Curvature singularity

Similar documents
The Concept of the Effective Mass Tensor in GR. Clocks and Rods

Lecture 23: Central Force Motion

Conformal transformations + Schwarzschild

4. Kruskal Coordinates and Penrose Diagrams.

Homework 7 Solutions

Physics: Work & Energy Beyond Earth Guided Inquiry

MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY Physics Department. Problem Set 10 Solutions. r s

Escape Velocity. GMm ] B

Physics 161: Black Holes: Lecture 5: 22 Jan 2013

d 2 x 0a d d =0. Relative to an arbitrary (accelerating frame) specified by x a = x a (x 0b ), the latter becomes: d 2 x a d 2 + a dx b dx c

GENERAL RELATIVITY: THE GEODESICS OF THE SCHWARZSCHILD METRIC

This gives rise to the separable equation dr/r = 2 cot θ dθ which may be integrated to yield r(θ) = R sin 2 θ (3)

Physics 181. Assignment 4

Geometry of the homogeneous and isotropic spaces

From Gravitational Collapse to Black Holes

The Schwarzschild Solution

Orbiting a naked singularity in large-g Brans-Dicke gravity. Bertrand Chauvineau UCA, OCA/Lagrange

Practice Integration Math 120 Calculus I Fall 2015

General Relativity Homework 5

Relativity and Astrophysics Lecture 38 Terry Herter. Rain fall source to distance observer Distance source to rain fall frame

But for simplicity, we ll define significant as the time it takes a star to lose all memory of its original trajectory, i.e.,

Rotational Motion. Lecture 6. Chapter 4. Physics I. Course website:

Practice Integration Math 120 Calculus I D Joyce, Fall 2013

Tidal forces. m r. m 1 m 2. x r 2. r 1

Chapter 5: Uniform Circular Motion

Phys 201A. Homework 5 Solutions

ENGI 4430 Non-Cartesian Coordinates Page xi Fy j Fzk from Cartesian coordinates z to another orthonormal coordinate system u, v, ˆ i ˆ ˆi

Qualifying Examination Electricity and Magnetism Solutions January 12, 2006

Hawking Radiation. Alex Fontana

Question Bank. Section A. is skew-hermitian matrix. is diagonalizable. (, ) , Evaluate (, ) 12 about = 1 and = Find, if

MATH 417 Homework 3 Instructor: D. Cabrera Due June 30. sin θ v x = v r cos θ v θ r. (b) Then use the Cauchy-Riemann equations in polar coordinates

30 The Electric Field Due to a Continuous Distribution of Charge on a Line

A New Approach to General Relativity

CHAPTER 5: Circular Motion; Gravitation

16.1 Permanent magnets

Newton s Laws, Kepler s Laws, and Planetary Orbits

= 4 3 π( m) 3 (5480 kg m 3 ) = kg.

OSCILLATIONS AND GRAVITATION

Physics 506 Winter 2006 Homework Assignment #9 Solutions

EFFECTS OF FRINGING FIELDS ON SINGLE PARTICLE DYNAMICS. M. Bassetti and C. Biscari INFN-LNF, CP 13, Frascati (RM), Italy

Circular-Rotational Motion Mock Exam. Instructions: (92 points) Answer the following questions. SHOW ALL OF YOUR WORK.

[ ] = jω µ [ + jω ε E r

rt () is constant. We know how to find the length of the radius vector by r( t) r( t) r( t)

Section 11. Timescales Radiation transport in stars

(a) Calculate the apparent weight of the student in the first part of the journey while accelerating downwards at 2.35 m s 2.

Circular Motion & Torque Test Review. The period is the amount of time it takes for an object to travel around a circular path once.

Magnetic Field. Conference 6. Physics 102 General Physics II

8-3 Magnetic Materials

Physics 312 Introduction to Astrophysics Lecture 7

The Schwartzchild Geometry

ME 210 Applied Mathematics for Mechanical Engineers

Electromagnetic Theory 1

ATMO 551a Fall 08. Diffusion

Force of gravity and its potential function

ESCI 342 Atmospheric Dynamics I Lesson 3 Fundamental Forces II

Chap 5. Circular Motion: Gravitation

Chapter 13 Gravitation

Homework # 3 Solution Key

A thermodynamic degree of freedom solution to the galaxy cluster problem of MOND. Abstract

Black Holes. Tom Charnock

Orbital Angular Momentum Eigenfunctions

Geodesic motion in Kerr spacetime

ECE 3318 Applied Electricity and Magnetism. Spring Prof. David R. Jackson ECE Dept. Notes 13

Physics 161 Fall 2011 Extra Credit 2 Investigating Black Holes - Solutions The Following is Worth 50 Points!!!

F(r) = r f (r) 4.8. Central forces The most interesting problems in classical mechanics are about central forces.

Section 26 The Laws of Rotational Motion

An Exact Solution of Navier Stokes Equation

10. Universal Gravitation

AST2000 Lecture Notes

Physics NYB problem set 5 solution

Recap. Centripetal acceleration: v r. a = m/s 2 (towards center of curvature)

A car of mass m, traveling at constant speed, rides over the top of a circularly shaped hill as shown.

Mechanics Physics 151

Lab #9: The Kinematics & Dynamics of. Circular Motion & Rotational Motion

Quantum Mechanics II

The study of the motion of a body along a general curve. the unit vector normal to the curve. Clearly, these unit vectors change with time, u ˆ

Chapter 12. Kinetics of Particles: Newton s Second Law

Physics 235 Chapter 5. Chapter 5 Gravitation

EM Boundary Value Problems

FARADAY'S LAW. dates : No. of lectures allocated. Actual No. of lectures 3 9/5/09-14 /5/09

Is there a magnification paradox in gravitational lensing?

Nuclear and Particle Physics - Lecture 20 The shell model

Scattering in Three Dimensions

Graphs of Sine and Cosine Functions

Today in Astronomy 142: the Milky Way s disk

Problem 1. Part b. Part a. Wayne Witzke ProblemSet #1 PHY 361. Calculate x, the expected value of x, defined by

Chapter 13: Gravitation

The tunneling spectrum of Einsein Born-Infeld Black Hole. W. Ren2

DYNAMICS OF UNIFORM CIRCULAR MOTION

Introduction to General Relativity 2

Section 8.2 Polar Coordinates

B. Spherical Wave Propagation

Earth and Moon orbital anomalies

3. Electromagnetic Waves II

University Physics Volume I Unit 1: Mechanics Chapter 13: Gravitation Conceptual Questions

Chapter 2: Basic Physics and Math Supplements

Problems with Mannheim s conformal gravity program

< 1. max x B(0,1) f. ν ds(y) Use Poisson s formula for the ball to prove. (r x ) x y n ds(y) (x B0 (0, r)). 1 nα(n)r n 1

Experiment 09: Angular momentum

SPH4U Unit 6.3 Gravitational Potential Energy Page 1 of 9

Transcription:

Cuvatue singulaity We wish to show that thee is a cuvatue singulaity at 0 of the Schwazschild solution. We cannot use eithe of the invaiantsr o R ab R ab since both the Ricci tenso and the Ricci scala vanish. The next siplest invaiant is R abcd R abcd The cuvatues ae given by whee R 1 010 1 2 ν,11e ν λ 1 4 ν,1ν,1 e ν λ 1 4 ν,1λ,1 e ν λ R 1 212 1 2 λ,1e λ R 1 313 2 λ,1e λ sin 2 θ R 2 020 1 2 ν,1e ν λ R 2 323 1 e λ sin 2 θ R 3 030 1 2 ν,1e ν λ Theefoe, e ν e λ ν,1 1 λ,1 R010 1 1 2 ν,11 ν,1 ν,1 e ν λ 1 4 2 4 3 1 4 3 1 4 2 4 R 1 212 R 1 313 sin2 θ R 2 020 3 R 2 323 sin2 θ R 3 030 3 Check R 1 010 1 2 ν,11e ν λ 1 4 ν,1ν,1 e ν λ 1 4 ν,1λ,1 e ν λ 1 2 ν,11 ν,1 ν,1 e ν λ 1

Loweing the uppe index, 1 4 2 4 3 1 4 2 4 1 2 4 3 1 R 1010 3 R 1212 R 1313 1 sin 2 θ R 2020 1 R 2323 sin 2 θ R 3030 sin 2 θ and aising all fou indices, R 1010 3 R 1212 5 1 R 1313 5 sin 2 1 θ R 2020 5 R 2323 7 sin 2 θ R 3030 5 sin 2 θ To copute the invaiant, we will have sus including all eaangeents of the indices of the nonvanishing tes, fo exaple, R 1212 R 1212 R 2112 R 2112 R 1221 R 1221 R 2121 R 2121 So each te ust be counted fou ties. Theefoe R abcd R abcd 4 3 3 4 1 5 4 1 sin 2 θ 5 sin 2 θ 2

4 1 5 8 sin 2 θ 7 sin 2 θ 4 1 sin 2 θ 5 sin 2 θ so siplifying, R abcd R abcd 162 6 162 6 42 6 42 6 which diveges stongly at 0, but is egula at. Regulaity at 42 6 162 6 42 6 It tuns out that the Schwazschild etic has only a coodinate singulaity at. A change of coodinates eoves the singula facto,. Null coodinates, u and v, such that holding eithe u o v constant gives a null geodesic, tun out to not only eove the singulaity, but also give a cleae pictue of the causal elationships nea the sta. Fist, we find the null geodesics in the t-plane. We have aleady shown that and the line eleent then tells us that u 0 k 0 k2 u 0 u 1 u 1 2 so that Taking the quotient, and integating, u 1 ±k d dt u1 u 0 ± ˆ d ±t ˆ d ˆ ˆ d d ±t c 3

Theefoe, defining u t v t we see that u constant gives an ingoing null geodesic and v constant gives an outgoing null geodesic. To wite the line eleent in tes of u and v, copute thei diffeentials, du dt d 1 dt d dv dt d Theefoe, This is still singula at, but now define Then Substituting into the line eleent, we have dudv dt 2 d 2 1 2 ds 2 1 dt 2 d2 1 2 dω 2 1 dudv 2 dω 2 U e u 4 V e v 4 dudv 1 u v dudve 4 162 1 16 2 dudve 16 2 e dudv ds 2 162 e dudv 2 dω 2 whee U, V. Thee is clealy no poble at, which is called the event hoizon. Radial infall We now conside a paticle falling into the black hole. Since the neighbohood of is now established to be egula, thee can be nothing to keep a paticle fo falling acoss the hoizon. We theefoe conside a paticle falling fo just inside the hoizon towad the singulaity. In this egion, becoes the tielike coodinate. The geodesic equation fo u 0 ay be witten as 1 u 0 k 4

with initial value at 0 given by 1 u 0 0 k 0 Since is now the tielike coodinate, we ay choose u 0 0 0, and theefoe, k 0, and u 0 0 along the entie geodesic. Then u 1 is given by Integating, 1 1 1 u 1 τ u 1 Letting y, and theefoe, y 2, ˆ 1 dτ 0 d 0 d 1 Now let y sin θ so that τ 2 τ 1 2 0 cos 2 θdθ 1 cos 2θ dθ 0 θ 12 0 sin 2θ ˆ y2 dy 2 0 2 θ sin θ cos θ 0 0 acsin 1 2 2 π 2 acsin 1 0 We ay take the initial position to be 0, which gives τ π 4 1 0 0 0 1 0 which is, in paticula, finite. The infall doesn t take long fo stella sized black holes. Fo a black hole with 10 ties the ass of the sun, we have τ GMπ 4c 2 6.67 10 11 1.99 10 31 π 4 9 10 16 3690 sec 5

o just ove an hou. Fo a black hole at the cente of a galaxy, which ay have a ass a illion ties as geat, the infall will take just shot of two yeas. The escape of light Finally, conside light which stats nea the event hoizon at t 0. How long does it take to escape fo the egion of the black hole? We conside an outgoing null geodesic, which has v constant, Suppose light leaves 0 δ at tie t 0. Then and the light eaches adius at tie c t c δ δ ct δ δ Copae this tie to the tie it would take in fee space fo light to tavel fo δ to, given by We find t 0 δ c t δ δ t 0 δ δ 1 δ 1 δ δ Conside a black hole with 10 ties the ass of the sun, so that 2GM c 2 2950 The tie to each the obit of Eath 1.5 10 11 fo nea the hoizon would noally be about 500 seconds. This is inceased by t 500 δ δ 500 2950 1.5 1011 1.5 1011 δ 9.83 10 6 1.5 1011 δ Fo a distance of δ 1c above the hoizon, the tie delay is t 9.83 10 6 1.5 10 13 2.98 10 4 sec so a collapsing sta will appea to settle to its Schwazschild adius exteely quickly. 6