Nanostructured Carbon Allotropes as Weyl-Like Semimetals Shengbai Zhang Department of Physics, Applied Physics & Astronomy Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
symmetry In quantum mechanics, symmetry can be critically important. Consider, for example, a two-particle system. Under particle exchange, bosons satisfy ψ r 1, r 2 = ψ r 2, r 1, whereas fermions satisfy ψ r 1, r 2 = ψ r 2, r 1. Just because the symmetry, bosons and fermions are very different from classical particles. Recent development in solid-state physics is also about symmetry: in case of Weyl fermions, chiral symmetry leads to novel properties/topological protection not envisioned before. 2
topological protection a Mobius ring a normal ring One cannot deform a normal ring into a Mobius ring without cutting the strip and then rejoin. 3
solid and its bloch wave A solid is a periodic system in which electron wavefunction may be written as a Bloch wave ψ k r = e ik r u k r = e ik r u k. The reciprocal space of r is the k space in which the smallest repeating unit defines the Brillouin zone. Brillouin zone (BZ) forms a closed loop in the sense that a k-point exiting from one face of the BZ is equivalent to reentering from the opposite face of the BZ. 4
berry curvature & chiral quantum number Electron living inside the Brillouin zone feels an (effective) vector potential A k = i u k k u k (Berry connection). The corresponding (Berry) curvature F k = k A k defines a field (similar to a magnetic field B). Chiral quantum number is defined by χ = 1 2π FS F k d S k (Chern number). Non-trivial Chern number (+1 or 1) tells the chirality (righthanded or left-handed). 5
low-energy particles Tomorrow's condensed matter physics will be rooted in manybody physics studying collective excitations and quasiparticles Theory developed for elementary particles can be shipped here to explore many-body interactions which cannot be easily obtained from experiment via serendipity. Theory is and will lead the way. Compared to traditional particle physics, condensed matter is a much richer field and experimental test should be easier. An emerging battlefield of particle physics. Good condensed matter physicist needs to be intradisplinary! 6
spin-half dirac fermions Dirac Hamiltonian (3D): H = mv2 v σ p v σ p mv 2 = mv 2 0 vp z v p x ip y 0 mv 2 v p x + ip y vp z vp z v p x ip y mv 2 0 v p x + ip y vp z 0 mv 2 Massless Dirac fermions (m = 0), H = 0 v σ p v σ p 0 Dirac semimetal (4x4 matrix; doublydegenerate Dirac cones; linear dispersion in all three directions). (2-Dirac points) M. Koshino 7
3-dimensional spin-half weyl fermions Separate in k- space the two Dirac cones : NJP 9, 356 (2007) Now, each cone is described by a 2x2 Weyl Hamiltonian: H ± = ± v p z p x ip y. Weyl fermions are protected by the chiral p x + ip y p z symmetry discussed earlier, so they are robust against perturbations. 8
surface states: fermi arcs Weyl points of different chirality's can be viewed as magnetic monopoles (MMP) with ±charges On the surfaces of a slab, Fermi arcs appear, which is characteristic of Weyl semimetal. A state moving in the (+y)-direction on top surface cannot be scattered back. y To observe Weyl points, the material must do not have either time reversal symmetry or inversion symmetry. 9
why bother? Weyl semimetal exhibits chiral anomaly, meaning chiral charges are not conserved. One can use B E fields to pump charge from one chiral channel to another. Experimental ramifications include negative magnetoresistance; quantum anomalous Hall effect (for dissipationless carrier transport like superconductivity); non-local transport; and non-conservation of ordinary current (at least locally). It can also give rise to unusual optical conductivity, and many more. real-part of optical conductivity σ xx versus chemical potential μ & optical frequency ω. 10
dirac/weyl semimetal as an intermediate phase A Dirac or Weyl semimetal is an intermediate phase in the transition between a topological insulator (TI) phase and a normal insulator (NI) phase. Topological insulator are materials with large spin-orbit coupling (SOC), such as Bi 2 Te 3 Search for Weyl semimetals also follows the same line of thought. 11
in pursuit of weyl semimetal (current status ) (ev) Photonic crystal: Science 349, 622 (2015) TaAs (Ta is heavy, large spin-orbit coupling): Science 349, 613 (2015); PRX 5, 031013 (2015). TaAs Band Structure (E versus k) 30-meV gap Drawbacks with TaAs: Too many Weyl points (24 in total) and they are too close (only ~% of BZ), unlike graphene Trivial Fermi pockets at Fermi level dominate (zero gap in the DOS). 12
what might be the next? # papers with Weyl in topic Regardless, experimental discovery of Weyl semimetal is an APS Highlight of the Year You bet, the study of Weyl fermion will continue 1945-2016 # papers with graphene in topic: 0 (1945-1990); 95,366 (1991-2016); 1,803 (2016 alone); >100 per day now. 13
graphene: an example of 2d dirac weyl semimetal r-space: A,B sublattice k-space: K K Near K and K : H = v p0 z p x ip y p x + ip y p 0 z 2 Dirac cones separated by 1 3 b 1 b 2. K K 14
carbon allotropes Graphene Graphite + many more Carbon has many allotropes due to its exceptionally strong C-C bonds. Once formed, these allotropes are hard to break. Carbon nanotube C 60 15
dp in graphene: unique orbital interactions p z p z atomic p orbitals graphene atomic p z -orbital 2D Dirac point p y p x graphene network atomic (p x, p y )- orbitals 3D Weyl point? 16
so, here is our charge Search for systems whose orbital interactions have the form of 3D Weyl Hamiltonian However, different from others searching for existing materials of limited use and supply, we target materials of broad use but in forms not yet synthesized In the process, we also uncovered structures with Hamiltonians that do not fit into any of the currently known models. 17
why weyl-like semimetal? Light elements have exceedingly small spin-orbit coupling (SOC for carbon ~1 millikelvin) At room temperature, (thermal scattering)/soc is 300K/0.001K = 3 10 5 Hence, for most applications, spin may be treated as a dummy variable, leading to Weyl-like semimetals Conclusion: Weyl physics exists in solids made of purely light elements (the lighter, the better). 18
interpenetrated graphene network (IGN) sp 3 sp 2 Formation energy (ev/c) Graphene Diamond IGN C 60 0.0 0.13 0.23 0.37 No imaginary-frequency phonons kinetically stable. 19
weyl line nodes Brillouin zone Z T θ G Y Weyl wedge E F Line nodes are the only Fermi surface for the entire system, along which the energy dispersion looks like a wedge. Nano Letters 15, 6974 (2015) 20
emergence of weyl points One may break the inversion symmetry either (1) by displacing some carbon atoms or (2) by inserting He interstitials, both turn the Weyl line nodes into points (1) (2) 21
fermi arcs appear on the [010] surface Schematic Actual calculation Nano Letters 15, 6974 (2015) 22
back to line nodes: what is unique? Chern number: χ = 1 2π A k d l k Co-dimension = 2 (even) weaker but non-vanishing topological protection. Line node gives rise to topologicallyprotected flat bands on surfaces. On a flat band, Coulomb repulsion U is exceptionally large, leading to a strong electron-electron correlation PRB 82, 184502 (2010) Can you imaging strongly-correlated carbon? 23
line nodes are robust under uniaxial strain θ reducing θ Topological protection remains until a critical angle θ = 64. 24
at θ = 64 transition from IGN to CKL Interpenetrated graphene network (IGN) Carbon Kagome lattice (CKL) G-3 1/3 C 4fold; 2/3 C 3fold (sp 2 ) All C 4fold (sp 3 ) Nano Letters 15, 6974 (2015) PRL113, 085501 (2014) 25
understanding electronic properties Polyacetylene is the root for most carbon allotropes. By connecting the chains, one builds graphene, anti-bonding state bonding state E F G A(=Z) diamond, IGN, Kagome lattice, etc. Different characters of the occupied and empty states are the reason for Weyl semimetal. 26
band inversion yields topological protection Increasing uniaxial strain 1D 3D polyacetylene IGN CKL E F A G 1 2 3 27 Red = Blue = Green =
ckl is as remarkable as ign 3.4-eV direct gap (blue color) (by HSE calc.) Effective mass m s comparable to Si Light absorption comparable to GaN Realization of optical-electronic integration in one material. Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 085501 (2014) 28
frustration in triangular lattice p-orbital carbon Kagome lattice Frustration in life + p-down p-up Frustration in physics Upon doping, will carriers in CKL act as spin-like liquid? 29
there is a whole family of 3d-graphene weyl semimetals 2-type carbon rings (more stable than IGN) Weyl surface nodes as Fermi level Co-dimension = 1 (odd) more topological protection (?) Colors denote different types of carbon 30
(b) ordered random Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) images of carbon channels. Most of the channels are perpendicular to the page. (a) Featured in Physics & Editor s Suggestion 31
summary Weyl-line nodes in interpenetrated carbon network [Nano Letters 15, 6974 (2015)] Carbon Kagome lattice [Phys Rev Lett 113, 085501 (2014)] Weyl-surface nodes in three-dimensional graphene [under review by Nanoscale (2016)] 32
acknowledgements Yuanping Chen Vincent Meunier Marvin Cohen, UCB Yiyang Sun Han Wang Damien West S.Y. Yang, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Singapore Fan Zhang, UT Dallas 33