Mean Convergence of Interpolation at Zeros of Airy Functions

Similar documents
SERIES REPRESENTATIONS FOR BEST APPROXIMATING ENTIRE FUNCTIONS OF EXPONENTIAL TYPE

WEIGHTED MARKOV-BERNSTEIN INEQUALITIES FOR ENTIRE FUNCTIONS OF EXPONENTIAL TYPE

References 167. dx n x2 =2

Hilbert Spaces. Hilbert space is a vector space with some extra structure. We start with formal (axiomatic) definition of a vector space.

ETNA Kent State University

Vector Spaces. Vector space, ν, over the field of complex numbers, C, is a set of elements a, b,..., satisfying the following axioms.

Convergence and Stability of a New Quadrature Rule for Evaluating Hilbert Transform

NEW BOUNDS FOR TRUNCATION-TYPE ERRORS ON REGULAR SAMPLING EXPANSIONS

MATH 5640: Fourier Series

Some Explicit Biorthogonal Polynomials

Vectors in Function Spaces

Advanced Computational Fluid Dynamics AA215A Lecture 2 Approximation Theory. Antony Jameson

Hilbert Transforms and Orthonormal Expansions for Exponential Weights

Recurrence Relations and Fast Algorithms

Polynomial approximation via de la Vallée Poussin means

Orthogonal polynomials with respect to generalized Jacobi measures. Tivadar Danka

Bernstein-Szegö Inequalities in Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces ABSTRACT 1. INTRODUCTION

On the Chebyshev quadrature rule of finite part integrals

A trigonometric orthogonality with respect to a nonnegative Borel measure

Scaling Limits of Polynomials and Entire Functions of Exponential Type

A Nodal Spline Collocation Method for the Solution of Cauchy Singular Integral Equations 1

WhittakerKotelnikovShannon Sampling Theorem and Aliasing Error. Fang Gensun*

Finite-dimensional spaces. C n is the space of n-tuples x = (x 1,..., x n ) of complex numbers. It is a Hilbert space with the inner product

Basic relations valid for the Bernstein space B 2 σ and their extensions to functions from larger spaces in terms of their distances from B 2 σ

On Some Mean Value Results for the Zeta-Function and a Divisor Problem

ON THE MULTIPLICITY OF EIGENVALUES OF A VECTORIAL STURM-LIOUVILLE DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION AND SOME RELATED SPECTRAL PROBLEMS

On the solution of integral equations of the first kind with singular kernels of Cauchy-type

ESTIMATES FOR MAXIMAL SINGULAR INTEGRALS

LEGENDRE POLYNOMIALS AND APPLICATIONS. We construct Legendre polynomials and apply them to solve Dirichlet problems in spherical coordinates.

UNIFORM BOUNDS FOR BESSEL FUNCTIONS

Approximation by Conditionally Positive Definite Functions with Finitely Many Centers

Asymptotic Zero Distribution of Biorthogonal Polynomials

Fourier Series. 1. Review of Linear Algebra

ON A WEIGHTED INTERPOLATION OF FUNCTIONS WITH CIRCULAR MAJORANT

On Marcinkiewicz-Zygmund-Type Inequalities

Global Solutions for a Nonlinear Wave Equation with the p-laplacian Operator

arxiv: v1 [math.ca] 23 Oct 2018

Bivariate Lagrange interpolation at the Padua points: The generating curve approach

1.5 Approximate Identities

Scientific Computing WS 2018/2019. Lecture 15. Jürgen Fuhrmann Lecture 15 Slide 1

Topics in Harmonic Analysis Lecture 1: The Fourier transform

Functional Analysis Review

Simultaneous Gaussian quadrature for Angelesco systems

On the Lebesgue constant of barycentric rational interpolation at equidistant nodes

SPECTRAL METHODS: ORTHOGONAL POLYNOMIALS

TD 1: Hilbert Spaces and Applications

BASIS PROPERTIES OF EIGENFUNCTIONS OF THE p-laplacian

7: FOURIER SERIES STEVEN HEILMAN

Hilbert Spaces. Contents

arxiv: v1 [math.cv] 13 Jun 2014

Your first day at work MATH 806 (Fall 2015)

Topics in Harmonic Analysis Lecture 6: Pseudodifferential calculus and almost orthogonality

An idea how to solve some of the problems. diverges the same must hold for the original series. T 1 p T 1 p + 1 p 1 = 1. dt = lim

Continuous Functions on Metric Spaces

EXAMINATION SOLUTIONS

ENTIRE FUNCTIONS AND COMPLETENESS PROBLEMS. Lecture 3

3 Orthogonality and Fourier series

2 Infinite products and existence of compactly supported φ

Lecture Notes on PDEs

Size properties of wavelet packets generated using finite filters

On Riesz-Fischer sequences and lower frame bounds

LECTURE 16 GAUSS QUADRATURE In general for Newton-Cotes (equispaced interpolation points/ data points/ integration points/ nodes).

PART IV Spectral Methods

First Prev Next Last Go Back Full Screen Close Quit ERDŐS CENTENNIAL JULY 1 5, 2013, BUDAPEST

Class notes: Approximation

Remarks on the Rademacher-Menshov Theorem

Lecture IX. Definition 1 A non-singular Sturm 1 -Liouville 2 problem consists of a second order linear differential equation of the form.

SZEGÖ ASYMPTOTICS OF EXTREMAL POLYNOMIALS ON THE SEGMENT [ 1, +1]: THE CASE OF A MEASURE WITH FINITE DISCRETE PART

arxiv: v2 [math.fa] 17 May 2016

Qualification Exam: Mathematical Methods

Superconvergence Results for the Iterated Discrete Legendre Galerkin Method for Hammerstein Integral Equations

On the Spectral Expansion Formula for a Class of Dirac Operators

Math 4263 Homework Set 1

EXAMPLES OF REFINABLE COMPONENTWISE POLYNOMIALS

Functional Analysis. Martin Brokate. 1 Normed Spaces 2. 2 Hilbert Spaces The Principle of Uniform Boundedness 32

Two special equations: Bessel s and Legendre s equations. p Fourier-Bessel and Fourier-Legendre series. p

EXACT INTERPOLATION, SPURIOUS POLES, AND UNIFORM CONVERGENCE OF MULTIPOINT PADÉ APPROXIMANTS

EXAM MATHEMATICAL METHODS OF PHYSICS. TRACK ANALYSIS (Chapters I-V). Thursday, June 7th,

Reconstruction of sparse Legendre and Gegenbauer expansions

Gaussian interval quadrature rule for exponential weights

OWN ZEROS LUIS DANIEL ABREU

Introduction to Fourier Analysis

Real Analysis Problems

Notes on uniform convergence

General Inner Product and The Fourier Series

Approximation theory

MATH 590: Meshfree Methods

A Product Integration Approach Based on New Orthogonal Polynomials for Nonlinear Weakly Singular Integral Equations

The Generating Functions for Pochhammer

NORMAL NUMBERS AND UNIFORM DISTRIBUTION (WEEKS 1-3) OPEN PROBLEMS IN NUMBER THEORY SPRING 2018, TEL AVIV UNIVERSITY

Wavelets and modular inequalities in variable L p spaces

Quantum mechanics. Chapter The quantum mechanical formalism

Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications. Non-symmetric fast decreasing polynomials and applications

MATH 590: Meshfree Methods

A Chebyshev Polynomial Rate-of-Convergence Theorem for Stieltjes Functions

Fourier Sin and Cos Series and Least Squares Convergence

Stability of Kernel Based Interpolation

Decomposition of Riesz frames and wavelets into a finite union of linearly independent sets

A LOWER BOUND ON BLOWUP RATES FOR THE 3D INCOMPRESSIBLE EULER EQUATION AND A SINGLE EXPONENTIAL BEALE-KATO-MAJDA ESTIMATE. 1.

A Perron-type theorem on the principal eigenvalue of nonsymmetric elliptic operators

Transcription:

Mean Convergence of Interpolation at Zeros of Airy Functions D. S. Lubinsky Abstract The classical Erdős-Turán theorem established mean convergence of Lagrange interpolants at zeros of orthogonal polynomials. A non-polynomial extension of this was established by Ian Sloan in 983. Mean convergence of interpolation by entire functions has been investigated by Grozev, Rahman, and Vértesi. In this spirit, we establish an Erdős-Turán theorem for interpolation by entire functions at zeros of the Airy function. Introduction The classical Erdős-Turán theorem involves a weight w on an compact interval, which we take as [,]. We assume that w 0 and is positive on a set of positive measure. Let p n denote the corresponding orthonormal polynomial of degree n 0, so that for m,n 0, p n p m w = δ mn. Let us denote the zeros of p n in [,] by < x nn < x n,n < < x 2n < x n <. Given f : [,] R, let L n [ f] denote the Lagrange interpolation polynomial to f at { x jn } n j=, so that L n[ f] has degree at most n and L n [ f]x jn = f x jn, j n. D. S. Lubinsky Georgia Institute of Technology, School of Mathematics, Atlanta, GA 30332-060, USA e-mail: lubinsky@math.gatech.edu

2 D. S. Lubinsky Theorem Erdős-Turán Theorem. Let f : [, ] R be continuous. For n, let L n [ f] denote the Lagrange interpolation polynomial to f at the zeros of p n. Then lim f L n [ f] 2 w = 0. n The ramifications of this result continue to be explored to this day. It has been extended in numerous directions: for example, rather than requiring f to be continuous, we can allow it to be Riemann integrable. We may replace w by a positive measure µ, which may have non-compact support. In addition, convergence in L 2 may be replaced, under additional conditions on w, by convergence in L p. There is a very large literature on all of this. See [0,, 2, 3, 22, 23] for references and results. Ian Sloan and his coauthor Will Smith ingeniously used results on mean convergence of Lagrange interpolation in various L p norms, to establish the definitive results on convergence of product integration rules [4, 6, 8, 9, 20, 2]. This is a subject of substantial practical importance, for example in numerical solution of integral equations. One can speculate that it was this interest in product integration that led to Ian Sloan extending the Erdős-Turán theorem to non-polynomial interpolation. Here is an important special case of his general result [7, p. 99]: Theorem 2 Sloan s Erdös-Turán Theorem on Sturm-Liouville Systems. Consider the eigenvalue problem with boundary conditions pxu x+qxu x+[rx+λ]ux = 0 cosαua+sinαu a = 0; cosβub+sinβu b = 0. Assume that p,q,r are continuous and real valued on [a,b], that p > 0 there, while α,β are real. Let {u n } n 0 be the eigenfunctions, ordered so that the corresponding eigenvalues {λ n } are increasing. Given continuous f : [a,b] R, let L n [ f] denote the linear combination of { } n u j j=0 that coincides with f at the n+ zeros of u n+ in the open interval a,b. Let Then wx = px exp x a qt pt dt, x [a,b]. b lim f x L n [ f]x 2 wxdx = 0, n a provided f a = 0 if sinα = 0 and f b = 0 if sinβ = 0. Moreover, there is a constant c independent of n and f such that for all such f,

Interpolation at Airy Zeros 3 b a f x L n [ f]x 2 wxdx C inf c 0,c,...,c n b a f x n j=0 c j u j x 2 wxdx. As a specific example, Sloan considers the Bessel equation. His general theorem [7, p. 02], from which the above result is deduced, involves orthonormal functions, associated reproducing kernels, and interpolation points satisfying two boundedness conditions. In 988, M. R. Akhlaghi [2] extended Sloan s result to convergence in L p for p. Interpolation by trigonometric polynomials is closely related to that by algebraic polynomials, in as much as every even trigonometric polynomial has the form Pcos θ where P is an algebraic polynomial. From trigonometric polynomials, one can pass via scaling limits to entire functions of exponential type, and the latter have a long and gloried history associated with sampling theory. However, to this author s knowledge, the first general result on mean convergence of entire interpolants at equispaced points is due to Rahman and Vértesi [5, Theorem, p. 304]. Define the classic sinc kernel { sinπt St = πt, t 0,, t = 0. Given a function f : R R, and > 0, define the formal Lagrange interpolation series kπ L [ f ;x] = f S x kπ. k= It is easily seen that this series converges uniformly in compact sets if for some p >, we have kπ p f <. k= Theorem 3 Theorem of Rahman and Vértesi. Let f : R R be Riemann integrable over every finite interval and satisfy for some β > p, Then f x C+ x β, x R. lim f x L [ f ;x] p dx = 0. Butzer, Higgins and Stens later showed that this result is equivalent to the classical sampling theorem, and as such is an example of an approximate sampling theorem [3]. Of course there are sampling theorems at nonequally spaced points see for example [7, 25], and in the setting of de Branges spaces, there are more general expansions involving interpolation series. However, as far as this author is aware, there are no analogues of the Rahman-Vértesi theorem in that more general

4 D. S. Lubinsky setting. Ganzburg [5] and Littman [9] have explored other aspects of convergence of Lagrange interpolation by entire functions. One setting where mean convergence has been explored, is interpolation at zeros of Bessel functions, notably by Grozev and Rahman [6, Theorem, p. 48]. Let α > and z α z 2k J α z = 2 k 2 k=0 k!γ α + k+ denote the Bessel function of order α. It is often convenient to instead use its entire cousin, G α z = z α J α z. J α has positive zeros and matching negative zeros j α, < j α,2 < j α,3 <, j α, k = j α,k, k, so for f : R C, and > 0, one can define the formal interpolation series jα,k L α, [ f ;x] = f l α,k z, k=,k 0 where for k 0, l α,k z = G α G α z. jα,k z jα,k Theorem 4 Theorem of Rahman and Grozev. Let α 2 and p >, or let < α < 2 and < p < 2 2α+. Let f : R R be Riemann integrable over every finite interval and satisfy for some δ > 0, Then f x C+ x α 2 p δ, x R. lim x α+ 2 f x L [ f ;x] p dx = 0. Note that p = 2 is always included. The proof of this theorem involves a lot of tools: detailed properties of entire functions of exponential type and of Bessel functions, and a converse Marcinkiewicz-Zygmund inequality that is itself of great interest. In this paper, we explore convergence of interpolation at scaled zeros of Airy functions. Recall that the Airy function Ai is given on the real line by [, 0.4.32, p. 447] Aix = cos π 3 t3 + xt dt. 0

Interpolation at Airy Zeros 5 { The} Airy function Ai is an entire function of order 3 2, with only real negative zeros a j, where Ai satisfies the differential equation 0 > a > a 2 > a 3 >. Ai z zaiz = 0. The Airy kernel Ai,, much used in random matrix theory, is defined [8] by { AiaAi b Ai aaib Aia,b = a b, a b, Ai a 2 aaia 2, a = b. Observe that l j z = Aiz,a j Aia j,a j = Aiz Ai a j z a j, is the Airy analogue of a fundamental of Lagrange interpolation, satisfying l j a k = δ jk. There is an analogue of sampling series and Lagrange interpolation series involving { l j } : Definition. Let G be the class of all functions g : C C with the following properties: a g is an entire function of order at most 3 2 ; b There exists L > 0 such that for δ 0,π, some C δ > 0, and all z C with argz π δ, gz C δ + z L exp 2 3 z 3 2 ; c ga j 2 j= a j /2 <. In [8, Corollary.3, p. 429], it was shown that each g G admits the expansion gz = j= ga j Aiz,a j Aia j,a j. Moreover, for f, g G, there is the quadrature formula [8, Corollary.4, p. 429] f xgxdx = j= f ga j Aia j,a j. In analogy with the entire interpolants of Grozev-Rahman, we define for f : R R, the formal series

6 D. S. Lubinsky L [ f ;z] = f j= a j l j z = Note that it samples f only in,0. We prove: f j= a j Aiz,aj Aia j,a j. Theorem 5. Let f : R R be bounded and Riemann integrable in each finite interval, with f x = 0 in [0,. Assume in addition that for some β > 2, and x R, Then f x C+ x β. 2 lim f x L [ f ;x] 2 dx = 0. 3 Observe that the integration is over the whole real line. We expect that there is an analogue of this theorem at least for all p >. However, this seems to require a converse Marcinkiewicz-Zygmund inequality estimating L p norms of appropriate classes of entire functions in terms of their values at Airy zeros. This is not available, so we content ourselves with a weaker result for the related operator L [ f ;z] = f j= This interpolates f at each a 2 j, but not at a 2 j. sup x R a2 j [l2 j z+l 2 j z ]. Theorem 6. a For bounded functions f : R R, and a, L a2 j, [ f ;x] C sup f 4 j where C is independent of and f. b Let 4 5 < p <. Let f : R R be bounded and Riemann integrable in each finite interval, with f x = 0 in [0,.Assume in addition that for some β > p, and x R, we have 2. Then lim f x L [ f ;x] p dx = 0. 5 Note that L [ ] f ; z G, so this also establishes density of that class of functions in a suitable space of functions containing those in Theorem 6. The usual approach to Erdős-Turan theorems is via quadrature formulae and density of polynomials, or entire functions of exponential type, in appropriate spaces. The latter density is not available for G. So in Section 2, we establish convergence for characteristic functions of intervals. We prove Theorems 5 and 6 in Section 3. Throughout C,C,C 2,... denote positive constants independent of n,x,z,t,, and possibly other specified quantities. The same symbol does not necessarily denote the same constant in different occurrences, even when used in the same line.

Interpolation at Airy Zeros 7 2 Interpolation of Step Functions We prove: Theorem 7. Let r > 0, and f denote the characteristic function χ [ r,0] of the interval [ r,0]. Then for p > 4 5, and lim L [ f ;x] f x p dx = 0. 6 lim L [ f ;x] f x p dx = 0. 7 This section is organized as follows: we first recall some asymptotics associated with Airy functions. Then we prove some estimates on integrals involving the fundamental polynomials l j. Next we prove the case p = 2 of Theorem 7. Then we estimate a certain sum and finally prove the general case of Theorem 7. Firstly, the following asymptotics and estimates are listed on pages 448 449 of []: see 0.4.59 6 there. Aix = 2π /2 x /4 exp 2 3 x 3 2 +o, x ; 8 2 Ai x = π /2 x [sin /4 3 x 2 3 + π ] + O x 3 2, x. 9 4 Then as Ai is entire, for x [0,, Aix C+x /4 exp Ai x C+x /4 ; 2 3 x 3 2 and 0 2 Ai x = π /2 x /4 cos + O x 2 3 3 x 3 2 + π 4, x. +O Next, the zeros { a j } of Ai satisfy [, p. 450, 0.4.94,96] a j = [3π 4 j /8] +O 2/3 3π j 2/3 = +o. 2 j 2 x 4 3 2 Consequently,

8 D. S. Lubinsky In addition, a j+ a j = π +o. 3 a j /2 Ai a j = j π /2 3π 8 4 j /6 +O j 2 4 = j π /2 a j /4 +o. A calculation shows that Ai a j Ai a j = C0 j 5/6 +O j, C 0 = 3 /6 6 2π 2. 5 Define the Scorer function [, p. 448, 0.4.42] Gix = t 3 sin π 3 + xt dt. 6 0 We shall use an identity for the Hilbert transform of the Airy function [24, p. 7, eqn. 4.4]: π PV Ait dt = Gix. 7 t x Here PV denotes Cauchy principal value integral. We also use [, p. 450, eqn. 0.4.87] 2 Gi x = π /2 x [cos /4 3 x 2 3 + π ] + o, x. 8 4 Finally the Airy kernel Aia,b satisfies [8, p. 432] Thus Aia j,sais,a k ds = δ jk Aia j,a j = δ jk Ai a j 2. Lemma. a As j, l j sl k sds = δ jk Aia j,a j = δ jk Ai a j 2. 9 b Uniformly in j,r with r > a j, 0 r l j tdt = π +o. 20 a j /2 l j tdt = π a j /2 +o+ O a j /4 r 3/4 r. 2 a j

Interpolation at Airy Zeros 9 Proof. a Now 7 yields l j tdt = Gia j π Ai a j 22 Here using 2, so from 8, 2 3 cos a j 2 + π 3 4 Substituting this and 4 into 22 gives b Using the bound 0, 0 = j + O, j Gia j = π /2 a j /4 j +o. l j tdt = π a j /2 +o. l j t C dt Ai a j 0 t /4 exp 2 3 t 3 2 dt t a j C a j Ai a j C a j 5/4, 23 recall 4. Next, r l j tdt = Ai a j Ai x dx r x+a j 24 = Ai a j x sin /4 2 π /2 3 x 3 2 + π 4 dx r x+a j x 7/4 + O x+a j dx, by 9. Here, r

0 D. S. Lubinsky x sin /4 23 x 3 2 + 4 π I = dx r x+a j x 4 3 = r d dx [ cos 2 3 x 3 2 + π 4 x+a j = cos 2 3 r3/2 + π 4 r 3/4 r a j + ] 2 cos dx r 3 x 3 2 + π 4 [ = O r 3/4 r d a j + O r dx = O r 3/4 r a j as is decreasing in [r,. Next, x 3/4 x a j r x 7/4 x+a j dx [ d dx x 3/4 x a j ] x 3/4 x a j dx ] dx, 25 r a j r x 7/4 dx C r 3/4 r a j. Thus, using also 25 in 24, r l j tdt C a j /4 r 3/4 r. a j Together with 20 and 23, this gives the result 2. Lemma 2. Let L, and Then S L x = lim L a L+ L j= Proof. Using 9, and then 4, l j x = L j= Aix,a j Aia j,a j. 26 SL x χ [al+,0]x 2 dx = 0. 27

Interpolation at Airy Zeros SL x χ [al+,0]x 2 dx L j= = L j= Ai a j 2 2 L j= 0 a L+ l j xdx+ a L+ π = a j /2 +o { } L π 2 +o+ O j= a j /2 a L+ 3/4 a j /4 al+ + a L+ a j L π = a L+ a j /2 +o+o a L+ 3/4 L a j /4 a L+, a j j= by 4 and 2. Here using 3, L j= Also, from 2, j= 28 L π a j /2 = a j+ a j +o = al+ +o. 29 j= a L+ 3/4 L a j /4 a L+ a j j= C a L+ 7/4 Substituting this and 29 into 28, gives L j= j /6 j L+ L C a L+ 7/4 0 x /6 C a L+ 7/4 L 5/6 logl L+ x dx C a L+ /2 logl. 30 SL x χ [al+,0]x 2 dx = o a L+ +O C a L+ /2 logl = o a L+. Proof of Theorem 7 for p = 2. Given a /r, choose L = L by the inequality Then a L r < a L+. 3

2 D. S. Lubinsky By Lemma 2, L [ f ;x] = a j / [ r,0] l j x = L j= l j x. 32 as. Also, as, L [ f ;x] χ [al+,0]x 2 dx = L j= = o a L+ = o, χ[r,0] x χ [al+,0] x 2 dx = χ a [ L+,r] x2 dx = a L+ r a L+ a L l j t χ [al+,0]t 2 dt = O L /3 = o. Then 6 follows. Since L [ f ;x] = L [ f ;x] if L above is even, 7 also follows. The case of odd L is easily handled by estimating separately the single extra term. Next we bound a generalization of S L x: Lemma 3. Let A > 0, 0 β < 5 4 and { } c j be real numbers such that for j, j= c 2 j = c 2 j, 33 and c2 j A + a2 j β. 34 Let Ŝx = j= Then the series converges and for all real x, Here C is independent of x,a, and { c j } j=. c j l j x. Ŝx CA+ x β. 35 Proof. We may assume that A =. We assume first that x,0, as this is the most difficult case. Set a 0 = 0. Choose an even integer j 0 2 such that x [a j0,a j0 2. Let us first deal with central terms: assume that j and j j 0 3. Then l j x = Ai a j Aix A i a j x a j = Ai t Ai a j,

Interpolation at Airy Zeros 3 for some t between x and a j, so t + / a j. Using, 4, and the continuity of Ai, we see that Thus as x + a j0, and 34 holds, l j x + t /4 C C. a j /4 c j l j x C+ x β. 36 j: j j 0 3 Again, we emphasize that C is independent of L and x and { } c j. We turn to the estimation of j0 S 4 x = + c j l j x. j= j= j 0 +3 Recall from 4 that Ai a j has sign j. Then S x = Aix j0 4/2 k= + k= j 0 /2+2 c 2k [ ] Ai a 2k x a 2k Ai a 2k x a 2k = AixΣ + Σ 2, 37 where Σ = = j0 4/2 k= j0 4/2 k= + + k= j 0 /2+2 k= j 0 /2+2 c 2k x a 2k x a 2k Ai a 2k c 2k a 2k a 2k Ai a 2k x a 2k x a 2k 38 and Σ 2 = j0 4/2 k= + k= j 0 /2+2 c 2k Ai a 2k Ai. a 2k x a 2k Then if I denotes the set of integers k with either k j 0 4/2 or k j 0 /2+ x a 2, we see that 2k x a 2k, and a 2k a 2k are bounded above and below by positive a 2k 2 a 2k constants independent of k,x, so using 4 and 34, so

4 D. S. Lubinsky Σ C C k I a 2k 2 a 2k a 2k /4+β x a 2k 2 [ a,\[ a j0 3, a j0 + ] C [ [ a a a j0,\ j0 3 t /4+β x t 2 dt = ] a j0 5/4+β a j0, a j 0 + s /4+β 2 ds x a j0 a j0 s C a j0 β 3/4, β > 3/4 a j0 5/4+β log a j0, β = 3/4 + a j0 x a, β < 3/4 j0 + a j0 3 x a j0 + C a j0 /4+β + a j0 /2 a j0 /4+β C+ x /4 β, 39 recall that β < 4 5, and that x a j0 3 a j0 a j0 2 Ca j0 /2, by 3. Next, using 3 5 and 34, Σ 2 C k I C C k I a 2k β Ai a 2k Ai a 2k x a 2k k 5/6 a 2k a 2k 2 a 2k 5/4+β x a 2k t 5/4+β x t dt [ a,\[ a j0 3, a j0 + ] C [ ] [ a a a j0,\ j0 3 a j0, a j 0 + a j0 a j0 5/4+β C a j0 5/4+β C a j0 s 5/4+β ds x a j0 s /4+β + log x a j0 3 a j0 a j0 + log x a j0 + a j0 a j0 a j0 + a j0 5/4 β log j0 C+ x /4 β, recall β < 5 4. Substituting this and 39 into 37 gives S x C Aix + x /4 β C+ x β, in view of 0. This and 36 gives 35. Finally, the case where x 0 is easier. We deduce: Proof of Theorem 7 for the general case. Recall that f = χ [ r,0]. Assume first p > 2. The previous lemma with all c j = and β = 0 shows that

Interpolation at Airy Zeros 5 L [ f ;x] f x sup L [ f ;x] + C, x R where C is independent of. We can then apply the case p = 2 of Theorem 7: lim sup L [ f ;x] f x p dx C p 2 limsup L [ f ;x] f x 2 dx = 0. Next, if 4 5 < p < 2, and s 2r, Hölder s inequality gives s lim sup L [ f ;x] f x p dx s s limsup Next, for x s > 2r, and all, we have Thus L [ f ;x] f x L [ f ;x] f x 2 dx s a j [ r,0] C Aix x C x 5/4 p Aix Ai a j x a j a j [ r,0] a j /4 j /6 j Cr 3/2 C x 5/4 r 5/4 = Cr 5/4 x 5/4. 2 2s p 2 = 0. 40 lim sup L [ f ;x] f x p dx C x 5p/4 dx Cs 5p/4 0 x s x s as s, recall p > 5/4. Together with 40, this gives 6. Of course 7 also follows as L [ f ;x] differs from L [ f ;x] in at most one term, which can easily be estimated. 3 Proof of Theorems 5 and 6 Proof of Theorem 5. Suppose first that f is bounded and Riemann integrable, and supported in r,0], some r > 0. Let ε > 0. Then we can find a piecewise constant step function g also compactly supported in r,0] such that both

6 D. S. Lubinsky g f in R and f g 2 < ε 2. This follows directly from the theory of Riemann sums and the boundedness of f. Theorem 7 implies that for any such step function g, /2 lim gx L [g;x] dx 2 = 0. Then using also the orthonormality relation 9, lim sup f x L [ f ;x] 2 dx a j /2 /2 f x gx dx 2 + limsup /2 + limsup ε + 0+limsup = ε + limsup L [g f ;x] 2 dx = ε +C limsup j= a j r,0 a j r,0 gx L [g;x] 2 dx a 2 j f g l j x dx f g 2 a j Ai a j 2 /2 a j a j 0 /2 = ε +C f g xdx 2 Cε. r /2 f g 2 a j /2 /2 a Here C is independent of ε,g and f, and we have used 3, 4, that max j j 0 as, and the theory of Riemann sums. So we have the result for such compactly supported f. Now assume that f is supported in, r and for some β > 2, 2 holds. Then using 9 again,

Interpolation at Airy Zeros 7 f x L [ f ;x] 2 dx /2 f xdx 2 + r /2 a j, r /2 C + x dx 2β +C r Cr 2 β +C Cr 2 β +C a j, r where C is independent of r and. So a j f 2 a j Ai a j 2 a j, r /2 2β a j a j /2 2β a j a j /2 /2 +2β t dt 2β Cr /2 β, r /2 lim sup f x L [ f ;x] dx 2 Cr /2 β. This can be made arbitrarily small for large enough r. Together with the case above, this easily implies the result. Proof of Theorem 6. a From Lemma 3 with β = 0, a2 j l2 sup f j x+l 2 j x a2 j. C sup f j x R j= Here C is independent of f,. b For p = 2, the exact same proof as of Theorem 5 gives lim L [ f ;x] f x2 dx = 0. If p > 2, we can use the boundedness of the operators, to obtain lim sup L [ f ;x] f x p dx limsup C f p 2 L R limsup sup L [ f ;x] f x x R p 2 L [ f ;x] f x 2 dx = 0. Now let 4 5 < p < 2. Let s > 0. Hölder s inequality gives L [ f ;x] f x 2 dx

8 D. S. Lubinsky s lim sup L [ f ;x] f x p dx s s p limsup L [ f ;x] f 2 x 2 dx 2s p 2 = 0, 4 s by the case p = 2. Next, our bound 2 on f and Lemma 3 show that for all x, L [ f ;x] f x C+ x β. Then x s L [ f ;x] f x p dx C + x pβ dx Cs pβ 0 as s, s as β > p. Acknowledgements Research supported by NSF grant DMS362208. References. M. Abramowitz and I. A. Stegun, Handbook of Mathematical Functions, Dover, New York, 965. 2. M. R. Akhlaghi, On L p -Convergence of Nonpolynomial Interpolation, J. Approx. Theory, 55988, 94 204. 3. P. L. Butzer, J. R. Higgins, and R. L. Stens, Classical and Approximate Sampling Theorems: Studies in the L p R and the uniform norm, J. Approx. Theory, 372005, 250 263. 4. P. Erdös and P. Turán, On interpolation, I. Quadrature and Mean Convergence in the Lagrange Interpolation, Ann. of Math. 38937, 42 55. 5. M. Ganzburg, Polynomial interpolation and asymptotic representations for zeta functions, Dissertationes Math. Rozprawy Mat., 496 203, 7 pp. 6. G. R. Grozev, Q. I. Rahman, Lagrange Interpolation in the Zeros of Bessel functions by Entire Functions of Exponential Type and Mean Convergence, Methods and Applications of Analysis, 3996, 46 79. 7. J. R. Higgins, Sampling Theory in Fourier and Signal Analysis: Foundations, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 996. 8. Eli Levin, D. S. Lubinsky, On The Airy Reproducing Kernel, Sampling Series, and Quadrature Formula, Integral Equations and Operator Theory, 632009, 427 438. 9. F. Littman, Interpolation and Approximation by Entire Functions, in Approximation Theory XI, Nashboro Press, Brentwood 2008, pp. 243 255. 0. D. S. Lubinsky, A Taste of Erdős on Interpolation, in Paul Erdős and his Mathematics, L. Bolyai Society Math. Studies II, Bolyai Society, Budapest, 2000, pp. 423 454.. G. Mastroianni, G. V. Milovanovic, Interpolation Processes Basic Theory and Applications, Springer Monographs in Mathematics XIV, Springer, Berlin, 2009. 2. P. Nevai, Lagrange Interpolation at Zeros of Orthogonal Polynomials, in Approximation Theory II, eds. G. G. Lorentz et al., Academic Press, New York, 976, pp. 63 20.

Interpolation at Airy Zeros 9 3. P. Nevai, Geza Freud, Orthogonal Polynomials and Christoffel Functions: A Case Study, J. Approx. Theory, 48986, 3 67. 4. P. Rabinowitz and I. H. Sloan, Product Integration in the Presence of a Singularity, SIAM J. Numerical Analysis, 2984, 49 66. 5. Q. I. Rahman and P. Vértesi, On the L p Convergence of Lagrange Interpolating Entire Functions of Exponential Type, J. Approx. Theory, 69992, 302 37. 6. I. H. Sloan, On choosing the points in product integration, Journal of Mathematical Physics, 2979, 032 039. 7. I. H. Sloan, Nonpolynomial interpolation, J. Approx. Theory, 39983, 97 7. 8. I. H. Sloan and W. E. Smith, Product integration with the Clenshaw-Curtis points: Implementation and error estimates, Numerische Mathematik, 34980, 387 40. 9. I. H. Sloan and W. E. Smith, Properties of Interpolatory Product Integration Rules, SIAM J. Numer. Anal., 9982, 427 442. 20. W. E. Smith and I.H. Sloan, Product-Integration Rules Based on the Zeros of Jacobi Polynomials, SIAM J. Numer. Anal., 7980, 3. 2. W. E. Smith, I. H. Sloan and A. Opie, Product Integration Over Infinite Intervals I. Rules Based on the Zeros of Hermite Polynomials, Math. Comp. 40983, 59 535. 22. J. Szabados and P. Vértesi, Interpolation of Functions, World Scientific, Singapore, 990. 23. J. Szabados, P. Vértesi, A Survey on Mean Convergence of Interpolatory Processes, J. Comp. Appl. Math., 43992, 3 8. 24. O. Vallée and M. Soares, Airy Functions and Applications to Physics, World Scientific, Singapore, 2004. 25. A. I. Zayed, M. A. El-Sayed and M. H. Annaby, On Lagrange Interpolations and Kramer s Sampling Theorem Associated with Self-Adjoint Boundary Value Problems, J. Math. Anal. Applns., 5899, 269 284.