Quantum Theory: What is it about?

Similar documents
On the role of Decoherence in Bohmian Mechanics

The Foundations of Quantum Mechanics and The Limitations of Human Being

Master Projects (EPFL) Philosophical perspectives on the exact sciences and their history

about Quantum Physics Bill Poirier MVJS Mini-Conference Lawrence Hall of Science July 9, 2015

226 My God, He Plays Dice! Entanglement. Chapter This chapter on the web informationphilosopher.com/problems/entanglement

The Measurement Problem

Cosmological quantum fluctuations from the

On the Present Status of Quantum Mechanics

What does Quantum Mechanics Tell us about Time?

Bohmian Mechanics. Detlef Dürr, Sheldon Goldstein, Roderich Tumulka, and Nino Zanghì. December 31, 2004

Evidence and Theory in Physics. Tim Maudlin, NYU Evidence in the Natural Sciences, May 30, 2014

The nature of Reality: Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen Argument in QM

The Measurement Problem of Quantum Mechanics Click to edit Master title style. Wells Wulsin SASS 24 September 2008

COPENHAGEN INTERPRETATION:

HSSP Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics 08/07/11 Lecture Notes

GRW Theory (Ghirardi, Rimini, Weber Model of Quantum Mechanics)

How does it work? QM describes the microscopic world in a way analogous to how classical mechanics (CM) describes the macroscopic world.

Intermediate Philosophy of Physics: Philosophy of Quantum Mechanics Somerville College Dr Hilary Greaves

For the seminar: Ausgewählte Probleme der Quantenmechanik Faculty of Physics, University of Vienna, WS 2011/2012 Christian Knobloch a

Q8 Lecture. State of Quantum Mechanics EPR Paradox Bell s Thm. Physics 201: Lecture 1, Pg 1

ON THE NOTION OF PRIMITIVE ONTOLOGY. Andrea Oldofredi Université de Lausanne MCMP (LMU) 29 Oct. 2014

Bell s inequalities and their uses

Time in Bohmian Mechanics

Determinate Values for Quantum Observables

Against the field ontology of quantum mechanics

The Relativistic Quantum World

The Role of the Wave Function in the GRW Matter Density Theory

Cambridge University Press Quantum Physics: Illusion or Reality?, Second Edition Alastair I. M. Rae Excerpt More information

Quantum reality. Syksy Räsänen University of Helsinki, Department of Physics and Helsinki Institute of Physics

viii My God, He Plays Dice! Preface Preface

If classical physics is wrong, why do we still use it?

Quantum Mechanics: Philosophy & Interpretations

David Bohm s Hidden Variables

Hugh Everett III s Many Worlds

Outline. What does Quantum Mechanics Tell us about Time? Classical Mechanics in a Nutshell. Classical Mechanics in a Nutshell

Topic 10: Bohm s Theory

Bell s Theorem. Ben Dribus. June 8, Louisiana State University

The hybrid-epistemic model of quantum mechanics and the solution to the measurement problem

Philosophy of QM First lecture.

Many Worlds: Quantum Theory and Reality? IÑAKI SAN PEDRO 1

Computer Simulation of Einstein-Podolsky. Podolsky-Rosen- Bohm Experiments with Photons.

Odd Things about Quantum Mechanics: Abandoning Determinism In Newtonian physics, Maxwell theory, Einstein's special or general relativity, if an initi

Closing the Debates on Quantum Locality and Reality: EPR Theorem, Bell's Theorem, and Quantum Information from the Brown-Twiss Vantage

PBR theorem and Einstein's quantum hole argument. Galina Weinstein

WHY DOES NONLOCALITY SUPPORT BOHM s THEORY?

arxiv:quant-ph/ v1 22 Apr 2004

Quantum Mechanics: Stranger than we can imagine?

ALBERT EINSTEIN AND THE FABRIC OF TIME by Gevin Giorbran

Hidden Variable Theory

Bohmian Mechanics as the Foundation of Quantum Mechanics

Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics

2 Quantum Mechanics. 2.1 The Strange Lives of Electrons

Philosophy and Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics

Spatial Locality: A hidden variable unexplored in entanglement experiments

Bohmian Trajectories as the Foundation of Quantum Mechanics

Bell s Theorem 1964 Local realism is in conflict with quantum mechanics

Lecture 2: Introduction to Quantum Mechanics

Bohmian Trajectories as the Foundation of Quantum Mechanics and Quantum Field Theory

What Does Quantum Mechanics Suggest About Our Perceptions of Reality?

A possible quantum basis of panpsychism

Entanglement. arnoldzwicky.org. Presented by: Joseph Chapman. Created by: Gina Lorenz with adapted PHYS403 content from Paul Kwiat, Brad Christensen

Primitive ontology and quantum state in the GRW matter density theory

Looking at Scripture with New Eyes: A Chance Conversation Between Faith and Science

Some solutions of the quantum measurement paradox

Some Remarks on Wave Function Monism

Collapse or no collapse? What is the best ontology of quantum mechanics in the primitive ontology framework?

What does it feel like to be in a quantum superposition?

Does the ψ-epistemic view really solve the measurement problem?

Newsletter No. 2. (part A)

Quantum mechanics is an exquisitely well-verified theory of how our physical world operates

Dialogue. Consciousness in Community. Christian de Quincey. (from Radical Knowing: Understanding Consciousness through Relationships)

Understanding Quantum Physics An Interview with Anton Zeilinger

Cosmology Lecture 2 Mr. Kiledjian

On the unavoidability of the interpretations of Quantum Mechanics arxiv: v2 [physics.hist-ph] 26 Sep 2013

Review of Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: An Exploration of the Physical Meaning of Quantum Theory

It From Bit Or Bit From Us?

Contextuality and the Kochen-Specker Theorem. Interpretations of Quantum Mechanics

Quantization, spatiotemporalization and pure variation

Phil Notes #7: Time Travel

Solving the Einstein Podolsky Rosen puzzle: The origin of non-locality in Aspect-type experiments

Popper School Methodological Disproof of Quantum Logic

A brief discussion about weak measurements

Physics and Faith 4. Rumors of a Designer Creator and Sustainer, Part III. The Ground of Physical Being in Quantum Physics

Tails of Schroedinger's Cat. In his famous thought experiment Schroedinger (1935) imagined a cat that measures the

Wave function collapse

Chapter 24: A Brief Introduction to Quantum Theory

Bell Inequality and Many-Worlds Interpretation

Basics on quantum information

Alan Mortimer PhD. Ideas of Modern Physics

Introduction to the strange world of Quantum Physics

What is spin? Thomas Pope and Werner Hofer. School of Chemistry Newcastle University. Web: wernerhofer.eu

Disentangling entanglement

What is it like to be a quantum observer? And what does it imply about the nature of consciousness?

Lecture 4. QUANTUM MECHANICS FOR MULTIPLE QUBIT SYSTEMS

Philosophy of quantum mechanics. VU University Amsterdam: W_MASP_TF013 Lecture 4: 12/2/2015 Kelvin J. McQueen

A New Conception of Science

Particle creation as the quantum condition for probabilistic events to occur Physics Letters A 187 Abstract A 1. Introduction

by Bradley Monton Department of Philosophy, University of Kentucky, Lexington KY USA phone: fax:

Relational Causality and Classical Probability: Grounding Quantum Phenomenology in a Superclassical Theory

Basics on quantum information

Transcription:

Quantum Theory: What is it about? Duino 2007 Quantum Theory is about? 1.? = Something out there What is out there = Ontology = What IS = Quantum Theory is about something going on IS can be particles, fields, strings, membranes, flashes, something which is in physical space and which can make up things we experience, like tables and chairs and pointers...

2.? = Not Ontology = Quantum Theory is not about something going on BUT? = Statistics of outcomes of measurements = PROBLEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! apparatus measurement apparatus is made out of?? Which theory is about Mechanics??? if not Quantum = 80 years debate about Quantum Mechanics

1.Bohr/Heisenberg lesson of QM: physics MUST NOT BE about ontology physics must not talk about?? physics is about how an observer must speak = Wittgenstein quantised 2.Working physicists lesson of QM: Schrödinger wave function says it all = all =?? = Schrödinger s cat = PROBLEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Who collapses the wavefunction? 3.Mathematical Physicists lesson of QM: physics is about observables = PROBLEM!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Who observes?

1.),2.),3) need observer = What is an observer? The Lesson from QM: Mysteries!!!!!! But I rather share the view that such debates, and accompanying experiments such as those of Gröblacher et al.(nature 2007), allow us to look deeper into the great mysteries of quantum mechanics A. Aspect in Nature 2007 great mysteries of quantum mechanics Johannes Kepler (1600): Mysterium Cosmographicum (the mystery of the universe) Galileo Galilei: The book of nature is written in the language of mathematics

What are the mysteries? wave-particle duality: The development of quantum mechanics early in the twentieth century obliged physicists to change radically the concepts they used to describe the world. The main ingredient of the first quantum revolution, waveparticle duality.. A. Aspect in Nature 2007 irreducible randomness and reality: Hopes of keeping quantum mechanics real have been dashed by new measurements of neutrons quantum behaviour. Despite what our classical sensibilities require, the world is indeed fundamentally random. Gregor Weihs in Nature 2007 entanglement: Thanks to ideas developed by Albert Einstein and John S. Bell, another essential quantum ingredient, entanglement, is now leading us through the conceptual beginnings of a second quantum revolution this time based on quantum information... A. Aspect in Nature 2007

Mystery wave-particle duality? trivial resolution as paticle and wave in de Broglie-Bohm (Bohmian Mechanics): Mystery irreducible randomness and reality? Pauli in a letter to Born, 1954 about Einstein, the realist :...I was unable to recognize Einstein whenever you talked about him in either your letter or your manuscript. It seemed to me as if you had erected some dummy Einstein for yourself, which you then knocked down with great pomp. In particular Einstein does not consider the concept of determinism to be as fundamental as it is frequently held to be (as he told me emphatically many times)... he disputes that he uses as a criterion for the admissibility of a theory the question Is it rigorously deterministic?... he was not at all annoyed with you, but only said that you were a person who will not listen...

Mystery entanglement? Schrödinger s wavefunction is entangled: Schrödinger s cat Mystery:Einstein and Bell = entanglement? Einstein (EPR) and J.S. Bell: Entanglement creates superluminal action between entangled physical systems. EPR+Bell = nature is nonlocal Mystery of Quantum Mechanics? NO!!!!! Fact of nature

The dummy Realism knocked down with great pomp Simon Gröblacher,... Anton Zeilinger Nature 2007: Most working scientists hold fast to the concept of realism a viewpoint according to which an external reality exists independent of observation. But quantum physics has shattered some of our cornerstone beliefs. According to Bells theorem, any theory that is based on the joint assumption of realism and locality (meaning that local events cannot be affected by actions in space-like separated regions) is at variance with certain quantum predictions. Experiments with entangled pairs of particles have amply confirmed these quantum predictions, thus rendering local realistic theories untenable. Maintaining realism as a fundamental concept would therefore necessitate the introduction of spooky actions that defy locality. Here we show by both theory and experiment that a broad and rather reasonable class of such nonlocal realistic theories is incompatible with experimentally observable quantum correlations.

If no one observes? Is the moon still there if nobody looks? Einstein Does this mean that my observations become real only when I observe an observer observing something as it happens? This is a horrible viewpoint. Do you seriously entertain the thought that without observer there is no reality? Which observer? Any observer? Is a fly an observer? Is a star an observer? Was there no reality before 109 B.C. before life began? Or are you the observer? Then there is no reality to the world after you are dead? I know a number of otherwise respectable physicists who have bought life insurance. By what philosophy will the universe without man be understood? Richard Feynman: Lecture Notes on Graviation What if everything is an illusion and nothing exists? In that case, I definitely overpaid for my carpet. Woody Allen

What is observation? Irrational (unspeakable) quantum mechanics It would seem that the theory [quantum mechanics] is exclusively concerned about results of measurement, and has nothing to say about anything else. What exactly qualifies some physical systems to play the role of measurer? Was the wavefunction of the world waiting to jump for thousands of millions of years until a single-celled living creature appeared? Or did it have to wait a little longer, for some better qualified system... with a Ph.D.? If the theory is to apply to anything but highly idealized laboratory operations, are we not obliged to admit that more or less measurement-like processes are going on more or less all the time, more or less everywhere. J.S. Bell, Against measurement

Quantum Theory is about something all the time, everywhere The world (including apparatuses) is made out of something = All mysteries disappear unromantic view of quantum mechanics (J.S.Bell) Quantum Theories without observers Two possibilities: Bohmian Mechanics GRW Collapse not part of theory (effective collapse) Bohmian Mechanics (David Bohm 1952 (de Broglie 1927)) Collapse as part of the theory (real collapse) GRW: Ghirardi-Rimini-Weber GRW-P (Pearle)- CSL Theory Continuous Spontaneous Collapse

Bohmian Mechanics What is Bohmian Mechanics about? particles and wavefunction What is real in Bohmian Mechanics? particles (positions) and wavefunction Q, ψ i h t ψ = Hψ ψ(t) Q(t) Determinism versus Irreducible Randomness? or Determinism yields Irreducible Randomness? Bohmian mechanics is deterministic.

BUT Theorem: In a typical Bohmian universe holds Quantum Equilibrium (QE) QE: If a systems wave function is ψ then its particles coordinates are distributed according to ψ 2. The proof is a Boltzmannian statistical analysis of Bohmian mechanics Bohmian Mechanics Quantum Formalism Bohmian Mechanics Limits of Knowledge. In QE is not possible to know the configuration Q(t) of a system more accurately than the

ψ 2 distribution allows, where ψ(q) is the system s wave function. Thus there are limits of knowledge: no matter what technology an observer uses, there are in-principle, insuperable limits to what she or he can find out about the world without paying the price of drastically changing the system s wave function, and thus the future trajectories. Analogoy: BM QM = NewtonianMechanics Epicycle T heory

IS is and what it is says the theory Bohmian mechanics (and also GRW) are rational (speakable) theories about the universe. They are about ontology. The ontologies are different. Which ontology is right, i.e. which theory is right? We can t say at the moment. We need to think harder, we need to understand relativity and non-locality. The true theory lies in our heads. When we spell it out, we say what IS. To deny that physics can spell out what IS, is to deny physics. The pysical world is real....[that] statement appears to me, however, to be, in itself, meaningless, as if one said: The physical world is cock-a-doodle-do. It appears to me that the real is an intrinsically empty, meaningless category (pigeon hole)... Who said that? Einstein the realist