Mathematische Annalen
|
|
- Debra Norman
- 5 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 Math. Ann. ( : DOI /s Mathematische Annalen Three circles theorems for harmonic functions Guoyi Xu 1 Received: 6 January 015 / Published online: January 016 Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 016 Abstract We proved two three circles theorems for harmonic functions on manifolds in integral sense. As one application, on manifold with nonnegative Ricci curvature, whose tangent cone at infinity is the unique metric cone with unique conic measure, we showed the existence of nonconstant harmonic functions with polynomial growth. This existence result recovered and generalized the former result of Ding, and led to a complete answer of Ni s conjecture. Furthermore in similar context, combining the techniques of estimating the frequency of harmonic functions with polynomial growth, which were developed by Colding and Minicozzi, we confirmed their conjecture about the uniform bound of frequency. Mathematics Subject Classification 35B40 58J05 53C3 35A01 Contents 1 Introduction Background and notations Three Circles Theorems for harmonic functions The existence of harmonic functions with polynomial growth Uniform bound of frequency function References B Guoyi Xu gyxu@math.tsinghua.edu.cn 1 Yau Mathematical Sciences Center, Jin Chun Yuan West Building, Tsinghua University, Beijing , People s Republic of China 13
2 18 G. Xu 1 Introduction In 1975, Yau [47] generalized the classical Liouville theorem to complete manifolds with nonnegative Ricci curvature. Specially, he proved that any positive harmonic function on such manifolds is constant. In [11], Cheng further proved that on such manifolds any harmonic function of sublinear growth must be constant. On complete manifolds, harmonic functions with polynomial growth are important analytic functions besides the Green s function and the heat kernel (note the latter two have singularities. In the study of harmonic functions on complete manifolds, Yau considered the space of harmonic functions with polynomial growth: H d (M ={u u(x is harmonic on M n ; u(x K (ρ(x + 1 d for some K > 0} where ρ(x = d(p, x and p is some fixed point on M n.in[48], the following conjecture was made: Conjecture 1.1 (Yau [48] Let M n be a complete manifold with nonnegative Ricci curvature, then dim ( H d (M < for any d > 0. Li and Tam firstly proved the conjecture for linear growth harmonic function (d = 1 in [33], and they further verified the -dimensional case (n = in [34]. In 1997, this conjecture was completely proved by Colding and Minicozzi [15] (also see [18,19, 31,35] for further developments. Although Yau s conjecture was confirmed, there are still several important questions about harmonic functions with polynomial growth remained open. It is well known that on any complete noncompact manifold, there always exist nonconstant harmonic functions (see [5]. A natural question is about the existence of nonconstant harmonic function with polynomial growth. Note any complete manifold with nonnegative Ricci curvature has at least linear volume growth (see [47]. C. Sormani proved the following: Theorem 1. ([43] Let M n be a complete manifold with nonnegative Ricci curvature and at most linear volume growth. If there exists a nonconstant harmonic function of polynomial growth, then the manifold splits isometrically, M n = R N n 1. As observed in [], there exists a suitable metric on R + S n 1, which has nonnegative Ricci curvature and linear volume growth, but can not split isometrically. From Theorem 1., it will not admit any nonconstant harmonic functions with polynomial growth. A concrete example is given in Sect. 4 (Example 4.8. Hence, to study the existence of nonconstant harmonic function with polynomial growth in nonnegative Ricci curvature context, we need to have some restriction on the volume growth of M n. To the author s knowledge, the following question is still open: Question 1.3 If (M n, g is a complete manifold with Rc 0 and maximal volume growth, does there exist d 1 such that dim ( H d (M? In other words, is there any nonconstant harmonic function with polynomial growth order at most d on M n? 13
3 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 183 In another direction, putting the existence problem in the positively curved context, [39] made the following conjecture: Conjecture 1.4 (L. Ni Let (M n, g be a complete Riemannian manifold of positive sectional curvature, the necessary and sufficient condition that M n admits nonconstant harmonic functions of polynomial growth is, that M n is of maximum volume growth. For the corresponding conjecture on Kähler manifolds, Ni proved that if the manifold is complete Kähler with bounded nonnegative bisectional curvature and of maximum volume growth, it admits nonconstant holomorphic functions of polynomial growth (see Corollary 1 of [38]. On the other hand, recently, G. Liu (see Theorem of [37] showed that if M is a complete noncompact Kähler manifold with positive bisectional curvature, and it admits a nonconstant holomorphic function with polynomial growth, then M is of maximal volume growth. In Riemannian geometry context, Ding [] proved that on complete manifolds with Rc 0, maximal volume growth and the unique tangent cone at infinity, there exists nonconstant harmonic function with polynomial growth. Note when M n has nonnegative sectional curvature, from Theorem I. 6 in [1], the tangent cone at infinity of M n is the unique metric cone C(Y, where Y is a compact metric space. Hence Ding s existence result will imply the sufficient part of Conjecture 1.4. However we have some difficulties to verify the proof of Ding s existence result. For example, Lemma 1.1, Corollary 1.11 and Lemma 1. in[] does not hold for zero function. The main technical tool in [] is a generalization of the monotonicity of frequency for harmonic functions on R n, which is a type of three circles theorem in L sense on complete manifolds (also see [14,49] for related results. The classical Hadamard s three circles theorem was implied in the announcement [7] published in 1896, we state it as the following form, which is sort of consistent with our presentation in Theorems 3. and 3.4 of this paper. Theorem 1.5 (Hadamard s three circles theorem If f (z is a holomorphic function on {z r 4 z r} C, where r > 0 is some constant, then M(r/ M(r/4 M(r M(r/ (1.1 where M(s := max z =s { f (z }, The classical Hadamard three circles theorem for holomorphic functions had also been generalized to solutions of partial differential equations in different contexts by Simon [4], Cheeger and Tian [9], Liu [36]. In spite of our concerns about the argument in [], partially motivated by the results there, we proved two modified three circles theorems for harmonic functions in integral sense (see Theorems 3. and 3.4 in Sect. 3. Remark 1.6 One novel thing in one of our three circles theorems (Theorem 3. is that it can be applied for the collapsed case, i.e. the case that the maximal volume growth assumption does not hold. Also Theorem 3. is dealing with the integral J u, whose domain is different from the original one considered in [] (see Corollary
4 184 G. Xu there. View from the domains of the integral appearing in those results, Theorem 3. is more like a three disks theorem, and Ding s technical tool is based on a three annuli theorem. As one application of our three circles theorems, we proved the following theorem, which generalizes the existence result in []. Theorem 1.7 Let (M n, g be a complete manifold with nonnegative Ricci curvature, the tangent cone at infinity with renormalized limit measure is a unique metric cone C(X with the unique conic measure of power κ, and H 1 (X >0. Then and for any d > inf{α α D(M, α = 0}, inf{α α D(M, α = 0} < (1. dim ( H d (M (1.3 The conic measure of power κ and D(M will be defined in Sect.. Generally, we do not know the uniqueness of the renormalized limit measure with respect to one tangent cone at infinity of the manifold (compare Example 1.4 of [6]. However, from Theorem 5.9of[6], if (M n, g is a complete manifold with Rc 0 and maximal volume growth, then every tangent cone at infinity has its unique renormalized measure; and the measure is a multiple of Hausdorff measure H n, which is a conic measure of power n. Hence, Theorem 1.7 implies the existence result in [] mentioned above. The uniqueness of tangent cone at infinity is an important and hard problem, which was addressed in [9,0] for Ricci flat manifolds under various assumptions. Remark 1.8 When (M n, g is a complete manifold with Rc 0 and maximal volume growth, Honda [9] showeddim ( H d (M = 1 for any d < inf{α α D(M, α = 0}. Hence the conclusion of Theorem 1.7 seems to be a sharp result except that the critical case d = inf{α α D(M, α = 0} is not clear yet. To prove Theorem 1.7, we partially followed the strategy in []. Because our three circles theorem (Theorem 3. works for the collapsed case too, we succeeded in proving the existence of nonconstant harmonic functions with polynomial growth in the collapsed case first time, although with additional assumptions. More concretely, to construct one nonconstant harmonic function with polynomial growth, we firstly choose a suitable harmonic function of polynomial growth on the tangent cone at infinity of the manifold, where we used the assumptions that the manifold has the conic renormalized limit measure and the tangent cone at infinity is a metric cone. Then we use the results of Cheeger [4], to get a sequence of approximate functions defined on a sequence of increasing geodesic balls exhausting the manifold, which are vanishing at the same fixed point. Solving the Dirichlet problem on those geodesic balls with the same boundary conditions as the corresponding approximate functions, this yields a family of harmonic functions defined on the exhausting domains of the manifold. 13
5 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 185 Because the sequence of harmonic functions constructed as above have the asymptotic growth behavior as the chosen harmonic function of polynomial growth on the tangent cone at infinity, we can get that the ratio between the average integrals of those harmonic functions on bigger domain and smaller domain are uniformly bounded near infinity, where the bound depends on the growth rate of the harmonic function of polynomial growth on the tangent cone at infinity chosen above. If we can get some induction estimate of the ratios from outer domains to inner domains, the uniform polynomial bound of the family of harmonic functions will be obtained by the induction method. Then, after the suitable rescaling, using the wellknown Cheng-Yau s gradient estimate for harmonic functions in [10], combining with the Arzela Ascoli theorem, for some subsequence of these harmonic functions, we get the limit function defined on the whole manifold, which is harmonic function of polynomial growth. The nonconstancy of the limit function follows from its vanishing at the fixed point, and the non-vanishing of some local integral of the limit function, which resulted from the suitable chosen rescaling mentioned above. Our three circles theorem (Theorem 3. will play the role of the induction estimate needed in the above argument. Starting from the eigenfunctions expansion of harmonic functions on the metric cone with conic measure, the key idea to prove the three circles theorem, is to use the gap between the eigenvalues of the tangent cone s cross-section. When the tangent cone at infinity with renormalized limit measure is the unique metric cone with unique conic measure, this gap is implied by the discreteness of the spectrum of Laplace operator on the cross-section, and we get the last piece in the proof of Theorem 1.7. When nonconstant harmonic functions with polynomial growth exist on complete manifolds, as proved in [16], the bound of frequency is essential to describe the asymptotic structure of those functions (like the almost separation of variables. Hence a natural question is about the uniform bound of frequency of harmonic functions on manifolds. Based on the study in [16], Colding and Minicozzi posed the following conjecture: Conjecture 1.9 ([17] Suppose that M n has nonnegative Ricci curvature and maximal volume growth. If u H d (M for some d > 0, then the frequency of u is uniformly bounded. Remark 1.10 Besides [16,17], the frequency was also studied in [1,3]. For more related reference about the frequency, the reader can consult Remark.16 in [16].We would like to point out that the monotonicity of the frequency in Euclidean space can be viewed as the quantitative version of the classical three circles theorem. Roughly say, to get the uniform bound of the frequency, we only need to control the ratios of I (r on concentric circles with increasing radii. Checking the results and techniques developed in [16] carefully, the ratios have uniform bound on a sequence of concentric circles, whose radii are approaching the infinity. If a suitable three circles theorem is available, the uniform bound of ratios can be obtained by the induction method similar as the former argument, which will imply the uniform bound of the frequency. Hence, using the three circles theorem (Theorem 3.4 established in Sect. 3, we proved the following theorem: 13
6 186 G. Xu Theorem 1.11 Suppose that (M n, g has nonnegative Ricci curvature and maximal volume growth, also assume the tangent cone at infinity of M n is unique. Then for u(x H d (M, the frequency of u(x is uniformly bounded by C(u, n, V M, d. Remark 1.1 This theorem confirms Conjecture 1.9 with the additional assumption the uniqueness of the tangent cone at infinity of manifolds. In fact, we proved a stronger result which implies Theorem 1.11, see Theorem 5.5 in Sect. 5 for details. As we mentioned before, from [1], for any complete manifold with nonnegative sectional curvature, the tangent cone at infinity is a unique metric cone. From Theorem 1.7, we have the following corollary. Corollary 1.13 Suppose that (M n, g has nonnegative sectional curvature, the tangent cone at infinity with renormalized limit measure is a unique metric cone C(X with the unique conic measure of power κ, and H 1 (X >0. Then (1. and (1.3 hold. Remark 1.14 On non-negatively curved manifolds, maximal volume growth implies the uniqueness of the tangent cone at infinity and the conic renormalized limit measure of power κ = n and H n 1 (X >0, hence the sufficient part of Conjecture 1.4 is implied by Corollary On the other hand, there exists complete manifolds M n with positive sectional curvature, whose tangent cone at infinity C(X has the unique renormalized limit measure, which is conic measure of power κ and H 1 (X >0 (see Example 4.9. Hence by Corollary 1.13, Example 4.9 is a counterexample to the necessary part of Conjecture 1.4. The organization of this paper is as the following. In Sect., we stated some background facts about Gromov Hausdorff convergence and Cheeger Colding s theory, which are needed for later sections. We also recalled the definition of frequency function and the related formulas. In Sect. 3, we proved two three circles theorems, which are the key technical tools applicable for the existence and frequency problems respectively. For both theorems, the method is proof by contradiction and reduced the related analysis to the analysis on the tangent cone at infinity. In Sect. 4, we constructed the nonconstant harmonic function of polynomial growth from the harmonic function on the tangent cones at infinity. And the three circles theorem is used to guarantee the polynomial growth of the constructed harmonic function. We also constructed two example manifolds, which address the nonexistence and existence of harmonic functions with polynomial growth, under linear volume growth and at least quadratic volume growth assumptions respectively. Specially, one example is the first counterexample to the necessary part of Conjecture 1.4. In Sect. 5, using the other three circles theorem, combining the results and techniques developed in [16], we proved the uniform bound of frequency. Some technical results in this section are well-known from [16] in more general context, but we provide the details here to make our argument self-contained in this concrete case. 13
7 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 187 Background and notations In this section, we always assume that (M n, g is an n-dimensional complete manifold with Rc 0. We firstly review some background material about Gromov Hausdorff convergence and analysis on limit spaces. Let { (Mi n, p i,ρ i } be a sequence of pointed Riemannian manifolds, where p i Mi n and ρ i is the metric on Mi n.if{ (Mi n, p i,ρ i } converges to (M, p,ρ in the Gromov Hausdorff sense, we write (Mi n, p i,ρ i d GH (M, p,ρ. See [6] for the definition and basic facts concerning Gromov Hausdorff convergence. A metric space (M, p,ρ is a tangent cone at infinity of M n if it is a Gromov Hausdorff limit of a sequence of rescaled manifolds (M n, p, r j g, where r j. By Gromov s compactness theorem, [6], any sequence r j, has a subsequence, also denoted as r j, such that the rescaled manifolds (M n, p, r j g converge to some tangent cone at infinity M in the Gromov Hausdorff sense. Let us recall that from Bishop Gromov s volume comparison theorem, we can define the asymptotic volume ratio V (r V M = lim r r n (.1 where V (r is the volume of the geodesic ball B(r centered at p with radius r. And the above definition is independent of p, soweomitp there. If V M > 0, we say that (M n, g has maximal volume growth.notev M V0 n (1 from Bishop Gromov s volume comparison theorem, where Vk n (r is the volume of ball with radius r in the n-dimensional space form with sectional curvature equal to k. Example of Perelman [40] shows that tangent cone at infinity is not unique in general even if the manifold with Rc 0 has maximal volume growth and quadratic curvature decay. Although the tangent cone at infinity may be not unique, under maximal volume growth assumption, Cheeger and Colding proved the following theorem characterizing it: Theorem.1 ([5] Let M n be a complete manifold with Rc 0 and maximal volume growth, then every tangent cone at infinity M is a metric cone C(X, where X is a compact metric space and diam(x π. Note the metric on the metric cone C(X is dr + r dx, where r [0,. In the collapsed case (i.e. the maximal volume growth assumption does not hold, we can consider the renormalized measure on the limit space under the measured Gromov Hausdorff convergence. As in Section 9 of [4], we have the following definition. Definition. If ω i, ω are Borel regular measures on Mi n, M, we say that (Mi n, p i,ρ i,ω i converges to (M, p,ρ,ω in the measured Gromov Hausdorff sense, if(mi n, p i,ρ i d GH (M, p,ρ, in addition, for any x i x,(x i Mi n, x M, r > 0, we have ( ω i (B i (x i, r ω B (x, r 13
8 188 G. Xu where (M,ρ is a length space with length metric ρ, and B i (x i, r ={z M n i d ρ i (z, x i r}, B (x, r ={z M d ρ (z, x r} For later use, we also set up the following Blow Down Setup: Note that (M n, g,μ is a complete Riemannian manifold with Rc 0, where μ is the volume element determined by the metric g. We can define (M i, p,ρ i,ν i, where M i is the same differential manifold as M n, ρ i is the metric defined as ρ i = ri g, {r i } i=1 is an increasing positive sequence whose limit is, p is a fixed point on M i = M n, and ν i is the renormalized measure defined by ( 1 ( ν i (A := 1dμ i 1dμ i = ri n V (r i 1 μ i (A (. B i (1 A where A M i, B i (1 := {z M i d ρi (z, p 1}, and μ i is the volume element determined by ρ i. Then by Gromov s compactness theorem (see [6] and Theorem 1.6 in[6], after passing to a suitable subsequence, we have (M i, p,ρ i,ν i d GH (M, p,ρ,ν in the measured Gromov Hausdorff sense, where ν is the renormalized limit measure defined as in Section 1 of [6]. Let Z be a metric space and let ν be a Borel measure on Z. As in Section of [7], we define the associated Hausdorff measure in codimension 1 (denoted as ν 1 as follows. Fix δ>0and U Z, letb ={B ri (q i } be a covering of U with r i <δ, for all i. Put and (ν 1 δ (U = inf B i r 1 i ν ( B ri (q i (.3 ν 1 (U = lim δ 0 (ν 1 δ (U (.4 Definition.3 On a metric cone (C(X, dr + r dx, ν is called conic measure of powerκ, and κ is a positive constant denoted as p(ν, if for any C(X, ν( = r κ 1 dr χ( r dν 1 (.5 0 where r ={z z,r(z = r}, χ( is the characteristic function on C(X. If (M n, g is a complete manifold with Rc 0 and maximal volume growth, from Theorem.1 above and Theorem 5.9 in[6], every tangent cone at infinity of M n is a metric cone, with the unique corresponding renormalized limit measure, which is a conic measure of power n. In collapsing case, our definition of conic measure will play the role of co-area formula on metric cones in non-collapsing case, which was showed in Section 7 of [9]. 13 X
9 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 189 Assume that (M n, g is a complete manifold with Rc 0, all tangent cones at infinity are metric cones and every renormalized limit measure is conic measure, we define the set of all tangent cones at infinity of M n with renormalized limit measure as M (M := {(C(X, ν C(X is the metric tangent cone at infinity of M n, ν is the conic renormalized limit measure}. From [8] (also see [4], there exists a self-adjoint Laplace operator (C(X,ν on (C(X, ν M (M. From(.3 and (.4, ν induces a natural measure ν 1 on X, which satisfies a volume doubling property. Similar argument as in [1] (see Section 4 there, weak Poincaré inequality also holds on (X,ν 1. Hence from [8] (also see [4], volume doubling property, weak Poincaré inequality and the rectifiability of the cross section X yields the existence of a self-adjoint positive Laplace operator (X,ν 1 on (X,ν 1. When H 1 (X >0 where H i is i-dimensional Hausdorff measure, L (X is an infinite dimensional Hilbert space. Now from Rellich-type Compactness Theorem (Theorem 4.9 of[8], also see the Appendix of [46], similar as the standard elliptic theory on compact manifolds (see Chapter 6 in [45] etc., on compact metric measure space (X,ν 1, we have an orthonormal basis {ϕ i (x} i=1 for L (X, and a sequence 0 = λ 1 <λ λ 3, lim i λ i =, such that (X,ν 1 ϕ i (x = λ i ϕ i (x (.6 Now assume that (M n, g is a complete manifold with Rc 0, all tangent cones at infinity are metric cones and every renormalized limit measure is conic measure, and H 1 (X >0. Then we have the following proposition: Proposition.4 For any (C(X, ν M (M, assume that conic measure ν is of power κ>0, for any u(x H 1 0 (C(X, (C(X,ν u = u r + κ 1 u r r + 1 r (X,ν 1 u (.7 Proof For any w H0 1(C(X, by definition of (C(X,ν and (X,ν 1 (see Section 6 of [8], we can use integration by parts, combining with the definition of conic measure (.5, then (C(X,ν u wdν C(X ( = u wdν = r κ 1 u wdν 1 dr C(X 0 X ( ( = r κ 1 r u + 1 ( 0 X r xu r w + 1 r xw dν 1 (x dr ( = r κ 3 x u x wdν 1 (x dr r κ 1 r u r wdν 1 (x 0 X 0 X 13
10 190 G. Xu = r κ 1 1 ( 0 X r (X,ν 1 u w + r κ 1 u 0 X r + κ 1 u w (.8 r r [ u = C(X r + κ 1 u r r + 1 ] r (X,ν 1 u wdν (.9 where (.8 follows from the metric cone structure of C(X. From (.9, we obtain (.7. The following corollary is similar as Theorem 1.11 of [16] (also see [3], for completeness we provide its proof here following the argument in [16]. Corollary.5 If u is a harmonic function on (C(X, ν with respect to (C(X,ν, then u(r, x = c i r α i ϕ i (x (.10 i=1 where c i, α j 0 are constants, and ϕ j, λ j = α j ( κ + α j are defined in (.6. Proof We can assume that u(0 = 0. By the spectral theorem applied on (X,ν 1, u(1, x = a j ϕ j (x (.11 j=0 where the convergence is in L (X,ν 1 sense. On the other hand, from Proposition.4, it is not hard to prove that û(r, x = a j r α j ϕ j (x j=0 is a harmonic function on (C(X, ν, where α j (α j + κ = λ j and α j 0. Now consider the harmonic function ũ(r, x = u(r, x û(r, x From (.11, ũ vanishes on B 1 C(X and at the vertex 0. Then by the maximum principle, ũ 0. Hence (.10 follows. And we also define S (M the spectrum at infinity of (M n, g and D(M the degree spectrum at infinity of (M n, g: S (M := {λ λ = λ j (X,ν 1 f or some positive interger jand(c(x, ν M (M} D(M := {α 0 α ( κ + α = λ for someλ = λ j (X,ν 1 S (M and κ = p(ν} 13
11 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 191 We also define the convergence concept for functions on manifolds {Mi n } as the following, it is called uniform convergence in Gromov Hausdorff topology, for simplification, sometimes it is written as uniform convergence in G H topology. Definition.6 (Uniform Convergence in G H topology Suppose K i M n i d GH K M Assume that { f i } i=1 are functions on Mn i, f is a function on M. and i : K K i are ɛ i -Gromov Hausdorff approximations, lim i ɛ i = 0. If f i i converge to f d GH uniformly, we say that f i f uniformly over K i K. In the rest of this section, unless explicitly stated, (M n, g is an n-dimensional complete manifold with Rc 0 and maximal volume growth. We restrict our discussion to the case of n 3, fix p M n,letg(x denote the minimal positive Green s function on M n with singularity at p. And as in [17], we will normalize G(x by G(x = ( nv n 1 1 (πδ p (x (.1 From [44] (also see [30] and the maximal volume growth of the manifold, we know that G(x exists. Set b(x = ( VM V n 0 (1 G(x 1 n, ρ(x = d(p, x (.13 Note when M n is R n, the function b(x is just the distance function ρ(x.wealsouse B(r to denote the geodesic ball centered at p with radius r on M. And we have the following fact: ( 1 b(x lim ρ(x 0 ρ(x = VM n V0 n(1 (.14 We collect some important facts about b(x proved by Cheeger and Colding [5], Colding and Minicozzi [17], Colding [13] in the following. Theorem.7 ([5], [17], [13] lim r b(x r b 1 dx Vol(b(x r lim ρ(x where g is the metric tensor on M n. = lim r b(x r Hess(b g dx = 0; (.15 Vol(b(x r b(x = 1 ; ρ(x b 1 (.16 13
12 19 G. Xu Let us recall the definition of frequency function in [16], we firstly define: D u (r = r n b(x r then the frequency function is defined by I u (r = r 1 n u b dx (.17 b(x=r u dx, F u (r = r 3 n u b dx (.18 n b(x=r F u (r = D u(r I u (r (.19 where u(x is a harmonic function defined on {b(x r}. Using the fact that u is harmonic, differentiating (.17, we get I u (r = D u(r 0 (.0 r From (.0, I 1 (r is constant. Then by the fact (.14, it is not hard to see that I 1 (r = nv M (.1 We further define two quantities which are technically easier to be dealt with, comparing with D u and F u. E u (r = r n b(x r u b dx, W u (r = E u(r I u (r (. d GH Sometimes for simplification, we omit the subscript u in I u (r,..., W u (r when the context is clear, and use I (r,..., W (r instead. When M n is a complete manifold with Rc 0 and maximal volume growth, r j, assume that the rescaled manifolds (M n, p, r j g converge to some tangent cone at infinity M in the Gromov Hausdorff sense, From Theorem 0.1of[17], and Theorem 3.1, Corollary 4. of [1], we have the following proposition: Proposition.8 If K j and K are compact subsets of (M n, p, r g and M respectively, suppose K j K, then b j b uniformly over K j K, where b j and b are defined by (.13 on (M n, p, r j g and (M, p,ρ respectively, furthermore b = ρ. j d GH 3 Three Circles Theorems for harmonic functions Different types of three circles theorems were proved by Simon [4], Cheeger and Tian [9], Colding et al. [14] in different contexts. Also see Zhang [49], Ding [] for harmonic functions on manifolds and Liu [36] for holomorphic functions on Kähler manifolds. 13
13 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 193 However, to study Question 1.3, Conjecture 1.4 and Conjecture 1.9, we need to do some modification to get the three circles theorems applicable on those problems. Lemma 3.1 For {w i } i=1, w i 0, if then i=1 w i (α α i w i (3.1 i=1 i=1 α i w i (α α i w i (3. where 0 = α 1 <α α 3..., and α>0. Furthermore, the equality in (3. holds if and only if w i = 0 for all i satisfying α i = α. Proof (3.1 is equivalent to and (3. is equivalent to i=1 α i =α 1 w i (1 (α αi w 1 ( α 1 (3.3 α i =α 1 αi w i (1 (α αi w 1 ( α 1 (3.4 Note αi w i (1 (α αi α w i (1 (α αi (3.5 α i =α 1 α i =α 1 If α i =α 1 w i (1 (α α i 0, from (3.5, α i =α 1 αi w i (1 (α αi 0 w 1 ( α 1 If α i =α 1 w i (1 (α α i >0, from (3.3 α i =α 1 αi w i (1 (α αi α w 1 ( α 1 <w 1 ( α 1 Hence (3.4 is proved, and (3. is obtained. Check the above argument carefully, it is easy to find that the equality in (3. holds if and only if w i = 0 for all i satisfying α i = α. 13
14 194 G. Xu On (M n, g,μwhere μ is a Borel regular measure on M n, define the J-function of u as the following: J u (r = 1 u dμ (3.6 μ(b(r B(r Unless otherwise mentioned, for J u (r in (3.6, the measure μ will be assumed as the volume measure determined by the metric g. Theorem 3. Let (M n, g be a complete manifold with nonnegative Ricci curvature, assume that every tangent cone at infinity of M n is a metric cone C(X with the conic renormalized limit measure of power κ, and H 1 (X >0. Ifα / D(M, then there exists integer k 0 = k 0 (α > 1, such that for r k 0, and u(x harmonic over B(r (M n, g, ( r J u (r α J u (3.7 implies ( r ( r J u α J u 4 (3.8 Proof By contradiction. If Theorem 3. is not true, then there exists a sequence {r l }, r l, and the corresponding harmonic functions u l such that the following inequalities hold: ( J ul (r l α rl J ul ( rl, J ul ( > α rl J ul 4 (3.9 Using the assumptions about tangent cones with renormalized limit measure, combining the knowledge about measured Gromov Hausdorff convergence, without loss of generality (by choosing subsequence of {u l }, we assume (M n, p,ρ l,ν i converges to (C(Y, p,ρ,ν in the measured Gromov Hausdorff sense as in Blow Down Setup of Sect., and (C(Y, ν is a metric cone with conic measure. Clearly (3.9 implies J ul ( r l = 0, define ũ l = u l ( J ul ( r l 1 Look at ũ l as the function on B l (1 (M n, g l, from (3.9 ( ( ( J (l ũ l (1 α J (l 1 ũ l, J (l 1 ũ l > α J (l 1 ũ l 4 (3.10 where J (l ũ l 13 is the J-function of ũ l on manifold (M n, g l,ν l.alsowehave
15 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 195 ( J (l 1 ũ l ( rl = Jũl = 1 (3.11 From Theorem 1. in[3] and Cheng-Yau s gradient estimate in [10], we have the following estimates: [ sup ũ l C(n, p,θ J (l ] 1 ( ] 1 (1 C(n, p,θ,α[ J (l 1 B (l ũ l ũ = C(n, p,θ,α l (1 θ sup ũ l gl C(n, p,θ,α B (l (1 θ So for any θ (0, 1, ũ l and ũ l are uniformly bounded over B (l (1 θ.by Harnack s convergence theorem in the Gromov Hausdorff sense (see [1], also [46], we get that {ũ l } converges uniformly on compact subsets of B (1 C(Y to u, and u is harmonic over B (1. Hence, ( ( lim J (l 1 1 l ũ l = J u (3.1 where J u is the J-function of u on (C(Y, ρ,ν defined as in (3.6. By u is harmonic over B (1 C(Y, asin(.10 we can write u = c i r α i ϕ i (x (3.13 i=1 where {ϕ i (x} are the eigenfunctions of Y on Y, also the orthonormal basis for L (Y, Y ϕ i (x = λ i ϕ i (x, λ i = α i (α i + n and α i 0. From (3.10, we get u dν = lim B (1 k lim l B (1 1 k u dν = lim lim k l ũl dν l α lim B l (1 l V (r l V ( r l B l (1 1 k B l ( 1 ũ l dν l ũ l dν l = B α+κ ( u 1 dν (3.14 u B ( 1 dν α+κ ( u B 14 dν (3.15 in the last equality of (3.14 we used the assumption that the renormalized limit measure is conic measure of degree κ. 13
16 196 G. Xu Plug (3.13 into(3.14 and (3.15, we get w i (α α i w i, i=1 i=1 α i w i (α α i w i i=1 i=1 c i α i +κ. where w i = From the above two inequalities, by Lemma 3.1 and the assumption α / D(M, we get w i = 0 and c i = 0, hence u 0. Taking limit in (3.11, combining (3.1 and u = 0, we obtain ( ( 1 = lim J (l 1 1 l ũ l = J u = 0 It is the contradiction, hence the conclusion is proved. Recall we defined I u in (.17 for harmonic functions u(x, we have the other three circles theorems for I u, which will be useful for estimating the frequency of u(x. Before proving the theorem, we firstly need to control the C 0 and C 1 norm of u(x by I u, which is achieved by the following lemma. Lemma 3.3 Assume that (M n, g is an n-dimensional complete manifold with Rc 0 and maximal volume growth, u(p = 0 and u(x is harmonic on {b r} M n. Then for any θ (0, 1 and r > 0, Proof From I (r = D(r r,wehave hence sup u C(n, p,θ,v M I u (r (3.16 b (1 θr sup b (1 θr u C(n, p,θ,v M r I u (r (3.17 r ( 1 θ r D(s s = I (r I (( 1 θ r I (r r ( s n D(sds r n 1 I (r ( θ r by the definition of D(r, s n D(s is nondecreasing, and therefore (3.18 yields θr (( 1 θ n (( r D 1 θ r r n 1 I (r 13
17 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 197 After simplification, we get (( D 1 θ r C(n,θI (r (3.19 Assume that u (x 0 = sup b (1 θr u and b(x 0 = r 0 (1 θr. From (.16, there exists r 1 = C(p, V M,θr > 0 such that B x0 (r 1 {b ( 1 θ r}, hence by Theorem 1. in[3], u (x 0 (( C(n V ( B x0 (r 1 u C(n, p,θ,v M r D 1 θ r B x0 (r 1 Combining (3.19, we obtain sup u C(n, p,θ,v M r I (r (3.0 b (1 θr By integrating (3.0 along geodesics starting at p and using u(p = 0, sup u C(n, p,θ,v M I (r b (1 θr Theorem 3.4 Assume that (M n, g is an n-dimensional complete manifold with Rc 0 and maximal volume growth, α/ D(M, then there exists integer k 0 = k 0 (α > 1, such that for r k 0,u(x harmonic over B(r (M n, g and u(p = 0, ( r I u (r α I u (3.1 implies ( r ( r I u α I u 4 (3. Proof By contradiction. If Theorem 3.4 is not true, then there exists a sequence {r l }, r l, and the corresponding harmonic functions u l such that the following inequalities hold: I ul (r l α I ul ( rl ( rl, I ul ( > α rl I ul, u l (p = 0 (3.3 4 Without loss of generality (by choosing subsequence of {u l }, we can assume that (M n, p,ρ l d GH (C(X, p,ρ (3.4 where ρ l = g l = rl g is the rescaled metric, and C(X is one tangent cone at infinity of (M n, g, which is a metric cone by Theorem.1. 13
18 198 G. Xu Clearly (3.3 implies I ul ( r l = 0, define ũ l = ( Iul ( rl u l 1 Look at ũ l as the function on B l (1 (M n, g l,wehave ( ( ( I (l ũ l (1 α I (l 1 ũ l, I (l 1 ũ l > α I (l 1 ũ l, ũ l (p = 0 (3.5 4 where I (l ũ l is the frequency function of ũ l on manifold (M n, g l, and ( I (l 1 ũ l ( rl = Iũl = 1 (3.6 From Lemma 3.3 and (3.5, we have the following estimates, [ sup ũ l C(n, p,θ,v M I (l 1 [ ũ l (1] C(n, p,θ,v M,α I (l ũ l ( 1 ] 1 b l (1 θ = C(n, p,θ,v M,α sup ũ l gl C(n, p,θ,v M,α b l (1 θ where b l is the b(x function defined as in (.13 on(m n, p, g l. So for any θ (0, 1, ũ l and ũ l are uniformly bounded over {b l (1 θ}.by Harnack s convergence theorem in the Gromov Hausdorff sense (see [1], also [46], we get that {ũ l } converges uniformly on compact subsets of {b < 1} C(X to u, and u is harmonic over {b < 1}. From Proposition 3.4 in[9], we have ( ( lim I (l 1 1 l ũ l = I u (3.7 By u is harmonic over {b < 1}, asin(.10 we can write u = c i r α i ϕ i (x (3.8 i=1 where {ϕ i (x} are the eigenfunctions of X on X, also the orthonormal basis for L (X, X ϕ i (x = λ i ϕ i (x, λ i = α i (α i + n and α i 0. From (3.5, note b = ρ on C(X, again by Proposition 3.4 in[9] { ( 1 1 } b =1 13 u = lim ( u k b = 1 k 1 = lim k lim l I (l ũ l (1 lim l α I (l ũ l ( 1 k = α+n 1 n 1 lim l I (l ũ l (1 1 k b = 1 u (3.9
19 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 199 b = 1 u α+n 1 b = 1 4 u (3.30 in the first inequality of (3.9 we used the fact I (r is nondecreasing in r.plug(3.8 into (3.9 and (3.30, we get w i (α α i w i, i=1 i=1 α i w i (α α i w i i=1 i=1 where w i = c i. From the above two inequalities and Lemma 3.1, c i = 0, hence u 0. Taking limit in (3.6, combining (3.7 and u = 0, we obtain ( ( 1 = lim I (l 1 1 l ũ l = I u = 0 It is the contradiction, hence the conclusion is proved. 4 The existence of harmonic functions with polynomial growth In the following lemma, we assume that (M n, g is a complete manifold with Rc 0, and every tangent cone at infinity of M n with renormalized limit measure is a metric cone C(X with conic measure of power κ, and H 1 (X >0. Lemma 4.1 Assume u is harmonic on C(X M (M and u (p = 0, then there exist R i,b(r i M n (, such that lim i d GH Bi (1, B (1 = 0, where B i (1 (M n, Ri g, B (1 C(X, and u i harmonic on B p (R i = B i (1 satisfying the following property: lim u i,i u ( i L B (1 = 0, ui (p = 0 (4.1 where,i : B (1 B i (1 is an ɛ i -Gromov Hausdorff approximation, and lim i ɛ i = 0. Remark 4. The above lemma was inspired by Theorem.1 of[], however there is a small (but new restriction on u i (u i (p = 0 in our statement, which is crucial in our proof of Theorem 4.3. Proof It follows from Lemma 10.7 in[4], there exists Lipschitz function ũ i defined on (M n, Ri g such that lim ũ i,i u ( i L B (1 = 0 ; Lip(ũi C (4. 13
20 1300 G. Xu where C is some positive constant independent of i, and Lip( f := sup z B (1 lim inf r 0 sup d(z,y=r f (y f (z r Let û i be the solution of the following Dirichlet problem: { ûi = 0, on B i (1 û i =ũ i, on B i (1 (4.3 By (4. and Lemma 10.7 in[4], ũ i Bi (1 is uniformly bounded. From maximum principle on B i (1, û i are uniformly bounded. Let x i B i (1, x i x B (1. For any ɛ>0, from (4. there exists δ (0, 1 such that ũ i (x ũ i (x i < ɛ if x x i <δ On the cone C(X there is a unique ray starting from the pole p, passing through x. Pick a point q on this ray with d (p, q >d (p, x, then d (x, q >d(x, q, x {z d (z, x <δ} B (1 Hence we can choose q i q such that Consider d ρi (q i, x d ρi (q i, x i, x {z d ρi (z, x i <δ} B i (1 w i (x = d ρi (q i, x i n d ρi (q i, x n By the Laplacian comparison theorem, i w i 0, and it is easy to see that w i 0on {z d ρi (z, x i <δ} B i (1, w i (x i = 0. Hence it is the barrier function defined as in Section.8 of[4]. Now let M = sup i sup x Bi (1 ũ i(x <, using the fact lim w i(y i = d (q, x n d (q, y n if y i y (4.4 i hence there exists constant k > 0, which is independent of i, such that when i >> 1, kw i (x M if x x i δ Then it is easy to check ( ũ i (x i + ɛ + kw i(x û i (x Bi 0, (1 13
21 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 1301 ( ũ i (x i + ɛ + kw i(x û i (x 0 From maximum principle, in B i (1, Similarly in B i (1, wehave Hence ũ i (x i + ɛ + kw i(x û i (x ũ i (x i ɛ kw i(x û i (x û i (x ũ i (x i ɛ + kw i(x x B i (1 (4.5 Note k is independent of i, using the fact (4.4 again, we get δ 0 > 0, such that for x i B i (1, d ρi (x, x i δ 0 implies û i (x ũ i (x i ɛ for any i >> 1. In fact, from (4.5, we can obtain that û i are uniformly continuous near boundary of B i (1. Combining with the Cheng-Yau s gradient estimate, û i are uniformly continuous on B i (1. From Harnack s convergence theorem in the Gromov Hausdorff sense (see [1], also [46], û i converges to w on B (1, i.e. lim û i,i w ( i L B (1 = 0 (4.6 From (4., (4.3 and (4.6, we get that w B (1 = u B (1. From maximum principle on C(X, w = u on B (1. We get lim û i,i u ( i L B (1 = 0 Choose u i (x =û i (x û i (p, note û i (p u (p = 0, then lim u i,i u ( i L B (1 = 0 The conclusion is obtained. Theorem 4.3 Let (M n, g be a complete manifold with nonnegative Ricci curvature, assume that every tangent cone at infinity of M n with renormalized limit measure is a metric cone C(X with conic measure of power κ, and H 1 (X >0. If there exists d / D(M and d > inf{α α D(M, α = 0}, then dim ( H d (M. Proof By assumption, there exists α 1 D(M, α 1 = 0 and α 1 < d. Hence there is C(X M (M, and ϕ 1 (x is the eigenfunction on X with respect to eigenvalue λ 1 = α 1 (α 1 + κ, X ϕ 1 = 1. Let u = r α 1ϕ 1 (x in Lemma 4.1, then choose {u i } from Lemma 4.1. We have the following lemma: 13
22 130 G. Xu Lemma 4.4 For any given positive constant r 0 (0, 1, there exists i 0 = i 0 (d α 1, r 0 >0 such that if i i 0, for any r [r 0 R i, R i ], ( r J ui (r d J ui (4.7 Proof By contradiction. If the lemma is not true, without loss of generality, we can assume that for some r 0 (0, 1, there exists a subsequence of {i} 1, for simplicity also denoted as {i} 1 such that ( J ui (r i > d ri J ui (4.8 where r i [r 0 R i, R i ]. Note Ri 1 r i [r 0, 1], without loss of generality, we can assume that there exists a subsequence of {i}, for simplicity also denoted as {i} such that lim i R 1 i r i = c 0 [r 0, 1] (4.9 where c 0 is some constant. Taking the limit in (4.8, from (4.9 and Lemma 4.1 we get 1 u d dν ( ν (B (c 0 B (c 0 ν B ( c 0 ( c0 u dν (4.10 B From u = r α 1ϕ 1 (x and d > α 1,(4.10 implies X ϕ 1(x dx = 0, which is contradiction. Note d / D(M, from Theorem 3. and induction method, there exists k 0 = k 0 (d such that for r [ k 0 ], R i,(4.7 holds, where we choose i big enough such that i i 0 (d α 1, r 0, R i > k 0 and u i 0. Now we define ǔ i (x = u i(x ( (4.11 J k0 ui then ( k0 Jǔi = 1, ǔ i (p = 0 (4.1 Note the scaling invariant property of (4.7, hence there exists i 0 > 0, if i i 0,for r [ k 0, R i ], Jǔi (r d Jǔi ( r, and we get 13
23 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 1303 ( Jǔi (r ( d ln r ( k0 +1 r d Jǔi (k 0 = ( d Jǔi k (k 0 ( By Theorem 1. of[3], ǔ i (x C(n, pjǔi ( ρ(x (4.14 recall that ρ(x = d(x, p. From (4.13 and (4.14, when i i 0,forρ(x [ k 0 4, R i ], ǔ i (x C(n, p, d, k 0 ρ(x d (4.15 Combining with the Cheng-Yau s gradient estimate in [10] and the Arzela Ascoli theorem, after taking suitable subsequence, ǔ i converges to a polynomial growth harmonic function u(x on M n.from(4.1, we know that u(x is not constant. The conclusion is proved. Proof of Theorem.1.7 When the tangent cone at infinity of M n with renormalized limit measure is the unique metric cone with conic measure, denoted as (C(X, ν, then D(M is a countable set by the fact that the spectrum of (X,ν 1 is a discrete set. Hence we can find d / D(M and d > inf{α α D(M, α = 0}, from Theorem 4.3, the conclusion is proved. Lemma 4.5 Suppose (M n, g has nonnegative sectional curvature, and for some fixed constants κ>1,a 0 > 0, V (B(x, s lim s s κ = a 0 (4.16 where the convergence in (4.16 is uniform for all x M n. Then the tangent cone at infinity of M n with renormalized limit measure is a unique metric cone C(X with unique conic measure ν of power κ, H κ 1 (X >0 and κ is an integer. Remark 4.6 If (4.16 holds uniformly for all x M n, we will say (M n, g has uniform asymptotic polynomial volume growth of degree κ. Proof Assume x i x, r i, then B i (x i, r B (x, r, wehave μ i (B i (x i, r ν(b (x, r = lim i μ i (B i (p, 1 = lim μ(b(x i, r i r i μ(b(p, r i = r κ lim i μ(b(x i, r i r a 0 (r i r κ = r κ (4.17 where the last equation follows from the uniform convergence of (4.16. From the definition of Hausdorff dimension, using (4.17, we obtain that the Hausdorff dimension of C(X is κ and H κ (C(X > 0. Because C(X is a metric cone on metric space X, it is not hard to get that the Hausdorff dimension of X is (κ 1 and H κ 1 (X >0. 13
24 1304 G. Xu By Theorem 5.5 of[8] and the definitions of Ahlfors l-regular and ν-rectifiable (Definition s 5.1 and 5.3 in[8], where l is some non-negative number, using (4.17, we obtain that ν is Ahlfors κ-regular at all x C(X, and κ must be a non-negative integer. By assumption κ>1, we proved that κ is an integer. From the Definition.3 and (4.17, it is straightforward to verify that ν is a conic measure of power κ. From the above Lemma and Theorem 1.7, we have the following corollary. Corollary 4.7 Suppose (M n, g has nonnegative sectional curvature and uniform asymptotic polynomial volume growth of degree κ, and κ>1, then (1. and (1.3 hold. Example 4.8 (Ding s example On R n, we define the warped product metric g = dr + f (rds n 1, where S n 1 is the classical (n 1-dimensional unit sphere, f (r is defined by modifying the famous symmetric mollifier e 1 1 r as the following : a b exp f (r = 1 ( 1 r+3 4 1, 0 r < a, r { where b = a exp }, a = (4.18 ( The number is chosen in (4.18, because it is the inflection point of the symmetric mollifier e 1 1 r. It is straightforward to check that Rc(g 0 by the above definition of f (r and the metric g is smooth. And it is obvious that (R n, g has linear volume growth and will not split isometrically. Hence by Theorem 1., there does not exist any nonconstant harmonic function of polynomial growth on (R n, g. Example 4.9 (Counterexample of Ni s Conjecture Let us start from the generalized Hopf fibration of S 7 as the following: S 3 S 7 π S 4, g S7 = k 1 + k where S 3, S 7, S 4 carry the metrics g S3, g S7, 4 1 gs4 ; π is a Riemannian submersion with totally geodesic fibers and k 1 = g S3, k = π ( 1 4 g S4 ; g S n denotes the canonical metric of curvature 1onS n. Then for metric g = dr + f (rk 1 + h (rk on M 8, which is diffeomorphic to R 8, from (8.13 in [6] and Section in [], we have 13 Rm(X 1, X, X 1, X = 1 f (r Rm(X, Y, X, Y = f h 4 f h f h ( f (r (4.19 f (r (4.0
25 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 1305 Rm(Y 1, Y, Y 1, Y = 4 h 3 f ( h h 4 h (4.1 Rm( r, X, r, X = f, Rm( r, Y, r, Y = h f h (4. where X 1, X, X T S 3 and Y 1, Y, Y T S 4. In the following a, δ, {c i } i=0 6 are positive constants to be determined later, set f (r = { 1a sin(ar, 0 r δ f(r δ, r >δ (4.3 h(r = { 1a sin(ar, 0 r δ h(r δ, r >δ (4.4 where f and h are defined as the following: f(x := c 1 c e c 3x, h(x := c 0 + c 4 x c 5 e c 6x, x 0 It is easy to see that the metric g = dr + f (rk 1 + h (rk has positive sectional curvature when 0 r δ, in the following we will try to find suitable constants a, δ, {c i } i=0 6 such that the C -metric g has positive sectional curvature when r >δ. If a, δ, {c i } i=0 6 are positive constants satisfying the following eight assumptions: a = ( c c3 1, (4.5 c 1 c c 1 = c + 1 c c 3 c c3, (4.6 δ = a 1 sin 1 [ a(c 1 c ], (4.7 c 0 c 5 = c 1 c, (4.8 c 5 c6 = c c3, (4.9 c 4 + c 5 c 6 = c c 3, (4.30 c 6 > c 3, (4.31 c 0 3c + c 5 (4.3 Note that there are many choices of a, δ, {c i } i=0 6 satisfying the above eight assumptions, and the following is one choice satisfying all the above assumptions: a = 1 3, δ = π, c 0 = , c 1 = 4, c = 1, c 3 = 1, c 4 = 1 4, c 5 = 1 4, c 6 = 1 13
26 1306 G. Xu Define s(r := a 1 sin(ar,by(4.5, (4.6 and (4.7, we have s(δ = f(0, s (δ = f (0, s (δ = f (0 (4.33 which implies that f (r is a C function on [0,. And by (4.8, (4.9 and (4.30, f(0 = h(0, f (0 = h (0, f (0 = h (0 (4.34 And (4.34 combining with (4.33 yields that h is a also a C function on [0,. From the definition of f (r, h(r and the formula (4., it is easy to get Rm( r, X, r, X >0, Rm( r, Y, r, Y >0 (4.35 Now we consider (h(x f(x,using(4.31, (h(x f(x = c c 3 e c 6x ( e (c 6 c 3 x 1 0, x 0 (4.36 On the other hand, from (4.34, (h f (0 = 0. Then by (4.36 Again, by (4.34 and (4.37, (h f (x (h f (0 = 0, x 0 (4.37 From (4.6, (4.8 and (4.3, we get (h f(x (h f(0 = 0, x 0 ( c c 3 c c 3 = c 1 c = c 0 c 5 3c simplifying it yields c c 3 1 (4.39 Then h (0 = f (0 = c c 3 1,byh (x <0, h (x <h (0 1 (4.40 From (4.37, (4.40 and (4.19, we obtain that when r >δ, 13 Rm(X 1, X, X 1, X >0 (4.41
27 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 1307 From (4.38, (4.40 and (4.1, when r >δ, Rm(Y 1, Y, Y 1, Y = h( 4 (h 3f h 4 > 3(h f h 4 0 (4.4 Now consider ϕ(x := f 3 (x h 3 (xf (xh (x, note On the other hand, using h < 0, ϕ(0 = h 3 (0(1 f (0 >0 (4.43 ϕ (x = 3f f 3h (h f h 3 f h h 3 f h > h h ( f h 3f h (4.44 and f h 3f h = ( c c 3 e c 3x [ ] c 0 c 3 + c 3 c 4 x 3c 4 (c 3 c 5 + 3c 5 c 6 e c 6x ( c c 3 e c 3x [ ] c 0 c 3 3c 4 (c 3 c 5 + 3c 5 c 6 = ( c c 3 e c 3x [ c 0 c 3 3c c 3 c 5 c 3 ] 0 (4.45 in the last equation above we used (4.30, and in the last inequality we used (4.3. Combining (4.44 with (4.45, we obtain From (4.43 and (4.46, By (4.47 and (4.0, when r >δ, x = r δ>0, ϕ (x >0 (4.46 ϕ(x >0, x 0 (4.47 Rm(X, Y, X, Y = ϕ(x f(x h 4 (x > 0 (4.48 From (4.35, (4.41, (4.4 and (4.48, the metric g = dr + f (rk 1 + h (rk on M 8 has positive sectional curvature, where f, g are defined in (4.3 and (4.4. It is not hard to see that this metric also has the uniform asymptotic polynomial volume growth of degree 5 as in (4.16 and Remark 4.6. Then by Corollary 4.7, there exists nonconstant harmonic function of polynomial growth on (M 8, g, but(m 8, g does not have maximal volume growth. This disproves the necessary part of Conjecture
28 1308 G. Xu 5 Uniform bound of frequency function Much of argument in this section followed the detailed analysis about frequency functionin[16] (especially Proposition 3.3, Proposition 3.36, Proposition 4.11 and Lemma 7.1 there. We are providing details here again to make our argument self-contained and concrete enough for our purpose, some more general argument can be found in [16]. In this section, I (r, D(r, E(r, F(r, F (r and W (r are defined as in Sect. with respect to some nonconstant function u H d (M. Further assume that u(p = 0, where p M n. The following Lemma is a weak version of a uniform Harnack inequality for harmonic function with polynomial growth. Lemma 5.1 For nonconstant u H d (M, there exists positive increasing sequence {r i } i=1 such that lim i r i = and for any i D( 4n+1 r i 10nd D(r i Proof By contradiction. If the conclusion does not hold, there exists R 0 1, such that D( 4n+1 r> 10nd D(r when r R 0 by induction we get that for any j = 1,, 3,... D( (4n+1 j R 0 > 10ndj D(R 0 (5.1 On the other side, by u H d (M and Corollary 3. in Chapter 1 of [41], sup u C(n sup u C(n, dr d 1, r 1 (5. B(r r B(r From (.16 and V (r V n 0 (1r n, there exists C 1 > 0 such that for any r > 0, By (5.1 amd(5.3, which implies D(r = r n b(x r u(x dx C 1 (r d + 1 (5.3 C 1 [ ( (4n+1 j R 0 d + 1 ] > 10ndj D(R 0 13 ( n jd + 10ndj > D(R 0 C 1 R d 0
29 Three circles theorems for harmonic functions 1309 let j in the above, we get 0 D(R 0. However, D(R C 1 R0 d 0 >0because u is nonconstant, which is the contradiction. Lemma 5. (Equivalence of E and D For ɛ>0, there exists R 1 = R 1 (ɛ, p, n, V M, γ>0 such that for r R 1,if D( 4n+1 r γ D(r (5.4 then for s [r, 4n r], ln ( D(s ɛ (5.5 E(s Proof From Theorem.7, for given δ>0, there exists R = R(p,δ > 0 such that for ρ(x = r R, ln b(x δ, ρ(x b(x r b 1 dx δ Vol(b(x r (5.6 where δ>0istobedetermined later. From Cauchy Schwarz inequality, b 1 δvol(b r (5.7 Then for s [r, 4n r], b r D(s E(s =s n b s u (1 b s n sup b(x s u (x δvol(b s C(δ, ns sup u (x (5.8 b(x s in the first inequality above we used (5.7, and we have lim δ 0 C(δ, n = 0. Without loss of generality, assume e δ 4 3. From Theorem 1. in[3] and (5.6 above, sup u (x sup u C(n b(x 4n r B( 43 Vol(B( 3 4n r 4n B( u 3 r 4n r C(n ( 3 n u V M 4n r b 4n+1 r in the last inequality we used (5.4. C(n, V M r D( 4n+1 r C(n, V M γ D(rr (5.9 13
ICM 2014: The Structure and Meaning. of Ricci Curvature. Aaron Naber ICM 2014: Aaron Naber
Outline of Talk Background and Limit Spaces Structure of Spaces with Lower Ricci Regularity of Spaces with Bounded Ricci Characterizing Ricci Background: s (M n, g, x) n-dimensional pointed Riemannian
More informationA new proof of Gromov s theorem on groups of polynomial growth
A new proof of Gromov s theorem on groups of polynomial growth Bruce Kleiner Courant Institute NYU Groups as geometric objects Let G a group with a finite generating set S G. Assume that S is symmetric:
More informationPseudo-Poincaré Inequalities and Applications to Sobolev Inequalities
Pseudo-Poincaré Inequalities and Applications to Sobolev Inequalities Laurent Saloff-Coste Abstract Most smoothing procedures are via averaging. Pseudo-Poincaré inequalities give a basic L p -norm control
More information1 The Heisenberg group does not admit a bi- Lipschitz embedding into L 1
The Heisenberg group does not admit a bi- Lipschitz embedding into L after J. Cheeger and B. Kleiner [CK06, CK09] A summary written by John Mackay Abstract We show that the Heisenberg group, with its Carnot-Caratheodory
More informationGeometry of Ricci Solitons
Geometry of Ricci Solitons H.-D. Cao, Lehigh University LMU, Munich November 25, 2008 1 Ricci Solitons A complete Riemannian (M n, g ij ) is a Ricci soliton if there exists a smooth function f on M such
More informationRICCI CURVATURE: SOME RECENT PROGRESS A PROGRESS AND OPEN QUESTIONS
RICCI CURVATURE: SOME RECENT PROGRESS AND OPEN QUESTIONS Courant Institute September 9, 2016 1 / 27 Introduction. We will survey some recent (and less recent) progress on Ricci curvature and mention some
More informationEigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the Laplacian. Andrew Hassell
Eigenvalues and eigenfunctions of the Laplacian Andrew Hassell 1 2 The setting In this talk I will consider the Laplace operator,, on various geometric spaces M. Here, M will be either a bounded Euclidean
More informationThe Ricci Flow Approach to 3-Manifold Topology. John Lott
The Ricci Flow Approach to 3-Manifold Topology John Lott Two-dimensional topology All of the compact surfaces that anyone has ever seen : These are all of the compact connected oriented surfaces without
More informationRESEARCH STATEMENT GANG LIU
RESEARCH STATEMENT GANG LIU My mathematical research is mainly in geometric analysis. Currently I am interested in studying the geometry of Kähler manifolds by using the Gromov-Hausdorff convergence technique.
More informationRegularity of Einstein manifolds and the codimension 4 conjecture
Annals of Mathematics 182 (2015), 1093 1165 Regularity of Einstein manifolds and the codimension 4 conecture By Jeff Cheeger and Aaron Naber Abstract In this paper, we are concerned with the regularity
More informationPerelman s proof of the Poincaré conjecture
University of California, Los Angeles Clay/Mahler Lecture Series In a series of three papers in 2002-2003, Grisha Perelman solved the famous Poincaré conjecture: Poincaré conjecture (1904) Every smooth,
More informationON THE REGULARITY OF SAMPLE PATHS OF SUB-ELLIPTIC DIFFUSIONS ON MANIFOLDS
Bendikov, A. and Saloff-Coste, L. Osaka J. Math. 4 (5), 677 7 ON THE REGULARITY OF SAMPLE PATHS OF SUB-ELLIPTIC DIFFUSIONS ON MANIFOLDS ALEXANDER BENDIKOV and LAURENT SALOFF-COSTE (Received March 4, 4)
More informationNOTE ON ASYMPTOTICALLY CONICAL EXPANDING RICCI SOLITONS
PROCEEDINGS OF THE AMERICAN MATHEMATICAL SOCIETY Volume 00, Number 0, Pages 000 000 S 0002-9939(XX)0000-0 NOTE ON ASYMPTOTICALLY CONICAL EXPANDING RICCI SOLITONS JOHN LOTT AND PATRICK WILSON (Communicated
More informationAnalysis in weighted spaces : preliminary version
Analysis in weighted spaces : preliminary version Frank Pacard To cite this version: Frank Pacard. Analysis in weighted spaces : preliminary version. 3rd cycle. Téhéran (Iran, 2006, pp.75.
More informationHeat kernels of some Schrödinger operators
Heat kernels of some Schrödinger operators Alexander Grigor yan Tsinghua University 28 September 2016 Consider an elliptic Schrödinger operator H = Δ + Φ, where Δ = n 2 i=1 is the Laplace operator in R
More informationERRATUM TO AFFINE MANIFOLDS, SYZ GEOMETRY AND THE Y VERTEX
ERRATUM TO AFFINE MANIFOLDS, SYZ GEOMETRY AND THE Y VERTEX JOHN LOFTIN, SHING-TUNG YAU, AND ERIC ZASLOW 1. Main result The purpose of this erratum is to correct an error in the proof of the main result
More informationHouston Journal of Mathematics c 2009 University of Houston Volume 35, No. 1, 2009
Houston Journal of Mathematics c 2009 University of Houston Volume 35, No. 1, 2009 ON THE GEOMETRY OF SPHERES WITH POSITIVE CURVATURE MENG WU AND YUNHUI WU Communicated by David Bao Abstract. For an n-dimensional
More informationLiouville Properties for Nonsymmetric Diffusion Operators. Nelson Castañeda. Central Connecticut State University
Liouville Properties for Nonsymmetric Diffusion Operators Nelson Castañeda Central Connecticut State University VII Americas School in Differential Equations and Nonlinear Analysis We consider nonsymmetric
More informationGradient Estimates and Sobolev Inequality
Gradient Estimates and Sobolev Inequality Jiaping Wang University of Minnesota ( Joint work with Linfeng Zhou) Conference on Geometric Analysis in honor of Peter Li University of California, Irvine January
More informationSection 6. Laplacian, volume and Hessian comparison theorems
Section 6. Laplacian, volume and Hessian comparison theorems Weimin Sheng December 27, 2009 Two fundamental results in Riemannian geometry are the Laplacian and Hessian comparison theorems for the distance
More informationTHE FUNDAMENTAL GROUP OF MANIFOLDS OF POSITIVE ISOTROPIC CURVATURE AND SURFACE GROUPS
THE FUNDAMENTAL GROUP OF MANIFOLDS OF POSITIVE ISOTROPIC CURVATURE AND SURFACE GROUPS AILANA FRASER AND JON WOLFSON Abstract. In this paper we study the topology of compact manifolds of positive isotropic
More informationBounding scalar curvature and diameter along the Kähler Ricci flow (after Perelman) and some applications
Bounding scalar curvature and diameter along the Kähler Ricci flow (after Perelman) and some applications Natasa Sesum, Gang Tian Abstract In this short note we present a result of Perelman with detailed
More informationarxiv: v4 [math.dg] 18 Jun 2015
SMOOTHING 3-DIMENSIONAL POLYHEDRAL SPACES NINA LEBEDEVA, VLADIMIR MATVEEV, ANTON PETRUNIN, AND VSEVOLOD SHEVCHISHIN arxiv:1411.0307v4 [math.dg] 18 Jun 2015 Abstract. We show that 3-dimensional polyhedral
More informationEssential Spectra of complete manifolds
Essential Spectra of complete manifolds Zhiqin Lu Analysis, Complex Geometry, and Mathematical Physics: A Conference in Honor of Duong H. Phong May 7, 2013 Zhiqin Lu, Dept. Math, UCI Essential Spectra
More informationHarmonic Functions on Complete Riemannian Manifolds
* Vol. I?? Harmonic Functions on Complete Riemannian Manifolds Peter Li Abstract We present a brief description of certain aspects of the theory of harmonic functions on a complete Riemannian manifold.
More informationSPECTRAL PROPERTIES OF THE LAPLACIAN ON BOUNDED DOMAINS
SPECTRAL PROPERTIES OF THE LAPLACIAN ON BOUNDED DOMAINS TSOGTGEREL GANTUMUR Abstract. After establishing discrete spectra for a large class of elliptic operators, we present some fundamental spectral properties
More informationHarmonic quasi-isometric maps II : negatively curved manifolds
Harmonic quasi-isometric maps II : negatively curved manifolds Yves Benoist & Dominique Hulin Abstract We prove that a quasi-isometric map, and more generally a coarse embedding, between pinched Hadamard
More informationThe p-laplacian and geometric structure of the Riemannian manifold
Workshop on Partial Differential Equation and its Applications Institute for Mathematical Sciences - National University of Singapore The p-laplacian and geometric structure of the Riemannian manifold
More information7 Complete metric spaces and function spaces
7 Complete metric spaces and function spaces 7.1 Completeness Let (X, d) be a metric space. Definition 7.1. A sequence (x n ) n N in X is a Cauchy sequence if for any ɛ > 0, there is N N such that n, m
More informationGeometry of Shrinking Ricci Solitons
Geometry of Shrinking Ricci Solitons Huai-Dong Cao Lehigh University The Conference on Geometry in honor of Prof. S.-T. Yau s 60th birthday Warsaw, April 7, 2009 1 Ricci Solitons A complete Riemannian
More informationLecture 5 - Hausdorff and Gromov-Hausdorff Distance
Lecture 5 - Hausdorff and Gromov-Hausdorff Distance August 1, 2011 1 Definition and Basic Properties Given a metric space X, the set of closed sets of X supports a metric, the Hausdorff metric. If A is
More informationRESEARCH STATEMENT MICHAEL MUNN
RESEARCH STATEMENT MICHAEL MUNN Ricci curvature plays an important role in understanding the relationship between the geometry and topology of Riemannian manifolds. Perhaps the most notable results in
More informationNotation : M a closed (= compact boundaryless) orientable 3-dimensional manifold
Overview John Lott Notation : M a closed (= compact boundaryless) orientable 3-dimensional manifold Conjecture. (Poincaré, 1904) If M is simply connected then it is diffeomorphic to the three-sphere S
More informationChanging sign solutions for the CR-Yamabe equation
Changing sign solutions for the CR-Yamabe equation Ali Maalaoui (1) & Vittorio Martino (2) Abstract In this paper we prove that the CR-Yamabe equation on the Heisenberg group has infinitely many changing
More informationWELL-POSEDNESS OF THE LAPLACIAN ON MANIFOLDS WITH BOUNDARY AND BOUNDED GEOMETRY
WELL-POSEDNESS OF THE LAPLACIAN ON MANIFOLDS WITH BOUNDARY AND BOUNDED GEOMETRY BERND AMMANN, NADINE GROSSE, AND VICTOR NISTOR Abstract. Let M be a Riemannian manifold with a smooth boundary. The main
More informationthe neumann-cheeger constant of the jungle gym
the neumann-cheeger constant of the jungle gym Itai Benjamini Isaac Chavel Edgar A. Feldman Our jungle gyms are dimensional differentiable manifolds M, with preferred Riemannian metrics, associated to
More informationCalderón-Zygmund inequality on noncompact Riem. manifolds
The Calderón-Zygmund inequality on noncompact Riemannian manifolds Institut für Mathematik Humboldt-Universität zu Berlin Geometric Structures and Spectral Invariants Berlin, May 16, 2014 This talk is
More informationON FRACTAL DIMENSION OF INVARIANT SETS
ON FRACTAL DIMENSION OF INVARIANT SETS R. MIRZAIE We give an upper bound for the box dimension of an invariant set of a differentiable function f : U M. Here U is an open subset of a Riemannian manifold
More informationAncient solutions to Geometric Flows Lecture No 2
Ancient solutions to Geometric Flows Lecture No 2 Panagiota Daskalopoulos Columbia University Frontiers of Mathematics and Applications IV UIMP 2015 July 20-24, 2015 Topics to be discussed In this lecture
More informationEigenvalues and Eigenfunctions of the Laplacian
The Waterloo Mathematics Review 23 Eigenvalues and Eigenfunctions of the Laplacian Mihai Nica University of Waterloo mcnica@uwaterloo.ca Abstract: The problem of determining the eigenvalues and eigenvectors
More informationCones of measures. Tatiana Toro. University of Washington. Quantitative and Computational Aspects of Metric Geometry
Cones of measures Tatiana Toro University of Washington Quantitative and Computational Aspects of Metric Geometry Based on joint work with C. Kenig and D. Preiss Tatiana Toro (University of Washington)
More informationCMS winter meeting 2008, Ottawa. The heat kernel on connected sums
CMS winter meeting 2008, Ottawa The heat kernel on connected sums Laurent Saloff-Coste (Cornell University) December 8 2008 p(t, x, y) = The heat kernel ) 1 x y 2 exp ( (4πt) n/2 4t The heat kernel is:
More informationWave equation on manifolds and finite speed of propagation
Wave equation on manifolds and finite speed of propagation Ethan Y. Jaffe Let M be a Riemannian manifold (without boundary), and let be the (negative of) the Laplace-Beltrami operator. In this note, we
More informationThe Lusin Theorem and Horizontal Graphs in the Heisenberg Group
Analysis and Geometry in Metric Spaces Research Article DOI: 10.2478/agms-2013-0008 AGMS 2013 295-301 The Lusin Theorem and Horizontal Graphs in the Heisenberg Group Abstract In this paper we prove that
More informationRigidity and Non-rigidity Results on the Sphere
Rigidity and Non-rigidity Results on the Sphere Fengbo Hang Xiaodong Wang Department of Mathematics Michigan State University Oct., 00 1 Introduction It is a simple consequence of the maximum principle
More informationElliptic PDEs of 2nd Order, Gilbarg and Trudinger
Elliptic PDEs of 2nd Order, Gilbarg and Trudinger Chapter 2 Laplace Equation Yung-Hsiang Huang 207.07.07. Mimic the proof for Theorem 3.. 2. Proof. I think we should assume u C 2 (Ω Γ). Let W be an open
More informationEstimates for the resolvent and spectral gaps for non self-adjoint operators. University Bordeaux
for the resolvent and spectral gaps for non self-adjoint operators 1 / 29 Estimates for the resolvent and spectral gaps for non self-adjoint operators Vesselin Petkov University Bordeaux Mathematics Days
More informationMath The Laplacian. 1 Green s Identities, Fundamental Solution
Math. 209 The Laplacian Green s Identities, Fundamental Solution Let be a bounded open set in R n, n 2, with smooth boundary. The fact that the boundary is smooth means that at each point x the external
More informationOn Shalom Tao s Non-Quantitative Proof of Gromov s Polynomial Growth Theorem
On Shalom Tao s Non-Quantitative Proof of Gromov s Polynomial Growth Theorem Carlos A. De la Cruz Mengual Geometric Group Theory Seminar, HS 2013, ETH Zürich 13.11.2013 1 Towards the statement of Gromov
More informationarxiv: v1 [math.cv] 21 Jun 2016
B. N. Khabibullin, N. R. Tamindarova SUBHARMONIC TEST FUNCTIONS AND THE DISTRIBUTION OF ZERO SETS OF HOLOMORPHIC FUNCTIONS arxiv:1606.06714v1 [math.cv] 21 Jun 2016 Abstract. Let m, n 1 are integers and
More informationCritical metrics on connected sums of Einstein four-manifolds
Critical metrics on connected sums of Einstein four-manifolds University of Wisconsin, Madison March 22, 2013 Kyoto Einstein manifolds Einstein-Hilbert functional in dimension 4: R(g) = V ol(g) 1/2 R g
More informationThe volume growth of complete gradient shrinking Ricci solitons
arxiv:0904.0798v [math.dg] Apr 009 The volume growth of complete gradient shrinking Ricci solitons Ovidiu Munteanu Abstract We prove that any gradient shrinking Ricci soliton has at most Euclidean volume
More informationThe Dirichlet s P rinciple. In this lecture we discuss an alternative formulation of the Dirichlet problem for the Laplace equation:
Oct. 1 The Dirichlet s P rinciple In this lecture we discuss an alternative formulation of the Dirichlet problem for the Laplace equation: 1. Dirichlet s Principle. u = in, u = g on. ( 1 ) If we multiply
More informationProblem Set 5. 2 n k. Then a nk (x) = 1+( 1)k
Problem Set 5 1. (Folland 2.43) For x [, 1), let 1 a n (x)2 n (a n (x) = or 1) be the base-2 expansion of x. (If x is a dyadic rational, choose the expansion such that a n (x) = for large n.) Then the
More informationTobias Holck Colding: Publications
Tobias Holck Colding: Publications [1] T.H. Colding and W.P. Minicozzi II, The singular set of mean curvature flow with generic singularities, submitted 2014. [2] T.H. Colding and W.P. Minicozzi II, Lojasiewicz
More informationLocal Asymmetry and the Inner Radius of Nodal Domains
Local Asymmetry and the Inner Radius of Nodal Domains Dan MANGOUBI Institut des Hautes Études Scientifiques 35, route de Chartres 91440 Bures-sur-Yvette (France) Avril 2007 IHES/M/07/14 Local Asymmetry
More informationMinimal submanifolds: old and new
Minimal submanifolds: old and new Richard Schoen Stanford University - Chen-Jung Hsu Lecture 1, Academia Sinica, ROC - December 2, 2013 Plan of Lecture Part 1: Volume, mean curvature, and minimal submanifolds
More informationObstacle Problems Involving The Fractional Laplacian
Obstacle Problems Involving The Fractional Laplacian Donatella Danielli and Sandro Salsa January 27, 2017 1 Introduction Obstacle problems involving a fractional power of the Laplace operator appear in
More informationLaplace s Equation. Chapter Mean Value Formulas
Chapter 1 Laplace s Equation Let be an open set in R n. A function u C 2 () is called harmonic in if it satisfies Laplace s equation n (1.1) u := D ii u = 0 in. i=1 A function u C 2 () is called subharmonic
More informationarxiv:math/ v1 [math.dg] 19 Nov 2004
arxiv:math/04426v [math.dg] 9 Nov 2004 REMARKS ON GRADIENT RICCI SOLITONS LI MA Abstract. In this paper, we study the gradient Ricci soliton equation on a complete Riemannian manifold. We show that under
More informationTHE UNIFORMISATION THEOREM OF RIEMANN SURFACES
THE UNIFORISATION THEORE OF RIEANN SURFACES 1. What is the aim of this seminar? Recall that a compact oriented surface is a g -holed object. (Classification of surfaces.) It can be obtained through a 4g
More informationPLURISUBHARMONIC FUNCTIONS AND THE STRUCTURE OF COMPLETE KÄHLER MANIFOLDS WITH NONNEGATIVE CURVATURE
j. differential geometry 64 (2003) 457-524 PLURISUBHARMONIC FUNCTIONS AND THE STRUCTURE OF COMPLETE KÄHLER MANIFOLDS WITH NONNEGATIVE CURVATURE LEI NI & LUEN-FAI TAM Abstract In this paper, we study global
More informationDaniel M. Oberlin Department of Mathematics, Florida State University. January 2005
PACKING SPHERES AND FRACTAL STRICHARTZ ESTIMATES IN R d FOR d 3 Daniel M. Oberlin Department of Mathematics, Florida State University January 005 Fix a dimension d and for x R d and r > 0, let Sx, r) stand
More informationMATH 566 LECTURE NOTES 6: NORMAL FAMILIES AND THE THEOREMS OF PICARD
MATH 566 LECTURE NOTES 6: NORMAL FAMILIES AND THE THEOREMS OF PICARD TSOGTGEREL GANTUMUR 1. Introduction Suppose that we want to solve the equation f(z) = β where f is a nonconstant entire function and
More informationDIFFERENTIAL FORMS, SPINORS AND BOUNDED CURVATURE COLLAPSE. John Lott. University of Michigan. November, 2000
DIFFERENTIAL FORMS, SPINORS AND BOUNDED CURVATURE COLLAPSE John Lott University of Michigan November, 2000 From preprints Collapsing and the Differential Form Laplacian On the Spectrum of a Finite-Volume
More informationTobias Holck Colding: Publications. 1. T.H. Colding and W.P. Minicozzi II, Dynamics of closed singularities, preprint.
Tobias Holck Colding: Publications 1. T.H. Colding and W.P. Minicozzi II, Dynamics of closed singularities, preprint. 2. T.H. Colding and W.P. Minicozzi II, Analytical properties for degenerate equations,
More informationarxiv: v1 [math.dg] 11 Jan 2009
arxiv:0901.1474v1 [math.dg] 11 Jan 2009 Scalar Curvature Behavior for Finite Time Singularity of Kähler-Ricci Flow Zhou Zhang November 6, 2018 Abstract In this short paper, we show that Kähler-Ricci flows
More informationHow curvature shapes space
How curvature shapes space Richard Schoen University of California, Irvine - Hopf Lecture, ETH, Zürich - October 30, 2017 The lecture will have three parts: Part 1: Heinz Hopf and Riemannian geometry Part
More informationIntroduction In this paper, we will prove the following Liouville-type results for harmonic
Mathematical Research Letters 2, 79 735 995 LIOUVILLE PROPERTIES OF HARMONIC MAPS Luen-fai Tam Introduction In this paper, we will prove the following Liouville-type results for harmonic maps: Let M be
More informationON THE STATIC METRIC EXTENSION PROBLEM
ON THE STATIC METRIC EXTENSION PROBLEM STEFAN CZIMEK Abstract. The subject of this Master thesis under the guidance of M. Eichmair is the following theorem of J. Corvino and R. Schoen [5]: Minimal mass
More informationRicci Curvature and Bochner Formula on Alexandrov Spaces
Ricci Curvature and Bochner Formula on Alexandrov Spaces Sun Yat-sen University March 18, 2013 (work with Prof. Xi-Ping Zhu) Contents Alexandrov Spaces Generalized Ricci Curvature Geometric and Analytic
More informationAn extremal eigenvalue problem for surfaces with boundary
An extremal eigenvalue problem for surfaces with boundary Richard Schoen Stanford University - Conference in Geometric Analysis, UC Irvine - January 15, 2012 - Joint project with Ailana Fraser Plan of
More informationThe Geometrization Theorem
The Geometrization Theorem Matthew D. Brown Wednesday, December 19, 2012 In this paper, we discuss the Geometrization Theorem, formerly Thurston s Geometrization Conjecture, which is essentially the statement
More informationarxiv: v2 [math.dg] 25 Oct 2014
GAP PHENOMENA AND CURVATURE ESTIMATES FOR CONFORMALLY COMPACT EINSTEIN MANIFOLDS GANG LI, JIE QING AND YUGUANG SHI arxiv:1410.6402v2 [math.dg] 25 Oct 2014 Abstract. In this paper we first use the result
More information(1) Consider the space S consisting of all continuous real-valued functions on the closed interval [0, 1]. For f, g S, define
Homework, Real Analysis I, Fall, 2010. (1) Consider the space S consisting of all continuous real-valued functions on the closed interval [0, 1]. For f, g S, define ρ(f, g) = 1 0 f(x) g(x) dx. Show that
More informationShort note on compact operators - Monday 24 th March, Sylvester Eriksson-Bique
Short note on compact operators - Monday 24 th March, 2014 Sylvester Eriksson-Bique 1 Introduction In this note I will give a short outline about the structure theory of compact operators. I restrict attention
More informationPartial Differential Equations
Part II Partial Differential Equations Year 2015 2014 2013 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 2007 2006 2005 2015 Paper 4, Section II 29E Partial Differential Equations 72 (a) Show that the Cauchy problem for u(x,
More informationNegative sectional curvature and the product complex structure. Harish Sheshadri. Department of Mathematics Indian Institute of Science Bangalore
Negative sectional curvature and the product complex structure Harish Sheshadri Department of Mathematics Indian Institute of Science Bangalore Technical Report No. 2006/4 March 24, 2006 M ath. Res. Lett.
More informationAn upper bound for curvature integral
An upper bound for curvature integral Anton Petrunin Abstract Here I show that the integral of scalar curvature of a closed Riemannian manifold can be bounded from above in terms of its dimension, diameter,
More informationTHEOREMS, ETC., FOR MATH 515
THEOREMS, ETC., FOR MATH 515 Proposition 1 (=comment on page 17). If A is an algebra, then any finite union or finite intersection of sets in A is also in A. Proposition 2 (=Proposition 1.1). For every
More informationThe uniformization theorem
1 The uniformization theorem Thurston s basic insight in all four of the theorems discussed in this book is that either the topology of the problem induces an appropriate geometry or there is an understandable
More informationStochastic completeness of Markov processes
Stochastic completeness of arkov processes Alexander Grigor yan Lecture course at CUHK, February-arch 211 Contents Introduction 1 1 Brownian motion on Riemannian manifolds 3 1.1 Laplace-Beltrami operator........................
More informationLECTURE 15: COMPLETENESS AND CONVEXITY
LECTURE 15: COMPLETENESS AND CONVEXITY 1. The Hopf-Rinow Theorem Recall that a Riemannian manifold (M, g) is called geodesically complete if the maximal defining interval of any geodesic is R. On the other
More informationFinite-dimensional spaces. C n is the space of n-tuples x = (x 1,..., x n ) of complex numbers. It is a Hilbert space with the inner product
Chapter 4 Hilbert Spaces 4.1 Inner Product Spaces Inner Product Space. A complex vector space E is called an inner product space (or a pre-hilbert space, or a unitary space) if there is a mapping (, )
More informationOverview of normed linear spaces
20 Chapter 2 Overview of normed linear spaces Starting from this chapter, we begin examining linear spaces with at least one extra structure (topology or geometry). We assume linearity; this is a natural
More informationQuasi-conformal minimal Lagrangian diffeomorphisms of the
Quasi-conformal minimal Lagrangian diffeomorphisms of the hyperbolic plane (joint work with J.M. Schlenker) January 21, 2010 Quasi-symmetric homeomorphism of a circle A homeomorphism φ : S 1 S 1 is quasi-symmetric
More informationLarge scale conformal geometry
July 24th, 2018 Goal: perform conformal geometry on discrete groups. Goal: perform conformal geometry on discrete groups. Definition X, X metric spaces. Map f : X X is a coarse embedding if where α +,
More informationREAL AND COMPLEX ANALYSIS
REAL AND COMPLE ANALYSIS Third Edition Walter Rudin Professor of Mathematics University of Wisconsin, Madison Version 1.1 No rights reserved. Any part of this work can be reproduced or transmitted in any
More informationVolume comparison theorems without Jacobi fields
Volume comparison theorems without Jacobi fields Dominique Bakry Laboratoire de Statistique et Probabilités Université Paul Sabatier 118 route de Narbonne 31062 Toulouse, FRANCE Zhongmin Qian Mathematical
More informationIntrinsic Geometry. Andrejs Treibergs. Friday, March 7, 2008
Early Research Directions: Geometric Analysis II Intrinsic Geometry Andrejs Treibergs University of Utah Friday, March 7, 2008 2. References Part of a series of thee lectures on geometric analysis. 1 Curvature
More informationOn the Intrinsic Differentiability Theorem of Gromov-Schoen
On the Intrinsic Differentiability Theorem of Gromov-Schoen Georgios Daskalopoulos Brown University daskal@math.brown.edu Chikako Mese 2 Johns Hopkins University cmese@math.jhu.edu Abstract In this note,
More informationRANDOM FIELDS AND GEOMETRY. Robert Adler and Jonathan Taylor
RANDOM FIELDS AND GEOMETRY from the book of the same name by Robert Adler and Jonathan Taylor IE&M, Technion, Israel, Statistics, Stanford, US. ie.technion.ac.il/adler.phtml www-stat.stanford.edu/ jtaylor
More informationMyopic Models of Population Dynamics on Infinite Networks
Myopic Models of Population Dynamics on Infinite Networks Robert Carlson Department of Mathematics University of Colorado at Colorado Springs rcarlson@uccs.edu June 30, 2014 Outline Reaction-diffusion
More informationFunctional Analysis. Franck Sueur Metric spaces Definitions Completeness Compactness Separability...
Functional Analysis Franck Sueur 2018-2019 Contents 1 Metric spaces 1 1.1 Definitions........................................ 1 1.2 Completeness...................................... 3 1.3 Compactness......................................
More informationBERGMAN KERNEL ON COMPACT KÄHLER MANIFOLDS
BERGMAN KERNEL ON COMPACT KÄHLER MANIFOLDS SHOO SETO Abstract. These are the notes to an expository talk I plan to give at MGSC on Kähler Geometry aimed for beginning graduate students in hopes to motivate
More informationCompactness of Symplectic critical surfaces
August 2016 Outline Symplectic surfaces 1 Symplectic surfaces 2 3 4 5 Symplectic surfaces Let M be a compact Kähler surface, let ω be the Kähler form. For a compact oriented real surface Σ without boundary
More informationTRANSITIVE HOLONOMY GROUP AND RIGIDITY IN NONNEGATIVE CURVATURE. Luis Guijarro and Gerard Walschap
TRANSITIVE HOLONOMY GROUP AND RIGIDITY IN NONNEGATIVE CURVATURE Luis Guijarro and Gerard Walschap Abstract. In this note, we examine the relationship between the twisting of a vector bundle ξ over a manifold
More informationALF spaces and collapsing Ricci-flat metrics on the K3 surface
ALF spaces and collapsing Ricci-flat metrics on the K3 surface Lorenzo Foscolo Stony Brook University Simons Collaboration on Special Holonomy Workshop, SCGP, Stony Brook, September 8 2016 The Kummer construction
More informationADJOINTS, ABSOLUTE VALUES AND POLAR DECOMPOSITIONS
J. OPERATOR THEORY 44(2000), 243 254 c Copyright by Theta, 2000 ADJOINTS, ABSOLUTE VALUES AND POLAR DECOMPOSITIONS DOUGLAS BRIDGES, FRED RICHMAN and PETER SCHUSTER Communicated by William B. Arveson Abstract.
More informationUNIFORMLY DISTRIBUTED MEASURES IN EUCLIDEAN SPACES
MATH. SCAND. 90 (2002), 152 160 UNIFORMLY DISTRIBUTED MEASURES IN EUCLIDEAN SPACES BERND KIRCHHEIM and DAVID PREISS For every complete metric space X there is, up to a constant multiple, at most one Borel
More information