Experimental generalized contextuality with single-photon qubits: supplementary material XIANG ZHAN 1, ERIC G. CAVALCANTI 2, JIAN LI 1, ZHIHAO BIAN 1, YONGSHENG ZHANG 3,4*, HOWARD M. WISEMAN 2,5,, AND PENG XUE 1,6, 1 Department of Physics, Southeast University, Nanjing 211189, China 2 Centre for Quantum Dynamics, Griffith University, Gold Coast, QLD 4222, Australia 3 Key Laboratory of Quantum Information, University of Science and Technology of China, CAS, Hefei 230026, China 4 Synergetic Innovation Center of Quantum Information and Quantum Physics, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei 230026, China 5 Centre for Quantum Computation and Communication Technology Australian Research Council), Griffith University, Brisbane 4111, Australia 6 State Key Laboratory of Precision Spectroscopy, East China Normal University, Shanghai 200062, China * Corresponding author: yshzhang@ustc.edu.cn Corresponding author: h.wiseman@griffith.edu.au Corresponding author: gnep.eux@gmail.com Published 9 August 2017 This document provides supplementary information to "Experimental generalized contextuality with single-photon qubits," https://doi.org/10.1364/optica.4.000966. We provide the details of the experiment and data analysis. The raw probabilities to demonstrate the joint measurability of positive operator-valued measures POVMs) are also provided. 2017 Optical Society of America https://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.5219884 1. IMPLEMENTATION OF THE ELEMENTS OF THE JOINT POVM G Each element of the POVM can be written as Gɛε ij ξ ij = λ ɛε ɛε ξ ij, with ɛ, ε {+1, 1}, i = j {1, 2, 3}, ɛε and ξ+ ξ + ξ++ ξ ξ+ 13 = λ ++ = λ = 2 η2 ) 4 3η + i 2 + 3η η 2 2 + 3η + η 2 3η + i 2 η η 2 2 η + η 2 2 3η + η 2 ξ + 13 = 3η + i 2 + 3η + η 2 ξ++ 13 = 2 + η + η 2, λ + = λ + = 2 + η2 ), S1) 4 / 8 12η + 8η 2 6η 3 + 2η 4, / 8 + 12η + 8η 2 + 6η 3 + 2η 4, / 8 4η 8η 2 + 2η 3 + 2η 4, / 8 + 4η 8η 2 2η 3 + 2η 4, / 8 12η + 8η 2 6η 3 + 2η 4, / 8 + 12η + 8η 2 + 6η 3 + 2η 4, / 8 4η 8η 2 + 2η 3 + 2η 4,
Supplementary Material 2 ξ 13 = 3η + i 2 η + η 2 / 8 + 4η 8η 2 2η 3 + 2η 4, 12η i 4 8η ξ+ 23 = 2 + η 4 / 22 + η 2 ), 2 + η 2 ξ + 23 = 12η i / 22 + η 2 ), 2 + η 2 ξ++ 23 = i 4 4η 4η 2 + 2η 3 + η 4 / 2 2 + η 2 ), 4 + 4η 4η 2 2η 3 + η 4 ξ 23 = i 4 + 4η 4η 2 2η 3 + η 4 / 2 2 + η 2 ), 4 4η 4η 2 + 2η 3 + η 4 Each element can be implemented by a single-qubit rotation followed by a two-outcome measurement. In the first step, to realize the element + the single-qubit rotation is designed as U + = 0 φ + + 1 φ +, φ ξ ij + = +. S2) The POVM element {P+ 0, P1 + } takes the form P+ 0 = 0 0 + 1 χ + ) 1 1, P+ 1 = χ + 1 1, χ + = λ +. S3) The choice of φ + guarantees if P 1 + clicks the initial state is projected onto the eigenstate ξ ij + and let the component of the state ξ ij + which is orthogonal to ξ ij + all pass through for the next measurement. Therefore the state after the first rotation is U + φ 0 φ 0 U + for any input φ 0. The first detector P+ 1 ) clicks with the probability TrP1 + U + φ 0 φ 0 U + ) = λ + ξ ij ξ ij + φ 0 φ 0 + = Tr + φ 0 φ 0 ). Thus we implement the element of POVM +. The other state without click is P 0 + U + φ 0 = ξ ij + φ 0 0 + 1 χ + ξ ij + φ 0 1. S4) In the second step, to implement the element +, the single-qubit rotation is designed as U + = 0 φ + + 1 φ +, S5) where φ 1 + = ξ ij N + ξij + 0 + 1 χ + ξ ij ) + ξij + 1 S6) + with the normalization factor N +. Compared Eqs. S5) and S7), one can see that we only replace φ 0 in Eq. S5) by ξ ij + in Eq. S7). The second POVM element takes the form {P + 0, P1 + }, where P 0 + = 0 0 + 1 χ + ) 1 1, P 1 + = χ + 1 1, χ + = λ +N 2 + 1 λ +. S7) The parameter χ + is chosen such that after the projector is performed, the probability of the click of P + 1 is that of the measurement + performing on the initial state φ 0. The state after the second qubit rotation is U + P+ 0 U + φ 0 φ 0 U + U +. The second detector P + 1 ) clicks with the probability TrP1 + U +P+ 0 U + φ 0 φ 0 U + U + ) = λ + ξ ij ξ ij + φ 0 φ 0 + = TrG + φ 0 φ 0 ). Thus we implement the element +. The other state without click is P 0 + U + φ 0 P + 0 U + = φ + 0 ξ ij + φ 0 + 1 χ + φ + 1 ξ ij ) + φ 0 0 + 1 χ + φ + 0 ξ ij + φ 0 + 1 χ + φ + 1 ξ ij ) + φ 0 1. S8)
Supplementary Material 3 In the third step, to implement ++ the single-qubit rotation is designed as U ++ = 0 φ ++ + 1 φ ++, S9) where φ 1 [ φ ++ = N + 0 ξ ij + ξij ++ + 1 χ + φ + 1 ξ ij + ξij ++ ) 0 S10) ++ + 1 χ + φ + 0 ξ ij + ξij ++ + 1 χ + φ + 1 ξ ij + ξij ++ ) 1 with the normalization factor N ++. Comparing Eqs. S9) and S11), one can find that we replace φ 0 in Eq. S9) by ξ ij ++ in Eq. S11). The third POVM element takes the form {P++ 0, P1 ++ }, where P 0 ++ = 0 0, P 1 ++ = 1 1. With this setup when the input state is ξ ij ++ the detector P++ 1 ) never clicks. Thus the measurement corresponding to click of P1 ++ is proportional to ξ ij ++ ξ ij ++. We now prove the measurement we implement is exactly ++. Assume the POVM elements corresponding to clicks of P++ 1 ξ and P0 ++ are x ij ++ ξ ij ++ and y ψ ψ. Due to the fact that we have ξ ij realized λ + + ξ ij ξ ij + and λ + + ξ ij +, we have x ξ ij ++ ξ ij ξ ij ++ + y ψ ψ = 1 λ + + ξ ij ξ ij + λ + + ξ ij + ξ ij = λ ++ ++ ξ ij ξ ij ++ λ ξ ij ] S11) S12) Tracing both sides of Eq. S12) leads to x + y = λ ++ + λ, S13) and ξ ij ++ x ξ ij ++ ξ ij ) ξ ij ++ + y ψ ψ ++ = ξ ij ++ ξ ij λ ++ ++ ξ ij ξ ij ++ λ ξ ij ) ξ ij ++ S14) leads to y = λ S15) Then we also have x = λ ++ S16) Thus the POVM element corresponding to the click of P++ 1 is Gij ++ = λ ++ ξ ij ++ ξ ij ++. The POVM element corresponding to the click of P++ 0 is Gij = λ ξ ij ξ ij. 2. THE MEASUREMENT STAGE OF REALIZING JOINT POVMS In the measurement stage, the single-qubit rotations can be realized by a combination of quarter-wave plates QWPs) and half-wave plates HWPs), so-called a sandwich-type QWP-HWP-QWP set, with certain setting angles depending on the parameters of the joint positive operator-valued measure POVM). The setting angles of the wave plates WPs) used to realize the corresponding elements of joint POVMs are shown in Table S1. We employ partially polarizing beam splitters PPBSs) with specific transmission probabilities for vertical polarization T V and same transmission probability for horizontal polarization T H = 1. This allows us to implement the measurement V on the reflected port of the PPBSs. In the basis { H, V}, the single-qubit rotations realized by HWP and QWP are R HWP θ H ) = cos 2θ H sin 2θ H, sin 2θ H cos 2θ H R QWP θ Q ) = cos2 θ Q + i sin 2 θ Q 1 i) sin θ Q cos θ Q, 1 i) sin θ Q cos θ Q sin 2 θ Q + i cos 2 θ Q respectively, where θ H and θ Q are the angles between the optic axes of HWP and QWP and horizontal direction. S17)
Supplementary Material 4 Table S1. The setting angles of WPs and the transmission probabilities for vertical polarization T 12) V of the two PPBSs for realization of joint POVMs. θ Q1 /θ Q2 θ H1 θ Q3 /θ Q4 θ H2 θ Q5 /θ Q6 θ H3 TV 1 TV 2 G 12 7.3 32.9 1.4 29.5 22.4 69.2 0.390445) 0.289750) G 23 21.7 60.2 4.9 36.5 21.7 60.2 0.390445) 0.289750) G 13 7.3 47.5 1.4 32.2 112.4 110.8 0.390445) 0.289750) 3. RELATIVE DETECTION EFFICIENCIES OF DETECTORS After applying joint POVM on the single-photon qubit, the photons are detected by single-photon avalanche photodiodes APDs) on the reflected ports of the two PPBSs, and both reflected and transmitted ports of PBS, in coincidence with the trigger photons. The relative detection efficiencies of the detectors D1-D4 are measured and used to correct the coincidence counts. To measure the relative efficiencies of the different detectors D1, D2, D3 and D4, we make a reasonable assumption that the total number of photons is fixed. We tune the setting angles of WPs to change the photon distribution. That is, for each time after we tune the setting angles of WPs, the normalized number of photons at each output port with respect to the total number of photons is changed, which can be read at the corresponding detector. The readout photon counts at each detector equal to the number of photons at each output port multiplied by the relative efficiency of the corresponding detector. After we tune the setting angles of WPs for four times, we have four linear equations with four variables relative efficiencies of detectors) and then solve them to obtain the relative efficiencies of the detectors D1, D2, D3, and D4. In our experiment, the relative efficiencies of the detectors D1, D2, D3, and D4 are 1, 0.9499 ± 0.0070, 0.9199 ± 0.0069 and 0.9801 ± 0.0063 respectively calculated from the experimental data. Thus we can use the relative efficiencies of the detectors to correct the photon counts in the measurement stage. For example, after the correction the photon counts at D2 which are used to calculate the probability of the photons being measured at D2 should be the readout photon counts divided by the relative efficiency of D2 0.9499 ± 0.0070. 4. JOINT MEASURABILITY OF POVMS. We test the joint measurability of the constructed joint POVM. For different qubit states, we analyze the experimental results of the joint POVM and test whether the marginal condition Xji) = E ij) X is satisfied. Without loss of generality, we choose the four ij) states H, V, R = H + i V)/ 2, and D = H + V)/ 2 as states being measured. The results are shown in Table S2. The measured probabilities Tr Xj ρ) are in agreement with the theoretical predictions of the probabilities TrE X i i ρ) of the POVM element EX i i on the state ρ { H H, V V, R R, D D }, which proves the marginal condition is satisfied. Thus the constructed joint POVM shows the joint measurability.
Supplementary Material 5 Table S2. Experimental results of Xj on the four different single-qubit states compared to the theoretical predictions of the probabilities of E i X i on these states. H V R D G 12 ++ + G12 + 0.835713) 0.160713) 0.499021) 0.495820) G 13 ++ + G13 + 0.835313) 0.169913) 0.500322) 0.502921) E+ 1 Theory) 0.8350 0.1650 0.5000 0.5000 G 12 + + G12 0.164213) 0.839313) 0.500921) 0.504220) G 13 + + G13 0.164713) 0.830113) 0.499722) 0.497121) E 1 Theory) 0.1650 0.8350 0.5000 0.5000 G 12 ++ + G12 + 0.315520) 0.674719) 0.501322) 0.781817) G 23 ++ + G23 + 0.317919) 0.674819) 0.500121) 0.778816) E+ 2 Theory) 0.3325 0.6675 0.5000 0.7901 G 12 + + G12 0.684520) 0.325319) 0.498722) 0.218217) G 23 + + G23 0.682119) 0.325219) 0.499921) 0.221216) E 2 Theory) 0.6675 0.3325 0.5000 0.2099 G 13 ++ + G13 + 0.345421) 0.665219) 0.500822) 0.208316) G 23 ++ + G23 + 0.344820) 0.651921) 0.502022) 0.210217) E+ 3 Theory) 0.3325 0.6675 0.5000 0.2099 G 13 + + G13 0.654621) 0.334819) 0.499222) 0.791716) G 23 + + G23 0.655120) 0.348121) 0.498022) 0.789817) E 3 Theory) 0.6675 0.3325 0.5000 0.7901