On the fractional-order logistic equation

Similar documents
Equilibrium points, stability and numerical solutions of fractional-order predator prey and rabies models

The Fractional-order SIR and SIRS Epidemic Models with Variable Population Size

On modeling two immune effectors two strain antigen interaction

Numerical solution of the Bagley Torvik equation. Kai Diethelm & Neville J. Ford

Picard,Adomian and Predictor-Corrector methods for integral equations of fractional order

ON FRACTIONAL ORDER CANCER MODEL

ERROR ANALYSIS, STABILITY, AND NUMERICAL SOLUTIONS OF FRACTIONAL-ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

A Fractional-Order Model for Computer Viruses Propagation with Saturated Treatment Rate

EXISTENCE AND UNIQUENESS OF SOLUTIONS FOR A SYSTEM OF FRACTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS 1. Yong Zhou. Abstract

Fractional Calculus Model for Childhood Diseases and Vaccines

PAijpam.eu NUMERICAL SOLUTION OF FRACTIONAL DELAY DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS USING SPLINE FUNCTIONS

DISCONTINUOUS DYNAMICAL SYSTEMS AND FRACTIONAL-ORDERS DIFFERENCE EQUATIONS

SMOOTHNESS PROPERTIES OF SOLUTIONS OF CAPUTO- TYPE FRACTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS. Kai Diethelm. Abstract

An Analysis on the Fractional Asset Flow Differential Equations

A computationally effective predictor-corrector method for simulating fractional order dynamical control system

Fractional Order Model for the Spread of Leptospirosis

On Local Asymptotic Stability of q-fractional Nonlinear Dynamical Systems

EXISTENCE OF SOLUTIONS TO FRACTIONAL ORDER ORDINARY AND DELAY DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS AND APPLICATIONS

Applied Mathematics Letters

Existence results for fractional order functional differential equations with infinite delay

Exact Solution of Some Linear Fractional Differential Equations by Laplace Transform. 1 Introduction. 2 Preliminaries and notations

Higher order numerical methods for solving fractional differential equations

On the numerical solutions of some fractional ordinary differential equations by fractional Adams-Bashforth-Moulton method

Research Article Nonlinear Dynamics and Chaos in a Fractional-Order HIV Model

Comparing Numerical Methods for Solving Nonlinear Fractional Order Differential Equations

Bifurcations of Fractional-order Diffusionless Lorenz System

Boundedness of solutions to a retarded Liénard equation

A FRACTIONAL ORDER SEIR MODEL WITH DENSITY DEPENDENT DEATH RATE

arxiv: v1 [math-ph] 9 Mar 2018

Numerical Solution of Multiterm Fractional Differential Equations Using the Matrix Mittag Leffler Functions

Construction of a New Fractional Chaotic System and Generalized Synchronization

Lecture 4: Numerical solution of ordinary differential equations

The (CLR g )-property for coincidence point theorems and Fredholm integral equations in modular metric spaces

A Survey of Numerical Methods in Fractional Calculus

EXISTENCE AND UNIQUENESS OF POSITIVE SOLUTIONS TO HIGHER-ORDER NONLINEAR FRACTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION WITH INTEGRAL BOUNDARY CONDITIONS

Numerical Detection of the Lowest Efficient Dimensions for Chaotic Fractional Differential Systems

Nonlocal problems for the generalized Bagley-Torvik fractional differential equation

Journal of Inequalities in Pure and Applied Mathematics

On boundary value problems for fractional integro-differential equations in Banach spaces

NUMERICAL SOLUTION OF FRACTIONAL ORDER DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS USING HAAR WAVELET OPERATIONAL MATRIX

Applied Mathematics Letters. Stationary distribution, ergodicity and extinction of a stochastic generalized logistic system

We are IntechOpen, the world s leading publisher of Open Access books Built by scientists, for scientists. International authors and editors

SOME RESULTS FOR BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEM OF AN INTEGRO DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS WITH FRACTIONAL ORDER

A Fractional Spline Collocation Method for the Fractional-order Logistic Equation

Exact Solutions of Fractional-Order Biological Population Model

June 17 19, 2015 Fields Institute, Stewart Library 2015 Summer Solstice 7th International Conference on Discrete Models of Complex Systems

On the synchronization of a class of electronic circuits that exhibit chaos

Local Polynomial Smoother for Solving Bagley-Torvik Fractional Differential Equations

A New Mathematical Approach for. Rabies Endemy

An Efficient Numerical Method for Solving. the Fractional Diffusion Equation

Boundary value problems for fractional differential equations with three-point fractional integral boundary conditions

Generalized Function Projective Lag Synchronization in Fractional-Order Chaotic Systems

NUMERICAL SOLUTION OF FRACTIONAL RELAXATION OSCILLATION EQUATION USING CUBIC B-SPLINE WAVELET COLLOCATION METHOD

A fractional order SIR epidemic model with nonlinear incidence rate

On the Finite Caputo and Finite Riesz Derivatives

multistep methods Last modified: November 28, 2017 Recall that we are interested in the numerical solution of the initial value problem (IVP):

Applied Mathematics Letters. Nonlinear stability of discontinuous Galerkin methods for delay differential equations

This work has been submitted to ChesterRep the University of Chester s online research repository.

A New Fractional-Order Chaotic System and Its Synchronization with Circuit Simulation

Fractional-order attractors synthesis via parameter switchings

A generalized Gronwall inequality and its application to a fractional differential equation

NONTRIVIAL SOLUTIONS TO INTEGRAL AND DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

ADAPTIVE SYNCHRONIZATION FOR RÖSSLER AND CHUA S CIRCUIT SYSTEMS

ISSN X (print) BIFURCATION ANALYSIS OF FRACTIONAL-ORDER CHAOTIC RÖSSLER SYSTEM

Applied Mathematics Letters

Impulsive stabilization of two kinds of second-order linear delay differential equations

Solving nonlinear fractional differential equation using a multi-step Laplace Adomian decomposition method

9.6 Predictor-Corrector Methods

Chaos Control and Synchronization of a Fractional-order Autonomous System

CHAPTER 5: Linear Multistep Methods

Oscillatory Solutions of Nonlinear Fractional Difference Equations

Applied Mathematics Letters. A reproducing kernel method for solving nonlocal fractional boundary value problems

Persistence and global stability in discrete models of Lotka Volterra type

DIfferential equations of fractional order have been the

Approximating solutions of nonlinear second order ordinary differential equations via Dhage iteration principle

MEASURE OF NONCOMPACTNESS AND FRACTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS IN BANACH SPACES

Jim Lambers MAT 772 Fall Semester Lecture 21 Notes

APPLICATION OF HAAR WAVELETS IN SOLVING NONLINEAR FRACTIONAL FREDHOLM INTEGRO-DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

Existence and Uniqueness Results for Nonlinear Implicit Fractional Differential Equations with Boundary Conditions

Conformable variational iteration method

Anti-synchronization of a new hyperchaotic system via small-gain theorem

Projective synchronization of a complex network with different fractional order chaos nodes

Applied Mathematics Letters

EXACT TRAVELING WAVE SOLUTIONS FOR NONLINEAR FRACTIONAL PARTIAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS USING THE IMPROVED (G /G) EXPANSION METHOD

Fractional Schrödinger Wave Equation and Fractional Uncertainty Principle


On Monch type multi-valued maps and fixed points

ON QUADRATIC INTEGRAL EQUATIONS OF URYSOHN TYPE IN FRÉCHET SPACES. 1. Introduction

A General Boundary Value Problem For Impulsive Fractional Differential Equations

Exponential Integrators

AN EXISTENCE-UNIQUENESS THEOREM FOR A CLASS OF BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEMS

Notes on uniform convergence

ON THE NUMERICAL SOLUTION FOR THE FRACTIONAL WAVE EQUATION USING LEGENDRE PSEUDOSPECTRAL METHOD

Viscosity approximation methods for the implicit midpoint rule of asymptotically nonexpansive mappings in Hilbert spaces

ASYMPTOTIC BEHAVIOR OF SOLUTIONS OF DISCRETE VOLTERRA EQUATIONS. Janusz Migda and Małgorzata Migda

LMI Methods in Optimal and Robust Control

A generalized Gronwall inequality and its application to fractional differential equations with Hadamard derivatives

SOLUTION OF FRACTIONAL INTEGRO-DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS BY ADOMIAN DECOMPOSITION METHOD

On the solution of the stochastic differential equation of exponential growth driven by fractional Brownian motion

Fractional differential equations with integral boundary conditions

Transcription:

Applied Mathematics Letters 20 (2007) 817 823 www.elsevier.com/locate/aml On the fractional-order logistic equation A.M.A. El-Sayed a, A.E.M. El-Mesiry b, H.A.A. El-Saka b, a Faculty of Science, Alexandria University, Alexandria, Egypt b Department of Mathematics, Damietta Faculty of Science, New Damietta, Egypt Received 14 November 2005; received in revised form 5 June 2006; accepted 4 August 2006 Abstract The topic of fractional calculus (derivatives and integrals of arbitrary orders) is enjoying growing interest not only among mathematicians, but also among physicists and engineers (see [E.M. El-Mesiry, A.M.A. El-Sayed, H.A.A. El-Saka, Numerical methods for multi-term fractional (arbitrary) orders differential equations, Appl. Math. Comput. 160 (3) (2005) 683 699; A.M.A. El-Sayed, Fractional differential difference equations, J. Fract. Calc. 10 (1996) 101 106; A.M.A. El-Sayed, Nonlinear functional differential equations of arbitrary orders, Nonlinear Anal. 33 (2) (1998) 181 186; A.M.A. El-Sayed, F.M. Gaafar, Fractional order differential equations with memory and fractional-order relaxation oscillation model, (PU.M.A) Pure Math. Appl. 12 (2001); A.M.A. El-Sayed, E.M. El-Mesiry, H.A.A. El-Saka, Numerical solution for multi-term fractional (arbitrary) orders differential equations, Comput. Appl. Math. 23 (1) (2004) 33 54; A.M.A. El-Sayed, F.M. Gaafar, H.H. Hashem, On the maximal and minimal solutions of arbitrary orders nonlinear functional integral and differential equations, Math. Sci. Res. J. 8 (11) (2004) 336 348; R. Gorenflo, F. Mainardi, Fractional calculus: Integral and differential equations of fractional order, in: A. Carpinteri, F. Mainardi (Eds.), Fractals and Fractional Calculus in Continuum Mechanics, Springer, Wien, 1997, pp. 223 276; D. Matignon, Stability results for fractional differential equations with applications to control processing, in: Computational Engineering in System Application, vol. 2, Lille, France, 1996, p. 963; I. Podlubny, A.M.A. El-Sayed, On Two Definitions of Fractional Calculus, Solvak Academy of science-institute of experimental phys, ISBN: 80-7099-252-2, 1996. UEF-03-96; I. Podlubny, Fractional Differential Equations, Academic Press, 1999] for example). In this work we are concerned with the fractional-order logistic equation. We study here the stability, existence, uniqueness and numerical solution of the fractional-order logistic equation. c 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. Keywords: Logistic equation; Fractional-order differential equations; Stability; Existence; Uniqueness; Numerical solution; Predictor corrector method 1. Introduction Now we give the definitions of fractional-order integration and fractional-order differentiation. Corresponding address: Department of Mathematics, Damietta Faculty of Science, Mansoura University, 34517 New Damietta, Egypt. Fax: +20 57 403868. E-mail addresses: amasayed@maktoob.com (A.M.A. El-Sayed), elmisiery@hotmail.com (A.E.M. El-Mesiry), halaelsaka@yahoo.com (H.A.A. El-Saka). 0893-9659/$ - see front matter c 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.aml.2006.08.013

818 A.M.A. El-Sayed et al. / Applied Mathematics Letters 20 (2007) 817 823 Definition 1. The fractional integral of order β R + of the function f (t), t > 0 is defined by I β f (t) = t 0 (t s) β 1 f (s) ds Γ (β) and the fractional derivative of order α (n 1, n) of f (t), t > 0 is defined by D α f (t) = I n α D n f (t), D = d dt. (1) (2) The following properties are some of the main ones of the fractional derivatives and integrals (see [10 19]). Let β, γ R + and α (0, 1). Then we have (i) Ia β : L 1 L 1, and if f (x) L 1, then Ia γ Ia β f (x) = Ia γ +β f (x). (ii) lim β n Ia β f (x) = Ia n f (x) uniformly on [a, b], n = 1, 2, 3,..., where I a 1 f (x) = x a (iii) lim β 0 Ia β f (x) = f (x) weakly. (iv) If f (x) is absolutely continuous on [a, b], then lim α 1 Da α d f (x) f (x) = dx. (v) If f (x) = k 0, k is a constant, then Da αk = 0. The following lemma can be easily proved (see [15]). Lemma 1.1. Let β (0, 1); if f C[0, T ], then I β f (t) t=0 = 0. f (s) ds. In Section 2 we will study the stability of the fractional-order differential equation and obtain results which agree with [2,3,17]. In Section 3 we will study the stability of the fractional-order logistic equation. In Section 4 we will study the existence and uniqueness of the fractional-order logistic equation. In Section 5 we will apply the PECE method for solving the fractional-order logistic equation. 2. Equilibrium and stability Let α (0, 1] and consider the initial value problem D α x(t) = f (x(t)), t > 0 and x(0) = x o. (3) To evaluate the equilibrium points of (3) let then D α x(t) = 0, f (x eq ) = 0. To evaluate the asymptotic stability, let then x(t) = x eq + ε(t), D α (x eq + ε) = f (x eq + ε) which implies that but D α ε(t) = f (x eq + ε) f (x eq + ε) f (x eq ) + f (x eq )ε + f (x eq + ε) f (x eq )ε

where f (x eq ) = 0, and then A.M.A. El-Sayed et al. / Applied Mathematics Letters 20 (2007) 817 823 819 D α ε(t) f (x eq )ε(t), t > 0 and ε(0) = x o x eq. (4) Now let the solution ε(t) of (4) exist. So if ε(t) is increasing, then the equilibrium point x eq is unstable and if ε(t) is decreasing, then the equilibrium point x eq is locally asymptotically stable. It must be noted that these results are the same results as for studying the stability of the initial value problem of the ordinary differential equation d dt x(t) = f (x(t)), t > 0 and x(0) = x o. Also these results agree with [2,3,17]. 3. Fractional-order logistic equation Now we study the equilibrium and stability of the fractional-order logistic equation. Let α (0, 1], ρ > 0 and x o > 0; the initial value problem of the fractional-order logistic equation is given by D α x(t) = ρ x(t)(1 x(t)), t > 0 and x(0) = x 0, (5) and to evaluate the equilibrium points, let D α x(t) = 0; then x = 0, 1 are the equilibrium points. Now, to study the stability of the equilibrium points, we have (see Section 2) f (x(t)) = ρ(1 2x(t)) f (0) = ρ and f (1) = ρ. Now the solution of the initial value problem D α ε(t) = f (x eq = 0)ε(t) = ρ ε(t), t > 0 and ε(0) = x o is given by (see [11]) ε(t) = n=0 ρ n t nα Γ (nα + 1) x o and then the equilibrium point x = 0 is unstable. Also for the equilibrium point x = 1 we have the initial value problem (6) D α ε(t) = f (x eq = 1)ε(t) = ρ ε(t), t > 0 and ε(0) = x o 1 which is (if x o > 1) the fractional-order relaxation equation and has the solution [13] ε(t) = n=0 ( ρ) n t nα Γ (nα + 1) (x o 1) and then the equilibrium point x = 1 is asymptotically stable. (7) 4. Existence and uniqueness Let I = [0, T ], T < and C(I ) be the class of all continuous functions defined on I, with norm x = sup e Nt x(t), N > 0 (8) t which is equivalent to the sup-norm x = sup t x(t). When t > σ 0 we write C(I σ ). Consider the initial value problem of the fractional-order logistic equation (5).

820 A.M.A. El-Sayed et al. / Applied Mathematics Letters 20 (2007) 817 823 Definition 2. We will define x(t) to be a solution of the initial value problem (5) if (1) (t, x(t)) D, t I where D = I B, B = {x R : x b}. (2) x(t) satisfies (5). Theorem 4.1. The initial value problem (5) has a unique solution x C(I ), x X = {x L 1 [0, T ], x = e Nt x(t) L1 }. Proof. From the properties of fractional calculus the fractional-order differential equation in (5) can be written as I 1 α d x(t) = ρx(t)(1 x(t)). dt Operating with I α we obtain x(t) = x o + I α ρ(x(t) x 2 (t)). Now let the operator F : C(I ) C(I ) be defined by (9) Then Fx(t) = x o + I α ρ(x(t) x 2 (t)). e Nt (Fx Fy) = ρ e Nt I α [(x(t) y(t)) (x 2 (t) y 2 (t))] t (t s) α 1 ρ e N(t s) (x(s) y(s))(1 + (x(s) + y(s)))e Ns ds 0 Γ (α) (1 + 2b) ρ t s α 1 e Ns N α x y ds. Γ (α) This implies that (1 + 2b) ρ Fx Fy x y N α and it can be proved that if we choose N such that N α Fx Fy < x y 0 > (1 + 2b) ρ, we obtain and the operator F given by (10) has a unique fixed point. Consequently the integral equation (9) has a unique solution x C(I ). Also we can deduce that [15] I α (x x 2 ) t=0 = 0. Now from Eq. (9) we formally have and [ x(t) = x o + ρ t α Γ (α + 1) (x o x 2 o ) + I α+1 (x (t) 2x(t)x (t)) [ dx t α 1 ] = ρ dt Γ (α) (x o xo 2 ) + I α (x (t) 2x(t)x (t)), [ t e Nt x (t) = ρe Nt α 1 ] Γ (α) (x o xo 2 ) + I α (x (t) 2x(t)x (t)) from which we can deduce that x C(I σ ) and x X. Now from Eq. (9), we get dx = ρ d dt dt I α [x(t) x 2 (t)] 1 α dx I = ρ I 1 α d dt dt I α [x(t) x 2 (t)] 1 α dx I = ρ d dt dt I 1 α I α [x(t) x 2 (t)] ] (10)

A.M.A. El-Sayed et al. / Applied Mathematics Letters 20 (2007) 817 823 821 D α x(t) = ρ d dt I [x(t) x2 (t)] D α x(t) = ρ [x(t) x 2 (t)] and x(0) = x o + I α ρ [x(t) x 2 (t)] t=0 x(0) = x o + 0 x(0) = x o Then the integral equation (9) is equivalent to the initial value problem (5) and the theorem is proved. 5. Numerical methods and results An Adams-type predictor corrector method has been introduced in [4,5] and investigated further in [1,6 10,14]. In this work we use an Adams-type predictor corrector method for the numerical solution of a fractional integral equation. The key to the derivation of the method is replacing the original fractional differential equation in (3) by the fractional integral equation (11) x(t) = x o + I α f (x(t)). (11) The product trapezoidal quadrature formula is used with nodes t j ( j = 0, 1,..., k + 1), taken with respect to the weight function (t k+1.) α 1. In other words, one applies the approximation tk+1 t 0 (t k+1 u) α 1 g(u)du tk+1 t 0 k+1 (t k+1 u) α 1 g k+1 (u)du = a j,k+1 g(t j ), where h α a j,k+1 = α(α + 1) [kα+1 (k α)(k + 1) α ] if j = 0, h α if j = k + 1 α(α + 1) and h is a step size, and for 1 j k a j,k+1 = h α α(α + 1) [(k j + 2)α+1 2(k j + 1) α+1 + (k j) α+1 ]. This yields the corrector formula, i.e. the fractional variant of the one-step Adams Moulton method ( ) x k+1 = x 0 + 1 k a j,k+1 f (x j ) + a k+1,k+1 f (x p Γ (α) k+1 ). (12) The remaining problem is the determination of the predictor formula that is needed to calculate the value x p k+1. The idea used to generalize the one-step Adams Bashforth method is the same as the one described above for the Adams Moulton technique: the integral on the right-hand side of Eq. (11) is replaced by the product rectangle rule, i.e. tk+1 t 0 (t k+1 u) α 1 g(u)du k b j,k+1 g(t j ),

822 A.M.A. El-Sayed et al. / Applied Mathematics Letters 20 (2007) 817 823 where b j,k+1 = hα α [(k + 1 j)α (k j) α ]. Fig. 1. Thus, the predictor x p k+1 is determined by the fractional Adams Bashforth method: x p k+1 = x 0 + 1 Γ (α) k b j,k+1 f (x j ). This completes the description of the basic algorithm, namely, the fractional version of the one-step Adams Bashforth Moulton method. Recapitulating, one first calculates the predictor x p k+1 according to Eq. (13), then evaluates f (x p k+1 ), uses this to determine the corrector x k+1 by means of Eq. (12), and finally evaluates f (x k+1 ) which is then used in the next integration step. Methods of this type are usually called predictor corrector or, more precisely, PECE (Predict, Evaluate, Correct, Evaluate) methods. Now we apply the PECE method to the fractional logistic equation in (5). The approximate solutions are displayed in Fig. 1 for the step size 0.05 and different values of α. In Fig. 1 we take ρ = 0.5 and x 0 = 0.85. References [1] E. Ahmed, A.M.A. El-Sayed, E.M. El-Mesiry, H.A.A. El-Saka, Numerical solution for the fractional replicator equation, Internat. J. Modern Phys. C. 16 (7) (2005) 1 9. [2] E. Ahmed, A.M.A. El-Sayed, H.A.A. El-Saka, On some Routh Hurwitz conditions for fractional order differential equations and their applications in Lorenz, Rössler, Chua and Chen systems, Phys. Lett. A 358 (1) (2006). [3] E. Ahmed, A.M.A. El-Sayed, H.A.A. El-Saka, Equilibrium points, stability and numerical solutions of fractional-order predator prey and rabies models, J. Math. Anal. Appl. 325 (2007) 542 553. [4] K. Diethelm, A. Freed, On the solution of nonlinear fractional order differential equations used in the modelling of viscoplasticity, in: F. Keil, W. Mackens, H. Voß, J. Werther (Eds.), Scientific Computing in Chemical Engineering II Computational Fluid Dynamics, Reaction Engineering, and Molecular Properties, Springer, Heidelberg, 1999, pp. 217 224. [5] K. Diethelm, A. Freed, The FracPECE subroutine for the numerical solution of differential equations of fractional order, in: S. Heinzel, T. Plesser (Eds.), Forschung und wissenschaftliches Rechnen 1998, Gesellschaft für Wisseschaftliche Datenverarbeitung, Göttingen, 1999, pp. 57 71. [6] K. Diethelm, N.J. Ford, The numerical solution of linear and non-linear fractional differential equations involving fractional derivatives several of several orders, Numerical Analysis Report 379, Manchester Center for Numerical Computational Mathematics. [7] K. Diethelm, Predictor corrector strategies for single- and multi-term fractional differential equations, in: E.A. Lipitakis (Ed.), Proceedings of the 5th Hellenic European Conference on Computer Mathematics and its Applications, LEA Press, Athens, 2002, pp. 117 122 [Zbl. Math. 1028.65081]. [8] K. Diethelm, N.J. Ford, A.D. Freed, A predictor corrector approach for the numerical solution of fractional differential equations, Nonlinear Dyn. 29 (2002) 3 22. [9] K. Diethelm, N.J. Ford, A.D. Freed, Detailed error analysis for a fractional Adams method, Numer. Algorithms 36 (2004) 31 52. [10] E.M. El-Mesiry, A.M.A. El-Sayed, H.A.A. El-Saka, Numerical methods for multi-term fractional (arbitrary) orders differential equations, Appl. Math. Comput. 160 (3) (2005) 683 699. (13)

A.M.A. El-Sayed et al. / Applied Mathematics Letters 20 (2007) 817 823 823 [11] A.M.A. El-Sayed, Fractional differential difference equations, J. Fract. Calc. 10 (1996) 101 106. [12] A.M.A. El-Sayed, Nonlinear functional differential equations of arbitrary orders, Nonlinear Anal. 33 (2) (1998) 181 186. [13] A.M.A. El-Sayed, F.M. Gaafar, Fractional order differential equations with memory and fractional-order relaxation oscillation model, Pure Math. Appl. 12 (2001). [14] A.M.A. El-Sayed, E.M. El-Mesiry, H.A.A. El-Saka, Numerical solution for multi-term fractional (arbitrary) orders differential equations, Comput. Appl. Math. 23 (1) (2004) 33 54. [15] A.M.A. El-Sayed, F.M. Gaafar, H.H. Hashem, On the maximal and minimal solutions of arbitrary orders nonlinear functional integral and differential equations, Math. Sci. Res. J. 8 (11) (2004) 336 348. [16] R. Gorenflo, F. Mainardi, Fractional calculus: Integral and differential equations of fractional order, in: A. Carpinteri, F. Mainardi (Eds.), Fractals and Fractional Calculus in Continuum Mechanics, Springer, Wien, 1997, pp. 223 276. [17] D. Matignon, Stability results for fractional differential equations with applications to control processing, in: Computational Engineering in System Application, vol. 2, Lille, France, 1996, p. 963. [18] I. Podlubny, A.M.A. El-Sayed, On Two Definitions of Fractional Calculus, Solvak Academy of science-institute of experimental phys, ISBN: 80-7099-252-2, 1996. UEF-03-96. [19] I. Podlubny, Fractional Differential Equations, Academic Press, 1999.