University of Groningen Field effect controlled magnetism and magnetotransport in low dimensions Liang, Lei IMPORTANT NOTE: You are advised to consult the publisher's version (publisher's PDF) if you wish to cite from it. Please check the document version below. Document Version Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record Publication date: 2017 Link to publication in University of Groningen/UMCG research database Citation for published version (APA): Liang, L. (2017). Field effect controlled magnetism and magnetotransport in low dimensions [Groningen]: Rijksuniversiteit Groningen Copyright Other than for strictly personal use, it is not permitted to download or to forward/distribute the text or part of it without the consent of the author(s) and/or copyright holder(s), unless the work is under an open content license (like Creative Commons). Take-down policy If you believe that this document breaches copyright please contact us providing details, and we will remove access to the work immediately and investigate your claim. Downloaded from the University of Groningen/UMCG research database (Pure): http://www.rug.nl/research/portal. For technical reasons the number of authors shown on this cover page is limited to 10 maximum. Download date: 20-11-2017
Dedicated to my families and friends
The work described in this thesis was performed in the research group Device Physics and Complex Materials of the Zernike Institute for Advanced Materials at the University of Groningen, the Netherlands. The thesis proposal was awarded an Ubbo Emmius scholarship funded by the University of Groningen and the research was supported by the European Research Council (consolidator grant no. 648855 Ig-QPD) and Dutch national facility NanoLabNL. Lei Liang All rights reserved. Figures, images, illustrations of this publication are original unless further noted. No part may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission of the author before being published on scientific journals. Zernike Institute PhD thesis series 2017-23 ISSN: 1570-1530 ISBN: 978-94-034-0290-1 (hardcopy version) ISBN: 978-94-034-0289-5 (electronic version) Cover design: Lei Liang Printed by: Gildeprint, Enschede Page number: 264 Print date: November 7, 2017
Field Effect Controlled Magnetism and Magnetotransport in Low Dimensions Proefschrift ter verkrijging van de graad van doctor aan de Rijksuniversiteit Groningen op gezag van de Rector Magnificus prof. dr. E. Sterken en volgens besluit van het College voor Promoties. De openbare verdediging zal plaatsvinden op vrijdag 17 november 2017 om 12.45 uur door Lei Liang geboren op 4 augustus 1987 te Shanxi, China
Promotores Prof. dr. J. T. Ye Prof. dr. T. T. M. Palstra Copromotor Dr. G. R. Blake Beoordelingscommissie Prof. dr. B. Koopmans Prof. dr. A. A. Khajetoorians Prof. dr. M. V. Mostovoy
Table of Contents Preface... 1 Emergent Electrical Transport and Magnetism at Low Dimensionality... 2 Motivation and Outline of this Thesis... 2 How to read this dissertation... 5 1 Ionic Gating Techniques and Magnetic Ionic Liquids... 8 1.1 Ionic Gating Technique... 8 1.1.1 Electric double layer transistor... 8 1.1.2 Ionic liquid/solid interfacial structure... 11 1.1.3 Transfer curve... 12 1.1.4 Carrier accumulation dynamic... 13 1.1.5 Leak current... 14 1.1.6 Temperature dependence of the ionic mobility... 16 1.2 Paramagnetic Ionic Liquids... 19 1.2.1 Synthesis... 19 1.2.2 Differential scanning calorimetry... 21 1.2.3 Thermogravimetric analysis... 23 1.2.4 X-ray diffraction measurement... 24 1.2.5 X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy... 24 1.2.6 Magnetic properties... 25 1.3 Summary... 27 1.4 References... 28 2 Inducing Ferromagnetism in Platinum by Paramagnetic Ionic Gating... 33 2.1 Introduction... 32 2.1.1 Electrical control of magnetism... 32 2.1.2 Magnetism at molecule/metal interface... 32 2.2 Concept... 33 2.2.1 Two-dimensional ferromagnetism... 33 2.2.2 Stoner criterion of band ferromagnetism... 33 2.2.3 Hall effect family and anomalous Hall effect... 34 2.3 Experiment... 37 2.3.1 Device fabrication and transport measurement... 37 2.3.2 Paramagnetic ionic liquid... 38 2.3.3 Magnetic property... 39 2.3.4 Paramagnetic ionic gating and temperature dependence of resistance... 40 2.4 Results and Discussion... 42 2.4.1 Band structure of the ionic gated Pt... 42 2.4.2 Perpendicular magnetic anisotropy... 43 2.4.3 Temperature-dependent anomalous Hall effect... 45 2.4.4 Gate-dependent anomalous Hall effect... 46 2.4.5 Thickness-dependent anomalous Hall effect... 47 2.4.6 Strong spin-orbit interaction... 48
ii Contents 2.4.7 Crossover between weak localization and weak anti-localization... 50 2.4.8 Scaling relationship of AHE in PIL-gated Pt and various other systems. 53 2.4.9 Magnetic phase diagram of PIL gated Pt... 55 2.5 Supplementary information... 57 2.5.1 Transport properties under negative ionic gate bias... 57 2.5.2 Transport properties of PIL-gated gold thin film... 58 2.5.3 Transport properties of PIL-gated palladium film... 59 2.5.4 Transport properties of Pt thin film doped with Fe impurity... 60 2.5.5 Gating cycles with sequential switch between PIL and conventional IL. 61 2.5.6 Optical and atomic force microscopy of Pt film before and after gating. 63 2.6 Summary... 64 2.7 References... 65 3 Discovery of the Kondo Effect in Molecular Spin Doped Platinum Thin Films.. 71 3.1 Introduction... 72 3.1.1 Electron transport of metal at low temperature... 72 3.1.2 Discovery and interpretation of the Kondo effect... 73 3.2 Concepts... 74 3.2.1 Ruderman-Kittel-Kasuya-Yosida interaction... 74 3.2.2 Quantum dots as artificial magnetic impurities... 75 3.2.3 Doniach diagram and the interplay between Kondo effect and the RKKY interaction... 75 3.3 Experiments... 76 3.3.1 Sample preparation... 76 3.3.2 Paramagnetic ionic gating... 77 3.4 Results and Discussion... 78 3.4.1 Thickness dependence of transfer curves... 78 3.4.2 Two-channel model for calculating in Kondo effect measurement... 79 3.4.3 Temperature dependence of R s for a series of film thicknesses... 80 3.4.4 The Kondo length scale and gated ion distribution... 81 3.4.5 Analysis of the Kondo parameters with numerical renormalization group method... 82 3.4.6 Correlation between the Kondo effect and paramagnetic ionic gating... 85 3.4.7 Interpretation of the Kondo state in presence of ferromagnetism... 86 3.5 Supplementary information... 86 3.5.1 Possible origins account for the low temperature transport other than Kondo effect... 86 3.5.2 Field dependence of the low temperature behavior... 88 3.6 Summary... 91 3.7 References... 92 4 Gate-Controlled Spin-Dependent Magnetoresistance of a Platinum Paramagnetic Insulator Interface... 95 4.1 Introduction... 96 4.1.1 Spintronics... 96 4.1.2 Molecular spintronics... 97 4.1.3 Paramagnetic ionic gating induced magnetoresistance... 97 4.2 Concepts... 98 4.2.1 A brief history of the magnetoresistance... 98 4.2.2 Anisotropic magnetoresistance... 102 4.2.3 Spin-Hall magnetoresistance... 102
Contents iii 4.3 Experiments... 104 4.3.1 Sample preparation... 104 4.3.2 Electrical measurement method... 105 4.3.3 Paramagnetic ionic gating... 106 4.3.4 Magnetic characterization of the PIL... 107 4.4 Results and Discussion... 110 4.4.1 Temperature dependence of longitudinal resistance... 110 4.4.2 Modulation of the resistivities... 112 4.4.3 Angle dependence of magnetoresistivity... 112 4.4.4 Field dependence of magnetoresistivity... 116 4.4.5 Temperature-dependent in-plane magnetoresistivity... 119 4.4.6 Temperature-dependent out-of-plane magnetoresistivity... 122 4.4.7 Temperature-dependent anomalous Hall effect... 123 4.4.8 Magnetic phase diagram... 125 4.4.9 Theory of spin-dependent magnetoresistance at Pt/paramagnetic insulator interface. 126 4.5 Supplementary Information... 128 4.5.1 Two-channel model of electrical transport with out-of-plane geometry. 128 4.5.2 Comparison of the in-plane magnetoresistance of PIL gated Pt with other systems... 130 4.5.3 Finite element modeling of the electrical transport... 132 4.6 Summary... 134 4.7 References... 135 5 Giant Magnetic Anisotropy in Layered Manganese Intercalated Tantalum Disulfide Thin Flake... 141 5.1 Introduction... 142 5.1.1 Layered materials... 142 5.1.2 Transition metal dichalcogenide... 144 5.1.3 Types of magnetic anisotropy... 145 5.2 Concepts... 147 5.2.1 Magnetocrystalline anisotropy... 147 5.2.2 SQUID Magnetometry... 150 5.3 Experiments... 151 5.3.1 Crystal growth... 151 5.3.2 X-ray diffraction... 152 5.3.3 Electron diffraction... 154 5.4 Results and discussion... 154 5.4.1 Magnetic susceptibility measurement... 154 5.4.2 Determination of the phase transition temperature from Arrott plot... 154 5.4.3 Field dependence of magnetization... 158 5.4.4 Temperature dependence of magnetization... 159 5.4.5 Magnetic phase diagram... 160 5.4.6 The appearance of spin-flop phase at low temperature... 161 5.4.7 Spin structures of the Mn 1/4 TaS 2... 162 5.5 Supplementary information... 163 5.5.1 Temperature dependence of magnetization... 163 5.5.2 Field dependence of magnetization with perpendicular magnetic field.. 164 5.5.3 Field-dependent magnetization as a function of temperature... 165
iv Contents 5.6 Summary... 166 5.7 References... 167 6 Spin-Dependent Magnetotransport in Layered Magnetic Mn 1/4 TaS 2 Thin Film... 171 6.1 Introduction... 172 6.1.1 Physical properties of TaS 2... 172 6.1.2 Magnetism of transitional metal intercalated TaS 2... 173 6.2 Concepts... 174 6.2.1 Giant magnetoresistance... 174 6.2.2 Band structure of the intercalated transitional metal dichalcogenide... 176 6.3 Experiments... 177 6.3.1 Mechanical cleavage of atomically thin films... 177 6.3.2 Device fabrication... 179 6.4 Results and discussion... 179 6.4.1 Temperature dependence of longitudinal resistance... 179 6.4.2 Field-dependent anisotropic magnetoresistance with perpendicular field... 181 6.4.3 Temperature-dependent magnetoresistance... 182 6.4.4 Theory of the spin-dependent magnetoresistance... 185 6.4.5 Angle-dependent magnetoresistance... 187 6.5 Supplementary information... 188 6.5.1 Determination of the spin-dependent longitudinal resistance... 188 6.5.2 Band structure of the Mn intercalated TaS 2... 189 6.5.3 Anomalous Hall effect of Mn 1/4 TaS 2... 190 6.6 Summary... 191 6.7 References... 192 7 A magnetically responsive one-dimensional mesoporous material functionalized with paramagnetic ionic liquid... 195 7.1 Introduction... 196 7.1.1 Porous material... 196 7.1.2 Synthesis of mesoporous material using block-copolymer... 197 7.2 Concepts... 197 7.2.1 Phase transition of ionic liquid... 197 7.2.2 Synthesis of SiO 2 -based mesoporous template... 198 7.3 Experiments... 200 7.3.1 Synthesis of SBA-15 mesoporous silica... 200 7.3.2 Encapsulation of paramagnetic ionic liquid... 200 7.3.3 Synthesis of SiO 2 nanospheres as comparison... 201 7.3.4 Transmission electron microscopy... 202 7.3.5 Raman spectra of PIL and the PIL@SBA-15... 202 7.4 Results and discussion... 204 7.4.1 Magnetic susceptibility measurement... 204 7.4.2 Magnetization curve of PIL@SBA-15... 204 7.4.3 Magnetization curve of the precursors... 205 7.4.4 Low temperature differential scanning calorimetry... 206 7.4.5 Raman spectrum of PIL@SBA-15... 206 7.4.6 Plausible explanation of one-dimensional ferromagnetism... 207 7.5 Conclusion... 208
Contents v 7.6 References... 209 A Appendix... 211 A.1 Micro-fabrication... 212 A.1.1 Electron-beam lithography... 212 A.1.2 Deep-UV optical lithography... 215 A.1.3 Magnetron sputtering... 218 A.1.4 Electron beam evaporation... 220 A.1.5 Exfoliation of layered materials... 222 A.2 Transport Measurement... 223 A.2.1 Lock-in technique... 223 A.2.2 Physical property measurement system... 226 A.2.3 Cryogen free measurement system... 227 A.2.3 Magnetic property measurement system... 228 Summary... 231 Samenvatting... 237 Acknowledgement... 243 Index... 249
Submitted to Science Advance: Lei Liang, Qihong Chen, Jianming Lu, Wytse Talsma, Juan Shan, Graeme R. Blake, Thomas T. M. Palstra, Jianting Ye Inducing ferromagnetism and Kondo effect in platinum by paramagnetic ionic gating, 2016 (in review) Preface T here is plenty of room at the bottom was a famous lecture given by physicist Richard Feynman in 1959. He was fascinated by many interesting phenomena at small scales and was particularly interested in seeing things small. It turns out to be a great perspective to the recent tremendous success of nanoscience. Magnetism, on the other hand, is a quite early discovery in the human history back to ancient time, when people noticed that lodestones can attract iron and made them into compass to show directions. Magnetism is mainly caused by spinning electrons. This spontaneous effect influences the behavior of other electrons in an interacting manner. In low dimensions, how do the electron transport and magnetism differ from the current understanding is a question that this thesis will try to answer.
2 Preface Emergent Electrical Transport and Magnetism at Low Dimensionality P Lev Landau unveils the profound essence of phase transitions, which is the change of symmetries. For example, the ferromagnetic ordering is due to the breaking of the time-reversal symmetry. Ferroelectricity, on the other hand, is because of the breaking of the spatial inversion symmetry. In low dimensionality, because of the reduced coordination number of the nearest neighboring atoms, the correlation of the electron wavefunctions differ significantly from the bulk, resulting in a strong perturbation of the band structure. Many exotic physical phenomena may stem from it. The burgeoning opportunities in spintronics benefit a lot from the growing knowledge of the magnetism at nanoscales. Throughout the evolution history of electronic devices, a deeper understanding of magnetism always accompanies with the development of newer techniques. These include the enormous successes of fabricating nanostructures with high-resolution electron-beam/photo lithography as well as the focused ion beam technologies. The breakthrough of the graphene research revitalizes the study of layered materials and successfully drives the limit of devices down to the two-dimensionality. Besides the aforementioned top-down approach, nanodevices can also be constructed bottom-up ascribing to the selfassembly polymer chemistry. This method has become an important supplement to the physics-oriented methods. Magnetism originates from spinning electrons and orbital motions. Taming spins would require concerted manner of magnetic field, electric field, crystal structure and temperature. The responses of these parameters vary for different materials, which forms the beauty of the physics. Motivation and Outline of this Thesis The main objective of this thesis is to explore and understand the electrical transport and magnetism in low-dimensional systems. Instead of complicated preparation of ultrathin films or heterojunctions, ionic gating provides a unique approach to access two-dimensional systems at channel/ionic liquid interface through fabricating an electric double layer transistor. In addition, the vast interests in layered materials since the experimental discovery of graphene boosts the development of new applications based on two-dimensional materials, including their magnetic properties. The outlines of each chapter of this thesis are addressed as follows. Chapter 1 first presents a general introduction to the ionic gating technique that is widely used in this thesis. The transfer curve of the ionic-gated field effect transistor as well as the kinetic of the involved electrochemistry will be
Preface 3 discussed. Later, comprehensive characterizations of the magnetic ionic liquids will be shown. Chapter 2 starts to explore the possibility of controlling magnetism with electrical means. Ferromagnetism has been successfully switched ON and OFF in platinum (Pt) thin film transistor by paramagnetic ionic gating. In ON state, anomalous Hall effect is used to characterize the magnetic parameters of ferromagnetic Pt. It shows coercivity as large as 1.5 T and a perpendicular magnetic anisotropy that is potentially important for developing new type of spintronics devices. The modification of surface carrier density is analyzed with respect to the band structure of Pt. Large spin-orbit interaction of Pt and its interaction with the magnetic ions are attributed to the emergence of ferromagnetism. In the longitudinal transport, magnetoresistance changing from negative to positive with increasing temperatures is interpreted as crossover between weak localization and weak anti-localization. Besides, clear thickness dependence is found in this system, which displays not only a decline of the ferromagnetism with the increase of film thicknesses but also a sign reversal of the normal Hall coefficient. In the end, a comprehensive phase diagram is constructed for the paramagnetic ionic gated-pt thin film system. P Chapter 3 focuses on the influence of local magnetic moments on electrical transport of Pt at low temperature from another point of view that is the Kondo effect. Molecular spins have been proved to be effective dopants in inducing complex transport phenomena at metal surfaces. They form mutual interaction with itinerant conduction electrons in a metal at a high concentration without aggregating, which is difficult to reach with other methods. The Kondo effect is investigated with the numerical renormalization group method, from which the Kondo parameters are derived. Normally, the Kondo correlation will be destructed with the presence of ferromagnetism. There are, however, several exceptions that the Kondo effect and magnetic ordering can be coexisting, which originate from the low-dimensionality. Moreover, our results shed light on understanding the itinerant-localized duality of electron transport. Chapter 4 is devoted to the investigation of the newly found spin-dependent magnetoresistance at the metal/paramagnetic insulator interface. Magnetoresistance is the core of data storage, sensors and logic devices. Each breakthrough of discovering new types of magnetoresistance in history will lead to a dramatic progress of electronic devices, such as the anisotropic magnetoresistance in sensors and giant magnetoresistance in high capacity data storages. Both of which, however, require the usage of ferromagnets that cause energy loss due to their stray field. We present the experimental results that support the availability of electrical manipulated magnetoresistance based
4 Preface P on interaction between conduction electrons in metal and local magnetic moments from a paramagnetic insulator. By virtue of the ionic gating technique, the magnitude of this interaction is determined by the number of ions at the metal surface and their types, which makes it gate controllable. The physics of this unique transport phenomenon is explained by the recently reported spin-hall magnetoresistance theory that is spin-dependent. Our results demonstrate the opportunity to electrically control the magnetism in low dimension by gating and pave the way of developing new type of spintronic devices. Chapter 5 moves to the study of transition metal dichalcogenide (TMD). Ever since the experimental discovery of graphene, many layered materials have been studied in terms of their electrical and photonic properties, particularly the large family of TMDs. However, the magnetic properties of these materials are comparably less studied, mostly because pristine TMDs are diamagnetic, which makes them less interesting. By intercalating magnetic ions into the crystal lattice of TMDs, it is possible to introduce fascinating magnetic properties. In this chapter, we will focus on the magnetic measurement of the layered manganese doped tantalum disulfide (Mn 1/4 TaS 2 ). This material shows extremely large magnetocrystalline anisotropy, which favors ferromagnetic ordering within the layers and antiferromagnetic ordering between the layers. Temperature and angle dependent magnetization and susceptibility measurement are performed to characterize this material. In the end, a magnetic phase diagram is presented as an overview of these unique properties. Chapter 6 will continue the study of Mn 1/4 TaS 2 from the electrical transport point of view. Because of the aforementioned large magnetic anisotropy, the atomic thin film of this material exhibits peculiar magnetoresistance. The transport properties are characterized by angular, temperature and field dependent measurements. The simultaneously detected anomalous Hall effect offers further information about the electron conduction mechanism and influence from the intercalated magnetic ions. A spin-dependent giant magnetoresistance type of mechanism is proposed to explain the observed phenomena. Chapter 7 presents an application in functionalizing nanoporous material through encapsulation of magnetic ionic liquid (PIL). Strong magnetic response of diamagnetic nanoporous silica is observed after encapsulating PIL molecules into their nanopores. In addition, the phase transition temperature of the PIL is shifted to higher temperature after encapsulation, which is due to stronger correlation between molecules inside the pores. The experiment
Preface 5 demonstrates that the PIL is universal besides gating purpose. Considering the large variety of PILs, more applications are expected to be discovered. Appendix lists the auxiliary means used in this thesis, including the device fabrication techniques, the preparation of the low-dimensional materials and the measurement methods. P How to read this thesis This thesis is written in a way that each chapter is independent from each other. You could jump to any chapter that you find interesting and start reading. On the other hand, we try to build up inter-chapter connection in order to unify all chapters into one thesis. If you would like to know more about the related works, you could refer to the Index of the key words. The content was conceived around the same topic: magnetism in low dimensions. Each chapter comprises of seven sections (maybe less), which are: 1. Introduction, 2. Concepts, 3. Experiments, 4. Results and Discussion, 5. Supplementary information, 6. Summary, 7. References. Start from Introduction, I first brief the audiences the background of the following research. Then, some relevant basic Concepts that will be used later to analyze the data or be helpful to understand the analysis will be presented. Next, I will move to the Experiments: the detail of device fabrication, material synthesis and measurement method will be mentioned. Afterward, the main dish will be served that is the Results and Discussion. In this thesis, electrical and magnetic measurements are the major means of studying samples' physical properties. For big size (in the order of millimeter) or large amount (in the order of milligram) of samples, direct characterization of the magnetization changes can be realized with magnetometry. However, it is not always possible to achieve especially in the case of interfacial effect that accompany with large background signals. In contrast, confining the electric current in low dimensions is much easier, which allows us to investigate the surface and interface behaviors. In some chapters, I split the secondary results into the Supplementary Information, such as many control experiments that increase the credibility of the explanation to our observation,
6 Preface which avoids the redundancy of including everything in the Results and Discussion section. In the end, we will put the main discovery and claims of this chapter in Summary. The References cited in the main text with numbers in square brackets will be listed in the end of each chapter. P