Existence of Positive Periodic Solutions of Mutualism Systems with Several Delays 1

Similar documents
EXISTENCE OF POSITIVE PERIODIC SOLUTIONS OF DISCRETE MODEL FOR THE INTERACTION OF DEMAND AND SUPPLY. S. H. Saker

Dynamics of an almost periodic facultative mutualism model with time delays

Research Article Existence of at Least Two Periodic Solutions for a Competition System of Plankton Allelopathy on Time Scales

EXISTENCE THEOREM FOR A FRACTIONAL MULTI-POINT BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEM

Periodicity of scalar dynamic equations and applications to population models

Research Article Multiple Periodic Solutions of a Nonautonomous Plant-Hare Model

Research Article Existence of Almost-Periodic Solutions for Lotka-Volterra Cooperative Systems with Time Delay

FRACTIONAL BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEMS ON THE HALF LINE. Assia Frioui, Assia Guezane-Lakoud, and Rabah Khaldi

EXISTENCE OF SOLUTIONS TO FRACTIONAL DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS WITH MULTI-POINT BOUNDARY CONDITIONS AT RESONANCE IN HILBERT SPACES

Existence of homoclinic solutions for Duffing type differential equation with deviating argument

Existence of solutions for a coupled system of. fractional differential equations

MUtualism, an interaction of two-species of organisms

ONe of the most interesting questions considering ecological

Existence of solutions for fractional integral boundary value problems with p(t)-laplacian operator

Meng Fan *, Ke Wang, Daqing Jiang. Abstract

LEt R, Z and N + denote the sets of real numbers,

PERMANENCE IN LOGISTIC AND LOTKA-VOLTERRA SYSTEMS WITH DISPERSAL AND TIME DELAYS

Research Article Existence and Uniqueness of Homoclinic Solution for a Class of Nonlinear Second-Order Differential Equations

On a non-autonomous stochastic Lotka-Volterra competitive system

A NONLINEAR NEUTRAL PERIODIC DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION

BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEMS OF A HIGHER ORDER NONLINEAR DIFFERENCE EQUATION

Solvability of Neumann boundary value problem for fractional p-laplacian equation

Upper and lower solution method for fourth-order four-point boundary value problems

Existence of positive periodic solutions for a periodic logistic equation

Research Article On the Stability Property of the Infection-Free Equilibrium of a Viral Infection Model

Existence and Uniqueness of Anti-Periodic Solutions for Nonlinear Higher-Order Differential Equations with Two Deviating Arguments

EXISTENCE AND GLOBAL ATTRACTIVITY OF POSITIVE PERIODIC SOLUTIONS FOR A PREDATOR-PREY MODEL WITH CROWLEY-MARTIN FUNCTIONAL RESPONSE

Stationary distribution and pathwise estimation of n-species mutualism system with stochastic perturbation

Global attractivity and positive almost periodic solution of a discrete multispecies Gilpin-Ayala competition system with feedback control

ALMOST PERIODIC SOLUTIONS OF NONLINEAR DISCRETE VOLTERRA EQUATIONS WITH UNBOUNDED DELAY. 1. Almost periodic sequences and difference equations

On the solvability of multipoint boundary value problems for discrete systems at resonance

JUNXIA MENG. 2. Preliminaries. 1/k. x = max x(t), t [0,T ] x (t), x k = x(t) dt) k

EXISTENCE OF POSITIVE PERIODIC SOLUTIONS FOR A CLASS OF NONAUTONOMOUS DIFFERENCE EQUATIONS

Periodic Solutions in Shifts δ ± for a Dynamic Equation on Time Scales

EXISTENCE AND UNIQUENESS OF SOLUTIONS FOR FOURTH-ORDER BOUNDARY-VALUE PROBLEMS IN BANACH SPACES

RELATION BETWEEN SMALL FUNCTIONS WITH DIFFERENTIAL POLYNOMIALS GENERATED BY MEROMORPHIC SOLUTIONS OF HIGHER ORDER LINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

LYAPUNOV-RAZUMIKHIN METHOD FOR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS WITH PIECEWISE CONSTANT ARGUMENT. Marat Akhmet. Duygu Aruğaslan

Hausdorff operators in H p spaces, 0 < p < 1

MULTIPLICITY OF CONCAVE AND MONOTONE POSITIVE SOLUTIONS FOR NONLINEAR FOURTH-ORDER ORDINARY DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

Stability and Hopf-bifurcation analysis of an unidirectionally coupled system

On the simplest expression of the perturbed Moore Penrose metric generalized inverse

Existence Of Solution For Third-Order m-point Boundary Value Problem

ALMOST PERIODIC SOLUTION OF A MULTISPECIES DISCRETE LOTKA-VOLTERRA MUTUALISM SYSTEM

Three symmetric positive solutions of fourth-order nonlocal boundary value problems

Research Article Almost Periodic Solutions of Prey-Predator Discrete Models with Delay

Positive periodic solutions of higher-dimensional nonlinear functional difference equations

Positive solutions of BVPs for some second-order four-point difference systems

Applied Mathematics Letters. Stationary distribution, ergodicity and extinction of a stochastic generalized logistic system

Xiyou Cheng Zhitao Zhang. 1. Introduction

Permanence and global stability of a May cooperative system with strong and weak cooperative partners

Existence of Almost Periodic Solutions of Discrete Ricker Delay Models

POSITIVE SOLUTIONS FOR NONLOCAL SEMIPOSITONE FIRST ORDER BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEMS

HIGHER ORDER CRITERION FOR THE NONEXISTENCE OF FORMAL FIRST INTEGRAL FOR NONLINEAR SYSTEMS. 1. Introduction

Persistence and global stability in discrete models of Lotka Volterra type

Abdulmalik Al Twaty and Paul W. Eloe

Global attractivity and positive almost periodic solution of a multispecies discrete mutualism system with time delays

Banach Algebras of Matrix Transformations Between Spaces of Strongly Bounded and Summable Sequences

Global existence of periodic solutions of BAM neural networks with variable coefficients

PUBLICATIONS. Bo Zhang

ON THE BEHAVIOR OF SOLUTIONS OF LINEAR NEUTRAL INTEGRODIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS WITH UNBOUNDED DELAY

On Some Stochastic Fractional Integro-Differential Equations

DYNAMICS IN A COMPETITIVE LOTKA-VOLTERRA PREDATOR-PREY MODEL WITH MULTIPLE DELAYS. Changjin Xu 1. Yusen Wu. 1. Introduction

Fractional differential equations with integral boundary conditions

Existence Results for Multivalued Semilinear Functional Differential Equations

CONVERGENCE BEHAVIOUR OF SOLUTIONS TO DELAY CELLULAR NEURAL NETWORKS WITH NON-PERIODIC COEFFICIENTS

FUZZY SOLUTIONS FOR BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEMS WITH INTEGRAL BOUNDARY CONDITIONS. 1. Introduction

Research Article Solvability of a Class of Integral Inclusions

ON WEAKLY NONLINEAR BACKWARD PARABOLIC PROBLEM

MONOTONE POSITIVE SOLUTION OF NONLINEAR THIRD-ORDER TWO-POINT BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEM

Asymptotic stability of solutions of a class of neutral differential equations with multiple deviating arguments

Hopf Bifurcation and Limit Cycle Analysis of the Rikitake System

Nontrivial Solutions for Boundary Value Problems of Nonlinear Differential Equation

Oscillation Criteria for Certain nth Order Differential Equations with Deviating Arguments

Upper and lower solutions method and a fractional differential equation boundary value problem.

FUNCTIONAL COMPRESSION-EXPANSION FIXED POINT THEOREM

On Positive Solutions of Boundary Value Problems on the Half-Line

x 2 F 1 = 0 K 2 v 2 E 1 E 2 F 2 = 0 v 1 K 1 x 1

Computation of fixed point index and applications to superlinear periodic problem

AN EXISTENCE-UNIQUENESS THEOREM FOR A CLASS OF BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEMS

NONLINEAR THREE POINT BOUNDARY VALUE PROBLEM

On the Existence of Almost Periodic Solutions of a Nonlinear Volterra Difference Equation

LOTKA-VOLTERRA SYSTEMS WITH DELAY

Bifurcation and Stability Analysis of a Prey-predator System with a Reserved Area

A MIN-MAX THEOREM AND ITS APPLICATIONS TO NONCONSERVATIVE SYSTEMS

EVANESCENT SOLUTIONS FOR LINEAR ORDINARY DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS

Optimal harvesting policy of a stochastic delay predator-prey model with Lévy jumps

A NOTE ON THE COMPLETE MOMENT CONVERGENCE FOR ARRAYS OF B-VALUED RANDOM VARIABLES

On the split equality common fixed point problem for quasi-nonexpansive multi-valued mappings in Banach spaces

ON QUADRATIC INTEGRAL EQUATIONS OF URYSOHN TYPE IN FRÉCHET SPACES. 1. Introduction

Journal of Inequalities in Pure and Applied Mathematics

On boundary value problems for fractional integro-differential equations in Banach spaces

EXISTENCE OF SOLUTIONS TO THREE-POINT BOUNDARY-VALUE PROBLEMS AT RESONANCE

On the existence of solution to a boundary value problem of fractional differential equation on the infinite interval

Some Integral Inequalities with Maximum of the Unknown Functions

A Concise Course on Stochastic Partial Differential Equations

Delay-Dependent Exponential Stability of Linear Systems with Fast Time-Varying Delay

GLOBAL ATTRACTIVITY IN A NONLINEAR DIFFERENCE EQUATION

Permanence and global attractivity of a nonautonomous modified Leslie-Gower predator-prey model with Holling-type II schemes and a prey refuge

EXISTENCE OF SOLUTIONS FOR KIRCHHOFF TYPE EQUATIONS WITH UNBOUNDED POTENTIAL. 1. Introduction In this article, we consider the Kirchhoff type problem

STABILITY OF A POSITIVE POINT OF EQUILIBRIUM OF ONE NONLINEAR SYSTEM WITH AFTEREFFECT AND STOCHASTIC PERTURBATIONS

Transcription:

Advances in Dynamical Systems and Applications. ISSN 973-5321 Volume 1 Number 2 (26), pp. 29 217 c Research India Publications http://www.ripublication.com/adsa.htm Existence of Positive Periodic Solutions of Mutualism Systems with Several Delays 1 Yonghui Xia College of Mathematics and Computer Science, Fuzhou University, Fuzhou 352, P.R.China E-mail: yhxia@fzu.edu.cn; xiayonhui@163.com Abstract In this paper, by using Mawhin coincidence degree, we study the global existence of positive periodic solutions for a class of mutualism systems with several delays and obtain a new and interesting criterion, which is much different from those of Yang etc. [8]. Moreover, our arguments for obtaining bounds of solutions to the operator equation Lx = λn x are much different from those used in [8]. So some new arguments are employed for the first time. AMS subject classification: 34C25, 92D25, 92B5. Keywords: Periodic solutions, coincidence degree, mutualism model. 1. Introduction Traditional Lotka Volterra type predator-prey model or competitive model has received great attention from both theoretical and mathematical biologists and has been studied extensively (for example, see [1 5, 9, 11 22]). But there are few papers considering the mutualism system. Goh [6] discussed the stability in models of mutualism of the form ẋ1 (t) = x 1 (t) [ r 1 (t) a 11 (t)x 1 (t) + a (t)x 2 (t) ], ẋ 2 (t) = x 2 (t) [ r 2 (t) + a 21 (t)x 1 (t) a 22 (t)x 2 (t) ]. (1.1) 1 This work was supported by the Foundation of Developing Science and Technology of Fuzhou University under the grant 24-XY- and the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant (No.16717) and Shanghai Shuguang Genzong Project (6SGG7). Received March 11, 26; Accepted June 9, 26

21 Yonghui Xia Then Gopalsamy and He [7] studied the following system with discrete delay ẋ1 (t) = x 1 (t) [ r 1 (t) a 11 (t)x 1 (t τ) + a (t)x 2 (t τ) ], ẋ 2 (t) = x 2 (t) [ r 2 (t) + a 21 (t)x 1 (t τ) a 22 (t)x 2 (t τ) ]. (1.2) Some sufficient conditions were obtained for the persistence and global attractivity of system (1.2). Then Yang etc. [8] obtained some sufficient conditions for the existence of positive periodic solutions of the system ẏ1 (t) = y 1 (t) [ r 1 (t) a 11 (t)y 1 (t τ 1 (t)) + a (t)y 2 (t τ 2 (t)) ], ẏ 2 (t) = y 2 (t) [ r 2 (t) + a 21 (t)y 1 (t τ 1 (t)) a 22 (t)y 2 (t τ 2 (t)) ] (1.3). Now we generalize the system to ẏ1 (t) = y 1 (t) [ r 1 (t) a 11 (t)y 1 (t τ 1 (t)) + a (t)y 2 (t τ 2 (t)) ], ẏ 2 (t) = y 2 (t) [ r 2 (t) + a 21 (t)y 1 (t σ 1 (t)) a 22 (t)y 2 (t σ 2 (t)) ], (1.4) where a ij (t), i, j = 1, 2, τ i (t), σ i (t), i = 1,..., n are positive periodic functions with period ω > and r i (t)dt >, i = 1, 2. The assumption of periodicity of the parameters a ij (t) is a way of incorporating the periodicity of the environment (e.g., seasonal effects of weather condition, food supplies, temperature, mating habits, harvesting etc.). The growth functions r i (t) are unnecessary to remain positive, since the environment fluctuates randomly, in bad condition, r i (t) may be negative. Obviously, system (1.3) is a special case of system (1.4). Unlike system (1.3), σ i (t) τ i (t). Thus the existing argument in Yang etc. [8] for obtaining bounds of solutions to the operator equation Lx = λnx are not applicable to our case and some new arguments are employed for the first time. The initial conditions for system (1.4) take the form of ẏ i (s) = ψ i (s), τ = max sup τ i (t), σ i (t), i = 1, 2} t [,ω] ψ i (t) C([ τ, ], R + ), ψ i () >, i = 1, 2. Throughout this paper, we will use the following natation: f = 1 ω where f(t) is an ω-periodic function. f(t)dt, f ι = min f(t), f µ = max f(t), t [,ω] t [,ω] 2. Existence of Positive Periodic Solutions (1.5) In order to obtain the existence of positive periodic solutions of (1.4), for convenience, we shall summarize in the following a few concepts and results from [1] that will be prerequisite for this section.

Positive Periodic Solutions of Mutualism Systems with Several Delays 211 Let X, Y be real Banach spaces, let L : DomL X Y be a linear mapping, and N : X Y be a continuous mapping. The mapping L is called a Fredholm mapping of index zero if dimkerl = codim ImL < + and ImL is closed in Y. If L is a Fredholm mapping of index zero and there exist continuous projections P : X X, and Q : Y Y such that ImP = KerL, KerQ = ImL = Im(I Q). It follows that L doml KerP : (I P )X ImL is invertible. We denote the inverse of that map by K p. If Ω is an open bounded subset of X, the mapping N will be called L-compact on Ω if QN(Ω) is bounded and K p (I Q)N : Ω X is compact. Since ImQ is isomorphic to KerL, there exists an isomorphism J : ImQ KerL. Lemma 2.1. [1] Let Ω X be an open bounded set. Let L be a Fredholm mapping of index zero and N be L-compact on Ω. Assume (a) for each λ (, 1), x Ω DomL, Lx λnx; (b) for each x Ω KerL, QNx ; (c) degjqn, Ω KerL, } =. Then Lx = Nx has at least one solution in Ω DomL. Lemma 2.2. Assume that f, g are continuous nonnegative functions defined on the interval [a, b]. Then there exists ξ [a, b] such that Theorem 2.3. Let b a f(t)g(t)dt = f(ξ) b a g(t)dt. b ι 11 = min t [,ω] b ι 22 = min t [,ω] a 11 (t) 1 τ 1 (t), bµ = max t [,ω] a 22 (t) 1 σ 2 (t), bµ 21 = max t [,ω] a (t) 1 τ 2 (t), a 21 (t) 1 σ 1 (t). If b ι 11b ι 22 > b µ 21b µ and τ i (t) < 1, σ i (t) < 1, (i = 1, 2) hold, then system (1.4) has at least one positive ω-periodic solution. Proof. We make the change of variables x i (t) = ln y i (t), i = 1, 2. (2.1) Then (1.4) is rewritten as ẋ1 (t) = r 1 (t) a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))} + a (t) expx 2 (t τ 2 (t))}, ẋ 2 (t) = r 2 (t) + a 21 (t) expx 1 (t σ 1 (t))} a 22 (t) expx 2 (t σ 2 (t))}. (2.2)

2 Yonghui Xia Take and define X = Y = x = (x 1, x 2 ) T C(R, R 2 ) : x(t + ω) = x(t)} x = max t [,ω] x 1(t) + max t [,ω] x 2(t), x = (x 1, x 2 ) T X or Y (here denotes the Euclidean norm). Then X and Y are Banach spaces with the norm. For any x = (x 1, x 2 ) T X, because of the periodicity, we can easily check that r 1 (t) a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))} + a (t) expx 2 (t τ 2 (t))} := 1 (x, t) C(R, R), r 2 (t) + a 21 (t) expx 1 (t σ 1 (t))} a 22 (t) expx 2 (t σ 2 (t))} := 2 (x, t) C(R, R), are ω-periodic. Set ( dx1 (t) L : DomL X, L(x 1 (t), x 2 (t)) =, dx ) 2(t), dt dt where DomL = (x 1 (t), x 2 (t)) C 1 (R, R 2 )} and N : X X, ( ) ( ) x1 1 (x, t) N =. 2 (x, t) x 2 Define P ( x1 x 2 ) ( x1 = Q x 2 ) = 1 ω ω 1 ω x 1 (t)dt x 2 (t)dt, ( x1 x 2 ) X = Y. It is not difficult to show that KerL = x x X, x = C, C R 2 }, } ImL = y y Y, y(t)dt = is closed in Y, dim KerL = codim ImL = 2, and P and Q are continuous projections such that ImP = KerL, KerQ = ImL = Im(I Q). It follows that L is a Fredholm mapping of index zero. Furthermore, the inverse K p of L p exists and has the form K p : ImL DomL KerP K p (y) = t y(s)ds 1 ω t y(s)dsdt.

Positive Periodic Solutions of Mutualism Systems with Several Delays 213 Then QN : X Y and K p (I Q)N : X X read QNx = 1 ω ω 1 ω K p (I Q)Nx = 1 (x, t)dt 2 (x, t)dt t Nx(s)ds 1 ω t ( t Nx(s)dsdt ω 1 2) Nx(s)ds. Clearly, QN and K p (I Q)N are continuous. By using the Arzelà Ascoli Theorem, it is not difficult to prove that K p (I Q)N(Ω) is compact for any open bounded set Ω X. Moreover, QN(Ω) is bounded. Therefore, N is L-compact on Ω for any open bounded set Ω X. Now we reach the position to search for an appropriate open bounded subset Ω for the application of Lemma 2.1. Corresponding to the operator equation Lx = λnx, λ (, 1), we have ẋ1 (t) = λ [ r 1 (t) a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))} + a (t) expx 2 (t τ 2 (t))} ], ẋ 2 (t) = λ [ r 2 (t) + a 21 (t) expx 1 (t σ 1 (t))} a 22 (t) expx 2 (t σ 2 (t))} ]. (2.3) Suppose x = (x 1, x 2 ) T X is a solution of (2.3) for a certain λ (, 1). Integrating (2.3) over the interval [, ω], we obtain Hence, r 1 ω + r 2 ω + [ r1 (t) a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))} + a (t) expx 2 (t τ 2 (t))} ] dt =, [ r2 (t) + a 21 (t) expx 1 (t σ 1 (t))} a 22 (t) expx 2 (t σ 2 (t))} ] dt =. a (t) expx 2 (t τ 2 (t))}dt = a 21 (t) expx 1 (t σ 1 (t))}dt = a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))}dt, (2.4) a 22 (t) expx 2 (t σ 2 (t))}dt. (2.5) Let s = t τ 1 (t). We note that τ 1 (t) < 1, which implies ds dt = 1 τ 1(t) >, ds = (1 τ 1 (t))dt. Therefore, the function s = t τ 1 (t) has the continuous inverse function t = τ 1 (s), s [ τ 1 (), ω τ 1 (ω)]. So we have a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))}dt = τ1 (ω) τ 1 () a 11 (τ 1 (s)) 1 τ 1 (τ 1 (s)) expx 1(s)}ds.

214 Yonghui Xia By Lemma 2.2, there exists ξ [ τ 1 (), ω τ 1 (ω)] = [ τ 1 (), ω τ 1 ()] such that a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))}dt = = a 11 (τ1 (ξ)) 1 τ 1 (τ1 (ξ)) a 11 (η 1 ) 1 τ 1 (η 1 ) τ1 (ω) τ 1 () expx 1 (s)}ds expx 1 (t)}dt, (η 1 = τ 1 (ξ)). For the equations (2.3) and (2.4), similar to the above discussion, there exist η i [, ω], (i = 1, 2, 3, 4) such that We denote r 1 ω + a (η 2 ) ω expx 2 (t)}dt = a 11(η 1 ) ω expx 1 (t)}dt, 1 τ 2 (η 2 ) 1 τ 1 (η 1 ) (2.6) r 2 ω + a 21(η 3 ) ω expx 1 (t)}dt = a 22(η 4 ) ω expx 2 (t)}dt. 1 σ 1 (η 3 ) 1 σ 2 (η 4 ) (2.7) b 11 = a 11(η 1 ) 1 τ 1 (η 1 ), b = a (η 2 ) 1 τ 2 (η 2 ), b 21 = a 21(η 2 ) 1 σ 1 (η 2 ), b 22 = a 22(η 4 ) 1 σ 2 (η 4 ). It follows from (2.6) (2.7) that r 1 ω + b expx 2 (t)}dt = b 11 expx 1 (t)}dt, (2.8) r 2 ω + b 21 expx 1 (t)}dt = b 22 expx 2 (t)}dt. (2.9) Under the assumption of Theorem 2.3, it is not difficult to derive that and expx 1 (t)}dt = b r 2 + b 22 r 1 ω bµ r 2 + b µ 22 r 1 b 11 b 22 b 21 b b ι 11b ι 22 b µ 21b µ ω (2.1) expx 2 (t)}dt = b 21 r 1 + b 11 r 2 ω bµ 21 r 1 + b µ 11 r 2 b 11 b 22 b 21 b b ι 11b ι 22 b µ 21b µ ω. (2.11) Therefore, there exists t i [, ω], i = 1, 2 such that x 1 (t 1 ) ln bµ r 2 + b µ 22 r 1 b ι 11b ι 22 b µ 21b µ, x 2 (t 2 ) ln bµ 21 r 1 + b µ 11 r 2 b ι 11b ι 22 b µ 21b µ. Obviously, there exists positive constants M i >, i = 1, 2 such that x i (t i ) M i, i = 1, 2. (2.)

Positive Periodic Solutions of Mutualism Systems with Several Delays 215 On the other hand, it follows from (2.3), (2.4) and (2.1) that ẋ 1 (t) dt = λ r1 (t) a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))} +a (t) expx 2 (t τ 2 (t))} dt, < r 1 ω + = 2 + 2b µ 11 a (t) expx 2 (t τ 2 (t))}dt a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))}dt a 11 (t) expx 1 (t τ 1 (t))}dt Similarly, it follows from (2.3), (2.5) and (2.11) that It follows from (2.) (2.14) that expx 1 (t)}dt 2b µ b µ r 2 + b µ 22 r 1 11 b ι 11b ι 22 b µ 21b µ ω := H 1. (2.13) ẋ 2 (t) dt < 2b µ b µ 21 r 1 + b µ 11 r 2 11 b ι 11b ι 22 b µ 21b µ ω := H 2. (2.14) x i (t) x i (t i ) + ẋ i (t) dt < M i + H i. Clearly, M i, H i, i = 1, 2 are independent of the choice of λ. We note that ā 11 = 1 ω a 11 (t)dt = 1 ω τ1 () τ 1 () a 11 (τ 1 (s)) 1 τ 1 (τ 1 (s)) ds = a 11(τ 1 (s 1 )) 1 τ 1 (τ 1 (s 1 )), s 1 [ τ 1 (), ω τ 1 ()], (2.15) where t = τ 1 (s) is the inverse function of s = t τ 1 (t). Similar to the discussion of (2.15), ā = a (τ 2 (s 2 )) 1 τ 2 (τ 2 (s 2 )), ā 21 = a 21(σ 1(s 3 )) 1 σ 1 (σ 1(s 3 )), ā 22 = a 22(σ 2(s 4 )) 1 σ 2 (σ 2(s 4 )). (2.16) Thus, under the assumptions in Theorem 2.3, it follows from (2.15) (2.16) that ā 11 ā 22 ā ā 21 > b ι 11b ι 22 b µ b µ 21 >. (2.17) Now it is easy to show that the system of algebraic equations r i ā ii v i + ā ij v j =, i, j = 1, 2.

216 Yonghui Xia has a unique solution (v 1, v 2) T R 2 + with x i >. Take H = maxm i + H i + C, M i + H i +C}, where C > is taken sufficiently large such that (ln v 1, ln v 2) T < C. Define Ω = x(t) X : x < H}. It is clear that Ω satisfies condition (a) of Lemma 2.1. Let x Ω KerL = Ω IR 2, x be a constant vector in IR 2 with x = H. Then QNx = [ r i ā ii expx i } + ā ij expx j } = ] 2 1. Furthermore, let J : ImQ KerL. In view of assumptions in Theorem 2.3 and (2.15) (2.17), it is easy to see that [ ] ā11 ā degjqn, Ω KerL, } = sgn det sgn(b ι ā 21 ā 22 11b ι 22 b µ b µ 21), where deg( ) is the Brouwer degree and the J is the identity mapping since ImQ = KerL. By now, we have shown that Ω verifies all requirements of Lemma 2.1. Then it follows that Lx = N x has at least one solution in DomL Ω. By (2.1), we derive that (1.4) has at least one positive ω-periodic solution. The proof is completed. Remark 2.4. Our results and the method used in the proof are much different from those in the known literature. We remark that we generalize system (1.3) in [8] to system (1.4), where τ i (t) σ i (t), i.e., all the delays are different. It is in this aspect that we generalize the results in [8]. Acknowledgement The authors would like to express their gratitude to the reviewers and editor for their valuable comments and careful reading. References [1] L. Chen. Mathematical Models and Methods in Ecology, Science Press, Bejing, 1998, (in Chinese). [2] Y. Kuang. Delay Differential Equations With Application Dynamic, New York, Academic Press, 1988. [3] M. Fan and K. Wang. Positive periodic solutions of a periodic integro-differential competition system with infinite delays, Z. Angew. Math. Mech., 81(3):197 23, 21. [4] M. Fan and K. Wang. Periodicity in a delayed ratio-dependent pedator-prey system, J. Math. Anal. Appl., 262:179 19, 21. [5] B.S. Goh. Management and Analysis of Biological Populations, Elsevier Scientific, The Netherlands, 198. [6] B.S. Goh. Stability in models of mutualism, Amer. Natural, 113:261 275, 1979.

Positive Periodic Solutions of Mutualism Systems with Several Delays 217 [7] K. Gopalsamy and X.Z. He. Persitence, attractivity, and delay in facultative mutualism, J. Math. Anal. Appl., 215:154 173, 1997. [8] F. Yang, D. Jiang, and A. Ying. Existence of positive solution of multidelays facultative mutualism system, Journal of Engineering Mathematics, 3:64 68, 22. [9] Y. Xia and J. Cao. Almost periodicity in an ecological model with M-predators and N-preys by pure-delay type system, Nonlinear Dynamics, 39(3):275 34, 25. [1] R.E. Gaines and J.L. Mawhin. Coincidence Degree and Nonlinear Differential Equations, Springer, Berlin, 1977. [11] Y. Xia, M. Lin and J. Cao. The existence of almost periodic solutions of certain perturbation systems, J. Math. Anal. Appl., 31(1):81 9, 25. [] Y. Xia and J. Cao. Almost periodic solutions for an ecological model with infinite delays, Proc. Edinburgh Math. Soc., 5(1):229 249, 27. [13] K. Gopalsamy. Stability and Oscillation in Delay Differential Equations of Population Dynamics, Mathematics and its Applications 74, Kluwer Academic Publishers Group, Dordrecht, 1992. [14] Y.K. Li. Periodic solutions of a periodic delay predator-prey system, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., 7:1331 1335, 1999. [15] Y.K. Li and Y. Kuang. Periodic solutions in periodic state-dependent delay equations and population models, J. Math. Anal. Appl., 255:265 28, 21. [16] L.L. Wan and W.T. Li. Existence and global stability of positive periodic solutions of a predator-prey system with delays, Appl. Math. Comput., 146:167 185, 23. [17] Y. Xia, F. Chen, A. Chen, and J. Cao. Existence and global attractivity of an almost periodic ecological model, Appl. Math. Comput., 157(2):449 475, 24. [18] Y. Xia, J. Cao, H. Zhang, and F. Chen. Almost periodic solutions of n-species competitive system with feedback controls, J. Math. Anal. Appl., 294(2):53 522, 24. [19] M. Fan and K. Wang. Global existence of positive periodic solutions of periodic predator-prey system with infinite delay, J. Math. Anal. Appl., 262:1 11, 21. [2] H.I. Freedman and Y. Kuang. Stability switches in linear scalar neutral delay equations, Funkc. Ekvac., 34:187 29, 1991. [21] M. Fan, P.J.Y. Wong, and R.P. Agarwal. Periodicity and stabilty in periodic n- species Lotka-Volterra competition system with feedback controls and deviating arguments, Acta Mathematica Sinica, 19:81 822, 23. [22] M. Fan, P.J.Y. Wong, and R.P. Agarwal. Periodicity in a class of nonautonomous scalar equations with deviating arguments and applications to population models, Dynamical Systems, 19:279 31, 24.