Consistency test of martial arts competition evaluation criteria based on mathematical ahp model

Similar documents
Evaluation model of young basketball players physical quality and basic technique based on rbf neural network

COMPARISON OF ANALYTIC HIERARCHY PROCESS AND SOME NEW OPTIMIZATION PROCEDURES FOR RATIO SCALING

An Indian Journal FULL PAPER ABSTRACT KEYWORDS. Trade Science Inc. Research on scheme evaluation method of automation mechatronic systems

Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research, 2014, 6(7): Research Article

Solving Constrained Flow-Shop Scheduling. Problems with Three Machines

Ranking Bank Branches with Interval Data By IAHP and TOPSIS

Comparison of Parameters of Lognormal Distribution Based On the Classical and Posterior Estimates

A New Method for Consistency Correction of Judgment Matrix in AHP

Confidence Intervals for Double Exponential Distribution: A Simulation Approach

A Method for Damping Estimation Based On Least Square Fit

Estimation of Stress- Strength Reliability model using finite mixture of exponential distributions

Comparing Different Estimators of three Parameters for Transmuted Weibull Distribution

An Analysis of the Drivers Affecting the Implementation of Cost Control in Hydropower Construction Project Based on ISM-FAHP

Study on Risk Analysis of Railway Signal System

Introduction to local (nonparametric) density estimation. methods

ECONOMETRIC THEORY. MODULE VIII Lecture - 26 Heteroskedasticity

Evaluation on Ecological Environment of Scientific and Technological Innovation Talents in China

TWO NEW WEIGHTED MEASURES OF FUZZY ENTROPY AND THEIR PROPERTIES

ABOUT ONE APPROACH TO APPROXIMATION OF CONTINUOUS FUNCTION BY THREE-LAYERED NEURAL NETWORK

Management Science Letters

VOL. 3, NO. 11, November 2013 ISSN ARPN Journal of Science and Technology All rights reserved.

Optimization Research of Batch Order Processing Queue in Internet Consumption Custom Marketing

Bayes Estimator for Exponential Distribution with Extension of Jeffery Prior Information

Combining Gray Relational Analysis with Cumulative Prospect Theory for Multi-sensor Target Recognition

Application of Calibration Approach for Regression Coefficient Estimation under Two-stage Sampling Design

Analysis of a Repairable (n-1)-out-of-n: G System with Failure and Repair Times Arbitrarily Distributed

2.28 The Wall Street Journal is probably referring to the average number of cubes used per glass measured for some population that they have chosen.

Functions of Random Variables

Generalization of the Dissimilarity Measure of Fuzzy Sets

Studies on the risk evaluation of landslide geological disaster in Wulong County

Application of Improved Grey Correlative Method in Safety Evaluation on Fully Mechanized Mining Faces

Lecture 1 Review of Fundamental Statistical Concepts

Bayes Interval Estimation for binomial proportion and difference of two binomial proportions with Simulation Study

Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research, 2014, 6(7): Research Article

Evaluation study on training of 100m sprint athletes based on improved D-S evidence theory

ESS Line Fitting

BAYESIAN INFERENCES FOR TWO PARAMETER WEIBULL DISTRIBUTION

Reliability evaluation of distribution network based on improved non. sequential Monte Carlo method

POSSIBILITY APPROACH FOR SOLVE THE DATA ENVELOPMENT ANALYTICAL HIERARCHY PROCESS (DEAHP) WITH FUZZY JUDGMENT SCALES

Unimodality Tests for Global Optimization of Single Variable Functions Using Statistical Methods

Interval Entropy Measurement Method in Risk Analysis and Its Application to Metro Construction

Simple Linear Regression

Analysis of Variance with Weibull Data

Validating Multiattribute Decision Making Methods for Supporting Group Decisions

Analysis of Lagrange Interpolation Formula

Fuzzy TOPSIS Based on α Level Set for Academic Staff Selection

Cubic Nonpolynomial Spline Approach to the Solution of a Second Order Two-Point Boundary Value Problem

Bounds for the Connective Eccentric Index

Research Article New Combined Weighting Model Based on Maximizing the Difference in Evaluation Results and Its Application

A Study on Generalized Generalized Quasi hyperbolic Kac Moody algebra QHGGH of rank 10

On Eccentricity Sum Eigenvalue and Eccentricity Sum Energy of a Graph

Research on SVM Prediction Model Based on Chaos Theory

MEASURES OF DISPERSION

Some Notes on the Probability Space of Statistical Surveys

Summary of the lecture in Biostatistics

Dynamic Analysis of Axially Beam on Visco - Elastic Foundation with Elastic Supports under Moving Load

STRONG CONSISTENCY FOR SIMPLE LINEAR EV MODEL WITH v/ -MIXING

Median as a Weighted Arithmetic Mean of All Sample Observations

A Fuzzy Evaluation and AHP based Method for the Energy Efficiency Evaluation of EV Charging Station

A New Family of Transformations for Lifetime Data

Complete Convergence for Weighted Sums of Arrays of Rowwise Asymptotically Almost Negative Associated Random Variables

METHODS OF EVALUATION AND IMPROVEMENT OF CONSISTENCY OF EXPERT PAIRWISE COMPARISON JUDGMENTS. Nataliya Pankratova, Nadezhda Nedashkovskaya

(Monte Carlo) Resampling Technique in Validity Testing and Reliability Testing

Dr. Shalabh Department of Mathematics and Statistics Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur

Investigating Cellular Automata

best estimate (mean) for X uncertainty or error in the measurement (systematic, random or statistical) best

Chapter 2 - Free Vibration of Multi-Degree-of-Freedom Systems - II

Research Article A New Derivation and Recursive Algorithm Based on Wronskian Matrix for Vandermonde Inverse Matrix

LINEAR REGRESSION ANALYSIS

A Planning Approach of Engineering Characteristics Based on QFD-TRIZ Integrated

Chapter 8. Inferences about More Than Two Population Central Values

CHAPTER VI Statistical Analysis of Experimental Data

TESTS BASED ON MAXIMUM LIKELIHOOD

Simulation Output Analysis

Chapter 11 Systematic Sampling

Permutation Tests for More Than Two Samples

Multivariate Transformation of Variables and Maximum Likelihood Estimation

IJOART. Copyright 2014 SciResPub.

A New Method for Decision Making Based on Soft Matrix Theory

On the construction of symmetric nonnegative matrix with prescribed Ritz values

X ε ) = 0, or equivalently, lim

QR Factorization and Singular Value Decomposition COS 323

RELIABILITY OF THE IEC (1995) STANDARD FOR DETERMINING BREAKDOWN VOLTAGE OF ELECTROINSULATING OILS

PICTURE FUZZY CROSS-ENTROPY FOR MULTIPLE ATTRIBUTE DECISION MAKING PROBLEMS

An Extended TOPSIS Method for the Multiple Attribute Decision Making Problems Based on Interval Neutrosophic Set

A NEW LOG-NORMAL DISTRIBUTION

Systematic Selection of Parameters in the development of Feedforward Artificial Neural Network Models through Conventional and Intelligent Algorithms

Chapter 3 Sampling For Proportions and Percentages

Analyzing Fuzzy System Reliability Using Vague Set Theory

An Improved Differential Evolution Algorithm Based on Statistical Log-linear Model

Correlation coefficients of simplified neutrosophic sets and their. multiple attribute decision-making method

An Introduction to. Support Vector Machine

Some Hybrid Geometric Aggregation Operators with 2-tuple Linguistic Information and Their Applications to Multi-attribute Group Decision Making

A New Measure of Probabilistic Entropy. and its Properties

Dice Similarity Measure between Single Valued Neutrosophic Multisets and Its Application in Medical. Diagnosis

Linear Regression Linear Regression with Shrinkage. Some slides are due to Tommi Jaakkola, MIT AI Lab

Chapter 5 Properties of a Random Sample

f f... f 1 n n (ii) Median : It is the value of the middle-most observation(s).

PTAS for Bin-Packing

9.1 Introduction to the probit and logit models

Transcription:

ISSN : 0974-7435 Volume 8 Issue 2 BoTechology BoTechology A Ida Joural Cosstecy test of martal arts competto evaluato crtera based o mathematcal ahp model Hu Wag Isttute of Physcal Educato, JagSu Normal Uversty, Xuzhou 226, Jagsu, (CHINA) E-mal: tyux@qq.com BTAIJ, 8(2), 203 [204-208] ABSTRACT The gradg crtero of Martal art route competto s fe ad complex, the tme for the referee to judge the game s very short ad lmt, such as boxg etc. optoal route oly 90s, some competto tme of the games s eve less. Therefore, such cases, the referee should gve a more accurate grade accordg to the rules, ad the dffculty s very great. I order to strctly abde by the rules ad reach the smple, fast ad accurate goal, we must select some dcators ad varables that ca accurately reflect the comprehesve ablty of athletes. Ths paper attempts to troduce AHP mathematcal model; the evaluato crtera are dvded to two categores; t uses statstcal software tools SPSS to establsh judgmet matrx ad coduct cosstecy test; the results shows that: the judgmet matrx cosstecy test of walkthrough level, CR = 0.5953 <0.; the judgmet matrx cosstecy test of acto completo s CR = 0.808 <0.. The above judgmet dcators all ca go through cosstecy test evaluato ad ca be appled the actual game. 203 Trade Scece Ic. - INDIA KEYWORDS AHP; Martal arts competto; Performace evaluato; Cosstecy testg. INTRODUCTION The evaluato crtera durg martal arts compettos s a mportat measure of value for experts ad coaches to make preparatos, s the bass for classfcato. Wthout ths measuremet ad bass, the evaluato actvtes caot be carred through. Ths paper uses AHP method, ad selects some dcators ad varables that ca accurately reflect the comprehesve ablty of athletes. The evaluato crtera are dvded to two categores: walkthrough level ad acto completo, where walkthrough level s dvded to skll level, acto choreography, ad exercse tps; acto completo s dvded to posture, style ad sprt three evaluato crtera. It costructs matrx ad coducts cosstecy test, the judges whether the above dcators ca become the judgmet crtera of the match. THE ESTABLISHMENT OF AHP MODEL AHP method s proposed by the Amerca operatoal research experts T. L. Saaty 970s. After years of developmet t has ow become a more mature approach. The basc prcple s: dvdg the varous elemets of the alteratves of the evaluato system to a umber of levels, ad takg the varous elemets of the

BTAIJ, 8(2) 203 Hu Wag 205 same level accordace wth upper layer elemet as a crtero, coducts par-wse comparso ad calculates the weght of each elemet, determe the optmal weghtg scheme accordg to comprehesve weght ad the maxmum weght prcple. It s deduced o the bass of smple addtve weghtg method. It reasoably combes qualtatve ad quattatve strateges, layerg ad quatfes the decso-makg process accordace wth thkg ad metal dscple. Sce the method was troduced to the coutry 982, wth the characterstcs of dsposg varous decso-makg processes combg ts qualtatve ad quattatve factors, as well as t s a smple ad flexble system, t has bee wdely used ad valued our socal ad ecoomc felds, such as eergy systems aalyss, urba plag, ecoomc maagemet, ad scetfc evaluato. Establsh a herarchcal structure model Ths paper takes the martal arts athletes performace evaluato as a target layer of herarchy aalyss, takes the walkthrough level ad acto completo as the termedate layer, takes the skll level, techque, acto choreography, posture, style, rhythm ad ovato capablty as the program layer of AHP, establshes the herarchcal model of performace aalyss for martal arts athletes, as show Fgure. Fgure : The structure of AHP model Costruct judgmet matrx ad seek the largest egevalues ad egevectors Sce herarchcal structure model determes the membershp fucto of the upper ad lower elemets, you ca costruct par-wse judgmet matrx of dfferet levels for the above layer crtera. If the par-wse judgmet matrx s ( aj), the a j > 0 ; aj,. j, 2,3, a j The specfc judgmet matrx costructo method of each level s: uder the target layer of martal arts competto comprehesve evaluato, depedg o the walkthrough level, acto completo ad other factors, coduct par-wse comparso o the mportace, the hgher the class level s, the hgher ts mportace becomes. The cossteces of par-wse comparsos: / 2 4 A 2 7 a2 ( C : C2 ) 2 a 4( C : C ) a 8( C : C ) 3 3 23 2 3 Allow cosstet, but we eed to determe the allowable rage of cosstet. w w w w w2 w w2 w2 w2 A w w2 w w w w w w2 w Cosstet matrx propertes: () The rak of A s ; the oly o-zero egevalues of A s. (2) Ay colums vector of A s correspodg to the egevectors of. (3) The ormalzed egevector of A ca be used as weght vector. For the cosstet par-wse comparso matrx A, recommed takg the correspodg egevector of maxmum egevalue ë as the weght vector w, amely A. Comparso Scale: Saaty et al put forward BoTechology BoTechology A Ida Joural

206 Cosstecy test of martal arts competto evaluato crtera based BTAIJ, 8(2) 203 ~ 9 scale,.e. the value of a j s, 2,3 9 ad ts re- cprocal,,,, so as to facltate the coverso 2 3 9 from qualtatve to quattatve. Proporto Scale 3 5 7 9 TABLE : Relatve mportace scale BoTechology A Ida Joural Meag Represets the mportace of the two elemets are the same Represets a factor s slghtly mportat tha aother elemet Represets a factor s sgfcatly mportat tha aother elemet Represets a factor s hghly mportat tha aother elemet Represets a factor s extremely mportat tha aother elemet 2,4,6,8 The meda value of the above adjacet judgmet,,, 2 9 Is the recprocal of the above scale Psychologsts beleve that factors of par-wse comparsos should be o more tha e. Calculate the maxmum egevalues ad egevectors of judgmet matrx by geometrc mea approxmato method (root method) o. The calculato steps are: ()Calculate the product of matrx elemets each row: m aj,,2,3 () (2)Calculate the -th order root m (2) (3)Normalze the vector (, 2, ) T : j j j, 2,3 (3) The obtaed (, 2, ) T s the egevector approxmato, amely the weght of each factor. (4)Calculate the maxmum egevalue max of the matrx; Amog them, ( A ) s the -th elemet of the vector max ( A ) (4) A. Calculate the cosstecy dex of judgmet matrx ad test ts cosstecy I order to test the cosstecy of the matrx, defe TABLE 3 : The judgmet matrx cosstecy test of walkthrough level X X2 X3 X4 M O cubc W Aw AW/W CI=((ë-)/(-)) CR=CI/RI X2 /3 4 /3 0.57735 0.227930704 0.8 3.55 0.345284536 0.59538 X3 3 /5 3.73205 0.6837923 2.4 3.3 X4 /4 /5 0 0.223607 0.08827782 0.02 0.25 2.533008 Maxmum egevalue =2.3 TABLE 4 : The judgmet matrx cosstecy test of acto completo Acto completo Posture Style Sprt Multpled by le O cubc W Aw AW/W CI=(ë-)/(-) CR=CI/RI Posture /3 5.67.290994 0.38236656 0.9 2.86 0.468950025 0.808535 Style 3 2 6.00 2.44949 0.603860.89 3.3 Sprt /5 /2 0.0 0.36228 0.07795743 0.02 0.20 4.05672 TABLE 2 : Average radom cosstecy dex Order 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 5RI 0 0 0.58 0.90.2.24.32.4.45 X: Walkthrough level; X: Skll level; X3: Acto choreography; X4: Exercse tps; M: Multpled by le Maxmum egevalue =2.06

BTAIJ, 8(2) 203 Hu Wag 207 CI = max. Whe t s fully cosstet, the we have CI 0. The larger s CI, the worse the cosstecy of the matrx s. For the~ 9 order matrx, the average radom cosstecy dex RI s show TABLE. Whe the order 2, the matrx has always complete cosstecy; whe the order> 2, CR RI s called radom cosstecy of the matrx. aci CI CR 0. Whe RI, the overall level sort re- a CI sults have a satsfactory cosstecy. As ca be see from the TABLE CR 0.5953 0., that the three dcators walkthrough level, acto choreographed ad exercse tps have goe through cosstecy test. As ca be see from the TABLE CR 0.808 0., that the three dcators: posture, style ad sprt have goe through cosstecy test. CONCLUSIONS CI Ths paper troduces the AHP Comprehesve Evaluato dcators ad gves judgg mathematcal model of martal arts competto. Ths model just eeds geeral PC to ru ad operate, whch s coducve to computerzato. Evaluato crtera s dvded to walkthrough level ad acto completo two dcators, where walkthrough level s dvded to skll level, acto choreography, ad exercse tps; Acto completo s dvded to posture, style ad sprt three evaluato crtera; establsh judgmet matrx ad carry out cosstecy test through well-kow statstcal tools EXCLE, the results show: the judgmet matrx cosstecy test of walkthrough level,, dcates that three dcators skll level, acto choreography, ad exercse tps have goe through cosstecy test; the judgmet matrx cosstecy test of acto completo,, dcates that three dcators posture, style ad sprt have goe through cosstecy test. The above judgmet dcators all have passed the assessmet, ad ca be appled the actual game. REFERENCES [] Bg Zhag, Ya Feg; The Specal Qualty Evaluato of the Trple Jump ad the Dfferetal Equato Model of Log Jump Mechacs Based o Gray Correlato Aalyss. Iteratoal Joural of Appled Mathematcs ad Statstcs, 40(0), 36-43 (203). [2] Bg Zhag; Dyamcs Mathematcal Model ad Predcto of Log Jump Athletes Olympcs. Iteratoal Joural of Appled Mathematcs ad Statstcs, 44(4), 422-430 (203). [3] Ca Cu; Applcato of Mathematcal Model for Smulato of 00-Meter Race. Iteratoal Joural of Appled Mathematcs ad Statstcs, 42(2), 309-36 (203). [4] Hab Wag, Shuye Yag; A Aalyss of Hurdle Performace Predcto Based O Mechacal Aalyss ad Gray Predcto Model. Iteratoal Joural of Appled Mathematcs ad Statstcs, 39(9), 243-250 (203). [5] Hogwe Yag; Evaluato Model of Physcal Ftess of Youg Tes Athletes Based O AHP- TOPSIS Comprehesve Evaluato. Iteratoal Joural of Appled Mathematcs ad Statstcs, 39(9), 88-95 (203). [6] L Bg, The equvalece aalyss of shp rudder based o aalytc herarchy process. Chese Joural of Scetfc Istrumet, 34(2), 434-438 (203). [7] L We-guo; Research o qualtatve method of power trasformato codto assessmet usg aalytc herarchy process. Joural of Hua Uversty (Natural Sceces), 0, 56-60 (20). [8] Luo Zheg-qg, Comparatve study o several scales AHP. Systems Egeerg-theory & Practce, 24(9), 5-56 (2004). [9] She Ju-y; A research o the comprehesve evaluato of physcal educato teachg ad sports trag wth fuzzy theory. Cha Sport Scece Ad Techology,36, (2000). [0] Wag Xao-ju; Applcato of the aalytcal herarchy process to determg evaluato dex weghts for the predcto of reservor damage. Acta Petrole Sca, 6, 037-040 (20). [] Y Lu; The Establshmet of Herarchcal Model for Basketball Defesve Qualty. Iteratoal Joural of Appled Mathematcs ad Statstcs, 44(4), BoTechology A Ida Joural

208 Cosstecy test of martal arts competto evaluato crtera based BTAIJ, 8(2) 203 245-252 (203). [2] Yog Fa; Statstcal Aalyss Based O Gray System Theory Basketball Team Scores Its Techcal Idcators Assocated. Iteratoal Joural of Appled Mathematcs ad Statstcs, 44(4), 85-92 (203). [3] Zuoju Ta; Fuzzy Data Evelopmet Aalyss ad Neural Network Evaluato Mathematcal Applcatos Model Whch Based O Martal Arts Competto. Iteratoal Joural of Appled Mathematcs ad Statstcs, 44(4), 37-44 (203). BoTechology A Ida Joural