Strategies for the Analysis of Therapeutic Peptides in Biofluids by LC-MS/MS Lee Goodwin
Sample Preparation Chromatography Detection General Strategies Examples New Approaches Summary Outline
ABUNDANCE Introduction AMINO ACIDS PEPTIDES PROTEINS 10 100 1000 10000 100000 1000000 Mass (Da)
Introduction Working definition of Peptide vs Protein Peptide consists of <50 amino acid residues Homogenous Usually <10 kda May be synthetic May contain non-natural amino acids Protein consists of >50 amino acid residues Non-homogenous The chemical and physical properties of both peptides and proteins will be determined by the composition and relative abundance of the constituent amino acids.
Sample Preparation Adsorption: Low adsorption polypropylene storage vessels Preparation of standards in matrix Using inhibitors or competitors e.g. surfactants Using aqueous and organic modifier mix to keep peptides in solution, e.g. acetonitrile, methanol and iso-propanol Elimination of peptide - protein binding (changing the structure of the protein) Guanadine HCl Urea Organic solvent Trifluoroacetic acid Phosphoric acid
Reverse Phase (SPE) Sample Preparation Use of polymeric sorbents Ion-exchange (SPE) Mixed mode polymeric sorbents such as WCX, MCX (cation ex.) MAX (anion ex.) Pore size of 40-80 Å allows elimination of large proteins at the sample preparation stage Very efficient at removing salts
Chromatography Reverse Phase Chromatography The most widely used Efficient mode of separation Can distinguish peptides with minor structural differences Compatible with electrospray MS Mechanism: The peptide adsorbs on to the reverse phase sorbent and is desorbed from the surface at a critical organic modifier concentration Combination of adsorption/desorption and partitioning PARTITIONING SIZE ADSORPTION
Chromatography O H O N H 2 Amino acid PARTITIONING SIZE ADSORPTION Peptide HPLC Particle C18 Brush Border
Particle size Chromatography Smaller particles give greater efficiency Pore size Must be big enough to allow peptides to penetrate Typical pore sizes for peptide separation - 120 to 300 Å Column length Rate of gradient more important than column length Isocratic or gradient elution? Gradient elution preferred Typical gradient <10% change in acetonitrile.
Chromatography Effect of Ionic Modifiers TFA is the most common modifier for peptides Strong ion pair reagent: protonates silanols eliminates secondary effects Suppresses MS sensitivity Reducing concentration from 0.1% to 0.01% reduces this effect Formic and acetic acid may be used to increase MS sensitivity (fine balance between chromatography and MS sensitivity) Require more inert (end capped columns) e.g. RP-18 shield, C18-peptide Neutral peptides will chromatograph better Higher charged peptides will show greater MS sensitivity
Detection Analysis of peptides by electrospray ionisation Electrospray is suitable for polar compounds Electrospray is a concentration dependent technique and sensitivity can be increased by running narrower columns: 2.1 mm and below with lower flow rates. Multiple charging enables larger masses to be analysed, but compromises sensitivity through charge distribution
Variable Ionisation M+1 Singly charged
M+2 Variable Ionisation Doubly charged
Summed Variable Ionisation Monitoring several ionisation states can help linearity and sensitivity Linear range often has to be truncated to <500x due to linearity problems
Detection Peptides can be difficult to fragment under collision induced dissociation (CID) within the quadrupole instrument All or nothing Collision cell pressure (amount of collision gas) is more critical than the collision energy of the ions to increase the efficiency of the desired fragmentation
Small peptides General Strategies Small peptides (up to approx. 3 kda) TFA often used in place of solvent precipitation - denaturation step prevents protein binding Many peptides are insoluble in high levels of methanol or acetonitrile Off-line SPE using mixed mode ion-exchange Sample concentration under temperature and nitrogen Use of RP or HILIC UPLC
General strategies LLOQ 5 ng/ml
Approach to Small Peptides Uses protein precipitation or SPE methods similar to those applied to small molecules Compatible with automated systems Small Peptides Typical chromatography is short gradient RP- UPLC/HPLC as used for small molecules Some additional consideration required towards solubility and adsorption (balancing the aqueous/organic composition)
Why the need for a second approach? Insufficient sensitivity for larger peptides Multiple charge states mean lower sensitivity and greater need for high sample and loading volumes Greater sample and loading volumes requires additional cleanup Insufficient cleanup for larger peptides Larger peptides are often quite polar and are difficult to separate from endogenous contaminants using conventional approaches
General Strategies Mid-mass range peptides 3 to 10 kda Off-line SPE using mixed mode ion-exchange No concentration of sample by the use of temperature or pressure Peptides are susceptible to adsorption On-line SPE aid sample concentration, maximise sample loading and further clean-up Analytical column with reverse phase TFA gradient
General strategies Protein binding is common & is resolved by: Incubation with guanidine prior to SPE Incubation with 10% phosphoric acid prior to SPE Protein precipitation with 10% TFA Ensure that aqueous:organic mixture is optimised Keep peptide in solution Prevent adsorption to vessels
Preclinical 10 ng/ml, 5 kda peptide from 100 μl plasma; offline SPE 5 kda Peptide in Plasma 160 cps Clinical 0.5 ng/ml from 200 μl plasma; online SPE
Approach to Larger Peptides Can use protein precipitation and SPE methods similar to those applied to small molecules as preliminary clean-up or for high LLOQ assays Additional considerations such as protein binding, adsorption, cleanup and phase choices Larger peptide On-line SPE to achieve maximum loading and sensitivity More manual processing required (methods often use high sample volume, and both PPT or dissociation followed by SPE)
Large Peptides/Proteins Recent increase in large biomolecules has led to an interest in LC- MS/MS approaches for quantification Immunoassay is limited by the requirement for, and the selectivity of antibodies LC-MS/MS allows sensitive and selective quantification of small peptides, however, sensitivity for larger molecules is compromised by many multiple charge states forming Therefore tryptic digestion is used, followed by analysis of proteotypic surrogate peptide sequence(s).
Proteins Proteins (>10 kda) General strategies Digest the peptide with trypsin at arg and lys residues Identify the smaller characteristic peptide fragments (surrogate peptide) Quantitate using the surrogate peptide from the target polypeptide by LC-MS/MS - treat as approach 1 or 2!
Proteolytic Digestion and Surrogate Peptides Denature pure protein standard and digest Infuse on MS/MS system Look for predicted surrogate peptides (typical masses 500-3000, usually M+2 ions formed) Develop LC-MS/MS method for chosen surrogate Apply method to quantify plasma samples
Tryptic Digestion of Lysozyme Mol. Wt 14.3 kda. Choice of internal standard Denature 500 μl sample Optimising denaturation Abundant Protein Depletion (Oasis HLB) Digest Surrogate peptide Choice of surrogate peptide Cleanup by manual SPE (Oasis HLB) Optimise cleanup Dilute out Eluate with 0.1% TFA in water containing 0.01% Triton X-100 Load onto Symbiosis system Optimise Symbiosis
Refinement of Method for Lysozyme in Plasma Approach One Initial method 5000 ng/ml (350 nm) Approach Two Protein Depletion 500 ng/ml (35 nm) Approach Three Symbiosis (larger volume extracted) 50 ng/ml
Relative Abundance High Field Asymmetric Waveform Ion Mobility Spectrometry Acts as an ion filter between the source and MS: Removes singly charged interferences eg lipids, plasticisers Allows polycharged ions through, increasing specificity RT: 3.38-5.66 SM: 7B NL: 3.41E3 100 95 90 85 80 4.06 1043.5 500pg no FAIMS m/z= 1043.50-1044.50 F: + c ESI SIM cnl 0.000 [894.250-894.750, 1043.250-1043.750, 1251.750-1252.250] MS Std500pg005 RT: 0.00-7.00 SM: 7B 100 95 90 RT: 5.66 AA: 3631 SN: 128 NL: 8.91E2 m/z= 1251.50-1252.50 F: + c ESI SIM cnl 0.000 [894.250-894.750, 1043.250-1043.750, 1251.750-1252.250] MS Genesis Std500pg003 75 85 70 80 65 75 60 70 500pg/mL 50uL 0 CNL CE 20 gas pressure 2.0 55 50 45 40 35 30 4.83 RT: 5.12 MA: 5348 SN: 2 65 60 55 50 45 40 35 Summing +5, +6 and +7 charge states of a 6.2 kda peptide 25 30 20 15 4.72 4.36 5.38 4.54 5.00 5.26 5.41 25 20 10 15 5 10 0 3.53 3.65 3.85 3.98 3.4 3.6 3.8 4.0 4.2 4.4 4.6 4.8 5.0 5.2 5.4 5.6 Time (min) No FAIMS 5 0 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 FAIMS 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 Time (min)
Potential benefits of DBS for peptides Peptides often degrade or protein bind in liquid samples Proteolytic degradation Enzymic modification Blood spot cards are treated with a variety of surfactants and enzyme inhibitors to lyse cells and inhibit enzymes Whatman FTA DMPK-A and B (Treated cards) Whatman FTA DMPK C (Untreated cards) DBS sampling may prevent degradation
Challenges for DBS of Peptides Achieving 10 ng/ml sensitivity (same as the plasma LLOQ) with only a fraction of the equivalent sample volume from a blood spot punch. 20 μl spot approximate diameter 7mm 4 mm punch equivalent to only 6.5 μl volume (65 pg ramoplanin) Achieving recovery of the peptides from the bloodspot cards without compromising their solubility Balancing aqueous and organic composition may be critical Combating the usual challenges of peptides, including adsorption and poor MS/MS fragmentation
Recovery (%) Results of Optimisation 4 mm punch of sample added to 1 ml 96-well plate. 100 μl of water: acetonitrile (50:50 v/v) containing 1000 ng/ml Teicoplanin added (blanks receive blank solvent instead). Stand plate for 20 minutes then vortex mix for 90 minutes. Centrifuge plate and remove 60 μl supernatant to 1 ml well plate. Add 40 μl 10 mm ammonium formate + 0.2% formic acid. Cap plate, vortex mix, centrifuge and inject (50 μl) 65.0 60.0 55.0 50.0 45.0 40.0 35.0 30.0 25.0 20.0 15.0 10.0 5.0 Recovery of Ramoplanin from Human DBS 0.0 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 % Acetonitrile (aq)
DBS of Ramoplanin MW: 2554 10 ng/ml Calibration Curve 10-10000 ng/ml Validation of a bioanalytical method for the quantification of a therapeutic peptide, ramoplanin, in human dried blood spots using LC-MS/MS. Matthew F. Ewles, Phillip E. Turpin, Lee Goodwin, David M. Bakes; Biomedical Chromatography: In Press
Summary Sample Preparation Very different from small molecules Binding, solubility and adsorption effects can all be significant Use of mixed mode ion exchange Chromatography Important considerations: column chemistry, ionic modifier, flow rate, gradient rate and column temperature The best analytical combination: Mixed mode ion exchange followed by reverse phase chromatography (Analysis based upon 2D separation) HILIC chromatography for small peptides Detection Electrospray for quantitative work, but there are limitations with fragmentation, charge distribution and selectivity with increasing mass