Constructing Trig Values: The Golden Triangle and the Mathematical Magic of the Pentagram A Play in Five Acts 1 "Mathematicians always strive to confuse their audiences; where there is no confusion there is no prestige Mathematics is prestidigitation" From Mathematics made difficult by Carl E Linderholm Prologue: You Can with Beakman and Jax," In the spring of 006 I was assigned to teach a trigonometry class for the first time since 199 In preparation for the course I made the following rather standard chart showing the well known exact values of cosine and sine around the unit circle For the values not on axis (ie, not 0, 90, 10 360, the results are easily derived from either an equilateral triangle or an isosceles right triangle Figure 1 The Monday after Christmas, I was doing some stretching while reading the Sunday comics In the science strip, You Can with Beakman and Jax, there was a discussion of the magic of the five pointed Christmas star and the occurrence therein of the Golden Ratio I must admit with some embarrassment that this was all news to me I had never really thought much about pentagrams before But I immediately realized that this meant there was another group of exact trig values based on a 1, 7 right triangle This presentation is based on my re-discovery of these very well known properties Al Lehnen Madison College //013
Act I: The Golden Ratio In Book VI of the Elements Euclid (1 divides a line segment into two intervals in such a way that the length of the longer interval to the length of the shorter interval is equal to the length of the whole interval to the length of the long interval Figure AB AC AB + BC 1 Designate the ratio as the Greek letter phi Then, φ 1+ Hence, BC AB AB φ φ φ + 1 or equivalently, φ φ 1 0 Since this ratio is positive, the quadratic formula gives the 1+ 1 + + 1 result φ 1610339799063366 Euclid called this number the extreme and mean ratio Later it acquired the name the Golden Ratio Numbers like phi are constructible ( All constructible numbers are algebraic, ie a solution of a polynomial equation with rational number coefficients Equivalently non algebraic (transcendental numbers are never constructible A possible modern (non-collapsing compass construction of φ is shown in Figure 1 Figure 3 Al Lehnen Madison College //013
3 Consider now the rectangle ABCD with AE AD and rectangle FEBC similar to rectangle ABCD Figure AD AB AE+EB AD+EB AD The similarity condition means that 1+ This is precisely EB AD AD AD EB AB the extreme and mean proportion Hence, φ and such a rectangle is called Golden The numberφ AD occurs in the solution of many different problems For example, the famous Fibonacci sequence which is defined by the following recursion, F F + F ; F F 1 ; 1,1,,3,,,13,1,3,,9,1 has the explicit formula { } n+ n+ 1 n 1 n 1 n n 1 1 n 1 1 1 n 1 F + + φ n φ φ n φ + φ + 1 φ φ φ + 1 Similarly, a Golden Spiral can be constructed by inscribing a quarter circle in successive adjacent squares inside a Golden Rectangle This is shown in Figure The limit point of these spirals can be expressed in terms ofφ The frequency with whichφ unexpectedly appears in mathematics has given it an almost magical reputation Figure 1 Al Lehnen Madison College //013
Act II: The Golden Triangle Consider an isosceles triangle with the property that when one of its equal angles is bisected the bisector generates a smaller triangle similar to the original This is illustrated in Figure 6 Figure 6 Since α + α + α 10, we see that the angles must be 36,7, 7 S w 1 From the similarity of the two triangles This yields the quadratic equation w S w S 1 w S S 1 0 w The only positive solution is w Bisecting the side opposite to the cos 1 S w + 1 φ 36 degree angle gives the result that sin( 1 10 + ( 1 1 In terms of φ, sin ( 1 w S w 1 S φ, and ( φ 1( φ + 1 ( 1( + ( 1 and 1 φ 1 φ φ φ φ φ φ φ + cos ( 1 1 φ φ φ φ φ Al Lehnen Madison College //013
Act III: Knowing All the Angles From the half-angle formulas we have the following exact results sin ( 1 1 cos 1+ cos cos( 1 From the subtraction formulas, sin cos ( 30 3 3 3 + 1 ( 3 1 ( 3 1 ( 30 + 3 3 + 3 + 1 ( 3 + 1 ( 3 + 1 ( 3 sin( 1 1 sin( 1 cos( 1 cos( 1 sin( 1 1 6 + 30 + 10 6 10 + 1 + 3 + 6 + ( 3 cos( 1 1 cos( 1 cos( 1 + sin( 1 sin( 1 10 + 6 + + 1 6 1 + 3 + + + 30 10 6 + These results for three degrees can be used to construct exact values for any multiple of three degrees using the following recursions based on the addition formulas sin [( n + 1 3 ] sin( 3n cos( 3 + cos( 3n sin( 3 30 10 6 + + 1 + 3 + + 30 + 10 6 1 + 3 + + cos [( n + 1 3 ] cos( 3n cos( 3 sin( 3n sin( 3 30 10 6 + + 1 + 3 + + 30 + 10 6 1 + 3 + + sin cos sin ( 3n ( 3n cos + ( 3n ( 3n 6 6 + Al Lehnen Madison College //013
6 For some angles additional simplification is possible For example, from the recursion the cosine of 7π 1 is found to be 60 30 + 10 + 6 + + 7 + 1 + 1 + 3 + + However, 7 + 1 + 1 + 3 + + 1+ 3 ( 1 + ( 1 1 3 ( 1 ( 1 ( 1 3 ( 6 ( ( 6 + + + + 60 1 0 1 3 So that the cosine of 1 degrees can be expressed as cos ( 1 30 + 10 + 6 + + 1 3 Proceeding in this manner the results in Table 1 were generated Angles beyond can be generated by the symmetry of the unit circle: ( θ ( θ ( θ ( θ cos sin 90 cos 360 cos 10 ( θ ( θ ( θ ( θ sin cos 90 sin 360 sin 10 In fact, multiples of three degrees is the best one can do using integer degree arguments This follows from Gauss s famous constructability theorem for regular polygons (3, Regular polygons with 10 and 360 sides can not be constructed with rule and compass since the prime factorization of both of these 0 numbers contains two factors of the Fermat prime 3 + 1 This means that no exact solution in terms of square roots is possible for the trigonometric functions of either or 1 Of course 10 can be factored 3 as 10 (( 3 and so contains only one factor each of the Fermat primes 3 and Thus a 10 sided polygon is constructible and the exact values for three degrees presented above must exist You could go further and use the half angle formulas to extend the values in Table 1 to intervals of 07 and then interpolate the resulting decimal values This would allow the construction from exact values of that peculiar anachronism known as a trig table without the use of an infinite series! Al Lehnen Madison College //013
7 Table 1: Exact Values of Sine and Cosine for Angles that are Multiples of Three Degrees θ cos θ sin θ 0 0 1 0 3 π 30 10 6 + + 1 + 3 + + 30 + 10 6 1 + 3 + + 60 6 π 1 + 3 + 10 30 9 π 10 + + 0 1 + 30 6 10 + 1 π 1+ 30+ 6 3 1 + 10+ 1 1 π 6 + 6 1 1 π 10 + 1 10 7π 1 30 + 10 + 6 + + 1 3 30 + 10 6 + + 1 3 + 60 π 1+ + 30 6 1 + 3 10 1 3π 7 10 + + 10 + + + 0 π 3 1 30 6 11π 33 30 + 10 + 6 + 1 + 3 + + 30 + 10 6 + 1 + 3 + 60 π +1 36 10 13π 39 30 10 + 6 + 1 3 + 30 + 10 + 6 + 1 3 + 60 7π 1 3 + 10 + 1 + 30 + 6 30 π Al Lehnen Madison College //013
Act IV: Constructing a Regular Pentagon on a Limited Budget Proposition 10 of Book IV of Euclid s Elements ( gives a construction of the Golden Triangle This serves as the basis for Proposition 11 (6 which constructs a regular pentagon However, the number of steps involved is rather large A very simple and elegant construction of a regular pentagon was given by H W Richmond in 193 (7,, 9 and is presented below Figure 7 (1 Construct a pair of perpendicular lines Let O mark the point of intersection ( Construct a circle of radius r centered at O (3 Mark one of the points of intersection of the lines of (1 with the circle of ( as A ( On the line which does not contain A bisect the radius at point M ( Bisect the angle OMA and extend the bisector to P on segment OA (6 From P construct a line perpendicular to OA with point of intersection C with the circle of ( (7 Mark off length AC and proceed around the circle generating three additional vertices The following argument based on trigonometry proves the validity of Richmond s construction Since OA is twice OM, tan ( OMP From the addition formulas, sin ( ( OMP cos( OMP tan( OMP tan OMP cos OMP sin OMP 1 tan OMP ( ( ( Al Lehnen Madison College //013
9 Rearranging the above equation gives a quadratic equation: ( OMP ( OMP or tan ( + tan( OMP 1 0 1 tan tan OMP The tangent of angle OMP is positive, so the only admissible solution is 1+ 1 tan ( OMP φ 1 OP 1 1 Hence, OP MO tan( OMP OC and sin ( OCP OC φ Thus, OCP 1 ; COA 90 OCP 7, which divides the circle into five equal arcs The argument is summarized in Figure Figure Al Lehnen Madison College //013
Act V: Magic Happens 10 Line up Golden Triangles in a horizontal row so that their short bases form a continues line segment of width w Then rotate the four right most triangles 7 clockwise Now rotate the three triangles at the end of the line 7 clockwise, next rotate the two triangles at the end of the line 7 clockwise, and finally rotate the last triangle 7 clockwise This will generate a regular pentagram As shown in Figure 9 the ratio properties noted by Beakman and Jax follow rather easily from the Golden Quadratic Equation φ φ + 1 Figure 9 A more complete and revealing analysis considers a regular pentagon inscribed in a circle of radius OA and with vertices at A, B, C, D and E Construct segments AD, AC, BE, BD, and CE with points of intersection F, M, G, H, I and J This is shown in Figure 10 Al Lehnen Madison College //013
11 Figure 10 360 First AOB arcab arcbc arccd arced arcea 7 Then since the measure of an angle inscribed on a circle is equal to half of its subtended arc, we have that EAD DAC CAB AEB ABE BEC EBD 36 So by ASA congruency AEF and ABG are congruent isosceles triangles with AF EF AG GB so all of the sides of the pentagram AFEJDICHBG are equal Furthermore, triangle AFG is isosceles so that 10 DAC arcac AFG AGF 7, ADC 7, and AJE 10 BEC AEB EAD 10 3( 36 7 Similar arguments establish that ACD AHB 7 Thus, as shown in Figure 11 the four triangles AFG, AEJ, ABH and ADC are Golden In the same way each vertex of the pentagon ABCDE is the top vertex of four such Golden triangles Al Lehnen Madison College //013
1 Figure 11 From the triangle AFG, AF FG EF φ, but EF AF, so φ Now FG EG EF EF + FG EF 1 1+ φ ; however, 1 φ + 1 φ 1 + φ φ φ φ EB EG + GB EG + EF Similarly, + 1 1 EG EG EG φ φ So in summary each of the following ratios of lengths of segments in the chord EB is the Golden Ratio: EF FG EG EG EB EB φ 1610339799 EF GB EG FB Triangles AEJ and ACD are both Golden and FS FG, EJ EF AF, AJ AE CD Thus, AD AJ AF AJ AD φ DC EJ FJ AF AJ AH AG AC AH Similarly, AG GH AH BH φ Al Lehnen Madison College //013
Finally, exact relationships between the radius, r OA, of the inscribing circle and segments within the pentagon can be obtained using Table 1 Since AOE arcea 7 AOB and OE OB r triangles MOB and MOE are congruent BMO cos( 7 sin( 1 EMO 90 MB r AM r sin 1 ( 7 cos( 1 MO r 10 + 13 MO r EB r AB r MB 10 + r sin ( 36 10 1 The perimeter, P, of the regular pentagon is related to the radius of the inscribed circle as P 10 r 0 + 10 7797 and 0170130701 r P 0 FG GH HI IJ JF and EFA EJD DIC CHB BGA 10 ( 36 10, so GFJIH is also a regular pentagon As shown in Figure 1 one can construct an infinite regress of imbedded regular pentagons and associated pentagrams The dimensions of each new pentagon/pentagram OG are related to the previous pentagon/pentagram by the scale factor OG bisects AOB so that r MO OG cos ( 36 + 1 and 1 OG MO + 1 1 3 031966011010 r r + 1 3 7 3 The areas of the embedded figures are scaled by 019033703 Figure 1 Al Lehnen Madison College //013
1 References: 1 http://aleph0clarkuedu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookvi/defvi3html http://enwikipediaorg/wiki/compass_and_straightedge 3 http://enwikipediaorg/wiki/heptadecagon Weisstein, Eric W "Trigonometry Angles" From MathWorld--A Wolfram Web Resource http://mathworldwolframcom/trigonometryangleshtml http://aleph0clarkuedu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookiv/propiv10html 6 http://aleph0clarkuedu/~djoyce/java/elements/bookiv/propiv11html 7 Weisstein, Eric W "Pentagon" From MathWorld--A Wolfram Web Resource http://mathworldwolframcom/pentagonhtml Richmond, H W "A Construction for a Regular Polygon of Seventeen Sides" Quart J Pure Appl Math 6, 06-07, 193 9 http://wwwjimloycom/geometry/pentagonhtm Al Lehnen Madison College //013