DIRECT TORQUE CONTROL OF PERMANENT MAGNET SYNCHRONOUS MOTOR USING TWO LEVEL INVERTER- SURVEY PAPER 1 PREETI SINGH, BHUPAL SINGH 1 M.Tech (scholar) Electrical Power & Energy System, lecturer Ajay Kumar Garg Engineering College, Ghaziabad (India) Email:- singhpreeti45@gmail.com, bhupals_1@yahoo.co.in Abstract: Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor is most popular AC Motor in industrial and other servo applications, because of its higher efficiency, reliability and better dynamic response. There is large number of control strategies reported in the literature. In present study Direct Torque Control scheme has been discussed, which produces quick and robust speed control. In this review paper, functional details of the DTC are presented. Keywords:- DTC Scheme, Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor, Voltage Vector Selection. I. INTRODUCTION Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor is one of an AC Motor for Electric drive which is widely used in the field of Automation, Robotics and the Industries, because of its compact size, higher efficiency and faster response. It is well established, in that PMSM the increase in electromagnetic torque is proportional to the increase in the angle between the rotor flux linkages, which are the positive aspects of DTC. Two control strategies of PMSM are Field Oriented Control and the Direct torque Control. In present review only Direct Torque Control is discussed. The concept of DTC was proposed by Depenbrock, Thakahashi and Noguchi in 1980 s [1]. In this technique, the voltage vector values are selected based on the error between the reference value and the actual value of the flux and the torque usually treated in a d-q reference frame fixed to the rotor. The voltage equations of permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor is :- U = R i + dψ ωψ dt U = R i + dψ + ωψ dt Where, U, U = stator voltages in direct and quadrature axis R = stator resistance i i = stator current in direct and quadrature axis The flux linkage components can be obtained by the Ψ = L i + L i + Ψ Ψ = L i + L i II. MATHEMATICAL MODEL OF PMSM Where:- Ψ, Ψ = flux linkage components in direct and quadrature axis L, L = magnetizing inductance in direct and quadrature axis Fig.1. Equivalent circuit diagram in d-direction The Torque equation according to cross field principle is:- T e = p[ψ Pmi sq L mq L md i sd i sq + L md i D i sq + L mq i Q i sd ] Fig.. Equivalent circuit diagram in q-direction Equivalent circuit diagram [8] of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor is shown in figure, which is III. DIRECT TORQUE CONTROL OF PMSM Direct Torque Control method is used to control the torque of Electric Motor. In a Direct Torque Control method, the estimated and the reference value of stator flux linkage and the torque of the motor are 46
compared. If estimated values of flux and the Torque, deviates from the reference values exceeding the tolerance value, the IGBT switches of the Variable Frequency Drive are turned OFF or ON. So the flux and the Torque error is form to return tolerant bands. Fig.. Model Diagram of Direct Torque Control Block diagram of DTC scheme is shown in fig.. The basic principle of Direct Torque Control is to select the stator voltage vectors in according to the error between the reference and the actual value of the Torque and the stator flux. The brief description of the functional blocks of scheme is presented below:- Speed controller:- In the speed controller [], reference value of speed is compared to the measured value. Resulting output signal becomes the reference for the Torque reference control. This block consist PI controller. Equation for the PI controller is as listed below and the correspondence diagram is shown in fig.4. Fig.4. PI controller u(t) = K [e(t) + e(t)dt] U(s) = Kp 1 + 1 T E(s) Kp = Controller gain E(t) = error gain U(t) = controller output Ti = Integral or reset time Torque and Flux Controller:- Torque hysteresis Controller and Flux hysteresis Controller are used to compare the reference and the estimated values of Torque and Flux respectively and gives the Torque hysteresis bandwidth (ΔT ), stator flux hysteresis bandwidth (ΔΨ ). when the torque drops is above the value of torque hysteresis bandwidth, it shows the low status of torque. Likewise when the torque drops is below the hysteresis bandwidth than the torque status goes high. Similarly, when the flux drops is higher than the flux hysteresis bandwidth, status of flux goes low and when the flux drops is lower than the flux hysteresis bandwidth, it shows the status of flux is high [9]. For torque hysteresis bandwidth:- If, [T T ] > Δ then dt = 1 ------- (1) If, [T T ] < Δ then dt = 0 ------- () Similarly, for stator flux hysteresis bandwidth:- If, Ψ Ψ > ΔΨ then d Ψ = 1 ------- () If, Ψ Ψ < ΔΨ then d Ψ = 0 ------ (4) where :- T= output of torque hysteresis comparator Ψ= output of flux hysteresis comparator T=0 means that the estimated value of torque is maximum the reference and out of hysteresis limit. T=1 means that the estimated value of torque is minimum the reference and out of the hysteresis limit. Ψ =1 means the flux linkage estimated value is below the reference and out of the hysteresis limit. Ψ=0 means the flux linkage estimated value is above the reference value and out of the hysteresis limit. Inverter:- In the DTC scheme we are using Four Switch Three Phase inverter. The diagram of FSTP inverter is shown in figure in which two phase of machines are connected to the power switches and remaining one is connected to the midpoint of dc link capacitor. Following are the assumptions for the simulation of inverter []:- The inverter switching devices are assumed to be ideal, i.e. the ON state voltage drops across the device, turn on time and turn off time are neglected. The dc bus/ battery voltage is assumed to be constant. Fig.6. Four Switch Three Phase Inverter 47
Table.. voltage vectors of FSTP inverter From the table:- In case 1:- if the switching states of inverter is 00, i.e.- S, S =off S, S = on V =V /, V =V =o In case 4:-switching states of inverter will be o1, i.e.- S, S =off S, S =on V = -V /, V = -V, V =0 V and V can be obtained as [7]:- V = V V V V = V V Where, V,V,V = phase to neutral voltages, these can be calculated as follows- V = V V = V = V V = V V V V = V V = V V V Where- V, V, V = phase to zero voltages. Voltage switching table:- Main principle of Direct Torque Control [], [4]is to determine the correct voltage vector using the appropriate switching table. For obtaining the correct switching table, we should know about the correct values of the Torque and the stator flux hysteresis bandwidth and sector information. In case :- switching states of inverter will be 10, i.e.- S, S = on S, S =off V = V /, V = V, V =0 Fig.5. Control of stator flux linkage with DTC FSTP inverter. In case:- switching states of inverter will be 11, i.e.- S, S =on S, S =off V = V /, V =V =V For sector information:- Space vector angle determines the sector. [5] Following equation can be used when its switching signals can be generated. θ = arctan Ψ Ψ = Ψ + Ψ Te= Ψ Ψ 48
Torque and the Flux estimation block:- in these block,[] we fed the motor current, and the DC voltage as input. Sector block takes the angle information and generated out of d- axis and q- axis fluxes and provide the sector information and output which is subsequently used along with the flux and torque controller outputs to decide the switching condition of the inverter. Magnitude of stator flux Ψs is obtained as:- Table no.1 switching table for DTC method Switching table for DTC method is shown above [6], this table is depends upon the hysteresis bandwidth values of torque and the stator flux linkage. According to the equations (1-4), the sequence of voltage vector values in sectors, will occur. Transformation:- Complexity of simulation can be reduced by the suitable transformation of three phase electrical parameters. The most common methods to do this are the Clarke and Park transformations. Using these modifications [6] it is possible to calculate the correct power/torque values from the transformed motor parameters without the need to transform them back to three phase values. The description of these transformations relevant to present study is given subsequently. Clarke's transformation The ABC parameters are transformed into αβ0 parameters with orthogonal axes in the same stationary reference frame by equation. = T = T -1 Where f can be any one of the motors armature parameters, and the transformation Matrix T is:- 1 T= 0 1 1 1 1 1 Park's transformation The Park transformation changes a three phase system [8] in one stationary reference frame into a two phase system with orthogonal axes in a different rotating reference frame. The ABC parameters are transformed into dq0 parameters by equation. = T(θ) = T(θ) -1 Where f can be any one of the motors armature parameters, and the transformation matrix T is:- cos cos Π cos + Π T= sin sin Π sin( + Π ) 1 1 1 Ψ = Ψ + Ψ IV. = tan 1 ADVANTAGE AND DISADVANTAGE OF DTC There are several advantages of DTC over other control systems such as vector control. In DTC scheme when we generate the lookup table for the switching commands of inverter, in fact lookup simplifies the control system and also decreases the processing time unlike the PWM modulator used in vector control. The torque and the flux estimation, employes the simple hysteresis controller to avoid the chattering. There is no need of vector transformation because stator quantities are enough to control the torque and flux linkages. Although several advantages of DTC scheme, it still has a few drawbacks as well. A major disadvantage of DTC scheme is introduces higher ripples in Torque and Flux linkages. For the stator flux linkage estimation, requires a stator resistance, so any variation in resistance may introduce the error in the estimation. CONCLUSION In this review paper, the Direct Torque Control method for Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor has been discussed. Selection of voltage vector is the key part of the DTC method. PMSM is popular because it gives high efficiency, high power factor. It is well established that electromagnetic torque is proportional to the angle between rotor and the stator flux linkage. DTC scheme provides good torque response and robustness, and other advantages also there over the vector control method.although it has few drawbacks too. So many problems are already overcome by the researchers. REFERENCES 1) David Ocee, Direct Torque Control of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor m.tech thesis, SWEEDEN 005. ) E-Book, JUHA Pyrohonen, LUT, Department Of Electrical Engineering. 49
) Vaibhav B. Magdum, Ravindra M. Malka, Study and Simulation of Direct Torque Control method for Three Phase Induction Motor drives IEEE, Volume Number 1, January - April (011) 4) D. Siva Krishna and C. Srinivasa Rao, Speed Control of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor based on Direct torque control method International journal of advances in science and technology, vol,011 5) Selin Ozcira and Nur Bekiroglu Direct Toque Control of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor Yildiz Technical University, TURKEY. 6) Salih Baris Ozturk, Direct Torque Control of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor with Non Sinusoidal Back EMF, P.HD thesis, Graduate studies of Texas A& M University, may 008. 7) Khoa D. Hoang, Q. Zhu and Martin P. Foster, Influence and Compensation of Inverter Voltage Drop in Direct Torque- Controlled Four-Switch Three-Phase PM Brushless AC Drives, IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, vol. 6, no. 8, august 011. 8) Anders Kronberg, Design & Simulation Of Field Oriented Control & Direct Torque Control For a Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor With Positive Saliency, ISRN UTH- INGUTB- Ex- E- 01/05- SE Examensarbete 15hp May 01. 9) Anitpal singh, Mr. Shakti singh, Mr. sssr Sarathbabu Duvvuri Direct Torque Control of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motor using three level inverter, thesis, THAPAR UNIVAERSITY. PUNJAB, JUNE 010 50