Shock Waves in a Dusty Plasma with Positive and Negative Dust where Ions are Non-Thermal

Similar documents
Shock Waves in a Dusty Plasma with Positive and Negative Dust, where Electrons Are Superthermally Distributed

Dr. A A Mamun Professor of Physics Jahangirnagar University Dhaka, Bangladesh

COMPRESSIVE AND RAREFACTIVE DUST-ACOUSTIC SOLITARY STRUCTURES IN A MAGNETIZED TWO-ION-TEMPERATURE DUSTY PLASMA. 1. Introduction

Dust Acoustic Solitary Waves in Saturn F-ring s Region

Dust-Acoustic Solitary Waves in a Magnetized Dusty Plasma with Ions of Distinct Temperatures

Effect of Positive Dust on Non-linear Properties of Ion-acoustic Waves

The effects of vortex like distributed electron in magnetized multi-ion dusty plasmas

Cylindrical Three-Dimensional Dust-Ion Acoustic Propagation in Plasmas

Dust acoustic solitary and shock waves in strongly coupled dusty plasmas with nonthermal ions

Linear and Nonlinear Dust Acoustic Waves, Shocks and Stationary Structures in DC-Glow-Discharge Dusty Plasma Experiments.

Chapter 3. Head-on collision of ion acoustic solitary waves in electron-positron-ion plasma with superthermal electrons and positrons.

A DUSTY PLASMA PRIMER

Effects of ion temperature on electrostatic solitary structures in nonthermal plasmas

Nonlinear electrostatic structures in unmagnetized pair-ion (fullerene) plasmas

Effect of Dust Grain Parameters on Ion Beam Driven Ion Cyclotron Waves in a Magnetized Plasma

arxiv:quant-ph/ v1 4 Apr 2006

Computational Solutions for the Korteweg devries Equation in Warm Plasma

A Model for Periodic Nonlinear Electric Field Structures in Space Plasmas

Dust density waves: ion flows and finite temperature effects

Ericson Lopez Quito Astronomical Observatory ( Ecuador) and STScI. MARLAM, September 27th, 2013

arxiv: v3 [physics.plasm-ph] 1 Jul 2017

Quasipotential Approach to Solitary Wave Solutions in Nonlinear Plasma

Self-gravitating Envelope Solitons in a Degenerate Quantum Plasma System

Laboratory studies of waves and instabilities in dusty plasmas*

ELECTROHYDRODYNAMICS IN DUSTY AND DIRTY PLASMAS

Waves and Instabilities in Dusty Plasmas

Electrostatic Nonplanar Positron-Acoustic Shock Waves in Superthermal Electron-Positron-Ion Plasmas

Author's personal copy

Dust Acoustic Compressive Waves in a Warm Dusty Plasma Having Non-Thermal Ions and Non-Isothermal Electrons

Measurements of the power spectrum and dispersion relation of self-excited dust-acoustic waves

Collisionless Shocks and the Earth s Bow Shock

13.1 Ion Acoustic Soliton and Shock Wave

Face-to-face interaction of multisolitons in spin-1/2 quantum plasma

Australian Journal of Physics

Anisotropic electron distribution functions and the transition between the Weibel and the whistler instabilities

Spin Stability of Aysmmetrically Charged Plasma Dust. I.H. Hutchinson. February 2004

K-dV and mk-dv equations for solitary waves in negative ion plasmas with non-maxwellian electrons

Collisions and transport phenomena

Simulation results for magnetized plasmas

Brazilian Journal of Physics ISSN: Sociedade Brasileira de Física Brasil

Stable Propagating Waves and Wake Fields in Relativistic Electromagnetic Plasma

Charging of particles in a plasma

Contribution of Non-thermal Electrons to Ion-acoustic Soliton Formation in Warm Positive and Negative Ions Plasma

Chapter 1. Introduction to Nonlinear Space Plasma Physics

Electromagneic Waves in a non- Maxwellian Dusty Plasma

Characteristic Behavior of Ion Acoustic Wave in A dusty Plasma

Localized modulated electrostatic wavepackets in space and dusty plasmas

ELECTROSTATIC ION-CYCLOTRON WAVES DRIVEN BY PARALLEL VELOCITY SHEAR

xkcd.com It IS about physics. It ALL is.

Head-on collisions of electrostatic solitons in nonthermal plasmas

Chapter 1 Introduction

Peristaltic Transport of a Hyperbolic Tangent Fluid Model in an Asymmetric Channel

Excitation of Ion Cyclotron Instability in. Inhomogeneous Rotating Dusty Plasma

Large-amplitude dust-ion acoustic solitary waves in a dusty plasma with nonthermal electrons

Faraday Transport in a Curved Space-Time

Particle simulation of two dimensional dust crystal formation in a mesothermal plasma flow

PLASMA ASTROPHYSICS. ElisaBete M. de Gouveia Dal Pino IAG-USP. NOTES: (references therein)

Dusty plasmas: Experiments on nonlinear dust acoustic waves, shocks, and structures

EFFECT OF CONCENTRATION OF NEGATIVE ION AND TEMPERATURE OF BOTH IONS ON AMPLITUDE AND WIDTH FOR NON-THERMAL PLASMA Sankar Chattopadhyay 1,

Space Physics. An Introduction to Plasmas and Particles in the Heliosphere and Magnetospheres. May-Britt Kallenrode. Springer

Research Article Propagation Characteristics of Oblique Incident Terahertz Wave in Nonuniform Dusty Plasma

Calculation of alpha particle redistribution in sawteeth using experimentally reconstructed displacement eigenfunctions

Series Solutions for the Peristaltic Flow of a Tangent Hyperbolic Fluid in a Uniform Inclined Tube

Characteristics of Positive Ions in the Sheath Region of Magnetized Collisional Electronegative Discharges

Equation for three dimensional nonlinear waves in liquid with gas bubbles

Generalizations of a nonlinear fluid model for void formation in dusty plasmas

Figure 1.1: Ionization and Recombination

Simulation Study of High-Frequency Magnetosonic Waves Excited by Energetic Ions in Association with Ion Cyclotron Emission )

Development of the Magnetized Dusty Plasma Experiment (MDPX)

Modulated envelope localized wavepackets associated with electrostatic plasma waves

arxiv: v1 [nlin.ps] 9 Apr 2016

Production of Secondary Cosmic Rays in Supernova Remnants

Plasma waves in the fluid picture I

xkcd.com It IS about physics. It ALL is.

International Workshop on the Frontiers of Modern Plasma Physics July 2008

Magnetohydrodynamic waves in a plasma

Yair Zarmi Physics Department & Jacob Blaustein Institutes for Desert Research Ben-Gurion University of the Negev Midreshet Ben-Gurion, Israel

Influence of Generalized (r, q) Distribution Function on Electrostatic Waves

1 Introduction. Commun. Theor. Phys. 63 (2015) Vol. 63, No. 6, June 1, B.C. Kalita 1, and R. Kalita 2,

Whistler oscillitons revisited: the role of charge neutrality?

Single particle motion and trapped particles

Simulations in Saturn s F Ring. Amy Anderson Austin College Sherman, TX. Faculty Mentor: Dr. Lorin Matthews Department of Physics Baylor University

MHD turbulence in the solar corona and solar wind

FINITE COULOMB CRYSTAL FORMATION

Existence Conditions for Stable Stationary Solitons of the Cubic-Quintic Complex Ginzburg-Landau Equation with a Viscosity Term

Nonlinear Waves, Solitons and Chaos

Long Wavelength Flow Analysis in a Curved Channel

Using controlling chaos technique to suppress self-modulation in a delayed feedback traveling wave tube oscillator

Modeling and Simulation of Plasma Based Applications in the Microwave and RF Frequency Range

Formation and dynamics of coherent structures involving phase-space vortices in plasmas

25 years of dust acoustic waves

Landau Bogolubov Energy Spectrum of Superconductors

Dust-acoustic waves in collisional dusty plasmas of planetary rings ABSTRACT

arxiv: v1 [physics.plasm-ph] 5 Aug 2012

Lecture 2. Introduction to plasma physics. Dr. Ashutosh Sharma

Titan s Atomic and Molecular Nitrogen Tori

Available at Appl. Appl. Math. ISSN:

Interaction of an Intense Electromagnetic Pulse with a Plasma

Energy Loss of a Test Charge in Dusty Plasmas: Collective and Individual Particle Contributions

Global existence for the ion dynamics in the Euler-Poisson equations

Transcription:

Shock Waves in a Dusty Plasma with Positive and Negative Dust where Ions are Non-Thermal Gurudas Mandal a and Prasanta Chatterjee b, a Department of ECE, East West University Mohakhali, Dhaka-, Bangladesh b Plasma Physics Laboratory, Department of Physics, University of Malaya, Malaysia On leave from the Department of Mathematics, Visva Bharati University, Santiniketan, India Reprint requests to G. M.; Fax: +880 88336; E-mail: gdmandal@ewubd.edu Z. Naturforsch. 65a, 85 90 (00); received March 3, 009 A four-component dusty plasma consisting of electrons, ions, and negatively as well as positively charged dust grains has been considered. Shock waves may exist in such a four-component dusty plasma. The basic characteristics of shock waves have been theoretically investigated by employing reductive perturbation technique (RPT). It is found that negative as well as positive shock potentials are present in such dusty plasma. The present results may be useful for understanding the existence of nonlinear potential structures that are observed in different regions of space (viz. cometary tails, lower and upper mesosphere, Jupiter s magnetosphere, interstellar media, etc). Key words: Dusty Plasma; Shock Waves; Non-Thermal; Dust Acoustic (DA) Wave.. Introduction The nonlinear behaviour of charged dust particles has received much attention in the recent years because of its vital role in understanding of electrostatic density perturbations and nonlinear potential structures which are observed in different regions of space environments, namely lower and upper mesosphere, cometary tails, planetary rings, planetary magnetosphere, interplanetary space, interstellar media, etc. [ 4]. Most of the dusty plasma studies have been confined in considering that the dust grains are negatively charged [5 ]. Very recent it has been found that there are some plasma systems, particularly in space plasma environment, where positively charged dust grains are present and also play a significant role [, 3,, 3]. There are three basic mechanisms by which the dust grains in the plasma system mentioned above can be positively charged [4]. These three mechanisms are the following: (i) photoemission in the presence of a flux of ultraviolet (UV) photons, (ii) thermionic emission induced by radiative heating, and (iii) secondary emission of electrons from the surface of the dust grains. Chow et al. [] have shown theoretically that due to the size effect on secondary emission insulating dust grains with different sizes in space plasmas can have the opposite polarity (smaller ones being positive and larger ones being negative). This is mainly due to the fact that the excited secondary electrons have shorter (longer) distance to travel to reach the surface of the smaller (larger) dust grains []. There are also direct evidences for the existence of both positively and negatively charged dust particles in different regions of space, viz. cometary tails [, 3, ], upper mesosphere [3], Jupiter s magnetosphere [5], etc. It has been suggested that the coexistence of positively and negatively charged dust are also present in laboratory plasmas [, 3, 6]. On basis of theoretical predictions and satellite observations, Mamun and Shukla [7] have considered a very simple dusty plasma system, which assumes positively and negatively charged dust particles only, and have theoretically investigated the properties of linear/nonlinear electrostatic waves that may propagate in such a dusty plasma system. This simple system is only valid if a complete depletion of background electrons and ions in the dusty plasma is considered. However, a complete depletion of background electrons and ions in most of the cases is not possible. Recently, Armina et al. [8] have considered a four-component dusty plasma containing positively and negatively charged dust and Boltzmann distributed electrons and ions. They have investigated the possibility for the formation of shock waves and also found the existence shock structures in this four-component dusty plasma. Recent observations [9, 0] show that the ion distribution does not follow a Boltzmann distribution and in 093 0784 / 0 / 000 0085 $ 06.00 c 00 Verlag der Zeitschrift für Naturforschung, Tübingen http://znaturforsch.com

86 G. Mandal and P. Chatterjee Shock Waves in Dusty Plasma these cases the non-thermal distribution of ions is suggested. In our present work, we considered a four-component unmagnetized dusty plasma system containing Boltzmann distributed electrons, non-thermal distributed ions, and also positively (smaller size) and negatively (larger size) charged dust grains. The manuscript is organized as follows: The basic equations governing the dusty plasma system are presented in Section. The nonlinear Burgers equation for the propagation of dust acoustic (DA) shock waves is derived in Section 3. The stationary shock wave solution of the Burgers equation is analyzed in Section 4. Finally, a brief discussion is presented in Section 5.. Governing Equations We consider a one-dimensional (D), unmagnetized collision less dusty plasma consisting of Boltzmann distributed electrons, non-thermal distributed ions, and positively and negatively charged dust grains. The nonlinear dynamics of DA waves is governed by n t u t + x (n u )=0, () u + u x = z e φ m x + η u I x, () n + t x (n u )=0, (3) u u + u t x = z e φ m x + η u II x, (4) n e n i + z n z n = 0, (5) where n (n ) is the negative (positive) dust number density, u (u ) is the negative (positive) dust fluid speed, z (z ) is the number of electrons (protons) residing on a negative (positive) dust particles, m (m ) is the mass of negative (positive) dust particle, e is the electronic charge, φ is the wave potential, η I (η II ) is the viscosity coefficient of negative (positive) dust fluid, x is the space variable, and t is the time variable. n e (n i ) is the electron (ion) number density: n e = n e0 e eφ k B Te, n i = n i0 [ + ( ) ( ) ] ( ) β eφ k B T i + β eφ k B T i e eφ k B Te, β = 4α +3α, α is the non-thermal parameter that determines the number of fast ions, T e( T i) is the temperature of electrons (ions), and k B is the Boltzmann constant. In (5) we have assumed the quasi-neutrality condition at equilibrium. Now, in terms of normalized variables, namely N = n n 0, N = n n 0, U = u C, U = u C, ψ = eφ k B T, T = i tω pd, X = x λ, η D = η I ω pd λ D, η = η II ω pd λ D,where n 0 (n 0 ) is equilibrium value of n (n ), C = z k B T i z k B T i. We can ex- 4πz e n 0 ω pd = 4πz e n 0 m,andλ D = press () (5) as m, N T + X (N U )=0, (6) U T +U U X = ψ X + η U X, (7) N T + X (N U )=0, (8) U T +U U ψ = αβ X X + η U X, (9) N =( + µ e µ i )N µ e e σψ + µ i ( + β ψ + β ψ )e ψ, (0) where α = z z, β = m σ = T i T e. m, µ e = 3. Derivation of Burgers Equation n e0 z n 0, µ i = n i0 z n 0,and Now, we derive the Burgers equation from (6) (0) by employing the reductive perturbation technique (RPT) and the stretch coordinates [] ξ = ε / (X T ), andτ = ε 3/ T,whereε is a smallness parameter measuring the weakness of the nonlinearity and is phase speed of the DA waves normalized by C.We now express (6) (0) in terms of ξ and τ as ε 3/ N ε / N + ε/ (N U )=0, () ε 3/ U ε / U + U ε/ U = / ψ ε + () U ε3/ η 0, ε 3/ N ε / N + ε/ (N U )=0, (3) ε 3/ U ε / U + ε/ U U = ε / αβ ψ + ε3/ η 0 U, (4)

G. Mandal and P. Chatterjee Shock Waves in Dusty Plasma 87 N =( + µ e µ i )N µ e e σψ + µ i ( + β ψ + β ψ )e ψ (5), where η = ε / η 0 and η = ε / η 0 are assumed [7]. We can expand the variables N, U, N, U,andψ in a power series of ε as N = + εn () + ε N () +..., (6) U = 0 + εu () + ε U () +..., (7) N = + εn () + ε N () +..., (8) U = 0 + εu () + ε U () +..., (9) ψ = 0 + εψ () + ε ψ () +... (0) Now, substituting (6) (0) into () (5) and taking the coefficient of ε 3/ from () (4) and ε from (5) we have = U (), () N () U () = ψ(), () = U (), (3) N () U () =(αβ) ψ(), (4) N () =(+ µ e µ i )N () µ e σψ () + µ i β ψ (). (5) Now, using () (5) we get N () = ψ(), (6) V 0 N () =(αβ) ψ() V0, (7) V0 = + αβ( + µ e µ i ). (8) σµ e µ i β (8) is the linear dispersion relation for the DA waves propagating in our dusty plasma system. Similarly, substituting (6) (0) into () (5) and equating the coefficient of ε 5/ from () (4) and ε from (5) one obtains N () N () () U + + [N() U () ]=0, (9) U () N () V U () 0 N () U () +U () U () () U + U () +U() αβ ψ() + η 0 = ψ() +η U () 0, (30) + [N() U () U () = U (), N () =( + µ e µ i )N () µ e σψ () ]=0, (3) (3) σ µ e [ψ () ] +µ i β ψ () +µ i β [ψ () ]. (33) Now, using (), (4), and (6) (8), and eliminating N (), N(), U (), U (),andψ (), we finally obtain ψ () + Aψ () ψ () = C ψ (), (34) where the nonlinear coefficient A and the dissipation coefficient C are given by A = 3α β (+µ e µ i ) 3 V0 4(σ µ e µ i β ), (35) [ + αβ( + µ e µ i )] η 0 + αβη 0 C = [ + αβ( + µ e µ i )]. (36) (34) is known as Burgers equation which can describe the nonlinear propagation of DA waves in our fourcomponent dusty plasma system. 4. Solution of Burgers Equation The stationary solution of this Burgers equation is obtained by transforming the independent variables ξ and τ to ζ = ξ U 0 τ and τ = τ,whereu 0 is a constant velocity normalized by C, and imposing the appropriate boundary conditions, viz. ψ () 0, ψ() 0, at ζ ζ. Thus, one can express the stationary solution of the Burgers equation as ψ () = ψ () m [ tanh(ζ/ )], (37) where the amplitude ψ m () (normalized by k B T i /e) and the width (normalized by λ D )aregivenby ψ () m = U 0 A, (38)

88 G. Mandal and P. Chatterjee Shock Waves in Dusty Plasma Fig.. A = 0(β vs. µ i ) curves for α = 0.0, σ = 0.5, µ e = 0. (solid curve), µ e = 0.3 (dottedcurve),µ e = 0.4 (dashed curve). Fig. 3. Negative shock potential profiles (ψ vs. ζ curves) for α = 0.0, σ = 0.5, µ i = 0.5, µ e = 0.3, η 0 = 0., η 0 = 0. β = 50 (solid curve), β = 40 (dotted curve), β = 30 (dashed curve). Fig.. Positive shock potential profiles (ψ vs. ζ curves) for α = 0.0, σ = 0.5, µ i = 0.5, µ e = 0.3, η 0 = 0., η 0 = 0. β = 400 (solid curve), β = 500 (dotted curve), β = 600 (dashed curve). = C. (39) U 0 It is observed from (37) (39) that the amplitude (width) of the shock waves increases (decreases) as U 0 increases. It is also clear from (35), (37), and (38) that shock potential profile is positive (negative) when A is positive (negative). To find the different range of values of β and µ i for which the positive and negative potential profiles exist, we obtain A = 0(β vs. µ i )curves. The A = 0(β vs. µ i ) curves are displayed in Figure. From these A = 0 curves, we can have positive (negative) shock potential profiles for the parameters whose values lie above (below) the curves. Fig. 4. Positive amplitude profiles (ψ m vs. µ i curves) for α = 0.0, σ = 0.5, β = 400, η 0 = 0., η 0 = 0., µ e = 0. (solid curve), µ e = 0.3 (dotted curve), µ e = 0.4 (dashed curve). Figure and Figure 3 show how positive and negative shock potentials vary with β. Figure shows the positive shock potential profile, where the potential decreases with the increase of β. Figure 3 shows the negative shock potential profile, where the potential decreases with decrease of β. Figure 4 and Figure 5 show the positive (negative) amplitude (ψ m )profilesof shock waves and how it varies with µ e. Figure 4, for the positive amplitude profile shows that the amplitude of the shock waves increases as µ e increases. Figure 5, for the negative amplitude profile shows that the amplitude of shock waves decreases as µ e increases. Figure 6 and Figure 7 show how the width of shock waves varies (β = 400 for Fig. 6 and β = 40 for Fig. 7) with µ e. For both the values of β, the width ( ) of shock waves always decreases as µ e increases.

G. Mandal and P. Chatterjee Shock Waves in Dusty Plasma 89 Fig. 5. Negative amplitude profiles (ψ m vs. µ i curves) for α = 0.0, σ = 0.5, β = 40, η 0 = 0., η 0 = 0., µ e = 0. (solid curve), µ e = 0.3 (dotted curve), µ e = 0.4 (dashed curve). Fig. 6. Width profile ( vs. µ i curves) for α = 0.0, σ = 0.5, β = 400, η 0 = 0., η 0 = 0., µ e = 0. (solid curve), µ e = 0.3(dottedcurve),µ e = 0.4 (dashed curve). 5. Discussion We have considered unmagnetized dusty plasma containing mobile positive and negative charged dust, Boltzmann electrons, and non-thermal distributed ions, and have theoretically investigated the basic features of the DA shock waves by employing the reductive perturbation technique (RPT). It has been found in (35) that if we consider there is no positive dust grains in the plasma system, i. e. z = 0, hence α = 0thenA is always negative. It indicates only the existence of negative shock potentials in the plasma system. We have then investigated the effect of coexistence of positive and negative dust grains, and we found that after certain values of α and β (which corresponds to the pres- Fig. 7. Width profile ( vs. µ i curves) for α = 0.0, σ = 0.5, β = 40, η 0 = 0., η 0 = 0., µ e = 0. (solid curve), µ e = 0.3 (dotted curve), µ e = 0.4 (dashed curve). ence of certain number of positive dust), one can have positive shock potential structures in the dusty plasma system. Armina et al. [8] found the similar result though they have considered the plasma system containing positive and negative dust grains, Boltzmann electrons and ions. The following features have been noticed in this theoretical investigation: (i) the amplitude of both the positive and negative shock potential structures increases with increasing of U 0, (ii) the width of both the positive and negative shock potential structures decreases with increasing of U 0, (iii) the positive and negative shock potentials are almost doubled when ion distribution is considered as non-thermal instead of Boltzmann ions [8], (iv) the potential of the positive shock structures decreases with increasing of β, (v) the potential of the negative shock structures increases with increasing of β, (vi) the amplitude and the width of the DA shock waves are positive for β = 400 and both are decreasing with increasing of µ e, (vii) the amplitude of the DA shock waves is negative for β = 40 and is increasing with increasing of µ e, and (viii) the width of the DA shock waves is also decreasing for β = 40 with increasing of µ e. It would be possible that the shock negative potential may trap positively charged dust particles which can attract dust particles of opposite polarity to form larger sized dust or to be coagulated into extremely large sized neutral dust in cometary tails, upper mesosphere, Jupiter s magnetosphere or even in laboratory experiments. The parameters chosen in our numerical calculations are completely relevant to different regions of

90 G. Mandal and P. Chatterjee Shock Waves in Dusty Plasma space, viz. cometary tails [, 3, ], mesosphere [3]; Jupiter s magnetosphere [5], etc. In conclusion, we stress that our theoretical investigation and results may also be applied to laboratory dusty plasma devices which will be able to produce a plasma containing positive and negative dust grains. [] M. Horanyi and D. A. Mendis, J. Geophys. Res. 9, 355 (986). [] D. A. Mendis and M. Rosenberg, Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 3, 49 (994). [3] M. Horanyi, Annu. Rev. Astron. Astrophys, 34, 383 (996). [4] P. K. Shukla and A. A. Mamun, Introduction to Dust Plasma Physics, IoP Publishing Ltd., Bristol 00. [5] N. N. Rao, P. K. Shukla, and M. Y. Yu, Planet. Space Sci. 38, 543 (990). [6] J. X. Ma and L. Liu, Phys. Plasmas 4, 53 (997). [7] A. A. Mamun, Phys. Scripta 57, 58 (998). [8] A. A. Mamun, Astrophys. Space Sci. 68, 443 (999). [9] A. A. Mamun and P. K. Shukla, Phys. Lett. A 90, 73 (00). [0] W. M. Moslem, Phys. Plasmas 0, 368 (003). [] J. K. Xue, Phys. Rev. E 69, 06403 (004). [] V. W. Chow., D. A. Mendis, and M. Rosenberg, J. Geophys. Res. 98, 9065 (993). [3] O. Havnes, J. Trøim, T. Blix, W. Mortensen, L. I. Naesheim, E. Thrane, and T. Tønnesen, J. Geophys. Res. 0, 039 (996). [4] V. E. Fortov, A. P. Nefedov, and O. S. Vaulina, J. Exp. Theor. Phys. 87, 087 (998). [5] M. Horanyi, G. E. Morfill, and E. Grtin, Nature 363, l44 (993). [6] D. A. Mendis and M. Horanyi, in Cometary Plasma Processes, AGU Monograph 6, 7 (99). [7] A. A. Mamun and P. K. Shukla, Geophys. Rev. Lett. 9, 870 (00). [8] R. Armina, A. A. Mamun, and S. M. K. Alam, Astrophys. Space Sci. 35, 43 (008). [9] R. Lundlin, A. Zakharov, R. Pelinenn, B. Hultqvist, H. Borg, E. M. Dubinin, S. Barabasj, N. Pissarenkon, H. Koskinen, and I. Liede, Nature 34, 609 (989). [0] Y. Futaana, S. Machida, Y. Saito, A. Matsuoka, and H. Hayakawa, J. Geophys. Res. 08, 5 (003). [] H. Washimi and T. Taniuti, Phys. Rev. Lett. 7, 996 (966).