The (q, t)-catalan Numbers and the Space of Diagonal Harmonics. James Haglund. University of Pennsylvania

Transcription

1 The (q, t)-catalan Numbers and the Space of Diagonal Harmonics James Haglund University of Pennsylvania

2 Outline Intro to q-analogues inv and maj q-catalan Numbers MacMahon s q-analogue The Carlitz-Riordan q-analogue Intro to Symmetric Functions The monomial symmetric functions The elementary symmetric functions The power-sum symmetric functions The Schur functions

3 The Macdonald Polynomials Selberg s Integral Plethysm and the q, t-kostka matrix The modules V (µ) and the diagonal action The Space of Diagonal Harmonics The Hilbert and Frobenius Series The operator and the q, t- Catalan Combinatorial Interpretations The bounce statistic Extension to parking functions The m-parameter q, t-catalan

4 Permutation Statistics and q-analogues In combinatorics a statistic on a finite set S is a mapping from S N given by an explicit combinatorial rule. Ex. Given π = π 1 π 2 π n S n, define invπ = {(i, j) : i<j and π i >π j } and majπ = If π = 31542, and π i >π i+1 i. invπ =2+2+1=5 majπ =1+3+4=8.

5 Let and (n) q =(1 q n )/(1 q) (n!) q = =1+q q n 1 n (i) q i=1 =(1+q)(1+q+q 2 ) (1+q+...+q n 1 ) be the q-analogues of n and n!. Then q invπ =(n!) q = q majπ. π Sn π Sn

6 Partitions and the Gaussian Polynomials Let λ =(λ 1,λ 2,...,λ n ), λ i N for 1 i n be a partition and let λ = i λ i. Define ( n k ) q = (n!) q (k!) q ((n k)!) q. Theorem. For n, k N, ( ) n + k = k q (λ 1,...,λn) (k,k,...,k) q λ. Note: We denote the conjugate partition by λ. Example n = k =2. TheFerrers shapes are

7 1 2 q q q 2 q 3 q 4 The Catalan Numbers Recurrence: C n = 1 n +1 C n = n k=1 ( ) 2n n C k 1 C n k Over 70 interpretations in Stanley s Enumerative Combinatorics Volume 2, including

8 The number of standard tableaux of shape (n, n): The number of Catalan words, i.e. mulitset permutations of {0 n 1 n } where in any initial segment, the number of zeros is at least as big as the number of ones The number of Catalan paths from (0, 0) to (n, n), i.e. lattice paths consisting of N and E steps which never go below the main diagonal.

9 A Catalan Path

10 Theorem. (MacMahon) q maj(σ) 1 = (n +1) q Catalan words σ The Carlitz-Riordan q-catalan Let D n denote the set of Catalan paths, and set C n (q) = σ Dn q area(σ) where area(σ) isthenumberof squares below the path and strictly above the diagonal. Proposition. n C n (q) = q k 1 C k 1 (q)c n k (q). k=1 ( 2n n ) q.

11 Symmetric Functions A symmetric function is a polynomial f(x 1,x 2,...,x n ) which satisfies f(x π1,...,x π n)=f(x 1,...,x n ), i.e. πf = f, for all π S n. Examples The monomial symmetric functions m λ (X) m (2,1) (x 1,x 2,x 3 )=x 2 1x 2 +x 2 1x 3 + x 2 2x 1 + x 2 2x 3 + x 2 3x 1 + x 2 3x 2. The elementary symmetric functions e k (X) e 2 (x 1,x 2,x 3 )=x 1 x 2 +x 1 x 3 +x 2 x 3. The power-sums p k (X) = i xk i.

12 The Schur functions s λ (X), which are important in the representation theory of the symmetric group: s λ (X) = β n K λ,β m β (X) where K λ,β equals the number of ways of filling the Ferrers shape of λ with elements of the multiset {1 β 12 β 2 }, weakly increasing across rows and strictly increasing down columns. For example K (4,2),(2,2,1,1) =

13 Selberg s Integral For k, a, b C, (x i x j ) 2k = n i=1 (0,1) n n i=1 1 i<j n x a 1 i (1 x i ) b 1 dx 1 dx n Γ(a +(i 1)k)Γ(b +(i 1)k) Γ(a + b +(n + i 2)k) Γ(ik +1) Γ(k +1).

14 Macdonald s Generalization: There exist symmetric functions P λ (X; q, t) such that 1 P λ (X; q, t) n! (0,1) n k 1 (x i q r x j )(x i q r x j ) 1 i<j n n i=1 = q F n r=0 x a 1 i (x i ; q) b 1 d q x 1 d q x n i=1 1 i<j n Γ q (λ i + a +(i 1)k) Γ q (λ i + a + b +(n + i 2)k) Γ q (b +(i 1)k) Γ q (λ i λ j +(j i +1)k) Γ q (λ i λ j +(j i)k)

15 where k N, F = kη(λ) +kan(n 1)/2+k 2 n(n 1)(n 2)/3, t = q k, Γ q (z) =(1 q) 1 z (q; q) /(q z ; q) is the q-gamma function with (x; q) = i 0(1 xq i ), and 1 0 f(x)d q x = i=0 is the q-integral. f(q i )(q i q i+1 )

16 Plethysm: If F (X) is a symmetric function, then F [(1 t)x] is defined by expressing F (X) as a polynomial in the p k (X) = i xk i s and then replacing each p k (X) by (1 t k )p k (X). Macdonald expanded scalar multiples of his P λ (q, t) in terms of the basis s λ [(1 t)x] and called the coefficients K λ,µ (q, t). He conjectured these coefficients were in N [q, t]. He proved K λ,µ (1, 1) = K λ,1 n and asked if K λ,µ (q, t) = q a(µ,t ) t b(µ,t ) T for some statistics a, b on partitions µ and standard tableaux T.

17 (0,0) (0,1) µ (1,0) (1,1) (2,0) (µ) = 1 y 1 x 1 x 1 y 1 x y 2 x 2 x 2 y 2 x y 3 x 3 x 3 y 3 x y 4 x 4 x 4 y 4 x y 5 x 5 x 5 y 5 x 2 5

18 For µ n let V (µ) denotethe linear span over Q of all partial derivatives of all orders of (µ).

19 π( a basis element ) = linear combo. of basis elements. π( a basis ) = matrix M(π). M(π) M(β) =M(π β). The character χ is the trace of M(π), which is independent of the basis. Furthermore a basis for which

20 Μ = ****** ****** ****** 0 ****** ****** **** 0 **** **** **** 0 0 0

21 V (µ) decomposes as a direct sum of its bihomogeneous subspaces V i,j (µ) of degree i in the x-variables and j in the y-variables. There is an S n -action on V i,j (µ) givenby πf = f(x π1,...,x π n,y π1,...,y π n) called the diagonal action. The Frobenius Series is the symmetric function s λ (X) q i t j m ij, λ n i,j 0 where m ij is the multiplicity of the irreducible S n -character χ λ in the diagonal action on V i,j (µ).

22 Conjecture. (Garsia, Haiman; PNAS 1993) The Frobenius Series of V (µ) is given by the modified Macdonald polynomial H µ (X; q, t) = λ n t η(µ) K λ,µ (q, 1/t)s λ (X), where η(µ) = i (i 1)λ i. Garsia and Haiman also pioneered the study of the space of diagonal harmonics R n, which is n {f : x h i yi k f =0, h+k >0}. i=1 This is known to be isomorphic to the quotient ring Q [x 1,...,x n,y 1,...,y n ]/I,

23 where I is the ideal generated by the set of all polarized power sums n i=1 xh i yk i, h+k >0. The V (µ) are S n -submodules of R n. Conjecture. (Haiman) The dimension of the space of diagonal harmonics, as a vector space over Q,is(n +1) n 1. The space R n decomposes as a direct sum of subspaces of bihomogeneous degree (i, j); R n = i,j Ri,j The Hilbert Series is the sum i,j 0 q i t j dim(r i,j n ). Example: If n = 2, a basis for n.

24 the space is 1,x 2 x 1,y 2 y 1,and the Hilbert Series is 1 + q + t. The Frobenius Series is the sum s λ (X) q i t j m i,j λ n i,j 0 where m i,j is the multiplicity of χ λ in the character of Rn i,j under the diagonal action of S n.for n = 2 this is s 2 (X)+s 1 2(X)(q + t). Let be a linear operator on the basis H µ (X; q, t) givenby H µ (X; q, t) =t η(µ) q η(µ ) Hµ (X; q, t).

25 Conjecture. (Garsia, Haiman) The Frobenius Series of R n is given by e n (X). A polynomial f is alternating if πf =( 1) invπ f for all π S n. A special case of the above conjecture is that the coefficient of S 1 n(x) in e n (X), corresponding to the sign character χ 1n,is the Hilbert Series of the subspace R ɛ n of alternates. When q, t 1 in e n (X) they showed this coefficient equals the nth Catalan number, which would then equal dim(r ɛ n). By results of Macdonald, this coefficient has an expression as a rational function in q, t.

26 Definition. (q, t-catalan ) Let C n (q, t) =(1 q)(1 t) µ n t 2η(µ) q 2η(µ ) (1 q a t l ) q a t l (qa t l+1 )(t l q a+1 ), where the products are over the squares of µ, and the arm a, coarm a,legl, and coleg l ofasquare are as below.

27 l a a l

28 Conjecture. (Garsia, Haiman; 1992) C n (q, t) is a polynomial in q and t with nonnegative coefficients. For n = 2 the terms in C 2 (q, t) are: µ =2; µ =1 2 ; So q 2 (1 t)(1 q)(1 q)(1 + q) (1 q 2 )(q t)(1 q)(1 t) t 2 (1 t)(1 q)(1 t)(1 + t) (1 t 2 )(t q)(1 t)(1 q) C 2 (q, t) = t2 t q + q2 q t = t2 q 2 t q = t+q.

29 After simplification the terms in C 3 (q, t) are µ =3; q 6 q 2 t) µ = 21; µ =1 3 ; t 2 q 2 (1 + q + t) (q t 2 )(t q 2 ) t 6 (t 2 q)(t q) So C 3 (q, t) = q 6 (t 2 q)+t 2 q 2 (1 + q + t)(q t)+t 6 (t q 2 ) (q 2 t)(t 2 q)(q t) = q 3 + q 2 t + qt 2 + qt + t 3.

30 Theorem. (Garsia, Haiman) q (n 2) Cn (q, 1/q) = 1 (n +1) q ( 2n n ) q. Theorem. (Garsia, Haiman) C n (q, 1) = q area(σ). σ Dn Problem: Is there a pair of statistics (qstat, tstat) on Catalan paths such that C n (q, t) = q qstat(σ) t tstat(σ)? σ Dn

31 Theorem. (Haiman; JAMS 2001) If µ n, the Frobenius Series of V (µ) is the modified Macdonald polynomial Hµ (X; q, t). Pf: Algebraic Geometry and Commutative Algebra. Corollaries. For all λ, µ n, K λ,µ (q, t) N [q, t] and dim(v (µ)) = n!. So far no pair of statistics for the K λ,µ (q, t) have been proposed. Theorem. (Garsia, H.; PNAS 2001) C n (q, t) N [q, t]. Pf: Intricate application of plethystic identities involving after an empirical discovery of a recurrence.

32 7 4 2 The circles form the bounce path. The bounce statistic is 2+4+7=13.

33 Definition. F n (q, t) = q area(σ) t bounce(σ). σ Dn Conjecture. (H.; To appear in Adv. in Math.) For all n N, F n (q, t) =C n (q, t). (Verified in Maple for n 14).

34 Definition. Say σ ends in end(σ) E steps. For n, s N,set F n,s (q, t) = q area(σ) t bounce(σ). σ Dn end(σ)=s Theorem. F n,s (q, t) = F n s,r (q, t) n s r=0 q (s 2) t n s ( r + s 1 r ) q. Corollary. q (n 2) Fn (q, q 1 )= 1 (n +1) q ( 2n n ) q.

35 Theorem. (Garsia, H.; PNAS 2001) For all n, s N, t n s q (s 2) en s [X 1 qs 1 q ] s 1 n s (X) Corollary. Corollary. = F n,s (q, t). C n (q, t) =F n (q, t). F n,s =(1 q s ) µ n t η(µ) q η(µ ) (1 q a t l )h s [(1 t) q a t l ] (qa t l+1 )(t l q a+1 ) Corollary. F n (q, t) =F n (t, q)..

36 Haiman discovered another pair of statistics for the q, t-catalan. Conjecture. (Haiman) C n (q, t) = q area(σ) t dinv(σ). σ Dn Proposition. q area(σ) t dinv(σ) = σ Dn σ Dn q bounce(σ) t area(σ). Corollary. Haiman s conjecture above is true.

37 t 14 q 13 The statistic dinv is the # of pairs (i, j),i<j with the lengths r i and r j of rows i, j satisfying r j r i {0, 1}.

38 Corollary. F n (q, 1) = F n (1,q). Open Question. Find a bijective proof that F n (q, t) =F n (t, q). Theorem. (Haiman; Invent. Math. 2002) e n (X) is the Frobenius Series of R n. Corollary. The (q, t)-catalan C n (q, t) is the Hilbert Series of the space of alternates R ɛ n. Corollary. dim(r n )=(n+1) n 1. The number (n+1) n 1 is the number of rooted, labeled trees on n+ 1 vertices, with root node labeled 0, and also the number of parking functions on n cars.

39 t 6 q 13 dinv = #(i, j),i < j : r i = r j and car i >car j or r i = r j 1 and car i <car j.

40 Conjecture. (H., Loehr) The Hilbert Series of R n is given by W n (q, t) = q area(σ) t dinv(σ), σ where the sum is over all parking functions on n cars. Using Maple, we have verified our conjecture for n 7. We can t prove, by any method, that W n (q, t) = W n (t, q), nor can we prove that q (n 2) Wn (q, 1/q) =(1+q+...+q n ) n 1, which is the value for the Hilbert Series at t =1/q conjectured by Stanley and now proven by Haiman. Loehr has a proof that W n (q, 1) = W n (1,q).

41 Garsia and Haiman define C m n (q, t) = m e n (X) s1 n (X), m N. Note Cn(q, 1 t) =C n (q, t). These are connected to lattice paths from (0, 0) to (nm, n) which never go below the diagonal, and also have an algebraic description. Conjecture. (Haiman, Loehr) q area(σ) t m-dinv(σ) = Cn m (q, t) σ D m n = q area(σ) t m-bounce(σ). σ D m n Loehr obtains recurrences involving the parameter m which extend the recurrence for F n,s (q, t).

42 Lapointe, Lascoux and Morse have introduced a generalization of Schur functions they call Atoms, which depend on X, t, a positive integer k, and a partition λ satisfying λ 1 k. The coefficients in the expansion of the Atoms in terms of Schur functions are in N [t], and they conjecture that if µ 1 k, the coefficients in the expansion of the H µ (X; q, t) in terms of the Atoms are in N [q, t]. This conjecture thus implies K λ,µ (q, t) N [q, t]. Hear more about this in the special session on Algebraic and Enumerative Combinatorics.

43 The bounce path for the case m = 2. Go up distance a 1 to the path, then over a 1, then up distance a 2,thenovera 1 + a 2,then up a 3,thenovera 2 + a 3, etc.

44 Start with the path above. Form the bounce path (circles, next page) whose top step is the # of rows length zero, etc. Then start at corner of top step, and look at subword of 0 s and 1 s on previ-

45 (area, dinv) (bounce, area) ous page, starting at bottom. For each 0 go down, for each 1 go left. Then iterate with subword of 1 s and 2 s.