INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CIVIL AND STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING Volume 6, No 2, 2015

Similar documents
Rainfall Analysis in Mumbai using Gumbel s Extreme Value Distribution Model

Forecasting Drought in Tel River Basin using Feed-forward Recursive Neural Network

Inflow forecasting for lakes using Artificial Neural Networks

Optimal Artificial Neural Network Modeling of Sedimentation yield and Runoff in high flow season of Indus River at Besham Qila for Terbela Dam

Forecasting River Flow in the USA: A Comparison between Auto-Regression and Neural Network Non-Parametric Models

Study of Hydrometeorology in a Hard Rock Terrain, Kadirischist Belt Area, Anantapur District, Andhra Pradesh

Rainfall is the major source of water for

Analysis of Rainfall and Other Weather Parameters under Climatic Variability of Parbhani ( )

Chiang Rai Province CC Threat overview AAS1109 Mekong ARCC

Best Fit Probability Distributions for Monthly Radiosonde Weather Data

Prediction of Monthly Rainfall of Nainital Region using Artificial Neural Network (ANN) and Support Vector Machine (SVM)

Summary and Conclusions

Journal of Urban and Environmental Engineering, v.3, n.1 (2009) 1 6 ISSN doi: /juee.2009.v3n

Proceeding OF International Conference on Science and Technology 2K14 (ICST-2K14)

DETECTION OF TREND IN RAINFALL DATA: A CASE STUDY OF SANGLI DISTRICT

Analysis of Historical Pattern of Rainfall in the Western Region of Bangladesh

Seasonality and Rainfall Prediction

1. Evaluation of Flow Regime in the Upper Reaches of Streams Using the Stochastic Flow Duration Curve

River Flow Forecasting with ANN

Key Finding: Long Term Trend During 2014: Rain in Indian Tradition Measuring Rain

To Predict Rain Fall in Desert Area of Rajasthan Using Data Mining Techniques

Frequency analysis of rainfall deviation in Dharmapuri district in Tamil Nadu

Research Article Development of Artificial Neural-Network-Based Models for the Simulation of Spring Discharge

Rainfall variation and frequency analysis study in Dharmapuri district, India

SEPTEMBER 2013 REVIEW

Rainfall variation and frequency analysis study of Salem district Tamil Nadu

A Study on Storm Water Drainage System of Annanagara and Ashokanagara of Shimoga City Karnataka India

Optimum Neural Network Architecture for Precipitation Prediction of Myanmar

The Trend Analysis Of Rainfall In The Wainganga River Basin, India

Chapter-1 Introduction

Journal of of Computer Applications Research Research and Development and Development (JCARD), ISSN (Print), ISSN

Dry spell analysis for effective water management planning

PRELIMINARY DRAFT FOR DISCUSSION PURPOSES

Seasonal Rainfall Trend Analysis

Local Ctimatotogical Data Summary White Hall, Illinois

Rainfall Observations in the Loxahatchee River Watershed

Country Presentation-Nepal

2017 Fall Conditions Report

MONTHLY RESERVOIR INFLOW FORECASTING IN THAILAND: A COMPARISON OF ANN-BASED AND HISTORICAL ANALOUGE-BASED METHODS

Research Article Weather Forecasting Using Sliding Window Algorithm

Estimation of Pan Evaporation Using Artificial Neural Networks A Case Study

DROUGHT IN MAINLAND PORTUGAL

Application of an artificial neural network to typhoon rainfall forecasting

Current Water Conditions in Massachusetts January 11, 2008

David R. Vallee Hydrologist-in-Charge NOAA/NWS Northeast River Forecast Center

2015 Fall Conditions Report

Real time wave forecasting using neural networks

A Feature Based Neural Network Model for Weather Forecasting

Flood Forecasting Using Artificial Neural Networks in Black-Box and Conceptual Rainfall-Runoff Modelling

Stochastic Hydrology. a) Data Mining for Evolution of Association Rules for Droughts and Floods in India using Climate Inputs

Journal of Pharmacognosy and Phytochemistry 2017; 6(4): Sujitha E and Shanmugasundaram K

Investigation of Rainfall Trend in Jorhat Town, Assam, India

Monthly Long Range Weather Commentary Issued: SEPTEMBER 19, 2016 Steven A. Root, CCM, Chief Analytics Officer, Sr. VP,

A Report on a Statistical Model to Forecast Seasonal Inflows to Cowichan Lake

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF PURE AND APPLIED RESEARCH IN ENGINEERING AND TECHNOLOGY

NATIONAL WEATHER SERVICE

A High Resolution Daily Gridded Rainfall Data Set ( ) for Mesoscale Meteorological Studies

SOIL MOISTURE MODELING USING ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORKS

Meta-heuristic ant colony optimization technique to forecast the amount of summer monsoon rainfall: skill comparison with Markov chain model

January 25, Summary

Spatial and Temporal Analysis of Rainfall Variation in Yadalavagu Hydrogeological unit using GIS, Prakasam District, Andhra Pradesh, India

NON-STATIONARY & NON-LINEAR ANALYSIS, & PREDICTION OF HYDROCLIMATIC VARIABLES OF AFRICA

Drought Monitoring in Mainland Portugal

Advanced Hydrology. (Web course)

Fire Weather Drivers, Seasonal Outlook and Climate Change. Steven McGibbony, Severe Weather Manager Victoria Region Friday 9 October 2015

ENGINEERING HYDROLOGY

Of droughts and flooding rains cyanobacterial presence in NSW over the past 5 summers. BGA in NSW Lee Bowling EEP Branch 23 rd August 2012

Rainfall Prediction using Back-Propagation Feed Forward Network

APPLICATION OF ARTIFICIAL NEURAL NETWORKS FOR FLOOD FORECASTING

Rainfall Analysis. Prof. M.M.M. Najim

Analysis of Meteorological drought condition for Bijapur region in the lower Bhima basin, India

Application and verification of ECMWF products 2015

3. HYDROMETEROLOGY. 3.1 Introduction. 3.2 Hydro-meteorological Aspect. 3.3 Rain Gauge Stations

Effect of land use/land cover changes on runoff in a river basin: a case study

Assessment of Meteorological Drought- A Case Study of Solapur District, Maharashtra, India

Three main areas of work:

2016 Fall Conditions Report

Chapter-4 Analysis on Rainfall Variability and Distribution

ISPRS Archives XXXVIII-8/W3 Workshop Proceedings: Impact of Climate Change on Agriculture CLIMATE VARIABILITY OVER GUJARAT, INDIA

July, International SWAT Conference & Workshops

Section 2 Rainfall and Climatic Data

THE CLIMATE OVER SRI LANKA YALA SEASON 2017

Wavelet transform based trend analysis for drought variability over 566 stations in India

WHEN IS IT EVER GOING TO RAIN? Table of Average Annual Rainfall and Rainfall For Selected Arizona Cities

The hydrologic service area (HSA) for this office covers Central Kentucky and South Central Indiana.

Projected Change in Climate Under A2 Scenario in Dal Lake Catchment Area of Srinagar City in Jammu and Kashmir

Memo. I. Executive Summary. II. ALERT Data Source. III. General System-Wide Reporting Summary. Date: January 26, 2009 To: From: Subject:

Solution: The ratio of normal rainfall at station A to normal rainfall at station i or NR A /NR i has been calculated and is given in table below.

DEPARTMENT OF EARTH & CLIMATE SCIENCES Name SAN FRANCISCO STATE UNIVERSITY Nov 29, ERTH 360 Test #2 200 pts

HYDROLOGIC AND WATER RESOURCES EVALUATIONS FOR SG. LUI WATERSHED

investment decisions

International Journal of Computer Science Trends and Technology (IJCST) Volume 3 Issue 3, May-June 2015

UK Flooding Feb 2003

American International Journal of Research in Science, Technology, Engineering & Mathematics

Modeling of peak inflow dates for a snowmelt dominated basin Evan Heisman. CVEN 6833: Advanced Data Analysis Fall 2012 Prof. Balaji Rajagopalan

Technical Note: Hydrology of the Lukanga Swamp, Zambia

AN OVERVIEW OF ENSEMBLE STREAMFLOW PREDICTION STUDIES IN KOREA

Analytical Report. Drought in Sri Lanka January2017 ERCC Analytical Team and JRC Drought Team 26 January Map

Trends and Variability of Climatic Parameters in Vadodara District

Government of Sultanate of Oman Public Authority of Civil Aviation Directorate General of Meteorology. National Report To

Transcription:

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CIVIL AND STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING Volume 6, No 2, 2015 Copyright by the authors - Licensee IPA- Under Creative Commons license 3.0 Research article ISSN 0976 4399 Rainfall analysis and forecasting in Mumbai metropolitan region using artificial neural networks (ANN) Sangita Mishra S 1, K. Phadtare 2, Solapure M 3 1- Assistant Professor, Departmentof Civil Engineering, AIKTC School of Engineering and Technology, New Panvel, Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra. 2,3- BE Students, Department of Civil Engineering, Saraswati College of Engineering, Kharghar, Navi Mumbai, Maharashtra. dr.sushreemishra80@gmail.com doi:10.6088/ijcser.6011 ABSTRACT Irregular rainfall pattern and high surface runoff are the main reasons of water logging and subsequent flood conditions in the Mumbai metro Politian region. Also, the urban heat island effect leads to increased rainfall, both in amounts and intensity in the city. Therefore, research on rainfall patterns and their variations as well as prediction of rainfall for short term as well as long term periods is necessary in Mumbai region. In the present study, an attempt has been made to perform statistical analysis of rainfall for various duration and return periods, and analysis of rainfall trend and intensity pattern for Mumbai region. The records of the observed annual maximum daily rainfall were analyzed statistically for different rainfall return periods (2, 3, 5, 10, 15, 20, 30, 50, 70 years) during the period 1994 to 2013 for Santacruz rain gauge station using Gumbel s extreme value distribution model. The forecasted rainfall values obtained from Gumbel s model is then validated using Artificial Neural Network model. It was observed from the study that the model architecture 4-2-1 performed best with a (R 2 ) value of 0.99 and mean absolute error of 0.04 for rainfall forecasting in Mumbai metropolitan region. Keywords: Rainfall analysis, Rainfall forecasting, Mumbai, ANN 1. Introduction Mumbai is a densely populated city that is located on the coast. Being a tropical wet-dry region, this island city receives high intensity rainfall from monsoon from June to September months and the other months are mostly dry resulting in extreme climatic events like floods and droughts. The study of spatial variability of extreme rainfall events help to identify zones of high and low values of extreme rainfall events. Also, prediction of monsoon rainfall a few weeks or months advance is necessary to prepare contingency plans for extreme events like droughts and floods. In recent decades, artificial neural networks (ANNs) have shown great ability in modeling and forecasting nonlinear and non-stationary time series in hydrology and water resource engineering due to their innate nonlinear property and flexibility for modeling. Some of the advantages of ANNs are (ASCE, 2000a). (1) They are able to recognize the relation between the input and output variables without explicit physical considerations. (2) They work well even when the training sets contain noise and measurement errors. (3) They are able to adapt to solutions over time to compensate for changing circumstances and (4) they possess other inherent information processing characteristics and once trained are easy to use. Received on July 2015 Published on November 2015 129

Karunanithi et al., (1994) and Hsu et al., (1995), attempted to predict flow at the current catchment outlet with inputs such as rainfall, upstream flow, and/or temperature only. Nagesh Kumar et al., (2004) used recurrent neural networks for river flow forecasting. The superior performance of the ANN for short-term stream flow forecasting in the Winnipeg River system (Canada) within a stochastic-deterministic watershed model was described by (Zealand et al,1999). Jain et al., (1999) compared ARIMA time series model and ANN for stream flow forecasting in India and again concluded in favor of the ANN approach.thirumalaiah and Deo, (1998) demonstrated the ability of ANN to accurately predict hourly flood runoff and daily water stage in real-time. Birikundavyiet al., (2002) established that ANN outperformed a conventional conceptual model in forecasting of daily stream flow in the Mistassibi River in Quebec, Canada.Luket al., (2000) for short-term rainfall forecasting within a flood warning system and Ramirez et al., (2005) for daily rainfall forecasting. In the present study, a detailed analysis of rainfall on monthly and annual basis was carried out to study the rainfall pattern in Mumbai metropolitan region. Long term forecasting of rainfall was done using the Gumbel s extreme value distribution model. The forecasted values were then validated using ANN. Neural network models were developed using the recursive multi-step neural network approach (RMSNN). Different combinations of past rainfall were used for rainfall forecasting in this study. 2.Study area The city of Mumbai (Greater Mumbai) consists of two administrative districts: the Island City District and the Suburban District. It extends between 18 and 19.20 N and between 72 and 73 E (Figure 1). Geographically, Greater Mumbai is an island separated from the mainland by the narrow Thane Creek and a relatively wider Harbour Bay. Mumbai has a tropical wet and dry climate, and may be best described as moderate temperatures with high level of humidity. Its coastal and tropical location ensure moderate temperature throughout the year, average of 27.2 C and annual average precipitation of 242.2 cm (95.35 inches). The temperature of Mumbai city is on average about 30 C in summer and 18 C in winter. Mumbai has 4 distinct seasons: Winter (December Feb); summer (March May); Monsoon (June Sep) and Post-Monsoon (Oct Dec). Every year, Mumbai experiences heavy rainfall during the monsoon time as it is in the windward side of Western Ghat. Between June and September, the south west monsoon rains splurge the city. Occasionally, premonsoon showers are received in May and north-east monsoon showering may occur in October and November. The maximum annual rainfall ever recorded was 3,452 mm (136 in) for 1954. The highest rainfall recorded in a single day was 944 mm (37 in) on 26 July 2005. Theaverage total annual rainfall is 2,146.6 mm (85 in) for the Island City, and 2,457 mm (97 in) for the suburbs. Due to incessant rains and simultaneous high tidal waves, the overall risk to flooding is more in coastal urban areas. Mumbai is prone to flooding and experiences severe flooding almost every year, for example, 2004 and 2007, Mumbai witnessed flooding each summer. But in 2005, thecity witnessed the worst flooding in its recorded history. 3. Methodology Analysis of rainfall pattern and trend is done using the daily rainfall data from (1993-2013) collected from IMD regional office, Santacruz, Mumbai. International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 130

3.1 Rainfall pattern analysis From the data obtained from IMD (Indian Metrological Department, Santacruz), Rainfall pattern and behavior has been analyzed on annual and monthly basis and various graphs has been plotted for years (1994-2013). Trend analysis of a time series consists of the magnitude of trend and its statistical significance. Obviously, different workers have used different methodologies for trend detection. In general, the magnitude of trend in a time series is determined either using regression analysis (parametric test) or using Sen. s estimator method (non-parametric method). Figure 1: Location map of the study area (www.mapsofindia.com) Both these methods assume a linear trend in the time series (Jain and Kumar, 2012), (Sen et al., 2013). Regression analysis is conducted with time as the independent variable and rainfall/temperature as the dependent variable. The regression analysis can be carried out directly on the time series or on the anomalies (i.e. deviation from mean). A linear equation, y = mt + c (1) where, c :-the intercept trend m :-the slope, The linear trend value represented by the slope of the simple least-square regression line provided the rate of rise/fall in the variable. 3.2 Rainfall forecasting As it is already discussed that rainfall forecasting is crucial for determination of drought or flood events and is helpful for developing early warning measures. In this study, rainfall International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 131

forecasting is carried out using Gumbel s extreme value distribution model. Then the model is validated using artificial neural networks. 3.2.1 Gumbel s model Gumbel introduced the concept of extreme value distribution and developed a model for prediction of hydrologic event such as flood peaks, maximum rainfall, etc (Das, 2004). Gumbel found that the probability of occurrence of an extreme event, equal to or larger than a value is given by the following equation: P(X x) = 1-e (-e-y) ----------------------------------------------------(2) Where, P-the probability of occurrence X -the event the hydrologic series x -the desired value of the event y -the reduced variate Gumbles equations for field The variatext can also be expressed as Xt σ ------------------------------------------------------ (3) σ -standard deviation of sample K -frequency factor ------------------------------------------------------ (4) --------------------------------------------------------- (5) yt-the reduced variate for a given return period T and yt is calculated by ----------------------------------------------- (6) Return period Where, y n- the reduced mean as a function of sample size N σ -reduced standard deviation as a function of sample size N Return period or recurrence interval is the average interval of time within which any extreme event of given magnitude will be equaled or exceeded at least once ------------------------------------------------------------(7) Where, N= Total number of years of record and R= Rank of observed rainfall values arranged in descending order. 3.2.2 Artificial neural network (ANN) model Artificial Neural Network (ANN) methodology allows us to develop nonlinear systems receiving large quantities of inputs that development based on only instances of input-output relations. A major application field of ANNs is forecasting. ANN is especially best fit for discovering accurate solutions in an environment characterized by nonlinear, irrelevant, complex, partial or noisy data. International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 132

A Neural network essentially has three layers which are the input layer, the output layer and the hidden layer in between. Neural network is made up of interconnected neurons and each neuron has the relationship with neighboring neurons. The relationship between the neurons is measured by weight. The ANNs learning is the process of finding the optimal weight matrices in a systematic manner, in order to achieve the desired value of target outputs. The performance measure used to train ANNs is minimizing the network error function. Figure 3.5.3 represents a typical neural network with 4 input layers, 1 hidden layer and 1 output layer. Figure 2: ANN architecture with four input and one output for mean annual rainfall data. In order to perform the weather forecasting using neural network and comparing the performance of neural network model with different learning rates and by setting different number of neurons in hidden layer, backpropagation algorithm and supervised learning is used in this study. The following Steps are followed in the process:- 1. Data preprocessing. 2. Defining the ANN model. 3. Training of ANN. 4. Testing of data. The relationship between the output (yt) and the inputs r(t- 1), r(t- 2)and r(t- 3)can be represented by, The following mathematical equation: ------------------------------(8) Where, y(t) is an output from the network, International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 133

r(t-i) is the inputs to network. Wj and Wi are the connection weights. S1 and S2 are activation function, The most commonly used function is a logistic sigmoid function given by equation: ---------------------------------------- (9) For validation of Gumbel s distribution model, annual rainfall data from 1994-2014 is used in this study. Also the forecasted rainfall value for 2015 which is predicted using Gumbel s model is also used as input data. Further rainfall moving average series i.e. RH1, RH2, RH3, RH4 etc were calculated and used as input layers in the neural network model to get the desired output. 4. Results and discussion 3.3 Rainfall pattern and trend analysis As stated earlier, the rainfall pattern analysis was done using daily rainfall data for the period (1994-2013). The daily rainfall was then summed into weekly, monthly and yearly rainfall. Wide variation of annual rainfall was observed with the maximum value of 5112.5 mm and minimum of 1155.7 mm. This erratic rainfall distribution gives rise to extreme climatic conditions like floods and droughts in Mumbai region. A detailed statistical analysis of annual rainfall is shown in table 1.As the rainfall in Mumbai occurs mainly between June- September, a further detailed analysis of rainfall is done only for monsoon months. (Figure 2).From the figure it is clear that there is much variation of rainfall between months and also in the same month for the entire period under observation. Hence the rainfall trend was studied for indivisual months for the period under observation. Table 1: Basic statistics for annual rainfall of Mumbai (1994-2013) Description Santacruz(1994-2013) Number of years of observation 19 Minimum rainfall(mm) 1155.7 Maximum rainfall(mm) 5112.5 Mean rainfall(mm) 2497.15 Standard deviation 857.2626 Median 2180.7 Coefficient of variation 0.37 A positive rainfall trend is observed in June, July and August months (Figure 4). However, the rainfall trend was nearly linear in September month for all the years except for the year 2005 (Figure 5). Mumbai experienced an acute and disastrous flood hazard in this year because of this unusually high rainfall. The maximum daily rainfall in this year was 944 mm in the September month. To estimate the probability of occurrence of maximum one day rainfall in future, further analysis of rainfall was carried out. International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 134

Figure 3: Annual rainfall variation in Mumbai from 1994-2013 Figure 4: Trend analysis of rainfall in June for the period 1994-2013 Figure 5: Trend analysis of rainfall in September for the period 1994-2013 4.2 Rainfall forecasting 4.2.1 Gumbel s Extreme value distribution model Analysis of rainfall trend and pattern and analysis of probable maximum precipitation indicated erratic and uneven distribution of rainfall in Mumbai region over the years. So there is a need to estimate the quantity of rainfall that may occur after 1 year and after many years. Hence the rainfall amount is estimated for different return periods using Gumbel s extreme value model. From the analysis it was observed that the rainfall amount may be 2219.67 mm International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 135

in the year 2015.The analysis indicated a positive trend in the quantity of rainfall in future. (Table. 2, Figure 6) 4.2.2 Artificial neural network (ANN) model The neural network models were developed using the feed forward training with the standard back propagation algorithm to forecast rainfall values. Past combination of rainfall values were used as input parameters as explained earlier. The available data were split into three parts, 60% of the total data set was used for training, 20% for testing and 20% of the total dataset were used for validation. Table 2: Estimation of rainfall at different return periods Return Predicted Rainfall in mm Period in (Xt) years 2 2219.67 3 2663.489 5 3157.497 10 3986.129 15 4127.02 20 4375.348 30 4874.64 50 5145.86 6000 5000 Rainfall intensity 4000 3000 2000 1000 0 2 12 22 32 42 52 62 Return period Figure 6. Estimation of rainfall at different return periods using Gumbel s model The forecasted rainfall using Gumbel s model for 2 years return period from 2013 was found to be 2219.67mm which is being validated using ANN which is a standard model used by Indian meteorological department (IMD) with different number of trails as shown in table 3and the results obtained are in the form of graphs having actual v/s forecasted plot which are also provided below. From all these trials it is found that the model architecture having 4 International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 136

neurons in input, two hidden neurons and one output neuron (4-2-1)worked best with correlation coefficient value as 0.98 and regression coefficient value as 0.99 least absolute relative error of 0.04 (Figure 7,8). Figure 7: Actual V/S Forecasted Rainfall for model architecture (4-2-1) Figure 8: Scatter plot for actual V/S forecasted rainfallfor model (4-2-1) Table 3: Different model architectures Trial Number Model Architecture Regression Coefficient (R 2 ) Correlation Coefficient (R) Absolute Relative Error (ARE) 1 4-2-1 0.99 0.98 0.04 International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 137

(Note: 4-2-1 means 4 neurons in input, 2 neurons in hidden layer and 1 neuron in output layer) 5. Conclusion Due to the high population growth and looming climate change, Mumbai is experiencing wide variation in spatial-temporal distribution of rainfall. Hence, rainfall trend and pattern analysis was done for Mumbaimetropolitan region for a duration of 20 years (1994-2013). It was observedthat aberrant variation in rainfall either causes flood or shortage of water supply. Hence rainfall forecasting is necessary to predict the rainfall well in advance to prepare contingency plans.this study incorporated Gumbel s model to forecast rainfall for different return periods and then the forecasted rainfall is validated using ANN. Results obtained from detailed rainfall analysis such as rainfall estimates for different return periods using the above methods could be used for hydrologic modeling and for early warning systems. 6. References 2 4-10-1 0.94 0.97 0.07 3 4-4-1 0.93 0.97 0.08 4 3-8-1 0.95 0.90 0.08 5 3-5-1 0.93 0.87 0.09 6 3-3-1 0.94 0.84 0.08 1. ASCE Task Committee on Application of Artificial Neural Networks in Hydrology, (2000). Artificial neural networks in hydrology. I: Preliminary concepts. J. Hydrol. Eng., 5(2), pp 15-123. 2. Birikundavyi, S., Labib, R., Trung, H.T. and Roussele, J.,(2002), Performance of Neural Network in Daily Streamflow Forecasting, J. Hydrol. Eng., ASCE, 7(5), pp 393-398. 3. G. Das, (2004), Hydrology and soil conservation engineering, (Prentice-Hall of India Pvt. Ltd 4. Hsu, K. L., Gupta, H.V. and Sorooshian, S., (1995), Artificial neural network modeling of the rainfall-runpff processes, Water Resource and Research, 31(10), pp 2517 2530. 5. Jain, S. K., Das, A. and Srivastava, D, K., (1999), Application of ANN for reservoir inflow prediction and operation, ASCE Journal of Water Resource Planning and Management,125, pp 263 271. 6. Jain, S., and Kumar, V., (2012), Trend analysis of rainfall and temperature data for India, In reviews of current science, 102(1), pp 1-13. International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 138

7. Karunanithi, N., Grenney, W.J., Whitley, D. and Bovee, K., (1994), Neural networks for river flow prediction, Journal of Computing in Civil Engineering, 8(2), pp 201-220. 8. Luk, K.C., Ball, J.E. and Sharma, A., (2000), A study of optimal model lag and spatial inputs to artificial neural network for rainfall forecasting, Journal of Hydrology, 227 (1-4), pp 56-65. 9. Nagesh Kumar, D., Raju, K.S. and Satish, T., (2004), River flow forecasting using recurrent neural networks, Water Resource Management, 18, pp 141 163. 10. Ramireza, M.C.V., Velhob, H.F.C. and Ferreiraa, N. J., (2005), Artificial neural network technique for rainfall forecasting applied to the Sao Paulo region, Journal of Hydrology, 301, pp 146 162. 11. Sen, S.,Vittal, H., Singh, T., Singh,J., and Karmakar,S.,(2003), At-site design rainfall estimation with diagonostic check for non-stationarity, An application to Mumbai rainfall dataset, In Proccedings of Hydro 2013 International, 4-6 Dec, IIT Madras, India, pp: 1-14. 12. Thirumalaiah, K. and Deo, M.C., (1998), River stage forecasting using artificial neural networks. ASCE Journal of Hydrological Engineering, 3(1), pp 26 32. 13. Zealand, C.M., Burn, D. and Simonovic, S.P., (1999), Short term stream flow forecasting using artificial neural networks, Journal of Hydrology, 214, pp 32 48. International Journal of Civil and Structural Engineering 139