A Case Study of B s µ + µ in the MSSM Based on arxiv:0812:4320 In collaboration with A. Dedes, J Rosiek. Cornell University Informal CIHEP Pizza Lunch February 6, 2009 Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 1 / 16
GeV 10 19 String Theory 10 16 Unification &!s 10 3 10 2 10 1 10 0 Supersymmetry LHC Energy... eventually EWSB brown muck of Hadronic Physics 10-6 Cosmology... not to scale Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 2 / 16
GeV 10 19 String Theory 10 16 Unification &!s 10 3 10 2 10 1 10 0 Supersymmetry LHC Energy... eventually EWSB brown muck of Hadronic Physics 10-6 Cosmology... not to scale Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 2 / 16
GeV 10 19 10 16 10 3 10 2 10 1 10 0 10-6 String Theory Unification &!s Supersymmetry LHC Energy... eventually EWSB brown muck of Hadronic Physics Cosmology... not to scale decreasing espresso machine responsibility Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 2 / 16
Complimentarity Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 3 / 16
The program of flavor physics Goniometry The measurement of angles Luminosity frontier Many different measurements Laboratory: B mesons We will focus on one particular decay (B s µµ), but one should always remember that it s just one piece of a larger program. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 4 / 16
B-mesons: state-of-the-art flavor laboratories Meson Mass Mean lifetime Bd 0 5.280 GeV 1.53 10 12 s Bs 0 5.370 GeV 1.44 10 12 s B-factories traditionally run at Υ(4S) resonance, which produce B d, but not B s. B-mesons have just the right mass and width to allow us to measure their oscillation (CP phase). Asymmetric B-factories allow us to measure the different branching ratios of B and B mesons. Presently we are interested in FCNC B-decays. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 5 / 16
The March of the Penguins b s Penguin diagram Allows FCNC sub-diagram to occur on-shell. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 6 / 16
The March of the Penguins Penguin diagram b u i s Allows FCNC sub-diagram to occur on-shell. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 6 / 16
The March of the Penguins Penguin diagram b u i s Allows FCNC sub-diagram to occur on-shell. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 6 / 16
The March of the Penguins Penguin diagram b u i s Allows FCNC sub-diagram to occur on-shell. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 6 / 16
The March of the Penguins new physics Penguin diagram b u i s Allows FCNC sub-diagram to occur on-shell. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 6 / 16
The March of the Penguins new physics Penguin diagram b u i s Allows FCNC sub-diagram to occur on-shell. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 6 / 16
The March of the Penguins new physics Penguin diagram b u i s Allows FCNC sub-diagram to occur on-shell. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 6 / 16
The March of the Penguins Where do we look for penguins? Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 7 / 16
The March of the Penguins Where do we look for penguins? Antarctica. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 7 / 16
The March of the Penguins Where do we look for penguins? Antarctica. Very little background, penguin is dominant fauna. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 7 / 16
The March of the Penguins µ µ Where do we look for SUSY penguins? B s µ + µ. Very little background, penguin is dominant process. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 7 / 16
B s µ + µ : Very little background The Standard Model background is suppressed by... Loop: no tree-level contribution, (16π 2 ) 1 FCNC: GIM suppression, V V bs Helicity: Lepton mass insertion, m µ /M Bs Channel Expt. Bound (90% CL) SM Prediction Bs 0 µ + µ CDF II < 4.7 10 8 (4.8 ± 1.3) 10 9 Bd 0 µ + µ CDF II < 1.5 10 8 (1.4 ± 0.4) 10 10 Bs 0 µ + e CDF II < 2.0 10 7 0 Bd 0 µ + e CDF II < 6.4 10 8 0 Clean dilepton signal, only hadronic uncertainty is f B. Ideal for LHC. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 8 / 16
B s µ + µ : Penguin is the dominant process In the MSSM, the Higgs-penguin mediated B s µ + µ diagram is sensitive to tan β. Recall: tan β = v u /v d. b b µ µ ( ) ( ) ( ) m sr b s 0 sl R y b ɛv u m b b L Amplitude is enhanced by tan 3 β. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 9 / 16
B s µ + µ : Penguin is the dominant process In the MSSM, the Higgs-penguin mediated B s µ + µ diagram is sensitive to tan β. Recall: tan β = v u /v d. b b µ µ ( ) ( ) ( ) m sr b s 0 sl R y b ɛv u m b b L y b,l = m b,l v d 1 cos β tan β 1 tan β Amplitude is enhanced by tan 3 β. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 9 / 16
B s µ + µ : Penguin is the dominant process In the MSSM, the Higgs-penguin mediated B s µ + µ diagram is sensitive to tan β. Recall: tan β = v u /v d. b y d µ ( ) ( ) ( ) m sr b s 0 sl R y b ɛv u m b b L b µ y b,l = m b,l v d 1 cos β tan β 1 tan β Amplitude is enhanced by tan 3 β. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 9 / 16
B s µ + µ : Penguin is the dominant process In the MSSM, the Higgs-penguin mediated B s µ + µ diagram is sensitive to tan β. Recall: tan β = v u /v d. b y d y l µ ( ) ( ) ( ) m sr b s 0 sl R y b ɛv u m b b L b µ y b,l = m b,l v d 1 cos β tan β 1 tan β Amplitude is enhanced by tan 3 β. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 9 / 16
B s µ + µ : Penguin is the dominant process In the MSSM, the Higgs-penguin mediated B s µ + µ diagram is sensitive to tan β. Recall: tan β = v u /v d. b b y d y l µ µ ( ) ( ) ( ) m sr b s 0 sl R y b ɛv u m b b L s-b mixing: sin θ y b ɛv u /m b ɛ tan β y b,l = m b,l v d 1 cos β tan β 1 tan β Amplitude is enhanced by tan 3 β. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 9 / 16
The March of the Penguins The standard model background... Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 10 / 16
The March of the Penguins The standard model background... and SUSY at large tan β Br (B s µµ) 5 10 7 (tan β/50) 6 (300 GeV/M A 0) 4 Motivation: Grand unification, msugra + (g 2) µ Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 10 / 16
But what about low tan β? Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 11 / 16
But what about low tan β? b d χ 0 µ l b g d Z µ b ũ χ + h µ s χ 0 µ s d µ s χ µ No photon penguin by Ward identity. Higgs penguin no longer dominant One has to consider interference with other diagrams Possibility: cancellation below SM prediction? Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 12 / 16
Low tan β scan + - ) μ μ Br(B s -> 10-6 10-7 10-8 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 5 10 15 20 25 30 tan β + - ) Br(B s -> 10-6 10-7 10-8 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 -0.1-0.05 0 0.05 0.1 23 d LR Scan over MSSM parameter space with respect to SM prediction and experimental limit, taking into account existing experimental bounds. μ μ δ Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 13 / 16
Low tan β scan + - ) μ μ Br(B s -> 10-6 10-7 10-8 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 5 10 15 20 25 30 tan β + - ) μ μ Br(B s -> 10-6 10-7 10-8 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 -0.1-0.05 0 0.05 0.1 23 d LR Scan over MSSM parameter space with respect to SM prediction and experimental limit, taking into account existing experimental bounds. δ Mass insertion parameterizes flavor violation: δ IJ (M 2 QXY = Q) IJ XY q (MQ 2 )IJ XX (M Q 2 )IJ YY Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 13 / 16
Low tan β scan + - ) μ μ Br(B s -> 10-6 10-7 10-8 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 5 10 15 20 25 30 tan β + - ) μ μ Br(B s -> 10-6 10-7 10-8 10-9 10-10 10-11 10-12 -0.1-0.05 0 0.05 0.1 23 d LR Scan over MSSM parameter space with respect to SM prediction and experimental limit, taking into account existing experimental bounds. δ Mass insertion parameterizes flavor violation: δ IJ (M 2 QXY = Q) IJ XY q (MQ 2 )IJ XX (M Q 2 )IJ YY Funnel region: Pseudoscalar and axial contributions cancel, scalar contribution is negligible; e.g. models where MSSM is extended with an additional light CP-odd Higgs. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 13 / 16
LHCb benchmark process Potential... Signal in 1Y Discovery in 3Y Implications on LHCb upgrade? (B s or B d?) Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 14 / 16
General purpose detectors... Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 15 / 16
Conclusion: Lessons Theory There is life outside of Minimal Flavor Violation (MFV)... though perhaps only minimal life? We can model-build beyond MFV; e.g. 0712.0674, 0712,2074 Our numerical code is available Experiment Keep an eye out for a measurement of B s µµ Non-discovery at SM limit could hit at low tan β, beyond-mfv Need to think about LHCb upgrade scenarios Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 16 / 16
Range of input parameters for numerical scan Parameter Symbol Min Max Step Ratio of Higgs vevs tan β 2 30 varied CKM phase γ 0 π π/25 CP-odd Higgs mass M A 100 500 200 SUSY Higgs mixing µ -450 450 300 SU(2) gaugino mass M 2 100 500 200 Gluino mass M 3 3M 2 3M 2 0 SUSY scale M SUSY 500 1000 500 Slepton Masses M l M SUSY /3 M SUSY /3 0 Left top squark mass M QL 200 500 300 Right bottom squark mass M br 200 500 300 Right top squark mass M t R 150 300 150 Mass insertion δdll, 13 δdll 23-1 1 1/10 Mass insertion δdlr, 13 δdlr 23-0.1 0.1 1/100 Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 16 / 16
Constraints used in numerical scan Quantity Current Measurement Experimental Error m χ 0 1 > 46 GeV > 94 GeV m χ ± 1 m b > 89 GeV m t > 95.7 GeV m h > 92.8 GeV ɛ K 2.232 10 3 0.007 10 3 M K 3.483 10 15 0.006 10 15 M D < 0.46 10 13 M Bd 3.337 10 13 GeV 0.033 10 13 GeV M Bs 116.96 10 13 GeV 0.79 10 13 GeV Br(B X sγ) 3.34 10 4 0.38 10 4 Br(K L π 0 ν ν) < 1.5 10 10 Br(K + π + ν ν) 1.5 10 10 1.3 10 10 Electron EDM < 0.07 10 26 Neutron EDM < 0.63 10 25 Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 16 / 16
Calculation: Effective Operators The effective Hamiltonian can be written as H = 1 (4π) 2 (C VXY O VXY + C SXY O SXY + C TX O TX ) X,Y =L,R Writing flavor indices I, J, K, L, the operators are O IJKL VXY = (qj γ µ P X q I )(l L γ µ P Y l K ) O IJKL SXY = (qj P X q I )(l L P Y l K ) O IJKL TX = (qj σ µν P X q I )(l L σ µν l K ) Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 16 / 16
Calculation: Factorization The hadronic and leptonic parts of the matrix element factorize: l, l H eff B(p) = l, l OL i 0 0 Oi Q B(p) i=ops Definition of the decay constant, f B 0 bγ µ P L,R s B(p) = i 2 p µf B 0 bp L,R s B(p) = ± i M B f B 2 m b + m s Note that there are no tensor ( bσ µν s) operators by antisymmetry. f B contains all the hadronic muck; look it up from non-perturbative methods (i.e. lattice). Leptonic decay: don t have to worry about jets, inclusive decays, etc. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 16 / 16
Calculation: Amplitude We can now write the amplitude in terms of form factors M = F S ll + F P lγ 5 l + F V p µ lγ µ l + F A p µ lγ µ γ 5 l In terms of the Wilson coefficients, these are F S = i MB 2 s f Bs (C SLL + C SLR C SRR C SRL ) 4 m b + m s F P = i MB 2 s f Bs ( C SLL + C SLR C SRR + C SRL ) 4 m b + m s F V = i 4 f B s (C VLL + C VLR C VRR C VRL ) F A = i 4 f B s ( C VLL + C VLR C VRR + C VRL ) Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 16 / 16
Calculation: Branching Ratio B(B 0 s l L l+ K ) = s τ «s B s M 2 mlk + m 2 «ll mlk m 2 ll 1 1 16π M Bs M Bs M Bs M 2 = 2 F S 2 h M 2 B s (m ll + m lk ) 2i + 2 F P 2 h M 2 B s (m ll m lk ) 2i + 2 F V 2 h M 2 B s (m lk m ll ) 2 (m 2 l K m 2 l L ) 2i + 2 F A 2 h M 2 B s (m lk + m ll ) 2 (m 2 l K m 2 l L ) 2i + 4 Re(F S FV )(m ll m lk ) hm 2 Bs + (m lk + m ll ) 2i h + 4 Re(F P FA )(m ll + m lk ) MB 2 s (m ll m lk ) 2i. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 16 / 16
Calculation: B s µ + µ at low tan β For the case l K = l L = µ, the amplitude-squared is M 2 2M 2 B q ( F S 2 + F P + 2 m µ F A 2), where we have also taken m µ /M B 0. The minima of this comes from two cases, (1) F P + 2m l F A 0, F P F S (2) F S F P F A 0. Flip Tanedo, Cornell University/CIHEP The Birds and the Bs: B µµ 16 / 16