HSNV122 - Thermoplasticity and metallurgy in large deformations in simple tension

Similar documents
Code_Aster. HSNV120 - Tension hyper elastic of a bar under thermal loading

HSNV140 - Thermoplasticity with restoration of work hardening: test of blocked dilatometry

FE FORMULATIONS FOR PLASTICITY

Code_Aster. Constitutive law élasto (visco) plastic in large deformations with metallurgical transformations

Law of behavior élasto (visco) plastic in great deformations with transformations metallurgical

SSNV221 Hydrostatic test with a behavior DRUCK_PRAGER linear and parabolic

SSNA109 - Tensile test with the model VISC_CIN2_CHAB

SSNP102 - Rate of energy restitution for a plate notched in elastoplasticity: approaches Summarized

The. Consortium. Continuum Mechanics. Original notes by Professor Mike Gunn, South Bank University, London, UK Produced by the CRISP Consortium Ltd

SSNP110 - Crack of edge in a rectangular plate finished in elastoplasticity

A SIMPLE PLASTICITY MODEL FOR PREDICTING TRANSVERSE COMPOSITE RESPONSE AND FAILURE

ZZZZ120 - Calculation of an assembly pin-attaches

8.7 Associated and Non-associated Flow Rules

Geo-E2010 Advanced Soil Mechanics L Wojciech Sołowski. 07 March 2017

Churilova Maria Saint-Petersburg State Polytechnical University Department of Applied Mathematics

Adam Paweł Zaborski. 8 Plasticity. reloading. 1. Bauschinger s effect. 2. unchanged yielding limit. 3. isotropic hardening

Code_Aster. HSNV129 - Test of compression-dilation for study of the coupling thermics-cracking

REFINED STRAIN ENERGY OF THE SHELL

THE GENERAL ELASTICITY PROBLEM IN SOLIDS

ANALYSIS OF ULTRA LOW CYCLE FATIGUE PROBLEMS WITH THE BARCELONA PLASTIC DAMAGE MODEL

SSNS106 Damage of a reinforced concrete plate under requests varied with model GLRC_DM

Pressure-sensitivity Effects on Toughness Measurements of Compact Tension Specimens for Strain-hardening Solids

Finite Element Method in Geotechnical Engineering

Code_Aster. SSNV160 - Hydrostatic test with the law CAM_CLAY

A compression line for soils with evolving particle and pore size distributions due to particle crushing

Numerical simulation of bird strike in aircraft leading edge structure using a new dynamic failure model

Elio Sacco. Dipartimento di Ingegneria Civile e Meccanica Università di Cassino e LM

SSNV137 - Cable of prestressed in a Summarized concrete straight beam

dn i where we have used the Gibbs equation for the Gibbs energy and the definition of chemical potential

HPLP300 - Plate with Young modulus function of the temperature

I Poles & zeros. I First-order systems. I Second-order systems. I E ect of additional poles. I E ect of zeros. I E ect of nonlinearities

u y

Adiabatic Shear Bands in Simple and Dipolar Plastic Materials

Chapter 1 Fundamentals

The Second Law: The Machinery

A Simple And Efficient FEM-Implementation Of The Modified Mohr-Coulomb Criterion Clausen, Johan Christian; Damkilde, Lars

Numerical and experimental investigation on shot-peening induced deformation. Application to sheet metal forming.

Code_Aster. SDLV123 - Computation of G elastodynamic in infinite medium for a plane crack finite length

NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF THE BEHAVIOR OF AN EXPANSIVE SOIL

Identification of the source of the thermoelastic response from orthotropic laminated composites

PREDICTION MODEL FOR BURR FORMATION

Finite element simulation of residual stresses in laser heating

The effect of dynamic bending moments on the ratchetting behavior of stainless steel pressurized piping elbows

Efficiencies. Damian Vogt Course MJ2429. Nomenclature. Symbol Denotation Unit c Flow speed m/s c p. pressure c v. Specific heat at constant J/kgK

3D Elasticity Theory

FINITE ELEMENT SIMULATION OF BACKWARD EXTRUSION DIES USING SHRINK FITTED RINGS

SHAPE OPTOMIZATION OF H-BEAM FLANGE FOR MAXIMUM PLASTIC ENERGY DISSIPATION

SSNV231 Sphere digs under internal pressure in great deformations

Elio Sacco. Dipartimento di Ingegneria Civile e Meccanica Università di Cassino e LM

Conference Paper A Finite Element Approach for the Elastic-Plastic Behavior of a Steel Pipe Used to Transport Natural Gas

Lower bound solutions for bearing capacity of jointed rock

A General Damage Initiation and Evolution Model (DIEM) in LS-DYNA

Local resolution of constitutive laws. Code_Aster, Salome-Meca course material GNU FDL licence (

Measurement of deformation. Measurement of elastic force. Constitutive law. Finite element method

Code_Aster. Reaction of the steel subjected to corrosion

The reciprocal effects of bending and torsion on springback during 3D bending of profiles

ELASTO-PLASTIC ANALYSIS OF CORRUGATED SANDWICH STEEL PANELS

An elasto-plastic model to describe the undrained cyclic behavior of saturated sand with initial static shear

Computational Solid Mechanics Computational Plasticity

Flexible Pipes in Trenches with Stiff Clay Walls

Maximum Entropy and the Stress Distribution in Soft Disk Packings Above Jamming

Characterization of Material Parameters

Code_Aster. SSNP161 Biaxial tests of Kupfer

INTRODUCING THE SHEAR-CAP MATERIAL CRITERION TO AN ICE RUBBLE LOAD MODEL

Code_Aster. Connection Harlequin 3D Beam

THE INFLUENCE OF DISLOCATION DENSITY ON THE BEHAVIOUR OF CRYSTALLINE MATERIALS

Implementation and Validation of Finite Volume C++ Codes for Plane Stress Analysis

Quasi-Three-Dimensional Simulation of Viscoelastic Flow through a Straight Channel with a Square Cross Section

MAE 323: Chapter 4. Plane Stress and Plane Strain. The Stress Equilibrium Equation

6.4 A cylindrical specimen of a titanium alloy having an elastic modulus of 107 GPa ( psi) and

CONSERVATION OF ENERGY FOR ACONTINUUM

The Finite Element Method II

Application of Automated Ball Indentation for Property Measurement of Degraded Zr2.5Nb

Phase transition. Asaf Pe er Background

Code_Aster. A finite element of cable-pulley

Chapter 6 2D Elements Plate Elements

Finite Element Analysis of V-Bending of Polypropylene Using Hydrostatic-Pressure-Dependent Plastic Constitutive Equation*

Planar Transformations and Displacements

Finite Element Solutions for Geotechnical Engineering

A J estimation scheme for surface cracks in piping welds

Week 8 lectures. ρ t +u ρ+ρ u = 0. where µ and λ are viscosity and second viscosity coefficients, respectively and S is the strain tensor:

SDLS505 - Buckling of a cylindrical envelope under external pressure

Optimization of Gear Design and Manufacture. Vilmos SIMON *

2x2x2 Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson (H-O-S) model with factor substitution

The thermal wind 1. v g

SDLV121 - Wave planes shearing in an elastic column

Chapter 7 Sampling and Sampling Distributions. Introduction. Selecting a Sample. Introduction. Sampling from a Finite Population

A NUMERICAL MODEL OF FINITE DIFFERENCE (F.D) FOR DYNAMIC PILE DRIVING

STRESS-STRAIN-DILATANCY RELATIONSHIPS OF NORMALLY CONSOLIDATED DHAKA CLAY

NUMERICAL SIMULATION OF THE INELASTIC SEISMIC RESPONSE OF RC STRUCTURES WITH ENERGY DISSIPATORS

Higher order theory for analytic saddle point approximations to the Ρ Ρ and Ρ Ś reflected arrivals at a solid/solid interface

HEAT, WORK, AND THE FIRST LAW OF THERMODYNAMICS

Pretest (Optional) Use as an additional pacing tool to guide instruction. August 21

MAE4700/5700 Finite Element Analysis for Mechanical and Aerospace Design

FUGACITY. It is simply a measure of molar Gibbs energy of a real gas.

SAMARIS. Draft report

Code_Aster. SDNV114 Simulation of benchmark SAFE - T5 veil out of reinforced concrete

Models of Bordet and Rice and Tracey

EMA 3702 Mechanics & Materials Science (Mechanics of Materials) Chapter 2 Stress & Strain - Axial Loading

INFLUENCE OF POROSITY AND MOISTURE ON MECHANICAL PROPERTIES OF CERAMIC BRICK ANALYTICAL HOMOGENISATION APPROACH

Transcription:

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 1/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 HSNV122 - Thermolasticit and metallurg in large deformations in simle tension Summarized: One treats e determination of e mechanical evolution of a clindrical bar subjected to known and uniform evolutions ermal and metallurgical (e metallurgical transformation is of bainitic te) and to a mechanical loading of tension. The behavior model is a model of lasticit in large deformations (command STAT_NON_LINE, ke word DEFORMATION: SIMO_MIEHE ) wi linear isotroic hardening and lasticit of transformation. The ield stress and e sloe of curve of tension deend on e temerature and e metallurgical comosition. The coefficient of ermal exansion deends on e metallurgical comosition. The bar is modelled b axismmetric elements. The mechanical loading alied is a following ressure. This case test is identical to e case test HSNV101 (modelization B, [V7.22.101]) in e meaning where it acts of e same material, e same loading and e same ermal and metallurgical evolutions but in a version in large deformations. Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 2/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 1 Problem of reference 1.1 Geometr Raon : a = 0.05 m Hauteur : h = 0.2 m z P C D h r A B 1.2 Proerties of e material e material obes a constitutive law in large deformations wi linear isotroic hardening and lasticit of transformation. For each metallurgical hase, e hardening sloe is given in e logarimic strain lane - rational stress. a F = = S F S o l. l o hase E E T hase ln( l / l o ) l o and l are, resectivel, e initial leng and e current leng of e useful art of e test-tube. S o and S are, resectivel, surfaces initial and current. Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 3/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 wi C 6 aust 6 o 6 E = 200000. 10 Pa = 400. 10 Pa + 0. 5 ( T T ) 10 Pa ν α α fbm aust ref fbm ref 1 1 1 = 2000000. J m C λ = 9999. 9 W m C = 0. 3 = 530. 10 Pa + 05. ( T T ) 10 fbm 6 o 6 Pa 6 1 6 o 6 aust = 15. 10 C h = 1250. 10 Pa 5. ( T T ) 10 Pa 6 1 6 o 6 C h fbm Pa T T Pa = 235. 10 = 50. 10 5. ( ) 10 1 K f Pa = 2. 52 10 = 0. 10 C b M Pa 1 T = 900 K = K = 10 C = ermal F = 2. (1- Z ) heat = conductivit ca acit E = Young's modulus = Poisson's ratio * aust = characteristic relating to e austenitic hase * fbm = characteristic relating to e hases ferritic, bainitic and martensitic = ermal coefficient of ermal exansion ref = strain of e hases ferritic, bainitic and martensitic fbm e reference temerature, austenite being regarded as not deformed wi is temerature = ield stress h = EET E ET K = coefficient relating to e lasticit of transformation F = function relating to e lasticit of transformation fbm e TRC used makes it ossible to model a metallurgical evolution of bainitic te, on all structure, of e form: Z fbm = 1.3 Boundar conditions and loadings fbm 0. si t τ1 τ1 = 60s t τ1 si τ1 t < τ2 τ2 = 112 s τ2 τ1 1. si t τ2 u Z =0 on e face AB (condition of smmetr). tension imosed (following ressure) on e face CD : Note: ( t ) o t our t τ1 = 6 t 360 10 Pa our τ 1 1 o 6 = 6 10 Pa τ = 60s Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 4/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 In large deformations, it is essential to use e following ressure to take account of current surface and not of initial surface (before strain). o T = T + µ t, = 5 C.s 1 on all structure. 1.4 Initial conditions T o = 900 C = T ref 2 Reference solution 2.1 Comutation of e reference solution (cf feeding-bottle [1] and [3]) For a traction test according to e direction x, e tensors of Kirchhoff and Cauch are form: τ 0 0 τ = 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 and = 0 0 0 0 0 0 wi τ = J e variation of volume J is given b e resolution of J 2 K J J ( 3 + ) 3 = 0 3 3 2 where is e ermal strain. This one alies to an austenitic transformation bainitic: Note: ref ref [ fbm fbm ] = Z α ( T T ) + Z α ( T T ) + aust aust ref b The coefficient K is e bulk modulus (not to be confused wi e coefficients K hase relating to e model of lasticit of transformation) In lastic load, for a linear isotroic R hardening, such as: R = ( Z h + Z h ) aust aust b fbm e cumulated lastic strain is wor = J Z h + Z h aust aust b fbm wi = Z + Z aust aust b fbm Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 5/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 e tensor gradients of e transformation F and F e strain tensor lastics G are form: F = J= det F = FF F = J / F F 0 0 F F = F = = - 1/ 3 F J F - 1/ 3 = J 0 F 0 et det 1 / F = F 0 0 F G = F 0 0 0 F 0 0 0 F G 0 0 0 G 0 0 0 G et et det G The law of evolution of e lastic strain G P is written: 2 = 1 G G / G = 2 4τ K ( 1 Z ) Z b b b 1 2 = ( G ) For 0s t 60s, ere A. Zb = 0 It is not ere lasticit of transformation. One obtains en: G = e 2 For 60s t 176s, one A. = constante to integrate e law of evolution of e lastic strain, it should be suosed at e stress of Kirchhoff varies ver little, i.e. e variation of volume J is ver small. Under is assumtion, one obtains G e e 2 ( ) K b Z b Z b = 2 4τ / 2 1/ 2 e comonent F of e gradient of e transformation is given b e resolution of: F 3 τ G F 1 3 2 = 0 µ ( G ) / Lastl, e field of dislacement u (in e initial configuration) is form u = uxx + uy + uz Z. The comonents are given b: u = ( F 1) X x ( / 1) ( / 1 ) u = J F Y u = J F Z z Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 6/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 2.2 Notice In e case test HSNV101 (modelization B), e coefficients of e material were selected of such wa not to have classical lasticit = 0 during e metallurgical transformation which takes lace between times 60 and 122s. Indeed if one writes e criterion of load-discharge in is time interval, one obtains f = 2750-250 wi = 360 MPa whom cancels oneself onl for onl one value of e cumulated lastic strain. For e constitutive law written in large deformations, e criterion of load-discharge is written between ese two times f = J( t ) 2750-250 wi = 360 MPa In is case, as long as e variable J remains lower an e value obtained at time t=60s, one will have = 0. However e value of J is function onl of e value of e ermal strain (e stress is constant and e coefficient K is indeendent of e metallurgical hases and e temerature). In is time interval, e ermal strain is given b e following equation: 7 2 4 = 8173. 10 t 11807. 10 t 2. 90763 10 One traces below e ermal strain as well as e variation of volume J, solution of e equation of e 3rd degree, according to time. Title: e Creator: cano avec agraf + Ilog Views CreationDate: 08/11/1999 10:42:57 Thermal strain according to time Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 7/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 Title: J Creator: cano avec agraf + Ilog Views CreationDate: 08/11/1999 10:50:01 Variation of volume J according to time One notes at e variable J decreases and increases same wa as e ermal strain. In is case, to know time from which e variable J is higher an e value obtained at time 60s, it is enough to know e time for which e ermal strain is identical to at obtained at time t=60s. One finds b e resolution of e equation above t=84.46s. 2.3 Uncertaint on e solution e solution is analtical. Two mistakes are made on is solution. The first door on e comutation of e bainitic roortion of hase created. The comutation metallurgical recondition does not restore exactl e equation of [ 1.2] giving Z fbm according to time, is is wh e results of reference resented below are calculated wi e bainitic roortion of hase calculated b Code_Aster. The second error is e assumtion made on e stress of Kirchhoff which is not constant on e time interval understood enters 60 and 176s. This will imact e comutation of dislacement u x and e lastic strain G P. 2.4 Results of reference One will adot like results of reference dislacement in e direction of e loading of tension, e stress of Cauch, e Boolean indicator of lasticit and e cumulated lastic strain. Various times of comutations are t=47, 48,60,83,84,85 and 176s. For e comutation of dislacement, e initial leng of e bar in e direction of loading is of 0.2m. Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 8/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 In all e cases, one has 3K=500000MPa (bulk modulus) =76923.077 MPa At time t=47s, one has Z b = 0 T = 665 C, = 282 MPa = 55225. 10 J = 0. 983855 τ = 277. 45 = 282. 5 MPa = 0 χ = 0 MPa G = 1 F = 10012. u = 8. 4347 10 At time t=48s, one has Z b = 0 T = 660 C, = 288 MPa = 564. 10 J = 0. 983508 τ = 28325. = 280. MPa = 1327. 10 χ = 1 MPa G = 0. 997 F = 100256. u = 5. 9639 10 At time t=60s, one has Z b = 0 T = 600 C, = 360 MPa = 7. 05 10 J = 0. 979337 τ = 352. 56 = 250. MPa = 37295. 10 χ = 1 G = 0. 9281 F = 103959. u = 6. 47595 10 At time t=83s, one has Z b = 0. 442138 T = 485 C, = 360 MPa 2 MPa 4 m 4 m m = 7. 07867 10 J = 0. 979249 τ = 352. 53 MPa -2 = 249. 978 MPa = 37295. 10 χ = 0-2 m G = 0. 8841277 F = 106514. u = 115441. 10 At time t=84 S, one has Z b = 0. 461361 T = 480 C, = 360 MPa = 7. 06031 10 J = 0. 979305 τ = 352. 55 MPa -2 = 249. 977 MPa = 3. 7296 10 χ = 1-2 G = 0. 8828104 F = 106593. u = 117051. 10 At time t=85s, one has Z b = 0. 480584 T = 475 C, = 360 MPa = 7. 04032 10 J = 0. 979367 τ = 352. 57 MPa -2 = 249. 976 MPa = 373044. 10 χ = 1-2 G = 0. 8815276 F = 106671. u = 118644. 10 At time t=176s, one has Z b = 1 T 2 = 20 C, = 360 MPa = 1068. 10 J = 0. 968132 τ = 348. 527 2 = 90. MPa = 59432. 10 χ = 1 G = 082814. F = 110053. u = 17743. 10 MPa 2 m Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 9/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 2.5 bibliograhical References One will be able to refer to: 1) V. CANO, E. LORENTZ: Introduction into e Code_Aster of an elastolastic model of behavior in large deformations wi isotroic hardening internal Note EDF DER HI - 74/98/006/0 2) A.M. DONORE, F. WAECKEL: Influence structure transformations in e elastolastic constitutive laws Notes HI-74/93/024 3). WAECKEL F, V. CANO: Constitutive law large deformations élasto (visco) lastic wi metallurgical transformations [R4.04.03] Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 10/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 3 Modelization A 3.1 Characteristic of e modelization C D N13 N11 N12 N9 N10 N7 N6 N8 N1 N3 N4 N2 N5 A B A= N4 B=N5 C= N13 D= N12. Charge: e nombre total of increments is of 102 (4 increments of 0 wi 46s, 2 increments of 46 wi 48s, 6 increments of 48 wi 60s, 26 of 60 wi 112s, 4 of 112 wi 116s and 60 increments until 176s ). Convergence is carried out if residue (RESI_GLOB_RELA) is lower or equal to 10-6. 3.2 Characteristics of e mesh Man nodes: 13 Number of meshes and tes: 2 meshes QUAD8, 6 meshes SEG3 3.3 Values tested Identification Reference t=47 Dislacement DY N13 8.4347 10-4 m t=47 Variable VARI M1, PG1 0. t=47 VARI M1, PG1 0 t=47 Stress SIGYY M1, PG1 282. 10 6 Pa t=48 Dislacement DY N13 5.9639 10-4 m t=48 Variable VARI M1, PG1 1.3260 10-3 t=48 VARI M1, PG1 1 t=48 Stress SIGYY M1, PG1 288. 106 Pa t=60 Variable DY N13 Dislacement 6.476 10-3 t=60 m VARI M1, PG1 3.7295 10-2 t=60 VARI M1, PG1 1 t=60 Stress SIGYY M1, PG1 360. 106 Pa Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)

Titre : HSNV122 - Thermo-lasticité et métallurgie en gran[...] Date : 27/02/2013 Page : 11/11 Resonsable : Jean ANGLES Clé : V7.22.122 Révision : 10537 t=83 Variable DY N13 Dislacement 1.1544 10-2 t=83 m VARI M1, PG1 3.7295 10-2 t=83 VARI M1, PG1 0 t=83 Stress SIGYY (M1, PG1) 360. 106 Pa t=84 Variable DY N13 Dislacement 1.1705 10-2 t=84 m VARI M1, PG1 3.7296 10-2 t=84 VARI M1, PG1 1 t=84 Stress SIGYY M1, PG1 360. 106 Pa t=85 Variable DY N13 Dislacement 1.1864 10-2 t=85 m VARI M1, PG1 3.7304 10-2 t=85 VARI M1, PG1 1 t=85 Stress SIGYY (M1, PG1) 360. 106 Pa t=176 Variable DY N13 Dislacement 1.7743 10-2 t=176 m VARI M1, PG1 5.943 10-2 t=176 VARI M1, PG1 1 t=176 Stress SIGYY M1, PG1 360. 106 Pa 4 Summar of e results Them results found wi Code_Aster are ver satisfactor wi ercentages of error lower an 0.9%, knowing at e analtical solution of reference makes e dead end on certain asects which into account recisel e solution of Code_Aster takes. This can exlain e differences observed. Warning : The translation rocess used on is website is a "Machine Translation". It ma be imrecise and inaccurate in whole or in art and is rovided as a convenience. Licensed under e terms of e GNU FDL (htt://www.gnu.org/coleft/fdl.html)