råáp=== = = ======råáîéêëáíó=çñ=pìêêéó Discussion Papers in Economics CONNECTING PEOPLE By M. Ali Choudhary (University of Surrey) DP 04/04 Department of Economics University of Surrey Guildford Surrey GU2 7XH, UK Telephone +44 (0)1483 689380 Facsimile +44 (0)1483 689548 Web www.econ.surrey.ac.uk
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
@A= JDAO O CH=@K=O IMEJ?D J = AM IAAH )I = HAIKJ B JDAIA @A=OI A=?D?KIJAH H JDAEH LKA >A?AI = =IIAJ =@?= >A ANFEJA@ JDHKCD DECDAH FHE?AI 0A?A JDA H B=?AI = JH=@A E JD=J EJ?= H=EIA FHE?AI >KJ O =J JDA ANFAIA B CH=@K=O IEC I=AI CAAH=JA@ BH EJI?KIJAHI >=IA 6DKI JDA FHE?EC FE?O D=I = CJAH EFE?=JE MA?= JDEI JDA?KIJAH=HAJ AA?J 9A EJH@K?A E JDEI @O=E? IAJKF AJMHEC?IJI =@ K?AHJ=EJO HA=JA@ J JDA?KIJAH>=IA =I = @AJAHE=J B JDA FHE?EC FE?O 9A ME IDM JD=J = DECD ALA B K?AHJ=EJO E JDA AJMH JCAJDAH MEJD?IJO =EJA=?A B?KIJAHAJMHI HA@K?A JDA E?AJELAI BH HI J ELAIJ JDAEH?KIJAHI 9A =I @ = AC=JELA HA=JEIDEF >AJMAA K?AHJ=EJO =@ L=HEKI A=IKHAI B ELAIJAJI JDA?KIJAH AJMHI 6DA BMEC IA?JE =OI KJ JDA IJHK?JKHA B JDA @A =@ 5A?JE! AN= EAI JDA AFEHE?= HA=JEIDEF >AJMAA K?AHJ=EJO =@?KIJAHAJMH?IJI 5A?JE "??K@AI @A +IE@AH = E@KIJHO MEJD = =H>EJH=HO K>AH B E@AJE?= FEIJE?=O?FAJEJELA HI 6DA HAFHAIAJ=JELA H ELAIJI?KIJAHI =@ KIAI EJI FHE?A FE?O J =EJ=E =@ ANF=@ EJI I=AI JDHKCD EJI AJMH B?KIJAHI 6DAHA =HA?IJI B?A?JEC FAFA =@ =EJ=EEC JDA AJMH =@ JDIA =HA?=FJKHA@ >O 6DA@A=@BHA=?DA>AHBAJMHEA =IECA
?KIJAH EI =IIKA@ J J=A J J=A JDA BH MDAHA @AJA @A=@ A=IJE?EJO JDA H=JE B JDA HI MFHE?A =@ JDA =LAH=CA =HAJ FHE?A BH IEE=H FH@K?JI KJFKJ =@ = IDEBJ F=H=AJAH HAIFA?JELAO 6DKI @A=@ EI DECDAH MDA JDA H EI HA?FAJEJELA E JAHI B FHE?AI HA=JELA J JDAH HI 6DEI JOFA B @A=@ ANFE?EJO HAIKJI BH = @A MDAHA?KIJAHI?@K?J = IAGKAJE=IA=H?D BH JDA?DA=FAIJ FH@K?J MEJD = KEBH @EIJHE>KJE B IA=H?D?IJI =?HII >KOAHI IAA +=HI =@?)BAA '&! 6DKI JJ= I=AI =HA JDA CELA >O 5MDAJDAIEABJDA?KIJAHAJMH EI I= I =HA JDA I=AI LAHJEA JDA IK??AII B =?KIJAHAJMH @AFA@I HA=JELA FHE?AI >KJ JDAHA =HA KFHA@E?J=>EEJEAI I JD=J CHMJD E JDA HI?KIJAHAJMH?=>A MHEJJA =I = CAAJHE? *HME= JE F MDAHA EI = 9EAAH FH?AII F IE?A EJ EI H=O@EIJHE>KJA@ H=@ L=HE=>A MEJD A= AH IJ=@=H@ @ALE=JE B KEJO 6DA BK?JE =IIKAI JD=J CHMJD E JDA AJMH EI = BK?JE B JDA FHE?A IAJ >O JDA H =@JDA=LAH=CA FHE?A AIAMDAHA E JDA E@KIJHO 6DA JAH?=FJKHAI JDA HA=JELA EFHJ=?A B K?AHJ=EJO E JDA CHMJD B JDA AJMH 6DA BK?JEI =@ =HA JDA I=A AN?AFJ JD=J JDA =JJAH D=I = FIEJELA?IJ=J =@@A@ 6DEI AIKHAI JD=J JDA H B=?AI K?AHJ=EJO =J = JEAI )IIKEC JD=J JDA BK?JE JDA =HCE=?D=CA E?KIJAHAJMH IEA MDA JDA HA=JELA FHE?A @EAHI EI MDAHA @AJAHEAI EFE?EJO JDA IJHACJD B @A=OI E?KIJAH
LAAJI >AJMAA IAAHI H AJMHI MDE?D =HA?=KIA@ >O JDA JAFH=HO?EC B?KIJAHI E?JH=?JI 7IEC 1JI A= JDA?KIJAHAJMH *HME= JE =@ -G JDA HAFHAIAJ=JELA HI FHJ =NEE=JE?= >A @AI?HE>A@ >O JDA BMEC *A = AGK=JE @AJAI JDA L=KA B JDA H EI HA= EJAHAIJ H=JA =@ JDA?LAN BK?JE =HA JDA ELAIJAJI JDA H =AI =EJ=EEC?KIJAHAJMH 6DA EJKEJE BH =?LAN?KIJAHAJMH?IJI IJHK?JKHA EI JD=J =I JDA?KIJAH >=IA ANF=@I I @?KIJAH JOFAI JDAEH AA@I =@ JDA F=?=CAI JDAO HAGKEHA 6DAIA JCAJDAH?= @HELA KF JDA?IJI B IKIJ=EEC = =HCA?KIJAH AJMH 6DA HIJ JDHAA JAHI JDA HECDJD=@IE@A HAFHAIAJ JDA EA@E=JA FHJ BH KEJI B JDA?KIJAHAJMH MDAHA=I JDA HA=EEC JM JAHI HAFHAIAJ JDA L=KA B = E?HA=IA E JDA?KIJAH AJMH.H IEFE?EJO EJ EI =IIKA@ JD=J =HCE=?IJI B FH@K?JE =HA?IJ=J 6DA HIJH@AH?@EJE BH EI! )J JDA AGKEE>HEK MDAHA JDA A?AII=HO?@EJE?= >A ANFHAIIA@ =I = FHE?EC AGK=JE "
6DA HIJ JAH JDA HECDJD=@IE@A EI JDA JANJ> FO =HKF =IIKEC JD=J A=IJE?EJO AN?AA@I KEJO 6DA IA?@ JAH EI JDA ELAIJAJ JD=J JDA H =AI E JAHI B MAH FHE?AI MDA EJ =??KJI BH JDA EJAHJAFH= =IFA?J B EJI AJMH 6DA JDEH@ JAH?=FJKHAI JDA AA?J B K?AHJ=EJO JDA EJAHJAFH= =IFA?J B JDA?KIJAHAJMH 5K>IJEJKJEC JDA HIJH@AH?@EJE E =@ =IIKEC JDA AGKEE>HEK? @EJE JD=J CELAI JDA BMEC AGK=JE # )IIKEC = IEFA?LAN?IJ BK?JE BH?KIJAHAJMH?IJI -G# D=I JDA IKJE $ 6DA?KIJAHAJMHEIHAL=K=>A=JJDA=HCEMDAJDA=HCE=?IJI B FH@K?JE @A=@ =@ K?AHJ=EJO @KA J JDA FJE L=KA IAA,ENEJ =@ 2E@OA? ''" =HA DECD >KJ EI AII L=K=>A MDA JDA?KIJAHAJMH?IJI =HA DECD 9A KIA -GI $ =@ " J >J=E = ANFE?EJ IKJE BH JDA FHE?A % 6DA HIJ JAH JDA HECDJ D=@ IE@A EI JDA JANJ> FO =HKF 6DA IA?@ JAH?=FJKHAI JDA ELAIJAJ JDA H =AI E JDA BH B MAH FHE?AI MDA EJ J=AI E J =??KJ JDA EJAHJAFH= L=KA B EJI?KIJAHAJMH
6DEI =HEIAI BH JDA =HAJ BHE?JEI MDE?D CAAH=JA JDA?KIJAHAJMH @O=E?I 6DKI JDA H I=?HE?AI IA B EJI?KHHAJ FHJI E B=LH B AAFEC EJI?KIJAH AJMH 6DA JDEH@ JAH DMALAH IDMI JD=J K?AHJ=EJO HA@K?AI JDEI EJAHJAFH= L=KA E JD=J JDA EIJ=J=AKI AA?J FHE?AI JD=J HAIKJI BH = @O=E? AJMH EI HA@K?A@ 5EE=HO JDEI JDEH@ JAH =I IDMI JD=J DECD?KIJAHAJMH?IJI?= =I IDHJ?EH?KEJ JDA EFHJ=?A B =EJ=EEC BKJKHA AJMHI )JCAJDAH JDAIA?=?=KIA HI J ELAIJ I=AH =KJI E JDA BH B DECDAH FHE?AI JDAEH?KIJAH >=IA ) FHBK@ EFE?=JE B JDAIA HAIKJ EI JD=J AJMHKFHA@E?J=>EEJO =@?KIJAHAJMH?IJI IBJA =@?= ALA HALAHIA JDA?KIJAH=HAJ AA?JI 6DA BMEC IA?JE FHAIAJI AFEHE?= ALE@A?A?KIJAH ELAIJAJI =@ K?AHJ=EJO! -FEHE?= 6AIJEC 9A KIA JDA AIJE=JA@ =LAH=CA ALA B =HKFI =@ = FHNO BH?KIJAH AJMH?IJI =I A=IKHAI B ELAIJAJI?KIJAHI 9A JAIJ BH JDA HA= JEIDEF >AJMAA =HKFI =@?KIJAHAJMH?IJI =@ K?AHJ=EJO EFEA@ >O -G%.MEC 0=I F=FAHI '&$ =@ 0=IA AJ = ''# JDA =LAH=CA =HKFI =HA AIJE=JA@ KIEC = JMIJ=CA NA@AA?J @A %"& &' MDAHA =HA JDA CHMJDI E KJFKJ =@ =>H FAH KEJ B?=FEJ= JDA =HKF =?JK= =>H DKHI =>H ID=HA B?=FEJ= E JDA FH@K?JE HAIFA?JELAO 6DA JAH EI JDA 5M HAIE@K= =@ J?JH BH EJI L=HE=JE LAHJEA MA D=LA E?K@A@ JM @KO L=HE=>AI LAH JDA FAHE@I B
Markup 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 Log(markup)= -0.95 + 0.55 Log(Uncert) (2.75) r = 0.74 % Customer Costs in Total Costs 30 25 20 Log(customer costs)= 4.2-0.49 Log(Uncert) (-3.30) r = -0.83 0.5 4 6 8 10 12 14 Uncertainty (a) 15 4 6 8 10 12 14 Uncertainty (b).eckha '%"'& =@ '&'' 6DA =HKFI =HA AIJE=JA@ BH AECDJ *HEJEID E@KIJHEAI LAH JDA FAHE@ B '$&'' KIEC @=J= BH 7I +AIKIB2H@K?JE=@ -FOAJ /=AJJA 9A FHNO BH?KIJAH AJMH?IJI >O?A?JEC @=J= LAHJDAI=AFAHE@E@KIJHE= IAHLE?AI?IJI =@?IJI B FAH=JELAI BH 7I )K= =KB=?JKHAHI 5KHLAO 7?AHJ=EJO EI FHNEA@ >O JDA IJ=@=H@ @ALE=JE B I=AI >AJMAA BH JDIA E@KIJHEAI LAH '$&''.ECI = =@ > FJI JDA L=HEKI HA=JEIDEFI EFEA@ >O -G% MEJD JDAEH?HHA=JE?A?EAJI *JD =HA IJ=JEIJE?=O IECE?=J ALA JDKCD MA D=LA O & E@KIJHEAI 6DAIA HAIKJI IKCCAIJ JD=J JDA A D=@ E@KIJHEAI MEJD
DECDAH K?AHJ=EJO JA@ J?D=HCA DECDAH =HKFI DA?A MAH ELAIJAJ JDAEH?KIJAH >=IA JDA JDAH D=@ E@KIJHEAI MEJD DECDAH K?AHJ=EJO =FFA=H J IFA@ AII?KIJAHAJMHEC 6DKI >JD?D=AI B ELAIJAJ?KIJAHI =HA AC=JELAO?HHA=JA@ MEJD K?AHJ=EJO.ECI = =@ > =I EFO JD=J E@KIJHEAI JD=J ELAIJ AII?KIJAHAJMHEC =I?D=HCA JDA DECDAIJ =HKFI =@ =HA JDKI AII AA >KE@EC JDAEH AJMHI " +?KIE 9A D=LA @AHELA@ = @O=E? FHE?EC @A MEJD?KIJAHAJMHI?IJI =@ H=@AII E JDA?KIJAH AJMHI KH @A FHA@E?JI JD=J MEJD DECDAH K?AHJ=EJO =@?KIJAHAJMH?IJI HI =HA AII AA ELAIJEC JDAEH?KIJAHAJMH J =EJ=E =@ >KE@ JDAEH BKJKHA FHJ=>EEJO 9A BK@ IJ=JEIJE?=O IECE?=J HA=JEIDEFI >AJMAA =HKFI =@?KIJAHI?IJI =@ K?AHJ=EJO 7@=J= )?DMA@CAAJI 9A MEID J JD= 1= 5= BH FHLE@EC @=J= JDA E@KIJHEAI =@ EA HI=C /O AC= 8=I? /=>HEA =@ 2=K ALEA BH?AJI 4ABAHA?AI *EI '&% 6DA +O?E?= *AD=LEH B JDA =HCE= +IJ =@ 2HE?A )AHE?= -?E? 4ALEAM %% &!&&#% +=HI D ) =@ 2AJAHI?)BAA '&!,EI?HAJA -GKEE>HEK FHE?A,EI FAHIE KH= B 2EJE?= -?O '! "&"'!
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