Difference Resonances in a controlled van der Pol-Duffing oscillator involving time. delay

Similar documents
Additive resonances of a controlled van der Pol-Duffing oscillator

Suppression of the primary resonance vibrations of a forced nonlinear system using a dynamic vibration absorber

α Cubic nonlinearity coefficient. ISSN: x DOI: : /JOEMS

The Effects of Machine Components on Bifurcation and Chaos as Applied to Multimachine System

DYNAMICS OF ASYMMETRIC NONLINEAR VIBRATION ABSORBER

Feedback Control and Stability of the Van der Pol Equation Subjected to External and Parametric Excitation Forces

Chapter 14 Three Ways of Treating a Linear Delay Differential Equation

COMPLEX DYNAMICS AND CHAOS CONTROL IN DUFFING-VAN DER POL EQUATION WITH TWO EXTERNAL PERIODIC FORCING TERMS

ANALYSIS AND CONTROLLING OF HOPF BIFURCATION FOR CHAOTIC VAN DER POL-DUFFING SYSTEM. China

2.034: Nonlinear Dynamics and Waves. Term Project: Nonlinear dynamics of piece-wise linear oscillators Mostafa Momen

Three ways of treating a linear delay differential equation

BIFURCATIONS OF PERIODIC ORBITS IN THREE-WELL DUFFING SYSTEM WITH A PHASE SHIFT

Internal and external synchronization of self-oscillating oscillators with non-identical control parameters

Citation Acta Mechanica Sinica/Lixue Xuebao, 2009, v. 25 n. 5, p The original publication is available at

Active Vibration Control for A Bilinear System with Nonlinear Velocity Time-delayed Feedback

TWO DIMENSIONAL FLOWS. Lecture 5: Limit Cycles and Bifurcations

HORSESHOES CHAOS AND STABILITY OF A DELAYED VAN DER POL-DUFFING OSCILLATOR UNDER A BOUNDED DOUBLE WELL POTENTIAL

Strange dynamics of bilinear oscillator close to grazing

CALCULATION OF NONLINEAR VIBRATIONS OF PIECEWISE-LINEAR SYSTEMS USING THE SHOOTING METHOD

Hopf Bifurcation Analysis and Approximation of Limit Cycle in Coupled Van Der Pol and Duffing Oscillators

Nonlinear dynamics of system oscillations modeled by a forced Van der Pol generalized oscillator

Recent new examples of hidden attractors

The Stick-Slip Vibration and Bifurcation of a Vibro-Impact System with Dry Friction

Stability and bifurcation of a simple neural network with multiple time delays.

B5.6 Nonlinear Systems

Control of Periodic and Chaotic Motions in a Cantilever Beam with Varying Orientation under Principal Parametric Resonance

Dynamical behaviour of a controlled vibro-impact system

Parametric Resonance in the Rayleigh Duffing Oscillator with Time-Delayed Feedback

NON-STATIONARY RESONANCE DYNAMICS OF THE HARMONICALLY FORCED PENDULUM

A plane autonomous system is a pair of simultaneous first-order differential equations,

Global analysis of the nonlinear Duffing-van der Pol type equation by a bifurcation theory and complete bifurcation groups method

Controlling Hopf Bifurcations: Discrete-Time Systems

BIFURCATIONS AND CHAOS IN A PERIODICALLY FORCED PROTOTYPE ADAPTIVE CONTROL SYSTEM 1

DELAY-INDUCED BIFURCATIONS IN A NONAUTONOMOUS SYSTEM WITH DELAYED VELOCITY FEEDBACKS

Chapter 23. Predicting Chaos The Shift Map and Symbolic Dynamics

Report E-Project Henriette Laabsch Toni Luhdo Steffen Mitzscherling Jens Paasche Thomas Pache

Stability and bifurcation analysis of a Van der Pol Duffing oscillator with a nonlinear tuned vibration absorber

Self-Excited Vibration

Resonances of a Forced Mathieu Equation with Reference to Wind Turbine Blades

Introduction to Applied Nonlinear Dynamical Systems and Chaos

arxiv: v1 [nlin.cd] 20 Jul 2010

Clearly the passage of an eigenvalue through to the positive real half plane leads to a qualitative change in the phase portrait, i.e.

Existence of permanent oscillations for a ring of coupled van der Pol oscillators with time delays

Mathematical Foundations of Neuroscience - Lecture 7. Bifurcations II.

On a Codimension Three Bifurcation Arising in a Simple Dynamo Model

Period-doubling cascades of a Silnikov equation

2:2:1 Resonance in the Quasiperiodic Mathieu Equation

On the periodic logistic equation

DYNAMICS OF AN UMBILICAL CABLE FOR UNDERGROUND BORE-WELL APPLICATIONS

Nonlinear Stability and Bifurcation of Multi-D.O.F. Chatter System in Grinding Process

DRIVEN and COUPLED OSCILLATORS. I Parametric forcing The pendulum in 1:2 resonance Santiago de Compostela

Chaos Control of the Chaotic Symmetric Gyroscope System

Simple conservative, autonomous, second-order chaotic complex variable systems.

Lecture 5. Outline: Limit Cycles. Definition and examples How to rule out limit cycles. Poincare-Bendixson theorem Hopf bifurcations Poincare maps

Chapter 1. Introduction

CHAPTER 6 HOPF-BIFURCATION IN A TWO DIMENSIONAL NONLINEAR DIFFERENTIAL EQUATION

Two models for the parametric forcing of a nonlinear oscillator

Dynamics of a mass-spring-pendulum system with vastly different frequencies

QUARTERLY OF APPLIED MATHEMATICS

2:1 Resonance in the delayed nonlinear Mathieu equation

Edward Lorenz. Professor of Meteorology at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology

Research Article. The Study of a Nonlinear Duffing Type Oscillator Driven by Two Voltage Sources

Analysis of the Chatter Instability in a Nonlinear Model for Drilling

DIFFERENTIAL EQUATIONS, DYNAMICAL SYSTEMS, AND AN INTRODUCTION TO CHAOS

Classification of Phase Portraits at Equilibria for u (t) = f( u(t))

arxiv: v1 [nlin.ao] 19 May 2017

= F ( x; µ) (1) where x is a 2-dimensional vector, µ is a parameter, and F :

Synchronization of Chaotic Systems via Active Disturbance Rejection Control

Stabilization of Hyperbolic Chaos by the Pyragas Method

The phenomenon: complex motion, unusual geometry

A Singular Perturbation Approach in Nonlinear Aeroelasticity for Limit-Cycle Oscillations

NONLINEAR NORMAL MODES OF COUPLED SELF-EXCITED OSCILLATORS

In-Plane and Out-of-Plane Dynamic Responses of Elastic Cables under External and Parametric Excitations

Dynamics of Modified Leslie-Gower Predator-Prey Model with Predator Harvesting

Nonlinear Control Lecture 1: Introduction

The influence of noise on two- and three-frequency quasi-periodicity in a simple model system

ENGI 9420 Lecture Notes 4 - Stability Analysis Page Stability Analysis for Non-linear Ordinary Differential Equations

Invariant manifolds of the Bonhoeffer-van der Pol oscillator

FROM EQUILIBRIUM TO CHAOS

DOUBLE HOPF BIFURCATION IN DELAYED VAN DER POL DUFFING EQUATION

Bifurcation Analysis, Chaos and Control in the Burgers Mapping

On Riddled Sets and Bifurcations of Chaotic Attractors

PERTURBATIONS. Received September 20, 2004; Revised April 7, 2005

Calculus and Differential Equations II

Dynamics of Two Coupled van der Pol Oscillators with Delay Coupling Revisited

FADING MEMORY LEARNING IN THE COBWEB MODEL WITH RISK AVERSE HETEROGENEOUS PRODUCERS

Generalized projective synchronization between two chaotic gyros with nonlinear damping

2D-Volterra-Lotka Modeling For 2 Species

On the Solution of the Van der Pol Equation

Quasiperiodic phenomena in the Van der Pol - Mathieu equation

Harmonic balance approach for a degenerate torus of a nonlinear jerk equation

CONTROLLING IN BETWEEN THE LORENZ AND THE CHEN SYSTEMS

Vibration Reduction and Stability of Non-Linear. System Subjected to External and Parametric. Excitation Forces under a Non-Linear Absorber

Control of Chaos in Strongly Nonlinear Dynamic Systems

Problem Set Number 5, j/2.036j MIT (Fall 2014)

DYNAMICS OF THREE COUPLED VAN DER POL OSCILLATORS WITH APPLICATION TO CIRCADIAN RHYTHMS

acta physica slovaca vol. 54 No. 2, April 2004 SIMPLE EXPERIMENTAL METHODS TO CONTROL CHAOS IN A DOUBLE PLASMA MACHINE 1

1708. Dynamical analysis of fractional-order Mathieu equation

Control Systems. Internal Stability - LTI systems. L. Lanari

Analytical estimations of limit cycle amplitude for delay-differential equations

Transcription:

Difference Resonances in a controlled van der Pol-Duffing oscillator involving time delay This paper was published in the journal Chaos, Solitions & Fractals, vol.4, no., pp.975-98, Oct 9 J.C. Ji, N. Zhang, Wei Gao Faculty of Engineering, University of Technology, Sydney PO Box, Broadway, NSW 7, Australia The current address for correspondence: Dr. J. C. Ji Faculty of Engineering Level, Building University of Technology, Sydney PO Box, Broadway, NSW 7 Australia Email: jin.ji@uts.edu.au Phone: ++6 954 4 Total number of pages including figures: + = Total number of figures:

Difference Resonances in a controlled van der Pol-Duffing oscillator involving time delay J.C. Ji, N. Zhang, Wei Gao Faculty of Engineering, University of Technology, Sydney PO Box, Broadway, NSW 7, Australia Abstract A non-resonant interaction of two Hopf bifurcations may appear after the trivial solution of a controlled van der Pol-Duffing oscillator without external excitation loses its stability, when two critical time delays corresponding to two Hopf bifurcations have the same value. In the vicinity of the non-resonant Hopf bifurcations, the presence of a periodic excitation in the controlled oscillator can induce difference resonances in the forced response, when the forcing frequency and the frequencies of the two Hopf bifurcations satisfy certain relationships. It is found that the frequency response curves of the controlled system under difference resonances are an isolated closed curve. The difference resonance response may admit two stable motions on a three-dimensional torus consisting of three frequencies. Illustrative examples are given to show the quasi-periodic motions.. Introduction Time delayed feedback control has been applied to suppress nonlinear vibrations and stabilise bifurcations of nonlinear systems with parametric (or external) excitations [-5]. In addition to the selection of control gains, effective vibration control requires an optimal selection of the appropriate values of time delays to achieve satisfactory control performance. Usually the time delays are selected to be well separated from the critical values at which the trivial solution of the corresponding autonomous system loses its stability. It is now accepted that an introduction of time delays in a nonlinear system can

induce certain dynamic behaviour such as instability, bifurcations and chaotic motions [6- ], which may be undesirable from the perspective of vibration control. For a nonlinear system having external excitation, the presence of time delays may lead to distinct behaviour that cannot be observed in the same nonlinear system without time delay. An important phenomenon is the interaction of the periodic external excitation and the stable periodic solutions that result from Hopf bifurcations of the corresponding autonomous system. In particular, for a nonlinear system losing the stability of its trivial solution through a single Hopf bifurcation, the interaction may lead to primary resonances, sub-harmonic and super-harmonic resonances in the forced response when the frequency of the Hopf bifurcation and the forcing frequency satisfy a certain relationship. More interestingly, for a nonlinear system losing the stability of its trivial solution via two Hopf bifurcations, the interaction can further result in additive resonances and difference resonances, when the forcing frequency and the frequencies of the two Hopf bifurcations satisfy certain relationships. The main purpose of the present paper is to study difference resonance response of a controlled van der Pol-Duffing oscillator subjected to a periodic excitation, which results from an interaction of the external excitation and two periodic solutions bifurcated from the trivial solution of the corresponding autonomous system at non-resonant Hopf bifurcations. An externally forced van der Pol-Duffing oscillator under a linear-plus-nonlinear feedback control considered in the present paper is of the form x x ) x x x e cos( t) px( t ) qx ( t ) k x ( t ) ( k x ( t ) k x ( t ) x ( t ) k x ( t ) x( t () 4 where x is the displacement, an overdot indicates the differentiation with respect to time t, is the natural frequency, is the coefficient of the nonlinear term, and are the linear and nonlinear damping coefficients with,, e and represent the amplitude and frequency of the external excitation, p, q and k i ( i,,, 4) are linear and

weakly nonlinear feedback gains, respectively, and denotes the time delay occurring in the feedback path. Only one time delay is considered here for simplicity. With the increase of the value of time delay, the trivial solution of the corresponding autonomous system (obtained by letting e in equation ()) was found to lose its stability via a subcritical or supercritical Hopf bifurcation and regain its stability via a reverse subcritical or supercritical Hopf bifurcation [4]. An intersection of two nonresonant Hopf bifurcations may occur on the stability boundary of the trivial solution. The point of the intersection is usually associated with the bifurcation of co-dimension two and may be a source of complicated behaviour in the context of ordinary differential equations [5,6]. It was found that the autonomous system may admit the trivial solution, two periodic solutions and a quasi-periodic solution on a two-dimensional (D) torus [7]. In the neighbourhood of non-resonant Hopf bifurcations, the presence of an external periodic excitation can further induce rich dynamic behaviour of the controlled oscillator (), which includes primary resonances, sub-harmonic and super-harmonic resonances, additive and difference resonances [8]. These phenomena are hard to identify from the original system (), as they do not relate to the so-called natural frequency (nor to its multiples). Understanding of the distinct observable behaviour in nonlinear systems involving time delays remains limited. The non-resonant response and two types of primary resonances of the controlled oscillator were studied in reference [8] and three types of additive resonances were discussed in reference [9]. Difference resonance response has not yet attracted much attention even in the context of non-linear oscillations to the authors best knowledge. Two types of difference resonance responses will be discussed in the present paper. The present paper is organised into five sections. Section presents four first-order ordinary differential equations on the centre manifold. Section lists types of resonances

that can occur in the forced response. Two types of difference resonance responses are studied in Section 4. Conclusion is given in Section 5.. Reduction of the centre manifold The dynamic behaviour of the solutions of equation () in the vicinity of non-resonant Hopf bifurcations can be interpreted by the solutions and their stability of four ordinary differential equations on the centre manifolds, which are expressed in component form as z ( l ) z lz l4 f ( z, z, z, ) e cos( lz t z ( l) z l z lz l4 f ( z, z, z, ) e cos( t), z lz l z lz ( l4 ) f ( z, z, z, ) e cos( t), z 4 l4z l4 z ( l4 ) z l44 f 4 ( z, z, z, ) e4 cos( t), () where and are the normalized frequencies of Hopf bifurcations. ( z, z, z, ) f i ( i,,,4.) are polynomial functions of order three in terms of k l m n z z z with k l m n and k, l, m, n,,,. More details on the coefficients and relevant algebraic manipulations can be found in the reference [7].. Types of resonances When two natural frequencies (or their combinations) and the forcing frequency satisfy certain relationships, the forced response of the system () may exhibit non-resonant response and a number of resonant responses. In particular, two types of primary resonances may occur when or. Two types of sub-harmonic resonances happen when or, and two types of super-harmonic resonances take place when or. For, a number of combinational resonances of additive and difference types may appear in the forced response. Specifically, additive resonances may appear when either, or, or. Difference resonances may occur when either, or, or 4

; or. Accordingly, a total of types of nonlinear responses may take place in the forced nonlinear response. Thus in studying the forced response of the nonlinear system (), six cases need to be distinguished based on six categories of resonances discussed above, which are (a) primary resonances at either frequency of two Hopf bifurcations; (b) sub-harmonic resonances at either of two Hopf bifurcation frequencies; (c) super-harmonic resonances at either of two Hopf bifurcation frequencies; (d) additive resonances; (e) difference resonances; and (f) non-resonant response when the forcing frequency is well separated from the above-mentioned resonances. 4. Difference resonances By using the method of multiple scales [], the first-order solutions to equation () can be written in a general form as z z z z cos( T ) A cos( T ) A sin( r T r sin( T ) B cos( T ) B sin( T cos( T ) A cos( T ) A4 sin( r T sin( T ) B cos( T ) B4 sin( () 4 r T where r, r,, represent the amplitudes and phases of the free-oscillation terms, and the coefficients A and B s denote the amplitudes of the particular solutions. As discussed in Section, four types of difference resonances may appear in the forced response. The present paper will study two cases of difference resonances, namely,. The other cases can be studied in a similar manner. To account for the nearness of the forcing frequency to the combination of two natural frequencies, two detuning parameters, and, are introduced in terms of, be referred to here as Cases I and II.. These two types of difference resonances will 5

Case I: The averaged equations that determine the amplitudes and phases of the response of difference resonance Case I are given by r r s r s r r s r cos( ) sr sin( r r ( ) r sr sr r sr sin( ) sr cos( r sr r sr sr r cos( ) s4r sin( (4) ( ) r s4r r s4r sr sin( ) s4r cos( where T, T, the coefficients are not reproduced here. The steady-state difference resonance response can be studied by finding the solutions to the four algebraic equations which can be obtained by letting r r and in equation (4). The frequency response equations are given by ( r sr sr ) r ( sr sr ) r ( s s ), ( r sr sr ) r ( s4r s4r ) r ( s s4). (5) Real positive solutions of equation (5) lead to the frequency-response curves. The stability of the solutions can be examined by computing the eigenvalues of the coefficient matrix of characteristic equations which are derived from equation (4) in terms of small disturbances to the steady state solutions. Case II: The averaged equations for difference resonance Case are given by r cos( ) s4r r sin( r sr sr r s4r r r r ( ) r sr sr r s4r r sin( ) s4r r cos( r sr r sr s4r r cos s( ) s44r sin( (6) ( ) r s4r r s4r s4r sin( ) s44r cos( 6

where T, T, the coefficients are not produced here. The frequency response curves can be determined by numerically solving the equations: ( r sr sr ) r ( sr sr ) r ( s4 s4 ) r, ( r 4 sr sr ) r ( s4r s4r ) r ( s4 s44 ). (7) Equation (7) admits two types of solutions which are referred to here as the single-mode solutions with r and r, and the mixed-mode solutions with r and r. As illustrative examples, consider a specific system with parameters.,., p.4, q. 49,. 4,. 5, k., k. 5,. 4 k k. The frequencies of non-resonant Hopf bifurcations were found to be. 88 and.758. Difference resonances may appear in the neighbourhood of. 88 for Case I, and. 84494 for Case II. When.,., e 4.,. 88, the frequency-response curves for difference resonance Case I are shown in Figure. Stable solutions are represented by circles and unstable solutions by crosses. The frequency response curve is an isolated closed curve in Figures (a) and (b). The difference resonance exists only in a small interval of the external detuning and does not exist outside this closed curve. The closed curve consists of two branches. The upper branch of r is stable with the four eigenvalues having negative real part. The lower branch of r is unstable with one eigenvalue having positive real part. On the contrary, the upper branch of r is unstable and the lower branch of r is stable. As increases from a small value, the amplitude r of the free-oscillation term with natural frequency grows, whereas the amplitude r of the free-oscillation term having natural frequency decreases. The amplitude r is much higher than amplitude r, which means the motion corresponding to dominates the response while the motion relating to is smaller in amplitude but not negligible. Stable 7

non-trivial solutions indicate that the forced response under difference resonances comprises both the free-oscillation terms and forced terms as given in equation (). Because two natural frequencies and are incommensurable, the system response under difference resonance Case I exhibits quasi-periodic motions. Figure shows frequency-response curves for difference resonance Case II under., 5., e. 6,. 845. The frequency response curve is an isolated closed curve. The upper branch of the curve comprises two parts; stable part and unstable part. The lower branch is stable. There exists a region of bi-stability in the closed curve. In the interval [.585,.695], two stable solutions coexist for the amplitudes r and r. Amplitude r is much higher than r, which means the motion corresponding to dominates the response. As the detuning increases along the upper branch, both amplitudes r and r increases till. 695, where the stable mixed-mode solution loses its stability with one eigenvalue being zero. The other meeting point of stable and unstable branches is at. 98, where a saddle-node bifurcation occurs with one eigenvalues being zero. Two stable solutions coexist in the region [.585,.695], where two quasiperiodic solutions appear when doing numerical simulations to equation () under different sets of initial conditions. Figure shows the phase portraits of two quasi-periodic motions at. 8694 under different sets of initial conditions. The large-amplitude quasi-periodic motion shown in Figure (a) corresponds to a mixed-mode stable solution in the upper branch shown in Figure, while the small-amplitude quasi-periodic motion shown in Figure (b) relates to a mixed-mode stable solution in the lower branch. The quasi-periodic motions shown in Figure contain three individual harmonic components:, and. These three frequencies satisfy the difference resonance condition for Case II. The numerical results are in good agreement with the analytical predictions. 8

5. Conclusion Two types of difference resonances have been studied using the method of multiple scales. Illustrative examples have been given to demonstrate the frequency-response curves and quasi-periodic motions. It was shown that the difference resonance response of the forced oscillator exhibits quasi-periodic motions on a D torus. The quasi-periodic motion consists of three components having the frequencies of two Hopf bifurcations and the frequency of the excitation, which satisfy the difference resonance conditions. The difference resonance response may lose its stability via a saddle-node bifurcation. Two stable solutions exist in the forced response of the system under difference resonances. The co-existence of two quasi-periodic motions has been validated by numerical integration using different sets of initial conditions. Acknowledgment This research is partially supported by the Centre for Intelligent Mechatronic Systems (IMS centre) at UTS. References [] Maccari, A., 8 Arbitrary amplitude periodic solutions for parametrically excited systems with time delay, Nonlinear Dynamics, vol.5, pp.-6. [] Maccari, A., 7 Delayed feedback control for a parametrically excited van der Pol oscillator, Physica Scripta, vol.76, pp.56-5. [] Chatterjee, S., 7 Time-delayed feedback control of friction-induced instability, International Journal of Non-Linear Mechanics, vol.4, pp.7-4. [4] Maccari A, 6 Vibration control for parametrically excited Lienard systems, International Journal of Non-Linear Mechanics, vol.4, pp.46-55. [5] Ji, JC, Leung, AYT., Bifurcation control of a parametrically excited Duffing system, Nonlinear Dynamics, vol.7, pp.4-47. [6] Niu, B., Wei, JJ., 8 Stability and bifurcation analysis in an amplitude equation with delayed feedback, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, vol.7, pp.6-7. 9

[7] Sah, S., Belhaq, M., 8 Effect of vertical high-frequency parametric excitation on self-excited motion in a delayed van der Pol oscillator, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, vol.7, pp.489-496. [8] Belhaq, M, Sah, SM., 8 Fast parametrically excited van der Pol oscillator with time delay state feedback, International Journal of Non-Linear Mechanics, vol.4, pp.4-. [9] EI-Bassioouny, AF, 6 Stability and oscillation of two coupled Duffing equations with time delay state feedback, Physica Scripta, vol.74, pp.76-75. [] Lazarevic, MP., 6 Finite time stability analysis of PD alpha fractional control of robotic time-delay systems, Mechanics Research Communications, vol., pp.69-79. [] Xu, J., Yu, P., 4, Delay-induced bifurcation in an nonautonomous system with delayed velocity feedbacks. International Journal of Bifurcation and Chaos, vol.4, pp.777-798. [] Maccari, A., The response of a parametrically excited van der Pol oscillator to a time delay state feedback, Nonlinear Dynamics, vol.6, pp5-9. [] Campbell, S.A., Belair, J., 999 Resonant co-dimension two bifurcation in the harmonic oscillator with delayed forcing, Canadian Applied Mathematics Quarterly, vol.7, pp.8-8. [4] Ji, J.C., Hansen, C.H., 6 Stability and dynamics of a controlled van der Pol- Duffing oscillator, Chaos, Solitons and Fractals, vol.8(), pp.555-57. [5] Guckenheimer, J., Holmes, P., Nonlinear Oscillations, Dynamical Systems, and Bifurcations of Vector Fields, Springer-verlag, New York, 98. [6] Itovich, G.R., Moiola, J.L, 5 Double Hopf bifurcation analysis using frequency domain methods, Nonlinear Dynamics, vol.9, pp.5-58. [7] Ji, J.C., 6 Nonresonant Hopf bifurcations of a controlled van der Pol-Duffing oscillator, Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol.97(-), pp.8-99. [8] Ji, J.C., Zhang, N., 8 Nonlinear response of a froced van der Pol-Duffing oscillator at non-resonant bifurcations of codimension two, Chaos, Solitons & Fractals, In press (doi:.6/j.chaos.8.6.8). [9] Ji, J.C., Zhang, N., 8 Additive resonances of a controlled van der Pol-Duffing oscillator, Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol.5, pp.-. [] Nayfeh, A.H., Mook, D.T., Nonlinear Oscillations, Wiley, New York, 979.

.8 Amplitude r.7.6.5.5.6.7 External detuning (a) the variation of amplitude r with external detuning.5 Amplitude r.48.44.5.6.7 External detuning (b) the variation of amplitude r with external detuning. Figure. The frequency-response curves for difference resonance Case I for.,., 4 e.,. 88; (a) the variation of amplitude r with external detuning, (b) the variation of amplitude r with external detuning. Stable solutions are denoted by circles while unstable solutions by crosses.

. Amplitude r.9.8.7.55.65.75.85.95 External detuning (a) the variation of amplitude r with external detuning.. Amplitude r..8.55.65.75.85.95 External detuning (b) the variation of amplitude r with external detuning. Figure. The frequency-response curves for difference resonance Case II for.,.5, e. 6,. 845, (a) the variation of amplitude r with external detuning, (b) the variation of amplitude r with external detuning. Stable solutions are denoted by circles while unstable solutions by crosses.

.5. Velocity, dx/dt.5 -.5 -. -.5 -. -.5.5. Displacement, x (a) the initial conditions for numerical integration are ( x, x ) (.,.)..5. Velocity, dx/dt.5 -.5 -. -.5 -. -.5.5. Displacement, x (b) the initial conditions for numerical integration are ( x, x ) (.4,.5). Figure. Phase portraits to illustrate the co-existence of two quasi-periodic motions for difference resonance Case II at. 8694 ; (a) the initial conditions for numerical integration are ( x, x ) (.,.), (b) the initial conditions for numerical integration are ( x, x ) (.4,.5).