Journal of Chemical Ecology, Vol. 30, No. 2, February 2004 ( C 2004) Originally published online January 14, 2004, Rapid Communications, pp. RC125 129 (http://www.kluweronline.com/issn/0098-0331) STEREOCHEMISTRY OF HOST PLANT MONOTERPENES AS MATE LOCATION CUES FOR THE GALL WASP Antistrophus rufus JOHN F. TOOKER 1,2 and LAWRENCE M. HANKS 1, 1 Department of Entomology, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL 61801 (Received December 11, 2003; revised January 9, 2004; accepted January 13, 2004) Abstract In spring, adult males of the gall wasp Antistrophus rufus L. emerge from inconspicuous galls in stems of their host plant Silphium laciniatum L. and search for sites on stems where females will later emerge. The behavior of males suggests that they use olfaction rather than visual or tactile cues in searching for mates. In an earlier publication, we reported that galls of A. rufus were associated with changes in enantiomeric ratios of α- and β-pinene emitted by plant stems, and hypothesized that monoterpene stereochemistry served as a mate location cue for adult males. Here, we support this hypothesis with bioassays that demonstrate that males can discriminate between galled and ungalled stems, as well as between blends of synthetic monoterpenes with ratios of enantiomers representative of galled and ungalled stems. Key Words Asteraceae, Silphium, Cynipidae, prairie, pinene, enantiomer. INTRODUCTION Larvae of Antistrophus rufus L. (Hymenoptera: Cynipidae) feed within ellipsoid galls ( 3-mm long) in flowering stems of Silphium laciniatum L., an asteraceous prairie perennial (Gillette, 1891; Tooker et al., 2002, 2004; Tooker and Hanks, 2004a,b). Unlike most galling insects, development of A. rufus galls does not alter the physical structure of the stem surface (Gillette, 1891; Tooker and Hanks, 2004b). Adult males emerge before females in spring and locate areas on dead stems of host plants, in the apparent absence of visual or tactile cues, where females will later emerge (Tooker et al., 2002). Males defend these diminutive 2 Current Address: Department of Entomology, 501 ASI Building, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA 16802. To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: hanks@life.uiuc.edu 473 0098-0331/04/0200-0473/0 C 2004 Plenum Publishing Corporation
474 TOOKER AND HANKS territories, driving off other males by charging and head butting (Tooker and Hanks, 2004b). Antistrophus rufus males display characteristic behaviors while searching for mates on plant stems, turning frequently, lowering their heads, and rapidly drumming their antennae on the stem surface (Tooker et al., 2002; Tooker and Hanks, 2004b), suggesting that males use olfactory cues to detect females in stems. Ratios of monoterpenes emitted by dead stems of S. laciniatum included α-pinene, β-pinene, and camphene, but these compounds were produced in similar amounts by galled and ungalled stems (Tooker et al., 2002). Enantiomeric ratios [+: ] of both α- and β-pinene, however, approximated 50:50 in ungalled stems but were significantly skewed in both directions in galled stems (camphene was 100% [ ] in all stems; Tooker et al., 2002). Skewness of enantiomeric ratios in both directions suggests that oviposition by gall wasps, or feeding by the larvae, alters in some non-uniform way the expression of genes that code for pinene synthases, in some cases activating or repressing the gene for the synthase of one enantiomer, in other cases influencing the gene for the synthase of the other enantiomer. In bioassays, males responded positively to a blend of synthetic compounds with enantiomeric ratios representative of galled stems (Tooker et al., 2002). Based on these findings, we hypothesized that ratios of pinene enantiomers, altered during development of gall wasp larvae, provide olfactory cues that adult males later use in detecting mates in dead stems of host plants (Tooker et al., 2002). In this article, we present further support for our hypothesis with bioassays that confirm that adult male A. rufus can discriminate between plant stems that contain galls and those that do not, and between blends of synthetic compounds representative of galled and ungalled stems. METHODS AND MATERIALS Response to Galled and Ungalled Stems. To determine whether male gall wasps can discriminate between galled and ungalled stems, we conducted a choice test based on a Y-configuration of stems (see Tooker et al., 2002; Tooker and Hanks, 2004b). A dead stem (20-cm long) of the non-host plant Solidago altissima L. served as the base of a Y, and the arms were 20-cm sections of galled and ungalled stems of S. laciniatum of approximately equal diameter. The Y was positioned on an incline directed toward a north-facing window. Wasps released at the base of the Y invariably walked uphill where they encountered the junction of galled and ungalled stems. Wasps responded to a stem by remaining on it for at least two minutes; individuals that did not respond to either stem within five min were recorded as no response. We repeated this bioassay until 38 individuals had responded (N = 42 trials), replacing stems and switching galled and ungalled treatments between arms after every five wasps to control for location effects.
STEREOCHEMISTRY OF HOST PLANT MONOTERPENES AS MATE LOCATION CUES 475 We used the X 2 goodness-of-fit test (Sokal and Rohlf, 1995) to test differences between treatments in numbers of responding wasps. For our bioassays, we collected dead stems of S. laciniatum that contained diapausing larvae of A. rufus from Fithian Railroad Prairie (FRP, Vermilion Co., IL; Tooker and Hanks, 2004c) and dead stems of the same species that did not contain galls from a prairie garden where A. rufus was absent (Lincoln Bookbindery Prairie Garden, Champaign Co., IL). Stems were collected in February 2003. We reared all gall wasps from half of the FRP stems in an incubator (22 C, 16:8 L:D) to eliminate the potential complication of volatile compounds produced by wasps themselves. Thus, the galled stems referred to below contained recently abandoned A. rufus galls, but no insects. In an unheated outbuilding, we stored ungalled stems and the remaining FRP stems from which we reared adult gall wasps for bioassays. Response to Synthetic Compounds. To test the response of adult male A. rufus to synthetic monoterpenes, we created blends of α- and β-pinene and camphene (Aldrich Chemical Co., Milwaukee, WI) in reagent grade hexane in concentrations of 0.9-ng/ml ( 1 equivalent of a 20-cm stem section in 3-ml). To account for skewness in enantiomeric ratios in both directions from 50:50 that was characteristic of galled stems (see Tooker et al., 2002), we conducted two trials: one with enantiomers of α- and β-pinene in ratios of 10:90 [+: ] and the other with ratios of 90:10 (100% [ ] camphene in both trials). For each trail, we applied one stem-section equivalent of the galled blend to a 2.5-cm square of filter paper (Qualitative No. 1, Whatman, Maidstone, UK), another paper square was treated with a similar dosage of the ungalled blend (with α- and β-pinene enantiomers in ratios of 50:50 and 100% [ ] camphene), and a third square of paper was treated with hexane. We allowed solvent to evaporate and arranged the three paper squares in a 8-cm diam circle within a 10-cm diam Petri dish. Individual males were released at the dish center, and we recorded how long they remained on each paper square during a 5-min period, and their behaviors. Wasps were from the same source as above. We replicated the bioassay 20 times for each trial, replacing the paper squares and changing their position after every 5 wasps. We tested differences between treatments in the amount of time wasps spent on paper squares with ANOVA (SAS Institute, 2001). Differences between individual treatment means were tested with the LSD means separation test (Sokal and Rohlf, 1995). RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Response to Galled and Ungalled Stems. In the Y -configuration test, 34 of 38 male A. rufus responded to the galled stems (X 2 = 23.7, P < 0.001). On seven occasions, wasps walked onto the ungalled stem first, but immediately walked off and onto the galled stem where they remained. Moreover, wasps exhibited the characteristic searching behavior only on galled stems, while on ungalled
476 TOOKER AND HANKS FIG. 1. Relationship between amount of time that male Antistrophus rufus spent on pieces of filter paper and ratios of enantiomers of α- and β-pinene with which the paper was treated. In one trial (group of bars on left), the pinene blend was representative of galled stems with a 10:90 [+: ] enantiomeric ratio of both compounds, while this ratio was skewed in the opposite direction [90:10] in the second trial (bars on right; including 100% [ ] camphene in both trials; see text for explanation of treatments). Pinene blends representative of ungalled stems had enantiomeric ratios of 50:50 (also including [ ] camphene). In both trials, male wasps spent significantly more time on paper representative of galled stems than on ungalled paper and solvent controls (Trial with pinenes in enantiomeric ratios of 10:90: ANOVA F 2,55 = 12.1, P < 0.001; trial with 90:10: ANOVA F 2,59 = 8.8, P < 0.001). Bars marked with different letters of the same case are significantly different (LSD P < 0.05). stems they walked in a directed manner, infrequently antennating the stem surface. These findings are further evidence that male A. rufus use volatile plant cues to discriminate between stems that contained galls and those that do not. Response to Synthetic Compounds. In bioassays that tested the response, males remained on filter paper treated with the galled blend of monoterpenes for three to eight times longer than on solvent controls, and two to three times longer than on paper treated with the ungalled blend (Figure 1). Males showed a statistically significant, although weaker response to the ungalled blend relative to the solvent control (Figure 1). Consistent with their behavior on plant stems in the Y -configuration test, males usually displayed their characteristic searching behavior on filter paper treated with the galled blend, but rarely did so on paper treated with the ungalled blend or the solvent control. Our hypothesis that mate location by male A. rufus is cued by changes in monoterpene stereochemistry that are associated with galls of conspecifics is supported by their ability to discriminate between galled and ungalled plant stems, by chemical differences between the two types of stems, and by the corresponding response of males to blends of synthetic compounds that mimic volatile profiles
STEREOCHEMISTRY OF HOST PLANT MONOTERPENES AS MATE LOCATION CUES 477 of plant stems. Monoterpene stereochemistry also influences the behavior of other insects (e.g., Erbilgin and Raffa, 2001); however, our studies are apparently the first to demonstrate that changes in monoterpene stereochemistry that are associated with the insect itself play a central role in location of mates. Acknowledgments We thank R. Croteau for discussion of terpene biosynthesis, A. L. Crumrin and J. F. Westberg for assistance with lab bioassays, and C. Hohn for access to the prairie garden. Funding was provided by a Harley J. Van Cleave Fellowship from the School of Integrative Biology, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and the Cooperative State Research, Education, and Extension Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture, under Agreement 2001-35316-11275. REFERENCES ERBILGIN, N. and RAFFA, K. F. 2001. Modulation of predator attraction to pheromones of two prey species by stereochemistry of plant volatiles. Oecologia 127:444 453. GILLETTE, C. P. 1891. Descriptions of new Cynipidae in the collection of the Illinois State Laboratory of Natural History. Bull. Il. St. Lab. Nat. Hist. 3:191 197. SOKAL, R.R.andROHLF, F. J. 1995. Biometry, 3rd edition. W. H. Freeman, New York. TOOKER, J. F. and HANKS, L. M. 2004a. Impact of prescribed burning on endophytic insect communities of prairie perennials (Asteraceae: Silphium spp.) Biodivers. Conserv. (in press). TOOKER, J. F. and HANKS, L. M. 2004b. Endophytic insect communities of two prairie perennials (Asteraceae: Silphium spp.) Biodivers. Conserv. (in press). TOOKER, J. F. and HANKS, L. M. 2004c. Trophic position of the endophytic beetle Mordellistena aethiops Smith (Coleoptera: Mordellidae). Environ. Entomol. (in press). TOOKER, J. F., DEANS, A. R., and HANKS, L. M. 2004. Description of the Antistrophus rufus (Hymenoptera: Cynipidae) species complex, including two new species. J. Hymenop. Res. (in press). TOOKER, J. F., KOENIG, W. A., and HANKS, L. M. 2002. Altered host plant volatiles are proxies for sex pheromones in the gall wasp Antistrophus rufus. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 99:15486 15491.