Two students investigated the change of state of stearic acid from liquid to solid.

Similar documents
Name: New Document 1. Class: Date: 83 minutes. Time: 82 marks. Marks: Comments:

6-3 Particle model of matter Physics

6-3 Particle model of matter Trilogy

AQA (Trilogy) Combined Science GCSE Unit 6.3 Particle Model of Matter

M1. (a) range of speeds 1. moving in different directions accept random motion 1. internal energy 1. density = mass / volume 1. (d) / 0.

What Is Air Temperature?

CIE Physics IGCSE. Topic 2: Thermal Physics

Thermal Effects. IGCSE Physics

Past Exam Questions Core Practicals Physics Paper 1

Atoms and molecules are in motion and have energy

Exam questions: HEAT. 2. [2003 OL][2004 OL][2005 OL][2006 OL][2007 OL][2008 OL][2009] Name two methods by which heat can be transferred.

PAPER 2 THEORY QUESTIONS

SPH3U1 Lesson 03 Energy

Chapter: Heat and States

Chapter 1 Heating Processes

Specimen Paper. Physics. AQA Level 1/2 Certificate in Physics Specimen Paper. Paper 2 TOTAL. Time allowed 1 hour 30 minutes

P5 Heat and Particles Revision Kinetic Model of Matter: States of matter

Review: Heat, Temperature, Heat Transfer and Specific Heat Capacity

CLASSIFIED 2 PRESSURE THERMAL PHYSICS MR. HUSSAM SAMIR

THE PARTICLE MODEL AND PROPERTIES OF THE GASES, LIQUIDS AND SOLIDS. STATES CHANGES

3.3 Phase Changes 88 A NATURAL APPROACH TO CHEMISTRY. Section 3.3 Phase Changes

Calorimetry. A calorimeter is a device in which this energy transfer takes place

Chapter 7.1. States of Matter

IGCSE Double Award Extended Coordinated Science

Chapter 14 Temperature and Heat

How Does the Sun s Energy Cause Rain?

Paper One Extended Writing

Estimate, for this water, the specific heat capacity, specific heat capacity =... J kg 1 K 1. the specific latent heat of vaporisation.

CHM Solids, Liquids, and Phase Changes (r15) Charles Taylor 1/9

1. Thermal energy is transferred through the glass windows of a house mainly by. D. radiation and convection. (1)

Name... Class... Date... Specific heat capacity and specific latent heat

Physics PH1FP. (Jun14PH1FP01) General Certificate of Secondary Education Foundation Tier June Unit Physics P1. Unit Physics P1 TOTAL

2,000-gram mass of water compared to a 1,000-gram mass.

SAM Teachers Guide Phase Change Overview Learning Objectives Possible Student Pre/Misconceptions

Time allowed: 1 hour 45 minutes

Particle Model of Matter. AQA Physics topic 3

P6 Molecules and matter. Student Book answers. P6.1 Density. Question Answer Marks Guidance. 1 a m 3 (= 0.80 m 0.60 m 0.

Topic 3 &10 Review Thermodynamics

KINETIC PARTICLE THEORY

HEAT HISTORY. D. Whitehall

Study Guide Unit 3 Chapter 6 DRAFT

Station 1: Temperature

* Defining Temperature * Temperature is proportional to the kinetic energy of atoms and molecules. * Temperature * Internal energy

Topic review. hi.com.au Science Resource Centre. Using scientific language 1. You should be familiar with the words in the following list.

SOLIDS, LIQUIDS AND GASES

Chemistry A: States of Matter Packet Name: Hour: Page 1. Chemistry A States of Matter Packet

SOLIDS, LIQUIDS, AND GASES

Physical Science Chapter 5 Cont3. Temperature & Heat

Put sufficient ice cubes into water (1 M) and wait for equilibrium (both exist) (1 M)

Electricity and Energy 1 Content Statements

What is a change of state? What happens during a change of state? What can happen when a substance loses or gains energy?

Kinetic Theory of Matter

TEACHER NOTES: ICE CUBE POSTER

SAM Teachers Guide Phase Change Overview Learning Objectives Possible Student Pre/Misconceptions

Thermochemistry, Reaction Rates, & Equillibrium

4.1. Physics Module Form 4 Chapter 4 - Heat GCKL UNDERSTANDING THERMAL EQUILIBRIUM. What is thermal equilibrium?

Name Class Date. What are three kinds of energy transfer? What are conductors and insulators? What makes something a good conductor of heat?

Topic 19b. Thermal Properties of Matter

MATTER IN OUR SURROUNDINGS

4.1. Physics Module Form 4 Chapter 4 - Heat GCKL UNDERSTANDING THERMAL EQUILIBRIUM. What is thermal equilibrium?

A, B, and C, in the P V plane. i C. D: none of the above

3.3 Phase Changes Charactaristics of Phase Changes phase change

EDULABZ INTERNATIONAL. Heat ASSIGNMENT

Solids (cont.) Describe the movement of particles in a solid and the forces between them.

Earth s Atmosphere. Energy Transfer in the Atmosphere. 3. All the energy from the Sun reaches Earth s surface.

S6. (a) State what is meant by an ideal gas...

KS3 Science. Heat and Energy

NATIONAL 5 PHYSICS THERMODYNAMICS

Name: New Document 1. Class: Date: 398 minutes. Time: 393 marks. Marks: Comments: Page 1 of 165

Name: Block: Date: Student Notes. OBJECTIVE Students will investigate the relationship between temperature and the change of the state of matter.

Preview. Heat Section 1. Section 1 Temperature and Thermal Equilibrium. Section 2 Defining Heat. Section 3 Changes in Temperature and Phase

Chapter 14 9/21/15. Solids, Liquids & Gasses. Essential Questions! Kinetic Theory! Gas State! Gas State!

Thermodynamics - Heat Transfer June 04, 2013

Changing States of Matter By Cindy Grigg

ICY HOT LAB. In at least one sentence, explain your reasoning behind your prediction of curve:

4.3.1 Changes of state and the particle model Density of materials. ρ = m. Content. Key opportunities for skills development

Conduction and Convection

PURE PHYSICS THERMAL PHYSICS (PART I)

THERMAL PROPERTIES OF MATTER

Ocean s Influence on Weather and Climate

Ordinary Level Physics Long Questions: TEMPERATURE AND HEAT

Chemistry A: States of Matter Packet Name: Hour: Page!1. Chemistry A States of Matter Packet

(ii) the total kinetic energy of the gas molecules (1 mark) (iii) the total potential energy of the gas molecules (1 mark)

The sun s energy is transferred to the Earth with a wide range of wave lengths consisting of visible light, infrared, and ultraviolet.

Solid Liquid Gas 1. Solids have a fixed volume and a definite shape.

1st Nine Weeks Midterm Study Guide

Name: New Document 1. Class: Date: 54 minutes. Time: 54 marks. Marks: Comments: Page 1 of 22

CALORIEMETRY. Similar to the other forms of the energy, The S.I unit of heat is joule. joule is represented as J.

What does temperature have to do with energy? What three temperature scales are commonly used? What makes things feel hot or cold?

Compiled and rearranged by Sajit Chandra Shakya

States of Matter. What physical changes and energy changes occur as matter goes from one state to another?

Solids, Liquids, and Gases. Chapter 14

Atmosphere, Weather & Climate Review for Unit Assessment (Can be taken on Study Island Due Mon., 11/26/12)

Unit 11: Temperature and heat

Name Class Date. What is a change of state? What happens during a change of state? What can happen when a substance loses or gains energy?

Heat and Temperature

Conduction is the transfer of heat by the direct contact of particles of matter.

This Week. 6/2/2015 Physics 214 Summer

Conduction, Convection, & Radiation

11/22/11. If you add some heat to a substance, is it possible for the temperature of the substance to remain unchanged?

Transcription:

Two students investigated the change of state of stearic acid from liquid to solid. They measured how the temperature of stearic acid changed over 5 minutes as it changed from liquid to solid. Figure shows the different apparatus the two students used. Figure Student A s apparatus Student B s apparatus Choose two advantages of using student A s apparatus. Tick two boxes. Student A s apparatus made sure the test was fair. Student B s apparatus only measured categoric variables. Student A s measurements had a higher resolution. Student B was more likely to misread the temperature. (2) Page of 34

(b) Student B removed the thermometer from the liquid each time he took a temperature reading. What type of error would this cause? Tick one box. A systematic error A random error A zero error () (c) Student A s results are shown in Figure 2. Figure 2 Page 2 of 34

What was the decrease in temperature between 0 and 60 seconds? Tick one box. 8.2 C 8.4 C 53.2 C 55.6 C () (d) Use Figure 2 to determine the time taken for the stearic acid to change from a liquid to a solid. Time =... seconds () (e) Calculate the energy transferred to the surroundings as 0.40 kg of stearic acid changed state from liquid to solid. The specific latent heat of fusion of stearic acid is 99 000 J / kg. Use the correct equation from the Physics Equations Sheet.......... Energy =... J (2) (f) After 200 seconds the temperature of the stearic acid continued to decrease. Explain why............. (2) (Total 9 marks) Page 3 of 34

2 The drawing shows water being heated in a metal saucepan. Explain, in terms of the particles in the metal, how heat energy is transferred through the base of the saucepan............. (2) (b) Energy is transferred through the water by convection currents. Explain what happens to cause a convection current in the water. The answer has been started for you. As heat energy is transferred through the saucepan, the water particles at the bottom........................ (3) Page 4 of 34

(c) Some energy is transferred from the hotplate to the air by thermal radiation. What is meant by thermal radiation?...... () (Total 6 marks) 3 The diagrams show the arrangement of the particles in a solid and in a gas. Each circle represents one particle. (i) Complete the diagram below to show the arrangement of the particles in a liquid. (2) Explain, in terms of the particles, why gases are easy to compress. (2) Page 5 of 34

(b) The diagram below shows the model that a science teacher used to show her students that there is a link between the temperature of a gas and the speed of the gas particles. The ball-bearings represent the gas particles. Switching the motor on makes the ball-bearings move around in all directions. (i) How is the motion of the ball-bearings similar to the motion of the gas particles? () The faster the motor runs, the faster the ball-bearings move. Increasing the speed of the motor is like increasing the temperature of a gas. Use the model to predict what happens to the speed of the gas particles when the temperature of a gas is increased. () (Total 6 marks) Page 6 of 34

4 According to kinetic theory, all matter is made up of small particles. The particles are constantly moving. Diagram shows how the particles may be arranged in a solid. Diagram One kilogram of a gas has a much larger volume than one kilogram of a solid. Use kinetic theory to explain why. (4) Page 7 of 34

(b) Diagram 2 shows the particles in a liquid. The liquid is evaporating. Diagram 2 (i) How can you tell from Diagram 2 that the liquid is evaporating? () The temperature of the liquid in the container decreases as the liquid evaporates. Use kinetic theory to explain why. (3) (Total 8 marks) Page 8 of 34

5 The diagrams, X, Y and Z, show how the particles are arranged in the three states of matter. (i) Which one of the diagrams, X, Y or Z, shows the arrangement of particles in a liquid? Write the correct answer in the box. () Which one of the diagrams, X, Y or Z, shows the arrangement of particles in a gas? Write the correct answer in the box. () (b) Draw a ring around the correct answer in each box to complete each sentence. vibrating in fixed positions. (i) In a gas, the particles are moving randomly. not moving. () stronger than In a solid, the forces between the particles are equal to the forces between weaker than the particles in a liquid. () Page 9 of 34

(c) The picture shows a puddle of water in a road, after a rain shower. (i) During the day, the puddle of water dries up and disappears. This happens because the water particles move from the puddle into the air. What process causes water particles to move from the puddle into the air? Draw a ring around the correct answer. condensation evaporation radiation () Describe one change in the weather which would cause the puddle of water to dry up faster. () (Total 6 marks) 6 A company is developing a system which can heat up and melt ice on roads in the winter. This system is called energy storage. During the summer, the black surface of the road will heat up in the sunshine. This energy will be stored in a large amount of soil deep under the road surface. Pipes will run through the soil. In winter, cold water entering the pipes will be warmed and brought to the surface to melt ice. The system could work well because the road surface is black. Suggest why. () Page 0 of 34

(b) (i) What is meant by specific latent heat of fusion? (2) Calculate the amount of energy required to melt 5 kg of ice at 0 C. Specific latent heat of fusion of ice = 3.4 0 5 J/kg. Energy =... J (2) (c) Another way to keep roads clear of ice is to spread salt on them. When salt is added to ice, the melting point of the ice changes. A student investigated how the melting point of ice varies with the mass of salt added. The figure below shows the equipment that she used. The student added salt to crushed ice and measured the temperature at which the ice melted. (i) State one variable that the student should have controlled. () Page of 34

During the investigation the student stirred the crushed ice. Suggest two reasons why. Tick ( ) two boxes. Tick ( ) To raise the melting point of the ice To lower the melting point of the ice To distribute the salt throughout the ice To keep all the ice at the same temperature To reduce energy transfer from the surroundings to the ice (2) (iii) The table below shows the data that the student obtained. Mass of salt added in grams 0 0 20 Melting point of ice in C 0-6 -6 Describe the pattern shown in the table. () (d) Undersoil electrical heating systems are used in greenhouses. This system could also be used under a road. A cable just below the ground carries an electric current. One greenhouse system has a power output of 0.50 kw. Calculate the energy transferred in 2 minutes. Energy transferred =... J (3) Page 2 of 34

(e) In this question you will be assessed on using good English, organising information clearly and using specialist terms where appropriate. A local council wants to keep a particular section of a road clear of ice in the winter. Describe the advantages and disadvantages of keeping the road clear of ice using: energy storage salt undersoil electrical heating. Extra space... (6) (Total 8 marks) Page 3 of 34

7 Solid, liquid and gas are three different states of matter. Describe the difference between the solid and gas states, in terms of the arrangement and movement of their particles............ (4) (b) What is meant by specific latent heat of vaporisation?.... (2) (c) While a kettle boils, 0.08 kg of water changes to steam. Calculate the amount of energy required for this change. Specific latent heat of vaporisation of water = 2.3 0 6 J / kg.... Energy required =... J (2) Page 4 of 34

(d) The graph shows how temperature varies with time for a substance as it is heated. The graph is not drawn to scale. Explain what is happening to the substance in sections AB and BC of the graph. Section AB....... Section BC....... (4) (Total 2 marks) Page 5 of 34

8 The figure below shows a balloon filled with helium gas. Describe the movement of the particles of helium gas inside the balloon............. (2) (b) What name is given to the total kinetic energy and potential energy of all the particles of helium gas in the balloon? Tick one box. External energy Internal energy Movement energy () (c) Write down the equation which links density, mass and volume.... () Page 6 of 34

(d) The helium in the balloon has a mass of 0.00254 kg. The balloon has a volume of 0.04 m 3. Calculate the density of helium. Choose the correct unit from the box. m 3 / kg kg / m 3 kg m 3............ Density =... Unit... (3) (Total 7 marks) Page 7 of 34

9 A student investigated the cooling effect of evaporation. She used the equipment (datalogger and probe) shown in Figure to measure how the temperature of a liquid changed as the liquid evaporated. Figure Which type of variable was the temperature in this investigation? Tick ( ) one box. Tick ( ) control dependent independent () (b) Before the investigation started, the student checked the accuracy of three different temperature probes. The student put the probes in a beaker of boiling water that had a temperature of 00.0 C. The readings from the three temperature probes are shown in Figure 2. Figure 2 Page 8 of 34

Which one of the temperature probes, A, B or C, was least accurate? Write the correct answer in the box. Give a reason for your answer....... (2) Page 9 of 34

(c) Figure 3 shows how the temperature recorded changed during the investigation. Figure 3 (i) Use Figure 3 to determine the lowest temperature recorded as the liquid evaporated. Temperature =... C () Use Figure 3 to determine how long it took for all the liquid to evaporate. Give a reason for your answer. Time =... seconds Reason:...... (2) (iii) How would increasing the starting temperature of the liquid above 20 C affect the rate of evaporation of the liquid?...... () (Total 7 marks) Page 20 of 34

0 A student wants to calculate the density of the two objects shown in the figure below. Whitehoune/iStock/Thinkstock, Marc Dietrich/Hemera/Thinkstock Describe the methods that the student should use to calculate the densities of the two objects............................... (Total 6 marks) Page 2 of 34

Mark schemes Student A s measurements had a higher resolution Student B was more likely to misread the temperature (b) a random error (c) 8.4 C (d) 740 (seconds) allow answers in the range 730 780 (e) 0.40 99 000 79 600 (J) accept 79 600 (J) with no working shown for 2 marks (f) stearic acid has a higher temperature than the surroundings accept stearic acid is hotter than the surroundings temperature will decrease until stearic acid is the same as the room temperature / surroundings [9] 2 ions / electrons gain (kinetic) energy accept atom / particles / molecules for ion accept ions vibrate faster accept ions vibrate with a bigger amplitude accept ions vibrate more do not accept ions move faster (free) electrons transfer energy by collision with ions or energy transferred by collisions between vibrating ions Page 22 of 34

(b) (c) move faster or take up more space do not accept start to move / vibrate (warmer) water expands or becomes less dense (than cooler water) do not accept answers in terms of particles expanding warm water rises (through colder water) or colder water falls to take its place transfer of energy by waves / infrared (radiation) accept rays for waves do not accept transfer of energy by electromagnetic waves ignore reference to heat [6] 3 (i) random distribution of circles in the box with at least 50 % of circles touching random distribution of circles occupies more than 50 % of the space judged by eye (large) gaps between particles accept particles do not touch accept particles are spread out (so) easy to push particles closer (together) or forces between particles are negligible / none an answer in terms of number of particles is insufficient (b) (i) (both are) random accept a correct description of random eg unpredictable or move around freely or in all directions they take up all the space is insufficient they are spread out is insufficient they move in straight lines is insufficient (speed also) increases Page 23 of 34

[6] 4 there are strong forces (of attraction) between the particles in a solid accept molecules / atoms for particles throughout accept bonds for forces (holding) the particles close together particles in a solid are less spread out is insufficient or (holding) the particles in a fixed pattern / positions but in a gas the forces between the particles are negligible accept very small / zero for negligible accept bonds for forces so the particles spread out (to fill their container) accept particles are not close together gas particles are not in a fixed position is insufficient (b) (i) particles are (shown) leaving (the liquid / container) accept molecules / atoms for particles throughout accept particles are escaping particles are getting further apart is insufficient accept molecules / atoms for particles throughout accept speed / velocity for energy throughout particles with most energy leave the (surface of the) liquid accept fastest particles leave the liquid so the mean / average energy of the remaining particles goes down and the lower the average energy (of the particles) the lower the temperature (of the liquid) [8] 5 (i) Z X Page 24 of 34

(b) (i) moving randomly stronger than (c) (i) evaporation any one from: becomes windy temperature increases accept (becomes) sunny the sun alone is insufficient less humid [6] 6 (black) is a good absorber of (infrared) radiation (b) (i) amount of energy required to change (the state of a substance) from solid to liquid (with no change in temperature) melt is insufficient unit mass / kg 5. 0 6 (J) accept 5 x 0 6 allow mark for correct substitution ie E = 5 3.4 0 5 2 (c) (i) mass of ice allow volume / weight / amount / quantity of ice (iii) to distribute the salt throughout the ice to keep all the ice at the same temperature melting point decreases as the mass of salt is increased allow concentration for mass accept negative correlation do not accept inversely proportional Page 25 of 34

(d) 60 000 (J) accept 60 KJ allow 2 marks for correct substitution ie E = 500 2.0 60 allow 2 marks for an answer of 000 or 60 allow mark for correct substitution ie E = 500 2.0 or 0.50 2.0 60 allow mark for an answer of 3 Page 26 of 34

(e) Marks awarded for this answer will be determined by the Quality of Communication (QC) as well as the standard of the scientific response. Examiners should also apply a best-fit approach to the marking. 0 marks No relevant content Level ( 2 marks) There is an attempt at a description of some advantages or disadvantages. Level 2 (3 4 marks) There is a basic description of some advantages and / or disadvantages for some of the methods Level 3 (5 6 marks) There is a clear description of the advantages and disadvantages of all the methods. examples of the points made in the response energy storage advantages: extra information no fuel costs no environmental effects disadvantages: expensive to set up and maintain need to dig deep under road dependent on (summer) weather digging up earth and disrupting habitats salt spreading advantages: easily available cheap disadvantages: can damage trees / plants / drinking water / cars needs to be cleaned away undersoil heating advantages: not dependent on weather can be switched on and off disadvantages: Page 27 of 34

costly bad for environment 6 [8] 7 solid particles vibrate about fixed positions closely packed accept regular gas particles move randomly accept particles move faster accept freely for randomly far apart (b) amount of energy required to change the state of a substance from liquid to gas (vapour) unit mass / kg dependent on first marking point (c) 4000 or 4. 0 4 (J) accept 4400 or 4.4 0 4 correct substitution of 0.08 2.3 0 6 gains mark 2 (d) AB changing state from solid to liquid / melting at steady temperature dependent on first AB mark BC temperature of liquid rises until it reaches boiling point dependent on first BC mark [2] Page 28 of 34

8 range of speeds moving in different directions accept random motion (b) internal energy (c) density = mass / volume (d) 0.00254 / 0.04 0.8 accept 0.8 with no working shown for the 2 calculation marks kg / m 3 [7] Page 29 of 34

9 dependent (b) (probe) C allow 03.2 largest difference between reading and actual temperature reason only scores if C chosen accept larger it is 3.2 greater is insufficient comparing C with only one other probe is insufficient (c) (i) 2( C) accept a value between 2.0 and 2.2 inclusive 40 (seconds) accept an answer between 30 and 50 inclusive temperature starts to rise only scores if time mark awarded accept the temperature was lowest (at this time) (iii) increase accept faster (rate) [7] Page 30 of 34

0 Level 3 (5 6 marks): Clear and coherent description of both methods including equation needed to calculate density. Steps are logically ordered and could be followed by someone else to obtain valid results. Level 2 (3 4 marks): Clear description of one method to measure density or partial description of both methods. Steps may not be logically ordered. Level ( 2 marks): Basic description of measurements needed with no indication of how to use them. 0 marks: No relevant content. Indicative content For both: measure mass using a balance calculate density using ρ = m / V Metal cube: measure length of cube s sides using a ruler calculate volume Small statue: immerse in water measure volume / mass of water displaced volume of water displaced = volume of small statue [6] Page 3 of 34

Examiner reports 2 This question was very poorly answered. Many candidates stated that particles start to vibrate, rather than vibrate faster. (b) (c) Candidates confused conduction and convection and frequently wrote about particles expanding and becoming less dense. Answers were generally poor. Few candidates mentioned waves, rays or infrared and many wrote about heat transferring to the air, or heat moving from hot to cold. 3 (i) Students found great difficulty in drawing a representation of a liquid - many of the diagrams looking like the structure of a gas rather than a liquid. A poorly answered question, with only the very best students scoring both marks. Many students simply stated that there were fewer particles in a gas. (b) (i) Students found difficulty in describing the way in which the motion of the ball bearings was similar to that of the gas particles; the difficulty was often with the language rather than the science. Some students referred to the ball bearings in the model instead of to the particles in the gas. Some students simply said that the particles moved more. There were many students who failed to attempt this question. 4 Whilst many answers referred to the arrangement of particles in solids and gases, fewer responses referred to the forces between the particles. (b) (i) Just under half of the students answered correctly in terms of particles leaving the container / liquid. Other answers seen just referred to the particles rising. Many answers referred to particles needing energy to escape, but often just stated gaining energy, without specifying that they had more energy than the particles that remained. Very few students gained the second marking point because they did not refer to mean / average energy. A fair number of students gained the third mark by linking a decrease in energy to the decrease in temperature. Page 32 of 34

5 (i) Nearly all students answered this correctly. Nearly all students answered this correctly. (b) (i) Nearly all students answered this correctly. Nearly all students answered this correctly. (c) (i) The majority of students correcty chose evaporation. Most students knew that if the weather became warmer or more windy the puddle of water would evaporate faster. A few students were unspecific and simply wrote temperature or the Sun. 6 Three-quarters of students knew why an energy storage system would work if the road surface was black. Many answers stated that black surfaces absorb heat rather than absorb heat well. (b) (i) A quarter of students gave a correct definition of specific latent heat of fusion. However, many incorrect responses referred to melting rather than a change from solid to liquid. Nearly all students correctly calculated the amount of energy required to melt the ice. (c) (i) Two-thirds of students correctly stated that the variable to be controlled was mass of ice. The remainder stated that the mass of salt had to be controlled. (iii) Two-thirds of students correctly ticked two boxes with suggestions as to why the student stirred the crushed ice. Nearly all students could correctly describe the pattern of how mass of salt added to some crushed ice affected the melting point of the ice. (d) (e) Just under half of students scored full marks for a calculation of energy transferred given values of power and time in non-si units. Conversion from: kw to W; and minutes to seconds, was required. The spread of marks demonstrated this, with a third of students dropping one mark. The Quality of Communication question brought together the elements of the entire question and asked for advantages and disadvantages of using energy storage, salt and undersoil heating for keeping a road free from ice in the winter. Most students used the available space and many used additional pages. 9 Three-quarters of students scored four marks or more. Some excellent work was seen, but many students wasted time by repeating much of what was in the question. Also they ended a very good account with an unnecessary summary. Some very well written work only addressed either an advantage or a disadvantage of each system. Just over a third of students scored this mark. The most common incorrect answer was control. Page 33 of 34

(b) Almost three quarters of students scored the mark for choosing probe C, a lot of students found it difficult to articulate their ideas to explain their choice. A common incorrect answer was that C was an anomaly, or was inaccurate because it was above 00⁰C and the temperature should have been going down, not up. Just over a third of students scored both marks. (c) (i) Just over half of students scored this mark. Some students incorrectly read the scale and were outside the tolerance; others misunderstood the graph and stated 20 C or 3.5 C. (iii) A quarter of students scored only mark by stating the correct time, but a fifth of students scored both marks. Half of students scored this mark, most incorrect responses stated the opposite effect, that rate of evaporation would be lower. Page 34 of 34