Analysis of composite hydrogen storage cylinders subjected to localized flame impingements

Similar documents
Modeling and simulation of high pressure composite cylinders for hydrogen storage

A MODEL AND FINITE ELEMENT IMPLEMENTATION FOR THE THERMO-MECHANICAL ANALYSIS OF POLYMER COMPOSITES EXPOSED TO FIRE

Influence of the filament winding process variables on the mechanical behavior of a composite pressure vessel

An Integrated Thermomechanical Method for Modeling Fiber Reinforced Polymer Composite Structures in Fire. Ziqing Yu¹ and Aixi Zhou²

Analysis of Composite Pressure Vessels

SIMULATION OF PROGRESSIVE FAILURE PREDICTION OF FILAMENT WOUND COMPOSITE TUBES SUBJECTED TO MULTIPLE LOADING WITH MEMBRANE-FLEXION COUPLING EFFECTS

Tensile behaviour of anti-symmetric CFRP composite

TABLE OF CONTENTS. Mechanics of Composite Materials, Second Edition Autar K Kaw University of South Florida, Tampa, USA

Prediction of Elastic Constants on 3D Four-directional Braided

QUESTION BANK Composite Materials

NUTC R296. Advanced Moisture Modeling of Polymer Composites. K. Chandrashekhara Curators Professor Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering

Modelling the nonlinear shear stress-strain response of glass fibrereinforced composites. Part II: Model development and finite element simulations

THE MUTUAL EFFECTS OF SHEAR AND TRANSVERSE DAMAGE IN POLYMERIC COMPOSITES

EXPLICIT DYNAMIC SIMULATION OF DROP-WEIGHT LOW VELOCITY IMPACT ON CARBON FIBROUS COMPOSITE PANELS

Numerical Analysis of Composite Panels in the Post-Buckling Field taking into account Progressive Failure

Modeling of Composite Panel Under Fire and Compression

Hygrothermal stresses in laminates

FRACTURE MECHANICS OF COMPOSITES WITH RESIDUAL STRESSES, TRACTION-LOADED CRACKS, AND IMPERFECT INTERFACES

THERMOELASTIC ANALYSIS OF THICK-WALLED FINITE-LENGTH CYLINDERS OF FUNCTIONALLY GRADED MATERIALS

Crash and Impact Simulation of Composite Structures by Using CAE Process Chain

Progressive Damage of GFRP Composite Plate Under Ballistic Impact: Experimental and Numerical Study

SIMULTANEOUS MEASUREMENT OF APPARENT THERMAL DIFFUSIVITY AND DISTORTION OF COMPOSITES AT HIGH TEMPERATURE

Effect of Thermal Stresses on the Failure Criteria of Fiber Composites

ME 582 Advanced Materials Science. Chapter 2 Macromechanical Analysis of a Lamina (Part 2)

A Study on the Tube of Integral Propeller Shaft for the Rear-wheel Drive Automobile Using Carbon Composite Fiber

THERMO-MECHANICAL RESPONSES OF FLAME- RETARDED FIBRE REINFORCED COMPOSITES AFTER EXPOSURE TO CONVECTIVE AND RADIATIVE HEAT

Experimental Study of the Induced Residual Stresses During the Manufacturing Process of an Aeronautic Composite Material

Computational Analysis for Composites

Multi Disciplinary Delamination Studies In Frp Composites Using 3d Finite Element Analysis Mohan Rentala

The Accuracy of Characteristic Length Method on Failure Load Prediction of Composite Pinned Joints

Calculation of Damage-dependent Directional Failure Indices from the Tsai-Wu Static Failure Criterion

ISSN: ISO 9001:2008 Certified International Journal of Engineering Science and Innovative Technology (IJESIT) Volume 2, Issue 4, July 2013

SIMULATION AND TESTING OF STRUCTURAL COMPOSITE MATERIALS EXPOSED TO FIRE DEGRADATION

Non-conventional Glass fiber NCF composites with thermoset and thermoplastic matrices. F Talence, France Le Cheylard, France

Fire Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Beams with 2-D Plane Stress Concrete Model

Module 7: Micromechanics Lecture 29: Background of Concentric Cylinder Assemblage Model. Introduction. The Lecture Contains

Passive Damping Characteristics of Carbon Epoxy Composite Plates

DESIGN OF LAMINATES FOR IN-PLANE LOADING

MODELING THE EFFECTIVE ELASTIC MODULUS OF RC BEAMS EXPOSED TO FIRE

BEARING STRENGTH ASSESSMENT OF COMPOSITE MATERIAL THROUGH NUMERICAL MODELS

PLY LEVEL UNCERTAINTY EFFECTS ON FAILURE OF COMPOSITE

S. Srinivasan, Technip Offshore, Inc., Houston, TX

APPLICATION OF ISOTENSOID-BASED CROSS SECTIONS TO FILAMENT-WOUND TOROIDAL PRESSURE VESSELS

Strength of GRP-laminates with multiple fragment damages

Most of the material in this package is based on a recently published book. This is:

Numerical Analysis of Delamination Behavior in Laminated Composite with Double Delaminations Embedded in Different Depth Positions

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF APPLIED ENGINEERING RESEARCH, DINDIGUL Volume 2, No 1, 2011

Module 7: Micromechanics Lecture 25: Strength of Materials Approach. Introduction. The Lecture Contains. Effective Transverse Modulus

A FINITE ELEMENT MODEL TO PREDICT MULTI- AXIAL STRESS-STRAIN RESPONSE OF CERAMIC MATRIX COMPOSITES WITH STRAIN INDUCED DAMAGE

Numerical methods of multiaxial fatigue life prediction for elastomers under variable amplitude loadings

IJSER 1. INTRODUCTION. M.Elhadary

BIAXIAL STRENGTH INVESTIGATION OF CFRP COMPOSITE LAMINATES BY USING CRUCIFORM SPECIMENS

LS-DYNA MAT54 for simulating composite crash energy absorption

EXPERIMENTAL AND NUMERICAL STUDY OF THE ENERGY ABSORPTION CAPACITY OF PULTRUDED COMPOSITE TUBES

Stress-strain response and fracture behaviour of plain weave ceramic matrix composites under uni-axial tension, compression or shear

NUMERICAL FEM ANALYSIS FOR THE PART OF COMPOSITE HELICOPTER ROTOR BLADE

FINITE ELEMENT AND EXPERIMENTAL STUDY OF NOVEL CONCEPT OF 3D FIBRE CELL STRUCTURE

MODELING OF THE BEHAVIOR OF WOVEN LAMINATED COMPOSITES UNTIL RUPTURE

Calculation of Energy Release Rate in Mode I Delamination of Angle Ply Laminated Composites

Mechanical and Thermal Properties of Coir Fiber Reinforced Epoxy Composites Using a Micromechanical Approach

NUMERICAL INVESTIGATION OF DELAMINATION IN L-SHAPED CROSS-PLY COMPOSITE BRACKET

Prediction of The Ultimate Strength of Composite Laminates Under In-Plane Loading Using A Probabilistic Approach

Design and optimization of a variable stiffness composite laminate

PRELIMINARY PREDICTION OF SPECIMEN PROPERTIES CLT and 1 st order FEM analyses

MULTIDISCIPLINARY OPTIMIZATION OF A LIGHTWEIGHT TORPEDO STRUCTURE SUBJECTED TO UNDERWATER EXPLOSION

FRACTURE MECHANICS APPROACHES STRENGTHENING USING FRP MATERIALS

Fracture Mechanics of Composites with Residual Thermal Stresses

Composite angle ply laminates and netting analysis

NUMERICAL MODELING OF GAS LEAKAGE THROUGH DAMAGED COMPOSITE LAMINATES

Integrity of Composite Aircraft Fuselage Materials under Crash Fire Conditions. ABSTRACT

KINK BAND FORMATION OF FIBER REINFORCED POLYMER (FRP)

Prediction of Delamination Growth Behavior in a Carbon Fiber Composite Laminate Subjected to Constant Amplitude Compression-Compression Fatigue Loads

POST-PEAK BEHAVIOR OF FRP-JACKETED REINFORCED CONCRETE COLUMNS

ME Final Exam. PROBLEM NO. 4 Part A (2 points max.) M (x) y. z (neutral axis) beam cross-sec+on. 20 kip ft. 0.2 ft. 10 ft. 0.1 ft.

Micromechanical analysis of FRP hybrid composite lamina for in-plane transverse loading

CHAPTER 8 ENTROPY. Blank

Online publication date: 23 October 2010

Nonlinearities in mechanical behavior of textile composites

Failure Analysis of Unidirectional Composite Pinned- Joints

Capability Assessment of Finite Element Software in Predicting the Last Ply Failure of Composite Laminates

ME 7502 Lecture 2 Effective Properties of Particulate and Unidirectional Composites

OPTIMAL DESIGN OF COMPOSITE INSERTS FOR A HYBRID ULTRACENTRIFUGE ROTOR

DAMAGE SIMULATION OF CFRP LAMINATES UNDER HIGH VELOCITY PROJECTILE IMPACT

Failure analysis of serial pinned joints in composite materials

2D damping predictions of fiber composite plates: Layup effects

Composites: Part A 39 (2008) Contents lists available at ScienceDirect. Composites: Part A

Finite Element Analysis of Graphite/Epoxy Composite Pressure Vessel

THE ROLE OF DELAMINATION IN NOTCHED AND UNNOTCHED TENSILE STRENGTH

Modelling of multi-axial ultimate elastic wall stress (UEWS) test for glass fibre reinforced epoxy (GRE) composite pipes

Finite Element-Based Failure Models for Carbon/Epoxy Tape Composites

Numerical simulation of delamination onset and growth in laminated composites

3D Compression Molding

Thermal load-induced notch stress intensity factors derived from averaged strain energy density

Composite Damage Material Modeling for Crash Simulation: MAT54 & the Efforts of the CMH-17 Numerical Round Robin

Open-hole compressive strength prediction of CFRP composite laminates

IMPACT STRENGTH AND RESPONSE BEHAVIOR OF CFRP GUARDER BELT FOR SIDE COLLISION OF AUTOMOBILES

Calibration and Experimental Validation of LS-DYNA Composite Material Models by Multi Objective Optimization Techniques

Mechanics of Composite Materials, Second Edition Autar K Kaw University of South Florida, Tampa, USA

SHEAR CAPACITY OF REINFORCED CONCRETE COLUMNS RETROFITTED WITH VERY FLEXIBLE FIBER REINFORCED POLYMER WITH VERY LOW YOUNG S MODULUS

DYNAMIC FAILURE ANALYSIS OF LAMINATED COMPOSITE PLATES

Transcription:

Available at www.sciencedirect.com journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/he Analysis of composite hydrogen storage cylinders subjected to localized flame impingements J. Hu a, J. Chen a, S. Sundararaman a, K. Chandrashekhara a,, William Chernicoff b a Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Missouri University of Science and Technology, Rolla, MO 65409, USA b US Department of Transportation, Washington, DC 20509, USA article info Article history: Received 3 February 2008 Received in revised form 9 March 2008 Accepted 10 March 2008 Available online 9 May 2008 Keywords: Hydrogen storage Composite cylinder Flame impingement Finite element abstract A comprehensive non-linear finite element model is developed for predicting the behavior of composite hydrogen storage cylinders subjected to high pressure and localized flame impingements. The model is formulated in an axi-symmetric coordinate system and incorporates with various sub-models to describe the behavior of the composite cylinder under extreme thermo-mechanical loadings. A heat transfer sub-model is employed to predict the temperature evolution of the composite cylinder wall and accounts for heat transport due to decomposition and mass loss. A composite decomposition sub-model described by Arrhenius s law is implemented to predict the residual resin content of thermal damaged area. A sub-model for material degradation is implemented to account for the loss of mechanical properties. A progressive failure model is adopted to detect various types of mechanical failure. These sub-models are implemented in ABAQUS commercial finite element code using user subroutines. Numerical results are presented for thermal damage, residual properties and profile of resin content in the cylinder. The developed model provides a useful tool for safe design and structural assessment of high pressure composite hydrogen storage cylinders. & 2008 International Association for Hydrogen Energy. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. 1. Introduction High pressure composite cylinders for hydrogen storage are typically made with a high molecular weight polymer or aluminum liner that serves as a hydrogen gas permeation barrier. A filament-wound, carbon/epoxy composite laminate over-wrapped outside of the liner provides the desired pressure load bearing capacity. Due to the flammable nature of polymer-reinforced composites, there is a high risk of failure of the composite hydrogen storage cylinder under accidental fire exposure. As the stiffness and strength of composites are temperature dependent, the high pressure (usually 34.5 70.0 MPa) in the cylinder will result in a catastrophic failure. Therefore, assessment of structural integrity of high pressure composite hydrogen storage cylinders subjected to fire exposure is necessary for safe cylinder design. Many investigations have been conducted by various researches [1 4] on the behavior of high pressure composite cylinder under mechanical loadings. Using finite element method, numerous studies have been performed on highpressure vessels analysis [5 7]. Compared to pure mechanical loading and pure thermal loading, there have been few studies on the composite cylinders subjected to the combined thermal and mechanical loads [8,9]. However, those models only consider the temperature range before the composite decomposition and fall short of capability to assess the cylinder behavior subjected to fire impingement. To study fire Corresponding author. Tel.: +1 573 341 4587; fax: +1 573 341 6899. E-mail address: chandra@mst.edu (K. Chandrashekhara). 0360-3199/$ - see front matter & 2008 International Association for Hydrogen Energy. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.ijhydene.2008.03.012

2739 effect on composites, different one-dimensional thermal models have been developed to predict the temperature and the residual resin content as a function of time [10 12]. These models account for heat transfer by conduction, resin decomposition and the cooling effect of volatile products passing through the laminate. Therefore, to characterize the fire response of high pressure hydrogen composite cylinders, mechanisms of mechanical effect, thermal effect and decomposition have to be considered. In this paper, a coupled thermo-mechanical finite element model has been developed to simulate the composite hydrogen storage cylinder subjected to high pressure and heat flux on the wall surface. The model is formulated in an axi-symmetric coordinate system which accounts for out-of-plane stresses and reduces computational cost dramatically. When the polymer materials are exposed to a sufficiently high temperature (200 300 1C), decomposition reactions and thermo-chemical expansion begin to occur and the resin system degrades to form gaseous products and carbonaceous char. In order to incorporate this phenomenon, the thermal model is built to account for gas convection and heat generation of decomposition in addition to conduction of the composite, convection and radiation of surface. The fire source is modeled as a constant heat flux throughout the simulation. Inner pressure of the cylinder is dependent on temperature of hydrogen gas which is modeled as a sink temperature. The variation of material properties with temperature is significant for composites, especially at high temperatures. A temperature dependent material model has been developed and implemented. Hashin s theory is used as progressive failure criterion to predict different types of failure (matrix cracking and fiber breakage). These models are developed and implemented in commercial finite element code ABAQUS, using user subroutines. A typical high pressure hydrogen composite cylinder is simulated using the developed model and results from the parametric study are reported. 2. Modeling of high pressure composite hydrogen storage cylinders A strong sequentially coupled thermal-stress analysis approach is implemented for predicting the behavior of composite hydrogen cylinder subjected to flame impingements and internal high pressure. At each increment, the temperature profile is obtained using the thermal and resin reaction models. The temperature field is then imported to the mechanical model with material damage information from previous increment. The pressure of the inner cylinder is updated based on the heat absorption of hydrogen gas, which is computed from the temperature profile. The thermal and mechanical models are solved sequentially in each increment. As the wall consists of a large number of laminae, modeling each lamina will cause extraordinary computational cost, especially when thermal and damage models are also incorporated. Hence, a homogenization technique is used to smear several laminae to a sub-laminate as in Fig. 1. The equivalent moduli of the sub-laminate are used in the formulation of finite element model. 2.1. Thermal model The high temperature will cause the resin decomposition of the cylinder composite wall. The decomposition rate of the resin is usually represented by Arrhenius s law and can be expressed as [13] qr qt ¼ Ar expð E A=RTÞ (1) where r is the density, t is time, T is the temperature, A is the pre-exponential factor, E A is the activation energy and R is the gas constant. Material constants A and E A are determined using differential scanning calorimetry. With the consideration of resin reaction, the heat transfer equilibrium equation has to include resin decomposition energy and vaporous migration energy. As the dimension in thickness direction is much less than those of hoop and axial directions, the vaporous gas are only assumed to transfer in thickness direction. The axi-symmetric heat diffusion equation can be written as [14] rc p qt ¼ q k r þ 1 k r þ q qr qr r qr qz k z qz þ _m g C pg qr þ qr qt ðq h com h g Þ (2) Aluminum liner Outer S-glass/epoxy protective layer Inner structural carbon/epoxy hoop laminate sub laminate sub laminate sub laminate Aluminum Inner structural carbon/epoxy helical laminate 3 2 1 R out R in lamina N lamina 2 lamina 1 Fig. 1 Schematic of hydrogen cylinder.

2740 where C p is specific heat of composite, k is thermal conductivity, r is displacement through the thickness, _m g is gas mass flux, C pg is specific heat of gas, Q is heat of decomposition, h com is enthalpy of composite and h g enthalpy of hydrogen gas. The mass flow direction of the gas generated in the laminate is towards the hot face of the laminate. The total mass flux of the generated gas at a specific spatial location in the laminate is the sum of the gas mass flux generated from the inner face to this spatial location. The gas mass flux at any spatial location can be calculated as _m g ¼ rh tw qr qt dr h (3) where r h is distance from hot face and t W is wall thickness of composite. Equivalent engineering properties used for the simulation can be obtained from Eq. (8) as E 11 ¼ 1=S 44 ; E 22 ¼ 1=S 55 ; E 33 ¼ 1=S 11 G 12 ¼ 1=S 66 ; G 13 ¼ 1=S 33 ; G 23 ¼ 1=S 22 v 12 ¼ S 45 =S 44 ; v 13 ¼ S 14 =S 44 ; v 23 ¼ S 15 =S 55 (9) After the global stresses and strains of sub-laminates are obtained, the stresses in each lamina are obtained in the global material coordinates as ðs o Þ k ¼hs o i ðs i Þ k ¼ðB T Þ k hs o iþðdþ k h i i (10) where k is the kth lamina of the sub-laminate. Finally, the stresses in local material coordinate system can be obtained by standard coordinate transformation. 2.2. Sub-laminate model The principle of sub-laminate (Fig. 1) homogenization is based on the assumption that the in-plane strains and the interlaminar stresses through the thickness are constant [15 18]. The lamina stress strain relationship in global coordinate can be written as ( ) hs o i s i " ¼ C # oo C oi C 0 oi C ii ( ) o h i i where C oo, C oi and C ii are sub-matrices of global stiffness matrix, C 0 oi is the transpose of C oi, hs o i and s i are out-of-plane and in-plane stresses, respectively, o and h i i are out-of-plane and in-plane strains, respectively. hi represents the term is constant through laminate. Partially inverting Eq. (4) yields ( ) " o C 1 oo C 1 oo ¼ C # ( oi hs o i ) s i C 0 oi C 1 oo C 0 oi C 1 oo C (5) oi þ C ii i After averaging, Eq. (5) can be expressed as ( ) h o i ¼ A B ( hs o i ) s i B T D i where A ¼ XN k¼1 D ¼ XN k¼1 t k t ðc 1 oo Þ ; B ¼ XN t k k t ðc 1 oo C oiþ k k¼1 t k t ð C0 oi C 1 oo C oi þ C ii Þ k t k is the thickness of each lamina in the smeared sublaminate and t is the total thickness of the smeared sublaminate. Partially inverting Eq. (6) yields the equivalent stiffness matrix Q eq of the sub-laminate as ( ) " # hs o i ¼ A 1 A 1 B ( h o i ) s i B T A 1 B T A 1 (7) B þ D i The equivalent compliance matrix is given by " # ½Q eq Š 1 ¼ A 1 A 1 1 B B T A 1 B T A 1 ¼½S ijš (8) B þ D (4) (6) 2.3. Formulation of finite element model Axi-symmetric formulation for transient analysis can be written as ½M e Šf D e gþ½k e ŠfD e g¼ff e gþff e T g (11) where ½M e Š¼2p r½nš T ½NŠr ds; s fd e g¼ffu r gfu y gfu z gg T ½K e Š¼2p ½BŠ T ½CŠ½BŠr ds; s ff e g and ff e Tg are forces due to mechanical and thermal loads, respectively. In addition, N is interpolation function, B is strain displacement function, C is elasticity matrix, r is density and ðu r ; u y ; u z Þ are displacement components in cylindrical coordinate system. By discretizing Eq. (2), the heat conduction formulation can be expressed as ½C T Šf _ Tgþ½K T ŠfTg ¼fH T g (12) where ½C T Š¼ rc p N T N dv; ½K T Š¼ N T kndv V V ½H T Š¼ N T q s ds þ N T q r dv S V where k is thermal conductivity, q s is surface heat flux and q r is the reaction heat due to the resin decomposition and vaporous migration. The reaction heat q r can be expressed as DT q r ¼ _m g C pg Dr þ Dr Dt ½Q þðc pg C p ÞðT T 1 ÞŠ (13) where C pg is the specific heat of gas, T 1 is ambient temperature and Q is heat of decomposition. Combining Eqs. (11) and (12), the sequentially coupled thermal-stress equation can be written as " # 8 e n o9e " M 0 < D = þ 0 0 # 8 e 9 _D e " < = þ K 0 # e ( ) fdg e 0 0 : ; 0 0 C T : _T ; 0 K T ftg ( ) ffgþff T g e ¼ (14) fh T g

2741 3. Material models Table 2 Thermal expansion coefficients of carbon/ epoxy 3.1. Temperature dependent material properties Mechanical and thermal properties of fiber reinforced composites vary significantly with temperature. As the carbon/ epoxy laminate carries the pressure loading from the hydrogen gas, the effect of temperature on its material properties cannot be ignored. However, the full required data of temperature dependent properties are not available in literature. Assumptions and curve fittings are necessary to obtain the material property data based on limited experimental data that are available. Numerous studies have been done on the curve fitting of temperature dependent properties. Gibson et al. [19] show that hyperbolic tan (tanh) function is capable of giving excellent fit to experimental data of material moduli and strength. The equation can be expressed as Temperature (1C) a 1 (1 10 6 /1C) a 2 (1 10 6 /1C) 20 1.47 29.2 40 0.97 29.5 60 0.77 33.2 80 0.81 40.0 100 1.09 50.2 120 1.61 63.6 140 2.37 80.4 350 9.03 238.0 Table 3 Specific heat and thermal conductivity of carbon/epoxy PðTÞ ¼ P U þ P R P U P R tanhðkðt T g ÞÞ C (15) 2 2 Specific heat Temperature (1C) C p (kj/kg/1c) where PðTÞ is temperature dependent material property, P U is the unrelaxed (low temperature) value of that property, P R is the relaxed (high temperature) value of that property, k is a constant describing the width of the distribution, T is temperature, T g is the mechanically determined glass transition temperature and C is a constant. The experimental data of carbon/epoxy are taken from literatures [20 22]. Moduli are fitted using Eq. (15). The curve fitting parameters are listed in Table 1. The thermal properties of carbon/epoxy are listed in Tables 2 and 3. Properties for resin reaction model are listed in Table 4. The strength of the composite is dependent on temperature and resin content. It has been assumed that the temperature variation of the ultimate longitudinal, transverse and shear strengths of carbon/epoxy follow the same pattern as the longitudinal, transverse and shear moduli, respectively, and resin content only affects the transverse and shear strengths. The virgin strengths used this investigation are listed in Table 5. Table 1 Curve fitting parameters for transverse and shear modulus 0 0.8 20 0.86 70 1.08 95 1.28 120 1.4 170 1.5 260 1.67 350 1.84 Thermal conductivity (W/m/1C) K 11 ¼ 6.5 K 22 ¼ 0.65 K 33 ¼ 0.65 Table 4 Parameters for resin reaction model Properties Values Pre-exponential factor, A (1/s) 500.0 Activation energy, E A (kj/kg-mole) 6.05 10 4 Gas constant, R (kj/kg-mole/1c) 8.314 Specific heat of gas, C pg (J/kg/1C) 2386.5 Specific heat of composite, C p (J/kg/1C) 1066.0 Heat of decomposition, Q (J/kg) 3.5 10 5 Longitudinal modulus Transverse modulus Shear modulus P U 133.35 9.135 4.515 (Gpa) P R 111 0.1 0.045 (Gpa) K 0.0064 0.022 0.02 C 1 1 1 T g (1C) 100 100 100 Table 5 Strength of carbon/epoxy Strengths (MPa) F t L F c L F t T F c T F S LT 2463 1070 40 170 60

2742 3.2. Composite failure criteria As the composite wall of the hydrogen cylinder experiences combined mechanical and thermal loads, a variety of failure types would occur in the process. A progressive failure model is employed in this study to identify the failure types based on failure criterion and predict the safety state of the cylinder. Hashin s failure criterion [23], accounting for four possible modes of ply failure, is used for this purpose. 1. Matrix tensile or shear cracking ðs 22 þ s 33 X0Þ ð I mt ¼ s 22 þ s 33 Þ 2 ðf t þ s2 12 þ s2 13 þ s2 23 s 22s 33 T Þ2 ðf S (16) LT Þ2 2. Matrix compressive or shear cracking ðs 22 þ s 33 o0þ 2! 3 I mc ¼ 1 2 4 F c F c T T 2ðF S LT Þ 15ðs 22 þ s 33 Þþ ðs 22 þ s 33 Þ 2 4ðF S LT Þ2 þ s2 12 þ s2 13 þ s2 23 s 22s 33 ðf S LT Þ2 (17) 3. Fiber tensile fracture ðs 11 X0Þ! I ft ¼ s 2 11 F t þ 1 L ðf S ðs2 LT Þ2 12 þ s2 13 Þ (18) 4. Fiber compressive fracture ðs 11 o0þ I fc ¼ s 11 F c L (19) Pressure (Bar) 1000 900 800 700 600 500 400 300 0 100 200 300 400 500 Table 6 Design parameters for the cylinder Parameters Fitting curve Test data Equation: P = 1.2 T + 320 Temperature ( C) Fig. 2 Curve fitting for hydrogen gas state equation at constant density. Values Outside diameter (m) 0.462 Liner thickness (mm) 2.54 Composite thickness (mm) 11.3 Thickness ratio (helical/hoop) 0.65 Stress ratio (helical/hoop) 0.8 Operation pressure (MPa) 34.5 Factor of safety 2.25 where F t L, Fc L, Ft T, Fc T and FS LT are longitudinal tensile strength, longitudinal compressive strength, transverse tensile strength, transverse compressive strength and shear strength of unidirectional ply, respectively. Once a specific type of failure is identified in the laminate, the reduction in its load-carrying capacity is accounted for by a reduction in its elastic moduli based on Tan s assumption [24]: (a) when matrix tensile or shear cracking occurs, properties ðe 22 ; G 12 ; G 23 Þ are taken as 0.2 times the original values. (b) when matrix compressive or shear cracking occurs, properties ðe 22 ; G 12 ; G 23 Þ are taken as 0.4 times the original values. (c) when fiber tensile fracture occurs, E 11 is taken as 0.07 times the original values. (d) when fiber compressive fracture occurs, E 11 is taken as 0.14 times the original values. Flame source Hydrogen gas L c Central axis of axisymmetirc model Fig. 3 Finite element model of the cylinder. L s Symmetric boundary 3.3. Model for hydrogen gas The hydrogen gas in the cylinder absorbs energy and increases the internal pressure. In the present study, the hydrogen gas effect is modeled as a sink whose temperature is updated at each increment based on the amount of heat flux going through the inner cylinder surface. The internal pressure of cylinder is computed from the state equation of hydrogen. The experimental data of hydrogen gas are taken from literature [25]. The pressure and temperature relationship at constant density of 23.59 kg/m 3 (when temperature is 20 1C and pressure is 34.5 MPa) is curve fitted as shown in Fig. 2. The fitted equation is employed to compute cylinder internal pressure. 4. Finite element simulation procedure The cylinder dimensions used in present study are based on the design proposed by Mitlitsky et al. [26] and are summarized in Table 6. An axi-symmetric finite element model is built in ABAQUS as shown in Fig. 3. The length of cylinder part is taken as L c ¼ 0:3 for analysis and the dome curve follows a

2743 geodesic path. The flame source is modeled as a constant heat flux (75 kw/m 2 ) applied on the area with length L s throughout the analysis. The radiation, as well as the convection, is also considered at the cylinder outside surface. Pressure is imposed on the inner liner surface. A symmetric boundary condition is applied at the end of cylinder to reduce the model to half of the cylinder. The model uses SAX8RT element accounting for both deformation and heat transfer. The cylinder wall consists of inner aluminum liner and six sub-laminates of carbon/epoxy (Fig. 4). Each hoop (901) and helical (7101) sub-laminate consists of many laminas. The implementation procedure of the developed models in ABAQUS is summarized as shown in Fig. 5 and the names of interface subroutines are listed in parenthesis. At each increment, the material properties are updated (using subroutine USDFLD) based on the information of current temperature, failure type and resin content. The mechanical loading vector is computed from the hydrogen gas model (in the subroutine FILM). The hydrogen gas model provides sink temperature from which the internal pressure of the cylinder is computed (from subroutine DLOAD) using gas state equation. For thermal loading vector, the heat flux from flame source, resin decomposition and mass flux of burning gas contribute collaboratively (calculated in subroutine HET- VAL). The coupled thermo-mechanical equations are then solved to get the global stresses and temperature field. The lamina stresses are retrieved from global stresses and imported into the failure model to compute failure indices. At the next increment, all sub-models (resin sub-model, hydrogen gas sub-model and material strength sub-model) are solved based on the temperature field and failure type from the previous increment. The procedure iterates until the specified time is met. In the present study, this transient analysis is carried out for 1000 s. 5. Results and discussion The heat exchange rate between the hydrogen gas and aluminum liner affects the increase in sink temperature (temperature of hydrogen gas) when the cylinder is subjected to flame impingement. In the simulation, the heat exchange rate is represented by a film coefficient (H). A parametric study is conducted on H ranging from 10 to 10,000 W/m 2 /1C. The results are shown in Fig. 6. The sink temperature increases rapidly with H at the beginning and it flattens out at higher values of H. At higher H values, the sink temperature is not sensitive to the heat exchange rate. In real situations, this value can vary over a large range with variation of hydrogen flow rate. H is taken as 1000 W/m 2 /1C Flame source 120 Hoop Sublaminate6 (90 ) 100 Helical Hoop Helical Hoop Helical Sublaminate5 (±10 ) Sublaminate4 (90 ) Sublaminate3 (±10 ) Sublaminate2 (90 ) Sublaminate1 (±10 ) Carbon/epoxy composite Temprature ( C) 80 60 40 Aluminum Liner Inner pressure 20 0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 H (W/m 2 / C) Fig. 4 Stacking sequence of the cylinder wall. Fig. 6 Variation of sink temperature with film coefficient. Fig. 5 Finite element implementation schemes.

2744 60 55 700 600 Sublaminate 6 Pressure (MPa) 50 45 40 L=1.0 L=0.5 L=0.1 Temperature ( C) 500 400 300 200 Sublaminate 5 Sublaminate 4 Sublaminate 3 Sublaminate 2 35 100 Sublaminate 1 30 0 200 400 600 800 1000 Time (Sec) Fig. 7 Internal pressure variation with time for various flame area sizes. 0 0 200 400 600 800 1000 Time (Sec) Fig. 9 Temperature distributions through composite thickness. 120 100 Time = 1000 Sec Temperature ( C) 80 60 40 20 Time = 800 Sec Time = 600 Sec Time = 400 Sec Time = 200 Sec Time = 0 Sec 0 0 2.5 5 7.5 10 12.5 15 Distance from flame center (cm) Fig. 8 Temperature distributions along the length at inner surface of the aluminum liner. Fig. 10 Residual resin content through the thickness. for convenience throughout the analysis. Fig. 7 plots the internal pressure variation with time for different flame impingement sizes. The non-dimensional L is defined as L ¼ L s /L c (Fig. 3). It can be seen that at the beginning the internal pressure increases very slowly and is much higher after 200 s. With increasing size of the flame area, the pressure goes up. For the rest of analysis, results are reported at L ¼ 0.1. Fig. 8 shows the temperature distributions of liner internal surface at different times. The temperature of flame impingement center is higher than the adjacent areas. Fig. 9 shows the temperature distributions of composite through the thickness direction at the flame center. The temperature of the outmost sub-laminate 6 increases to 520 1C in the first 200 s and then continues to go up very slowly during the rest of time. The innermost sub-laminate 1 increases slowly during the entire flame impingement process. Fig. 10 shows the residual resin content in the composite through the S 11 (MPa) 2000 1500 1000 500 Sublaminate 1 (Helical) Sublaminate 2 (Hoop) Sublaminate 3 (Helical) Sublaminate 4 (Hoop) 0 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Distance (mm) Sublaminate 5 (Helical) Sublaminate 6 (Hoop) Fig. 11 Stress (S 11 ) distribution through the thickness.

2745 5 0 S 22 S 22 S 33 (MPa) -5-10 -15-20 S 33-25 -30 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Distance (mm) Fig. 12 Stress (S 22, S 33 ) distribution through the thickness. thickness at the flame center. In the outmost sub-laminate 6, resin is depleted totally in the first 100 s and in the innermost sub-laminate 1, the resin content keeps almost constant throughout the entire process. Stress distributions through composite thickness at the end of simulation time are reported in Figs. 11 and 12. Uneven stress (S 11 ) distribution is observed in fiber direction for hoop sub-laminates. This can result in the breakage of fibers in the inner hoop layers. The stresses in transverse direction (S 22 ) and thickness direction (S 33 ) are plotted in Fig. 12. The shear stresses are not reported as they are negligible. Failures due to fiber fracture, matrix cracking and resin depletion are presented in Figs. 13 (a c). Higher fiber fracture index is observed for the inner layer. This is because the fibers of outer layers cannot bear much mechanical load as the resin is either depleted or softened due to the high temperature. Matrix cracking is observed at the inner half of the composite wall. However, the matrix failure index is very low at the outmost layers, since there is not much matrix (resin) left. Hence, no significant mechanical loading can be carried in this part. This can be observed in Fig. 13(c). 6. Conclusions A comprehensive finite element model has been developed to analyze composite hydrogen storage cylinders subjected to high pressure and flame impingements. The model considers the resin reaction, heat exchange between the hydrogen gas and liner and progressive failure process. A sub-laminate model has been developed to reduce computational time. A temperature dependent material model and failure model have been developed and implemented to accurately predict various types of failure for the hydrogen storage cylinder. All the models are formulated in an axi-symmetric coordinate system and implemented in ABAQUS through user subroutines. Analysis of a typical high pressure composite hydrogen cylinder under fire exposure is conducted by using the developed model. Parametric studies are done on heat exchange rate (between hydrogen gas and liner) and the sizes Fig. 13 (a) Fiber fracture index (I mt ) contour around heat source. (b) Matrix cracking index (I ft ) contour around heat source. (c) Density index (q/q 0 ) contour around heat source. of flame source. Stresses, temperature profile and failure types are reported. The developed model can be used to accommodate various types of thermal and mechanical loading, lamina stacking sequence and lamina thickness to establish safe working conditions and design limits for hydrogen storage cylinders. In addition, this simulation process can be used for both type 3 and type 4 hydrogen cylinders, as both have the similar structure except the type of liner. Acknowledgment This project is funded by National University Transportation Center. R E F E R E N C E S [1] Liang C, Chen H, Wang C. Optimum design of dome contour for filament-wound composite pressure vessels based on a shape factor. Compos Struct 2002;58:469 82.

2746 [2] Vasiliev VV, Krikanov AA, Razin AF. New generation of filament-wound composite pressure vessels for commercial applications. Compos Struct 2003;62:449 59. [3] Tabakov PY, Summers EB. Lay-up optimization of multilayered anisotropic cylinders based on a 3-D elasticity solution. Comput Struct 2006;84:374 84. [4] Chapelle D, Perreux D. Optimal design of a type 3 hydrogen vessel: part I analytic modeling of the cylindrical section. Int J Hydrogen Energy 2006;31:627 38. [5] Park J, Hong C, Kim C. Analysis of filament wound composite structures considering the change of winding angles through the thickness direction. Compos Struct 2002;55:63 71. [6] Kabir M. Finite element analysis of composite pressure vessels with a load sharing metallic liner. Compos Struct 2000;49:247 55. [7] Gray DL, Moser DJ. Finite element analysis of a composite overwrapped pressure vessel. In: 40th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE joint propulsion conference and exhibit, Fort Lauderdale, FL, July 11 14, 2004. AIAA 2004-3506, p. 1 15. [8] Akcay IH, Kaynak I. Analysis of multilayered composite cylinders under thermal loading. J Reinf Plast Compos 2005;24:1169 79. [9] Sayman O. Analysis of multi-layered composite cylinders under hygrothermal loading. Compos: Part A 2005;36:923 33. [10] Henderson JB, Wiebelt JA, Tant MR. A model for the thermal response of polymer composite materials with experimental verification. J Compos Mater 1985;19:579 95. [11] Henderson JB, Wiecek TE. A mathematical model to predict the thermal response of decomposing, expanding polymer composites. J Compos Mater 1987;21:373 93. [12] Gibson AG, Wright PNH, Wu Y-S. The integrity of polymer composites during and after fire. J Compos Mater 2004;38:1283 307. [13] Laidler KJ. Theories of chemical reactions rates. New York: McGraw-Hill; 1969. [14] Lua J, O Brien J, Key CT, Wu Y, Lattimer BY. A temperature and mass dependent thermal model for fire response prediction of marine composites. Compos Part A 2006;37:1024 39. [15] Chou PC, Carleone J. Elastic constants of layered media. J Compos Mater 1972;6:80 93. [16] Sun CT, Li S. Three-dimensional effective elastic constants for thick laminates. J Compos Mater 1988;22:629 39. [17] Chen H, Tsai SW. Three-dimensional effective moduli of symmetric laminates. J Compos Mater 1996;30:906 16. [18] Whitcomb J, Noh J. Concise derivation of formulas for 3D sublaminate homogenization. J Compos Mater 2000;34: 522 35. [19] Gibson AG, Wu Y-S, Evans JT, Mouritz AP. Laminate theory analysis of composites under load in fire. J Compos Mater 2006;40:639 58. [20] Yoon KJ, Kim J. Prediction of thermal expansion properties of carbon/epoxy laminates for temperature variation. J Compos Mater 2000;34:90 100. [21] Kalogiannakis G, Hemelrijck DV, Assche GV. Measurements of thermal properties of carbon/epoxy and glass/epoxy using modulated temperature differential scanning calorimetry. J Compos Mater 2004;38:163 75. [22] Liang G, Garg A, Chandrashekhara K, Flanigan V, Kapila S. Cure characterization of pultruded soy-based composites. J Reinf Plast Compos 2005;24:1509 20. [23] Hashin. Failure criteria for unidirectional fiber composites. J Appl Mech 1980;47:329 34. [24] Tan SC. A progressive failure model for composite laminates containing openings. J Compos Mater 1991;25:556 77. [25] Deming WE, Shupe LE. Some physical properties of compressed gases, III. Hydrogen. Phys Rev 1932;40:848 59. [26] Mitlitsky F, Weisberg AH, Myers B. Vehicular hydrogen storage using lightweight tanks. In: Proceedings of the 2000 USDOE hydrogen program review, NREL/CP-570-28890; 2000. p. 1 82.