Evaluation Document B

Similar documents
Annex (November 2007)

UNESCO Geopark Action. How to manage Geoparks!

ECONOMIC IMPACTS OF GEOTOURISM AND GEOPARKS IN CHINA

November 23, 2017 D-2

Sustainable development of the rural area in geoparks in Japan and other asian nations. Mahito Watanabe Geological Survey of Japan, AIST

Global Geoparks focus on developing their regions as Sustainable Tourism Destinations.

GEOCONSERVATION (GEOPARKS) CASE STUDY

Summary: This paper updates the Sub-committee on current thinking regarding the proposal for a Cotswolds Geopark

CHINESE GEOTOURISM AND GEOPARKS: SELECTED CASES

CLLD Cooperation OFFER

UNESCO Man and the Biosphere (MAB) Programme International Coordinating Council 29th Session, Paris, 12 to 15 June National Report of Japan

Briefing. H.E. Mr. Gyan Chandra Acharya

Role of Geotourism in Australia s Nature Based Tourism Strategy GlobalEco Angus M Robinson Geotourism Forum, Ecotourism Australia

GLOBAL GEOPARKS NETWORK

GENERAL RECOMMENDATIONS. Session 7. Breakout discussion. discuss on regional and interregional. proposals 1. COLLABORATION BETWEEN PROGRAMMES

Highland Environment Forum 6 th September, Lochaber Geopark: Community Action and Involvement

Marketing Australia s Scenic Areas SEGRA, 26 October Angus M Robinson Chair, GSA Geotourism Standing Committee

Model for Environmental Sustainability: A Case of Langkawi UNESCO Global Geopark

Unzen Volcanic Area Global Geopark Action Plan

GLOBAL NETWORK OF NATIONAL GEOPARKS. Patrick J Mc Keever

Grounds. (*) Arouca Declaration; International Congress of Geotourism, Arouca Geopark, Portugal, Nov

Declaration Population and culture

PART A Project summary

Geodiversity, Geoheritage & Geoconservation

PROMOTING NATURE CONSERVATION AND SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL DEVELOPMENT IN THE RURAL AREAS OF HONG KONG

China University of Geosciences, Beijing, China

Geotourism s Contribution to Protected Areas

Geoparks A powerful new development vehicle for regional Australia

Antelope Island State Park International Dark Sky Park Annual Report 2018

Earth heritage is underestimated. Earth Heritage Conservation. Geological tourism 2/1/2014

INTRODUCTION OF APPLICATION OF SE ORM FROM THE GLOBAL GEOPARKS NETW Title L VITALIZAITON PROJECT PREPERATIO ANAGEMENT

What is Geopark? Geopark? YES.

Outline of Japan Heritage Program

The 3rd International Intensive Course on UNESCO Global Geoparks Geoparks Management and Earth Heritage Interpretation

Chalenges in the creation and management of a Global Geopark

Towards a City Model for Heritage-Led Regeneration and Tourism Development

What is OneGeology in 2015?

REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS

Geopark Karavanke/Karawanken. Geo adventures in the cross- border geopark between Slovenia and Austria

COUNCIL OF THE EUROPEAN UNION. Brussels, 2 May /14 CULT 68

Developing a Global Guideline for Sustainable Tourism in Protected Areas: Input from Asia

GEOTOURISM, GEOPARKS and Porongorup

Transnational SWOT Analysis

Parrhasian Heritage Park Vision Plan

2018/1 The integration of statistical and geospatial information. The Regional Committee of UN-GGIM: Americas:

Background Document: Report of the Regional Committee of United Nations Global Geospatial Information Management for Asia and the Pacific

Australia Malaysia 2011 Oman. Books. Journals. Contents of Presentation Geotourism an emerging opportunity for Western Australia

Executive Board Hundred and ninety-fifth session

Report of the Regional Committee of UN-GGIM for Asia and the Pacific (UN-GGIM-AP)

M. Mikoš. Faculty of Civil and Geodetic Engineering, University of Ljubljana, Ljubljana, Slovenia

The National Spatial Strategy

United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization Executive Board

WELCOME & INTRODUCTION

CSA Global Geotourism Division

CAMP SLOVENIA. Mezek Slavko RRC Koper. Project coordinator November 2005

European Solar Days May Report Spain

Each State Party may propose a maximum of two properties, preferably relating to one cultural and one natural site.

EDUCATION DAYS RIO DE JANEIRO AUGUST 2018 I RIO DE JANEIRO, BRAZIL.

The international patterns of spatial planning system and choice of China. Cai yumei China land use planning and surveying institute (China, beijing)

TOWARDS STRATEGIC SPATIAL PLANNING IN JAMAICA: THE NATIONAL SPATIAL PLAN

High Level Training Course on. World Heritage under the framework of Digital Belt and Road. (02 September 17 September, 2017)

MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A CARPATHIAN INTEGRATED BIODIVERSITY INFORMATION SYSTEM

COLLABORATION OPPORTUNITIES ELLA TRAVEL - FITUR 2016

Local Development Pilot Project: Island of Cres. Ranka Saračević Würth, Ministry of Culture, Republic of Croatia

CEMAT results - over the years

Measure of Design Thinking-based Regional Innovation: Focusing on Gamcheon Culture Village

The ESPON Programme. Goals Main Results Future

The 26 th Session of the International Coordination Council of the Man and the Biosphere (MAB) Programme (10-13 June 2014 UNESCO) NATIONAL REPORT

EUROPEAN DIPLOMA-HOLDING AREAS AND THE GEOPARK INITIATIVE IN HUNGARY

ACTION PLAN FOR WORLD HERITAGE IN LATIN AMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN ( )

Cultural Routes of the Council of Europe - Glossary

International Intensive Course on Geoparks

Challenges and Potentials of Place Based Information Management in Nepal"

Economic and Social Council

Enrico Bertacchini, Department of Economics - University of Torino

Economic and Social Council

ANNEX II DRAFT PROPOSED OPERATIONAL GUIDELINES FOR UNESCO GLOBAL GEOPARKS

Sustainable tourism in for Sustaibale Danang

Urban-Rural Partnerships in Europe

Nepal (Countries & Cities Of The World) [Import] [Map]

Concept note. High-Level Seminar: Accelerating Sustainable Energy for All in Landlocked Developing Countries through Innovative Partnerships

the IRIS Consortium Collaborative, Multi-user Facilities for Research and Education Briefing NSF Business Systems Review September 9, 2008

Requests to Alberta Government Departments, Agencies, Boards and Commissions. April 1, 2010 March 31, 2011

NCAVES - Global initiative and national pilots

THE GLOBAL GEOPARKS NETWORK STATUTES

Nordic Council of Ministers Grant Programme for Nordic-Baltic Non-Governmental Organisations (NGO) Cooperation 2019 Estonia.

ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL COUNCIL 13 July 2007

FIG Asia Pacific Capacity Development Network

REPORT. To: Chair and Directors Date: April 23, 2018

Outline. Tourism A Viable Option for Abandoned Mines?

Regional stakeholders strategy of Donegal County Council

Presentation. Ms. Heidi Schroderus-Fox, Director, UN-OHRLLS

Sustainability Management of Unesco Global Geoparks Martina Pásková 1,a* and Josef Zelenka 2,b

NEPAL: FCPF READINESS GRANT FCPFR - FOREST CARBON PARTNERSHIP FACILITY

DRAFT PROGRAM Registration of participants, welcome coffee, exhibition tour

Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction (ABNJ) 2016 Regional Leaders Program. March 22 to April 1, 2016 United Nations, New York

Asia-Pacific Seminar on Geological Conservation and Sustainable Development 2008

The World Bank Local and Regional Competitiveness Project (P154263)

Community Engagement in Cultural Routes SiTI Higher Institute on Territorial Systems for Innovation Sara Levi Sacerdotti

16540/14 EE/cm 1 DG E 1A

Transcription:

1. Name of the Geopark 2. Date of revalidation Revalidation period Evaluation Document B Progress Evaluation Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark Four year Two year 2017 Updated: August 2017

Revalidation Overview Section Maximum Self-Awarded (Jan-17) Self-Awarded (revised,aug-17) I Contribution towards the Work of the GGN 320 235 280 II. Management Structure and Financial Status 160 160 160 III Conservation and Geoconservation Strategy 0 70 70 IV Strategic Partnerships 0 60 60 V Marketing and Promotional Activities after the Official Designation as a UNESCO Global Geopark 200 180 190 VI Sustainable Economic Development 120 90 90 Total 00 795 850

I. Contribution towards the Work of the Global Geoparks Network (GGN) Participation in Geopark conferences and networking events 1.0 (Award points for each meeting attended) Meetings Place Date Representatives Regional Geopark Conferences (i.e. European Geoparks Conference, Asian Pacific Geoparks Conference; Latin American Conference, etc.) 11th European Geoparks Conference Arouca Geopark 19-21.09.2012 Kazuhiro Yamamoto 12th European Geoparks Conference Cilento and Vallo di Diano Geopark 04-06.09.2013 Kazuhiro Nobe The 3rd Asia-Pacific Geoparks Network Jeju Island Geopark 09-11.09.2013 Ken Masutani The 4th Asia-Pacific Geoparks Network San'in Kaigan Geopark 16-20.09.2015 Kazuhiro Nobe International Geoparks Conference 6th International UNESCO Conference on Geoparks 7th International Conference on UNESCO Global Geoparks Stonehammer Geopark 19-22.09.2014 Kazuhiro Nobe English Riviera UNESCO Global Geopark 27-30.09.2016 Kazuhiro Nobe International Intensive Course on Geoparks International Geoparks Fair JGN Booth English Riviera UNESCO Global Geopark 27-30.09.2016 Kazuhiro Nobe Network Internal Meetings (i.e. GGN General Assembly, EGN / APGN Coordination Meetings, etc.) 6th International UNESCO Conference on Global Geoparks Stonehammer Geopark 22.09.2014 Kazuhiro Nobe 7th International Conference on UNESCO Global Geoparks English Riviera UNESCO Global Geopark 30.09.2016 Kazuhiro Nobe The 4th Asia-Pacific Geoparks Network San'in Kaigan Geopark 15.09.2015 Kazuhiro Nobe APGN Coordinators' Meeting English Riviera UNESCO Global Geopark 27.09.2016 Kazuhiro Nobe Explanation for any meetings missed. ( cannot exceed 0) 0 0 1.1 Participation in common projects (Award 30 points for each project) Common Project Position (leader, partner, observer) Japanese UNESCO Global Geoparks Magazine - 2017 Joint Publication: UNESCO Global Geoparks of Japan and China Projects utilzing Official Development Assistance for UNESCO Activities Leader 30 Partner 30 Leader 30 Comments - Details ( cannot exceed 60) 60 0 Japanese UNESCO Global Geoparks Magazine - 2017: A magazine introducing the eight UNESCO Global Geoparks of Japan, which was developed and printed by the Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark. Joint Publication: UNESCO Global Geoparks of Japan and China: A publication jointly developed by Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark and Hong Kong UNESCO Global Geopark. Projects utilizing ODA for UNESCO Activities: helped lead projects with three target countries in South East Asia using the 2016 ODA for UNESCO Activities.

1.2 Participation in common activities (Award 15 points for each activity) Common Activity Role UNESCO Global Geoparks Celebration Leader Forum 15 APGN Experience Sharing Week (14-21.12.2016) Leader of the Japanese delegation 15 Visit and Exchange Program - Chinese Geoparks Network to Japanese Partner 15 Comments - Details ( cannot exceed 80) 45 0 UNESCO Global Geoparks Celebration Forum: In November 2015, a new label 'UNESCO Global Geoparks' was officially created. To celebrate this, the 'UNESCO Global Geoparks Celebration Forum' was held alongside JGN country-wide workshops. APGN Experience Sharing Week: in order to encourage further international exchange within APGN region, an experience exchange took place in December 2016 between 7 Japanese Geoparks, including Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark and Hong Kong Geopark. Visit and Exchange Program - The first exchange visit between the CGN and JGN. Program took place over one week in three Japanese UNESCO Global Geoparks. 1.3 Participation in common communications (Award 15 points for each activity) Common Communication Role GGN Newsletter EGN Magazine No 9 (for EGN Members only) EGN Magazine No (for EGN Members only) EGN Magazine No 11 (for EGN Members only) EGN Magazine No 12 (for EGN Members only) Contributed to an article for the GGN website Submission of a manuscript 15 Contributed to an article for the EGN website Common leaflets Submission of a manuscript for the JGN leaflet 15 Common website Submission of a manuscript for the JGN website 15 Other Contribution to APGN 15 Other Contribution of an article to GEO ExPro Magazine 15 ( cannot exceed 80) 75 0 Comments - Details Total for Section I: Contribution towards the Work of the GGN ( cannot exceed 320) 280 0

II. Management Structure and Financial Status 2.0 Management structure This section reviews the management structure and legal status of the Geopark. Please provide a brief summary of how the management structure has changed since designation or after the last revalidation event. Description of management structure, organisation and legal status The 'Oki Islands Geopark Promotion Committee' is composed of Shimane Prefecture, the four municipal governments of the Oki Islands, tourism associations, economic organizations, transport companies, etc. After designation as a global geopark, the name of the committee changed to 'Oki Islands Global Geopark Promotion Committee', and after Global Geoparks were formally ratified by UNESCO as 'UNESCO Global Geoparks' the committee was renamed 'Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark Promotion Committee'. The number of organizations participating in planning within the committee increased from 43 to 45. Moreover, the number of staff working in the Head Office increased from 6 to 9 (as of December 2016). In addition, while the committee is currently a private organization mainly consisting of administrative bodies, there are plans to obtain a legal personality in 2019. 2.1 Management structure staff 2013 2014 2015 2016 Future prospects Scientific Staff (permanent) " (by contract) 1 1 2 2 Technical Staff (permanent) Plan to employ as permanent staff " (by contract) 1 1 1 2 Administrative Staff (permanent) 4 4 3 4 " (by contract) 1 Ranger (permanent) Plan to employ as permanent staff " (by contract) 2.2 Financial stability TOTAL 6 6 6 9 0 This section reviews the financial situation of the Geopark and its long term financial viability. Please provide a brief summary of how the financial status of the Geopark has changed since designation or after the last revalidation event. Description of financial status The geopark manages its own finances and has an independent budget. The main sources of capital are funds contributed by Shimane Prefecture and local municipalities of the Oki Islands (Okinoshima Town, Nishinoshima Town, Ama Town and Chibu Village). The expenses of the committee include contributions to UNESCO Global Geoparks Network and Japanese Geoparks Network, as well as administrative work (human resource development, spreading information, planning and publicity, etc) and research studies. Infratructure development such as the construction of walking trails, toilets, signboards, and so on is conducted using independent budgets of the Ministry of the Environment, Shimane Prefecture and the four municipalities of the Oki Islands. BUDGET INCOME EXPENDITURE BALANCE COMMENTS 2013 53,791,760 53,768,726 23,034 2014 60,439,147 60,400,465 38,682 2015 88,772,155 88,753,602 18,553 2016 118,641,000 118,641,000 0

2.3 Management structure and financial status Comments Geopark management structure (total score cannot exceed 50) Number of the committee members and staff of the Head Office has increased. There are plans for the Geopark Promotion Commitee to become a corporate body before April 2019. 50 Geopark financial status (total score cannot exceed 50) The budget of the committee is steadily increasing and there is a guarantee that it will not drop below the 2013 budget. 50 Significant policy changes since designation/last revalidation (total score cannot exceed 20) In order to ensure the sustainable management of the geopark, the Basic Plan and the Action Plan of the Geopark have been formulated. 20 Geopark staff number of new jobs created (total score cannot exceed 20) Three new staff members have been employed by the Head Office of the Promotion Committee. Moreover, there are 6 new corporate bodies which are partners of the Geopark. 20 Comments on the improvement of the financial stability of the Geopark since designation/last revalidation (total score cannot exceed 20) After designation as a Global Geopark the budget more than doubled. 20 ( cannot exceed 160) 160 0 Total for Section II: Management Structure and Financial Status ( cannot exceed 160) 160 0

III. Conservation and Geoconservation Strategy This section measures the success of conservation and geoconservation initiatives undertaken by the Geopark since designation or after the last revalidation event. 3.0 Conservation and geoconservation strategy Confirmation that geological material is not being sold by the Geopark partners Yes No Details Has the Geopark experienced any significant successes with regard to conservation issues? Geosites records are being created and geosites are being monitored. Has the Geopark experienced any significant problems with regard to conservation issues? No. 3.1 Number of sites conserved since designation/last revalidation Initiatives taken to improve the links between geodiversity and cultural, biological and other associated heritage Details Organization of Geopark events at cultural sites Organizing trial tours which include cultural sites. Inclusion of cultural sites in geological trails Inclusion of cultural sites, such as shrines where giant rocks and sacred trees are worshipped, as well as locations of festivals. Inclusion of sites of ecological interest in geological trails Interpretation boards with biological information and so on are being installed along the walking trails. Organization of nature observation events at geological sites Observation events take place every year e.g. near Yui Pond, which is a biologically diverse habitat.

3.2 Summary Comments Conservation and geoconservation Strategy (total score cannot exceed 50) Conservation and geoconservation strategy is described in the Basic Plan, which was formulated in 2016. In 2017, a detailed plan is to be completed. 20 Geological and cultural heritage (total score cannot exceed 50) Geological and cultural heritages are managed as geopark resources and actively utilized in geotourism. 50 Total ( cannot exceed 0) 70 0 Total for Section III: Conservation and Geoconservation Strategy ( cannot exceed 0) 70 0

IV. Strategic Partnerships 4.0 National partnerships (Award points for each partnership) Organisation Details The Shimane Nature Museum of Mt. Sanbe is a Museums member of the committee working group. Geological survey Universities University researchers are advisors to the committee. Tourism agencies Local tourism agancies are members of the committee. Collaboration with San'in Kaigan Geopark Co-operative ventures including stamp rally and sales of tourism products. Institutions Shimane Prefecture and municipalities of the Oki Islands are members of the committee. Conservation organisations Daisen-Oki National Park ( cannot exceed 60) 60 0 4.1 International partnerships (Award 20 points for each partnership (official partnership agreement required)) Organisation Details With other UNESCO Global Geoparks With international organisations (UNESCO, IUGS, Europarks, Eurosites etc ) 0 0 ( cannot exceed 40) 0 0 Total for Section VI: Strategic Parterships ( cannot exceed 0) 60 0

V. Marketing and Promotion of the Geopark after its Official Designation 5.0 Marketing and promotional activities This section measures the success of marketing and promotional activities undertaken by the Geopark since it was awarded UNESCO Global Geopark status. Press releases and copies of promotional materials should be provided as supporting evidence. Activity (Award points for each activity) Details Participants Conferences 1 2. 3. Seminars 1. Oki Islands Global Geopark Seminar 2. Guest seminars at Shimane University 3. Educational programmes 1. 'Oki Adventure Islands Programme' conducted in 2016 2. 3. A seminar organized in Tokyo aimed at visitors from the Tokyo metropolitan area Seminars organized at Shimane University about the Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark Tour introducing the appeal of the geopark, aimed at children from elementary schools in Shimane Prefecture around 40 around 0 Events (cultural festivals) 1. Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark Festival in 2016 2. Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark Festival in 2015 Organized in Matsue, aimed at visitors from Shimane Prefecture Organized in Matsue, aimed at visitors from Shimane Prefecture around 4,000 around 4,000 Organized in Osaka and Yokohama, 3. Montbell Friend Fair around,000 aimed at store members Participation in the development of tourism brochures 1. Guides Bleus Introduced as a three-star destination (the highest rank) 2. Lonely Planet Introduced as Oki Islands Global Geopark 3. Oki Raku A brochure published by Oki Tourism Association ( cannot exceed 60) 60 0 Please provide details on any successes or problems encountered with regard to the activities outlined above. The logo mark of Oki UNESCO Global Geopark is utilized in sightseeing brochures and tourism products, etc. sold by travel agencies. Moreover, information about Oki Islands and the geopark has been published in foreign guidebooks such as Guides Bleus or Lonely Planet. Because of those reasons, there has been an increase in overall visitors' numbers by 7 thousand compared to the previos year, and an increase in foreign visitors' numbers by around 290. Furthermore, since 2015 the name of Oki Airport, which serves as one of the entrances to the Oki Geopark, is also called 'Oki Global Geopark Airport'.

Publications 5.1 (Award points for each publication) Papers (author, date, title, journal) 1. Brenna. et. al., A Trachyte Syenite Core within a Basaltic Nest: Filtering of Primitive Injections by a Stepwise Magma Plumbing System (Oki Dōzen, South West Japan), Contributions to Mineralogy and Petrology, vol. 170 (Aug 2015), article id: 22,21. 2. Matsubara et al., Miocene Mollusca from the Ichibu Formation on Nishinoshima Island, Oki Islands, Southwest Japan, Paleontological Research no. 18 (2014): 6-32. 3. Kusano et al., Occurrence of Old Groundwater in a Volcanic Island on a Continental Shelf. An Example from Nakano-shima Island, Oki-Dozen, Japan, Journal of Hydrology, no. 511 (2014): 295-309. Publications (books, magazines, leaflets) (author, date, title, journal) 1. Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark (a comic book, Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark Promotion Committee,.2016.) 2. UNESCO Global Geoparks of Japan 2017 (a magazine to introduce Japanese Global Geoparks, 4.2016) 3. Adventure Japan, Oki Islands Geopark (leaflet introducing the Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark in English, Japanese and Thai) Media presentation (CD, DVD, TV or radio programmes) 1. Oki Global Geopark promotional DVD 2. The story hidden in landscape. Geohistory of the coasts. (DVD) 3. BSS Radio Please do not send publications (these should be provided only to field evaluators) ( cannot exceed 40) 40 0 5.2 Infrastructure This section highlights improvements to the infrastructure of the Geopark since it was awarded UNESCO Global Geopark status or since the last revalidation exercise. Infrastructure (Award points for each new or improved infrastructure) New Infrastructure Improvement of existing Infrastructure Museum New panels and displays Visitor centre Path or trails Information panels Other 5.3 Monitoring ( cannot exceed 50) Improvement of exhibition materials Repairs of walking trails and maintenance of information signs Improvement of contents, ulitizing GGN and UGGN logo marks Installing banners welcoming visitors to Oki Islands UNESCO Global Geopark in ferry terminals and airport 50 0 This section highlights the methods used for evaluating and improving the quality and standards of interpretation material and public awareness programmes implemented by the Geopark. Monitoring (Award points for each type of monitoring adopted) Do you conduct visitor surveys in the Geopark? Do you gather qualitative as well as quantitative data? Do you evaluate users responses to new developments in the Geopark Do 75% or more, of your visitors regard your infrastructure and services as being good or excellent 0

Do 75% or more, of your visitors regard your events or activities as being good or excellent ( cannot exceed 50) 40 0 Total for Section V: Marketing and Promotion of the Geopark after its Official Designation ( cannot exceed 200) 190 0

VI. Sustainable Economic Development This section highlights the both the positive and negative impacts of UNESCO Global Geopark status to the region and how UNESCO Global Geopark status has contributed towards sustainable economic development Impact Positive Negative 1. Regional Economy Agriculture Livestock farming Forestry maximum cannot exceed 30 Agriculture: utilizing the geopark label in branding. Forestry: developing energy from woody biomass as a part of environmental conservation. 20 2. Tourism Development 62.Tourism Development Tourist agencies Restaurants Accommodation maximum cannot exceed 30 Tourist agencies: sales of tourism products utilizing geopark brand. Restaurants and accommodation: due to an increase in nonresident population and foreign visitor numbers, the numbers of customers in restaurants and accomodations have increased. 30 3. Geotouristic Products Handicrafts Geological replicas Local products maximum cannot exceed 30 Production and sale of packages utilizing the geopark logo mark. The committee currently endeavours to raise the quality of these products by creating a geopark-product certification system. 4. Employment New permanent positions New temporary positions New enterprises Others maximum cannot exceed 30 New temporary positions: 1 new staff member has been employed in the Head Office of the committee. New enterprises: in order to improve systems to accommodate tourists sustainably, a private organization providing geopark guide services has employed 4 new staff members. Others: in order to expand business related to the geopark, Oki Shizen Mura, N.P.O., an organization related to the committee, has employed 2 new staff. 30 COMMENTS DETAILS: ( cannot exceed 120) 90 0 Total for Section VI: Sustainable Economic Development ( cannot exceed 120) 90 0