Bianchi Type-VI Bulk Viscous Fluid String Cosmological Model in General Relativity

Similar documents
International Journal of Applied and Universal Research E-ISSN No: Volume III, Issue V, Sept-Oct Available online at:

Bianchi Type V Magnetized String Dust Universe with Variable Magnetic Permeability

International Journal of Applied and Universal Research ISSN No: Volume III, Issue II, Mar-Apr Available online at:

Bianchi Type-III Inflationary Universe with Constant Deceleration Parameter in General Relativity

A Magnetized Kantowski-Sachs Inflationary Universe in General Relativity

STRING COSMOLOGICAL MODELS IN BIANCHI TYPE-III SPACE-TIME WITH BULK VISCOSITY AND Λ TERM

Bianchi-IX string cosmological model in Lyra geometry

Bianchi Type-VI0Dark Energy Cosmological Models in General Relativity

Bianchi Type VI0 Inflationary Universe with Constant Deceleration Parameter and Flat Potential in General Relativity

LRS Bianchi Type I Cosmological Model with Bulk Viscosity in Lyra Geometry

String Fluid Cosmological Model with Magnetic Field in Bimetric Theory of Gravitation

Hypersurface-homogeneous Universe filled with perfect fluid in f(r, T) theory of gravity

NEW EXACT SOLUTION OF BIANCHI TYPE V COSMOLOGICAL STIFF FLUID MODEL IN LYRA S GEOMETRY

SOME LRS BIANCHI TYPE-I COSMOLOGICAL MODELS WITH ZERO-MASS SCALAR FIELD

A higher-dimensional Bianchi type-i inflationary Universe in general relativity

Research Article LRS Bianchi Type II Massive String Cosmological Models with Magnetic Field in Lyra s Geometry

Bianchi Type-VI Inflationary Universe in General Relativity

Dynamics of Bianchi type-vi 0 holographic dark energy models in general relativity and Lyra s geometry

Locally-rotationally-symmetric Bianchi type-v cosmology in general relativity

Anisotropic Bianchi Type-I Magnetized String Cosmological Models with Decaying Vacuum Energy Density Λ(t)

Magnetized Anisotropic Bianchi Type-VI Cosmological Model Containing Dark Energy

Some LRS Bianchi Type VI 0 Cosmological Models with Special Free Gravitational Fields

PLANE SYMMETRIC UNIVERSE WITH COSMIC STRING AND BULK VISCOSITY IN SCALAR TENSOR THEORY OF GRAVITATION 1. INTRODUCTION

Bianchi Type VIII Inflationary Universe with Massless Scalar Field in General Relativity

arxiv:gr-qc/ v3 21 Jul 2006

Bianchi Type IX Magnetized Bulk Viscous String Cosmological Model in General Relativity

Cosmic Strings in Dilaton Gravity and in Brans-Dicke Theory

Non-static local string in Brans Dicke theory

Research Article Axially Symmetric Bulk Viscous String Cosmological Models in GR and Brans-Dicke Theory of Gravitation

Research Article Bianchi Types II, VIII, and IX String Cosmological Models with Bulk Viscosity in a Theory of Gravitation

Hypersurface-homogeneous cosmological models with anisotropic dark energy in Saez Ballester theory of gravitation

Anisotropic Dark Energy Bianchi Type III Cosmological Models in Brans Dicke Theory of Gravity

New Non-Diagonal Singularity-Free Cosmological Perfect-Fluid Solution

The Einstein field equations

arxiv:gr-qc/ v1 9 Mar 2000

Inflationary Universe Scenario in Bianchi Type VI 0 Space Time with Flat Potential and Bulk Viscosity in General Relativity

Bianchi Type-IX Bulk Viscous String Cosmological Model in f(r,t) Gravity with Special Form of Deceleration Parameter

Electromagnetic spikes

Addendum: Symmetries of the. energy-momentum tensor

Anisotropic Lyra cosmology

The Hubble Constant and the Deceleration Parameter in Anisotropic Cosmological Spaces of Petrov type D

Geometrical Behaviuors of LRS Bianchi Type-I Cosmological Model

Uniformity of the Universe

INFLATIONARY SOLUTIONS OF BIANCHI TYPE I STRING MODELS WITH BULK VISCOUS FLUID IN BIMETRIC THEORY OF GRAVITATION

Classical and Quantum Bianchi type I cosmology in K-essence theory

FRW UNIVERSE WITH VARIABLE G AND Λ TERM IN f(r,t ) GRAVITY

Exact Solution of an Ekpyrotic Fluid and a Primordial Magnetic Field in an Anisotropic Cosmological Space-Time of Petrov D

Hypersurface Homogeneous Space Time with Anisotropic Dark Energy in Brans Dicke Theory of Gravitation

Chapter 9. Perturbations in the Universe

On the Geometry of Planar Domain Walls. F. M. Paiva and Anzhong Wang y. Abstract. The Geometry of planar domain walls is studied.

PHYM432 Relativity and Cosmology 17. Cosmology Robertson Walker Metric

More on the analogy between disclinations and cosmic strings

Viscosity Effects on Anisotropic Universe in Curvature-Matter Coupling Gravity

Examining the Viability of Phantom Dark Energy

Graceful exit from inflation for minimally coupled Bianchi A scalar field models

Lecture 1 General relativity and cosmology. Kerson Huang MIT & IAS, NTU

Theoretical Models of the Brans-Dicke Parameter for Time Independent Deceleration Parameters

MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY Physics Department Physics 8.286: The Early Universe October 27, 2013 Prof. Alan Guth PROBLEM SET 6

Astr 2320 Tues. May 2, 2017 Today s Topics Chapter 23: Cosmology: The Big Bang and Beyond Introduction Newtonian Cosmology Solutions to Einstein s

Curved Spacetime III Einstein's field equations

arxiv: v1 [gr-qc] 22 Jul 2015

arxiv:gr-qc/ v1 20 May 2005

New Blackhole Theorem and its Applications to Cosmology and Astrophysics

Dynamics of a Charged Spherically Symmetric Thick Shell

SELF-SIMILAR PERFECT FLUIDS

BianchiTypeVICosmologicalModelwithQuadraticformofTimeDependentTerminGeneralRelativity

Canadian Journal of Physics. Anisotropic solution in phantom cosmology via Noether symmetry approach

Some Bianchi Type Cosmological Models in f(r) Gravity

arxiv: v1 [gr-qc] 18 Dec 2007

2.1 Basics of the Relativistic Cosmology: Global Geometry and the Dynamics of the Universe Part I

Big Rip Singularity in 5D Viscous Cosmology

arxiv: v2 [gr-qc] 27 Apr 2013

Modified generalized Chaplygin gas model in Bianchi type-v space-time geometry with dynamical G and

arxiv: v2 [gr-qc] 1 Oct 2009

arxiv:gr-qc/ v1 9 Aug 2006

Nature of Singularities in (n+2)-dimensional Gravitational Collapse of Vaidya Space-time in presence of monopole field.

SOME EXACT BIANCHI TYPE-I COSMOLOGICAL MODELS IN SCALAR-TENSOR THEORY OF GRAVITATION WITH TIME DEPENDENT DECELERATION PARAMETER

arxiv: v1 [gr-qc] 4 Dec 2007

Are naked singularities forbidden by the second law of thermodynamics?

Steady-State Cosmology in the Yilmaz Theory of Gravitation

arxiv: v1 [gr-qc] 3 Aug 2017

Number-Flux Vector and Stress-Energy Tensor

General Relativity and Cosmology Mock exam

4 Evolution of density perturbations

Non Linear Dynamics in Einstein-Friedman Equations

IoP. An Introduction to the Science of Cosmology. Derek Raine. Ted Thomas. Series in Astronomy and Astrophysics

Cosmic Strings. May 2, Safa Motesharrei University of Maryland

QGP, Hydrodynamics and the AdS/CFT correspondence

Gravitational collapse and the vacuum energy

Thermodynamics and emergent universe

BIANCHI TYPE-III COSMOLOGICAL MODEL WITH VARIABLE G AND Λ-TERM IN GENERAL RELATIVITY

Examining the Viability of Phantom Dark Energy

General relativity and the Einstein equations

Curved spacetime tells matter how to move

5.5 Energy-momentum tensor

arxiv:gr-qc/ v1 2 Apr 2002

COSMIC STRINGS AND ANISOTROPIC UNIVERSE

Gravitation: Cosmology

arxiv:gr-qc/ v1 25 Jan 1997

Relic Gravitons, Dominant Energy Condition and Bulk Viscous Stresses

Transcription:

Bulg. J. Phys. 38 2011 14 14 Bianchi Type-VI Bulk Viscous Fluid String Cosmological Model in General Relativity S.P. Kandalkar 1, P.P. Khade 2, S.P. Gawande 1 1 Department of Mathematics, Government Vidarbha Institute of Science and Humanities, Amravati 444604, India 2 Department of Mathematics, Vidyabharati Mahavidyalaya, Amravati 444603, India Received 19 February 2011 Abstract. We investigate the integrability of cosmic string of Bianchi type-vi space-time in presence of bulk viscous fluid by applying a new technique. The behavior of the model is reduced to the solution of single second order nonlinear differential equation. We show that this equation admits an infinite family of solutions. The physical implications of these results are also discussed. PACS codes: 04.20.-q 1 Introduction In recent years there has been considerable interest in string cosmology. Cosmic strings are topologically stable objects which might be found during a phase transition in the early universe Kibble [1]. Cosmic string plays an important role in the study of the early universe. This arises during the phase transition after the big bang explosion as the temperature goes down below some critical temperature as predicted by grand unified theories Zel dovich et al. [2]; Kibble [1,3]; Everett [4]; Vilenkin []. It is believed that cosmic strings give rise to density perturbations which lead to the formation of galaxies Zel dovich [6]. These cosmic strings have stress energy and coupled to the gravitational field. There it is interesting to study the gravitational effects that arise from strings. The general relativistic treatment of strings was initiated by Letelier [7,8] and Stachel [9]. Letelier [7] has obtained the solution of Einstein s field equations for a cloud of strings with spherical, plane and cylindrical symmetry. Then in 1983, he solved Einstein s field equations for a cloud of massive strings and obtained cosmological models in Bianchi type-i and Kantowski-Sachs space-times. Banerjee et al. [10] have investigated an axially symmetric Bianchi type-i string dust cosmological models with a magnetic field discussed also by Chakraborty 1310 017 c 2011 Heron Press Ltd. 14

Bianchi Type-VI Bulk Viscous Fluid String Cosmological Model [11], Tikekar and Patel [12]. Patel and Maharaj [13] investigated stationary rotating world model with magnetic field. Ram and Singh [14] obtained some new exact solutions of string cosmology with and without a source free magnetic field for a Bianchi type-i space-time in different basic form considered by Carmaniti and McIntosh [1]. Exact solutions of string cosmology for Bianchi type-ii, VI 0, VIII and IX space-time have been studied by Krori et al. [16] and Wang [17]. On the other hand, the matter distribution is satisfactorily described by perfect fluids due to the large scale distribution of galaxies in our universe. However, a realistic treatment of the problem requires the consideration of material distribution other than the perfect fluid. It is well-known that when neutrino decoupling occurs, the matter behaves as a viscous fluid in an early stage of universe. Viscous fluid cosmological models of early universe have been widely discussed in the literature. Recently Yadav et al. [18] have studied some Bianchi type string cosmological model with bulk viscosity. Motivated by the situation discussed above, in this paper we focus on the problem establishing formalism for studying the new integrability of cosmic strings in Bianchi type-vi space-time in the presence of bulk viscous fluid by applying new technique. 2 Metric and Field Equations We consider the space-time of general Bianchi type-vi with the metric ds 2 = dt 2 + A 2 dx 2 + B 2 exp 2qxdy 2 + C 2 exp2qxdz 2, 1 where q is a constant. A, B, C are functions of t. The energy momentum tensor for a cloud of string dust with a bulk viscous fluid of string is given by Letelier and Landau Lifchitz T j i = ρu iu j λx i x j u i ; ig j i + u iu j, 2 where u i and x i satisfy condition u i u i = x i x i = 1, u i x i =0. 3 In 2 ρ is the proper energy density for a cloud of string with particles attached to them, λ is the string tension density, u i is the four velocities of the particles and x i is a unit space-like vector representing the direction of string. If the particle density of the configuration is denoted by ρ p, then we have ρ = ρ p + λ. 4 The Einstein field equations in gravitational units c =1, G =1read as 146 R j i 1 2 Rgj i = 8πT j i,

S.P. Kandalkar, P.P. Khade, S.P. Gawande where R j i is the Ricci tensor; R = gij R ij is the Ricci scalar. In a co-moving coordinate system, we have u i =0, 0, 0, 1. 6 The field equations with 2 subsequently lead to the following system of equations: B B + C C + ḂĊ BC + q2 =8πθ, A2 7 Ä A + C C + AĊ AC q2 =8πθ, A2 8 Ä A + B B + ȦḂ AB q2 =8πθ + λ, A2 9 ȦḂ AB + ḂĊ BC + ȦĊ AC q2 =8πρ, A2 10 Ḃ B Ċ =0, C 11 where over the symbols A, B, C denotes ordinary differentiation with respect to t. The particle density ρ p is given by 8πρ p = ḂĊ BC +2ȦĊ AC B B + C C q2 A 2 12 in accordance with equation 4. The velocity field u i specified by 6 is irrotational, the scalar expansion θ and components of shear σ ij are given by θ = Ȧ A + Ḃ B + Ċ 2 A A Ḃ B Ċ C σ 11 = A2 3 σ 22 = B2 exp 2qx C, 13, 14 2Ḃ 3 B Ȧ A Ċ, 1 C σ 33 = C2 exp2qx 2Ċ 3 C Ȧ A Ḃ, 16 B σ 44 =0. 17 Therefore, σ 2 = 1 Ȧ 2 3 A 2 + Ḃ2 B 2 + Ċ2 C 2 ȦḂ AB ḂĊ BC AĊ. 18 AC 147

Bianchi Type-VI Bulk Viscous Fluid String Cosmological Model 3 Solutions of the Field Equations The field equations 7-11 are a system of five equations with six unknown parameters A, B, C, ρ, λ and. One additional constraint relating to these parameters is required to obtain explicit solutions of the system. We assume that the expansion θ in the model is proportional to the eigenvalue σ 3 3 of the shear tensor σ j i. This condition leads to C = αab β, 19 where α and β are arbitrary constants. Equation 11 leads to B = mc, 20 where m is an integrating constant. From 19 and 20, we obtain C = MA N, 21 where M = α 1 / 1 β m β / 1 β, N = β 1 β. 22 By the use of 20 field equations 9-10 reduce to Ä A + C C + ȦĊ AC q2 =8πλ + θ. A2 23 AĊ 2 AC + Ċ2 C q2 =8πρ. A2 24 Equations 7 and 8, together with the use of 13 and 21, lead to 3N +1Ä A +N 2 2NȦ2 A =16π2N +1 A2 A. 2 Let us consider Ȧ = fa. 26 Using 26 in 2, we get df { N 2 da + 2N 1 2N +1 f =16π. 27 3N +1 A} 3N +1 After integration, 27 reduces to 148 f =16π 2N +1 N 2 + N +1 A + A P N 2 2N 3N+1 «, 28

S.P. Kandalkar, P.P. Khade, S.P. Gawande where P is an integrating constant. Integrating 28, we obtain A = 1 [k k4 1 + k 2 expk 3 t] k4, 29 where S is an integrating constant. Therefore where C = M [k k 1 + k 2 expk 3 t] k, 30 B = mm [k k 1 + k 2 expk 3 t] k, 31 k 1 = P N 2 +N +1, 16π2N +1 k 2 = S, 16π2N +1 32 k 3 =, 3N +1 3N +1 k 4 = N 2 +N +1. Hence the metric 1 reduces to the form ds 2 = dt 2 k1 + k 2 expk 3 t 2k4dx 2 + +exp 2qxm 2 M 2 k 1 + k 2 expk 3 t 2kdy 2 +exp2qxm 2 k 1 + k 2 expk 3 t 2kdz 2. 33 Using the suitable transformation k1 + k 2 expk 3 t = L sinτ, L k4 x = X, 34 mml k y = Y, ML k z = Z, the metric 33 reduces to ds 2 L cosτ 2dτ sinτ 2k4dX = 2 2 + k 3 k 1 L sinτ +exp 2qX sinτ 2kdY 2qX sinτ 2kdZ 2 +exp 2. 3 L k4 L k4 149

Bianchi Type-VI Bulk Viscous Fluid String Cosmological Model The rest energy ρ, the string tension density λ, the particle density ρ p, expansion θ and shear σ for the model 3 are given by 8πρ = k3k 2 k 1 2 2k 4 + k q 2 2k4. 36 L sinτ L sinτ k 1 8πλ = 8πk 3 k 4 +2k + k3k 2 4 2 + k 4 k + k 2 L sinτ k 1 L sinτ + k3k 2 2 1 k 4 +k L sinτ k 1 2 L sin 2 q 2 2k4, 37 τ L sinτ 8πρ p = k3k 2 k 1 2 4 k k 4 L sinτ [ + 8πk 3 k 4 +2k k3k 2 ] k 1 1 k 4 +k, 38 L sinτ L sinτ σ1 1 = 2 3 k k 1 3k 4 k, 39 L sinτ σ2 2 = σ3 3 = 1 3 k k 1 3k k 4, 40 L sinτ σ4 4 =0, 41 σ 2 = 1 [ k 1 ] 2, k 3 k k 4 42 3 L sinτ k 1 θ = k 3 k 4 +2k. 43 L sinτ From 36 and 38, we observe the energy conditions ρ 0 and ρ p 0 are fulfilled provided k 2k 4 + k 2 k 1 2 q 2 L sinτ k 3 L sinτ 2k4 and k3k 2 k 1 2 4 k k 4 L sinτ [ k3k 2 ] 1 k 4 + k L sinτ 8πk k 1 3k 4 +2k, L sinτ respectively. From 37, we observe that the string tension density λ>0provided 10

S.P. Kandalkar, P.P. Khade, S.P. Gawande 2 k3k 2 4 2 + k 4 k + k 2 k 1 L sinτ + k3k 2 2 1 k 4 + k L sinτ k 1 2 L sin 2 τ >q 2 2k4 k 1 +8πk3 k 4 +2k. L sinτ L sinτ The model 3 represents an expanding universe when sinτ >k 1 /L. When sinτ <k 1 /L, then θ decreases with time. Therefore the model describes a shearing non-rotating expanding universe without big bang start. We can see from above discussion that the bulk viscosity plays a significant role in the evolution of the universe. σ Furthermore, since lim 0, the model does not approach isotropy for large T θ value of τ. However, if sinτ =k 1 /L, the model 3 represents an isotropic model in presence of bulk viscosity. In absence of bulk viscosity, when 0, the metric 3 reduces to L 2dτ ds 2 = 2 + τ 2k4 dx 2 +exp 2qX τ 2k dy 2 k 1 k 3 L k4 2qX +exp τ 2k dz 2. 44 L k4 The physical parameters ρ, λ, ρ p and the kinematical parameters θ, σ 2 for this model are respectively given by k1 k 2k 3 8πρ = 2k 4 + k q2, 4 2k4 Lτ Lτ k1 k 3 2k 2 8πλ = Lτ 4 + k 4 k + k 4 + k 2 + k q2, 46 2k4 Lτ k1 k 2k4 3 8πρ p = k k 4 +1+k, 47 Lτ σ1 1 = 2 k 1 k 3 k k 4, 48 3 Lτ σ2 2 = σ3 3 = k 1k 3 k 4 k, 49 3Lτ.σ4 4 =0, 0 σ 2 = 1 [ k1 k 3 k 4 k ] 2, 1 3 Lτ θ = k 1k 3 k 4 +2k. 2 Lτ From 4 and 47, we observe that the energy conditions ρ 0, and ρ p 0, 11

Bianchi Type-VI Bulk Viscous Fluid String Cosmological Model are fulfilled provided k 2k 4 + k Lτ 2k4 1 1 k 1 k 3 2, k k 4 1. Respectively, from 46, we observe that the string tension density λ 0, provided q 2. k4 2 + k 4 k + k 4 + k 2 + k Lτ 2k4 1 k 1 k 3 In absence of bulk viscosity, the model 44 starts expanding with a big bang at τ =0and the expansion in the model decreases as time increases. When τ then shear is zero. Near the singularity τ =0, the physical parameters σ ρ, λ, ρ p are infinite, if k 4 < 0. Also, since lim 0, the model does not T θ approach isotropy for large value of τ. 4 Another Model In general is not constant throughout the fluid so that cannot be taken always constant, especially when the universe is expanding. Since in general, depends on temperature T and pressure p it is reasonable to consider as a function of t. In this case 2 after integration, leads to [ k4, A = htdt] 1 3 where ht =c 0 exp k 3 t dt. 4 And b 0, c 0 are constants of integration. Therefore, we obtain [ k, C = M htdt] 1 [ k. B = mm htdt] 1 6 Hence, in this case, the metric 1 reduces to [ ds 2 = dt 2 + 1 ] 2k4dx 2 htdt +exp 2qxmM 2[ 1 + M 2[ 1 ] 2kdy 2 htdt htdt] 2k exp2qxdz 2. 7 12

S.P. Kandalkar, P.P. Khade, S.P. Gawande The physical parameters ρ, λ, ρ p and the kinematical parameters θ, σ 2 for this model are respectively given by 8πρ = k 2+ k [ ht ] 2 [ k 4 k 4 q 2 2k4, htdt] 1 8 htdt 8πλ = q 2[ ] b 0 +k4 1 2k4 htdt 8πt 1+ 2k [ ht ] k 4 b 0 +k4 htdt [ + 1+ k ][ + k2 ht ] k 4 k4 2 htdt + 1+ k [ b 0 + k 4 htdt k 3 tht k4 1 h2 t] k 4 2, 9 htdt 8πρ p = θ = b 0 + k 1 4 [ 8πt 1+ 2k 1 k2 k 4 k4 2 k [ ht ] 2 k 4 htdt + k k 4 2+ k 1+ k [ k 4 1+ 2k [ k 4 ][ ht ] k 4 htdt 1 htdt k 3 tht k4 1 h2 t] 2, 60 htdt b 0 + k 1 4 ht ], 61 htdt σ1 1 = 2 1 k [ ht 3 k 4 ], 62 htdt σ2 2 = σ3 3 = 1 k [ ht 1 3 k 4 ], 63 htdt σ4 4 =0, 64 σ 2 = 1 [ 1+ k2 3 k4 2 2k ][ h 2 t ] k 4 2. 6 htdt Conclusion We have presented a new class of Bianchi type-vi string cosmological models in the presence and absence of bulk viscosity. In our solution, we have obtained a relation between metric coefficients from our field equation in a natural way. In Section 4, we have obtained a general solution that has a rich structure and admits many number of solutions by suitable choice of function t. Here the choice of t is quit arbitrary but since we look for physically viable models of the universe, one can choose t, such that 4 is integrable. 13

Bianchi Type-VI Bulk Viscous Fluid String Cosmological Model It is observed that the bulk viscosity plays significant role in the evolution of the universe. In presence of bulk viscosity the model represents an expanding, shearing and non-rotating universe without the big bang start. But, in absence of bulk viscosity, the model starts expanding with a big bang at τ =0. References [1] T.W.B. Kibble 1976 J. Phys. A Math. Gen. 9 1387. [2] Ya.B. Zel dovich, I.Yu. Kobzarev, L.B. Okun 197 Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 67 3.; Ya.B. Zel dovich, I.Yu. Kobzarev, L.B. Okun 197 Sov. Phys. JETP 40 1. [3] T.W.B. Kibble 1980 Phys. Rep. 67 183. [4] A.E. Everett 1981 Phys. Rev. 24 88. [] A. Vilenkin 1981 Phys. Rev. D 24 2082. [6] Ya.B. Zel dovich 1980 Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 192 663. [7] P.S. Letelier 1979 Phys. Rev. D 20 1249. [8] P.S. Letelier 1983 Phys. Rev. D 28 2414. [9] J. Stachel 1980 Phys. Rev. D 21 2171. [10] A. Banerjee, A.K. Sanyal, S. Chakraborty 1990 Prarnana J. Phys. 34 1. [11] S. Chakraborty 1991 Ind. J. Pure Appl. Phys. 29 31. [12] R. Tikekar, L.K. Patel 1994 Gen. Rel. Grav. 24 397. [13] R. Tikekar, L.K. Patel 1992 Pramana J. Phys. 42 483. [14] L.K. Patel, S.D. Maharaj 1996 Pramana J. Phys. 47 1. [1] S. Ram, T.K. Singh 199 Gen. Rel. Grav. 27 1207. [16] J. Carminati, C.B.G. Mclntosh 1980 J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 13 93. [17] K.D. Krori, T. Chaudhury, C.R. Mahanta, A. Mazumdar 1990 Gen. Rel. Grav. 22 123. [18] X.X. Wang 2003 Chin. Phys. Lett. 20 61. [19] M.K. Yadav, A. Rai, A. Pradhan 2007 IJTP 7 9381. 14