Deep Thunder. Local Area Precision Forecasting for Weather-Sensitive Business Operations (e.g. Electric Utility)

Transcription

1 1

2 Deep Thunder Local Area Precision Forecasting for Weather-Sensitive Business Operations (e.g. Electric Utility) Dipl. Ing. Helmut Ludwar Chief Technologist Wien, im Oktober 2010

3 Forecasts for Weather-Sensitive Operations Problem: weather-sensitive business operations are often reactive to short-term local conditions due to unavailability of appropriate predicted data at this scale Energy, transportation, agriculture, insurance, broadcasting, sports, entertainment, tourism, construction, communications, emergency planning and security warnings Solution: application of reliable, affordable, weather models for predictive & proactive decision making & operational planning Numerical weather forecasts coupled to business processes Products and operations customized to business problems Competitive advantage -- efficiency, safety, security and economic & societal benefit It is not about weather but integrating forecasts into decision making to optimize business processes

4 Classes of Weather Models for Different Geographic Scales, Time Ranges & Applications National Weather Service uses a synopticscale model on a 12 km scale 40% physics, 50% dynamics, 10% microphysics Thunderstorms wind shear, land-sea breezes, circulation induced from topography cannot be seen at this resolution Like trying to catch small fish with a net that has a large mesh Regional models employ meso- and cloudscale grids (e.g., 1-10 km spacing) 50% physics, 20% dynamics, 30% explicit cloud microphysics Can resolve storms, winds, etc. Cast a finer net over coarse net

5 Storm Impact and Response Prediction Weather causes damage Damage require restoration (resources) Restoration takes time, people, etc. Build predictive model from environmental observations, storm impact and related data Damage location, timing and response Wind, rain, lightning and duration Demographics of effected area Infrastructure impacted in effected area Ancillary environmental conditions Couple this model to weather predictions to enable a forecast of impact and response Weather predictions Damage prediction Resource requirement prediction Restoration time prediction

6 Challenges of Building an Impact Model Damage forecast model inputs Which weather inputs are important for damage forecast? Most weather variables are correlated Multicollinearity may cause invalid interpretation of weather predictors Weather forecast calibration Forecasted variables (e.g., wind speed) may differ in meaning vs. observations used in the damage-forecast-model training How should physical model outputs be calibrated so that they can be used as the inputs of damage forecast model? Gust speed calculation Exploratory data analysis indicates that gust speed has a stronger relationship to damages vs. wind speed General meteorological models do not provide a direct gust forecast How should gust speed be calculated based on limited weather data? Model integration How should damage forecasts, multiple spatial resolution interpolations and calibration be integrated in one framework? Uncertainty quantification and visualization Uncertainties come from various data sources

7 Example: Development and Deployment of a Weather and Outage Prediction Service for Electric Utility Operations The operation of the distribution system of an electric utility, particularly with an overhead infrastructure, can be highly sensitive to local weather conditions What is the potential to enable proactive allocation and deployment of resources (people and equipment) to minimize time for restoration? Ability to predict specific events or combination of weather conditions that can disrupt that distribution network with sufficient spatial and temporal precision, and lead time Can highly localized, model-based forecasts (e.g., IBM Research Deep Thunder ) be adapted to address these problems and reduce the uncertainty in decision making?

8 Example: March 13th, 2010 Rain and Wind Storm in New York Coastal storm with strong winds and heavy rains Gusting between 40 and 75 mph observed in the afternoon and evening Innumerable downed trees and power lines Local flooding and evacuations Electricity service lost to over 600,000 residences and businesses in the New York City metropolitan area Widespread disruption of transportation systems (e.g., road and bridge closures, airport and rail delays) Other forecasts during the late morning on March 11th: rain may be heavy at times, east winds 20 to 25 mph with gusts up to 40 mph Wind advisories issued (gusts to mph) at 1619 EST, March 12th High wind warnings issued (gusts to mph) at 1343 EST, March 13th

9 Example: 2010, March 13th Nor easter: Result IBM Deep Thunder: High winds shown in forecast available more than two days before the event and 37 hours before the National Weather Service Estimated Outages (Repair Jobs) Actual Outages (Repair Jobs)

10 Wind Power Management Wind power intermittency creates significant barriers to expanding utilization Consider for wind Ramp events Spinning reserve Better forecasting and smarter dispatch can alleviate these barriers Ensemble forecasts Stochastic programming Dynamic reserves

11 Forecast for a Ramping Event 84-hour wind forecast showing speed and direction at a height of 80m (top, i.e., hub height for turbines as well as wind trajectories Peak wind speed before the ramp down is close to the cut-out speed of some turbines

12 Wind Farm Siting Configure and run a high-resolution weather model over the target area to create a climatology to determine the power potential Match weather model to the wind farm scale (horizontally, vertically, temporally) Include local, detailed geography such as terrain, vegetation, etc. Couple result to power estimation, includes assessment of variability Evaluate more than the maximum wind If there is too much variability or a sufficiently large variation between the surface and the turbine height, then the equipment will be subject to stress and fail relatively quickly Consider optimization driven by the physical constraints as well as economic and logistical ones Assess environmental impact of the turbine operations In aggregate, a large wind farm does take energy out of the atmosphere Estimate changes in local weather to a climate scale due to wind farm operations It is not about wind, but rather the nature of the weather in general (e.g., wind, storm intensity and duration, ground saturation, etc.), which you have to do correctly at the appropriate scale in order to determine wind correctly

13 Operational Applications Accurate timing of shut down due to severe weather Lead time required to take preventative measures (e.g., when a storm hits, the turbines must be shut down, which takes several minutes) The shut down causes a loss of energy generation The more precise the weather forecasting the more optimal can the time of shutdown be determined to minimize the loss Accurate reserve margins With improved power estimations and when losses would occur, the need for alternative sources (e.g., fossil fuel plants) can be determined better More cost effective management of all generators as the need for high margins on power reserves and standby production will decrease Accurate area for shut down Improved weather forecasting will allow for a more limited shut down of the facility since a subset of the effected areas could be determined Overall reduction in variability into the grid

14 The current reactive approach to weather-sensitive business operations into a proactive approach in industries as diverse as: transportation, agriculture, broadcasting, communications, energy, insurance, emergency management, security, sports, entertainment, tourism, construction, traffic management, etc., Photo by Victor Fellion and Wings of Life (see watch.org/news/2009/03/07/altona-wind-turbine-collapse-photos/)