Center for Electronic Correlations and Magnetism University of Augsburg Superfluid Helium-3: Universal Concepts for Condensed Matter and the Big Bang Dieter Vollhardt GSI Kolloquium, Darmstadt; May 9, 2017
Periodic table of the elements Noble gas Helium: after hydrogen the most abundant element in the universe
Helium Two stable Helium isotopes: 4 He, 3 He 4 He: air, oil wells,... Janssen/Lockyer/Secci (1868) He air He He 4 3 6 6 5 10 1 10 4 air Ramsay (1895) Cleveit (UO 2 ) 3 He: Li + n H + α 6 1 3 3 0 1 3 He 2 Research on macroscopic samples of 3 He only since 1947 4 He: Coolant, Welding, Balloons 3 He: - Contrast agent in medicine - Neutron detectors - 3 He- 4 He dilution refrigerators (quantum computers!)
Helium Atoms: spherical, hard core diameter 2.5 Å Interaction: hard sphere repulsion van der Waals dipole/multipole attraction Boiling point: 4.2 K, 4 He Kamerlingh Onnes (1908) 3.2 K, 3 He Sydoriak et al. (1949) Dense, simple liquids { isotropic short-range interactions extremely pure
Helium 40 P (bar) [10 bar = 1 MPa] 30 20 10 solid superfluid superfluid? 3 He 4 He normal fluid λ-line 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 T(K) vapor Atoms: spherical shape weak attraction light mass strong zero-point motion T 0, P < 3 MPa: Helium remains liquid λ kt B T 0 quantum phenomena on a macroscopic scale
Helium 4 He 3 He Electron shell: 2 e -, S = 0 Nucleus: p n n p n p p Atom(!) is a S = 0 Boson S = 1 2 Fermion Quantum liquids Phase transition T λ = 2.2 K Bose-Einstein condensation superfluid with frictionless flow T c =???
Interacting Fermions (Fermi liquid): Ground state k z Landau (1956/57) Fermi surface k y k x Fermi sphere
Instability of Fermi liquid k z + 2 non-interacting fermions k y k x Fermi sphere
Arbitrarily weak attraction instability Cooper (1956) k z k Cooper pair k y k x k Universal fermionic property
Arbitrarily weak attraction Cooper pair ( k, α; k, β) k,α Ψ L= 0,2,4,... = ψ () r S=0 (singlet) ξ 0 Antisymmetry k, β Ψ = r + L= 1,3,5,... ψ () + ψ () r + 0 + ψ () - r S=1 (triplet) L = 0 ( s-wave ): isotropic pair wave function L > 0 ( p,d,f, -wave ): anisotropic pair wave function 3 He: Strongly repulsive interaction L > 0 expected
BCS theory Bardeen, Cooper, Schrieffer (1957) Generalization to macroscopically many Cooper pairs Energy gap Δ(T) here: L=0 (s-wave) ε c <<E F E F Pair condensate with transition temperature T = 1.13 ε exp( 1/ N( 0) V ) c c L in weak coupling theory ε c, V L : Magnitude? Origin? T c? Thanksgiving 1971: Transition in 3 He at T c = 0.0026 K Osheroff, Richardson, Lee (1972) Osheroff, Gully, Richardson, Lee (1972)
The Nobel Prize in Physics 1996 "for their discovery of superfluidity in helium-3" David M. Lee Cornell (USA) Douglas D. Osheroff Stanford (USA) Robert C. Richardson Cornell (USA)
Phase diagram of Helium-3 P-T phase diagram Dense, simple liquid { isotropic short-range interactions extremely pure nuclear spin S=1/2 ordered spins disordered spins Fermi liquid Solid (bcc) http://ltl.tkk.fi/research/theory/helium.html
Phase diagram of Helium-3 P-T phase diagram Dense, simple liquid { isotropic short-range interactions extremely pure nuclear spin S=1/2 viscosity zero high viscosity (machine oil) http://ltl.tkk.fi/research/theory/helium.html
Phase diagram of Helium-3 P-T-H phase diagram http://ltl.tkk.fi/images/archive/ab.jpg Millikelvin Cryostat WMI Garching Very (ultra) low temperatures : T << T boiling ~ 3 K and << T backgr. rad. ~ 3 K
Superfluid phases of 3 He Experiment: Osheroff, Richardson, Lee, Wheatley,... Theory: Leggett, Wölfle, Mermin, L=1, S=1 ( p-wave, spin-triplet ) in all 3 phases Attraction due to spin fluctuations Anderson, Brinkman (1973) anisotropy directions in every 3 He Cooper pair ˆd ˆl orbital part spin part
and a mystery! NMR experiment on nuclear spins I= 1 2 Osheroff et al. (1972) ω ω ω L T 2 2 2 ( ) 3mT?! ω L ω Larmor frequency: L = γ H superfluid Shift of ω L T C,A normal T spin-nonconserving interactions nuclear dipole interaction g D 10 7 K TC Origin of frequency shift?! Leggett (1973)
The superfluid phases of 3 He
B-phase All spin states, +, occur equally ( k) = 0 Balian, Werthamer (1963) Vdovin (1963) energy gap Fermi sphere (pseudo-) isotropic state s-wave superconductor Weak-coupling theory: stable for all T<T c
A-phase Spin states, occur equally strong gap anisotropy ( k ˆ ) = sin( kl ˆ, ˆ ) Anderson, Morel (1961) 0 ˆl Cooper pair orbital angular momentum energy gap Fermi sphere Energy gap with point nodes axial (chiral) state Helped to understand unconventional pairing in heavy fermion superconductors (CeCu 2 Si 2, UPt 3, ) high-t c (cuprate) superconductors Strong-coupling effect
3 He-A: Spectrum near nodes ˆl ˆl ^ l E k Volovik (1987) Energy Egap k Excitations k Fermi sea = Vacuum e + 1 = 1 kˆ kˆ A = k l ˆ F p= k ea ( ) 2 E = v k k sin ( ˆˆ F + kl, ) 2 2 2 2 k F 0 + lˆ lˆ chirality up chirality down ij = g pp i j Lorentz invariance ij 2 g = v Fll i j+ ( δij ll i j) kf 2
3 He-A: Spectrum near nodes ˆl ˆl ^ l The Universe in a Helium Droplet, Volovik (2003) E k Energy Egap k Excitations Fermi sea = Vacuum k ( ) 2 E = v k k sin ( ˆˆ F + kl, ) e 2 2 2 2 k F 0 + 1 = 1 kˆ kˆ + lˆ lˆ chirality up chirality down ij = g pp i j Fermi point: spectral flow of fermionic charge Lorentz invariance ij 2 g = v Fll i j+ ( δij ll i j) kf 2 Massless, chiral leptons, e.g., neutrino E( p) = cp Chiral (Adler) anomaly measured Bevan et al. (1997)
A 1 -phase In finite magnetic field Only spin state Long-range ordered magnetic liquid
Cooper pairing of Fermions vs. Bose-Einstein condensation Cooper pair: Quasi-boson Conventional superconductors Superfluid 3 He High-T C superconductors ξ0 10000 Å ξ0 150 Å ξ0 10 Å } BCS? Superfluid 4 He: Tightly packed fermions (boson) ξ0 1 Å New insights from BEC of cold atoms BEC Leggett (1980)
Broken Symmetries & Long-Range Order
Broken Symmetries & Long-Range Order Normal 3 He 3 He-A, 3 He-B: 2 nd order phase transition T<T c : higher order, lower symmetry of ground state I. Ferromagnet Average magnetization: T>T c T<T c M = 0 M 0 Order parameter Symmetry group: SO(3) U(1) SO(3) T<T C : SO(3) rotation symmetry in spin space spontaneously broken
Broken Symmetries & Long-Range Order Normal 3 He 3 He-A, 3 He-B: 2 nd order phase transition T<T c : higher order, lower symmetry of ground state II. Liquid crystal T>T c T<T c Symmetry group: SO(3) U(1) SO(3) T<T C : SO(3) rotation symmetry in real space spontaneously broken
Broken Symmetries & Long-Range Order Normal 3 He 3 He-A, 3 He-B: 2 nd order phase transition T<T c : higher order, lower symmetry of ground state III. Conventional superconductor............. T>T c T<T c Pair amplitude c c 0 i e φ k k complex order parameter = iϕ Gauge transf. ck σ ck σe : gauge invariant not gauge invariant Symmetry group U(1)
Broken Symmetries & Long-Range Order Normal 3 He 3 He-A, 3 He-B: 2 nd order phase transition T<T c : higher order, lower symmetry of ground state III. Conventional superconductor............. T>T c T<T c T<T C : U(1) gauge symmetry spontaneously broken
Broken symmetries in superfluid 3 He L=1, S=1 in all 3 phases Cooper pair: ˆd ˆl orbital part spin part Quantum coherence in { phase (complex order parameter) anisotropy direction in real space anisotropy direction in spin space Superfluid, liquid crystal magnet Characterized by 2 (2L + 1) (2S + 1) = 18 real numbers 3x3 order parameter matrix A iμ SO(3) S SO(3) L U(1) φ symmetry spontaneously broken SU(2) L SU(2) R U(1) Y for electroweak interactions Leggett (1975) Pati, Salam (1974)
Broken symmetries in superfluid 3 He Mineev (1980) Bruder, Vollhardt (1986) 3He-A SO(3) S SO(3) L U(1) φ symmetry broken U(1) Sz U(1) Lz - φ Unconventional pairing ˆl Cooper pairs Fixed absolute orientation
solution of the NMR mystery
Superfluid 3 He - a quantum amplifier Cooper pairs in 3 He-A Fixed absolute orientation What fixes the relative orientation of? ˆ, d ˆl Interaction of nuclear dipoles ( spin-orbit coupling ) : Dipole-dipole coupling of 3 He nuclei: g D 10 7 K TC Unimportant?!
Superfluid 3 He - a quantum amplifier Cooper pairs in 3 He-A Fixed absolute orientation Long-range order in d ˆ, ˆl 7 g 10 K: tiny, but lifts degeneracy of relative orientation D d ˆ, ˆl Quantum coherence locked in all Cooper pairs at a fixed angle NMR frequency increases: 2 2 ω = ( γ H ) + g 2 D ( T ) Leggett (1973) Nuclear dipole interaction is macroscopically measurable
The Nobel Prize in Physics 2003 "for pioneering contributions to the theory of superconductors and superfluids" Alexei A. Abrikosov USA and Russia Vitaly L. Ginzburg Russia Anthony J. Leggett UK and USA
Order-parameter textures and topological defects
Order-parameter textures in 3 He-A Orientation of the anisotropy directions d ˆ, ˆl : 1) Walls ˆl or 2) Magnetic field ˆd Chirality exp. Confirmed: Walmsley, Golov (2012) Textures in d ˆ, ˆl liquid crystals
Order-parameter textures and topological defects in 3 He-A D=2: domain walls in ˆd or ˆl ˆl ˆl Cannot be removed by local surgery topological defect Single domain wall ˆl Domain wall lattice
Order-parameter textures and topological defects in 3 He-A D=1: Vortices Vortex formation by rotation http://ltl.tkk.fi/research/theory/vortex.html e.g., Mermin-Ho vortex (non-singular) Thin film of 3 He-A (chiral) Skyrmion vortex Volovik (2003), Sauls (2013)
Order-parameter textures and topological defects in 3 He-A D=0: Monopoles Boojum in ˆl -texture of 3 He-A Defect formation by rotation geometric constraints rapid crossing through continuous phase transition
Big bang simulation in the low-temperature lab
Universality in continuous phase transitions BANG! High symmetry, short-range order T>T c Spins: paramagnetic Helium: normal liquid Universe: Unified forces and fields T=T c Phase transition Broken symmetry, long-range order ferromagnetic superfluid elementary particles, fundamental interactions Defects: domain walls vortices, etc. cosmic strings, etc. Kibble (1976) T<T c nucleation of galaxies?
Rapid thermal quench through 2 nd order phase transition Bäuerle et al. (1996) 1. Local temperature T T C 3. Expansion + rapid cooling Defects overlap 2. Nucleation of independently ordered regions Clustering of ordered regions Defects 4. T < T C : Vortex tangle Estimate of density of defects: Zurek (1985) Kibble-Zurek mechanism of defect formation: How to test?
Big-bang simulation in the low-temperature laboratory Grenoble: Bäuerle et al. (1996), Helsinki: Ruutu et al. (1996) 3 He-B Measured vortex tangle density: Quantitative support for Kibble-Zurek mechanism
Current research on superfluid 3 He 3 He in 98% open silica aerogel 1. Influence of disorder on superfluidity 3 He Halperin et al. (2008) SiO 2 2. Quantum Turbulence (=Turbulence in the absence of viscous dissipation) Origin of dissipation in the absence of friction? Test systems: 4 He-II, 3 He-B Vortex tangle Tsubota (2008) 3. Majorana fermions (e.g., zero-energy Andreev bound states at surfaces in 3 He-B) Majorana cone for 3 He-B in a thick slab Tsutsumi, Ichioka, Machida (2011)
The Superfluid Phases of Helium 3 D. Vollhardt and P. Wölfle (Taylor & Francis, 1990), 656 pages Reprinted by Dover Publications (2013)
Conclusion Superfluid Helium-3: Anisotropic superfluid (p-wave, spin-triplet pairing) - Cooper pairs with internal structure - 3 different bulk phases with many novel properties Large symmetry group broken - Close connections with particle physics - Zoo of topological defects