arxiv: v1 [hep-th] 18 Apr 2007

Transcription

1 USTC-ICTS Probing α-vacua of Black Holes in LHC arxiv: v1 [hep-th] 18 Apr 2007 Tower Wang Institute of Theoretical Physics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, P. O. Box 2735 Beijing , China Interdisciplinary Center for Theoretical Study, University of Science and Technology of China, Hefei, Anhui , China Abstract Motivated by the idea of α-vacua in Schwarzschild spacetime, we studied the deformed spectrum of Hawking radiation. Such a deformation would leave signatures on the small black hole evaporation in LHC. 1

2 For massive scalar fields there is a family of de Sitter-invariant states, which includes the Hartle-Hawking vacuum state as a special case [1, 2]. These states are well known as the so-called α-vacua. The choice of physical vacuum from these states might be imprinted on the spectrum of CMBR (see e.g. [3]). The application of α-vacua to cosmological dark energy can be find in [4] as a recent review. In [5] Chamblin and Michelson constructed the α-vacua of scalar field in Schwarzschild, Schwarzschild-dS and Schwarzschild-AdS black hole spacetimes. Based on their work, we explored the modified spectrum of Hawking radiation, considering the α-vacua effects of Schwarzschild spacetime. If small black holes are produced in LHC abundantly [6, 7], such a modification would leave observable signatures on their evaporation. To achieve the result, we first introduced the global coordinates of Schwarzschild spacetime, by embedding it into M 6,1. By partly solving the Klein-Gordon equation in terms of global coordinates, we then deduced a more exact expression of α-vacua, which relates to the Hartle-hawking vacuum by a trivial (nonmixing) Bogoliubov transformation and a Mottola-Allen transformation. Finally, from this expression, we derived the evaporation spectrum following the standard procedure, i.e., by picking up the Bogoliubov coefficients. Although the result are obtained in four-dimensions, its generalization to higher dimensions is straightforward, given the spherical symmetry of Schwarzschild spacetime. So in the end we also discussed implications of our result for small black holes in large extra dimensional scenarios. In static coordinates, the Schwarzschild metric is ( ds 2 = 1 2M r ) ( dt M r ) 1 dr 2 + r 2 (dθ 2 + sin 2 θdϕ 2 ) (1) It can be embedded into M 6,1 by setting [5] ds 2 = dx dx dx dx dx dx dx 2 6 (2) X 1 = r sin θ cosϕ, X 2 = r sin θ sin ϕ, X 3 = r cosθ 2M r X 4 = 2M + 4M r 2M, X 5 = 2 2M 3M r X 6 = 4M 1 2M ( ) t r cosh, X 0 = 4M 1 2M ( ) t 4M r sinh 4M (3) The spacetime outside the horizon of Schwarzschild black hole is given as the 2

3 algebraic variety determined by the three polynomials [5] 4 3 X2 5 + X 2 6 X 2 0 = 16M 2 X 4 5 (X2 1 + X2 2 + X2 3 ) = 576M6 3X4 X 5 + X 2 5 = 24M 2 (4) The global coordinates are related to static coordinates via ( ) cos σ + tanh τ (t, r, θ, ϕ) static cosσ tanhτ, 2M cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ, θ, ϕ global (5) which is resulted from the definition 2M sin θ cosϕ X 1 = cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ, X 2M sin θ sin ϕ 2 = cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ, X 2M cos θ 3 = cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ 4M X 4 = 2M cosh τ sin σ + cosh τ sin σ, X 5 = 2 3M cosh τ sin σ X 6 = 4M cosh τ cosσ, X 0 = 4M sinh τ (6) and gives the form of metric ds 2 = 16M 2 cosh 6 τ sin 6 σ {sin2 σ[sinh 2 τ(1 + cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ) cosh 4 τ sin 4 σ]dτ 2 + cosh 2 τ[cos 2 σ(1 + cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ + cosh 4 τ sin 4 σ) + cosh 6 τ sin 6 σ]dσ 2 +2 sinhτ cosh τ sin σ cosσ(1 + cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ + cosh 4 τ sin 4 σ)dτdσ} 4M 2 + cosh 4 τ sin 4 σ (dθ2 + sin 2 θdϕ 2 ) (7) Clearly such a system of global coordinates is quite similar to but more complicated than the one for de Sitter spacetime [8]. Correspondingly the measure is 64M 4 sin θ g = cosh 6 τ sin 7 σ (8) while the non-vanishing components of contravariant metric tensor are g ττ = 1 σ(1 + cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ + cosh 4 τ sin 4 σ) + cosh 6 τ sin 6 σ] 16M 2[cos2 g τσ = g στ sinh τ sin σ cosσ = (1 + cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ + cosh 4 τ sin 4 σ) 16M 2 cosh τ g σσ sin 2 σ = 16M 2 cosh 2 τ [sinh2 τ(1 + cosh 2 τ sin 2 σ) cosh 4 τ sin 4 σ] g θθ = cosh4 τ sin 4 σ 4M 2, g ϕϕ = cosh4 τ sin 4 σ 4M 2 sin 2 θ (9) 3

4 The covariant Klein-Gordon equation 1 g µ ( gg µν ν Φ) µ 2 Φ = 0 (10) in global coordinates is rather complicated. However, we can get some indications by fixing the value of cosh τ sin σ and taking the limit σ 0 or π. From the identification (5), it is easy to see that r = corresponds to cosh τ sin σ = 0 while r = 2M corresponds to cosh τ sin σ = 1. So we discuss these two limits. form When cosh τ sin σ = 0, σ 0 or π, the Klein-Gordon equation (10) takes the 1 16M 2 2 τ Φ µ2 Φ = 0 (11) whose solution can be written as ψ l,m (x) = Y l,m (θ, ϕ) ( c 1 e 4iµMτ + c 2 e 4iµMτ) (12) whereas for cosh τ sin σ = 1, σ 0 or π, equation (10) becomes 1 4M τφ + 1 [ M 2 sin θ θ(sin θ θ Φ) + 1 ] sin 2 θ 2 ϕφ = µ 2 Φ (13) whose solution is simply ψ l,m (x) = Y l,m (θ, ϕ){c 3 exp[iτ l(l + 1) + 4µ 2 M 2 ] + c 4 exp[ iτ l(l + 1) + 4µ 2 M 2 ]} In the above c 1, c 2, c 3 and c 4 are normalization constants, and in (12) we have separated the Y l,m (θ, ϕ) part of solution. In terms of global coordinates, the antipodal map [2, 5] x x A reads (14) (τ, σ, θ, ϕ) ( τ, π σ, π θ, ϕ ± π) (15) Using the following relation for spherical harmonic functions Y l,m (π θ, ϕ ± π) = ( 1) l Y l,m (θ, ϕ) = ( 1) l+m Y l, m(θ, ϕ) (16) one can check in limits (12) and (14) that the trivial Bogoliubov transformation φ l,m (x) = 1 2 e iπl/2 [ e iπ/4 e iπm/2 ψ l,m (x) + e iπ/4 e iπm/2 ψ l, m (x) ] gives a complete set of orthonormal positive-norm modes [2]. In particular, 1. φ l,m (x A ) = φ l,m (x). 4

5 2. (φ l,m, φ l,m ) = δ l,l δ m,m and (φ l,m, φ l,m ) = The set of φ l,m is complete and spans the space of ψ l,m. 4. φ l,0 (x) = e iπl/2 ψ l,0 (x). The α-vacua are constructed from this set of modes by a Mottola-Allen transformation [2, 5] φ l,m (x) = cosh αφ l,m (x) + e iγ sinh αφ l,m (x) (17) In the following, to be brief, we will work in the matrix formalism. That is, we write a basis of modes in a column matrix and multiply it by a square matrix to represent the Bogoliubov transformation. for example, the trivial Bogoliubov transformation (17) will be written compactly φ = Pψ (18) in which and φ = φ 0,0 φ 1, 1 φ 1,0 φ 1,1 φ 2, 2., ψ = ψ 0,0 ψ 1, 1 ψ 1,0 ψ 1,1 ψ 2, e iπ/ e iπ/ e iπ/2 0 0 P = e iπ/ e iπ/ e iπ/ Similarly, the Mottola-Allen transformation (17) will be denoted in the form (19) (20) φ = cosh αφ + e iγ sinh αφ (21) It is not hard to show PP = P P = 1 P 1 = P (22) 5

6 as well as J J 3 0 P T 0 0 J 5 0 P = ( 1) n J 2n in which J n is an n n square matrix J n = (23) (24) With these results in hand, we now start to calculate the evaporation spectrum in α-vacua of Schwarzschild black holes. For Hartle-Hawking vacuum, the procedure is standard [9, 10]. If we use ψ i to denote the positive frequency modes on I + and ψ i to denote the positive frequency modes on I, then the Bogoliubov transformation ψ i ψ i, i.e., b i b i can be written as ψ = Aψ + Bψ (25) or namely b = ba + b B (26) in which A and B are Bogoliubov transformation matrices, while b and b are row matrices with elements b i and b i respectively. A solution of the Klein-Gordon equation (10) can be expanded as Φ(x) = i (b i ψ i + b iψ i ) = i (b iψ i + b i ψ i ) (27) It has been proved in [10] that there is a relation between the Bogoliubov coefficients B ij = e ω i/(2t H ) A ij (28) 6

7 and the late time particle flux through I + given a vacuum on I is < N i > I += ( BB ) ii = ( e ω i/t H 1 ) 1 (29) For α-vacua, we should consider the following set of transformations ψ i φ i φ i ψ i ψ i φ i φ i ψ i bi ã i a i b i b i a i ã i b i (30) The Bogoliubov transformations between the different bases of modes are φ = cosh αφ + e iγ sinh αφ, φ = cosh α φ e iγ sinh α φ φ = Pψ, ψ = P φ, φ = P ψ, ψ = P φ (31) Notice there are similar equations by exchanging ψ ψ, φ φ, φ φ and ψ ψ. The last equation of (31) is easy to understand if we take (22) into consideration. In addition, we can also formally write ψ = Ã ψ + B ψ, ψ = Ã ψ + B ψ (32) The expected number of particles in the ith mode is ( < Ni α > I += ( B ) ( ) B = B B ) The superscript α is added to indicate the particle flux in α-vacua of Schwarzschild spacetime. Making full use of (25), (31) and (32), after some algebra, we get the relation ψ = P {cosh 2 α ( PAP ) sinh 2 α ( PAP ) ii ii (33) + sinh α cosh α[e iγ ( PBP T) e iγ ( PBP T) ]}P ψ +P {cosh 2 α ( PBP T) e 2iγ sinh 2 α ( PBP T) +e iγ sinh α cosh α[ ( PAP ) ( PAP ) ]}P ψ (34) Thus the expression of B is B = cosh 2 α (B) e 2iγ sinh 2 α ( P P B P P ) +e iγ sinh α cosh α[ ( P P A ) ( AP P ) ] (35) Multiplied by B = cosh 2 α ( B ) e 2iγ sinh 2 α ( P T PB T P T P ) +e iγ sinh α cosh α[ ( A T P T P ) ( P T PA ) ] (36) 7

8 it gives B B = cosh 4 α ( BB ) + sinh 4 α ( P P B B T P T P ) + sinh 2 α cosh 2 α[ ( AA ) + ( P P A A T P T P ) ] sinh 2 α cosh 2 α[ ( P P A P T PA ) + ( AP P A T P T P ) ] sinh 2 α cosh 2 α[e 2iγ ( P P B P P B ) + e 2iγ ( BP T PB T P T P ) ] + sinh α cosh 3 α[e iγ ( BA T P T P ) + e iγ ( BA T P T P ) ] sinh α cosh 3 α[e iγ ( BP T PA ) + e iγ ( BP T PA ) ] + sinh 3 α cosh α[e iγ ( AB T P T P ) + e iγ ( AB T P T P ) ] sinh 3 α cosh α[e iγ ( P T PBP T PA P P ) + e iγ ( P T PBP T PA P P ) T ] This expression is rather complicated. When α = 0, apparently it reduces to the expected relation B B α=0 = BB. In virtue of (28) and (29), one can simplify the first and the third terms in (37) cosh 4 α ( BB ) + sinh 2 α cosh 2 α ( AA ) = (e ω i/t H sinh 2 α cosh 2 α + cosh 4 α) < N i > I + (37) = eω i/t H sinh 2 α cosh 2 α + cosh 4 α e ω i/t H 1 (38) Owing to (23), other terms in (37) will mix modes of different frequencies and hence be difficult to tackle. Therefore, the average number of particles < N α i > I += eω i/t H sinh 2 α cosh 2 α + cosh 4 α e ω i/t H 1 + frequency mixing terms (39) Equation (39) is our main result in this paper. We work it out in four dimensions, and have used relation (28) in the derivation. As proved in [2], massless scalar field has no de Sitter-invariant α-vacua. It is unclear whether there is a similar no-go theorem in Schwarzschild spacetime. Although (28) holds exactly only for massless scalar field, when the scalar mass µ T H this relation is good enough for our estimation above. Equation (39) will continue to exist in (4+n)-dimensions, if one defines temperature in the way [7] T H = n + 1 4πr H (40) The value of α cannot be determined theoretically 1. However, if it is large enough, the blackbody profile of Hawking radiation will be deformed according to (39). As- 1 Of course, there might be some arguments favoring a vanishing value of α. But that is a matter subject to debate. 8

9 suming large extra dimensions and TeV Plank scale, in [6, 7], it has been proposed that small black holes would be produced in LHC and provide the first experimental test of Hawking s radiation hypothesis. Schwarzschild phase is an important stage in the evaporation of small black holes. If α-vacua are indeed physical for Schwarzschild black holes, their profile (39) must be imprinted on the evaporation spectrum, thus can be found out by a detailed study of small black hole decay. Up to now, we have only discussed the spin-0 filed. It is well known that black holes radiate fields with various spins. α-vacua in de Sitter spacetime for scalar field have been previously extended to other fields, see [11, 12]. If such extensions go through in Schwarzschild spacetime, their effects should also be studied to probe α-vacua of black holes in LHC. Acknowledgement: We would like to thank Miao Li and Wei Song for useful discussions. References [1] E. Mottola, Particle Creation in de Sitter Space, Phys. Rev. D 31, 754 (1985). [2] B. Allen, Vacuum States in de Sitter Space, Phys. Rev. D 32, 3136 (1985). [3] U. H. Danielsson, Inflation, holography, and the choice of vacuum in de Sitter space, JHEP 0207, 040 (2002), hep-th/ [4] I. Antoniadis, P. O. Mazur and E. Mottola Cosmological Dark Energy: Prospects for a Dynamical Theory, New J. Phys. 9, 11 (2007), gr-qc/ [5] A. Chamblin and J. Michelson, Alpha-Vacua, Black Holes, and AdS/CFT, Class. Quant. Grav. 24, 1569 (2007), hep-th/ [6] S. B. Giddings and S. Thomas, High Energy Colliders as Black Hole Factories: The End of Short Distance Physics, Phys. Rev. D 65, (2002), hep-ph/ [7] S. Dimopoulos and G. Landsberg, Black holes at the LHC, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, (2001), hep-ph/ [8] M. Spradlin, A. Strominger and A. Volovich, Les Houches Lectures on de Sitter Space, hep-th/

10 [9] S. W. Hawking, Particle Creation by Black Holes, Commun. Math. Phys. 43, 199 (1975). [10] P. K. Townsend, Black Holes, gr-qc/ [11] J. de Boer, V. Jejjala and D. Minic, Alpha-states in de Sitter Space, Phys. Rev. D 71, (2005), hep-th/ [12] H. Collins, Fermionic alpha-vacua, Phys. Rev. D 71, (2005), hep-th/