Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! Andreas Ringwald DESY Graduiertenkolleg und EMG Seminar Johannes Gutenberg Universität Mainz 10 November 2010, Mainz, D
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 1 1. Motivation Models related to dark matter suggest existence of long-range forces mediated by new gauge bosons with masses in the MeV to GeV range and very weak coupling to ordinary matter: Hidden or Dark Photons Appear naturally in models descending from strings Experimental particle physics community has started to develop strategies and to form collaborations to attack these dark forces Fixed-target experiments exploiting electron beams especially sensitive Opportunity for new experiments at DESY, MAMI, and JLab
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 2 Table of Content: 2. Physics Case for Dark Forces 3. Attacking Dark Forces with Fixed-Target Experiments 4. Conclusions
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 3 2. Physics Case for Dark Forces Standard Model (SM) describes only 5 % of the universe: There are particles beyond the SM
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 4 Constituents of dark matter could be WIMPs: Weakly Interacting Massive Particles Super-WIMPs: Super-Weakly Interacting Massive Particles WISPs: very Weakly Interacting Slim Particles Embedding of standard model in supergravity or string theory particles beyond the standard model, in all three categories: WIMPs: neutralinos, sneutrinos,... Super-WIMPs: gravitinos, axinos, hidden U(1) gauginos,... WISPs: axions, axion-like particles, hidden U(1) gauge bosons,... Extra U(1) gauge bosons ubiquitous in well motivated extensions of the SM with large rank local gauge group: large gauge symmetries must be broken U(1)s are the lowest-rank local symmetries
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 5 Some of these extra U(1) factors can be hidden (no SM particles charged under them) Hidden U(1) gauge factors ubiquitous in string compactifications: heterotic string: arise e.g. in standard embedding, E 8 E 8 E 6 E 8 SU(3) c SU(2) L U(1) }{{ Y U(1) } hid, standard model from breaking of second E 8 type II/F theory: KK zero modes of closed string RR form fields massless excitations of space-time filling D-branes separated in compact space from locus of SM branes Hidden U(1) gauge bosons ( photons ) may be light, m γ TeV
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 6 At low energies, hidden U(1)s interact with the SM dominantly via kinetic mixing with U(1) Y or U(1) em, [Holdom 85] L 1 4 F (vis) µν F µν (vis) 1 4 F (hid) µν F µν (hid) + χ 2 F (vis) µν F (hid)µν + m 2 γ A (hid) µ A (hid)µ χ 1 generated at loop level via messenger exchange, 10 12 < χ g Y g h (16π) 2 f < 10 3 g h and f depend on the type of messenger: µ Va ν Vb
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 7 Kinetic mixing in field theory: [Holdom 85; Dienes,Kolda,March-Russell 97] 10 8 χ α ( ) q ) m (1 4π C log + 10 3, m for 1 < C < 10; q = 1, 2; 10 2 < m m < 1 Kinetic mixing between D-brane localized U(1)s in type II compactifications: [...;Abel,Schofield 04; Abel,Jaeckel,Khoze,AR 06;...;Goodsell et al. 09] 10 12 χ g Y g h 16π 2 2πg s 16π 2 ( 4π g 2 s Ms 2 ) q/12 MP 2 10 3, for q = 0, 4; 10 3 GeV M s 10 17 GeV
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 8 Current constraints on hidden U(1)s: [Bartlett,.. 88; Kumar,.. 06; Ahlers,.. 07; Jaeckel,.. 07; Redondo,.. 08;Postma,Redondo 08;Bjorken,Essig,Schuster,Toro 09;...] Log 10 Χ 10 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Jupiter Earth CMB Coulomb FIRAS hcmb LSW CAST Rydberg Solar Lifetime a e,μ 3 E774 E141 E137 EW 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 11 12 13 14 HB 12 13 14 15 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Log 10 m Γ' ev Deviations from 1/r 2 (Jupiter,Coulomb); γ γ oscillations (CMB,Light Shining through a Wall (LSW); stellar evolution (Sun,HB); g 2; fixed target; e + e (Υ,EW) 15
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 9 ALPS (Any-Light Particle Search): [AEI, DESY, Hamburger Sternwarte, Laser Zentrum Hannover] γ laser φ γ laser B B
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 10 ALPS (Any-Light Particle Search): [AEI, DESY, Hamburger Sternwarte, Laser Zentrum Hannover] γ γ γ γ
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 11 Last ALPS run end of 2009 [Phys. Lett. B 689 (2010) 149-155] Not a WISP of evidence [Nature 465 (2010) 271] [ALPS Collaboration 10]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 12 MeV-GeV scale hidden photon (dark force, dark photon,...) may explain (g 2) µ anomaly [Pospelov 08] may explain [Arkani-Hamed et al. 08; Pospelov,Ritz 08;...] terrestrial (DAMA, CoGeNT vs. CDMS, XENON) and cosmic ray (PAMELA, FERMI) DM anomalies if DM charged under hidden U(1) can be checked in new fixed-target experiments
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 13 Contribution of sub-gev scale γ to anomalous magnetic moment, a γ l = αχ2 1 2π 0 2m 2 { lz(1 z)2 αχ2 dz m 2 l (1 z)2 + m 2 = γ z 2π 1 for m l m γ, 2m 2 l /(3m2 γ ) for m l m γ, may explain a µ anomaly: [Pospelov 08] [Pospelov 08]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 14 Dark matter interpretation of annual modulation signal observed by DAMA and of excess of low energy events in CoGeNT not in conflict with null results of CDMS and XENON if χ-nucleus scattering dominated by elastic process, χ + N χ + N, with low mass m χ 5 10 GeV inelastic process, χ+n χ +N, with mass splitting m 100 kev Can be mediated by kinetically mixed sub-gev scale γ [Andreas et al. 10; CDMS II 10]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 15 Explanation of electron and/or positron excesses by PAMELA, FERMI,... in terms of thermal relic dark matter annihilation requires enhanced annihilation cross-section (boost factor) leptophilic final state [Meade,Papucci,Strumia,Volansky 09] Can be achieved via χ + χ γ + γ, if 2 m e < m γ m p [Arkani-Hamed,Finkbeiner,Slatyer,Weiner 08; Batell,Pospelov,Ritz 09;...]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 16 3. Attacking Dark Forces with Fixed-Target Experiments Fixed-target experiments with intense electron beams particularly sensitive to MeV-GeV scale hidden photon [Reece,Wang 09; Bjorken,Essig,Schuster,Toro 09] Production via γ Bremsstrahlung: σ en enγ α3 Z 2 χ 2 m 2 γ 1 pb ( χ 10 5 ) 2 ( 100 MeV m γ ) 2
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 17 Kinematics and geometry: e γ ( m γ E )3/2 (narrow) ( m γ E )1/2 (wide) m γ E l + l E γ E beam e E e m γ [Toro 09; Andreas 10]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 18 Decay length of γ e + e, ( )( ) E 10 5 2 ( 100 MeV l d = γcτ 8 cm GeV χ m γ varies a lot in parameter range or interest Multiple experimental approaches, with different strategies for fighting backgrounds: l d cm: beam dump; low background l d cm: vertex; limited by instrumental bkg l d cm: bump hunt; fight bkg with high intensity, resolution New experiments funded/proposed/designed/commissioned at DESY (HIPS), MAMI (A1 Collaboration), and JLab (APEX, DarkLight, HPS) ) 2
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 19 Past beam dumps: [Bjorken,Essig,Schuster,Toro 09] SLAC E137: 30 C, 20 GeV, 200 m, 200 m SLAC E141:.3 mc, 9 GeV, 10 cm, 35 m Fermilab E774:.8 nc, 275 GeV (p), 30 cm, 7 m
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 20 HIPS (HIdden Particle Search): a new beam dump experiment at DESY II (10 na,.45 7 GeV); funded by SFB 676 [Andreas,Bechtle,Ehrlichmann,Garutti,Lindner,Niebuhr,AR,Soloviev]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 21 HIPS (HIdden Particle Search): a new beam dump experiment at DESY II (10 na,.45 7 GeV); funded by SFB 676 [Andreas,Bechtle,Ehrlichmann,Garutti,Lindner,Niebuhr,AR,Soloviev]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 22 HIPS (HIdden Particle Search): a new beam dump experiment at DESY II (10 na,.45 7 GeV); funded by SFB 676 [Andreas,Bechtle,Ehrlichmann,Garutti,Lindner,Niebuhr,AR,Soloviev] Current situation: detector parts (H1 electron tagger) installed for background studies simulations for background, signal and sensitivity ongoing plans for 2011: install beam line in January install ZEUS MVX detector and CALICE ECAL take data
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 23 HIPS (HIdden Particle Search): a new beam dump experiment at DESY II (10 na,.45 7 GeV); funded by SFB 676 [Andreas,Bechtle,Ehrlichmann,Garutti,Lindner,Niebuhr,AR,Soloviev] [Andreas,AR 10]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 24 HIPS (HIdden Particle Search): a new beam dump experiment at DESY II (10 na,.45 7 GeV); funded by SFB 676 [Andreas,Bechtle,Ehrlichmann,Garutti,Lindner,Niebuhr,AR,Soloviev] [Andreas,AR 10] A. Ringwald (DESY) Mainz, November 2010
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 25 APEX at JLab and dark photon search by the A1 collaboration (MAMI): bump hunts exploiting large data samples (due to currents in 100 µa range) taken by high resolution spectrometers to search for a peak in the e + e invariant mass distribution (pilot runs already took place) Backgrounds to fight with:
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 26 APEX at JLab and dark photon search by the A1 collaboration (MAMI): bump hunts exploiting large data samples (due to currents in 100 µa range) taken by high resolution spectrometers to search for a peak in the e + e invariant mass distribution (pilot runs already took place) Raw rates: [Essig et sl. 10]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 27 APEX at JLab and dark photon search by the A1 collaboration (MAMI): bump hunts exploiting large data samples (due to currents in 100 µa range) taken by high resolution spectrometers to search for a peak in the e + e invariant mass distribution (pilot runs already took place) After cuts: [Essig et sl. 10]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 28 APEX at JLab and dark photon search by the A1 collaboration (MAMI): bump hunts exploiting large data samples (due to currents in 100 µa range) taken by high resolution spectrometers to search for a peak in the e+e invariant mass distribution (pilot runs already took place) [Andreas,AR 10] A. Ringwald (DESY) Mainz, November 2010
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 29 Proposals: JLab: HPS at CEBAF; DarkLight at FEL (10 ma; E max = 140 MeV); Mainz internal gas experiment at proposed MESA facility [Freytsis, Ovanesyan, Thaler 09]
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 30 Proposals: JLab: HPS at CEBAF; DarkLight at FEL (10 ma; Emax = 140 MeV); Mainz internal gas experiment at proposed MESA facility [Andreas,AR 10] A. Ringwald (DESY) Mainz, November 2010
Sub-GeV Scale Dark Forces?! 31 4. Conclusions Strong physics motivation for the possible existence of GeV-scale hidden/dark photons: top down: many extra U(1)s in string compactifications bottom up: anomalies associated with dark matter and (g 2) µ Fixed-target experiments well suited to attack dark forces Large parameter space requires multiple search strategies and experiments low coupling/mass: new beam dump experiments intermediate region: new forward-geometry experiments high coupling/mass: standard wide-angle spectrometers Great opportunities for new particle physics experiments at intensity frontier at DESY, MAMI, and JLab!