Interplay of the -type charge ordering and the -type spin ordering in a half-doped bilayer manganite Sr Mn arxiv:cond-mat/981119v [cond-mat.str-el] 19 Nov 1998 M. Kubota, 1 H. Yoshizawa, 1 Y. Moritomo, H. ujioka, 3 K. Hirota, 3 and Y. Endoh 3 1 Neutron Scattering Laboratory, I. S. S. P., University of Tokyo, Tokai, Ibaraki, 319-16, Japan PRESTO, Center for Integrated Research in Science and Engineering (CIRSE) Nagoya University, Nagoya, 6-8601, Japan 3 CREST, Department of Physics, Tohoku University, oba-ku, Sendai, 980-878, Japan (ebruary 6, 018) We demonstrate that the half-doped bilayer manganite Sr Mn exhibits -type chargeordered and spin-orderedstates below TN,CO=Kand belowtn 1 K, respectively. However, the volume fraction of the -type ordering is relatively small, and the system is dominated by the -type spin ordering. The coexistence of the two types of ordering is essential to understand its transport properties, and we argue that it can be viewed as an effective phase separation between the metallic d(x y ) orbital ordering and the charge-localized d(3x r )/d(3y r ) orbital ordering. 7..+z, 71.7.+a, 71.30.+h It is well known that a Mn-based Ruddlesden-Popper compound (La,Sr) n+1 Mn n O 3n+1 has a unique layeredtype structure in which every n MnO layers are separated by an additional ( x Sr x ) O blocking bilayer along the c axis. 1 One of the attractive features of this family of compounds is that, by changing the number of MnO layers (n), effective dimensionality can be artificially controlled. The change of effective dimensionality have the strong influence on the magnetism as well as transport properties. 1 or instance, the 3d n = system x Sr x is a ferromagnetic metal for 0.17 < x < 0.6duetothedouble-exchangemechanism, whereas the d n = 1 compound +x Sr 1 x MnO is a good insulator for 0 x < 0.7 and exhibits spin glass behavior for a wide range of the hole concentration. 3 or the n = bilayer La x Sr 1+x Mn system, we have very recently reported that a canted -type antiferromagnetic (M) structure is stabilized for the hole concentration of 0.0 < x < 0.8 (Ref. ). One of the important aspects of perovskite manganites is the charge ordering which is frequently observed at a commensurate hole concentration. In the vicinity of x = 1/, a number of the 3d n = manganite systems including Pr 1/ Ca 1/ (Ref. 6, 7) shows the so-called -type charge and spin ordering, in which Mn 3+ and Mn + ions are aligned alternately. 8 Neutron and X-ray diffraction experiments revealed that this unique -type charge/spin ordering is also realized in the n = 1 / Sr 3/ MnO system. 9, Very recently, an electron diffraction measurement suggested that the -type charge ordering is also formed in the n = Sr Mn system. 11 To see the influence of the -type charge ordering, the typical examples of the resistivity of several manganites with x = 0.0 are depicted in ig. 1. The resistivity of the 3d n = system Pr 1/ Ca 1/ (Ref. 1) and that of the d n = 1 system / Sr 3/ MnO are insulating over the whole temperature range, and they exhibit a sharp increase below T CO. By contrast, the resistivity of Pr 1/ Sr 1/ is considerably small. 1,1 This is because a relatively wide one-electron bandwidth W in Pr 1/ Sr 1/ suppresses the -type chargeordering, and leads to the -type M spin ordering with very small resistivity (ρ 7 3 Ωcm) below 138 K. Interestingly, the ab-plane resistivity in Sr Mn below T CO shows a rather flat temperature dependence similar to that of Pr 1/ Sr 1/, although it is two order of magnitude larger (ρ 1 Ωcm) than that of Pr 1/ Sr 1/. Resistivity [Ωcm] Resistivity of 0% hole-doped Manganites 3 1 0-1 - -3 - Pr 1/ Ca 1/ -type Nd 1/ Sr 1/ -type + (-type) Sr Mn -type + (-type) Pr 1/ Sr 1/ -type / Sr 3/ MnO -type 0 0 0 10 00 0 300 Temperature [K] IG. 1. Resistivity of 0 % hole-doped d and 3d manganite samples: Pr 1/ Ca 1/ from Ref. 1, Nd 1/ Sr 1/ from Ref. 13, Pr 1/ Sr 1/ from Ref. 1, the ab-plane resistivities in Sr Mn and in / Sr 3/ MnO by the present work. It would be of great interest to elucidate what sort of mechanism could possibly cause such a drastic difference of the resistivity among 0% hole-doped manganite samples, and why only a difference of one MnO layer leads to totally different behavior in the resistivity between two good d systems n = 1 / Sr 3/ MnO and n = Sr Mn. In order to obtain some insights on these issues, we have performed neutron diffraction studies on the high quality large single crystal sample of the 0 % 1
hole-doped bilayer system Sr Mn. or the present neutron diffraction study, we have prepared high quality single crystal samples by floating zone method as reported elsewhere. The sample quality was checked by powder x-ray diffraction measurements to confirm that all the crystals were in a single phase. The resistivity was measured for several crystals including the pieces taken from the same single crystal used in the present neutron diffraction studies, and the results are in excellent accord with the preceding work. 11,16 Neutron diffraction measurements were carried out on triple-axis spectrometers GPTS, TOPN, and HQR in the JRR-3M research reactor at the Japan tomic Energy Research Institute. The spectrometers were operated in their double axis mode, and the (00) reflection of pyrolytic graphite (PG) was used to monochromate the neutron beam. t GPTS, the measurements were carried out on both the (h,h,l) and (h,0,l) reciprocal zones with an incident momentum of k i =.667Å 1, together with PG filters to eliminate higher order contaminations, and with a typical combination of collimators of 0 80 0. The lattice constants of the sample at room temperature are a = 3.87Å, and c = 19.971Å, respectively. Intensity (counts/0 sec x ) Intensity (counts/ sec x 3 ) 0 1 8 6 (c) (0,0,.) Sr Mn (a) (0,0,3) 1 (1/,1/,3) 0 0 00 300 0 00 300 Temperature ( K ) Temperature ( K ) IG.. Temperature dependence of selected positions for Sr Mn : (a) -type M Bragg, (b) -type charge order, (c) magnetic diffuse scattering, (d) -type M Bragg. (b) heating cooling 1 (3/,3/,1) We first describe the ordering process observed in Sr Mn. igure shows the temperature dependences of Bragg and diffuse peaks in Sr Mn. The moststrikingresultofthebilayersystem Sr Mn is the coexistence of the -type M spin ordering and the -type charge ordering. The intensity at Q = (0,0,3) corresponds to the squared moment of the -type M spin ordering, while the intensity at Q = ( 3, 3,1) gives a measure of the order parameter of the -type charge ordering. t TN,CO = K, the -type M spin ordering and the -type charge ordering are formed simultaneously, as seen in ig. (a) and (b). With decreasing temperature, the intensity of Q = (0,0,3) increasesmonotonically, while that of Q = ( 3, 3,1) reaches (d) 8 6 0 Intensity (counts/30 sec x ) Intensity (counts/min x ) a maximum at TN 1 K, and turns to decrease, and almost vanishes at 7 K. By contrast, the intensity of the -type spin ordering emerges at TN 1 K, and exhibits a peak at 11 K, and drastically decreases below as shown in ig. (d). or all known manganites such as Pr 1 x Ca x, / Sr 3/ MnO, and Nd 1/ Sr 1/, the -type charge/spin ordering is stable at low temperatures. 7,9,13 By contrast, the type charge/spin-orderedstatein Sr Mn is unstable at low temperatures, and transforms to the metallic -type M state. It should be noted, however, that the substantial intensity for the -type charge/spin ordering is still discernible below 7 K in ig. (b) and (d). s was seen in the resistivity shown in ig. 1, salient hysteresis was also observed in the temperature dependences of the -type and -type charge/spin orderings in ig. for a wide temperature region of < T < TN,CO. Clearly, the hysteresis should be attributed to the onset and the suppression of the -type charge/spin ordering. The temperature dependence of the magnetic diffuse scattering in ig. (c) observed at Q= (0, 0,.) demonstrates that the strong M spin correlations have alreadybeen welldeveloped within the MnO layersfrom room temperature down to TN,CO. The observed structure for the -type charge and spin ordering in the bilayer system Sr Mn is essentially the same with the known -type ordering except for the stacking along the c axis. The -type spin pattern in the ab plane is depicted in ig. 3(a), and the observed Bragg spots on the (h,h,l) reciprocal plane is illustrated in ig. 3(d). The superlattice reflections due to the lattice distortion accompanied with the -type charge ordering are observed at (h,h,l) = ( n+1, n+1,m), while those for the -type M spin ordering are observed at (h,h,l) = ( n+1, n+1,l) with n,m = integer, and l = integer or half integer. In the (h,h,l) zone, however, all the magnetic reflections are originated from the Mn 3+ ions. Since the reflections which are originated from the Mn + sites in the -type spin ordering can be observed on the (h,0,l) zone, we have performed a survey of the (h,0,l) zone as well, and confirmedthat the reflectionsby Mn + sites are observed at the ( 1,0,l) positions with l = integer, and half integer. igure shows the typical profiles for the -type charge and spin ordering observed along the l direction in the (h,h,l) zone. The measurements were carried out at 10 K and at 11 K, respectively, where the each scattering intensity exhibited the maxima, and the data measured at room temperature were subtracted as a back ground. 17 We confirmed that the peaks for the charge ordering on the ( 3, 3,l) line were stronger than those on the ( 1, 1,l) line, whereas the peaks for the -type M spin ordering on the ( 3, 3,l) line were weaker than those on the ( 1, 1,l) line, being consistent with the magnetic form factor. We therefore identify that the former scattering is originated from the charge ordering, but the latter from the magnetic scattering.
(0,0,l) (0,0,) (0,0,) magnetic unit cell Mn 3+ Mn + La -x Sr 1+x Mn (x=0.0) y S S (b) Type-I stacking z (a) -type M S S magnetic unit cell (d) (h,h,l) zone I/mmm cell (c) Type-II stacking (0,0,0) (1/,1/, 0) (1,1,0) (3/,3/, 0) (,,0) (h,h,0) IG. 3. (a): -type spin arrangement in the ab plane. The dashed square indicates the offset pattern at the z = 1/ layer by a displacement vector d = ( 1,0,0)M. (b), (c): two stacking patterns along the c axis. and denote the ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic coupling between adjacent bilayers, respectively. (See the text in details) (d): (h, h, l) reciprocal plane for Sr Mn. x x -type CO -type M -type M Nuclear Reflecting a bilayer structure of the n = +x Sr x Mn system, the Bragg intensities for both charge and spin ordering are modulated along the l direction as, I( n+1 I( n+1, n+1,l) 1+cosπlz for charge, (1), n+1,l) 1 cosπlz for spin, () where z is the Mn-Mn distance between MnO layers within bilayers. Note that, due to the M coupling of two MnO layers within bilayers, the sign of the cosine term for the magnetic Bragg reflections becomes minus in eq. (). lthough the peaks of the charge ordering are observed only at l = integer, those of the spin ordering are observed both at l = integer and half integer. This difference is caused by the fact that there exist two kinds of coupling of bilayers along the c axis as depicted in ig. 3(b) and (c). rom a straight forward analysis, we found that the peaks given by l = integer correspond to the ferromagnetic stacking of bilayers along the c axis (Type- I stacking) as indicated by - in ig. 3(b). On the other hand, the peaks observed at l = half integer correspond to a stacking sequence of --- (Type-II stacking). In addition, the profile shown in ig. (b) has a broad component beneath the Bragg reflections, which corresponds to the magnetic diffuse scattering and is again modulated as I(l) 1 cosπlz. This indicates that, in addition to the regular Type-I and Type-II stackings, there are some bilayers which are randomly stacked along the c axis, reflecting a good d character of Sr Mn. Intensity (counts/30sec) Intensity (counts/0sec) 100 00 00 0 00 000 100 00 00 Sr Mn (3/,3/,l) 10 K-RT (1/,1/,l) 11 K-RT 0 0 1 3 6 7 IG.. (a) Profile of structural scattering observed along q = ( 3, 3,l), and (b) profile of -type spin order observed along q = ( 1, 1,l). or details, see the text. The analysis further revealed a shift of the -type spin patterns relative to the next bilayers. By going to the adjacent bilayers, the -type spin arrangement has to shift by either d = (± 1,0,0) M, (0,± 1,0) M or their linear combination, reflecting the body-centered tetragonal structure of the crystal. The case of d = ( 1,0,0) M in the units of the magnetic unit cell is illustrated by a dashed line in ig. 3(a), and our analysis yielded that the observed magnetic structure is consistent with d = (± 1,0,0) M for both the Type-I and Type-II stackings. mong the half-doped manganites with the -type charge/spin ordering, Sr Mn is very unusual. The preceding resistivity measurements and the electron diffraction study lead the speculation that Sr Mn hasanintermediate-temperaturecharge-orderedphase. 11 We found that it is correct, but the -type charge ordering coexists with the -type M ordering. One can see from ig. that the scattering from the -type ordering is weak, and that the scattering is dominated by the -type M ordering even in the intermediate temperature phase for < T <. This observation is corroborated by the analysis of the observed magnetic moments. We obtained the magnetic moments for the -type spin ordering at 11 K µ = 0.70()µ B /Mn for the Type-I stacking and µ = 0.6(6)µ B /Mn for the Type-II stacking, respectively, whereas the -type (a) (b) 3
moment was µ =.3(1)µ B /Mn at 11 K. Clearly the apparently small moment for the -type spin ordering is an artifact and is a strong indication of a small volume of the -type region. By assuming that the magnetic moments in the -type and -type spin ordering are approximately equal, we estimated that the volume fraction of the -type spin ordering is 18% at 11 K. Examining the resistivity of the half-doped manganites in ig. 1, one can notice that the resistivity has a clear correlation with the relative stability of the -type charge-ordered state against the metallic -type M state. Pr 1 x Ca x and / Sr 3/ MnO show no - type M state, and they exhibit very large resistivity at low temperatures. Unlike these -type charge-ordered systems, Nd 1/ Sr 1/ shows rather small resistivity of Ωcm, and it was recently discovered that this system exhibits a parasitic -type M state in the -type charge-ordered phase. 18 The resistivity of Sr Mn is an order of 0 Ωcm, 16 and we have demonstrated in the present work that Sr Mn is dominated by the -type ordering both in the intermediate temperature phase for < T < and at low temperatures with the remnant -type charge-ordered region. inally the metallic -type M Pr 1/ Sr 1/ has the resistivity of Ωcm. This trend of the resistivity should be attributed to a metallic character of the -type M spin ordering. 1 Since spins are aligned ferromagnetically within MnO planes in the -type ordering, the double-exchange interaction is actuated, and yields the metallic in-plane conductivity. Recently, the metallic conductivity of the -type M state is reported in several heavily-doped manganite systems. 1,19 igure 1 indicates that, as the fraction of the -type state increases, the low temperature resistivity decreases. It is intriguing to examine whether these results can be understood on analogy of phase separation, which is recently proposed for the less-doped manganite case. 0 The fluctuation of charge density is essential in the phase separation model, and it is naturally built-in in a less-doped manganite system because the charge-density fluctuation may drive the system to split into a low hole-density insulating M region or into a high holedensity metallic M region. 0 or the 0 % hole-doped systems, such charge fluctuation is unlikely. On the other hand, the present results indicate that there can be two stable phases near 0 % hole-doping due to the orbital and charge ordering. In the -type M state of Sr Mn, the e g electrons supposedly occupy the d(x y ) orbital, whereas in the -type chargeordered state, the e g electrons occupy d(3x r ) and d(3y r ) orbitals alternately. The d(x y ) orbital is isotropic and charges are delocalized, while the d(3x r ) and d(3y r ) orbitals are accompanied with large Jahn-Teller distortions of MnO 6 octahedra, and clearly the charges are localized in the -type charge/spin ordering. Combining the existing results on the half-doped manganites with our present observations, we suggest that, in general, the -type charge/spin ordering coexists with the -type spin ordering at any desired ratio in nearly 0 % hole-doped systems, and such a coexistence between two orbital-ordered states could be viewed as an effective phase separation. We note that somewhat different case of microscopic phase separation is observed in x Ca x. 1 In conclusion, we have demonstrated that the bilayer manganite Sr Mn exhibits a-typecharge/spin ordered state at intermediate temperature, but this state coexists with the dominant -type antiferromagnetic state. With decreasing temperature, the -type state is suppressed through a first order transition. Strong hysteresis was observed for < T <. Reflecting the dominant -type orbital and spin ordering, however, the resistivity of Sr Mn is extremely low, and the anomaly in the resistivity around the -type charge ordering is weak. These results indicate the importance of the competition between the metallic -type d(x y ) orbital ordering and the insulating -type d(3x r )/d(3y r ) orbital ordering near half-doped manganites. Wethank N.urukawa, E.DaggotoandH. Kawanofor valuable discussions, and Y. Tokura for providing numericaldatain Ref. 1, 13, 1. Thisworkwassupportedbya Grant-In-id for Scientific Research from the Ministry of Education, Science and Culture, Japan, and the work in Nagoya was supported by Precursory Research for Embryonic Science and Technology (PRESTO), Japan Science and Technology Cooperation (JST), Japan. 1 Y. Moritomo, Y. Tomioka,. samitsu, Y. Tokura, and Y. Matsui, Nature (London) 380, 11 (1996); T. Kimura,. samitsu, Y. Tomioka, and Y. Tokura, Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 370 (1997).. Urushibara, Y. Moritomo, T. rima,. samitsu, G. Kido, and Y. Tokura, Phys. Rev. B 1, 13 (199). 3 Y. Moritomo, Y. Tomioka,. samitsu, and Y. Tokura, Phys. Rev. B 1, 397 (199). K. Hirota, Y. Moritomo, H. ujioka, M. Kubota, H. Yoshizawa, and Y. Endoh, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 67, 3380 (1998). S-W. Cheong and C. H. Chen, pp.1, in Colossal Magnetoresistance, Charge Ordering and Related Properties of Manganese Oxides ed. by C. N. R. Rao and B. Raveau (World Scientific). 6 Z.Jirák, S.Krupička, Z.Šimša, M.DlouháandS.Vratislav, J. Magn. Magn. Mater. 3, 13 (198). 7 H. Yoshizawa, H. Kawano, Y. Tomioka, and Y. Tokura, Phys. Rev. B, R131 (199); J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 6 3 (1996). 8 E. O. Wollan and W. C. Koehler, Phys. Rev. 0, (19). 9 B. J. Sternlieb, J. P. Hill, U. C. Wildgruber, G. M. Luke, B. Nachumi, Y. Moritomo, and Y. Tokura Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 169 (1996). Y. Murakami, H. Kawada, M. Tanaka, T. rima, Y. Moritomo, and Y. Tokura, Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 193 (1998).
11 J. Q. Li, Y. Matsui, T. Kimura, Y. Tokura, Phys. Rev. B 7, R30 (1998). 1 Y. Tomioka et al., J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 6, 366 (199). 13 H. Kuwahara, Y. Tomioka,. samitsu, Y. Moritomo, and Y. Tokura, Science, 70 961 (199). 1 Y. Tomioka et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 7, 8 (199). 1 H.Kawanoet al., Phys.Rev.Lett.78, 3 (1997); Physica B1-3, 89 (1998);H. Yoshizawa et al., Phys. Rev. B 8, R71 (1998). 16 Y. Moritomo,. Nakamura, K.Ohoyama, M. Ohashi, K. Hirota, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn., in press. 17 romthehysteresis, wesuspectthepossibleexistenceofthe structural transition between T N 1 K and 7 K. However, because there is no influence of the nuclear Bragg points on these lines and the change of the lattice constants is negligible, we substract the room temperature data as a back ground. 18 H. Kawano et al., cond-mat/980886. 19 Y. Moritomo et al., Phys. Rev. B, 79 (1997); Phys. Rev. B 7, R9 (1998). 0 S. Yunoki et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 8 (1998); condmat/980719; S. Yunoki and. Moreo, Phys. Rev. B 8, 603 (1998); E. Daggoto et al., Phys. Rev. B 8, 61 (1998). 1 S. Mori et al., Nature (London) 39, 73 (1998); Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 397 (1998).