5, (d) m=, S= 2 and a = a 2 = 0.. analyz th rsults for m= and S= 2 in th following. In Fig. (c), th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns ar positiv (ngativ) whn b > 0 and > 0 (b < 0 and < 0), and th absolut valus of th corrlation cofficints ar larg whn b and ar nar 0.5 or In Fig. (d), th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns ar small in most cass, and th absolut valus of th corrlation cofficints ar larg whn b and ar nar 0. or -0.. From th simulation rsults in Fig. 2, for xampl, for a = and a 2 = 0. in Fig. 2(c), it can b sn that th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns ar positiv (ngativ) whn b > 0 (b < 0), and th absolut valu of th corrlation cofficints ar small whn is nar 0. Whn b > 0 (b < 0), th xpctd rturn of stock 2 is almost only affctd by stock and th xpctd rturn of stock is affctd by both stocks, hnc th corrlation cofficints btwn two stock rturns ar positiv (ngativ). In addition, th xpctd rturn of stock 2 is almost unaffctd by ithr stocks whn is nar 0, hnc th corrlation cofficint btwn th stock rturns is vry small. Morovr, th rsults in Figs. 2() and 2(f) ar similar to th rsults in Figs. 2(c) and 2(d) rspctivly, whil th rsults in Figs. 2(a) and 2(b) ar similar to rsults in Figs. (b) and (c) rspctivly. Thrfor, w will tak th simulation rsults in Fig. (b) as a rprsntativ to analyz. W hav also chckd th rsults for th cas that th agnt can tak a holding position, i.., th agnts mak trading dcisionsσ i (t)=,, or 0, which rprsnt buying or slling a unit of stock, or doing nothing. Hr, w show th simulation rsults for m=, S = 2 and a = a 2 = in Fig. 3. In comparison with th rsults for th modl without holding position shown in Fig. (b), th corrlation of th prsnt modl bcoms rlativly wakr, but th basic bhavior rmains th sam. Th introduction of th holding position dos not chang th main rsults, hnc this fatur will not b includd in our 5 Figur 2: Th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns with paramtrs m= and S= 2 for: (a) a = and a 2 = 0.5, (b) a = 0.5 and a 2 =, (c) a = and a 2 = 0., (d) a = 0. and a 2 =, () a = 0.5 and a 2 = 0., (f) a = 0. and a 2 = 0.5. modl. It is worth to study how much invstors xpctations of stock rturns account for th stock rturn corrlation whn othr factors ar includd in thir trading dcisions. For instanc th xognous factor introducd in Papadopoulos and Cooln (2008), which considrs a cas whn th markt is impactd by xtrnal vnts that may rprsnt th actions of markt rgulators, or othr maor natural or political vnts. W considr th impacts of th xtrnal vnts on th stock rturns, upon which th invstors mak dcisions to buy or sll, thrfor study thir influncs on invstors trading dcisions. In doing so, th intrnal and xtrnal contributions to th ovrall xcss dmand ar introducd as A (t)=a int (t)+ A xt (t), (9) whr A int (t) is th xcss dmand dfind in Eq. (3), and A xt (t) rprsnts th contribution of xtrnal vnts, which has a gnral formula A xt (t)=( ) θ(t) Ã E (t). (0) To mak A xt (t) mor ralistic, w us th mpirical data of th nws of A-shar stocks trad on Shanghai Stock Exchang during th priod form Dcmbr 6, 203 to Novmbr 22, 206 to calculat th avrag probability of th occurrnc of an xtrnal vnt pr minut, and us it to dtrmin th probability p(e (t)=)= Th basic rsults rmain to b th sam if p(e (t)=) is not too larg.θ(t) is a randomly gnratd in-

6 Figur 3: Th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns for th cas that th agnt can tak a holing position with paramtrs m=, S = 2 and a = a 2 =. Figur 4: Th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns for th cas that xtrnal vnts ar includd into invstors trading dcisions with paramtrs m=, S= 2 and a = a 2 = for: (a) k=, (b) k=2, (c) k=3, (d) k=4. tgr, which dtrmins th sign of th impact, positiv or ngativ whnθ(t) is vn or odd. A rflcts th impact strngth of th xtrnal vnt, which is masurd in units of th standard dviation s of A int (t), i.., Ã = ks. With th nw ovrall xcss dmand dfind abov, th pric is thrfor updatd according to Eq. (4), and th rturn is consquntly gnratd according to Eq. (5). Th rsults of th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns for th cas whn xtrnal vnts ar includd in invstors trading dcisions for k =, 2, 3, 4 ar shown in Fig. 4. As th impact strngth of xtrnal vnts incrass, th corrlation btwn th stocks bcoms rlativly smallr. Howvr, th main rsults ar ssntially similar to th ons shown in Fig. (b). Th rturns of th stocks ar still corrlatd undr th intrfrnc of xognous factor lik xtrnal vnts, and this shows that th stock rturn corrlations ar largly dtrmind by th mchanism of th xpctd rturns proposd in our modl Analysis of rsults From th simulation rsults, rgularitis in th corrlation cofficint btwn th stock rturns can b sn. Howvr, what causs th rgularitis, and why th corrlation cofficint is vry clos to 0 in som cass, whil in othr cass it is gratr than zro and lss than zro? To xplain ths phnomna, it is ncssary to analyz th sourc of th stock corrlation. From th assumptions of th modl, w know that th corrlation btwn th stock rturns is mainly dtrmind by th agnt s xpctd rturns of th stocks. Sinc th xpctd rturn of th agnt on on stock taks into account th influnc of th othr stock, th corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns is bound to affct th corrlation btwn th stock rturns. To vrify our argumnt, w should analyz th rlationship btwn th stock 6 Figur 5: Scattr plot of th rturn vrsus its xpctd rturn for (a) stock and (b) stock 2 with paramtrs m=, S= 2 and a = a 2 =. Colors corrspond to th rturns of diffrnt runs. rturn and its xpctd rturn. First, w draw th scattr plots of both stocks. W choos th simulation rsults whn m=, S= 2 and a = a 2 = for th scattr plots, which is shown in Fig. 5. It can b sn that th xpctd rturns and rturns of th stocks clustr in thr rgions in th scattr plots. This is mainly du to th fact that th mmory siz m is small. In a minority gam, on will display a multi-pak distribution for th rturn whn th mmory siz is small. It can also b sn that thr is a linar rlationship btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn. W thrfor propos a linar rgrssion modl btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn as follows r (t)=β 0 +β r (t)+ǫ, () whr r ( =, 2) and r ( =, 2) rprsnt th rturn and th xpctd rturn of stock rspctivly. Th rgrssion analysis of th stocks ar don sparatly and th rsults ar givn in Tabl 3. As shown in Tabl 3, thr is a significant positiv corrlation btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn. Although r-

7 Tabl 3: Rgrssion rsults of th stocks for a = a 2 =. Stock Stock 2 β p-valu R 2 β p-valu R For th cas whn r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)<0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b b r 2 (t )< r (t )< r 2(t ). (6) grssion rsults suggst that thr is a significant corrlation btwn th two, ust how th corrlation btwn th two stock xpctd rturns affcts th corrlation btwn th two stock rturns cannot b undrstood from th rgrssion modl. W thrfor study th corrlation btwn th two stock xpctd rturns in ordr to xplain th corrlation btwn two stock rturns. From Figs. and 2, w know that th corrlation btwn th stock rturns is mainly dtrmind by th valus of b ( =, 2). W thrfor concntrat on how th valus of b affct th corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns of th stocks, and thus th corrlation btwn th stock rturns. W hr put forth som concpts for th following discussion. r (t )=r (t ) r (t 2), ( =, 2) is th chang of stock s rturn dfind by th first-ordr diffrnc at tim t. r (t) ( =, 2) is th chang of th xpctd rturn of stock dfind by th firstordr diffrnc at tim t. From Eqs. () and (2), th changs of th stock xpctd rturns at tim t ar: (t)=a r (t )+ b r 2 (t ) r2 (t)=a (2) 2 r 2 (t )+ r (t ). Whn a = a 2 =, w hav (t)= r (t )+b r 2 (t ) r 2 (t)= r 2(t )+ r (t ). (3) Four sparat cass I-IV will b considrd for diffrnt valus of b ( =, 2) whn a = a 2 =. I. 0<b < and 0< < (a) If r (t )>0and r 2 (t )>0, thn (t)= r (t )+b r 2 (t )>0 r2 (t)= r (4) 2(t )+ r (t )>0. Hr, th xpctd rturns of both stocks incras at th sam tim, and th corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns is positiv. (b) If r (t )<0 and r 2 (t )<0, th analysis is similar to I (a). Hr, th xpctd rturns of both stocks dcras at th sam tim, and th corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns is positiv. (c) If r (t ) > 0 and r 2 (t ) < 0, w discuss th possibilitis for four cass of combinations of r (t) and r 2 (t). According to Eq. (3), th condition satisfying r (t)<0 and r2 (t)>0 is r 2(t ) < r (t )< b r 2 (t ). (5) Sinc r 2 (t )/ > b r 2 (t ) whn r 2 (t )<0, Eq. (5) cannot b satisfid, thrfor th cas whn r (t)<0and r2 (t)>0 is impossibl. 7 Th valu rang of r (t ) bcoms smallr whn b and approachs, and th probability of satisfying this condition bcoms smallr. Thrfor, th ngativ corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms wakr. W nxt discuss th othr two cass that th xpctd rturns ar positivly corrlatd. If r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b r (t )> r 2(t ). (7) Whn approachs, th lowr limit valu of r (t ) approachs r 2 (t ). Thrfor, th valu rang of r (t ) bcoms largr, and th probability of satisfying r (t)>0 and r2 (t)>0 also bcoms largr. Th probability that th xpctd rturns of both stocks incras simultanously is largr, i.., th positiv corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr. Similarly, if r (t)<0 and r 2 (t)<0 ar satisfid, th positiv corrlation of th xpctd rturns is strongr whn b approachs. Among th four cass abov, thr of thm ar valid, which includ two cass whn th xpctd rturns ar positivly corrlatd with larg probability. Thrfor th corrlation ar positiv on avrag, and th positiv corrlation bcoms strongr whn b ( =, 2) approachs. (d) If r (t )<0 and r 2 (t )>0, th analysis is similar to I (c), s Appndix A I (d) for dtails. Hr, th positiv corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr whn b ( =, 2) approachs. From I (a)-i (d), w s that th xpctd rturns of th stocks ar positivly corrlatd, and th xpctd rturn corrlation is strongr whn b ( =, 2) is closr to. II. <b < 0 and < < 0 Th analysis is similar to I, s Appndix A II for dtails. Hr, th xpctd rturns of th stocks ar ngativly corrlatd, and th xpctd rturn corrlation is strongr whn b ( =, 2) is closr to -. III. 0<b < and < < 0 (a) If r (t )>0 and r 2 (t )>0, r (t) is always positiv. Thr ar two possibl cass for r2 (t), namly r 2 (t)>0 and r2 (t)<0. If r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b r 2 (t )> r (t ). (8) Whn approachs -, th lowr limit valu of r 2 (t ) approachs r (t ). Thrfor, th valu rang of r 2 (t ) bcoms smallr, and th probability of satisfying r (t)>0 and r2 (t)>0 bcoms smallr. Th probability that th xpctd rturns of both stocks incras simultanously bcoms smallr, i.., th positiv corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms wakr.

8 Similarly, if r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)<0 ar satisfid, th ngativ corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr whn approachs -. (b) If r (t ) < 0 and r 2 (t ) < 0, th analysis is similar to III (a), s Appndix A III (b) for dtails. Hr, th positiv (ngativ) corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms wakr (strongr) whn approachs -. (c) If r (t )>0 and r 2 (t )<0, r2 (t) is always ngativ. Thr ar two cass for r (t), namly r (t)<0 and r (t)>0. If r (t)<0 and r 2 (t)<0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b r 2 (t )< r (t ) b. (9) Whn b approachs, th uppr limit valu of r 2 (t ) approachs r (t ). Thrfor, th valu rang of r 2 (t ) bcoms largr, and th probability of satisfying r (t)<0 and r2 (t)<0 bcoms largr. Th probability that th xpctd rturns of both stocks dcras simultanously bcoms largr, i..,th positiv corrlation btwn th stock xpctd rturns bcoms strongr. Similarly, if r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)<0 ar satisfid, th ngativ corrlation btwn th stock xpctd rturns is wakr whn b approachs. (d) If r (t )<0 and r 2 (t )>0, th analysis is similar to III (c), s Appndix A III (d) for dtails. Hr, th ngativ (positiv) corrlation btwn th stock xpctd rturns bcoms wakr (strongr) whn b approachs. From III (a)-iii (d), w obsrv that th positiv corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns is strongr whn b is closr to. W also obsrv that th ngativ corrlation btwn th stock xpctd rturns is strongr whn is closr to -. IV. <b < 0 and 0< < Th analysis is similar to III, s Appndix A IV for dtails. Th positiv corrlation btwn th stock xpctd rturns is strongr whn is closr to. W also obsrv that th ngativ corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns is strongr whn b is closr to -. From Fig. 5 and Tabl 3, w can s that thr is a significant positiv corrlation btwn th rturns and xpctd rturns. W summariz th rsults of simulatd rturns basd on th corrlation of xpctd rturns in th following.. Th corrlation btwn th stock rturns is positiv whn 0 < b < and 0 < <, and gts strongr as b ( =, 2) incrass. 2. Th corrlation btwn th stock rturns is ngativ whn <b < 0 and < < 0, and th corrlation is strongr whn b ( =, 2) dcrass. 3. Th corrlation btwn th stock rturns is wak whn 0<b < and < < 0, and it changs from ngativ to positiv as b ( =, 2) incrass. 4. Th corrlation btwn th stock rturns is wak whn <b < 0 and 0< <, and it changs from ngativ to positiv as b ( =, 2) incrass. 8 W can also obsrv th corrlation btwn th stock rturns from Fig. (b). Th rsults in Fig. (b) and th analytic rsults in th abov thus agr with ach othr Simulation rsults and analysis for agnts with diffrnt xpctations In a ral stock markt, agnts ar htrognous and thir xpctd rturns ar not xactly th sam. Indd, w can considr th htrognous agnts that hav diffrnt valus for both a and b,i ( =, 2; i=,..., N), according to th dfinition of xpctd rturn in Eqs. () and (2). Howvr, th paramtr b,i can rflct th information dissmination through stocks, which plays a cor rol in xplaining th corrlation btwn stocks. Bsids, w hav also studid th cas with a uniform distribution of a U(0, ), and found that th rsults rmain similarly. Hnc, w mainly focus on th paramtr b,i and show th simulation rsults for its diffrnt valus in th following discussion. W will mak an additional assumption that ach agnt i in th modl matchs a uniqu b,i ( =, 2), which is subct to a uniform distribution, i.., b,i U(c δ, c +δ ). Th cntr of th distribution is c, and th distribution rang is 2δ. It is worth to not that th rsults do not dpnd on th spcific formula of th distribution, but only th symmtry fatur of th distribution significantly affct th rsults. As on will s in th following discussions on th distributions with varying cntrs and rangs, th corrlation btwn th stocks is positiv or ngativ whn th distribution cntr is bias to positiv or ngativ, which may b drivn by th forcs of nws or big vnts in ral stock markts. For th distribution which is symmtric about 0, things cancl out ach othr and th stocks thrfor bcom uncorrlatd Simulation rsults for th distribution with varying distribution cntr and fixd distribution rang Th simulation rsult for a = a 2 = andδ = δ 2 = is shown in Fig. 6. Cntrs c and c 2 ar from - to, and th intrvals ar 0.2. Th rsult in Fig. 6 suggsts that th corrlation cofficint is proportional to c and c Analysis of rsults for th distribution with varying distribution cntr and fixd distribution rang Similar to th analysis in subsubsction 3..2, w first analyz th rlationship btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn. W draw th scattr plots of th rturns vrsus xpctd rturns of th stocks for four cass of c and c 2 in Fig. 7, namly, I. 0<c < and 0<c 2 <, II. <c < 0 and <c 2 < 0, III. 0 < c < and < c 2 < 0, IV. < c < 0 and 0<c 2 <. A linar rlationship btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn can b obsrvd in Fig. 7. W thrfor prform a rgrssion analysis for th stocks using Eq. (), and th rsults ar prsntd in Tabl 4. On can s from Tabl 4 that thr is a significant positiv corrlation btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn whn b and ar uniformly distributd. Using th linar rlationship btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn, on can obtain th corrlation btwn th rturns

9 Figur 6: Th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns whn m =, S= 2, a = a 2 = andδ =δ 2 =. Figur 7: Scattr plots of th rturn vrsus its xpctd rturn for stock with diffrnt valus of c and c 2 : (a) 0<c < and 0<c 2 <, (b) <c < 0 and <c 2 < 0, (c) 0<c < and <c 2 < 0, (d) <c < 0 and 0<c 2 <. Scattr plots of th rturns vrsus xpctd rturns for stock 2 with diffrnt valus of c and c 2 : (a) 0<c < and 0<c 2 <, (b) <c < 0 and <c 2 < 0, (c) 0<c < and <c 2 < 0, (d) <c < 0 and 0<c 2 <. Colors corrspond to th rturns of diffrnt runs, with paramtrs m=, S= 2 and a = a 2 =. Tabl 4: Rgrssion rsults of two stocks for a = a 2 = andδ =δ 2 =. Stock Stock 2 c c 2 β p-valu R 2 β p-valu R 2 0<c < 0<c 2 < <c < <c 2 < <c < 0 <c 2 < <c < 0 0<c 2 < from th corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns. From Eq. (2), th variations of th xpctd rturns of stock ( =, 2) for agnt i (i=,..., N) at tim t ar,i (t)=a r (t )+ b,i r 2 (t ) r2,i (t)=a (20) 2 r 2 (t )+,i r (t ). Th avrag variations of th xpctd rturns for stock and stock 2 ar r (t)= N N N a r (t )+ N b,i r 2 (t ) i= i= r2 (t)= N N (2) N a 2 r 2 (t )+ N,i r (t ), i= whr b,i and,i ar th valus of b and for agnt i rspctivly. Sinc b and ar subct to th uniform distribution, w hav N N b,i = c, i= N i= N,i = c 2. (22) From Eqs. (2) and (22), w s that th avrag variations of th xpctd rturns for th stocks whn a = a 2 = ar i= (t)= r (t )+ c r 2 (t ) r 2 (t)= r 2(t )+ c 2 r (t ). (23) W now study th corrlation of th xpctd rturns from Eq. (23) for diffrnt valus of c and c 2. Eq. (23) hr taks th 9 sam form as Eq. (3), with c rplacing b, and c 2 rplacing. Similar to th analysis for fixd valus of b and, four sparat cass will b considrd hr. I. 0<c < and 0<c 2 < Th positiv corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns is strongr whn c and c 2 ar clos to, and is wakr whn c and c 2 ar clos to 0. II. <c < 0 and <c 2 < 0 Th ngativ corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns is strongr whn c and c 2 ar clos to -, and is wakr whn c and c 2 ar clos to 0. III. 0<c < and <c 2 < 0 Th positiv corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr whn c approachs and c 2 approachs 0. Th ngativ corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr whn c approachs 0 and c 2 approachs -. IV. <c < 0 and 0<c 2 < Th positiv corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr whn c approachs 0 and c 2 approachs. Th ngativ corrlation btwn th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr whn c approachs - and c 2 approachs 0. From Fig. 7 and Tabl 4, w s that thr is a significant positiv corrlation btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn. Thrfor, w can obtain th corrlation btwn th rturns from th analytic rsults of I-IV, which is summarizd blow.. Th corrlation of th rturns is positiv whn 0<c < and 0<c 2 <, and bcoms strongr as c ( =, 2) incrass. 2. Th corrlation of th rturns is ngativ whn <c < 0, and <c 2 < 0, and bcoms strongr as c ( =, 2) dcrass. 3. Th corrlation of th rturns is wak whn 0<c < and <c 2 < 0, and changs from ngativ to positiv as c ( =, 2) incrass.

10 4. Th corrlation of th rturns is wak whn <c < 0 and 0<c 2 <, and changs from ngativ to positiv as c ( =, 2) incrass. W can also obsrv th corrlation btwn th stock rturns from Fig. 6, which agrs with th analysis in this subsction Simulation rsults for th distribution with fixd distribution cntr and varying distribution rang Th simulation rsults for a = a 2 = and c = c 2 = 0 ar shown in Fig. 8. Th rangs ofδ andδ 2 ar from to 5, and th intrvals ar 0.5. From Fig. 8, w can s that th corrlation cofficints ar small, and th corrlation btwn th stock rturns is wak. Tabl 5: Rgrssion rsults of stocks and 2 for a = a 2 = and c = c 2 = 0. Stock Stock 2 β p-valu R 2 β p-valu R in th figur. W thrfor carry out a rgrssion analysis of th stocks sparatly with Eq. (), and th rsults ar givn in Tabl 5. From th rgrssion rsults whn b and ar uniformly distributd, th rgrssion of both stocks passd th significanc tst. Thr is a significant corrlation btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn, and th corrlation is positiv. From Eq. (2), w gt (t)=a r (t )+ c r 2 (t ) r 2 (t)=a 2 r 2 (t )+ c 2 r (t ). (24) Whn a = a 2 = and c = c 2 = 0, w hav (t)= r (t ) r 2 (t)= r 2(t ). (25) Figur 8: Th corrlation cofficints btwn th stock rturns for m =, S= 2, a = a 2 = and c = c 2 = 0. In this cas, w can asily s that th man valu of th xpctd rturn is only rlvant to th stock rturn itslf. Hnc, th xpctd rturns of th stocks ar uncorrlatd. From Fig. 9 and Tabl 5, w s that th rturn and its xpctd rturn ar strongly corrlatd, implying that stock rturns ar not corrlatd. This is confirmd by th simulation rsults in Fig. 8. From th simulation rsults and th analysis of th modl, w find that stock corrlations ar proportional to th valus of b and, whthr thy ar fixd or subct to uniform distributions. W also find that th xpctd rturns of agnts hav a dirct impact on th stock corrlations. 4. Conclusion Figur 9: Scattr plot of th rturn vrsus its xpctd rturn for (a) stock and (b) stock 2 with paramtrs m=, S= 2 and a = a 2 =. Colors corrspond to th rturns of diffrnt runs Analysis of rsults for th distribution with fixd distribution cntr and varying distribution rang Scattr plots of th rturns vrsus xpctd rturns of th stocks whn c = c 2 = 0 ar shown in Fig. 9. A linar rlationship btwn th rturn and its xpctd rturn can b obsrvd In this papr, w study stock corrlations by using a modl basd on minority gam, in which w propos that an agnt s xpctd rturn of on stock is influncd by th historical rturn of th othr stock, and an agnt maks a dcision with his or hr xpctd rturn and th historical rturn of th stock. W modl th stock corrlation for all agnts with th sam xpctation, and find that th invstor s xpctation rgarding stock rturn is an important factor for th stock corrlation. W also find that stock rturns ar positivly (ngativly) corrlatd whn th xpctation of rturns ar positivly (ngativly) corrlatd, and th corrlation of stock rturns is proportional to th corrlation of stock xpctd rturns. W thn modl th stock corrlation for agnts with diffrnt xpctations, and th simulation rsults ar similar to th rsults whn all agnts hav th sam xpctation. Th simulation rsults also suggst that th cntr of th distribution has a significant influnc on th stock corrlation but th rang of th distribution has no influnc on th stock corrlation. Ths rsults rmain to b tru 0

11 whn w considr othr factors such as xtrnal vnts in financial markts. W hav thrfor dmonstratd th undrlying mchanism that invstors xpctation rturn of on stock is influncd by anothr stock would lad to a corrlation btwn two stocks in our modl. Two stocks hav strong (wak) corrlations whn invstors bliv that th stocks hav strong (wak) impacts on ach othr. To th bst of our knowldg, this is th first tim that on modls th corrlations btwn stocks from th prspctiv of agnt-basd modling. Our modl is drivd from th standard MG modl, in which th agnts ar allowd to trad multi-assts simultanously. Th xpctd rturns of th agnts ar modld with rfrnc to information dissmination in financial markts. To improv th practicability of th modl, w furthr introduc variabls that modl xtrnal nws and vnts in financial markts and fix thir valus from th analysis of ral data. Ths faturs mak our modl simulat ral stock markts mor closly, and hlp to xpand its practical implications in many issus daling with multi-assts or systmatic problms. Th modl not only can rval th microscopic mchanism undrlying th stock corrlations, but also can b applid to asst pricing, invstor dcision-making and financial risk rgulations. 5. Acknowldgmnts This work was partially supportd by th National Natural Scinc Foundation (Nos , and 73765), th Humanitis and Social Scincs Fund sponsord by Ministry of Education of th Popl s Rpublic of China (No. 7YJAZH067), th Collgial Laboratory Proct of Zhiang Provinc (No. YB20628), and th Fundamntal Rsarch Funds for th Cntral Univrsitis (205). W would also lik to thank th anonymous rviwrs for thir valuabl commnts and suggstions which hlp to improv th prsnt work. Appndix A In this appndix, w provid mor dtaild dscriptions of th analysis prsntd in subsction I. 0<b < and 0< < (d) If r (t ) < 0 and r 2 (t ) > 0, w discuss th possibilitis for four cass of combinations of r (t) and r 2 (t). According to Eq. (3), th condition satisfying r (t)>0 and r2 (t)<0 is b r 2 (t )< r (t )< r 2(t ). (26) Sinc r 2 (t )/ < b r 2 (t ) whn r 2 (t )>0, Eq. (26) cannot b satisfid, thrfor this cas is impossibl. For th cas whn r (t)<0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b r 2(t ) < r (t )< b r 2 (t ). (27) Undr this condition, th xpctd rturns ar ngativly corrlatd with a smallr probability as b ( =, 2) is closr to. W nxt discuss th othr two cass whn th xpctd rturns ar positivly corrlatd. If r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b r (t )> b r 2 (t ). (28) Whn b approachs, th lowr limit valu of r (t ) approachs r 2 (t ). Thrfor, th valu rang of r (t ) bcoms largr, and th probability of satisfying r (t)>0 and r2 (t)>0 also bcoms largr. Th probability that th xpctd rturns of both stocks incras simultanously is largr, i.., th positiv corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr. Similarly, if r (t) < 0 and r 2 (t) < 0 ar satisfid, th positiv corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr whn approachs. For two of th thr valid cass, th xpctd rturns ar positivly corrlatd with larg probability. Thrfor, th corrlation ar positiv on avrag, and th positiv corrlation bcoms strongr whn b ( =, 2) approachs. II. <b < 0 and < < 0 (a) If r (t ) > 0 and r 2 (t ) > 0, w discuss th possibilitis for four cass of combinations of r (t) and r 2 (t). According to Eq. (3), th condition satisfying r (t)<0 and r2 (t)<0is r 2(t ) < r (t )< b r 2 (t ). (29) Sinc r 2 (t )/ > b r 2 (t ) whn r 2 (t )>0, Eq. (29) cannot b satisfid, thrfor this cas is impossibl. For th cas whn r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b b r 2 (t )< r (t )< r 2(t ). (30) Undr this condition, th xpctd rturns ar positivly corrlatd, and its probability bcoms smallr whn b ( =, 2) is closr to -. W nxt discuss th othr two cass whn th xpctd rturns ar ngativly corrlatd. If r (t)>0and r 2 (t)<0ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b r (t )> r 2(t ). (3) Whn approachs -, th lowr limit valu of r (t ) approachs r 2 (t ). Thrfor, th valu rang of r (t ) bcoms largr, and th probability of satisfying r (t)>0 and r2 (t)<0 is largr. Th ngativ corrlation of th xpctd rturns is strongr. Similarly, if r (t) < 0 and r 2 (t) > 0 ar satisfid, th ngativ corrlation of th xpctd rturns is strongr whn b approachs -. For two of th thr valid cass, th xpctd rturns ar ngativly corrlatd with larg probability. Th corrlation ar ngativ on avrag, and th ngativ corrlation bcoms strongr whn b ( =, 2) approachs -.

12 (b) If r (t ) < 0 and r 2 (t ) < 0, th analysis is similar to Appndix A II (a). Hr, th ngativ corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr whn b ( =, 2) approachs -. (c) If r (t )>0and r 2 (t )<0, thn (t)= r (t )+b r 2 (t )>0 r2 (t)= r (32) 2(t )+ r (t )<0. Hr, th xpctd rturn of stock incrass whil th xpctd rturn of stock 2 dcrass, and th xpctd rturn of th stocks mov in opposit dirctions. Thrfor th corrlation of th xpctd rturns is ngativ. (d) If r (t ) < 0 and r 2 (t ) > 0, th analysis is similar to Appndix A II (c). Hr, th xpctd rturn of stock dcrass whil th xpctd rturn of stock 2 incrass, and th xpctd rturn of th stocks mov in opposit dirctions. Hnc th corrlation of th xpctd rturns is ngativ. III. 0<b < and < < 0 (b) If r (t )<0 and r 2 (t )<0, r (t) is always ngativ. Thr ar two possibl cass for r2 (t), namly r 2 (t)<0 and r2 (t)>0. If r (t)<0 and r 2 (t)<0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b r 2 (t )< r (t ). (33) Whn approachs -, th uppr limit valu of r 2 (t ) approachs r (t ). Thrfor, th valu rang of r 2 (t ) bcoms smallr, th probability of satisfying r (t)<0 and r2 (t) < 0 bcoms smallr. Th probability that th xpctd rturns of both stocks dcras simultanously bcoms smallr, i.., th positiv corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms wakr. Similarly, if r (t)<0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, th ngativ corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr whn approachs -. (d) If r (t )<0 and r 2 (t )>0, r2 (t) is always positiv. Thr ar two possibl cass for r (t), namly r (t)<0 and r (t)>0. If r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b If r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b r (t )> b r 2 (t ). (35) Whn b approachs -, th lowr limit valu of r (t ) approachs r 2 (t ). Thrfor, th valu rang of r (t ) bcoms smallr, th probability of satisfying r (t)>0 and r2 (t) > 0 bcoms smallr. Th probability that th xpctd rturns of both stocks incras simultanously bcoms smallr, i.., th positiv corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms wakr. Similarly, if r (t)<0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, th ngativ corrlation of th xpctd rturns is strongr whn b approachs -. (b) If r (t )<0 and r 2 (t )<0, th analysis hr is similar to Appndix A IV (a). Hr, th positiv (ngativ) corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms wakr (strongr) whn b approachs -. (c) If r (t )>0 and r 2 (t )<0, r (t) is always positiv. Thr ar two possibl cass for r2 (t), namly r 2 (t)>0 and r2 (t)<0. If r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, according to Eq. (3), th condition will b r (t )> r 2(t ). (36) Whn approachs, th lowr limit valu of r (t ) approachs r 2 (t ). Thrfor, th valu rang of r (t ) bcoms largr, th probability of satisfying r (t) > 0 and r2 (t)>0 is largr. Th positiv corrlation of th xpctd rturns is strongr. Similarly, if r (t)>0 and r 2 (t)<0 ar satisfid, th ngativ corrlation of th xpctd rturns is wakr whn approachs. (d) If r (t )<0 and r 2 (t )>0, th analysis is similar to Appndix A IV (c). Hr, th positiv (ngativ) corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr (wakr) whn approachs. r 2 (t )> r (t ). (34) b Whn b approachs, th uppr limit valu of r 2 (t ) approachs r (t ). Thrfor, th valu rang of r 2 (t ) bcoms largr, th probability of satisfying r (t) > 0 and r2 (t)>0 bcoms largr. Th probability that th xpctd rturns of both stocks incras simultanously bcoms largr, i.., th positiv corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms strongr. Similarly, if r (t)<0 and r 2 (t)>0 ar satisfid, th ngativ corrlation of th xpctd rturns bcoms wakr whn b approachs. IV. <b < 0 and 0< < (a) If r (t )>0 and r 2 (t )>0, r2 (t) is always positiv. Thr ar two possibl cass for r (t), namly r (t)>0 and r (t)<0. 2 Rfrncs Antón, M., Polk, C., 204. Connctd stocks. J. Financ 69, Arthur, W. B., 994. Inductiv rasoning and boundd rationality. Amr. Econ. Rv. 84, Ast, T., Shaw, W., Di Matto, T., 200. Corrlation structur and dynamics in volatil markts. Nw J. Phys. 2, Barato, A. C., Mastomatto, I., Bardoscia, M., Marsili, M., 203. Impact of mta-ordr in th Minority Gam. Quant. Financ 3, Bianconi, G., D Martino, A., Frrira, F. F., Marsili, M., Multi-asst minority gams. Quant. Financ 8, Bordino, I., Battiston, S., Caldarlli, G., Cristlli, M., Ukkonn, A., Wbr, I., 202. Wb sarch quris can prdict stock markt volums. PloS On 7, Challt, D., Marsili, M., Zhang, Y.-C., Modling markt mchanism with minority gam. Physica A 276, Challt, D., Marsili, M., Zhang, Y.-C., 200a. From minority gams to ral markts. Quant. Financ, Challt, D., Marsili, M., Zhang, Y.-C., 200b. Stylizd facts of financial markts and markt crashs in minority gams. Physica A 294,