This is a repository copy of Management Accounting Change in Developing Countries: Evidence from Libya. White Rose Research Online URL for this paper: http://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk// Version: Accepted Version Article: Lasyoud, A., Haslam, J. and Roslender, R. (Accepted: ) Management Accounting Change in Developing Countries: Evidence from Libya.. ISSN - https://doi.org/0.0/ara-0--00 Reuse Items deposited in White Rose Research Online are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved unless indicated otherwise. They may be downloaded and/or printed for private study, or other acts as permitted by national copyright laws. The publisher or other rights holders may allow further reproduction and re-use of the full text version. This is indicated by the licence information on the White Rose Research Online record for the item. Takedown If you consider content in White Rose Research Online to be in breach of UK law, please notify us by emailing eprints@whiterose.ac.uk including the URL of the record and the reason for the withdrawal request. eprints@whiterose.ac.uk https://eprints.whiterose.ac.uk/
!" %&%'%&%(')%'& "%*&+(
Page of 0 0 0 0 0!!" " % "% "%& '()*+, -! (.( %/. " 0. "%. % &'(.( - )** &)***.% )*+ & )***!,:
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 & ; % - < = ) %. -. -% )** )** )**> )? )! @ ) A )) ) % = )*+B = - % -. C )**B. C!! D )!!" )** )**> A; A% )*+> @)*** A )*+ % )** )**>!.. > D. + A )) )) )% 0. -. 0-0 -.( " E =E =C= )**F)**B/( F ) F
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 ' 0 ) = C ) ' G G% =C = )**B - -! ' C!! % )*+ -..? ; )*+ )** ( GG" )*+ ) = GG", %? '(?' ). % /./ - / C ) % )) - )) The General People's Congress (GPC) of Libya was the national legislature of Muammar Gaddafi's Great Socialist People's Libyan Arab Jamahiriya governance structure. It consisted of,00 representatives of the Basic People's Congresses. The GPC was the legislative forum that interacts with the General People's Committee, whose members are secretaries of Libyan ministries. It notionally served as the intermediary between the masses and the leadership and was composed of the secretariats of some 00 local "basic popular congresses".
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 C % ' D.,. %.!. - 0!" "% &' )*+,)**) -,), 0 -,),% % C H ) I I, I )'"% ' )** )** " & )**F ). J C' )** H CC= ' )**. K
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 C )** =. -. % )**>! E.. )***!! @ ) ) = > B D. + ).)A))!, J. E.. )**> & )**,.!!)**F B), H. 0.. C C! @ ).. / C. H E )*+*!)** / )*+ % )** A )*+?(? )*+F )** )**F )) -. /%E! )***! "%.
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 &')*+,)**).- )**> )**F )**> )**>)E! C = D, = )*+B + - % - -. C )**.( - % L( @)*** 0 - & )***. )*+. % )** )F H ).., C C 0 A )*+B )* 0 -.!.! )***% A )*+B 0! A)*+B!!!C
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 = & F E) H - % - 0 + H ), F H! " " % C -.!!.. & ' () * M - 0 C " -% )**! )*** +, C M - 0 -? ) -, - C. 0.(
Page of 0 0 0 0 0. * " % - 0 % 0 )**> + 0? )%.. > ))% "% - *'+!%, "% M)*BB& ')*+, )**). -!" "% -.. > -. > -.. - % - "% -. - "% -&')*+,)**)? =)**>!! ==C= )**> )& F > "%..( -. )F>+. J% +
Page of 0 0 0 0 0.. =. =. -J "%. "% ) 0 )... ) >0. %!-&.++!%,/ Competitive or technical Isomorphism Management Accounting and Control System (MACS) Intra-organizational Power relations "%.. - )**B!!)***. Institutional Isomorphism Coercive Mimetic Normative
Page 0 of 0 0 0 0 0 / )**B - J 0. -."% )**F% "% - 0. ) = =C =C= )**B==C >. ) > % C! " "% %. - >F)/'% 0 0 0'" "% %"% &')*+,)**)% - "% ==C >D. + "%. "% ) >% ()** H J)**F = H), M! ()*B* )** 0
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 M ), M ), - )**FM ),), NO - - - - J! C% C 0!)*+F) J% ( J!)*+F C ( - - %.C 0 -. -. -)** 0.. & - C % / )A ),,;! " )B!) " H
Page of 0 0 0 0 0.! "' -! )+, )!+ " )F & C E0. E-0 C. C - C% C M *F*/ 0 0 " H.. / *F+F (%!"H.! " C.0 )***)!" *P!. %! " - '+/! '&',++! - %! )*B> % @ %@E/ % ")*+) %
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 0. + *. (C H!&>+)*B>"&B>)*+) P!( &*> " 0 ),= )***!".! " % /.%/*)H! F" B )** G"G@> )) C ))! ) - +-&.% /++ / /+ /+ ' ) ' E!. E!, / ' ' ) < ' ) ) & ) / & ', '
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 & & ) %. M C ')'+ / ) % = ) M C ( KH ) % C - % C -, F MC " %! H C - - H &' (%/% -! H C< 0 -& 'H *! * B! C J Hajj means pilgrimage and is one of the pillars of Islam, where the Muslims visit Sacred Mosque in in Makkah in Saudi Arabia once a year for worship.
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 & '/ =./! ( % <%/*) C C F C %/ %F%/<, F ' C - C FC %/ = %/ & < ( H? )) )B 0? %/! ) -- J C% %/ *)H C!% C C <.H C C.( < H... ))! =
Page of 0 0 0 0 0! - 0 & H & C C! 0 %/*) J! C ) / C!%. % %? & 0/ Q Q = / &! R R! - = that: & K %!) &?(.!. ))J )' (
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 C! %!! 0 )B )) - C ( 0 &! C - = H! J &!!.! E- C = % -BB I= % % '*'!+ /!( -H
Page of 0 0 0 0 0! " )** GG!!=& ' & H % -! J 0 ))! & % H %.!%.! 0 )B )). J " %& "' ( % - 0 - - J = - - - - - - - Q % - 0 - ) - F %! FP
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 P 0H! %?( J = ))" ", -- -! "!& /.!( % /.%/ <<! F! C < % /.. %/ %/ % %/ % E %E. )!! % %@E/ P Q! %@E/!Q! %@E/ " % /. H % %!!%%! J The Legal provisions of the Articles,,, in determining Tariffs on supplied goods No. of have described as follows: () Article : Determines Tariffs (customs tariff) for motor vehicles, trucks and trailers of various kinds at 0%; () Article : Raw materials and production requirements shall be exempted from taxes, customs Fees, and other taxes and fees; () Article : Production tax and consumption tax on locally produced goods and imported shall be reduced to (0%); and () Article : Fees of supply services shall be cancelled.
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 )% % C )B 0 )) / =/ & / 0 =& & ' Q -H 0!.. Q (, C.J ) ' 0 - Q! &? C = -H % -! (% J 0 QC?!? & 0 /! &
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 (? /? & 0/? C '0'+ / ( %" H - H &' ( " " = % "? 'Q0 F 0 0? '(0 )*+ 0 C = )**? '( C ( ))!? "?" % = & % C Q! & *0 The General People s Committee of Finance is the Ministry of Finance (currently).
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 ( ( /-H -! J % * > & & )& & % C! % "! " % =& % H CQ = J () %" C? % %. C - 0 % C ( (C ) -
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 F) = F ) 0 )) C ) / )F ) ( A ) ), ) (/ +* - Q % ) / ) ( / = - % 0 -=&?!.H * Q % J )' " /%" % " < - & C )**< < B) & % // '%, ( )**>" %/ C < %/ <%/*)H The 0 report had directed to the General People s Committee of Industry (formerly), whereas the had directed to the Audit Bureau (currently).
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 " <%/*)HB)& % / H C Q 0 C <%/*)H Q ''!+ / - "( -H " %& "' ( ( 0 & ' = B! % C = %, B %,! ' C % 0 & H - )B KC)+ %- - - % - Q J
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 ))" " -- - " " = E- & C 0 -, = 0 + K % 0 /. H " -! & J ) ) " % " BP P & 0 ")*+) " % E " % C <%/*)!! B ) )% 0 -!"% = E- & H
Page of 0 0 0 0 0!! I! % 0 )B))!?(..! J = E- &. (!!"" -" % % " 0 -, " " - " % 0 )B )) "& % H )) J ) =& % 0 0 - C %C
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 - C. 0 & % / H! J % / % 0 ' %! " -. S, % > D,,F = '&+ / ( H),F %? ) + %! - 0 H <
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 H %" 0 H H! " <%/*)H) -. +-). + ++ &! " ", * & )< * 0 & & ) & ) &< ')(( // K % - ) >% - - & ')*+,0 % - %
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 ')'&( / %. - &')**) 0.). - -. - / )**) A ),, /,,)%!" ( % ( % A ),,) / % &')*+, ) J% 0 - G" G )**E G"( C - = 0? - - =C = )**F )**B G = ) = G ((,B. / ( ')')( % % % P! % %@E/
Page of 0 0 0 0 0!" % % % C. 0!" H/( '? )**+> ))',+.. = -/ 0 & ')*+, )! " - )**> F 0 %/*)!= " ')'*( %. %.!" - - %E-. &')*+,)**) -.? )**+ )), %".. = =C -.
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 '. = =C )>, =. ()).. & ( % "!" - %? )**+ ) - H/" %" 0,, J '*,! / %! " %! %!( )**F0+0 -! & '., )*? G J )***%. %! =
Page of 0 0 0 0 0!- ) >F = =C %" = -, " C " -" % '0(%" / ' "%. - & ' )*+, % "%"% "% 0 ) "%- /..( -! ) > ). %?)*B>!.% 0 - )F>B /. /. C.F>B/ )**).. %! ".. %! %"
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 0 0. )*+.? )*++ C = )**>B% = ( / = )**>B/ )))+)/.. :' ;! "-,),% J! < " < % S % - -.. > %. (.( %/
Page of 0 0 0 0 0. -./)*+% - 0 -. ( - H!"%. % )** )** )**>! ) = -!! "% &' )*+,)**) %"% "%. "%- )==C> F "% -. "% &')*+,"%.. "% )> "% 0 % C C ()** J)**F M ), 0 ( G = )G.
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 = ')*+% = 0.....! % ( 0 0 C!! C. " )**>0 MJH% %' J M ),>*>> )**B! -H / E!JM @+)FB)>+?TT% J= H0 G %H/* )FE % H %' J& G &!'& M ) E % J ' HKKKU UU).. > %! E ' H EJ G '& "&-MD)H - JA /.@))%HFFB>; A M = )**F - H JM @)B) D)%%H GJ ' M)**F%HJ =.@+H, +,)
Page of 0 0 0 0 0!)**M H J/. )F,F),B)! ' )** M J!&!M)***' '/.H?J! A & % ' " ' M %' 'JA @),>>*>! A M. H JM ))),! A @A) J M @ ),+*F! A E.. M )*** GJ! @BB,)F!?? )*B* ' /. J = @0.E=)% MH G ( J /.@>>*> + H M "J M )*B++ % = A % )**! J M >))B ')' H00' 0 JM )FF>F+> & )**> M H /. J A M @+),> &')**F/.H' JH'' & A 0 M A? F M /. -H &%.' JVA )BF> F &'')**)"%/.JG ' ),+ &'A')*+,% MH%% M/.0J MF+)FB> &! /')**, ' G E E )*+* H MJ M)F)BBF 0&+0 ' E' /.J& G G?)*B>"MJ=? )*+F H/ J H' '? ) - J M @))F))>>? )**+%( JA M @)),)B*
Page of 0 0 0 0 0? M=M)**>G M/.H! /"%JM)F))F = E JM ),F,B*F = )**>G ' H! J! A @B,)> =?)*+B WJ/.),B,F =C= )**FM'H!AJM @, =C= )**B'% M! ".A!J!M @B") )F, = =C G "' A! H "% ' J A @)"))>)+, % A 0 )** ' H 0 EJM )),)* % A 0 )**! G( J M >),B), A' = ) E H % ' J A E@))%H,,>,F, AE'))E % M (M JM ))F A )*+ E E J /. @) ",,,,+ M! A )** /. H = E- %?%J"D H0 ' M" &)** J=!MA K0 B)B* M)*+H. EE H=!'! )*> M)*+>HJ M@TTT@")BF)** E- H! %JM @),,,,F, M)**E M H L M( JA @+")>,+B M F ' H C H J ' @) >)BB A= )**>' JA M @+),B) + % H" J/.,,,F*,>)
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 M?) @ E JM @ )*, " M )** J /.)FFBB "! )**F H. J"D H? @)** H E'E@F >,+> A M! )*BB %. /.H 0 J A +,,F,>,! )*** H JM )),B)+ % H -J E M@))"F>,B* ) E- & J! G '&G A, /. G H J 0 0? G '& A! A > % J % M H %=C & )) H " J ' @)B / -H % JE G = ;'& /( " F K ( E E J /. @ *",KF,F*,B / )**) M%' JM@)> "))FB* / )**&J/.@),>,++ / M)**BH J? ="D /& )*+ H ' J /.FF),F+ ' )** H J?= @ @ 0 M H ' /. / H*)) ' )**) E- J &'' E "%/.G ' %'')+,, < ' = ). I M @)F,F, M M), I! C.J ' F,+ F) M! M M 0 J E=//"
Page of 0 0 0 0 0 ' * M! J = EH' = M" J%MA! EXE G " ' G), M)**F" H JM @,),) M>G ' H' A J! M@,+H)), M M A )**, H JM @F), ))M")*B"D A)**> "'@ J M @B)+)*B E- C J A E M )))B) )**B M " )**J A M @*,>) 0G.HE JM @)>FF,B A!M)*+F% <M J"D A?..A> H JM @)B,+*F+ A?..A> H JM @ )B,+*F+ G= )! H. J/.@>>F,B G ' M ' % H '? E J VA @)+">F+>BF @ A )*** E- L( J M @)F*F,B @&>= J G ' " =C G E F H JVA )B>BBF " =C G E F H JVA )B>BBF &= H - J ' @ )>FB,, =&)*** ' AH E %J % A @,F %H)''F*B AAE)' H" % EJ/.@>FF,F>
Page 0 of 0 0 0 0 0 D. =,0 0 H @J ))*)), D. = & +.J ' @)*FFF, DM,M H&J, / ))' '.H %' J& & G &!'& 0