Adsorption Studies of Cyanide (CN) - on Alumina

Similar documents
CHAPTER 5. EQUILIBRIUM AND THERMODYNAMIC INVESTIGATION OF As(III) AND As(V) REMOVAL BY MAGNETITE NANOPARTICLES COATED SAND

Removal of Cd (II) and Cr (VI) from Electroplating Wastewater by Coconut Shell

Simultaneous Adsorption and Biodegradation of Phenol and Cyanide in Multicomponent System

Removal Of Copper From Waste Water Using Low Cost Adsorbent

Chapter 7 Adsorption thermodynamics and recovery of uranium

Adsorption of chromium from aqueous solution by activated alumina and activated charcoal

Adsorption study on pomegranate peel: Removal of Ni 2+ and Co 2+ from aqueous solution

Application of Fe 2 O 3 nanoparticles in Heavy Metal Removal

The Use of Acacia tortilis Leaves as Low Cost Adsorbent to Reduce the Lead Cations from an Aquatic Environment

Comparision studies on Adsorbants for removal of Hardness from Water by using newly Prepared Zeolite

Original Research Isotherms for the Sorption of Lead onto Peat: Comparison of Linear and Non-Linear Methods. Yuh-Shan Ho

Performance evaluation of industrial by-product phosphogypsum in the sorptive removal of nickel(ii) from aqueous environment

a variety of living species. Therefore, elimination of heavy metals/dyes from water and

Removal of Chromium from Aqueous Solution Using Modified Pomegranate Peel: Mechanistic and Thermodynamic Studies

Journal of Babylon University/Engineering Sciences/ No.(4)/ Vol.(25): 2017

Kinetic and Isotherm Studies of Removal of Metanil Yellow Dye on Mesoporous Aluminophosphate Molecular Sieves

Comparision of Langmuir and Freundlich Equilibriums in Cr, Cu and Ni Adsorption by Sargassum

Adsorption of Acid Orange-7 Dye onto Activated Carbon Produced from Bentonite - A Study of Equilibrium Adsorption Isotherm

Department of Chemistry, Federal University of Technology Owerri, PMB 1526, Owerri. Nigeria.

AMMONIA ADSORPTION FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTION USING NATURAL ZEOLITES. Faculty of Science, Ubon Ratchathani University, Ubon Ratchathani 31490, Thailand

Removal of Copper (II) from Aqueous Solutions using Chalk Powder

Current World Environment Vol. 4(2), (2009)

Removal of Nickel ions from Aqueous Solutions on Packed bed of Zeolite NaX

Kinetics of adsorption of methylene blue onto activated carbon prepared from palm kernel shell

Adsorption Study of Some Sulphanilic Azo Dyes on Charcoal

EXTRAPOLATION STUDIES ON ADSORPTION OF THORIUM AND URANIUM AT DIFFERENT SOLUTION COMPOSITIONS ON SOIL SEDIMENTS Syed Hakimi Sakuma

Equilibrium and Kinetics of Adsorption of Cationic Dyes by STISHOVITE Clay TiO2 Nanocomposite

EQUILIBRIUM ANALYSIS FOR BATCH STUDIES OF ADSORPTION OF FLUORIDE IN WATER USING ACTIVATED ALUMINA R AND D 651-X

Treatment of a Selected Refinery Wastewater Compound (Benzene) by Chitin and Chitosan by Dr Maryam Mohamed

REMOVAL OF FLUORIDE IN DRINKING WATER BY GREEN CHEMICAL APPROACH

Removal of Copper Ion from Synthetic Wastewater using Aloe Vera as an Adsorbent

EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE

Katarzyna Zielińska, Alexandre G. Chostenko, Stanisław Truszkowski

ADSORPTION OF DYE RHODAMINE B BY IRAQI BENTONITE CLAY

Effect of Process Parameters on Adsorption of Methylene Blue from Synthetic Effluent Using Jack Fruit Seed Powder

Removal of crystal violet from waste water

Adsorption Studies of Organic Pollutants onto Activated Carbon

IMO LATERITIC SOIL AS A SORBENT FOR HEAVY METALS

Removal of rhodamine B from aqueous solution by almond shell biosorbent

Adsorption kinetics for the removal of copper(ii) from aqueous solution by adsorbent PSTM-3T

Removal of Fluoride from Synthetic Water Using Chitosan as an Adsorbent

EFFECT OF CONTACT TIME ON ADSORPTION OF NITRATES AND PHOSPHATES

Acid Orange 7 Dye Biosorption by Salvinia natans Biomass

Removal of indigocarmine from industrial effluents using low cost adsorbent

Evaluation of Nitrate Removal from Water Using Activated Carbon and Clinoptilolite by Adsorption Method

Studies on the Removal of Rhodamine B and Malachite Green from Aqueous Solutions by Activated Carbon

BIOSORPTION OF CADMIUM (II) IONS FROM SIMULATED WASTEWATERS BY DRIED YEAST BIOMASS

Removal of Crystal Violet from Aqueous Solution by Activated Biocharfibers. Maria A. Andreou and Ioannis Pashalidis

Removal of Basic Dyes from Aqueous Solutions by Sugar Can Stalks

Adsorption of Pb(II) onto Modified Rice Bran

Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research

ELIMINATION OF NICKEL (I) FROM SYNTHETIC WASTE WATER USING BAGASSE PITH WITH COLUMN STUDIES

ADSORPTION OF MALACHITE GREEN DYE ONTO ACTIVATED CARBON OBTAINED FROM THE NATURAL PLANT STEM

Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical Research, 2012, 4(10): Research Article

Adsorption of Cu(II) onto natural clay: Equilibrium and thermodynamic studies

Faculty of Sciences, University of Tlemcen, P.O. Box Tlemcen - ALGERIA Tel./Fax: 00 (213) : yahoo.

CHAPTER 3. BATCH STUDIES FOR As(III) REMOVAL FROM WATER BY USING MAGNETITE NANOPARTICLES COATED SAND: ADSORPTION KINETICS AND ISOTHERMS

Thermodynamics of Borax Dissolution

Removal of Vanadium (V) from water by adsorption using GAC loaded with ethylene di-amine tetra acetic acid (EDTA) and nitrilo tri-acetic acid (NTA)

Malachite Green Dye Removal Using the Seaweed Enteromorpha

Biokinetic Study on Chromium Removal from Textile Wastewater Using Azadirachta Indica as a Low Cost Adsorbent

Enthalpy and Entropy Changes of Chitosan-Coated onto Pineapple-Waste for Lead Adsorption

Int.J.Curr.Res.Aca.Rev.2016; 4(6): Biosorption of Lead (II), Nickel (II) Iron (II) and Zinc (II) on Flyash from Dilute Aqueous Solution

METHOD 9035 SULFATE (COLORIMETRIC, AUTOMATED, CHLORANILATE)

METHOD 9252A CHLORIDE (TITRIMETRIC, MERCURIC NITRATE)

Removal of Organic Contents from Wastewater Using Leusas aspera

STUDIES ON THE REMOVAL OF CATIONIC DYES FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTION BY MIXED ADSORBENTS

Research in Chemistry and Environment

Screening of Algae Material as a Filter for Heavy Metals in Drinking Water

Methylene blue adsorption by pyrolytic tyre char

Adsorption of Pb(II) Ions on Teak Leaves Activated Carbon- A Kinetic and Equilibrium Study

METHOD 9200 NITRATE. 1.2 The applicable range of concentration is 0.1 to 2 mg NO -N per liter. 3 of sample.

Adsorption of Humic acid on Powdered Activated Carbon (PAC)

The Study of Natural Nano-Composite Filter for Industrial Wastewater Treatment

Removal of Metal Iron from Groundwater Using Aceh Natural Zeolite and Membrane Filtration

METHOD 9210 POTENTIOMETRIC DETERMINATION OF NITRATE IN AQUEOUS SAMPLES WITH ION-SELECTIVE ELECTRODE

Removal of copper ions from aqueous solution by tree fern

Biosorption of aqueous chromium VI by living mycelium of phanerochaete chrysosporium

ADSORPTION PROPERTIES OF As, Pb AND Cd IN SOFT SOIL AND META SEDIMENTARY RESIDUAL SOIL

Sorption of metals on biological waste material

GROUNDNUT SHELL: EFFECTIVE ADSORBENT FOR DEFLUORIDATION FROM AQUEOUS SOLUTION

Sriperumbudur , INDIA

Uranium biosorption by Spatoglossum asperum J. Agardh:

Removal of Heavy Metals Fe 3+, Cu 2+, Zn 2+, Pb 2+, Cr 3+ and Cd 2+ from Aqueous Solutions by Using Eichhornia Crassipes

Adsorption potential of Blast Furnace Granulated slag towards removal of aqueous cyanide

Study of some Effecting Factors on the Removal of Phenol from Aqueous Solutions by Adsorption onto Activated Carbon

Received: 24 th April-2012 Revised: 07 th May-2012 Accepted: 10 th May-2012 Research article

Vol. 3, No. 4 December 2002 pp

A Study of Ability of Adsorption of Some Dyes on Activated Carbon From Date S Stones

Removal of basic dye methylene blue by using bioabsorbents Ulva lactuca and Sargassum

Distinguish quantitatively between the adsorption isotherms of Gibbs, Freundlich and Langmuir.

MASS TRANSFER AND ADSORPTION OF AMOXICILLIN FROM WASTEWATER USING WHEAT GRAIN

Studies on the Removal of Ni(II) from Aqueous Solution using Fire Clay-TiO 2 Nanocomposite and Fire Clay

Appendix A. Supplementary information for ACS Sustainable Chemistry & Engineering

Removal of sulphates from acid mine drainage using desilicated fly ash slag

CEE 371 Water and Wastewater Systems

Studies on the Effect ph on the Sorption of Pb(II) and Cu(II) ions from Aqueous Media by Nipa Palm (Nypa fruticans Wurmb)

ISSN: ISO 9001:2008 Certified International Journal of Engineering Science and Innovative Technology (IJESIT) Volume 3, Issue 4, July 2014

Equilibrium, Kinetics and Isothem Studies onthe Adsorption of Eosin Red and Malachite Green Using Activated Carbon from Huracrepitans Seed Shells

Activated Carbon from Sugar Waste Bagasse is used for Removal of Colour from Dye Solution

Transcription:

ISSN-1996-918X Pak. J. Anal. Environ. Chem. Vol. 1, No. 1 & 2 (29) 83-87 Adsorption Studies of Cyanide (CN) - on Alumina Sumra Naeem and Uzma Zafar Minerals Processing Research Centre (MPRC) PCSIR Laboratories Complex, Lahore-546, Ferozepur Road, Lahore, Pakistan -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Abstract In this investigation, adsorption of cyanide on to alumina has been studied by means of batchtechnique. Percentage adsorption was determined for Alumina-Cyanide solution system as a function of (i) contact time, (ii) ph, (iii) adsorbate concentration and (iv) temperature. Adsorption data has been interpreted in terms of Freundlich and Langmuir equations. Thermodynamics parameters for the adsorption system have been determined at three different temperatures. The value of H o =5.448kJ/mole and G o =-7.162kJ/mole at 283K suggest that the adsorption of cyanide on Alumina is an endothermic and spontaneous process. Keywords: Cyanide, Alumina, Adsorption Isotherms. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Introduction Although cyanides themselves are useful industrial materials, but as a component of waste water certain forms of cyanide are undesirable, having been found to be offensive to the aquatic environment. Examples of the undesirable forms of cyanide are HCN and CN - [1]. As an environmentally protective measure, the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has placed strict limits on the allowable cyanide levels of industrial wastewater effluent streams. Industrial sources of undesirable forms of cyanide are waste water from electroplating industries. Cyanides are used extensively in metal finishing processes and heat treatment of steel, and are a significant constituent of wastes from coke oven and blast furnace operations. The toxic effects of cyanide are so severe to cause thyroid glands malfunctioning and nerve damage and established toxicity level so low (<.1mg/l) [2] that waste treatment efforts by industry need persistent analytical procedures for a better understanding of the various cyanide complexes that may be encountered [3]. Substantially elimination of cyanide from waste water by current analytical techniques has been reported by Tsoung [1]. Adsorption and biodegradation are two significant methods for treatment of wastewater bearing cyanide compounds, either operated separately or simultaneously [4] but the selection of the treatment methods is based on the concentration of waste and the cost of treatment. The Process of adsorption is a well established and powerful technique for treating domestic and industrial effluents. Activated carbon which has been the most used adsorbent however it is relatively expensive, other specific examples of materials which are used as adsorbents include both the naturally occurring materials such as the minerals, zeolites of different types, clays and synthetic materials which include Al 2 O 3, SiO 2 [1]. Iron-cyanide adsorption on to gamma Al 2 O 3 [5] as well adsorption of cyanide from aqueous solutions at pyrophyllite surface [6] have also been reported by different workers. Likewise batch and column tests were performed with various soils yielded significant removal of free cyanide at nearneutral ph values [7]. The objective of this work is to explore environment friendly material like Alumina as an adsorbent for the removal of cyanide from aqueous solution. The pertinent parameters that influence adsorption such as initial cyanide (CN - ) concentration, agitation time, ph and temperature were investigated. Adsorption isotherms at three different temperatures (i.e.283k, 313K, 323K) have been studied. The adsorption data have been interpreted using Freundlich and Langmuir isotherms. Various thermodynamic parameters including the mean energy of adsorption have been calculated. *Corresponding Author Email: uzma_@hotmail.com

84 Pak. J. Anal. Environ. Chem. Vol. 1, No. 1 & 2 (29) Materials and Methods All reagents used in the experimental work were of analytical grade (E.MERCK) Argentmetric (largely AgNO 3 ) titrations were employed for CN - determination [8]. Stock solution of cyanide (1mgl - ) was prepared by dissolving Sodium cyanide in distilled water. The concentration range of cyanide prepared from stock solution varied between 1 to 8mgl -. Adsorbent α- Alumina (E.MERCK), with a BET area of 1±3m 2 g -1, density 3.97g/cm 3 and a mean particle size 2nm was used as an adsorbent without any heat and chemical treatment. Instrumentation The ph of the solutions was measured using micro processor ph meter model HI 8417 by Hanna instruments. A Gallenkamp thermostated automatic shaker model BKS 35-166, UK was used for the batch experiments. The centrifugation was done with Wirowka Type WE-1 centrifuge machine at 45rpm. Adsorption studies The adsorption of CN - on α-alumina was studied by batch-technique [9]. The general method used for these studies is described below: A known weight (i.e.,.5g of the Alumina) was equilibrated with 25cm 3 of the spiked cyanide solution of known concentrations in Pyrex glass flasks at a fixed temperature in a thermostated shaker water bath for a known period of time (i.e. 3 minutes). After equilibrium the suspension was centrifuged in a stoppered tube for 5 minutes at 45 rpm, was then filtered through Whatman 41 filter paper. All adsorption experiments except where the ph was varied were done at ph 7.2, which was obtained naturally at solution to adsorbent ratio of 5:1. To study the effect of ph, in one set of experiments the ph of the suspensions was adjusted by using NaOH/NH 4 OH and HNO 3.The ph of solutions was in the range of 3.-12. The amount of cyanide adsorbed, X and the equilibrium cyanide concentration in the solution, Ce was always determined volumetrically with standard silver Nitrate solution. Adsorption of cyanide on Alumina was determined in terms of percentage extraction. Amount adsorbed per unit weight of the Alumina, X/m was calculated from the initial and final concentration of the solution, Adsorption capacity for the adsorption of cyanide species has been evaluated from the Freundlich and Langmuir adsorption isotherms were studied at three different temperatures (i.e. 283K, 313K, 323K). The cyanide concentration studied was in the range of 1pmm to 8ppm for 5:1 solution to Alumina ratio. Results and Discussion The adsorption of cyanide on the Alumina was studied as a function of shaking time in water Bath shaker (Gallenkamp-England), ph, adsorbate concentration and temperature for known cyanide concentration at 313K. The results are interpreted in terms of percentage adsorption. The variation of %adsorption with different intervals of time ranging from 5 minutes to 24 hours is illustrated by Fig.1 which shows that the adsorption of cyanide at 1ppm as well as 4 ppm concentration on alumina is rapid at 313K and equilibrium reached instantaneously after mixing cyanide solution with alumina. No significant change in %adsorption values was observed up to 24 hours, which indicates that surface precipitation as well as ion exchange may be the possible adsorption mechanism. Therefore, equilibrium time of 3 minutes was selected for all further studies. The adsorption is ph dependent, a much greater adsorptive capacity for cyanide was observed in neutral solution i.e., ph 7-8. Table-1A,. Because when the ph is reduced, surface charge of the particles becomes increasingly positive and because of the competition of the hydrogen ions for the binding sites, metal ions tend to desorbs at low ph region, as well a small decrease in cyanide adsorption was observed at ph higher than 9.. This behavior may be due to the formation of soluble cyanide complexes, which remain in solution as dissolved component. Similarly adsorption of cyanide as a function of its concentration was studied by varying the metal concentration from 1ppm to 8pmm, %age adsorption values decreases with increasing metal concentration Table-1B, which suggest that at least two types of phenomena (i.e. adsorption as well ion-exchange) taking place in the range of metal concentration studied, in addition less favorable lattice positions or exchange sites become involved with increasing metal concentration. The adsorption isotherms at three different temperatures (i.e.283k, 313K, 323K) were obtained by plotting the amount of cyanide adsorbed on alumina (mg/g) against metal at equilibrium concentration Ce (mg/l) Fig. 2 and Table-1C. Adsorption of cyanide decreases with increasing temperature. Two models, Langmuir and Freundlich equations, were used to describe experimental data for adsorption isotherms.

Pak. J. Anal. Environ. Chem. Vol. 1, No. 1 & 2 (29) 85 %age Adsorption 9 89 88 87 86 85 84 83 Where X/m is the amount adsorbed at equilibrium (mg/g), Ce is the equilibrium concentration of the adsorbate (mg/l), and K F and 1/n are the Freundlich constants related to adsorption capacity and adsorption intensity respectively, of the sorbent. The values of K F and 1/n can be obtained from the intercept and slope respectively, of the linear plot of experimental data of logx/m versus logce. 82 81 8 79 2 4 6 8 1 12 14 Time (minutes) 14 12 1 Figure 1. Effect of shaking time on %age Adsorption at 1ppm, 4 ppm for CN - adsorption on Alumina. x/m (mg/g) 8 6 4 Table-1-A: Effect of ph on Adsorption of CN - on Alumina at 313K. ph CN - in Soln. at Equilibrium CN - Adsorbed Adsorption (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (%) 3.2 1. 2.46 7.54 75.4 6.25 1. 1.6 8.4 84. 7.34 1. 1.15 8.85 88.5 9.5 1. 2.2 7.98 79.8 12.8 1. 2.7 7.3 73. Table-1-B: Dependence of Adsorbate concentration relative to CN - on Alumina at 313K at ph 7.34. Adsorbent Taken CN - in Soln. at CN - Equilibrium Adsorbed Adsorption (mg) (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (%) 5. 1. 1.15 8.85 88.5 5. 2. 2.8 17.2 86. 5. 4. 7.64 32.6 8.9 5. 6. 12.6 47.4 79. 5. 8. 2.8 59.2 74. The linear form of the Freundlich isotherm model is given by the following relation: logx/m = logk F +1/nlogCe (1) 2 Figure 2. Adsorption isotherms of CN - on Alumina at different temperatures: 283K, 313K, 323K. Table-1-C: Effect of Temperature on Adsorption of CN - on Alumina at ph= 7.34. Temperature 5 1 15 2 25 Ce (mg/l) CN - in Soln. at CN - Adsorption Equilibrium Adsorbed K (ppm) (ppm) (ppm) (%) 283 1. 1.1 8.9 89. 313 1. 1.15 8.85 88.52 323 1. 1.3 8.7 87. The linear form of the Langmuir isotherm model can be represented by the following relation: Ce/X/m= 1/K L Vm+Ce/Vm (2) Where Vm and K L are the Langmuir constants related to the maximum adsorption capacity and the energy of adsorption, respectively. These constants can be evaluated from the intercept and slope of the linear plot of experimental data of Ce/X/m versus Ce. The linearized Freundlich and Langmuir adsorption isotherms are shown in Fig. 3 and Fig. 4. The related parameters of Langmuir and Freundlich models are summarized in Table 2. The results reveal that both the Langmuir and Freundlich isotherm models can adequately describe the adsorption data.

86 Pak. J. Anal. Environ. Chem. Vol. 1, No. 1 & 2 (29) logx/m 2.5 2 1.5 1.5 y = 1.2651x +.6283 y = 1.1799x +.693 y = 1.2159x +.6247.5 1 1.5 logce Figure 3. Freundlich plots of CN - adsorption on Alumina at different temperatures: 283K, 313K,323K. Table 3 shows the values of thermodynamics parameters H O, S O G O. The positive value of H O =5.448kJ/mole, which is calculated from equation (5) and Fig. 5, confirms the endothermic nature of the overall adsorption process. The positive value of S O suggests increased randomness at the solid/solution interface with some structural change in the adsorbate and adsorbent and also affinity of the Alumina towards CN -. A negative value of G O indicates the feasibility and spontaneity of the adsorption process, where higher negative value reflects a more energetically favorable adsorption process. Table-3. Values of Thermodynamic Data for Adsorption of CN - on Alumina. Ce/x/m (g/l).6.5.4.3.2.1 y =.16x +.1515 y =.138x +.999 y =.14x +.755 Temperature H G S K (kj/mole) kj/mole (JK -1 mol -1 ) 283 5.448-7.162.445 313 5.448-5.329.344 323 5.448-1.67.47 5 1 15 2 25 Ce (mg/l) Figure 4. Langmuir plots of CN - adsorption on Alumina at different temperatures : 283K, 313 K, 323K. 4 3.5 3 2.5 y = -655.37x + 5.823 Table-2. Freundlich and Langmuir Isotherm parameters for Adsorption of CN - on α-alumina. lnk 2 1.5 Temperature Freundlich isotherm Langmuir isotherm K 1/n K F R 2 V m K L R 2 283 1.26.2.75 62.5 1..94 313 1.2.2.77 72.46 1..8 323 1.22.2.75 1.42 1..85 Calculations of thermodynamic parameters: Thermodynamic parameters such as Gibbs free energy G O (kj/mol), change in enthalpy H O (kj/mol) and change in entropy S O (J - K - mol - ) for cyanide adsorption were calculated from the distribution constant K [1] by using the following relations: G O =-RTlnK (3) G O = H O -T S O (4) And lnk= - H O /RT+Constant (5) 1.5.3.31.32.33.34.35.36 Figure 5. Plot of lnk Vs.1/T for CN - adsorption on Alumina. Conclusion Temp (1/TX1-3 ) K -1 Keeping the adsorptive nature of alumina in view it is felt desirable to select batch adsorption process for removal of Cyanide from the industrial wastewater using alumina. The main advantages of the procedure are: i. Cost of process as alumina is an indigenous material and easily available in country. ii. Ease and simplicity of preparation of the sorbent due to non-corrosive and non-poisonous nature of alumina.

Pak. J. Anal. Environ. Chem. Vol. 1, No. 1 & 2 (29) 87 iii. Rapid attainment of phase equilibration and good enrichment as well fitting of adsorption data with Freundlich and Langmuir isotherms. iv. The positive value of H O and negative values of G O indicate the endothermic and spontaneous nature of the adsorption process. References 1. Y. Y. Tsoung, U. S Patent No.5112494 (1992), May12. 2. World Health Organization (WHO), Ministry of Health, the Govt. of Pakistan, Quality Drinking Water: Guidelines and standards for Pakistan (25) 4. 3. ASTM D236-6, American Standards for Testing Materials (26) 82. 4. R. D. Roshan, C. Balomajumder and A. Kumar Iran J. Environ. Health. Sci. Eng. 3 (26) 91. 5. C. P. Hang and W. P. Cheng J. Colloidal and Interface Sci. 188 (1997) 647. 6. S. Sona, M. Prasad, S. S. Amritphale and C. Navin Separation and Purification Technology. 24 (21) 263. 7. A. David, Cyanide in water and soil: Chemistry, risk and management (Taylor & Francis Group, CRC publication, Florida (26) 61. 8. A. I. Vogel, A Text-Book Of Quantitative Inorganic Analysis. 3 rd Ed (Richard Clay and company, Ltd. Great Britain) (1961) 271. 9. N. Sumra, Z. Uzma, A. Arifa and I. Asma. J. Chem. Soc. Pak, 31 (29) 379. 1. A. K. Saad, U. R. Riaz and M. K. Ali, Waste Management 14 (1994) 56.