Survival of the Sweetest

Size: px

Start display at page:

Download "Survival of the Sweetest"

Alisha McDaniel
6 years ago
Views:

Biology Survival of the Sweetest A Tasty Tale of Natural Selection and Community Dynamics MATERIALS AND RESOURCES EACH GROUP teacher-provided materials 2 dice TEACHER bags, brown paper, small 3 bags

1 Biology Survival of the Sweetest A Tasty Tale of Natural Selection and Community Dynamics MATERIALS AND RESOURCES EACH GROUP teacher-provided materials 2 dice TEACHER bags, brown paper, small 3 bags Skittles, 1 lb ABOUT THIS LESSON In Part I, students will simulate the events of natural selection for a population of mussels. Candy pieces of two different colors will represent the variations of thick, strong shells and thin, weak shells found in a population of mussels. Beneficial variations increase the chance of survival for some organisms, leading to a shift in the population s genetic makeup. In Part II, students will simulate the effects of a predator on the diversity of a community. The students will become familiar with the role of keystone species and their importance to an ecosystem. T E A C H E R P A G E S OBJECTIVES Students will: Simulate the impact of natural selection on a population of mussels Simulate the effects of a predator on the diversity of a community LEVEL Biology i

2 COMMON CORE STATE STANDARDS NEXT GENERATION SCIENCE STANDARDS (LITERACY) RST Follow precisely a multistep procedure when carrying out experiments, taking measurements, or performing technical tasks, attending to special cases or exceptions defined in the text. DEVELOPING AND USING MODELS (MATH) A_CED.2 Create equations in two or more variables to represent relationships between quantities; graph equations on coordinate axes with labels and scales. STABILITY AND CHANGE SYSTEMS AND SYSTEM MODELS ASSESSMENTS The following types of formative assessments are embedded in this lesson: Visual assessment of graphs Discussion of specialized vocabulary in Part I. Assessment of students understanding of the importance of a keystone species Assessment of students understanding of the carrying capacity concept The following assessments are located on the website Populations & Environmental Assessment (Biology) Evolution and Taxonomy Assessment (Biology) LS4: EVOLUTION LS2: ECOSYSTEMS ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Skittles is a registered trademark of the Wm. Wrigley Jr. Company, a division of Mars, Inc. T E A C H E R P A G E S ii

3 CONNECTIONS TO AP* AP BIOLOGY 1 AP BIOLOGY 4 A.1 Natural selection is a major mechanism of evolution. A.2 Natural selection acts on phenotypic variations in populations. AP BIOLOGY 2 A.1 All living systems require constant input of free energy. D.1 All biological systems from cells and organisms to populations, communities and ecosystems are affected by complex biotic and abiotic interactions involving exchange of matter and free energy. A.5 Communities are composed of populations of organisms that interact in complex ways. A.6 Interactions among living systems and with their environment result in the movement of matter and energy. B.3 Interactions between and within populations influence patterns of species distribution and abundance. C.4 The diversity of species within an ecosystem may influence the stability of the ecosystem. *Advanced Placement and AP are registered trademarks of the College Entrance Examination Board. The College Board was not involved in the production of this product. T E A C H E R P A G E S iii

4 TEACHING SUGGESTIONS This activity simulates a classic study by Robert T. Paine. Food Web Complexity and Species Diversity was published in The American Naturalist in 1966, and discussed the impact of predators on an ecosystem. The article can be found online at Documents/511Readings/Paine% pdf consisting of the candies shown in Figure A. After completing this activity, a discussion of this article with your students would provide a deeper understanding of the model s purpose. This activity is divided into two parts. Part I is designed to introduce the concept of natural selection. Emphasize to the students that a single organism cannot adapt to its environment, but that it will survive if it possesses a successful adaptation. In this case, mussels with strong, thick shells are more likely to survive because the predator prefers mussels with thin, weak shells. The students will be using orange and yellow colored candies to represent variation within a single species. You will need to prepare brown bags for each group consisting of 20 yellow and 20 orange candies. The students take on the role of a predaceous starfish on the mussel population. The data collected in Part I can be a reference point for specialized vocabulary used during presentations on microevolution and speciation. It is important for students to randomly select the first generation and follow guidelines established in the procedure for subsequent generations. Use the class data table as a template to collect data on all five generations from each lab group. Students will then total the numbers for each generation and record the averages in Table A. Part II is designed to introduce the importance of keystone species to an ecosystem. Prior to the activity, you will need to prepare brown bags for each group Figure A. Candy representation of species It is important that students select 25 organisms randomly and place them on the rocky shoreline in the order of red, orange, yellow, green, and violet. This illustrates the concept of zonation for species in an intertidal community. Remind students that the rocky shoreline is a finite space with limited resources, which means that some organisms may be pushed out of the ecosystem if other organisms are more successful at reproduction. Students should find that the community is relatively stable for the first four generations as the predaceous starfish keeps the system in check as it preys upon the most numerous species. However, at the beginning of Generation 5 the predaceous starfish is removed and students should begin to see the exponential growth of the orange mussel. When they graph their data, they should see a stable population of orange mussels for Generation 1 through Generation 4 with exponential growth when the predator is removed starting with Generation 5 and then a leveling-off when the carrying capacity is reached. The takeaway of this lesson is that many species, like the predaceous starfish, have larger than expected effects on their environment. Biologists call such species keystone species. T E A C H E R P A G E S iv

5 TEACHING SUGGESTIONS (CONTINUED) Table A. Class Results, First Five Generations Group Yellow Mussels Orange Mussels G1 G2 G3 G4 G5 G1 G2 G3 G4 G T E A C H E R P A G E S Total Average v

6 ANSWER KEY - SURVIVAL OF THE SWEETEST HYPOTHESIS PART I If the predator prefers to eat the yellow mussels then the population of yellow mussels will decrease while the population of orange mussels will increase. PART II Student responses will vary. Here is an example you will likely encounter: If the starfish is removed then the populations of the prey will increase. DATA AND OBSERVATIONS PART I Table 1. Generations of Yellow and Orange Mussels Generation Yellow Mussels Orange Mussels A N S W E R K E Y PART II Table 2. Intertidal Food Web Student illustrations will vary. Look for the direction the arrows point and make sure all organisms are included. vi

7 DATA AND OBSERVATIONS (CONTINUED) Red carnivorous snail Orange mussel Yellow barnacle Green chiton Violet herbivorous snail Generation 1 Initial Final Table 3. Population of Each Species by Generation Generation 2 Generation 3 Generation 4 Initial Final Initial Final Initial Final A N S W E R K E Y Remove Starfish Continue with Generation 5 vii

8 DATA AND OBSERVATIONS (CONTINUED) Red carnivorous snail Orange mussel Yellow barnacle Green chiton Violet herbivorous snail Generation 5 Initial Final Table 3. Population of Each Species by Generation (continued) Generation 6 Generation 7 Generation 8 Generation 9 Initial Final Initial Final Initial Final Initial Final A N S W E R K E Y Generation 10 Initial Final viii

9 ANALYSIS PART I Prepare a graph of the class averages of orange and yellow mussels for each generation. Be sure to include axes labels, units, and a title on your graph. PART II Prepare a graph of the orange mussels for each generation (final generation). Be sure to include axes labels, units, and a title on your graph. Figure A. Mussel population change over time Figure B. Orange mussel population This graph reflects the data found in Table 1. In class, you will want to use the Class Averages Data Table. A N S W E R K E Y ix

10 CONCLUSION QUESTIONS 1. Write a statement describing how the number of yellow and orange mussels changed over the period of five generations in Part I of the procedure. The orange population increased while the yellow population decreased. 2. What do you predict would happen to the number of yellow mussels if you had continued predation for a total of 10 generations? Explain your prediction. The yellow population would continue to decrease, but the presence of the yellow allele in the population would always give a slight chance for it to reappear. 3. Which type of mussel would Darwin consider most fit in this predation situation? Why? The orange mussel is the most fit due to its successful reproduction. 4. What adaptation do these mussels possess that allows them to survive? They possess thicker shells. 5. Explain why it is incorrect to say that an individual adapts to its environment. The frequency of alleles in a population changes over time, an individual cannot change its genetic makeup. 6. In Part II of the procedure, which organism possesses traits that enable it to exploit the rocky shoreline more efficiently than the other populations in the community? Explain. The orange mussels possess a high reproductive rate that enables the exploitation its habitat. 7. Compare the change in the diversity of the community in Generation 1 to Generation 10. What major factor accounts for this change? The diversity actually decreases since the starfish is not there to keep populations from getting too large and crowding out other populations of organisms. 8. Consider the following hypothesis of Robert Paine. Local species diversity is directly related to the efficiency with which predators prevent the monopolization of the major environmental requisites (necessities of life) by one species. Does your data support or refute this hypothesis? Explain your answer using evidence from generations 1 through 10. It supports this hypothesis. The community began with six different species and concluded with only two. 9. Identify and discuss the major factors responsible for section A on the graph. Although the orange mussel has a high reproductive rate, many individuals are consumed by the predaceous starfish, keeping the population stable but low. 10. Identify and discuss the major factors responsible for sections B and C on the graph. Once the starfish is removed, the orange mussels increase exponentially until the population A N S W E R K E Y x

Survival of the Sweetest Biology Survival of the Sweetest Biology A Tasty Tale of Natural Selection and Community Dynamics MATERIALS teacher-provided materials Charles Darwin published The Origin of

11 Survival of the Sweetest Biology Survival of the Sweetest Biology A Tasty Tale of Natural Selection and Community Dynamics MATERIALS teacher-provided materials Charles Darwin published The Origin of Species in In his book, Darwin presented two main concepts, descent with modification and natural selection. Descent with modification is the phrase Darwin used to describe how modern species arose from a series of ancestors through accumulated changes over time. Natural selection, however, is the process by which biological traits become more or less pronounced in a population as a function of reproductive advantage. Reproduction allows organisms to pass on beneficial traits to the next generation. Without these beneficial traits, organisms are more likely to die before they have a chance to reproduce. The overall composition of the biological traits of the population will change as the survivors with more beneficial genes produce more offspring. Natural selection is sometimes referred to as survival of the fittest. For example, in an arid environment narrow leaf plants survive at a greater rate than broad leaf plants. The narrow leaf plant conserves water much better than the broad leaf plant. It is important to note that individual organisms do not adapt to their environment. Rather, they possess traits that make them better suited for survival and ultimately afford them a reproductive advantage. The struggle for existence does not only shape the traits of a population but also shapes communities. Competition for finite resources and predation both determine the size and diversity of a community. The relationships of the species in the community are often more complex than they first appear with some species having a disproportionate effect on their environment. 1

12 PURPOSE In Part I, you will simulate the events of natural selection for a population of mussels living in the rocky, intertidal zone of the Pacific Ocean. Mussels are bivalves much like clams and oysters. This simulated population of mussels (Peloris dulcis) has individuals with thick, strong shells and others with thin, weak shells. The thick shell provides more protection from the predaceous starfish lurking in the shallows. The starfish more readily eats the mussels with the thin shells. Orange and yellow candies will represent the variation found in this species of mussel. In Part II, you will simulate the effects of a predaceous starfish on the diversity of a community made up of barnacles, mussels, chitons, and snails. It is important to point out that each candy color represents a different species, not variations within a species as modeled in Part I. You will also simulate the effects of removing the predaceous starfish on the diversity of the community. In addition, each species is competing for limited space. Competition can force some species out of the ecosystem. 2

13 PROCEDURE PART I 1. Obtain the population of candy mussels (Peloris dulcis) from your teacher. This bag should contain equal numbers of yellow and orange candies. As the predator, you prefer to eat the yellow mussels with thin shells rather than the thicker shelled orange ones. 2. Formulate a hypothesis regarding what will happen to the ratio of yellow to orange mussels knowing the predator s preference. Record your hypothesis in the space provided on the student answer page. 3. Establish the first generation by having one partner reach in the bag and, without looking, randomly select 10 mussels. 4. Place the 10 mussels on the graph paper serving as the rocky shoreline found at the end of this lesson. This represents the initial population of mussels. Count the number of yellow and orange mussels present. Record your numbers for Generation 1 in Table 1 on the student answer page. 5. Simulate predation by choosing three yellow mussels from the rocky shoreline and eating them. Remember that you are the predaceous starfish, and you prefer to eat the yellow mussels first. If you only have one or two yellow mussels, eat them first and then consume enough orange mussels to meet your quota. For example, if you have only one yellow mussel, eat it and then two orange ones. If you have two yellow mussels, eat both of them and one orange mussel. 6. To simulate reproduction in the population, close your eyes, reach into the bag, and choose three mussels to add to your rocky shoreline. This should bring your total number of mussels back to Record the number of yellow and orange mussels that are now present in the population in the space for Generation 2 in Table The other partner should now take a turn at being a predator. The predator should eat three yellow mussels from the rocky shoreline. If there are not three yellow mussels, follow the procedure described in Step Simulate reproduction in the population by repeating Step 6. Count the number of each type of mussel in the population, and record this data in space for Generation 3 in Table 1. 3

14 PROCEDURE (CONTINUED) 10. Repeat this process detailed in Step 5 through Step 9 until you have a total of five generations of data. 11. As instructed by your teacher, combine your individual data with the class data for each of the five generations. Calculate the class average for each mussel for each generation. Record class averages in Table 4 of the Analysis section. PART II We will model the effects of a predator on the diversity of a community. Many communities have species with larger than expected effects on their environment. Biologists refer to these as keystone species. The keystone species in this model is a large, predatory starfish. Other members of the community include barnacles, mussels, chitons, and two types of snails (one carnivorous, the other herbivorous). The starfish preys upon all five species. The carnivorous snail eats both mussels and barnacles. Each species competes for the limited space along the rocky shoreline. Figure 1. Marine community species 4

15 PROCEDURE (CONTINUED) 1. Illustrate a food web representing the feeding relationships described above in the space provided on the student answer page. 2. After considering the illustrated food web, formulate a hypothesis predicting the abundance of the five prey species if the predatory starfish is removed from the environment. Record your hypothesis in the space provided. 3. Obtain the candy marine invertebrates from your teacher. This bag will contain the items described in Figure 1. You will serve as the predatory starfish. 4. Select 25 organisms (candy pieces) at random and place them on the graph paper serving as the rocky shoreline found at the end of this lesson. Each organism must be placed on a gray, numbered square within the outline of the rocky shoreline. Always place the red snails first (start with number 1). Next, place the orange mussels, then the yellow barnacles, then the green chitons and, finally, the violet snails (all in numerical order). Although the mussel, barnacle, chiton, and herbivorous snail do not eat one another, they do compete for available space. If one of the more competitive species quickly reproduces, it will push the other populations out of the ecosystem. 5. Count the number of each type of organism and record the data in the space marked Initial Population for Generation 1 in Table Using the Feeding Chart located elsewhere in this lesson, roll the die once to determine the next meal of the starfish (round up if there is half of a prey item). The choices of the starfish are found on the inner ring. Remove the organisms (candy pieces) consumed by the starfish. 7. Roll the die a second time to determine the action of the carnivorous snails. The choices of the carnivorous snail are located on the outer ring of the Feeding Chart. Remove a carnivorous snail, mussel, or barnacle as determined by your roll. 8. Once you have rolled the die twice and removed the organisms consumed, record the final population of each species in the space marked Final Population for Generation 1 in Table 3. 5

16 PROCEDURE (CONTINUED) 9. Before the next round, the organisms will reproduce. Use the following rules to determine the correct number of each species after reproduction: a. The orange mussels will double their number b. The yellow barnacles, green chitons, and violet herbivorous snails will add one organism for every two individuals present (do not round up) c. The red carnivorous snails will add one organism for every four individuals present (again, do not round up) d. If one of the populations does not meet the requirements for reproduction, add one individual to that population. Example: After Generation 2, there are three red carnivorous snails in the final population. According to (c), you must have at least four red carnivorous snails to reproduce; however, (d) states that you always add at least one individual to the population. Therefore, your initial population of red carnivorous snails for Generation 3 will be four. 10. After adding the appropriate number of individuals, record the new population in the space marked Initial Population for Generation 2 in Table Following the sequence established in Step 4, place the red snails first, then the orange mussels, then the yellow barnacles, then the green chitons and, lastly, the violet snails (all in numerical order). If there is not enough room to place all of the individuals, adjust the initial population of the species that is crowded out. 12. Repeat Step 6 through Step 9 to simulate events through Generation 4. Record your data in Table The starfish is now removed from the ecosystem. After Generation 4, you will only need to roll the die once to determine the actions of the carnivorous snails. Continue to follow Step 7 through Step 9 (with only one die and using the outer ring of the Feeding Chart) to simulate events through Generation 10. Record your data in Table 3. 6

17 HYPOTHESIS PART I PART II DATA AND OBSERVATIONS PART I Table 1. Generations of Yellow and Orange Mussels Generation Yellow Mussels Orange Mussels PART II Table 2. Intertidal Food Web 7

18 DATA AND OBSERVATIONS (CONTINUED) Red carnivorous snail Orange mussel Yellow barnacle Green chiton Violet herbivorous snail Generation 1 Initial Final Table 3. Population of Each Species by Generation Generation 2 Generation 3 Generation 4 Initial Final Initial Final Initial Final Remove Starfish Continue with Generation 5 8

19 DATA AND OBSERVATIONS (CONTINUED) Red carnivorous snail Orange mussel Yellow barnacle Green chiton Violet herbivorous snail Generation 5 Initial Final Table 3. Population of Each Species by Generation (continued) Generation 6 Generation 7 Generation 8 Generation 9 Initial Final Initial Final Initial Final Initial Final Generation 10 Initial Final 9

20 ANALYSIS PART I Table 4. Generations of Yellow and Orange Mussels (Class Averages) Generation Average Yellow Mussels Average Orange Mussels

21 ANALYSIS (CONTINUED) Prepare a graph of the class averages of orange and yellow mussels for each generation. Be sure to include axes labels, units, and a title on your graph. PART II Prepare a graph of the orange mussels for each generation (final generation). Be sure to include axes labels, units, and a title on your graph. 11

22 CONCLUSION QUESTIONS 1. Write a statement describing how the number of yellow and orange mussels changed over the period of five generations in Part I of the Procedure. 2. What do you predict would happen to the number of yellow mussels if you continued predation for a total of 10 generations? Explain your prediction. 3. Which type of mussel would Darwin consider most fit in this predation situation? Why? 4. What adaptation do these mussels possess that allows them to survive? 5. Explain why it is incorrect to say that an individual adapts to its environment. 12

23 CONCLUSION QUESTIONS (CONTINUED) 6. In Part II of the Procedure, which organism possesses traits that enable it to exploit the rocky shoreline more efficiently than the other populations in the community? Explain. 7. Compare the change in the diversity of the community in Generation 1 to Generation 10. What major factor accounts for this change? 8. Consider the following hypothesis of Robert Paine. Local species diversity is directly related to the efficiency with which predators prevent the monopolization of the major environmental requisites (necessities of life) by one species. Does your data support or refute this hypothesis? Explain your answer using evidence from Generation 1 through Generation

24 CONCLUSION QUESTIONS (CONTINUED) The Population Growth of Orange Mussels graph (Figure 2) was generated by a student performing this simulation last year. Considering the data you collected, answer the following questions. Figure 2. Population growth of orange mussels 9. Identify and discuss the major factors responsible for Section A on the graph. 10. Identify and discuss the major factors responsible for Section B and Section C on the graph. 14

25 FEEDING CHART L E S S O N C O N S U M A B L E 15

26 SHORELINE MODEL, PART I L E S S O N C O N S U M A B L E 16

27 SHORELINE MODEL, PART II L E S S O N C O N S U M A B L E 17

Charles Darwin published The Origin of Species in In his book,

Survival of the Sweetest Biology Survival of the Sweetest Biology A Tasty Tale of Natural Selection and Community Dynamics MATERIALS teacher-provided materials Charles Darwin published The Origin of Species