C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 20 FLED 204 Nv-0 PM 02:54 U.S. DSTRCT COURT N.D. OF ALABAMA N THE UNTED STATES DSTRCT COURT F OR THE NORTHERN DSTRCT OF ALABAMA S OUTHERN DVSON R OBERTA CLARK ) P l ) v. ) CVL A CTON: P LANNED PARENTHOOD ) C N.: 2:4-v-0939-S LB S OUTHEAST NC; PLANNED ) P ARENTHOOD OF GEORGA ) NC.; PLANNED PARENTHOOD ) O F ALABAMA; DR. AQUA DON ) E. UMOREN MD.; PYHSCANS ) L ABORATORY SERVCE NC. ) A ND DR. MCHAEL B. ) R OHFLNG MD. ) D. ) P LANTFF S MOTON TO REMAND THS CASE TO THE CRCUT COURT OF JEFFERSON COUNTY ALABAMA- BRMNGHAM DVSON A ND MEMORANDUM O F LAW COMES NOW Pl R Clk by ug ug ul by l M Rm u w Mmum L w upp Pl p Cu lk ubj m ju u vy zp; pl llwg:. U NDSPUTED STATEMENTS OF FACT. O Augu 9 202 R Clk l gl Cmpl Cu C u T Jul Cu J Cuy Albm Bmgm Dv C N. 0-CV 202-045 llgg ml mlp g
C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 2 20 Aqu E. D Um Pl P Albm. Pl P Gg. 2. O Juy 2 203 Pl R Clk l mm mpl g Pl P Su E. Pl P) P l Exb. 3. O Fbuy 9 203 Pl P Um l w Pl mpl. Pl E xb 2. 4. O J uly 4 204 llwg u Cu Cu u g g Pl P Um m. M w uuul. P l Exb 3. 5. O Spm 2 204 Pl R Clk l Am Cmpl "S Am Cmpl") mg l Py L by Sv. "PLS"). Rlg. P l Exb 4. 6. O Spm 204 Ml Rlg w v w P l m mpl. P l Exb 5. 7. O S pm 9 204 Pl P Um l Rul 2 b) 6) M m / m k Pl m mpl b u lm m uly g Nvm 204 Cu Cu J Cuy. P l Exb 6. 2
C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 3 20 8. O O 0 204 Ml B Rlg l N R mvl puu 28 U.S.C. 332) 44b) 446) b) ) b vy zp. 9. Al O 0 204 Pl P Su Aqu- D Um llvly l C Rmvl D Exb D N Rmvl) b vy zp. 0. T l pgp D Exb D- C Rmvl plly A m Cmpl w l Um w z Ng m z Ng ll m... O lm m Pl mpl w l b y 202 Um w z Ng gu b mvl. 2. O O 3 204 Pl ul l y mg m Um ul zp w Ng U S Am. P l Exb 7. 3. T O 3 203 l w llwg by lp v w ul M MCllum w p Um Pl P. T O 3 203 w llw by lp v 3
C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 4 20 w Ay MCllum ug w ul m Um U S z vg ul zp w Ng. Pl E xb 8. 4. Al O 3 204 Pl ul mmlz lp v w Ay MCllum v ml p mg v ul m Um ul z Ng U S Am. P l E xb 8. 5. B p O 3 204 Pl E xb 7 8 ug ll vluly ww mvl p u lk vy zp. 6. O O 7 204 ul Um l pl ul g y ubl m y Um ul zp w U S Ng. Splly Ay MCllum l p Bu ul mmug w. U m w m y ply m ul zp w U S Am.. P l Exb 9. 7. T ul blm bly mmu w Um g bl m m D Um ul zp w U S Am Ng. P l Exb 9. 4
C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 5 20 8. Um Rlg mvl p ly Um w z Ng m Um p my p p ul z p w Ng U. D Exb D-D Um Rmvl. 9. T v U m w z U S Am m Pl R Clk mpl w l Augu 9 2009 m z U S Am ll m. P l Exb 7 8 b u P l Exb 9. 20. T v Um u U S z p. P l Exb 9 2. l upu Um lly m U S llg; Lyl Cllg Cg w Uvy ll Ml Sl bg ml g 978. Pl E xb 0 U m p. pp. 65-66. A mplg y pgm lug p Cl OB/GYN Cl w/m Lu Kg Hpl Um wk 6 m Cl mvg Ng 984 bl w pv Hpl. Pl Exb 0 U m p. pp. 66-67. Um wk Ng m 984 998 mvg bk Tul A lbm w lv wk ul 5
C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 6 20 m v bk Ng g 2002. Pl Exb 0 65-66. U m p. pp. 22. Um 2003 l Ng mv bk Fllbk Cl ul m ull p 2008 l Cl mv Ng. Pl Exb 0 U m p. pp. 3-4. 23. Um l l Cl 2008 bl pm Cuy b Ng. Pl Exb 0 U m p. pp. 62-63. 24. A m vg m U S 2008 bl pm Ng Um u U S mm 2008 m S Albm wk. Pl Exb 0 U m p. pp. 4-6. 25. D Um Ml D Huvll Wm C T y. Pl Exb 0 U m p. pp. - 2. H l wk Mgmy Albm l 202. Pl Exb 0 U m p. p. 2. 26. A l w pl g l w l mpl w k gv pm Um gv Ng pm llwg w: Pl Exb gy N. 4 6
C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 7 20 P l gy N. 4: F p Aqu D E Um pl y yul ully gvg yu ull m u m p ply yu p m? Aw: Aqu D E Um Ng 2008 H p p- m Albm Wm Rpuv Hl Huvll Albm 62 M S SW. 27. Fum 2002 2004 u w Um l p Cp 7 3 Bkupy p U S D Cu W D Albm. 02-73935-CMS7 AND 04-70049-C MS3 pvly. P l Exb 9. A RGUMENT AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW. S TANDARD OF REVEW wll- l p y vkg ju l u uy bl l ju x. Fzgl Sb Sy. R.R. 760 F.2 249 25 C. 985) g B U Pw Lg C. 495 F.2 906 0 C.974). T pplbl vw Cu Rmvl p w ll p Elv Cu p qug T Cu F zgl Sb Sy. R.R. w Cu llwg: Rul 2) 3 ) Fl Rul Cvl Pu pv "wv pp by ugg p w u lk ju ubj m u ll m." A u lkg ju jugm bu mu m u y g pg w m pp 7
8 u ju vkg py T lkg... ju bu... x ju l bl uy lm u S U u ju l vkg py Tu x... g pump p... bu ju u' ju lk qu p u l uy T p... u m m ju wv ju lk pul... by u l p u C m) bu ulm u um F ju u ju l vkg py w ly u mvl mu mvl bu ub ll pkg glly mvl g u m. v lv Cp. G Ol Smk S S U.S. 33 94); 24 L.E. 85 868 S.C. 6 00 Plk ul B 5 293 F.2 592.979); C Wv x P. C.977) 5 F.2 936 53 5. S EFENDANT D F OF EXSTENCE THE ESTABLSH TO ALED EDERAL COURT JURSDCTON F u l vkg b l ly pm uly u j x vy mpl Cmpl. Am F gl pl lg m zp D Exb D - m R C l vl b. ) p mvl D) Exb D w u g lg m vy; mpl x C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 8 20
9 Cmpl Am F Ogl p m ll S z PPS. Su P Pl D m vy mg pup Gg Cmpl Am F Ogl lg p m ll Ng uy z w Um. 2008. Ng D Exb D S - Rmvl C plg l ) l P l ubm Ng Um vy mpl x gu zp m wu b pl w. Exb l P. 7 8 Exb Pl l 9 mvl p l 204 0 O Cu m Um bu u w y ; zp z Ng w Um uquvlly Cmpl Am Cmpl gl pl lg m vk u. ju D Exb D - ) Rmvl C N wv H pl ul l u Ay MCllum l C m w bu zp/ul ul Um U Ng w ly S ll Um pp S U w vl m ul lp 204 2 O v w zp ul Um C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 9 20
0 S U g N.. 7 Exb l P C v lp ul p ml mmlz w. Exb l P 8. O 204 7 O lg w l u l p ul g ul l p y m Am. S U w zp ul ply Um D 9. Exb l P y m bly blm ul D zp S U Um D D w mmug ul. m U.. 9 Exb l P zp S U x m Gv u quy qu p m p ju v A lg. zp qu m y blg l bu pw ly u l. x ju pbly wv ju 25 249 F.2 760 R.R. Sy. Sb zgl F ) 985 C. g C.974) 0 906 F.2 495 C. Lg Pw U B Fum u zp ul ly ul lw l bl wll u u l up ju vul U.S.C. 28 332)2). l S ) 980 C. 7 76 F.2 65 M S. lg lgu zp u T ply u x 760 R.R. Sy. Sb Fzgl C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 0 20
2.2 F 985) C. 25 9 4 C. 7 76 F.2 65 M S 980) lkg ju l u Cu b.. m gly. w R.R Sy. Sb zgl F up u u S p ju vy w u p b p kp w u l T. ul Fzgl R.R Sy. b S pl ppl vlk uly m u b. Sb. 25 pg gu ul pl T p plg lk pw lk u l - l l gug ju vy u w u Vg T ul Sb bu pl ppl ug g G Cu lv E m b lgl w ppl l m ul u l p Sb bu g. Cu Cu Elv T. l u m up ju b u u m v w w u kw pl kw u m Cu Elv ul A. R.R Sy. Sb zgl F m u u j u. q T ly u l l Cu Elv blg l bu pw wv ju qu m y C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 20
2 25.. x ju pbly Fum R.R Sy. Sb zgl F xm Cu Elv v ju l pul ug Ev p. by u l m my lg b lg x w ju lk m blg u ju w quy k m. 0 76 R.R. Sy. Sb Fzgl 985) C. 25 249.2 F g 95 707 U.S. 42 Glg Plbk U.S. 42 Bu W K Cy 975); 525 L.E.2 44 893 S.C. L.E.2 09 37 2225 2222 S.C. 93 5 07 5 ) 973 M S up T & Wl' H g Cu Sv T 973). 2 835 Sym Fl Cu Fl l ju b u l mk ul uy x." u mk u uy T u.. 88 l p ugg by pp wv 2)3) P. C R. F. ll u m ubj ju lk u w m ). uy u mvl p lg T u l ll m m w k gg ul Um u zp/ly x D pbly ul m U w ly g N Am S U C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 2 20
3 gly. u m l D) Exb D bu 9. 8 7 Exb l P ly ul Um u T w zp ul Ng S U m l w mpl. x vy 980). C. 7 76 F.2 65 M S R mmm 202 9 Augu u Um l lk C 80.. x. ju vy l w m wu )) 332 U.S.C. 8 2 v ju u l w ll p ul z w v p z 2) S U z ) mu Tu S. ul p vy u u my p.. pul z bu S U z 80 M l S U.S. 49. C.) 5 399 396 F.2 489 Py 025 F.2 727 Pllk Sgg 974); 70 L.E.2 42 74 S.C. 95 842.984) C. Sup M v S Cu Sv l ul S U Egyp l m Egyp w S mmm b ju l vk l Cu T 332). U.S.C. 28 u vy ul S kg S U Egyp l w ju l vk C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 3 20
4 mmm m S U y z x ju vy Egyp; u 332). u T Cu v S u l vy m u gz z ul ly Am ly ju 332) U.S.C. 8 2 u ; b ml w z S U z S U y z g mvl up p l S. 504 F.2 95 & C R M v S.A. A 99). C. 2 07 5 C. 2 68 60 F.2 922 & Cmwll Sullv v Cwll 990) b p Um D w m ll mpl pl lg m Ng ml ) D Exb D w upl p ul Ng w zp ul m ply Um S U Am m S U zp; x u ju w mvly l v x w uy v mmum ju u. 9 Exb l P. ju T y ul l u u y mvl zp pp lw lg p Ry. Mg & Lk Clw Ml 4 382 379 U.S. w S ) 884 462 L.E. 28 5 50.C. S. C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 4 20
C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 5 20 A lug ul y ul m y Um p ly m ul zp w Ng U S Am wv v u w Um u l U S zp. Um p u l U S zp bu w u pv v u xp p m by U m wll mu lg U S zp. V Tz 444 U.S. 252 00 S.C. 540 62 L.E.2 46 980) l 8 U.S.C. 48) 982) m 986). U 8 U.S.C. 48 l Am zp qu vluy pm xpg um Su. 8.U.S.C 48. L ly by v-b ulz z; vluy ; bu p; p ump ) A p w l U S w by b ulz ll l ly by vluly pmg y llwg w lqug U S ly- ) bg ulz g up w ppl up ppl l by uly uz g vg g g y; 2) kg mkg m ml l llg g pll ubv vg g g y; 3) g vg m g A) u m gg l g U S B) u p v mm - mm ; 4) A) pg vg pmg u y p mplym u gvm g pll ubv g g g y qu ly u g ; B) pg vg pmg u y p mplym u gvm g pll ubv g g g y w p mplym m l llg qu; 5
6 l mp Um D g ml w Ob 988 b m 978 Cg Uvy Spl Ml B Am by ylgy G ) ABMS wk m 998 S U mly 988 S U m l u - 2008. m l P xb E N. g 4 0 9 7 5. 008 2 v mplym Um ly m l b vu kg w Albm S lug D Ml vg - 8 200 P Pl. Exb l P g N. 9. v M gv g p gvm l ply Nulz mmg - 9 g pv uy T 8 l - Fl Nly Al pv uy S Rg mmg Al 8 302 U.S.C. 8 5) plm ly u ml kg m g S U ul S; Sy by p my u m 6) by p my m u ly u w ml S U mkg u b ll S U wv Gl Ay by g my ; l y u u ppv ll Ay Gl w 7) g y mmg U g m g vw by mpg pmg wllully 8 l 2383 pv y vl pg vlg S v 8 l 2385 vl y py ggg by 8 l 2384 lg m g w lvy S U Gvm y by w pu vw mp u by ml u by v w. u j b) mm pg y u pu ly S U l Wv up ll bu A y p pv vu by u 96 26 Spm p v. pp lm by u bl u l u lmg py u xp y pm mm w pm mm w p Ay A y p v p my pump u bu vluly v pum ll w pm mm v pp by wg up bu vluly. C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 6 20
7 U.S.C 308; 8 304.S.C. U P Pl vbl zp kw mm ly / Um u /Al g Ag D. l M v u b bu x ju l wg v y w u mmum m ul u C D m U w mvly mmg u u w uly v wk w mmg z S U pm S U mu m w mvly ju l x u. & Clw Ml k L 462 L.E. 28 5 50 S.C. 4 382 379 U.S. Sw Ry. Mg 884) l S. C. 25 249 F.2 760 R.R. Sy. Sb Fzgl 985) U.S.C 48 8. lm u l m jul mkg v v my v y lk my plg; ulyg g my lv my p Ly J.g. S p. zp F 87 3 2 0 2. C.967) 5 l 985) C. 25 249 F.2 760 R.R. Sy. Sb zgl F lly F gum lg m mvbl m. wu mpl m mpl gl T S py ug ym zp vy C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 7 20
8 u. C D m U u b Ng mly b 2008 Ng mv S U l p bl Ng Lg pm ul u Ng S U z Um D y z wul b Cu Fl u ul S ju vy u b ly. ul 980). C. 7 F.2 76 65 M S ug g y wk mplym b mly Um S U S ly w Albm S. 2008 wkg W S U w zp ul w Ng z m U Ng w Albm S z mplym m l vu 8 200 y w p z vy. Pl lly F Ay u u j w m m lg pvly pl g m. qug Cu qu ju py mvl. ul u y xp ul U.S.C 447) 28 S. mmum gg lg bv ll F Albm Cuy J m ul Clk R lw C Cu u - Dv mgm B ju l v x ju u l bu y lk w C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 8 20
C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 9 20 vy zp mmm mvbl. W pm R Clk pvly qu C u :. Rm bk J Cuy Cu Cu- B mgm Dv. 2. Aw bl y u ju w ppg M F Rm ; 3. G y l Cu m ju pp/ R pully ubm / / Ap T. Agbl ASB-7334- O 6A / / yl B A y Pl O F COUNSEL: B ENDER AND AGBOOLA LLC 7 8TH STRE ET NORTH B RMNGHAM AL 35203 P H. 205.322.2500 F AX: 205.324.20 E-MAL: Ap T. Agbl-A gbul@l.m yl B-B lw@l.m 9
C 2:4-v-0939-SLB Dum 5 Fl /0/4 Pg 20 20 C ERTFCATE OF SERVCE by y llly l gg w Clk Cu ug CM/ECF ym w wll u lg ll ul / by y v ml gg by U S Pl Sv 0 y O 204 : C l A. "Cp" MCllum E Hglu M Cllum Hglu Ck & by LLP 905 Mgmy Hgwy S u 20 V v Hll Albm 3526 P: 205)824-7767 Fx: 205)824-7768 mllu m@mlw.m glu@mlw.m LBll S. Alv ASB-0755- A 39L) R. J W ASB-25- R 69W) C ul D Ml B. R lg M.D. O F COUNSEL: C HRSTAN & SMALL LLP 505 N 20 S S u 800 B mgm Albm 35203 Tlp: 205) 795-6588 Fml: 205) 328-7234 l @y.m jw@y.m / / Ap T. Agbl O Cul. 20