&'( `E D# 5AD 3(O #%.4

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "&'( `E D# 5AD 3(O #%.4"

Elizabeth Russell
5 years ago
Views:

1 "#$ ( ) &'( 1340 /0".2 +,-.$*% 1380 ( 1340 "&" & "#$% 40 = 0 B?- /A = >= *% «9% :6;» &#2 4 & 32 0% +0 &0 L 1380 /". # K7 /#HEJ E 4 & FGH I#HC;D E Q0%# /;?N D# "&#%$ ( = & ( P- & "#9O?ANM67.W0J0 UV0- &0 "#$% = D# " T-S = R 3$.2 & ( 1340 /0" ( 0"0 30$ = I2 /; ( 9- X / FY /0_ 0X /0 FY 0A ^R(.2 :]# &" ( T & ZA # [ \KJ &K= T.*% ^0 0.0O0 9- I` & *% *( BA- &#H&.( ( = d0e 0c# 0D# [T#H by% ( T# by% a? = /_ &0 32 fd *% &#HO +7 3=:#2 & &" ( T +,- "BA- \# e%.2 ( 02 hk-0ij 30$ gd T B;# Q( &_ by% "3$ * X( =.2 32J( j3$ &= K by% &* ). 3$ *( BA- = 9% :6;.*% %H " 3$ mehdi_moradi1369@yahoo.com ehsan_aqababaee@yahoo.com m.jamal8@gmail.com masoudkianpour@gmail.com 1395/5/5 :.WJ l- = /7/12 :*H l- = q]# &F; T %K2& /#2 2eK2.1 &J 97 3`E D# 5AD 3(O #%.2 #% 3`E %K2& 3(O E `E D# 5AD 3(O #%.4

2 &+ $% " #! 34 '5 -. / 0 ( 12 ), &! '() # * + # *# 5 "62 ) ( 2! # * 7!8 E D #!(!6?@ A4.(50 : "/8) # 37G F@ E57!. '() ' 08 0)J.(52 :57!) 37G F@ GH 5 G% I ) H) $!K 4G 0 : 46 () ' A4 6!68! 6 N4G. LM7G% # * E6 '7!8!8 $!K 4G 6 I # "GH * O44 $+3!() # P 6 %6 6 0"7!8 QH 0F4R 7 F U#72 5 V% (!6?@.(56 :57!) * 2# S!) 7 RX " Y! 0*!() W6 A4 *.* )!5 0F4[ O 0G[ O41K, M4Z2 Abrams and Harpham, 2009: ) ^ _RE 6 5G 2\4S] *. # a[ 42 4 G 5 5 # 86 5H# 4`2 0( em) «4c7! * F/2. 5 # GE6.» #4`2 fg4 5 # * 5 U G4).O.. 4h% 5 # * X 5 8*1.(15:1389 " I(31 057!) * 4`2 *7 0Ei[ j *]Za 05 R42 k@ 0 /# 8*1 GSRm '5 1900W # # 5 U/6 47.# l2 8 E6.(92:57!) $S2 «Y4X» 6«nc Y4X» 'A4 6 6 G 108

3 . - +(, *() N 8 *So 7 8 4` # O6 A4 # GE6 I* "7! $! 5 p N.4 U G[@ P L)a!*/`[ / O6 4/1@ * GK8 37G GK8 6 F ,! N) 1380Q! (14: ) * F6 "!5 :* sv6 4+ (29: %) $GS!! #!5 0 ]3 0 G)u@.t G [ wj 2* F (4# (!6?@ ".F7 *F47 6" 37G N.t !! QGS Ur h) v!!5.4 G[@ F4[ 1! F68 "GSc $1 S x1 ". E F4[ 1 'A4V4 0 YJ 5 '( "7!. 5 *4h3 ) # * 37G " *7! G[ '58## # 5#4# 5#37G 6 *2 _] * 37G 1, F4[.# 4@$Hr me F4[ QKg6 4a u@.t2 "..tg 37G M4Z2 2 4!!!5 F4[ 7 0z "7!. (!6?@ " Q/yS K u@.t2 " 42 0wZ2 " +!! G M4Z2.t2 # 4 2 F F4# (!6?@ ". F 7 4r )!5 0 p4[ Q! 6 : ]3!4[ G[@!5 (!6?@ " #!(@.* {* F 7 4r !! )!5 F4[!! `GE 6 37G N F4[ {* G)u@.t2 4r 109

4 G r !!!5 F4[ 7 p4qs {4 a%,+- &&./ L)a r8 0F7 N4G Q]J #!} 0A47!} I + 2GS ]J " 0*S ]J " ~4`c l '"G 0i`Z2 6 }4 5*7! 054E 5U8OG% 547! QRX 0$! /!.(Freedman, 1969) _ 37G F _ ]E!} I# F ]J "!} G, 04[ 6 37G ih % 543 }4 037G u@*r4ys u@*r4ys 04)a 0*Ea 6 * G) 0RU 56 8.(Heald, 1964) 6 57@ F4[ *]S *Sc 1r 5 # 6 : v S EK Q! / Q1]!*R) 5#6Z 6 54 H 4# 2 G)8!5 GE 6 v! " # i GS 6 *7!,! 0.( #) 5#V F + «*/ 6 F i» «K i» Y!.G Q]J }i2 0 6H# *E (238 :57!) 4!! # J ".(520 : !) 4 5! 6 56H# GS 6 M O42 0]S F) 6 Ga 46 0# %J I*)8.( # I )) H je6 K 073 0! '$S2 110

5 . - +(, *() z 0# 6H# # 2M4Z2 ) 0*/ 6 F i '"G)M 6 `Z2 5 (U) _4 J " l2 $! F4[ 6 (530 : !) F#`Z2 54 H 6 54( 4 sx G.# l2 }4cG!F4[ QM@ 6 G!5 j 6 0 O+ *7 *#% 0`Z2 Q 5$!) J " 1!# $!!5 4% 6 5 ms Q 0" F6i3.4 N4G Q]J 5H # 4h% 5 6 F ˆ w% 5 I O S $G[! "7! L)a p4[ W4Z2.(502 : )) 8 $!). 2 $! 1380 Q! '5 W 1r 6 H Q! # 0]J ". W) F6 N4G Q]J 1380 Q! Q!, 4[ p6 5W)!H 04 F W W) Q]J, 6 037G 0 `GE 4% 4[ ]J " I# 46*S ]E 6 S) 7! *R6 6 (130 :1381 0H) 4 G4[ u _] *R6!* 0jE6.4 G) 4[! " \]2 )# 0 `GE ih 46 0$! "@ Q]J 6 4 F M Q]J `GE N4G Q]J.( :57!) * *R6 2$Z,Š4R4m!4@ 4 F W)! " 4[!G4[ wz2 5K6 *4Z " # 2]RX A4.Hc 7G 4[ 4h% 1380 Q! 6 (130 :57!) / *R6 ] 542 /7 5 I4 26KG k * Q]J F# 32 X ^4-( +67 r(2 = = Q%# /;?N.1

6 6 05 / !* 6 *4! 2 0,2U# 6 G!*R6 5 h) # 2iH 0.(24 :57!) # p4 54E jv ) 37G Q]J " h3 SR _] * Q! 547! 0! ".( U 6 F I1393 5G[ 7 /72 i`z2 Q.*)8 E 42 U# 5HE4% 05!) *)8 H@ $! 5S@ G% 6 F6U)!FH V% O3 6 05#4# *h% 0 ij! S "4E 0"7!.(328 :1389 _] $! 4!5 jk $! # 4E I(331 :57!) jv6 5 /3 *4H[ F '!*6Z [ Yu% 6 F4[ 5 F '52GS 7GK8 'l2 E 5]/J ia "G)# r Q! Q. 5 }u@ 'j ^ 0* 5 57!!* S 0 v.(1388 0h 6 4)) 4H#!FH 8 06 * *6 /Z2 }6 6 7 Q+ ]#2 (!6?@ " '}6 /Z2 }6,7# 0 }i2.8 E «SK2 $@» D 07@ ZR *)!/Z2 "'7 Q+ 8F1 6 4 /Z2 54G 0*6 07 Q8!+. \]2 F R42!5. # 37G * + *E "GH 0 FKG + " G[ A4 *]S 0 46 G!KRŒ *6 /Z2 }6 r8.* 6 0(# 0[ QKRŒ 1r cg # RX!4!/Z2 GS42 "2.Œ KRŒ 1r " I U#72 Za 112

7 . - +(, *() #547 *4/ 6 4rr (c.# )(. FKG 8 J 4rr!*6 I8![ F -5G Y *6 542.(18 : ) 8 4a p6 34 *Sc 0!/Z2 6.(109 : R)![ F!(c # 4 " (c # 58 0G]R I (c!5 6 0(# 0[!KRŒ 0kŽ. [ 6, 7GH # + "!5 Za `GE G N /Z2 0O {# K H (!6?@!5 N42 G)84a 7 p4 2 F!5 } 56 a * " 0 QKRŒ Yi[ 0Za QKRŒ p /a QG k3 I*S \]2 F4[ 1 5#4`2 L7GS KRŒ " # t2 7V 6 Z4/2 Li# J Za # 5 V% (!6?@!W6 0!/Z2 j7 525.# K ( 58 WMG a[ "63 F!(# 6![ 04+ "7!. $2.!4[ #D!KRŒ (c!5,! I cg «7»! 4@ $!!H 6 0$!K 0!Ur `3 # ) : 46 *)! 7 p4 p.(hall, 1997: 24) 4 F *)! RX ".(24 :1387 0F 1) 8*[ I 72 I * G *! *)! " I FKG 8*[ 113

8 QG[!5 L # * " 7 A4 " cg */3. *)! ".!4[ G[ 7 34 O 6 58S # U 6 4[ 4[!6 6 # 6!O+ FKG 0!6 6 0# *]^2 5 " w]j.48 «8*[ *)!» 5 06 ".$ 7 # * 5 $GS " / 0* 6% # *S '51 " 0*)! # GS! 5 5 ".$# FKG 5 4[ $!K Qm *[ 7 6!O+ 6!) 6 41K! 4rr.(25 :57!) 51 /6" 2 # FKG V 4Z*6 xrx *K# t2 }6 ]G3 5Z "/R rr 44 1r }6 ]G3.(Loh, 2013) I A 6 5 WMG u@6. FKG 6 em) «4c7! * F /2. 5 # GE6.» # * "!F # *K8 0(!6?@ " 54u@57J xt2.(15 : ,2,2 56 * R.* G)HG 6 F r!5 (!6?@ RX " 54r.* RX " u@t2 /R F #D 51@! # *K O 542 $! Q! 6!H7 j.* F *3 $! u@wg !W " F :;< = 14. r!5 Q7! (!6?@ " Q 114

9 . - +(, *() Q # p.f4[ A4V4 j #!5 I* *) `ch 3iJ !! F r!5 Q7! 5 :* 0F cg 7)! 4a # 047 $ %.H! 6!5 QRX z.1380 Q! \ Q! \4 6!5 cg. cg " 4 F G4. " # 5G 0O6 I F4[ A4V4. " 547h # J]2 0W6 : G)8 + "!Y! 54r. FG) K Q! 6!5 }i2 0* G[ 6 37G M4Z2 F4[ 1 u@.t2 (!6?@ G[@ $! F#D!! G[ 6 37G M4Z2 F cg!5 2. 0_ 06/ "71. 0_ K: ] Q!!5.4 : ]3 U 1380 Q!!5. *R6 47Z QG4 0K 60Ea W7. K!). 04@)# 60)6 ]). 0" p@ H( > ?@ -ABC.1 >&. &G (&A 2 T *F( 7 H(?H 9 "H F C2 9% 9% C2 = T IJ J&H E QEi3 4!.# *6 W F 'J 4! O S@ '8 _ K *6 }@. S!F3 YiG[ }@ 6. 8S4 115

10 G6 0)J. * 8S4 6 }4[ ^4! # Q7! GH 8?6 6 RX! ) 04 r 44 r 04! 4! 02 k@.!!5 8?6 "I* 6 zt!5 W% 54r 0$! )J.# 8 }F4[ GS# 8 $7`2 05G Q.4 W4lH (!z QRX 0* U@ QG `Z2 5G Hc!5 G /Ž "S% 6 ]# 6 7! 0 4[ % *1 4! GE6 0O. (@.# *6 }F4[ 6 4! \4 *6 : 46 *6 5 " $! 4! F6$! 5G6 *6 6 7/Ž "S% 6 ]# *6.* U#.#7 E a[ \]2 $!!*6,!.* 7E *6 K?L $! (R% 4! 5 # * [ 0R6 : [ 6 (c " * [ 06 I u8o «4! 56 4» [ " I4[ [ " O I# [ 6 }@ 2 6 5[ }@ 4! 5 # 46 5 " $1 (# 6. Gu8 «S@ "G) [ $!» $! 04[ Gc2 6 _ 5 4! 54r.[ 4! "G) (# 0 : 4! $7`2 6I u8o «Gc2 6 54[» &(# ". cg «F4[ H7! 2» U (# " O I}F4[ # 5 0 *6! 6 # nch ! i72 6 wmi3 6 ˆ4[ 6 G[4[ Ei3 "G4 6 0* RX! $! 5 Za. 6 6 jx Li# () * 116

11 . - +(, *() Za.# 4`2! v 5 5G # h) Z4/2 # 0ZK2!5 6!57G[ A4.* 2]J YiG[ A4V4 # ]J " xyig[ F4[ 04 F 5H ) 0 '5#@ Gc.# *6 W, J F4[ 8 K 5 ".47 6 ][! M4J 2.6 *4# 8 $7`2 # '5 k@.4 Ei3 0Gc S7! 0542[ 0F 8# 0_% 05 0Gc 02 k@.4gs6 _% $! 542[ 0*4# Gc ][ ' F * (@, 6 F7 # }[ 6 *E6 r Gc.6 }F4[ 8 4`2 6 # 6 #! G) 6 (GR4/ Q`P0# F+ # R # $! _% 05@.# H#4[ * F F# (. 6 # 6 4 Y` # 2 542[ 2 G)8 $7`2 I}F4[ 6 542[ *6 :# 542 *6. "!*6 0"7Gr + z 0jE6.}F4[ 6 /3 *6 6 I_% *6 7E }F4[ 6 /3 *6 6 GS! }F4[ 6 542[ 6 _% \4. \]2 $! U#!*6.GS! K?L 6 # 2 [ Gc 0 :* F4 + 5 " [ u8o «# 2 [ Gc» [ " I6 *4# # '5#@ `E 117

12 # 4 ][ _%.*«,GM Q[# [» [. R _% 0. *[ 8# 7 `E,GM Q[# 543 I* /3 p4[ 6 [ N [ "4.47 G)u@ 56 4]7# 0U F v!(# 5. FU8 [ " «/3 p4[ *V6» (# " 6[ 6! Z6 6 0!(2 0Gc H#4[ (# (# " } 6 542[!43 6 u8o «! Z6» `G[. cg 5#SK2 cg «!43» `G[ U h3,!.* 6[ 60 0Gc 0542[ 0_% 5!*`c }4#*c G]R 66}4[ LM47 _%.ih.tg ~[ / 6542[ # ( 6.Fu8 K }73 GH 6.* # *@ }G) 54r 0 7 G 542[.#,7# }F4[ 'Gc * GK8 Gc *`c. W4]E Li# 5 2 / 0 4 # 6 5G P # G!]! 12 KGH8 I* _/JF 6 G.* FW "g 60% 0fV 0}G[ *K36 #@ 5#) /7 06! ih '5#% # 4Z ih 0 + G[ ih 6 ]E 2 $! 6[. * 0$! Za. 4w 6 81 G[ 6 5)J!/[ # 6.# F H]/% p@ 0Gc Q[ 2Ka42 '5 * W7#.# 48 05G 51E 0W7# 8 F ( _ 0 118

13 . - +(, *(), 6. $/Ž 2 F E W, N) 6 * G 4( 5 u 6 U3 OZ F H7! # F4[ I* ]!u p4[ p4[ W7#.# Z2 6 $m I W7#.@ 6 0!"H 0!71 $#$# W7#.4!5 8 p4 6 1r4 # 047Z W7# 05 ".4 F68 "!u8}4[ H }@ W7# ^ 6 * RX! 47Z.4 0* $/ 8.# 8 }F4[ R "7! I* F4[ W7# # 4 _] 47Z ^ S# 6 1r4 p4[ 547!!F4[ # 0 4[ # G[.#, 4[ p4[ 8 }6 G }F4[ W7#. 8 ) Q]J!u8}4[ (@ 47Z 8 }6 547! *6 IW7# p4[ *6 :# 542 *6 _ 5 (U 6 1r4 6 W7# p4[!*6.47z *6 6 I(U 6 1r4 1r4 6 W7# p4[ *6 6.* 7E x*6 47Z *6 6 U# *6 J]2! je6 6 4 )!F4[ 5 W7# 4h% wj (U 6.N]2 $! (U 6 1r4 6 47Z * E!5 " K?L W7# 4[ QX. u8o «473 % FH» 543 [ "GSc " O I8! v!5 " #!FH _] } G)8 $7`2 W7# O4 [. Gu8 «"G)8/a)» [ $! *KRc "G) Q+ZR.6 )S (G6. u8o «@ 5U6i8» [ " I

14 # 0}@ FH k@ W7# : (# 44!(# 5 5#1E» O (# " I# 2 [ 0G) K2 W6!(c # 4 4G 0* G) W7# #!6. cg «[ F7! (G6 6 8 [ 72 0" 46 0* X2 7 6 W7# 5G6. cg «[ 5# 6» (# " O.4 } _ 2 # 0(!Y% 0* F5! 7 5 # 0W7#..*S * (!Y% 6 7 7! }@ # 48 0 W]. FU8 «@ }[@» O (# " *4[ 6!Ur Q 2 W7# }i2 QKRŒ F4[ 5U.* 42 4[ # " *7 6!2U. G ]!u $ )6 QEi3 W7# # * F 3 ]!u 6 8 p4 " "G)8/a) _] 5G6 6 x k#! Y% }4[ Y% U 6 * zh[ 6 ks[ W7# jx S@ +G 6 54r 6 už W7# l2 427 $! UU3. W4]E Za. [GS8 6 G% W7# 6KG!F8 0.* F !g # 2l2 6! 4 $! :N0O 6 G7!5[ # # 4 2St2 7!"R! " '5 ".(4 F!r4# 27E!7) 4 '$GS 06) 0RM 0W4]G!5[ # 07. W]G 4[ 'GP) ]2 37G 8 a3 *3 0*)8 4/1@ 6 120

15 . - +(, *() !W ! # *a p!5h OE " I* F _22 a% G "2.(1392 0Ri) * F4 O 5 FKG 5 5$!) Q/7 5 x A4 41g 6 37G ]J 6 0 N4G 06Š4 ]J 542 /7 5.* 1340 Q! M4Z2 2 A4V4_ 6 _K!5.# F G 6Š4F[ 66 N4G Q]J 6 6Š4 Q]J 2 _K.* GS ]J 6Š4F[ 6 N4G Q]J " 2]J 2 $! Ea. 6 $GS! ) Q]J 6Š4 Q]J.* E G 56!]/%!,4R ) # R% IG 4[ 6 ) 8 1 _ 67% $GS, Li^ ! 42 4 F? Q! [6 6Š4 Q]J.(253 : !) 0" F6i3.* 42 "!H F1$#!O6 '"G)8 I4 *R6. ]J " GH *42 _] /M *K *7E (U) I# X3 O6 wj F6 2 58U8 4/X!4 (@ E6.(8281 : UU34 6 Y)!!!v *R6 *Sc! (U) 6 O42 O6 57G[ 6 " }6) 6 [ # * 2M4Z2 W4`Z 4[ # * 56 " $1 Q]J N4G Q]J! )% 6 5``cG 6 K 5# ]J I F O 5!*R) ]J " # 7 GK8.(249 : !) F#`Z2 84[ _] *#H " OM h) 5H$!) 0G]R I* (8 $! # 04 H HE (U) 0" F6i3.(86 : UU34 6 Y) ]J " 121

16 F 4 1 W h) 0*)8 N4G Q]J p!5 S 04 FH * *7 " 4H# h) 56 54r " F " U 5!.(89 :57!) (8 i 6 8 r 3 ]J 6 *7» 2 _] K i l2 # # F A4V4 6 5K6 4 F E (Rr "2 4/1@ $Š Gu8 #.(251 : !) «1r ( 1 8# Q]J UU34 6 Y 7%.* G 6Š4F[ Q]J 44 Q]J!5 Q 4a!5 05Fl H2 1 ]S# 'G!Fl.*.4 E 5H2M4`Z.G 543 6@ *Z G # %6 r :F * ]J " ] fa42 GRU 6Š4F[!/Z, # F68 QGS!!5[ 4[ LM47, 6!5 ]S# 6.G)8 6 G[6) 58 56H@» fs #! # 6)F[ 6 056H@!} 6 8 p4 /a 5i% *%6 F7! 6.(90 : UU34 6 Y) «4 6H# (c 'W) *7 (!# _] 54U *7 j *#% 1341 W W) *7 a 48 / 6 6H# $1 # 4J I4 F (!# (K 54/ 2 / 96%) 1356 W a 32 / 1 (K 54/ 3 / 2 6%) *7 2j! 4H# W) *7.(671 : ) 4 G) K 54/ ( 4H# W) *7 0! w]j.* 6U) 6 P "G)M 4 /R " 6 I(670 :57!) 4 F 1345 K 54/ 7 / !4H# 1340 Q! U!a 044! w]j. # 5U 122

17 . - +(, *() *% " I(69 : S%) 4 W4lH # z) /[ Q%.* F4] R *4# K 5 51E '"G) W^ #! 5H WlG 6 # AV6 54]_! [ 58# 1 N]2 ) 6 5iP 5# p!5h $! GK '5 /[ p4%!4h# #! *u p!5h $! * 6H# (c Ga PH $1 '(U) 6!l 8#@ 564 j z) # " (671 : ) 6H# PH *]S 2[ 6.! * 4[ l 6H# (c 5iP 0 S7! 0.# *6 }) 6 6!4 8 "p@ 5 2, 0R "7! I # "G) 6 "J6 i QEi3 05 " " 0 S7! *H8 4] w)4 Gc.# 8 5 *6 6 * frc 1, 6 [ " Ei3! }4[.] tgs 6 c [ [!4[ 0# )S 4+ 0Gu 5 5HG4 W 6 # }Gu8 G4@ 0 S7! 0 6 0EK2 " #.6K 8 6 QGu8.48 }2U!4[ }4[ 8 $7` ) [ 0O.* Gu8.t2 6 6 GH.8 Q[ 8 # GS! G6 6 p4[ 6 }S7! 6 GH 8 123

18 * U# *6 }S7! 6 GH $! Li# *6 6.* 7E *6 p4[ K?L [ 6 (@ 5G *6 #![ Q7! 5 "G) 43» [ " I 6 6 " ' 43 0 : cg [ 0*S! [ # 0[ "6. u8o «#!(# # 0$! (# 6. F1 O «[ }6)» [ " I6) H# 0 6 IF4# `E [ "G) (# 0 : FU8 04 2K «1» O6 (# 6 «"G) F4#» W6 (#.# K 4# 5 # ()! 5 6 * F4[4[ S [ *`c. u8o A4V4 8 4J $! Za QKRŒ.*S $1 ( 5 *4[.# F 5 Gc 6 H572@ }S7! S QEi3 6 wh3 # * )# 5G 4@)# G[!5.4 $! 8 $7`2 0 $! # 2)iG[ _] )# " a )#.# 8 }@ (@ # 4S88 O )#.Ž 6 # 12 }S7! Q1 5 x 4G 2 * F# 02 k@.! sv42 (G6 6! GH [ p $! 5G W4J 8 6 # `E " 0# 8 )# @ # 04Ka 6 )# (7 5# Q1.#,U )# 4[ 04 6 S7! 6 # 0.4 # W4lH )# $! 6 4,U 124

19 . - +(, *() o@ ( k#! # 48 4Ka 0 *6 S 4[ Ol@ (!4[ 0O 0)#.4 [ 6 8 4Ka 6 #7.# $! #! *6.* 6 *6 6 " G QX. 46 *6 6 5 W4J *6 U 6 6 4Ka QX.* U# *6 0}S7! 6 6.GS! $! Li# 6 $! J]2! *6 6 ".* 7E K?L Ka }i2 :* 42 4[ [, 5 " 5. cg «6 8 4Ka 66» O [ " I 6 }F4[ `Z2 Q W r # $40 6 S7! $!!(# /Z2.* F }S7! 8 0F# 2 W% 7. cg 5 # * H# 0R6 :4 2.Œ 7! (# `Z2» (# " O I* }F4[ 6 6 `Z2 4[ fg6 2 4 _] (/`Z2 Q 42 6 U#72 5U "G) 6 (# O6 (#.4 )P }F4[ h3 *]S 6 [ " I6 "!F }S7! W]G 6 5 # H# I* "!F S7! W]G "G) 'O! 54Ei3. u8o «"!F "G)» (# p.* 41H Li# * F ) FH 6 z F2 # QGK8 06 * $/ ]/JF * *7! Um% *`c }F4[ F V% 4 )V (E4% 7# N) 0}S7! ( * GK8 Za QKR4.6 `Z2 W] 6 # 2 ~`G[ )# h) Za 6 u8 4@)# 5G

20 )# 54r # * 5 5 " Za )# 5 'GS. 5 0* *P) E6 5u8 N4G Q]J QEi3 4!5. F?6 42 5!PP 6 N4G Q]J Q/yS :N0O 72 5 N4G Q]J ) [ # * /ms 1 /73!G4[ " # 24a 0]J " '!G4[ 42.! 5H 0 G)42!4H# "G) 6 4H# 6[!5 # * ]J S 04H X ) /# 4J.# cg 0%F QRU I :# $S2 G 1r ".4 4H#,! *7! 6 ( 04H#! N GS.XZ 6 I)l I `GE.( ) # l " F F 4H# 1 6 js2 xg 43!(!6?@ [ 4H#!) :* G 6 1.Œ 43 0!(!6?@ " w]j.* #6 W6 QG N) 0V% (!6?@ 0G]R.` 4H#!D 6 Iˆ] *K# 547! /ms # F 5H!.$ '"G)4]1 # " I*.Œ 1 5U js2 6 1 * F! " 1 (U) _] 1380 Q! 43 " *V !W " 1.Œ 43 H!6?@.(57!).* `GE 6 h) 1.Œ 43 /7. G[@ ! 042 W%!4H# `GE 6!*6Z.( U 6 F) 4 1 5U _] 6 * ) 126

21 . - +(, *() Q]J " (.# F U 5 N4G Q]J A4V4 Q.* 2$1 i`z2 5U 6 sx!5 5 I 46!n[ 37G 4R 6 8 p4 I#64 I"H1 *7 5U : ]3!n[ 0*!n[ 8 p4. F73 ( 2]J,K2 # Y` k@ 6 I8 5 6 "G I*P) E6 5u8 p4 I]42 6 "S ^ *7! R3 i`z2 sx n[ 0!n[ " 5.(1388 0h 6 4)) 4H# 54 H !W " Q!. GH $6, 6% 6 F4 6 ( " 0! w]j.* F F6U) S.(57!) * F K 54/ $6 ( K 54/ 6 5 S 42 5U 01380Q! 37G M4Z2 \]2 \4 ms 6 `Z2! 142 " Q/7 0# F!5 4%.*)8 4a 2E 5 4% *7% 56 ".* ij 6 6 4H# [!FH GR6!4 FKG 56 F F 5 ". F!}4@6 54@ p U 4( 5G[ 6# `Z2 F6 he O+ 5 66!F.*) (U) W FU@ 5G[ 6 *h% w%.6 * ij N)!".(331: !) G)8 + 5 % F4[!F8 5 6 W *K! 5)!5 66 $! *[ *7 5 4% $! # * 37G M4Z2 Hc ij Q! F '4[ '$1 Q/yS.# 1S2 A7G 04H# W4% *]. 5 7 * F cg 3iJ z.*! " F*]. 6 (!! " # 5 *% ij 6 6!.* F ij 4H# 127

22 OQ;0 P j 6 /# 7 0!W6 $ wj 0!4[ }i2 *Sc (c " xy!!sk2 6 /Z2 %.4 m a%!sk2 6!/Z2 (c " Q/6.* F cg!5 "G # * OP V% (!6?@. * 1 651@ $!!SK2 %. R42 R6!OP N0O R@ "O% Q%# /;?N.1.2 u K% Bt /;?N ( +;?N T -;?N B;-.2 K- (v /;?N.*% &# Q%# T#H? & S" Q%# /;?N ( *%.*% & C%K "`? 4 KH = L 3$ B;- ( +(9- "3O.2>&. N0 R@ " ( =&.( $ & S" J ( J wk%&#]- ( $ 3$ `E" x- "Ly? & ( *% CANrK- " WJ&YA% >3=- O&YA% >*%?# ( z$ J & S* O6ABE =T N0O. hlh L.1 & T#H O.2 eh \A$ /2 "E.KK + = 1340 /" {6N.3.2 ( # K7 B E *% & *.4 B 2 H h" C?% -$.2 =(E h]? 4.3>&. N0.E c- & -;?N +H6#$ c# Q2.K x- &$ #] UV- *- 3$ =%4#%, /$ $." AD I$ * X( #] E$ T = 3$ h "f(.*% &#H "D 3$ }9.6- C = - 3$ gd.*% ZH. 3$ K }9 C?% +6RE = UV# T%.2 3$ #E :2." E KE?A IJ & S* O6ABE =T 128

23 . - +(, *().4>&. N0O 3$ gd T B;- ( ghlh "K% ~.1. & D# +;?N.2. ( C?% Bc- & R.3.2 6c hlh da#] D# "&;?N.4.2 B;- y S"? 4 3$ & &6D N0 Dq 3E = T#HO&A7H J 2L(6O &$ = &$ = ( J &.$J "BR2 "$ " E=H ( TF(.K &u- O=. -(9# - 2J = TF(. Y.*% 2 ( P- 2 " ( O= 4?% & S* O6ABE =T W 4 B;# x 5D : 3$ = LO :+ 3$ [-?U : U. >&..5>&.? 4 () :KH (+) :3$ = L () :"3O B;- ( +(9- (000) :" UV- *- 3$ c# Q2 () ( (+) :*% &#H T = 3$ h () :3$ K Q9 = - 3$ gd () :3$ gd T B;- ( g- (+) :3$ & &6D () : -(9# " E=H ( TF( OV F 51@ 0O 0!5 F cg QR6 _#2. R42 «F4[ G O3» 6 0«F4[ U8» 0«F4[ '2].» /a) 02]J 6K2 R 0h3 0_ 6 _K!5 427 a[ H h3,! 54r $! K 5.G)8 54 ) _K.4 2]. _] "7! 6 # 7!.* * E F4[ 54Ei3 $! _ 129.* 41H [

24 K.* F4[ ) Q U!43 0K 5 FH!5 " 6! E $! h3 & S ih 0 )ig[ " YiG[ $! h3 _.! v. $!K2 $! ) # * " 44 '2 $! _K.] ". G O3 51@ 8 _RX " Q7! A >&. N0O &A = &#H& %- "E & +.1.*% hlh & ( /K= BD ( O= *9.2.*% Uƒ + c# ( %% "*(.3 C?% " & %- "E.2 + L 2? 4 N0 T _@6#$ & T#H % D " q(= &$.(H 3$ & - T#H 3 + % & K#D? & Q;H 3$ H.*% $ "(=." E KE-J ^ ^* X( & S* O 6ABE =T.7>&. N0O r# /7D Q%# /;?N.1. F H g L B? = " $2 &;?N T.2.O= I2 ( KE2 +6c-. hlh E ue 2.3 I " A O= 4?%.4 ( * H +( WO.2 OO `K"H B ( Bc- & "&K=.5 &- = & {6N ( q(= & a.2 7$.2 = {6N.6? 4 3$ 7 2 &#2WO J = S" = 3$ gd T#HO&A7H 3$ = *A9 N0 & 97 (( ( O= Bc- & %J T"3 & T#H CAN3 %J.*%." $ &- L Q%# /;?N & S* O 6ABE =T 130

25 . - +(, *() W 4 3$ 2*"S : 3$ H g- :+ 3$ `yr &YF : U. >&..8>&.? 4 (+) :"q(= T _@6#$ () :3$ & - () :3$ H % & K#D () :3$ 7 2 &#2WO J= (+) :S" = 3$ gd T#HO&A7H () :3$ = *A9 OV F $! "p@ *`c $! * GK8 51@ "GSc p x]2 5H!6 6! G4[ 5 6! 4@)# 5 *`c G)8 "p@ # 277`2 6!43.!7 *7! F4[ 5HR73 F#D x[ 6!.# F4[ ) 5 h $! 4@)#. $! hg!f8 }S7! 6 6 # * sv6!krœ.*s w)4 }S7! `Z2 6 I* E "7! he W4a 5 0F4[ ) G3 R6! 6 R6.*) 542 F4[ rž 6 O S "G) " 6 0F4[ !!! 5 V% (!6?@ # 4 4 "G[@ 4#u! 6 M4Z2 Y! U 5]/J ia 6 6 (@ O+ *7 *4[ F.4 FH G 6.4 N4G Q]J!G4[ 8 W] 1380 Q! 1380 Q! M4Z2.* M4Z2 M *3 6 8 G c2 Q! 6 " 4H# i 6@ k@ W *S _E # 4 34E 2 2 }i2 # 4 nch E " '8 G.4 F 1 $! W4ZG 6Z 'W r 3 R*S!] $!.4 G3,R H N6 5#5488 4/1@ V7Z xy! 131

26 %ia Q8 % Q7! # 4 " (2E F 8 G QH. _4` Q! V )!5 F4[ 7 4r (@ 42 R6! # 4`2 *K F* QR6 FU@ 142» 547! 63.* GK 4`2 F F7 F4[ 48" * «F4[ U» 6 0«! 6 " +YiG[» 0«F4[ _ 6 1GR r 44 G[!H). F4[ # 4 \]G.4 "6 O6 (@ Za QKRŒ (.* F # 4`2 0* F# Wl!5 # (c KRŒ " r!!5 u@.t2 je6 # V3!5 [ h) Za 547!!Za.! 5H 4H# `GE 37G M4Z2 KRŒ " '( 7! H572@ *V6 6 02]J )ig[ 0H]/%!5 0jE6.! ][ 37G h) 5 u@.t2 55H * F G[ # G # 2 4# Za QKR4 Q/6.! 5H U!*E @ 0R6! F6 (@ "[ 6 "4 " F4[ F$2 6`2 6.# F!/Z2 F* 1 Q! p 4.*[@ S 2* 4a 542 0! 6 6 `GE![.tG!F4[ " I$GS! 66 F4[ 1340 *SS8 4 *)!5 6 4 r 6) ih 37G R6! # GSS8 I* $!!5 6 F4[ ) " 37G ms 5 6!!F4[ U 1380 Q!.# *) $! 51@ 6 132

27 . - +(, *() " # * «F4[ '2].» 51@ 0Li^. `GE 6 4[ p4[ 0`Z2 W] 5 0!5.# 7Z2 F4[ 6 " Q7!. 4H# 1 `E [ $! 6 # 2 F4`2!F4[ 5 #G QX GS!!48 ZV42 +!/Z2 1 # * «F4[ !5.* F G)8. :!" #$ %$ ZĤ U i 6 " 5.(1377). :!" #$ (1389) &&&&&&&&&& :& %&- &.)$ & F !) *6.(1380) )*) +.9 *2 + %/01 2 3)4 5+ %)* % )! :63486*K8.«1357 & 1283 :& =&>" 9&? )4 >&+ 7@&1 9AB».(1392) :1-5 &+)" F :.135&99 up# 4 S4.(1393) ) % i 60*R6 037G ]J.(1386) GA %::A*> HB.6? KL J+M : 5.9 :."*G : r].(1381) IJ 9 3 O 5 H1.(1377) L4 N" J Z2 «&*1 1 P Q K4R!+ Q 8 SM *A +)».(1393) L4 IJ$ ).9 G?B : 5.362&337 :2 `GE N6.(1369).)$ 4*+ Q/`) «8& & ++ %4U!V %4Q SW».(1392) 9> ):9 TR-* %4KB &J+M :&.)> :.69 &41 :77 ]! 6 k/ 2 O 5 S45G W a.(1368) IJ >A 5 O I& 5 37G M4Z2 2 IF *6.(1383) )*".+) L>" 8Y 133

28 Z5&[ Q &? &++ 8\*&$ )4 8SW& ]+*! [^_».(1388) 9$G T) $ %Q*".28&11 :17 i.#gv : * #-^A 5 /&[ :& K&>*1 R?&$ &.4Y %*> :."*G : 2 O K>*1 R?$ 5 i RX «)4 5+ i 2 O b"a 7 6 *6!H.(1369).).` %2.(1392) L4 I+*- IG.!+.(1389) L4 *4 O\.(1388) Z*2 9*-.9+)?+* 8?-c!"4 : 7 6!.(1387) $+ K4Q% Abrams, M.H. and Harpham, G.G. (2009). A Glossary of Literary Terms, Ninth edition, Boston: Wadsworth Cengage Learning. Freedman, Philip I. (1969). Middle Class Value Lower Class Rights, The Clearing House, 43(8): Hall, Stuart (1997). Representation: cultural representations and signifying practices, London Thousand Oaks, California: Sage in association with the Open University. Heald, James E. (1964). In Defense of Middle-Class Values, The Phi Delta Kappan, 46(2): Loh, J. (2013). Inquiry in to issues of trustworthiness and quality in narrative studies: A perspective, The Qualitative Report, 18(65):

T h e C S E T I P r o j e c t

T h e C S E T I P r o j e c t T h e P r o j e c t T H E P R O J E C T T A B L E O F C O N T E N T S A r t i c l e P a g e C o m p r e h e n s i v e A s s es s m e n t o f t h e U F O / E T I P h e n o m e n o n M a y 1 9 9 1 1 E T