CHARACTERISTICS OF WAVE PROPAGATION ON THE SOFT GROUND WITH NON-FLAT BASE -FROM THE VIEW POINT OF RAILWAY VEHICLE DYNAMIC BEHAVIOR-

Similar documents
Effect of Dynamic Interaction between Train Vehicle and Structure on Seismic Response of Structure

Examining the Adequacy of the Spectral Intensity Index for Running Safety Assessment of Railway Vehicles during Earthquakes

Special edition paper Development of Shinkansen Earthquake Impact Assessment System

Methods for Running Stability Prediction and their Sensitivity to Wheel/Rail Contact Geometry

ON SEISMIC MOTION NEAR ACTIVE FAULTS BASED ON SEISMIC RECORDS

Analysis of Local Vibration for High-Speed Railway Bridge Based on Finite Element Method

Derailment of High Speed Trains Moving over Bridges under Earthquakes

Fatigue Crack Analysis on the Bracket of Sanding Nozzle of CRH5 EMU Bogie

Research on Threshold Value of Seismic Urgent Handling System of High-speed Handling Railway System Train of

SURFACE WAVE MODELLING USING SEISMIC GROUND RESPONSE ANALYSIS

D scattering of obliquely incident Rayleigh waves by a saturated alluvial valley in a layered half-space

Effect of Liquefaction on Displacement Spectra

Earthquake response analysis of rock-fall models by discontinuous deformation analysis

Preparing for Major Earthquakes

AMPLIFICATION OF GROUND STRAIN IN IRREGULAR SURFACE LAYERS DURING STRONG GROUND MOTION

Practical Use of the Earthquake Early Warning (EEW) System for Shinkansen

Title. Author(s)T. MIZUTANI; Y. NARAZAKI; Y. FUJINO. Issue Date Doc URL. Type. Note. File Information

Experimental Study of Seismic Soil-Structure Interaction by using Large Geotechnical Centrifuge System

Derailment Safety Evaluation by Analytic Equations. Summary

A Basic Study on Wheel Flange Climbing using Model Wheelset

A STUDY ON EARTHQUAKE RESPONSES OF ACTUAL ROCK-FILL DAM AND NUMERICAL ANALYSES

Vibration analysis of concrete bridges during a train pass-by using various models

Vibration Characteristics of the Platform in highspeed Railway Elevated Station

University of Bristol - Explore Bristol Research. Publisher's PDF, also known as Version of record

RESPONSE ANALYSIS STUDY OF A BASE-ISOLATED BUILDING BASED

interaction and ground borne vibration Excitation mechanisms of train/track Structural Mechanics, Department of Civil Engineering, KU Leuven

Seismic Response Analysis of Structure Supported by Piles Subjected to Very Large Earthquake Based on 3D-FEM

RELATIONSHIP OF SEISMIC RESPONSES AND STRENGTH INDEXES OF GROUND MOTIONS FOR NPP STRUCTURES

RESPONSE SPECTRUM METHOD FOR EVALUATING NONLINEAR AMPLIFICATION OF SURFACE STRATA

REAL-TIME HYBRID EXPERIMENTAL SIMULATION SYSTEM USING COUPLED CONTROL OF SHAKE TABLE AND HYDRAULIC ACTUATOR

Effects of Surface Geology on Seismic Motion

Study on elevated light rail induced vibration attenuation along the surrounding ground

Seismic properties of surface layers in Shimizu by microtremor observations

ANALYSIS OF GROUND MOTION AMPLIFICATION OF SEDIMENTARY BASINS: STUDY ON THE HEAVILY DAMAGED BELT ZONE DURING 1995 KOBE EARTHQUAKE

Diagnosis of Overhead Contact Line based on Contact Force. Takahiro FUKUTANI Current Collection Laboratory, Power Supply Division

Field Investigation and Dynamic Analysis of Damaged Structure on Pile Foundation during the 2011 off the Pacific Coast of Tohoku Earthquake

Numerical Modelling of Dynamic Earth Force Transmission to Underground Structures

Blank line 10 pt Keywords: Response Characteristics, Skyscraper, Tohoku-Oki earthquake, Natural operiod

SOIL-STRUCTURE INTERACTION, WAVE PASSAGE EFFECTS AND ASSYMETRY IN NONLINEAR SOIL RESPONSE

Role of hysteretic damping in the earthquake response of ground

Train Localization by Mutual Correction of Acceleration and Interior Sound

VORONOI APPLIED ELEMENT METHOD FOR STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS: THEORY AND APPLICATION FOR LINEAR AND NON-LINEAR MATERIALS

Topographic effects on the seismic responses of slopes

DYNAMIC CENTRIFUGE TEST OF PILE FOUNDATION STRUCTURE PART ONE : BEHAVIOR OF FREE GROUND DURING EXTREME EARTHQUAKE CONDITIONS

5.5 Exercises for This Chapter Two-Axle Vehicle on Cosine Track Two-Axle Vehicle on Generally Periodic Track...

DYNAMIC CENTRIFUGE TEST OF PILE FOUNDATION STRUCTURE PART TWO : BEHAVIOR OF STRUCTURE AND GROUND DURING EXTREME EARTHQUAKE CONDITIONS

Frequency-Dependent Amplification of Unsaturated Surface Soil Layer

STUDY ON APPLICABILITY OF SEMI-ACTIVE VARIABLE DAMPING CONTROL ON BRIDGE STRUCTURES UNDER THE LARGE EARTHQUAKE MOTION

Phase Spectrum Modeling to Simulate Design Earthquake Motion

DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF PILES IN SAND BASED ON SOIL-PILE INTERACTION

Model tests and FE-modelling of dynamic soil-structure interaction

Part 2 - Engineering Characterization of Earthquakes and Seismic Hazard. Earthquake Environment

on the safety of high-speed trains running on bridges during earthquakes Qing ZENG Elias G. DIMITRAKOPOULOS

Analysis of Vibration Model and Dynamic Characteristics of the Integrated Bridge and Building Structure System for High-speed Train

Synopses of Master Papers Bulletin of IISEE, 47, 73-78, 2013

Y. Shioi 1, Y. Hashizume 2 and H. Fukada 3

Special edition paper

ESTIMATION OF INPUT SEISMIC ENERGY BY MEANS OF A NEW DEFINITION OF STRONG MOTION DURATION

Modelling of Train Induced Vibration

Railway induced ground vibration

Investigation of long period amplifications in the Greater Bangkok basin by microtremor observations

PILE FOUNDATION RESPONSE DUE TO SOIL LATERAL SPREADING DURING HYOGO-KEN NANBU EARTHQUAKE

Safety Margin Ratio-Based Design of Isolation Gap Size for Base-isolated Structures

SHAKING TABLE TESTS ON SEISMIC RESPONSE REDUCTION EFFECTS OF ROCKING BUILDING STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS

7 SEISMIC LOADS. 7.1 Estimation of Seismic Loads. 7.2 Calculation of Seismic Loads

Journal of Sound and Vibration

on the figure. Someone has suggested that, in terms of the degrees of freedom x1 and M. Note that if you think the given 1.2

Software Verification

Dynamic analysis of a reinforced concrete shear wall with strain rate effect. Synopsis. Introduction

THE REPRODUCTION ANALYSIS OF ARATOZAWA DAM DURING 2008 EARTHQUAKE

Evaluating the effects of near-field earthquakes on the behavior of moment resisting frames

A THEORETICAL MODEL FOR SITE COEFFICIENTS IN BUILDING CODE PROVISIONS

Dynamic behaviour of a steel plate girder railroad bridge with rail joints

SAFETY EVALUATION OF SEISMICALLY ISOLATED HOUSES WITH DISPLACEMENT RESTRAINT DEVICES UNDER SEVERE EARTHQUAKE MOTIONS

Topography on Earthquake Motions in Sedimentary Basins

New Prediction Formula of Fourier Spectra Based on Separation Method of Source, Path, and Site Effects Applied to the Observed Data in Japan

PACIFIC EARTHQUAKE ENGINEERING RESEARCH CENTER

4 Associate Professor, DPRI, Kyoto University, Uji, Japan

FREQUENCY DEPENDENT EQUIVALENT-LINEARIZED TECHNIQUE FOR FEM RESPONSE ANALYSIS OF GROUND

Introduction to structural dynamics

6 th International Conference on Earthquake Geotechnical Engineering 1-4 November 2015 Christchurch, New Zealand

Preliminary Examination in Dynamics

Seismic Analyses of Concrete Gravity Dam with 3D Full Dam Model

Long-period Ground Motion Characteristics of the Osaka Sedimentary Basin during the 2011 Great Tohoku Earthquake

BRB and viscous damper hybrid vibration mitigation structural system: seismic performance analysis method and case studies

2005. Reduction of train-induced vibrations by using a trench in a layered half-space

EFFECTS OF GROUND WATER ON SEISMIC RESPONSES OF BASIN

IZMIT BAY BRIDGE SOUTH APPROACH VIADUCT: SEISMIC DESIGN NEXT TO THE NORTH ANATOLIAN FAULT

1 Introduction. Abstract

Pseudo-dynamic tests in centrifugal field for structure-foundation-soil systems

INELASTIC RESPONSES OF LONG BRIDGES TO ASYNCHRONOUS SEISMIC INPUTS

A STUDY ON THE BLASTING VIBRATION CONTROL OF CREEP MASS HIGH SLOPE

2C09 Design for seismic and climate changes

Earthquake Loads According to IBC IBC Safety Concept

Application of Capacity Spectrum Method to timber houses considering shear deformation of horizontal frames

Experimental validation of numerical modelling of the bridge track moving train system

The Running Behaviour of an Elastic Wheelset

Pushover Seismic Analysis of Bridge Structures

Synthetic Earthquake Ground Motions for the Design of Long Structures

Prediction of Contact Wire Wear in High-speed Railways

Transcription:

October 2-7, 28, Beijing, China CHARACTERISTICS OF WAVE PROPAGATION ON THE SOFT GROUND WITH NON-FLAT BASE -FROM THE VIEW POINT OF RAILWAY VEHICLE DYNAMIC BEHAVIOR- T. Kawanishi, Y. Murono 2, T. Miyamoto 3, and M. Sogabe 4 Researcher, Structure Technology Division, Railway Technical Research Institute, Tokyo, Japan 2 Senior Researcher, Structure Technology Division, Railway Technical Research Institute, Tokyo, Japan 3 Laboratory Head, Railway Dynamics Division, Railway Technical Research Institute, Tokyo, Japan 4 Senior Researcher, Railway Dynamics Division, Railway Technical Research Institute, Tokyo, Japan Email: kawa@rtri.or.jp, murono@rtri.or.jp, takefumi@rtri.or.jp, sogabe@rtri.or.jp ABSTRACT : In order to check the running safety of trains on structures, it is essential to take into account the characteristics of input earthquake motions. On the soft ground with a non-flat base, waves generate in a base slant area and propagate in the horizontal direction. The behavior of railway vehicle, therefore, is affected by the horizontally propagating waves. In this paper, we clarify the effects of these characteristics of wave propagations on the railway vehicle dynamic behavior. By the simulations, the following two characteristics were obtained: ) the smaller shear wave velocity of soft surface layer becomes, the more cautions are necessary to secure the running safety of trains; 2) The running safety of vehicle running with high speed on the soft ground with a non-flat base is influenced by the amplification of the earthquake ground motion due to the basin effects rather than the difference of displacements between two adjacent piers. KEYWORDS: Soft ground with non-flat base, horizontally propagating wave, vehicle dynamics behavior. INTRODUCTION In seismic design for railway structures, it is necessary to secure the running safety of trains on structures. In order to check the effect of input earthquake motions on railway vehicles dynamic behaviors, shaking table tests using a full-scale carbody and numerical simulations have been conducted, and the results are effectively reflected in Japanese seismic design code [Railway Technical Research Institute, 27]. These investigations have been conducted on the assumption that all railway viaducts are constructed on the horizontally layered ground. On the soft ground with a non-flat base, however, waves would be generated in a base slant area and propagate in the horizontal direction [Murono and Tanamura, 2][Ishii and Ellis, 97]. In order to discuss the running safety of vehicle on viaducts, therefore, it is important to clarify the effects of the horizontally propagating waves on the behavior of vehicle. In this study, we investigated how these characteristics of wave propagations affect the railway vehicles dynamics behaviors by numerical simulations. We first grasped the characteristics of seismic ground behavior in the out-of-plane direction on the soft ground with a non-flat base by using 2D dynamic FEM analyses. Next we calculated seismic deformations of railway viaducts constructed on the soft ground with non-flat base. After that, we clarified how the horizontally propagating waves disturb the running safety of trains by calculating the folding angle, which is defined as the angle formed between neighboring slabs of viaduct due to the difference of displacements between two adjacent piers. Finally, we investigated the dynamics behavior of vehicles running on the railway structures on the soft ground with a non-flat base by using VehicleDynamicsSimulator,whichisthe program developed by one of the authors.

October 2-7, 28, Beijing, China 2. DYNAMIC FEM ANALYSIS OF SOFT GROUND WITH NON-FLAT BASE 2.. Analytical Method To investigate how characteristics of wave propagation on the soft ground with a non-flat base have an effect on the behavior of vehicle, we conducted two-dimensional (2D) dynamic FEM analyses in the out-of-plane direction with simple ground models as shown in Fig.. We constructed models of soft ground with a non-flat base by altering the following two parameters: the inclination of bedrock, and the shear wave velocity of soft surface layer. The viscous boundary is assumed at the bottom of the ground model, and the isodisplacement boundary conditions are used on both sides of the model. The properties of the ground model are listed in Table. We conducted the non-linear analysis using the input ground motion as shown in Fig. 2, which is the Level- earthquake motion in Japanese seismic design code for railway structures. Running direction m x=(m) + Bedrock Surface soft layer Inclination of bedrock S wave velovity Vs Figure Ground model 2m 6m Table Properties of ground model 2-2.2. Characteristic of wave propagation -2 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Time(sec) Figure 2 Input motion Figure 3 shows the acceleration responses obtained by 2D FEM analysis for Case. We see that different waves arrive at each point on the soft ground with a non-flat base. This characteristic occurs because of ground irregularities. Next Fig. 4 shows snapshots of the acceleration for Case. We see that a wave generated in the base slant area propagates in the horizontal direction. These characteristics of wave propagation, which is termed as basin effects, causes the time lag of responses between two structures. To examine the running safety of trains, therefore, it is essential to take into account the basin effects. Finally in Fig. 5, the maximum accelerations on the ground surface for Case, Case 2 and Case 3 are compared. Around

October 2-7, 28, Beijing, China the edge of the basin, the maximum accelerations become larger than those at the places remote from the edge of the basin due to horizontally propagating waves. Then the smaller shear wave velocity of soft surface layer becomes, the more remarkable this characteristic becomes. On the other hand, the inclination of bedrock does not much affect on the variation of the maximum acceleration. According to the analysis in the out-of-plane direction of several studies, it has been shown that Love wave predominates as a horizontally propagating wave [Akiyama, 993]. In Fig. 6, the phase velocities of Love waves on the horizontally layered ground for Case and Case 3 obtained by the method proposed by Haskell are compared [Haskell, 953]. The smaller shear wave velocity of soft surface becomes, the smaller velocity of Love wave becomes. As the velocity of the horizontally propagating wave is related to the time delay of the responses of railway structures, it is important that we take into account the influence of the horizontally propagating waves on railway vehicle dynamic behavior to examine the running safety of trains on railway structures. x=(m) Bedrock Surface soft layer 2 x=-(m) -2 2 3 4 5 6 2 x=2(m) -2 2 3 4 5 6 2 x=6(m) -2 2 3 4 5 6 2 x=3(m) -2 2 3 4 5 6 Time(sec) 2 t=32.5(sec) t=32.6(sec) t=32.7(sec) t=32.8(sec) t=32.9(sec) Figure 3 Acceleration response obtained by Figure 4 Snapshots of acceleration for Case 2D-FEM analysis for Case Maximum acceleration(gal) 3 Case =3 =3Vs=(m/s) =9Vs=(m/s) Case2 =9 Vs=(m/s) =3Vs=2(m/s) Case3 =3 Vs=2(m/s) 2-2 2 4 x(m) Phase velocity(m/s) 5 4 3 2 Case Vs=(m/s) (Vs=(m/s)) Case 3 (Vs=2(m/s)) 2 3 4 5 Frequency(Hz) Figure 5 Influence of each parameter on Figure 6 Phase Velocity of Love wave the maximum acceleration

October 2-7, 28, Beijing, China 3. INFLUENCE OF BASIN EFFECTS ON RESPONSE OF STRUCTURE 3.. Calculation of response of railway viaduct To examine the influences of basin effects on the responses of railway viaducts, we calculate the responses of one-degree-of-freedom piers based on the following conditions. () Piers are constructed at intervals of 2 meters on the soft ground with a non-flat base. (2) The natural periods of all piers are.8 (sec) (3) All piers are elastic, and their damping factors are.5. Figure 7 shows the acceleration responses of piers for Case. We see that the response of each pier is quite different from each other due to the basin effects. Bedrock 6 x=-(m) x=(m) -6 2 3 4 5 6 6 x=2(m) -6 2 3 4 5 6 6 x=6(m) Figure 7 Surface soft layer -6 2 3 4 5 6 6 x=3(m) -6 2 3 4 5 6 Time(sec) Acceleration responses of piers 3.2. Influence of basin effects on folding angle of railway viaduct In Japanese seismic design code for railway structures, the maximum folding angle, which is defined by Eqn.3., is used to check the running safety of trains. y 2 ( t) y ( t) y3 ( t) y2 ( t) (3.) S S2 where y ( t), y ( t), y ( t) express the displacement responses of piers, and 2 3 S and S, the spans between 2 adjacent piers as shown in Fig. 8. In this section, in order to clarify the effect of each parameter of the soft ground with a non-flat base on the running safety of trains, the maximum folding angles of railway viaducts are calculated based on the conditions shown in section 3... In Fig. 9, the maximum folding angles for Case, Case 2 and Case 3 are compared. First, the larger the inclination of bedrock becomes, the larger the maximum folding angle becomes also larger around the base slant area. For Case and Case 2, then, the maximum folding angle is much larger than those for Case 3. We can say, therefore, that the more caution is necessary in examining the running safety of trains on railway viaducts if the surface layer is relatively soft. max

October 2-7, 28, Beijing, China Pier No. y (t) Pier No.2 Pier No.3 y 2 (t) y 3 (t) Figure 8 S S 2 Calculation of folding angle of railway viaduct [ -3 ] 5 Maximum folding angle 4 3 2 Case =3 Vs=(m/s) =3Vs=(m/s) Case2 =9Vs=(m/s) =9 Vs=(m/s) Case3 =3Vs=2(m/s) =3 Vs=2(m/s) -2 2 4 x(m) Figure 9 Influence of each parameter on the maximum folding angle 4. INFLUENCE OF BASIN EFFECTS ON RAILWAY VEHICLE DYNAMIC BEHAVIOR 4.. Analytical Method One of the authors has developed a simulation program, which is termed as VDS: Vehicle Dynamics Simulator, that investigates the dynamic behavior of railway vehicles during earthquake [Miyamoto et al, 24]. In this study, we examine the influences of the basin effects on dynamic behavior of vehicle running on the soft ground with a non-flat base by using VDS. 4.. Simulation model Figure shows a model of Shinkansen vehicle, which has a carbody, a truck and two wheelsets. Each model is connected with springs and dampers, and the number of degrees of the freedom of the whole model is 58. 4..2 Input vibration model Figure shows a model to input the vibration of railway viaducts into the wheel. We assume the spring and damper to support rail which correspond to those of a slab track. In this study, we take into account the input motions only at the right angles to rail. 4..3 Evaluation of safety limit We use the relative displacement between a wheel and a rail as the indicator of the safety limit of running

October 2-7, 28, Beijing, China vehicle. We judge that the vehicle derails in the case where the relative displacement exceeds 7 (mm) as shown in Fig. 2. In this study, we increase the amplitude of the input motion gradually, and investigate the running safety of trains by calculating RSL Power, which is the power of the input motion in the case where the relative displacement reaches 7 (mm). Carbody Carbody 2nd Sus. Prim. Sus. (a) Front view Figure Truck Wheelset Rear truck Truck flame (b) Side view Simulation model of railway vehicle Front truck Vertical displacement Initial position +7mm Wheel Tread -7mm Lateral displacement Rail Figure Vibration input model Figure 2 Evaluation of safety limit 4.2. Influence of response of railway viaduct on vehicle dynamic behavior In this study, we investigate how the responses of railway viaduct affect the vehicle dynamic behavior by the following methods (shown in Fig. 3): (Type (a)) Vibration at the point of X is inputted at all points uniformly. (Type (b)) Vibration at each point is inputted separately by interpolating displacements at points between two piers. Then we assume that the railway vehicle runs at speeds of 3 (km). Figure 4 shows the RSL Power for Type (a). The horizontal axis expresses the point X where the input vibration is obtained. For Case and Case 2, the value of RSL Power around the edge of the base slant area is smaller than that in the other area. This means that the earthquake ground motion obtained in the area has a severe effect on the running safety of trains. Next, for Case 3, the value of RSL Power is larger than that for Case and Case 2. We can say, therefore, that the smaller the shear wave velocity of soft surface layer becomes, the more cautions should be taken in checking the running safety of railway vehicle, especially around the base slant area.

October 2-7, 28, Beijing, China 3(km/h) 3(km/h) Interpolation of vibration Joint area x Joint area Beam Vibration at the point of X is inputted at all points uniformly Vibration at each point is inputted separately Acc (gal) 6 x=6(m) X= -6 2 3 4 5 6 X Bedrock Surface soft layer Bedrock Surface soft layer Type (a) Figure 3 Method of numerical simulation Type (b) On the other hand, for Type (b), we calculated the heights of the maximum wheel lift by changing the passage timing of the railway vehicle. Figure 5 shows the results. The horizontal axis shows the occurrence point of the maximum wheel lift. We see that the occurrence point of the maximum wheel lift is far from the base slant area, where the maximum folding angle is relatively large as shown in Fig. 9. Comparing the results for Case with those for Case 3, we can know that the wheel of vehicle can be lifted more as the surface layer becomes softer. Then comparison between the results for Case and those for Case 2 shows that the inclination of bedrock has not so much effect on the heights of the maximum wheel lift. Finally, for the case that the largest height of the maximum wheel lift is obtained for Type (b), the RSL Power is about 2.55. This value is larger than that at the point on horizontally layered ground with surface soft layer for Type (a). This result indicates that the running safety of vehicle running with high speed on the soft ground with a non-flat base is influenced by the amplification of the earthquake ground motion due to the basin effects rather than the difference of displacements between two adjacent piers. Figure 4 Running safety limits(rsl) power according to Figure 5 Maximum wheel lift at various input wave at each point on a structure passage timing 5. CONCLUSION In this paper, we first investigated the characteristics of wave propagation on the soft ground with a non-flat base by 2D FEM dynamic analysis. Next we checked the effects of these characteristics of wave propagation on the railway vehicles dynamics behaviors by the numerical simulations. The results are as follows: ) By the influence of the horizontally propagating waves generated in the base slant area, different waves

October 2-7, 28, Beijing, China arrive at each point on the soft ground with a non-flat base. The horizontally propagating waves also affect the response of the railway viaduct. 2) The smaller the shear wave velocity of the soft surface layer becomes, the larger the variation of responses of railway viaducts becomes, and the larger the time delay of the responses between two piers becomes. It is necessary, therefore, to check carefully the running safety of trains on railway viaducts if the surface layer is relatively soft. 3) The running safety of vehicle running with high speed on the soft ground with a non-flat base is influenced by the amplification of the earthquake ground motion due to the basin effects rather than the difference of displacements between two adjacent piers. REFERENCES Akiyama, S. (993). Relation Between Love Wave and Scattering Wave Generated in a Dipping Layer due to Incident Plane SH Wave, Journal of the Japan Society of Civil Engineers, No.459, I-22, 29-38(in Japanese). Haskell, N. A. (953). The Dispersion of Surface Waves on Multilayered Media, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, Vol.43, No.2, 7-34. Ishii, H. and R. M. Ellis (97). Multiple Reflection of Plane SH Waves by a Dipping Layer, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America, Vol.6, No., 5-28. Miyamoto, T., Matsumoto, N., Sogabe, M., Shimomura, T., Nishiyama, Y. and Matsuo, M. (24). Railway Vehicle Dynamic Behavior against Large-Amplitude Track Vibration A Full-scale Experiment and Numerical Simulation, Quarterly Report of RTRI, Vol.45, No.3, -5. Murono, Y. and Tanamura, S. (2). Nonlinear Earthquake Response of Soft Ground with Non-Flat Base, Quarterly Report of RTRI, Vol.42, No.3, 5-55. Railway Technical Research Institute (27). Design Standards for Railway Structures and Commentary (Displacement Limits).