Responding to the 2016 and 2017 Mass Coral Bleaching events on the Great Barrier Reef: from Observations to Modelling EMatson@aims Craig Steinberg & Claire Spillman N. Cantin, J. Benthuysen, H. Tonin, S. Bainbridge, F. McAllister, R. Brinkman, M. Herzfeld, M. Baird, C. Sun, W. Skirving, R. Pears, T. Simpson, C. Pattiaratchi E. Klein Salas
Recent marine heatwave Alert Level 1: Significant coral bleaching Alert Level 2: Widespread coral bleaching and significant mortality More than 70% of coral reefs around the world have experienced heat stress that can cause bleaching and/or mortality since January 2014. NOAA Coral Reef Watch; Liu et al 2014
Monthly GBR SST 30.0 29.0 28.0 Mean Monthly Observed SST: GBR Climatology 2015 2016 2017 27.0 26.0 25.0 24.0 23.0 Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec ERSSTv4 data set: 1961-1990 climatology
2016 vs 2017 January March 2016 SST percentiles 2016 2017 ENSO El Niño Neutral Cloudiness Less cloudy than normal Normal January March 2017 SST percentiles SST January, February, March and April hottest since 1900 March second hottest since 1900 Tropical cyclones None over GBR (TCs Tatiana and Winston in Coral Sea) Severe TC Debbie late March Climate change a factor in both events through rising ocean temperatures
Seasonal forecasting POAMA ACCESS-S POAMA current Bureau global operational dynamical seasonal forecast system POAMA assimilates Argo, XBT, buoy, satellite SST and altimetry data POAMA GBR forecasts first operational dynamical forecasts of coral bleaching risk in the world ACCESS-S1 to replace POAMA operationally in 2018 UKMO collaboration ACCESS-S1 assimilates satellite & in situ SST, in situ T&S profiles, altimetry & satellite sea ice New operational seasonal GBR products March 2018 New operational Australia-wide SST and thermal stress products June 2019 Ocean model grid resolutions
Forecasts for March 2016 http://poama.bom.gov.au Did POAMA predict 2016? 20151001 20151101 20151203 20151217 20160103 20160114 20160131 20160214 20160228 Predictions in Oct/Nov 2015: Strong El Niño Warmer than normal summer SST 40% probability of DHM > 1 on GBR Predictions in Feb/March 2017: Local weather impacts in February increased SST predictions for March Warmer that average SST conditions predicted for GBR for March Very high probability of DHM > 1
Forecasts for March 2017 http://poama.bom.gov.au Did POAMA predict 2017? 20161120 20161201 20161229 20170119 20170202 20170216 2017226 20170312 20170323 Predictions in November 2016: La Niña WATCH status Near average SST conditions predicted for GBR for summer months Low probability of DHM > 1 over GBR Predictions in February/March 2017: Warmer that average SST conditions predicted for GBR for March Very high probability of DHM > 1
Monitoring the events ReefTemp Next Gen: Operational high resolution (2km x 2km) daily satellite SST monitoring tool IMOS L3S night-only daily SST Developed under ereefs Accumulation of daily thermal stress (Degree Heating Days): Green = ok Yellow = watch Orange = worry Upgrade planned for 2018/19 Garde et al (2014)
Monitoring Reef Weather NOAA Degree Heating Weeks (DHW s) AIMS reef weather stations & IMOS sensor networks
Great Barrier Reef > 2000km (1200miles) long ~ 3000 individual reefs and islands Coastal Barrier ecosystem Spatial size = challenging ecosystem to monitor & fully document major change AIMS Long-term monitoring began systematic repetitive surveys between 1980-1992 Co-ordinated approaches are key
RESPONDING TO A CORAL BLEACHING EVENT AERIAL SURVEYS
Coral mortality in 2016 "Based on combined survey results so far, the overall mortality is 22% and about 85% of that die-off has occurred in the far north between the tip of Cape York and just north of Lizard Island, 250 km north of Cairns." Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (GBRMPA), June 2016
A second successive bleaching in 2017
RESPONDING TO A CORAL BLEACHING EVENT 50 m x 1m belt transects Bleaching severity of all corals within the 1m quadrat scored for bleaching severity Community bleaching severity (%) Live coral cover using Line Intercept methods IN WATER SCUBA SURVEYS Flat Crest Slope 5 x 10m Transects per site. NO/MINOR BLEACHING SEVERELY BLEACHED AND DEAD
BLEACHING SEVERITY NO BLEACHING MINOR: 1-50% MAJOR: 50-95% SEVERE: 95-100% white & fluorescent RECENT MORTALITY
Bleached Porites Long-lived, old individuals 100-400 yrs Tolerant coral species Bleached and Partial mortality of tissue Surviving tissue overgrows sections of partial mortality June 2016 June 2016 ncantin_aims ncantin_aims
Sentinel-2 captures coral bleaching processed by J. Hedley; conceptual model by C. Roelfsema Images from the Copernicus Sentinel-2A satellite captured on 8 June 2016 and 23 February 2017 for Adelaide Reef, Central GBR.
16 & 17 dramatic increase in both heat stress and bleaching severity 1998 2002 2016 2017 Bleaching Severity SST Anomaly AIMS: Hughes Australia s et al., tropical 2017; marine Berkelmans research agency. et al. 2004
Slocum gliders track sub-surface warming in the Great Barrier Reef March 2016 Sea Surface Temperature Anomaly North East Cooktown 22 Mar 2016 S Cairns 12 Apr 2016 0 m 50 m E IMOS OceanCurrent News, 24 May 2016 100 m 200 m ( C)
E March 2017 Sea Surface Temperature S Townsville East 22 Mar 2016 North Slocum gliders track sub-surface warming in the Great Barrier Reef 200 m 100 m Cairns ( C)
Palm Passage mooring: bottom intrusions Temperature -15 2009-2010 2010-2011 -15-15 2011-2012 T ( o C) 30 z (m) z (m) z (m) 28-60 -15 2012-2013 -60-15 -60 2013-2014 -15 2014-2015 26 24 22 z (m) z (m) z (m) -60-60 -60 October - April -15 2015-2016 z (m) -60
ex TC Tatiana and TC Winston in 2016 Distant or low end tropical cyclones can have a silver lining
ereefs 3D captures cooling mechanisms
Differential heating on drying reefs 200m downscaled model GBR1 GBR4 4km model Mongin, CSIRO
ereefs RECOM DHW Elofer & Baird, CSIRO & Cantin AIMS
TC Debbie http://poama.bom.gov.au TC Debbie led to cooling of surface waters over the mid and southern GBR in late March. This is reflected in cooler mean observed SST for April 2017 as well as seasonal outlooks for April.
Oceancurrent 95m below the surface TC Debbie March 29, 2007 Mean Monthly Observed SST: GBR Courtesy Gary Brassington, BoM
Bleaching Thresholds in a warming ocean Increased frequency of extreme thermal anomalies influence bleaching thresholds? Can corals adapt and keep pace with the rising trend in temperature? Frieler et al. 2012, Nature Climate Change
Thank you Dr Claire Spillman (03) 9669 8105 claire.spillman@bom.gov.au Craig Steinberg c.steinberg@aims.gov.au OceanCurrent http://oceancurrent.imos.org.au ReefTemp Next Generation: http://www.bom.gov.au/environment/activities/ reeftemp/reeftemp.shtml POAMA seasonal forecasts http://poama.bom.gov.au ereefs http://ereefs.org.au/ereefs AIMS Weather http://weather.aims.gov.au/ http://www.bom.gov.au/environment/doc/marine-heatwave-2016.pdf