PENALTY FUNCTIONS FOR THE MULTIOBJECTIVE OPTIMIZATION PROBLEM

Similar documents
= y and Normed Linear Spaces

φ (x,y,z) in the direction of a is given by

Fairing of Parametric Quintic Splines

Iterative Algorithm for a Split Equilibrium Problem and Fixed Problem for Finite Asymptotically Nonexpansive Mappings in Hilbert Space

ON THE CONVERGENCE THEOREMS OF THE McSHANE INTEGRAL FOR RIESZ-SPACES-VALUED FUNCTIONS DEFINED ON REAL LINE

University of Pavia, Pavia, Italy. North Andover MA 01845, USA

The Linear Probability Density Function of Continuous Random Variables in the Real Number Field and Its Existence Proof

such that for 1 From the definition of the k-fibonacci numbers, the firsts of them are presented in Table 1. Table 1: First k-fibonacci numbers F 1

SOME REMARKS ON HORIZONTAL, SLANT, PARABOLIC AND POLYNOMIAL ASYMPTOTE

( m is the length of columns of A ) spanned by the columns of A : . Select those columns of B that contain a pivot; say those are Bi

An Unconstrained Q - G Programming Problem and its Application

. The set of these sums. be a partition of [ ab, ]. Consider the sum f( x) f( x 1)

Professor Wei Zhu. 1. Sampling from the Normal Population

Strong Convergence of Weighted Averaged Approximants of Asymptotically Nonexpansive Mappings in Banach Spaces without Uniform Convexity

14. MRAC for MIMO Systems with Unstructured Uncertainties We consider affine-in-control MIMO systems in the form, x Ax B u f x t

On EPr Bimatrices II. ON EP BIMATRICES A1 A Hence x. is said to be EP if it satisfies the condition ABx

χ be any function of X and Y then

Minimum Hyper-Wiener Index of Molecular Graph and Some Results on Szeged Related Index

ON THE STRUCTURE OF THE EULER MAPPING

RECAPITULATION & CONDITIONAL PROBABILITY. Number of favourable events n E Total number of elementary events n S

Abstract. 1. Introduction

FIBONACCI-LIKE SEQUENCE ASSOCIATED WITH K-PELL, K-PELL-LUCAS AND MODIFIED K-PELL SEQUENCES

Harmonic Curvatures in Lorentzian Space

Exponential Generating Functions - J. T. Butler

XII. Addition of many identical spins

Inequalities for Dual Orlicz Mixed Quermassintegrals.

Assignment 7/MATH 247/Winter, 2010 Due: Friday, March 19. Powers of a square matrix

are positive, and the pair A, B is controllable. The uncertainty in is introduced to model control failures.

A Remark on the Uniform Convergence of Some Sequences of Functions

The Mathematical Appendix

An Expanded Method to Robustly Practically. Output Tracking Control. for Uncertain Nonlinear Systems

Non-uniform Turán-type problems

SUBSEQUENCE CHARACTERIZAT ION OF UNIFORM STATISTICAL CONVERGENCE OF DOUBLE SEQUENCE

A comparative study between ridit and modified ridit analysis

Unique Common Fixed Point of Sequences of Mappings in G-Metric Space M. Akram *, Nosheen

Complete Convergence and Some Maximal Inequalities for Weighted Sums of Random Variables

THE PUBLISHING HOUSE PROCEEDINGS OF THE ROMANIAN ACADEMY, Series A, OF THE ROMANIAN ACADEMY Volume 9, Number 3/2008, pp

By the end of this section you will be able to prove the Chinese Remainder Theorem apply this theorem to solve simultaneous linear congruences

Lecture 3 : Concentration and Correlation

THE PROBABILISTIC STABILITY FOR THE GAMMA FUNCTIONAL EQUATION

A Penalty Function Algorithm with Objective Parameters and Constraint Penalty Parameter for Multi-Objective Programming

Research Article A New Iterative Method for Common Fixed Points of a Finite Family of Nonexpansive Mappings

FIXED POINT AND HYERS-ULAM-RASSIAS STABILITY OF A QUADRATIC FUNCTIONAL EQUATION IN BANACH SPACES

A MODIFIED REGULARIZED NEWTON METHOD FOR UNCONSTRAINED NONCONVEX OPTIMIZATION

Minimizing spherical aberrations Exploiting the existence of conjugate points in spherical lenses

Council for Innovative Research

FULLY RIGHT PURE GROUP RINGS (Gelanggang Kumpulan Tulen Kanan Penuh)

Record Values from Size-Biased Pareto Distribution and a Characterization

Trace of Positive Integer Power of Adjacency Matrix

Generalizations and analogues of the Nesbitt s inequality

EVALUATION OF SUMS INVOLVING GAUSSIAN q-binomial COEFFICIENTS WITH RATIONAL WEIGHT FUNCTIONS

Conditional Convergence of Infinite Products

PARAMETRIC STUDY ON PARETO, NASH MIN- MAX DIFFERENTIAL GAME

GREEN S FUNCTION FOR HEAT CONDUCTION PROBLEMS IN A MULTI-LAYERED HOLLOW CYLINDER

CHAPTER 5 : SERIES. 5.2 The Sum of a Series Sum of Power of n Positive Integers Sum of Series of Partial Fraction Difference Method

A nonsmooth Levenberg-Marquardt method for generalized complementarity problem

Part 4b Asymptotic Results for MRR2 using PRESS. Recall that the PRESS statistic is a special type of cross validation procedure (see Allen (1971))

( ) = ( ) ( ) Chapter 13 Asymptotic Theory and Stochastic Regressors. Stochastic regressors model

= lim. (x 1 x 2... x n ) 1 n. = log. x i. = M, n

Extend the Borel-Cantelli Lemma to Sequences of. Non-Independent Random Variables

Recent Advances in Computers, Communications, Applied Social Science and Mathematics

SOME ARITHMETIC PROPERTIES OF OVERPARTITION K -TUPLES

Optimality Criteria for a Class of Multi-Objective Nonlinear Integer Programs

DANIEL YAQUBI, MADJID MIRZAVAZIRI AND YASIN SAEEDNEZHAD

On Signed Product Cordial Labeling

Fourth Order Four-Stage Diagonally Implicit Runge-Kutta Method for Linear Ordinary Differential Equations ABSTRACT INTRODUCTION

LECTURE 8: Topics in Chaos Ricker Equation. Period doubling bifurcation. Period doubling cascade. A Quadratic Equation Ricker Equation 1.0. x x 4 0.

Johns Hopkins University Department of Biostatistics Math Review for Introductory Courses

MATH 247/Winter Notes on the adjoint and on normal operators.

8 Baire Category Theorem and Uniform Boundedness

Johns Hopkins University Department of Biostatistics Math Review for Introductory Courses

Some Integrals Pertaining Biorthogonal Polynomials and Certain Product of Special Functions

X ε ) = 0, or equivalently, lim

Almost Sure Convergence of Pair-wise NQD Random Sequence

VECTOR MECHANICS FOR ENGINEERS: Vector Mechanics for Engineers: Dynamics. In the current chapter, you will study the motion of systems of particles.

RANDOM SYSTEMS WITH COMPLETE CONNECTIONS AND THE GAUSS PROBLEM FOR THE REGULAR CONTINUED FRACTIONS

Objectives. Learning Outcome. 7.1 Centre of Gravity (C.G.) 7. Statics. Determine the C.G of a lamina (Experimental method)

Consider two masses m 1 at x = x 1 and m 2 at x 2.

Generalization of the Dissimilarity Measure of Fuzzy Sets

Q-analogue of a Linear Transformation Preserving Log-concavity

Second Geometric-Arithmetic Index and General Sum Connectivity Index of Molecule Graphs with Special Structure

The Exponentiated Lomax Distribution: Different Estimation Methods

Chapter 5 Properties of a Random Sample

Arithmetic Mean and Geometric Mean

Chapter Linear Regression

Lower Bounds for Cover-Free Families

Numerical Simulations of the Complex Modied Korteweg-de Vries Equation. Thiab R. Taha. The University of Georgia. Abstract

Counting Functions and Subsets

Fractional Integrals Involving Generalized Polynomials And Multivariable Function

Question 1. Typical Cellular System. Some geometry TELE4353. About cellular system. About cellular system (2)

Mean Cordial Labeling of Certain Graphs

Lecture 10: Condensed matter systems

A GENERAL CLASS OF ESTIMATORS UNDER MULTI PHASE SAMPLING

Set of square-integrable function 2 L : function space F

On ARMA(1,q) models with bounded and periodically correlated solutions

PROJECTION PROBLEM FOR REGULAR POLYGONS

CENTRAL INDEX BASED SOME COMPARATIVE GROWTH ANALYSIS OF COMPOSITE ENTIRE FUNCTIONS FROM THE VIEW POINT OF L -ORDER. Tanmay Biswas

Pattern Avoiding Partitions, Sequence A and the Kernel Method

INTRODUCTION. consider the statements : I there exists x X. f x, such that. II there exists y Y. such that g y

Mu Sequences/Series Solutions National Convention 2014

Transcription:

Joual o Mathematcal Sceces: Advaces ad Applcatos Volume 6 Numbe 00 Pages 77-9 PENALTY FUNCTIONS FOR THE MULTIOBJECTIVE OPTIMIZATION PROBLEM DAU XUAN LUONG ad TRAN VAN AN Depatmet o Natual Sceces Quag Nh Teache Tag College Quag Nh Vetam e-mal: dauualuog@gmal.com Depatmet o Mathematcs Vh Uvest 8 Le Dua Vh Ct Vetam Abstact I ths pape we appl the pealt ucto method to the multobjectve optmzato poblem ode to tasom a costaed poblem eeed to as the ogal poblem to a sequece o smple costaed o ucostaed poblems eeed to as the pealzed poblems. We show that a cluste pot o a sequece o wea ecet solutos o the pealzed poblems s a wea ecet soluto o the ogal poblem. Moeove ude ceta assumptos o the easble ego D ad the objectve ucto we ca show that eve pealzed poblem has a wea ecet soluto ad that a sequece o wea ecet solutos o the pealzed poblems alwas has at least oe cluste pot.. Itoducto The pealt ucto method s ote emploed to tasom a costaed poblem to a sequece o smple costaed (o eve 00 Mathematcs Subject Classcato: 90C9 90C5 65K05 65K0. Kewods ad phases: multobjectve optmzato olea optmzato pealt ucto wea ecet soluto. Receved Septembe 5 00 00 Scetc Advaces Publshes

78 DAU XUAN LUONG ad TRAN VAN AN ucostaed poblems so that a sequece o solutos o the smple costaed poblems coveges to a soluto o the costaed poblem. Thee have bee etesve studes o how to appl the pealt ucto method to the olea optmzato poblem (see o stace [3 4 0 4]. The pealt ucto method has bee also emploed to solve the multobjectve optmzato poblem (see [5 6 9 3]. I [9] the wea ecet solutos o the multobjectve optmzato poblem MOP( D wee studed togethe wth the epoetal pealt uctos. It was show [9] that s a cluste pot o a sequece o wea ecet solutos o the pealzed poblems ad s easble (.e. D the s a wea ecet soluto o the ogal poblem. The easblt o was assumed [9]. We ae hee usg the eteo pealt ucto ad ae able to show the ollowg: ( s a cluste pot o a sequece o wea ecet solutos o the pealzed poblems the s easble; ( such a pot s a wea ecet soluto o the ogal poblem; (3 ude ceta assumptos mposed o the objectve ucto eve pealzed poblem has a wea ecet soluto ad eve sequece o such wea ecet solutos has a cluste pot whch tu s a wea ecet soluto o the ogal poblem. The pape s ogazed as ollows. Necessa detos otatos ad some bass esults o the multobjectve optmzato poblem ae gve Secto. Secto 3 pesets ou ma esults. The pape s cocluded Secto 4.. Pelmaes T Fo ( R ad ( R we adopt the ollowg covetos: T < < </ :. Let deote the Eucldea om o amel

PENALTY FUNCTIONS FOR THE MULTIOBJECTIVE 79. The e poduct o ad s deed as. T R Let R { ( : 0 }. Let D be a oempt subset o R. We heceoth assume that D s closed ad cove. We cosde the ollowg D-costaed multobjectve optmzato poblem MOP( D : m ( ( ( ( D eeed to as the easble ego o MOP(. whee : R R ae abta uctos o R. D s D I D the s called a easble pot o MOP( D. I D R the MOP( D s called a ucostaed multobjectve optmzato poblem. Deto.. The pot D s called a wea ecet soluto o MOP( D thee does ot est D satsg ( < (. Thus D s a wea ecet soluto o MOP( D ad ol o all D thee ests some de such that ( (. Suppose that F : R R s a mappg whose age s a set o eal matces. The D-costaed vecto vaatoal equalt poblem s deed as ollows: VVIP( D F : Fd D such that F( ( </ 0 D.

80 DAU XUAN LUONG ad TRAN VAN AN I D R the VVIP( D F s called a ucostaed vecto vaatoal equalt poblem. Let F : R R be the compoet uctos o F.e. F ( s the -th ow o the mat F (. The T F( ( ( F ( F (. Theeoe D D s a soluto o VVIP( D F ad ol o all T ( F ( F ( </ 0 o othe wods thee ests some de such that F ( 0. The ollowg theoem establshes the elatoshp betwee the wea ecet solutos o a multobjectve optmzato poblem ad the solutos o the coespodg vecto vaato equalt poblem ude the assumpto o the covet ad deetablt o the objectve ucto. Theoem. ([]. Let be cove ad deetable.e. each compoet o s cove ad deetable. The s a wea ecet soluto o MOP( D ad ol s a soluto o VVIP( D whee s the total devatve o. The ollowg esults o the estece o solutos o a multobjectve optmzato poblem ae useul o us late. Theoem.3 ([8]. Let be cove ad deetable. Futhemoe suppose that D s ubouded ad thee ests a D such that lm D ( a > 0. The MOP( D has a wea ecet soluto.

PENALTY FUNCTIONS FOR THE MULTIOBJECTIVE 8 Deto.4 ([]. The ucto F : R R s sad to be mootoe o R each o ts compoets s mootoe.e. ( F ( 0 o all. Theoem.5 ([]. Let F : R R be a cotuous ad mootoe ucto o R. Assume that ( D s bouded o ( F s wea coecve o D amel thee ests a vecto vecto a D such that F s R ad a T lm s F( a. D The VVIP( D F has a soluto. Combg Theoems..3 ad.5 we deduce the ollowg sucet codto o the solvablt o a multobjectve optmzato poblem. Coolla.6. Let be cove ad deetable. Assume that oe o the ollowg holds: ( D s bouded ( D s ubouded ad thee ests a vecto a D such that s R ad a vecto lm s D ( a (3 D s ubouded ad thee ests a vecto a D such that lm D ( a > 0. The MOP( D has a wea ecet soluto.

8 DAU XUAN LUONG ad TRAN VAN AN Poo. Due to the covet o t ollows that s cotuous ad mootoe (see o stace Coolla 5.5. []. Let R F : R be the mappg wth compoets. The F s cotuous ad mootoe. I D s bouded b Theoem.5 VVIP( D F has a soluto. Usg Theoem. we deduce that s also a wea ecet soluto o MOP( D. Suppose that D s ubouded. I the secod popet holds the F s wea coecve o D. Theeoe b Theoem.5 VVIP( D F has a soluto. Hece aga b Theoem. s a wea ecet soluto o MOP( D. I the thd popet holds the b Theoem.3 MOP( D has a wea ecet soluto. 3. The Multobjectve Optmzato Poblem ad the Pealt Fuctos Fstl we dee ad stud the pealzed poblems. 3.. The pealzed poblems Deto 3.. Let D be a oempt subset o R. A ucto P : R R s called a pealt ucto o D t satses P( 0 P( > 0 D D. (3. I ths pape we assume that P s chose so that t s ot ol cove but also deetable. Fo stace D s deed as D { R : g ( 0 j m} (3. j whee g j : R R j m ae cotuous uctos we ca tae m P( [ ma { 0 g ( }]. (3.3 j j

PENALTY FUNCTIONS FOR THE MULTIOBJECTIVE 83 It s staghtowad to ve that P deed as above ot ol s cove ad deetable o R but also satses (3.. Note that t s wellow that P s cove the o eve ad R. P( P( P( Now a set K D. Fo t > 0 we dee the ollowg pealzed poblem ( ( MOP : m K K whee tp. The ego K ca well be R ad such a case the pealzed poblem has o costat. Net we stud the estece o solutos o the pealzed poblem ( MOP K. Lemma 3.. Let : R R be cove ad deetable. Futhemoe assume that oe o the ollowg codtos holds: ( K s bouded ( K s ubouded ad thee ests a vecto a D such that s R ad a vecto lm s K ( a (3 K s ubouded ad thee ests a D such that lm K ( a > 0. The ( MOP K has a wea ecet soluto. Poo. It s clea that each tp s cove ad deetable. I K s bouded the b Coolla.6 ( MOP K has a wea ecet soluto.

84 DAU XUAN LUONG ad TRAN VAN AN Suppose that the secod codto s satsed. We have s ( t ( a s ( a t s P( a s s ( a t( P( P( a ( a as K. The secod equalt s due to the act that P ( 0 ad P ( a 0 as a D. Theeoe Coolla.6 mples that ( MOP K has a wea ecet soluto. Suppose that the thd codto s satsed. Fo each we have ( a ( a t P( a ( a t( P( P( a ( a. Theeoe lm ( a > 0. K Aga b Coolla.6 we coclude that ( MOP K has a wea ecet soluto. 3.. The covegece theoems Let S ad S ( t deote the soluto sets o MOP( D ad MOP ( K espectvel. Let { t } be a sequece o postve eal umbes whch mootocall teds to as.

PENALTY FUNCTIONS FOR THE MULTIOBJECTIVE 85 S o Lemma 3.3. Assume that s cotuous ad that all N. Suppose that s a cluste pot o { }. The D. Poo. We pove ths lemma b cotadcto. Suppose that s the lmt o a subsequece m o ad that D. The { } m { } P ( > 0 ad hece P ( > ε o some ε > 0. Tae D. Sce S( thee ests t m Sce { } m m such that m ( m ( m. m m ( m thee ests a te sequece { } o dces all o whch have the same value sa o all N. To smpl the otato we assume that o all m N. Theeoe o all m N we have m m m m ( m ( m. (3.4 ( Sce P( m P( > ε o all m sucetl lage we have P( m > ε. Hece o m sucetl lage ( ( m m ( ( ( ( m m ( t ( P( m P( m ( m ( t ε m ( ( as m. Ths cotadcts (3.4. Note that hee P ( 0 as D. The ollowg theoem shows that a sequece o wea ecet solutos o the pealzed poblems coveges to a pot the s also a wea ecet soluto o the ogal poblem. Note that thee ests some N such that ( S D the t s eas to ve that s also a soluto o MOP( D.

86 DAU XUAN LUONG ad TRAN VAN AN S o Theoem 3.4. Assume that s cotuous ad that all N. The a cluste pot o the sequece { } s a wea ecet soluto o MOP( D. { }. Poo. We assume that s a cluste pot o the sequece Let m be a subsequece o whch coveges to. B { } m Lemma 3.3 we alead have D. { } Suppose o cotadcto that S. The thee ests D satsg ( < (. Sce m S thee ests m m such that m ( m ( m. m m Sce m { } thee ests a te sequece { m } o dces all o whch have the same value sa m o all N. Aga to smpl the otato we assume that the sequece { m } m tsel satses ths popet amel o all m N. Theeoe o all m N we have m m ( m ( m. (3.5 Sce ( < ( we deduce that ( ( < o some ε > 0. Sce m ε as m o sucetl lage m we have ( ( ( m <. ε Hece o m sucetl lage we have m ( m ( m ( ( m t ( P( P( m m

PENALTY FUNCTIONS FOR THE MULTIOBJECTIVE 87 < ε t P ( ε m m whch cotadcts (3.5. Theoem 3.5. Let : R R be cove ad deetable. Futhemoe assume that oe o the ollowg codtos holds: ( K s bouded ( K s ubouded ad thee ests a vecto a D such that lm K ( a > 0. Assume also that S o all N. The the sequece { } has at least oe cluste pot ad eve cluste pot o ths sequece s a wea ecet soluto o MOP( D. Poo. Fst ote that b Lemma 3. we have S (. Theeoe the sequece { } stated the theoem s well-deed. I K s bouded the the sequece { } K s also bouded. Theeoe t has at least oe cluste pot. The clam that eve cluste pot o ths sequece s a wea ecet soluto o MOP( D ollows dectl om Theoem 3.4. t Now assume that K s ubouded ad thee ests a D such that lm K ( a > 0. We am to show that the sequece { } s bouded. Fo t > 0 let B ( t be the smallest closed ball R ceteed at the og such that o all B( t ad o all we have ( a > 0

88 DAU XUAN LUONG ad TRAN VAN AN o othe wods ( a t P( a > 0. Sce whe s sucetl lage ad ( a > 0 t P( a t( P( P( a 0 we deduce that B ( t has te adus. Net we show that S( t B. Ideed suppose o the cota that thee ests some S \ B. The b deto o B o all we have o equvaletl t ( a > 0 ( ( a < 0. Hece s ot a soluto o ( ( VVIP K. B Theoem. we deduce that S( t a cotadcto. Hece S B. O the othe had o t > t we have B B. Ideed o all B( t ad o all we have whch mples as ( a t P( a > 0 ( a t P( a > 0 (3.6 P ( a P( P( a 0.

PENALTY FUNCTIONS FOR THE MULTIOBJECTIVE 89 B deto B s the smallest ball such that o all B the equalt (3.6 holds o all. Theeoe B s cotaed B (. t } Fall as { t s mootocall ceasg we have Theeoe o all N we have B B B. S B B(. Sce the adus o B s te we coclude that the sequece s bouded. We complete the poo. Eample 3.6. Let t { } D T { ( R : 0 0}. Fgue. The easble ego D.

DAU XUAN LUONG ad TRAN VAN AN 90 Tae P as (3.3: ( [ { }] [ { }] 0 ma 0 ma P ( ( ( ( ( ( (. III II I 0 D We have ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (. III 4 II 4 I 0 0 D P Let ( ( ( ( whee ( e (. e Cleal chose as above s cove ad deetable o. R Let R K ad. 0 D a The we have ( ( e ( e whch ae obvousl postve whe. Theeoe b Theoem 3.5 a sequece o wea ecet solutos o the pealzed poblems ( ( MOP K t has a cluste pot ad eve cluste pot o that sequece s a wea ecet soluto o (. MOP D

PENALTY FUNCTIONS FOR THE MULTIOBJECTIVE 9 4. Cocluso We vestgate the elatoshp betwee the set o wea ecet solutos o the ogal multobjectve optmzato poblem ad the sets o wea ecet solutos o the coespodg pealzed poblems. Theoem 3.4 shows that eve cluste pot o a sequece o wea ecet solutos o the pealzed poblems s a wea ecet soluto o the ogal poblem ude ol the cotut o. No covet o deetablt s equed. Howeve Theoem 3.5 eques such popetes o. Seveal authos have establshed esults o the estece o wea ecet solutos o a multobjectve optmzato poblem ude less stct equemets mposed o o stace whe s osmooth ad ocove (see o stace [7 8 ]. Based o these esults oe ma ela the assumptos mposed o the objectve ucto stated Theoem 3.5. Reeeces [] G. Y. Che ad X. Q. Yag The vecto complemeta poblem ad ts equvaleces wth the wea mmal elemet odeed spaces J. Math. Aal. Appl. 53 (990 36-58. [] G. Y. Che ad B. D. Cave Estece ad cotut o solutos o vecto optmzato J. Math. Aal. Appl. 0 (998 90-98. [3] R. Comett ad J. P. Dussault Stable epoetal-pealt algothm wth supelea covegece J. Optm. Theo Appl. 83( (994 85-309. [4] J. P. Evas ad F. J. Gould A estece theoem o pealt ucto theo SIAM J. Cotol. (974 505-56. [5] X. Q. Huag ad X. Q. Yag Nolea Lagaga o multobjectve optmzato ad applcatos to dualt ad eact pealzato SIAM J. Optm. 3(3 (00 675-69. [6] X. Q. Huag X. Q. Yag ad K. L. Teo Covegece aalss o a class o pealt methods o vecto optmzato poblems wth coe costats J. Global Optm. 36(4 (006 637-65. [7] K. R. Kazm Estece o solutos o vecto optmzato Appl. Math. Lett. 9 (996 9-. [8] G. M. Lee ad D. S. Km Estece o solutos o vecto optmzato poblems J. Optm. Theo Appl. 8(3 (994 459-468.

9 DAU XUAN LUONG ad TRAN VAN AN [9] S. Lu ad E. Feg The epoetal pealt ucto method o multobjectve pogammg poblems Optm. Methods Sotw. 5(5 (00 667-675. [0] V. H. Ngue ad J. J. Stodot O the covegece ate o a pealt ucto method o epoetal tpe J. Optm. Theo Appl. 7(4 (979 495-508. [] R. T. Rocaella Cove Aalss Pceto Uv. Pess Pceto New Jese 970. [] L. B. Satos G. Ruz-Gazo M. A. Rojas-Meda ad A. Rua-Lzaa Estece o weal ecet solutos osmooth vecto optmzato Appl. Math. Comput. 00( (008 547-556. [3] D. J. Whte Multobjectve pogammg ad pealt uctos J. Optm. Theo Appl. 3(3 (00 675-69. [4] W. I. Zagwll Nolea Pogammg: A Ued Appoach Petce Hall Eglewood Cls NJ 969. g