ASTRO-H Studies of Accretion Flow onto Supermassive Black Hole 2015 October 21 The Institute of Physical and Chemical Research (RIKEN) Nishina center Hirofumi Noda
1. Contents I. Introduction II. Geometry and State of Accretion Flow in NGC 3516 è With X-ray and Optical Correlation III. Phase Change of Accretion Flow in NGC 3227 è With Drastic Change of X-ray Variability IV. ASTRO-H Studies of Accretion in Seyferts
I. Introduction
1. Accretion Flow onto Black Hole Cyg X-1 X-ray spectrum High/So5 Low/Hard Hard tail L/L E = η 1 0.1 High/So5 Disk Corona Black body Compton Disk black body 0.01 BH Low/Hard In black hole (BH) binaries, disk black body appears in X-ray band è Inner disk temp. with M BH ~ 10M is consistent with b.body temp. of ~1 kev Broad-band continuum with high energy cutoff at several hundreds kev è Comptonization to disk b.body (Inhomogeneous corona, Maxima+08) With higher η, disk b.body becomes dominant, changing accretion state BHB spectra are explained with truncated disk and broad corona
1. Accretion Flow onto Black Hole Cyg X-1 X-ray spectrum High/So5 Low/Hard Compton L/L E = η 1 0.1 High/So5 Disk Corona Black body Compton Disk black body 0.01 BH Low/Hard In black hole (BH) binaries, disk black body appears in X-ray band è Inner disk temp. with M BH ~ 10M is consistent with b.body temp. of ~1 kev Broad-band continuum with high energy cutoff at several hundreds kev è Comptonization to disk b.body (Inhomogeneous corona, Maxima+08) With higher η, disk b.body becomes dominant, changing accretion state BHB spectra are explained with truncated disk and broad corona
2. Assumed Accretion Flow onto Supermassive BH NGC 1365 (Risaliti+13) νfν Fabian & Miniutti+05 Primary Compton Corona BH R in < 3 R s Disk Relativisticallyblurred refection Red wing Hard X-ray hump Seyferts have η ~ 0.001 1, which is a range between L/H and H/S state in BHBs. Tanaka+95 : Relativistically Broadened Fe line è Max BH spin in MCG-6-30-15 With various satellite broad-band spectra, the soft and hard X-ray excesses have been interpreted as relativistically-blurred reflection (RBR). Red wing cannot be explained without central compact corona (e.g., Wilkins+15) è Compact corona with the inner disk radius of R in < 3 R s
3. Geometry Assumed in Optical AGN Studies NGC 5548 I R1 Cackett+07 Geometry assumed in optical studies (Uttley+06) R V +5 Compact B ±0 Lag (day) In optical variations, shorter wavelength precedes longer ones in many Sys (cf. Collier+99, Cackett+07, Mchardy+14) The good correlations were found between optical and X-ray in several Sys è Optical variation is generated by X-ray illumination Disk is always assumed to have R in ~ 3 R s with compact X-ray region R in ~3 R s
4. Positioning of Our Studies of SMBH Accretion The corona has been regarded compact, and the accretion disk has been assumed to have R in < 3 R s, regardless of η, in optical and X-ray studies. Accretion onto SMBH in Seyferts is assumed to be in the High/Soft state, and to have no state transition è However, no clear evidence We need to determine geometry and state of accretion flow in Seyferts without model assumptions as possible. è X-ray and optical variabilities should be utilized In this study, we focus two Seyfert galaxies, NGC 3516 and NGC 3227, with η < 0.01, which corresponds to the Low/Hard state having truncated disk and broad corona in BHB.
II. Geometry and State of Accretion Flow in NGC 3516 è With X-ray and Optical Correlation
5. Hints of Geometry: X-ray and Optical Correlation kev 2 (Photons cm 2 s 1 kev 1 ) 0.1 0.01 10-3 10-4 νfν AGN meeeng @ Rikkyo Univ. X-ray spectrum in 2013 2014 20 times variation ΔF ~ 2.5 10-11 erg/s/cm 2 η ~ 0.0005 0.01 2 5 10 40 Energy (kev) To study accretion geometry, we performed X-ray optical simultaneous monitoring for 1 year Target: low η Seyfert NGC 3516 X-ray obs: Suzaku 50 ks 7 with various intervals, days, weeks, months B band obs : Japanese 5 telescope Pirka, Kiso, MITSuME, Nayuta, Kanata è Historically faint phase in X-ray and optical
2 10 kev flux (10-11 erg s -1 cm -2 ) B-band flux density (mjy) 4 3 2 1 0-1 2 1.5 1 0.5 0-0.5 6. X-ray and Optical Correlation in NGC 3516 Epoch 1 2 3 45 6 7 ~2.5 10-11 erg/s/cm 2 ~0.82 10-11 erg/s/cm 2 Main hard PL Pirka, Kiso, MITSuME, Nayuta, Kanata 56300 56400 56500 56600 56700 56800 MJD Hard primary X-ray is well correlated with B band Interpolate and compare (Zu+11) Lag~1.7 days JAVELIN and CCF method reveal that X-ray preceded opt. by ~1.7±0.7 days Opt. flux increase calculated by B-band is explained by X-ray irradiation Standard disk term F = 3GM BHṀ AGN 8meeEng R 3 + (1 A)L X X-ray irr. term @ Rikkyo Univ. 4 RX 2 cos
7. Contradiction b/w Lag and η in H/S state Results in our monitoring of NGC 3516 1. X-ray preceded B band à X-ray irradiation made optical variation 2. B band lag τ against X-ray is ~1.7 days à ~400 R S /c (M BH ~ 2.5 10 7 M ) 3. X-ray and optical are in very faint phase à η = 5 10-4 0.01 4. B-band flux explained by X-ray irr. à Standard disk term can be 0 τ inconsistent with η (Actual τ larger than that expected from η by ~20 times) è High/Soft state (compact corona) is unsuited for NGC 3516 in the faint phase η ~ 4 B band X-ray B-band η ~ 0.01 τ ~ 1 day corona BH τ ~ 1 hour 400 R S < 10 R S AGN meeeng @ Rikkyo Univ. disk
8. Geometries of Corona and Disk X-ray B-band Noda et al. (2015) in prep BH X-ray-luminous region corona 1.7 light day (~400R S ) Disk should be truncated to make τ ~1.7 days and η ~ 5 10-4 0.01 consistent Hot accretion flow in Low/Hard state X-ray bright point ~1.7 ld far from disk Optical flux is not by α-viscosity but X-ray irr. ( particularly N3516 ) In many Seyferts, optical lag τ is too large to explain their η (e.g., Cackett+07) NGC 4051 3C390.3 à τ larger than that expected from η by ~2 times Mrk 509 MCG+8-11-11à τ larger than that expected from η by ~3 times NGC 5548 à τ larger than that expected from η by ~5 times Seyferts generally have broad corona in the Low/Hard state! AGN meeeng @ Rikkyo Univ.
III. Phase Change of Accretion Flow in NGC 3227 è With Drastic Change of X-ray Variability
10. Hints of Accretion State: X-ray Variability Change Count Rate [cnt/s] Suzaku 6 observation (each exp. ~50 ksec) 1 0.1 Light curves 3 10 kev 2 3 kev 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 Time [ksec] 3-10 kev Count Rate [cnt/s] 2 1.5 1 0.5 Noda et al. 2014, ApJ, 794, 2 Count-Count Plot Clear break 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 2-3 kev Count Rate [cnt/s] Spectral hardness drastically changes at the count rate of ~0.16 cnt/s in 2 3 kev Not due to absorption variation è Dominant primary X-ray changes Two types of primary X-ray are present, differently from the popular assumption Difference spectrum (High Low spectrum) analyses for individual branches give us spectral shapes of the primary X-ray (Noda+13; 14)
10. Hints of Accretion State: X-ray Variability Change Count Rate [cnt/s] Suzaku 6 observation (each exp. ~50 ksec) 1 0.1 Hours Light curves Weeks 3 10 kev 2 3 kev 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 Time [ksec] 3-10 kev Count Rate [cnt/s] 2 1.5 1 0.5 Noda et al. 2014, ApJ, 794, 2 Count-Count Plot Faint state Bright state Phase change 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 2-3 kev Count Rate [cnt/s] Spectral hardness drastically changes at the count rate of ~0.16 cnt/s in 2 3 kev Not due to absorption variation è Dominant primary X-ray changes Two types of primary X-ray are present, differently from the popular assumption Difference spectrum (High Low spectrum) analyses for individual branches give us spectral shapes of the primary X-ray (Noda+13; 14)
νfν 0.1 10-2 10-3 10-4 2 40 Energy (kev) 11. Discovery of Two Different Primary X-ray (b) 5th 6th Faint phase 3-10 kev Count Rate [cnt/s] High Low 1 (a) Bright High Low phase in 1st 1 3 2 5 101.5 High 4 Low 40 2 5 Energy (kev) Bright phase 10 40 1 Phase change 0.5 High Faint phase Low 0 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1 1.2 2-3 kev Count Rate [cnt/s] 2 5 10 40 Noda et al. 2014, ApJ, 794, 2 High Low
0.1 10-2 11. Discovery of Two Different Primary X-ray (b) 5th 6th Faint phase High Low 40 2 5 10 40 Energy (kev) 1 (a) Bright High Low phase in 1st 1 Noda et al. 2014, ApJ, 794, 2 High Low νfν Difference N H 10 22 cm -2 3 Difference 10-3 Hard Primary N Soft Primary H ~10 23 cm -2 +0.19 (Γ=1.84 0.17 ) +0.20 (Γ=2.41 0.18 ) 4 10-4 2 5 10 40 2 5 10 40 Energy (kev) Low η High η Accretion onto SMBH causes two distinct primary X-ray (often simultaneously) Hard Primary : Flat spectrum (Γ ~ 1.8); strong neutral absorption (N H ~ 10 23 cm -2 ); t.scale is ~ weeks; dominates with low η è Compton in the Low/Hard state Soft Primary : Steep spectrum (Γ ~ 2.4); weak neutral absorption (N H 10 22 cm -2 ); t.scale is ~hours; appears with high η, together with Hard Pri. è Hard tail in the High/Soft state
νfν 0.1 10-2 10-3 10-4 11. Discovery of Two Different Primary X-ray (b) Faint-Branch result Faint phase Hard Primary Reflection χ kev 2 (Photons cm 2 s 1 kev 1 ) 40 2 5 10 40 2 5 10 40 2 Energy (kev) Energy (kev) Energy 0.1 0.01 10-3 10-4 (a) Bright-brach result Bright phase Noda et al. 2014, ApJ, 794, 2 Reflection Soft Primary Low η High η Accretion onto SMBH causes two distinct primary X-ray (often simultaneously) Hard Primary : Flat spectrum (Γ ~ 1.8); strong neutral absorption (N H ~ 10 23 cm -2 ); t.scale is ~ weeks; dominates with low η è Compton in the Low/Hard state Soft Primary : Steep spectrum (Γ ~ 2.4); weak neutral absorption (N H 10 22 cm -2 ); t.scale is ~hours; appears with high η, together with Hard Pri. è Hard tail in the High/Soft state
νfν 0.1 10-2 10-3 10-4 11. Discovery of Two Different Primary X-ray (b) Faint-Branch result Faint phase Hard Primary Reflection χ kev 2 (Photons cm 2 s 1 kev 1 ) 40 2 5 10 40 2 5 10 40 2 Energy (kev) Energy (kev) Energy 0.1 0.01 10-3 10-4 (a) Bright-brach result Bright phase Hard Primary Noda et al. 2014, ApJ, 794, 2 Reflection Soft Primary Low η High η Accretion onto SMBH causes two distinct primary X-ray (often simultaneously) Hard Primary : Flat spectrum (Γ ~ 1.8); strong neutral absorption (N H ~ 10 23 cm -2 ); t.scale is ~ weeks; dominates with low η è Compton in the Low/Hard state Soft Primary : Steep spectrum (Γ ~ 2.4); weak neutral absorption (N H 10 22 cm -2 ); t.scale is ~hours; appears with high η, together with Hard Pri. è Hard tail in the High/Soft state
12. Interpretation of Phase Change of NGC 3227 Faint phase NGC 3516, NGC 3227 faint Hard Primary Mixture phase Hard Primary NGC 3227 bright Soft Primary Standard disk BH RIAF (Low/Hard) Low η Standard disk BH RIAF (Low/Hard) Hard tail region (High/Soft) High η NGC 3227 shows phase change from Faint to Mixture phase Faint phase à Hard Primary (Low/Hard) Mixture phase à Hard Primary + Soft Primary (Low/Hard + High/Soft) Many Seyferts like MCG-6-30-15, IC4329A, NGC 4051, are in the Mixture state (à Maxima-sensei s talk at this afternoon)
IV. ASTRO-H Studies of Accretion in Seyferts
13. Our Studies of Accretion onto SMBH with ASTRO-H Hard Primary Soft Primary Optical Both illuminate disk? BH RIAF (Low/Hard) Hard tail region (High/Soft) Standard disk Hard and Soft primary X-ray both can illuminate disk, increasing optical Correlation between Soft pri. and opt. is good as well as Hard Primary? How large amount of energy is given to disk by X-ray irradiation?
13. Our Studies of Accretion onto SMBH with ASTRO-H Can wind contribute the state transition from High/Soft to Low/Hard? Hard Primary Soft Primary Optical BH RIAF (Low/Hard) Hard tail region (High/Soft) Standard disk Hard and Soft primary X-ray both can illuminate disk, increasing optical Correlation between Soft pri. and opt. is good as well as Hard Primary? How large amount of energy is given to disk by X-ray irradiation? In an accretion flow, two different states with different accretion rate (Low/Hard and High/Soft states) are present at the same time At boundary between the two regions, wind can take away accreting mass, changing state in a flow?
14. ASTRO-H Observations of Seyferts 0.1 0.01 Opt UV ASTRO-H sim. SXS HXI Disk SGD Soft Primary 10-3 10-4 Hard Primary Wind Reflection 0.01 0.1 1 10 100 Perform sim. observations of ASTRO-H and ground telescopes on Sy having multiple primary X-ray like MCG-6-30-15, NGC 4051, NGC 3227 1. Broad spec. with HXI/SGD è Precise luminosity of Soft and Hard pri. 2. Fe-K abs. features with SXS è Wind strength 3. Optical variations è Variation of disk luminosity State transition in an accretion flow X opt. correlation and energy deposit to disk by X-ray illumination
15. Summary With the simultaneous monitor of X-ray and optical, NGC 3516 was found in the Low/Hard state, with the disk truncated at ~400 Rs and a hot accretion flow formed at inner region. By analyzing the drastic change of X-ray variability, NGC 3227 was found to show the phase change from the Faint (Low/Hard) to Mixture (Low/Hard + High/Soft) phase. By observing Seyferts with ASTRO-H and ground-based telescopes, we can establish the geometries and states of accretion flows onto supermassive black holes.