Fermilab-Pub-98/33-E VECTOR BOSON PAIR PRODUCTION AND TRILINEAR GAUGE BOSON COUPLINGS - RESULTS FROM THE TEVATRON arxiv:hep-ex/986v Oct 998 H T Diehl For the CDF + DØ Collaborations Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, Batavia, IL 65 (September 25, 998) Abstract Direct measurements of vector boson pair production processes and trilinear gauge boson couplings have been conducted by the CDF and DØ Collaborations Preliminary results from searches for anomalous WW/WZ µν jet jet and W Z eeeν production are presented 95% CL anomalous coupling limits from previously published DØ results are 2 < λ < 2 ( κ = ) and 3 < κ < 43 (λ = ) for Λ = 2 GeV where the WWγ couplings are assumed to equal the W W Z couplings Combined DØ + LEP experiment anomalous coupling limits are presented for the first time 95% CL limits are 6 < λ γ < ( κ = ) and 5 < κ γ < 4 (λ = ) under the assumption that the couplings are related by the HISZ constraints 95% CL anomalous ZZγ and Zγγ coupling limits from DØ are h Z 3 < 36 (h Z 4 = ) and h Z 4 < 5 (h Z 3 = ) for Λ = 75 GeV CDF reports the first observation of a ZZ event Prospects for Run II are discussed Submitted to the Proceedings of ICHEP 98 XXIX International Conference on High Energy Physics UBC, Vancouver, BC Canada July 23-29, 998
VECTOR BOSON PAIR PRODUCTION AND TRILINEAR GAUGE BOSON COUPLINGS - RESULTS FROM THE TEVATRON H T DIEHL MS 357, Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, Batavia, IL 65, USA E-mail: DIEHL@FNALGOV Direct measurements of vector boson pair production processes and trilinear gauge boson couplings have been conducted by the CDF and DØ Collaborations Preliminary results from searches for anomalous WW/WZ µν jet jet and WZ eeeν production are presented 95% CL anomalous coupling limits from previously published DØ results are 2 < λ < 2 ( κ = ) and 3 < κ < 43 (λ = ) for Λ = 2 GeV where the WWγ couplings are assumed to equal the WWZ couplings Combined DØ + LEP experiment anomalous coupling limits are presented for the first time 95% CL limits are 6 < λ γ < ( κ = ) and 5 < κ γ < 4 (λ = ) under the assumption that the couplings are related by the HISZ constraints 95% CL anomalous ZZγ and Zγγ coupling limits from DØ are h Z 3 < 36 (hz 4 = ) and hz 4 < 5 (hz 3 = ) for Λ = 75 GeV CDF reports the first observation of a ZZ event Prospects for Run II are discussed Introduction The Standard Model of electroweak interactions makes precise predictions for the couplings between gauge bosons due to the non-abelian gauge symmetry of SU(2) L U() Y These self-interactions are described by the triple gaugeboson (trilinear) WWγ, WWZ, Zγγ, and ZZγ couplings and the quartic couplings Deviations of the couplings from the Standard Model (SM) values would indicate the presence of new physical phenomena The WWV (V = γ or Z) vertices are described by a general effective Lagrangian with two overall couplings, g WWγ = e and g WWZ = e cotθ W, and six dimensionless couplings g V, κ V, and λ V (V = γ or Z), after imposing C, P and CP invariance Electromagnetic gauge invariance requires that g γ =, which we assume throughout this paper The SM Lagrangian is obtained by setting g γ = gz =, κ V = ( κ V κ V = ) and λ V = A different set of parameters, motivated by SU(2) U()gaugeinvariance,hasbeenusedbytheLEPcollaborations 2 Thissetconsistsofthreeindependentcouplings α Bφ, α Wφ and α W : α Bφ κ γ g Z cos2 θ W, α Wφ g Z cos 2 θ W and α W λ γ The remaining WWZ coupling parameters λ Z and κ Z are determined by the relations λ Z = λ γ and κ Z = κ γ tan 2 θ W + g Z The HISZ relations 3 which have been used by the DØ and CDF collaborations are also based on this set with the additional constraint α Bφ = α Wφ The cross section with non-sm couplings grows with ŝ In order to avoid unitarity violation, the anomalous couplings are modified as form factors with a scale Λ; λ λ V (ŝ) = V (+ŝ/λ 2 ) and κ 2 V (ŝ) = κv (+ŝ/λ 2 ) 2 The ZγV (V = γ or Z) vertices are described by a general vertex function 4 with eight dimensionless couplings h V i (i =,4 ;V = γ or Z) In the SM, all of hv i s are zero The form factors for these vertices, similar to the WWV vertices, are h V i (ŝ) = h V i (+ŝ/λ 2 ), where n = 3 n for i =,3 and n = 4 for i = 2,4 Vector boson pair production provides sensitive ground for direct tests of the trilinear couplings This paper provides a description of recent results from DØ and CDF, including preliminary results from searches for anomalous couplings in WW/WZ µν jet jet and WZ eeeν final states at DØ, a description of a recently published, combined analysis, anomalous W W γ and WWZ coupling result from DØ, combined DØ + LEPanomalousWWγ andwwz couplingsresults(presented for the first time), limits on anomalous Zγγ and ZZγ couplingsfromstudies ofzγ final statesat DØ, and report of the observation of a ZZ µµµµ event at CDF in Run I Prospects for Run II are discussed 2 Preliminary Results from DØ 2 Search for anomalous WW/WZ µν jet jet Production This analysis searches for anomalous WW or WZ production using the decay signature W µν and W/Z jj We cannot distinguish between W and Z decays to jets Further, because SM WW and WZ production is swamped by backgrounds having this same signature, the analysis is sensitive only to production with anomalous couplings We selected events with an isolated, central muon with p T > 2 GeV/c and with /E T > 2 GeV where the transverse mass M T (µν) > 4 GeV/c 2, indicative of a W boson decay We required that the event contain at least two jets with E T > 2 GeV For 224 of the 372
CAL+TKS END VIEW 5-MAY-997 3:27 Run 8992 Event 232 26-MAR-995 22:54 Max ET = 56 GeV MISS ET(3)= 48 GeV ETA(MIN:-25-MAX: 25) EM ICD+MG HAD MISS ET MUON ELEC TAUS VEES OTHER Figure : DØ WW/WZ µν jet jet analysis The upper plot is the dijet invariant mass The lower plot is p T (µν) for events which pass the dijet mass selection criteria The histogram is the data The points are the background and it s uncertainty candidates which survived those selection criteria, the invariant mass of the two highest E T jets was between 5 and GeV/c 2, as expected from the hadronic decay of a W or Z boson From Monte Carlo simulation, we expected44 +54 68 WW eventsand49+ WZ events, given SM trilinear couplings Of course, if the couplings are non-sm, there will be an excess of events with highp T W bosons The background consists principally of W+ 2 jets (7±24 events expected) and multijet events with an accidentally isolated muon from a heavy quark decay (5 ± 9 events expected) Small contributions to the background arise from t t production The total expected background is 224 ± 3 events Figure shows the dijet invariant mass and p T (µν) for the data and expected background Since we observed no excess of events in the highp T (µν) region, we place upper limits on anomalous WWγ and WWZ couplings This is performed using a binned likelyhood fit of the observed p T (µν) spectrum to the expected p T (µν) spectrum, given anomalous couplings plus the expected background The -D 95% CL coupling limits are 45 < λ < 46 ( κ = ) and 62 < κ < 78 (λ = ) for Λ = 5 GeV, assuming the WWγ couplings equal the WWZ couplings While previous analyses have produced more restrictive anomalous coupling limits, these results will ultimately contribute to the DØ combined results 22 Search for WZ eeeν Events Searches for anomalous W Z production enable the possibility of constraining the W W Z couplings independant Figure 2: W Z eeeν candidate from DØ The figure shows the E T, represented by the height of the column, deposited in the central calorimeter The three largest towers are the three electrons The narrow tower shows the direction and magnitude of the missing transverse energy of the WWγ couplings DØ has searched for the process WZ eeeν Two electrons with E T > 25 GeV, one more electron with E T > GeV, and /E T > 5 GeV are required in candidate events The transverse mass of one electron and the /E T must be greater the 3 GeV/c 2 The invariant mass of the other two electrons must be between 8 and GeV/c 2 One candidate survives the selection criteria Based on SM Monte Carlo, 46±WZ events are expected The background, principally due to Z + jet events where the jet mimicks an electron and there is accidental /E T, amounts to 38±4 events Figure 2 shows the candidate s event display One pair of electrons has invariant mass of 936 GeV/c 2 ; the transverse mass of the other electron and the missing E T is 747 GeV/c 2 WZ production is more sensitive to the value of λ Z and g Z than κ Z Given one observed event and taking into account the expected background, 95% CL limits are λ < 27 ( g Z = ) and gz < 256 (λ Z = ) for Λ = GeV Although the limits are looser than some of those previously measured, they are independant of any assumptions on the relation between WWγ and W W Z couplings Ultimately, these results will help constrain g Z in DØ s combined limits 3 Combined WWγ and WWZ Anomalous Coupling Limits from DØ We have combined previously published limits on WWγ couplings obtained from a fit to the photon E T spectrum in Wγ events 5, limits on WWZ and WWγ couplings obtained from a fit to the E T of the two charged leptons in WW dilepton events 6, and limits on WWZ and 2
Coupling Λ = 5 TeV Λ = 2 TeV λ γ = λ Z ( κ γ = κ Z = ) 2, 2 2, 2 κ γ = κ Z (λ γ = λ Z = ) 33, 46 3, 43 λ γ (HISZ) ( κ γ = ) 2, 2 2, 2 κ γ (HISZ) (λ γ = ) 39, 6 37, 56 λ Z (SM WWγ) ( κ Z = g Z = ) 33, 37 3, 34 κ Z (SM WWγ) (λ Z = g Z = ) 46, 64 42, 59 g Z (SM WWγ) (λ Z = κ Z = ) 56, 86 52, 78 λ γ (SM WWZ) ( κ γ = ) 27, 25 26, 24 κ γ (SM WWZ) (λ γ = ) 63, 75 59, 72 Table : Limits at 95% CL from a simultaneous fit to the DØ Wγ, WW dilepton and WW/WZ eνjj data samples The four sets of limits apply the same assumptions as the four components (a), (b), (c) and (d), respectively, of Fig 3 The HISZ results include the additional constraint α Bφ = α Wφ WWγ couplings obtained from a fit to the p T spectrum of the electron-neutrino system in WW/WZ eνjj events 7 The results 8 are shown in Tables and 2 and in Figures 3 and 4 Coupling Λ = 5 TeV Λ = 2 TeV α Bφ (α Wφ = α W = ) 8, 6 77, 58 α Wφ (α Bφ = α W = ) 24, 46 22, 44 α W (α Bφ = α Wφ = ) 2, 2 2, 2 g Z (α Bφ = α W = ) 3, 6 29, 57 λ (a) equal couplings λ γ (b) HISZ Table 2: Limits at 95% CL on α parameters from a simultaneous fit to the DØ Wγ, WW dilepton and WW/WZ eνjj data samples 4 Combined DØ and LEP Anomalous WWγ and WWZ Couplings - - κ - - κγ The published results from DØ and the four LEP experiments (see the summary 9 by Hywel Phillips) were combined to produce the tightest available W W γ and W W Z coupling limits The procedure, documented in detail in preprint form, is to add the negative loglikelyhoods presented as a function of trilinear coupling from the several LEP analyses and the combined DØ analysis described above The one standard deviation limits are obtained directly from the curves by taking the values of the coupling where logl = +5 from the minimum The 95% CL limit is given by the values of the coupling where logl = +92 The dependencies on correlated systematic errors and on Λ are negligible Figures 5 and 6 show log-likelihoods and one σ limits on λ γ and κ γ where one coupling is varied at a time and the WWZ couplings are related to the WWγ couplings through the HISZ equations (without the extra constraint α Bφ = α Wφ ) The 95% CL limits are 6 < λ γ < ( κ = ) and 5 < κ γ < 4 (λ = ) These limits provide an update to the original analysis due to the inclusion of new LEP results λ Z - (c) SM WWγ U() - κz λ γ - (d) SM WWZ - κγ Figure 3: Contour limits on anomalous couplings from a simultaneous fit to the DØ data sets of Wγ, WW dilepton, and WW/WZ eνjj final states for Λ = 5 TeV: (a) κ κ γ = κ Z,λ λ γ = λ Z ; (b) HISZ relations; (c) SM WWγ couplings; and (d) SM WWZ couplings (a), (c), and (d) assume that g Z = The solid circles correspond to 95% CL one-degree of freedom exclusion limits The inner and outer curves are 95% CL two-degree of freedom exclusion contour and the constraint from the unitarity condition, respectively In (d), the unitarity contour is located outside of the boundary of the plot The HISZ results include the additional constraint α Bφ = α Wφ 3
α W - (a) - αbφ α W - (b) - αwφ Figure 4: Contour limits on anomalous couplings from a simultaneous fit to the DØ data sets of the Wγ, WW dilepton, and WW/WZ eνjj final states for Λ = 5 TeV: (a) α W vs α Bφ when α Wφ = ; and (b) α W vs α Wφ when α Bφ = The solid circles correspond to 95% CL one-degree of freedom exclusion limits The inner and outer curves are 95% CL two-degree of freedom exclusion contour and the constraint from the unitarity condition, respectively 5 Zγ and ZZ Production and Anomalous ZZγ and Zγγ Couplings from DØ and CDF DØ has recently published,2 studies of Zγ production using the ννγ, eeγ, and µµγ final states The two neutrino final state makes up for it s smaller integrated luminosity by having a larger branching fraction than the charged lepton mode and has the advantage that there are no photons radiating from the Z s decay products On the other hand, in the charged-lepton decay mode the backgrounds are smaller and the final state can be completely reconstructed The Zγ ννγ analysis, with a minimum photon E T of 4 GeV, yielded 4 candidates with an expected background of 58± events in an integrated luminosity of 4 pb The analysis of the charged-lepton decay mode yielded 29 candidates with an expected background of 54± events in 97 pb It is interesting that there were two events in the charged-lepton sample with an 75 GeV photon and with an l + l γ invariant mass of 2 GeV/c 2 SM Zγ production would yield two or more events with E γ T > 6 (7) GeV in 5% (73%) of repeats of the experiment Also, SM Monte Carlo indicates the most likely Zγ mass for events with E γ T in the range 7 to 79 GeV is 2 GeV/c 2 CDF noted 3 a Zγ event with E γ T 64 GeV and M(µµγ) 88 GeV/c2 in their 2 pb sample from Run Ia While there is no evidence of non-sm physics here, it is something to keep one s eye on in the future The tightest limits on anomalous ZZγ and Zγγ couplings are those from the combined 2 DØ analyses At 95% CL, the Zγγ limits are h γ 3 (hγ ) < 37 and h γ 4 (hγ 2 ) < 5 with Λ = 75 GeV The ZZγ limits are similar - lnl preliminary ALEPH 2 +28 33 DELPHI 34 +26 28 L3 6 +4 35 OPAL 9 +47 37 LEP 7 +6 6 D 8 +34 34 LEP+D 3 +4 4 3 2 - κ γ Figure 5: Limits on κ γ and the log-likelyhood curves for the LEP experiments, DØ, and the combination, assuming λ γ = λ Z = g Z = and that κ Z is determined from the HISZ relations At 95% CL, the combined limit is 5 < κ γ < 4 - lnl preliminary ALEPH 5 +5 5 DELPHI 7 +9 6 L3 +9 7 OPAL 8 +3 2 LEP 5 +8 9 D + LEP+D 3 +7 7 3 2 - -5 5 Figure 6: Limits on λ γ and log-likelyhood curves for the LEP experiments, DØ, and the combination, assuming λ γ = λ Z, and κ γ = κ Z = The limits are 68% CL At 95% CL, the combined limit is 6 < λ γ < λ γ 4
CDF ZZ-> µµµµ m(zz)~92 GeV µ 39 GeV/c µ? 42ish GeV/c RUN 75848 EVENT 34376 µ 35 GeV/c µ 58 GeV/c Figure 7: ZZ µµ event observed at CDF in Run I The E T and locations of the muons are shown 6 Prospects for the Near Future and for Run II In the immediate future, DØ will combine the two new analyses with the previous, finalizing the Run I anomalous WWγ and WWZ coupling limits Perhaps CDF will finish it s Run I Wγ and Zγ analyses soon Presently DØ and CDF are working on their detector upgrades for Run II The Main Injector will allow the Tevatron to provide 2 fb data samples to each detector at s = 2 GeV For DØ, the addition of a solenoid magnet and new tracking system will improve the muon resolution The CDF detector will have improved electron and photon acceptance in the forward direction These modifications strengthen the detectors ability to study diboson final states Limits on anomalous couplings scale by approximately the /4 root of the luminosity for fixed Λ and assuming no improvement in technique The large data samples will provide upwards of 3 Wγ lνγ events, 7 Zγ eeγ + µµγ events, WW dileptons events, some 3 WZ trileptons and a handful of ZZ e s and µ s per experiment CDF has already observed a ZZ event during Run I Figure 7 shows their ZZ µ + µ µ + µ event This is the first Z boson pair candidate recorded They expected slightly less than one such event in Run I Qualitatively, the Wγ, and perhaps, the WZ radiation zeroes will be unambiguously observed Anomalous trilinear coupling limits will begin to probe the theoretical expectations The first measurements of quadrilinear couplings will be available 7 Summary Direct measurements of vector boson pair production processes and trilinear gauge boson couplings have been conducted by the CDF and DØ Collaborations Preliminary results from searches for anomalous WW/WZ µν jet jet andwz eeeν productionfromdøwerepresented 95% CL anomalous coupling limits from previously published DØ results are 2 < λ < 2 ( κ = ) and 3 < κ < 43 (λ = ) for Λ = 2 GeV where the WWγ couplings are assumed to equal the WWZ couplings Combined DØ + LEP experiment anomalous coupling limits were presented for the first time 95% CL limits are 6 < λ γ < ( κ = ) and 5 < κ γ < 4 (λ = ) under the assumption that the couplings are related by the HISZ constraints 95% CL anomalous ZZγ and Zγγ coupling limits from DØ are h Z 3 < 36 (h Z 4 = ) and h Z 4 < 5 (h Z 3 = ) for Λ = 75 GeV CDF reports the first observation of a ZZ event Run II, with upgrades to the CDF and DØ detectors and larger integrated luminosities due primarily to the Main Injector, will provide even more tantalizing opportunities for studying gauge boson couplings References K Hagiwara, RD Peccei, D Zeppenfeld and K Hikasa, Nucl Phys B 282, 253 (987) 2 G Gounaris et al, in Physics at LEP2 edited by G Altarelli, T Sjöstrand and F Zwirner, CERN 96-, 996 (unpublished), p 525 3 K Hagiwara, S Ishihara, R Szalapski and D Zeppenfeld, Phys Rev D 48, 282 (993) 4 U Baur and EL Berger, Phys Rev D 4, 476 (99) 5 S Abachi et al, DØ Collaboration, Phys Rev Lett 78, 3634 (997) 6 B Abbott et al, DØ Collaboration, Phys Rev D 58, 5 (998) 7 B Abbott et al, DØ Collaboration, Phys Rev Lett 79, 44 (997) 8 B Abbott et al, DØ Collaboration, Phys Rev D 58, 32 (998) 9 H Phillips, these proceedings ALEPH, DELPHI, L3, OPAL, and DØ Collaborations, LEPEWWG/TGC/98- and DØ Note 3437, May 998 B Abbott et al, DØ Collaboration, Phys Rev Lett 78, 364 (997) 2 B Abbott et al, DØ Collaboration, Phys Rev D 57, 387 (998) 3 F Abe et al CDF Collaboration, Phys Rev Lett 74, 94 (995) 5