Charmed Baryon spectroscopy at Belle 1. Y. Kato KMI topics. Mainly based on the paper recently accepted by PRD ( arxiv: )

Transcription

1 Charmed Baryon spectroscopy at Belle 1 Y. Kato KMI topics Mainly based on the paper recently accepted by PRD ( arxiv: )

2 Introduction 2 The mass of matter is almost made of nucleons. But they are still not understood. 1. Mass generation. Mass of up, down quark is several MeV Nucleon mass: ~1000 MeV. Nucleon mass is generated from dynamics of quarks and gluons. 2. Quark confinement. Single quark has been never observed. These happens simultaneously! Bound state means it has negative potential like nuclei. But quarks obtain masses inside nucleon. To understand these two is (personal) goal of hadron physics. QCD is non-perturbative in low energy. Hard to solve but

3 Success of the constituent quark model 3 Assume ~300 (~500) MeV/c 2 for u,d (s) quark mass (constituent quark). Harmonic oscillation and hyperfine interaction. Phys.Rev. D18 (1978) 4187 very simple! Constituent quark is a good apporoximation. Why it works so well? What is adaptive limit? What is the real degree of freedom to describe hadrons? Constituent quarks are enough?

4 Physics of charmed baryons (1) 4 Mass of the charm quark is ~1.5 GeV. This is much heavier than. 1.Momentum of quarks inside the baryon (~0.2 GeV/c) Non-relativistic potential approach is a good approximation to describe interaction between heavy quarks Charmonium spectroscopy understanding of QQ bar potential LinearCoulomb doubly charmed baryon(ξ cc ) spectroscopy understanding of QQ potential. Interaction of colored object c c u c c d

5 Physics of charmed baryons (2) 5 Mass of the charm quark is ~1.5 GeV/c 2. This is much heavier than. 2.Mass of u,d,s quarks ( GeV/c 2 ) spin-spin interaction 1/m 1 m 2. In single charm baryon, strong spin-spin interaction among light quarks may form diquark c λ mode Two excitation modes in the baryon Interaction among diquark: ρ mode Interaction among diquark and c quark: λ mode u ρ mode d Diquark is a appropriate freedom to describe hadrons? Study of ρ mode diquark spectroscopy. Clear information for interaction of two light quarks.

6 CsI(Tl) 16X 0 Experimental probe: Belle experiment 6 SC solenoid 1.5T TOF conter Aerogel Cherenkov cnt. n=1.015~ GeV e 8 GeV e - Si vtx. det. 3/4 lyr. DSSD Central Drift Chamber m / K L detection 14/15 lyr. RPCFe General purpose detector Momentum measurement by SVD, CDC p/k/π ID by CDC (de/dx), TOF, ACC cover p<~3.5 GeV/c

7 Hadron physics at B-factories Z(3900) Z b (10610) η b (2S) h b (1P) Z(4430) Z(4050) Z(4250) η b (1S) Ξ c (3055)? Ξ c (3123)? Y(3940) Y(4660) Λ c (2940) Y(4260) Ds(2317) Ds(2460) η c (2S) Mesons Z b (10650) h b (2P) X(3872) Baryons Ω c (2770) Ξ c (2980) Σ c (2800) 7 Ξ c (3080) More than 20 new hadrons have been discovered by B-factories Among them, so called XYZ states are very famous.

8 Observed charmed baryons 8 Λ c 1/2 Λ c (2595) 1/2 - Λ c (2625) 3/2 - [Λ c (2765)?? ] Λ c (2880) 5/2 Λ c (2940)?? c d u CLEO 8(7) (1995~2001) BELLE 3 (2006~) BABAR 5(2) (2007~) Σ c (2455) 1/2 Σ c (2520) 3/2 Σ c (2800)?? c d u Ξ c 1/2 Ξ c 1/2 Ξ c (2645) 3/2 Ξ c (2790) 1/2 - Ξ c (2815) 3/2 - [Ξ c (2930)?? ] Ξ c (2980)?? [Ξ c (3055)?? ] Ξ c (3080)?? [Ξ c (3123)?? ] Ω c 1/2 Ω c (2770) 3/2 c s u c s s 16/21 (12/17) charmed baryons are observed in e e - collider experiment. All the ground state of single charmed baryons are discovered. Except for Λ c (2595), Λ c (2880), Σ c (2455), spin/parity are not measured.

9 Charm production in e e - collider e - e e - cc bar s=10.58 GeV c 9 γ* e Cross section for e e - qq bar does not depend on the flavor of quarks. Depends only on the charge 2. σ(e e - cc bar )=σ(e e - uu bar )=4σ(e e - ss bar )=4σ(e e - dd bar ) Detect decay particles only (inclusive reaction) π(p,d*)y c

10 Integrated luminosity of B-factories 10 CLEO:13.7fb -1 σ(e e - cc bar ) 1nb 10^9 cc bar events are produced!

11 Outline of this talk 11 Doubly charmed baryon(ξ cc ) search. Excited charm-strange baryons (Ξ c *). Work in progress.

12 Past experimental search for Ξ cc 12 Prediction of the mass: ~ GeV by quark model, 3.6 GeV by LQCD Evidence by SELEX was not supported by FOCUS, B-factories. No established state even for ground state. Evidence from SELEX in 2003 fb -1 Mass:~3.52 GeV/c 2 B-factories Belle@461.5fb -1 M(Λ c K - π ) hep-ex/ hep-ex/ M(Λ c K - π ) hep-ex/

13 Λ c yield ~ ~ for Belle

14 Ξ cc decay modes 14 Ground state baryon decays via weak interaction(c s). Ξ cc is expected to decay into Λ c K - π and Ξ c0 π π Ξ cc c c d W s c d u d u K - u Λ c Ξ cc c c d W s c d u d Ξ c 0 π Background: inclusive Λ c or Ξ c 0 production. σ(e e - Λ c X) Br(Λ c pkpi)/σ(e e - Ξ c0 X) Br(Ξ c0 Ξ - π ) ~10.

15 Improved search of Ξ cc by Belle 15 BaBar Previous Belle This study Luminosity (fb -1 ) Ξ cc decay Λ c K - π Ξ c0 π Λ c K - π Λ c K - π Ξ c0 π Λ c decay pk - π pk-π pk - π, pk S 0 Ξ c 0 decay Ξ - π Ξ - π, ΛK - π, pk - K - π Full statistics Two Ξ cc decay modes. Several sub decay modes

16 Reconstruction of Λ c M(pK - π ) M(pK s ) 16 Previous studies used pk - π only. Inclusion of pk S mode increases statistics by ~20 %. S/N ratio is comparable. Combine two decay modes. Total Λ c yield is around ~ ~1600 Λ c by SELEX. Apply mass constraint on Λ c Mass resolution for Ξ cc is MeV/c 2

17 Result for Λ c K - π decay mode 17 M(Λ c K - π ) 95% C.L Upper limit of σ(e e - Ξ cc X) Br(Ξ cc Λ c K - π ) Data MC expectation for signal σ=500 fb, Br(Ξ cc Λ c K - π ) = 5% Theoretical prediction: 70, 230 fb Significance from -2ln(L/L(0)) Significance is less than 3σ in all mass region... Belle fb Theory fb (assuming Br=5%)

18 Reconstruction of Ξ c 0 18 M(Ξ - π ) previous BaBar used this only M(ΛK - π ) M(pK - K - π ) Total yield of the Ξ c 0 is Previous study by BaBar use Ξ - π only. S/N largely depends on the decay mode. Simultaneous fit with fixing relative signal yield gives better sensitivity.

19 Calibration mode for Ξ cc Ξ c0 π : Ξ c (2645) Signal yield ratio for each decay mode of Ξ c 0 is determined from yield of Ξ c (2645), which decays strongly to Ξ c0 π. 19 Ξ c (2645) M(Ξ c0 π ) in low mass region Ξ - π (used by BaBar) ΛK - π feed down of Ξ c (2790) pk - K - π Feed down of Ξ c (2790) Ξ c0 π γ from MC Threshold type function for B.G Ξ - π :pk - K - π :ΛK - π : =1298±51:974±47:1444±58

20 Width of the Ξ c (2645) 20 Only upper limit is given in PDG CLEO PRL. 77, 810 Mode Width(MeV/c 2 ) Peak(MeV/c 2 ) pk - K - π 2.5± ±0.1 ΛK - π 2.6± ±0.1 Ξ - π 2.9± ±0.1 Simultaneous 2.6±0.2± ±0.1 (statistics only) First significant measurement of the width of Ξ c (2645)

21 Result of Ξ cc search:ξ c0 π 21 Ξ - π ΛK - π Data Signal MC (assuming 500 fb and 5% for branching farctions.) pk - K - π Simultaneous fit with fixing signal yield ratio. 3.2σ for GeV/c 2 but probability to observe a peak with significance>3.2 in this the mass range of GeV is 26%. 95% UL of σ(e e - Ξ cc X) Br(Ξ cc Ξ c0 π ) Br(Ξ c Ξ - π ) Belle Theory fb fb (assuming Br=5%)

22 Study of double charm production 22 Production mechanism of double charm production is poorly known. predicted cross section is not reliable. e e - J/ψcc bar by Belle 0.21 ( J / cc) pb pb No measurement on the double charm production without J/ψ so far. O. Seon in Nagoya University is studying the elementary DD production using Belle data.

23 Charmed strange baryons (Ξ c ) 23 u C ρ mode Ξ c λ mode S u/d-s diquark system! Identification of ρ mode excitation is essential for di-quark spectroscopy. (only λ mode excitation is observed) Ξ c (3123)? Ξ c (3080) Ξ c (3055)? Ξ c (2980) Ξ c (2815)(3/2 - ) Ξ c (2790)(1/2 - ) Ξ c (2645) (3/2 ) Ξ c (1/2 ) Ξ c (1/2 )

24 Ξ cc and Ξ c 24 Ground hadrons decays via the weak interaction. This is also a strong decay of hadrons in light quark configuration. ex. pπ is a weak decay mode of Λ and strong decay mode of Δ Kπ is a weak decay mode of D and strong decay mode of K* Ξ cc weak decay modes are Ξ c * strong decay modes Ξ cc Ξ c * c c u weak (c s) Λ c π K - strong s c u

25 M(Λ c π ) Excited Ξ c in Λ c K - π by Belle and BaBar 25 Belle@461.5fb -1 Ξ c (3080) hep-ex/ hep-ex : Babar@384fb -1 Ξ c (2980) Σ c (2520) Σ c (2455) M(Λ c K - π ) Ξ c (2980) Ξ c (3055)? Ξ c (3080) select Σ c (2455) Ξ c (3123)? select M(Λ c K π - ) Σ c (2520) Belle: First evidence of Ξ c (3080), Ξ c (2980) BaBar: Confirmed them and reported two more states. Ξ c (3055) 2star, Ξ c (3123) 1star. M(Λ c K - π )

26 M(Σ c (2455) K - ) by Belle 26 χ 2 /ndf = 54.8/51 Structure near 3055 MeV/c 2 is seen. Significance from -2log(L max /L(0). Significance of 6.6 σ. Mass/width of Ξ c (3055) Belle Babar Mass ±1.0± ±1.2±0.5 Width 9.7±3.4±3.3 17±6±1.1 Result of the Babar is confirmed with 6.8 σ.

27 M(Σ c *(2520) K - ) by Belle 27 Ξ c (3080) χ 2 /ndf = 28.6/42 Structure near 3123 MeV/c 2 is not seen Signal PDF:Gaussian convoluted Breit Wigner. Mean, width was fixed from measurement by BABAR. Yield = 8.2±22.0 Measurement of upper limit σ Br(Λ c pk - π ) of Ξ c (3123) < ±0.6±0.2 fb by BaBar Result of the Babar was not reproduced...

28 Comparison of Λ c and Ξ c or Σ c and Ξ c J p Λ c (udc) Ξ c (usc) 1/2 Λ c (2286) Ξ c (2470) 181 1/2 - Λ c (2595) Ξ c (2790) 194 3/2 - Λ c (2625) Ξ c (2815) 188?? Λ c (2765)? Ξ c (2980)? 205 ΔM(Mev/c 2 ) 28 spin0 di-quark 5/2 Λ c (2880) Ξ c (3080)? 200 J p Σ c (udc) Ξ c (usc) ΔM(Mev/c 2 ) 1/2 Σ c (2455) Ξ c (2575) 120 3/2 Σ c (2520) Ξ c (2645) 125?? Σ c (2800)?? spin1 di-quark The mass difference of Λ c and Ξ c is ~200 MeV/c 2, Σ c and Ξ c is ~120 MeV Λ c with = 2855? Σ c with = 2935?

29 Further study for Ξ c * 29 We confirmed Ξ c (3055) but its isospin partner Ξ c (3055) 0 is not found. Spin-parity and excitation mode is not known for excited states. Relative branching fraction is sensitive to the excitation mode. More excited states? arxiv: M(Λ c K S0 π - ) by BaBar c Ξ c (2980) Ξ c (3080) u ρ mode λ mode s All the Ξ c * are observed in (heavy baryon) (light meson) final states. Λ c, Σ c, Ξ c, Ξ c.. π, K How about the (light baryon) (heavy meson)? study ΛD!

30 Analysis of ΛD 30 M(K - π π ) D selection D sideband M(pπ - ) Λ selected region D from K - π π, Λ from pπ -. Vertex information on Λ.

31 M(ΛD ) distribution 31 Ξ c (3055) M(ΛD ) D sideband M(ΛD - ) Ξ c (3080) Peaks corresponds to Ξ c (3055), Ξ c (3080). No peak structure in D sideband region and wrong-sign ΛD - combination. Significance of the peaks are: 11.7σ for Ξ c (3055) and 4.7σ for Ξ c (3080). Further confirmation for Ξ c (3055) Most precise mass/width for Ξ c (3055) and consistent with previous measurements. Ξ c (3055) Ξ c (3080) Mass(MeV/c 2 ) ±0.4± ±0.6±0.7 Width(MeV) 7.1±1.2± ±1.5±1.0

32 Analysis of ΛD 0 32 D 0 K - π D 0 K - π π π - D 0 selection D 0 sideband D 0 from K - π, K - π π π -, K - π π 0 Relative yields are comparable. D 0 K - π π 0 Branch(%) Efficiency(%) Product(%) D K - π π D 0 K - π D 0 K - π π π D 0 K - π π

33 M(ΛD 0 ) distribution 33 Ξ c (3055) 0 M(ΛD 0 ) D 0 sideband M(ΛD 0bar ) Ξ c (3080) 0 Peaks corresponds to Ξ c (3055) 0, Ξ c (3080) 0. No peak structure in D 0 sideband region and wrong-sign D 0bar Λ combination. Significance of the peaks are: 7.6σ for Ξ c (3055) 0 and 2.6σ for Ξ c (3080) 0. First observation of Ξ c (3055) 0! Ξ c (3055) 0 Ξ c (3080) 0 Mass(MeV/c 2 ) ±0.6± ±0.6±0.7 Width(MeV) 7.4±1.9± ±1.8±1.9

34 Discussion from decay modes 34 The Ξ c * with mass around 3.0 GeV/c 2 is likely to be in N=2 shell. partial width Prediction by chiral quark model for partial width of Ξ c (3055) is inconsistent with this observation. arxiv: Lei-Hua Liu et al Ξ c (3055)/(3080) can decay into both of (heavy baryon) (light meson) and (light baryon) (heavy meson) Σ c K - Λ D u c ρ mode λ mode s Naively thinking, λ mode (light baryon) (heavy meson) ρ mode (heavy baryon) (light meson) Both ρ and λ mode excitation?? Help of the theorist is necessary!

35 Another interest: Λ c /Σ c (2765) 35 Most poorly known Λ c /Σ c state hep-ex/ hep-ex/ First evidence by CLEO By Belle Λ c (2765) Λ c (2880) Λ c (2880) Λ c (2765) Λ c (2940) 2803MeV/c MeV/c 2 pd 0 38MeV/c 2 Λ c (2765) M(Λ c π π - ) M(Σ c π)

36 Prediction from coupled channel approach 36 hep-ph: Coupled channel calculation in I=0 channel. Λ c (2595) is clearly seen. Calculate amplitude in I=1 channel Λ c (2595) If the scenario is correct, it must be... Isospin = 1 (Σ c state) J p = 1/2 - (S-wave DN scattering )

37 Summary 37 Charmed baryon spectroscopy at Belle experiment. B-factory is a good laboratory for hadron physics. Ξ cc is not discovered with full data of Belle. U.L is comparable with some of the predictions. Further study of double charm production is on going. First significant measurement on the width of Ξ c (2645) Existence of Ξ c (3055) is confirmed but not for Ξ c (3123). First observation of Ξ c (3055) in ΛD final state. Both experiment/theory approach is necessary to clarify the structure.