Short-Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos. Carlo Giunti
|
|
- Alannah Stephens
- 6 years ago
- Views:
Transcription
1 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 /53 Short-Baseline Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy Seminar at Roma Tre November 07
2 Fermion Mass Spectrum C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 /53 m [ev] d u e ν e c s µ ν µ ν ν ν 3 t b τ ν τ 3 4
3 Neutrino Mixing C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 3/53 Left-handed Flavor Neutrinos produced in Weak Interactions ν e, ν µ, ν τ, H CC = g W ρ (ν el γ ρ e L + ν µl γ ρ µ L + ν τl γ ρ τ L ) + H.c. Fields ν αl = k U αk ν kl = ν α, = k U αk ν k, States ν, ν, ν 3, Left-handed Massive Neutrinos propagate from Source to Detector U e U e U e3 3 3 Unitary Mixing Matrix: U = U µ U µ U µ3 U τ U τ U τ3
4 Neutrino Oscillations C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 4/53 ν(t = 0) = ν α = U α ν + U α ν + U α3 ν 3 ν α source ν ν ν3 L ν β detector ν(t > 0) = U α e ie t ν + U α e ie t ν + U α3 e ie 3t ν 3 ν α E k = p + m k P να ν β (L) = ν β ν(l) = k,j t = L U βk U αk U βj U αj exp ( i m kj L E ) the oscillation probabilities depend on U and m kj m k m j
5 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 5/53 ν-mixing: ( m P να ν β = sin ϑ sin ) L 4E = L osc = 4πE m 0.8 Pνα ν β sin ϑ 0. 0 L osc L Tiny neutrino masses lead to observable macroscopic oscillation distances! ( m km ) short-baseline experiments m ev MeV GeV L E 3 ( m km ) long-baseline experiments m 3 ev MeV GeV 4 km atmospheric neutrino experiments m 4 ev GeV m solar neutrino experiments m ev MeV Neutrino oscillations are the optimal tool to reveal tiny neutrino masses!
6 Three-Neutrino Mixing Paradigm C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 6/53 U = = Standard Parameterization of Mixing Matrix (as CKM) 0 0 c 3 0 s 3 e iδ 3 c s c 3 s s c 0 0 e iλ 0 0 s 3 c 3 s 3 e iδ 3 0 c e iλ 3 c c 3 s c 3 s 3 e iδ s c 3 c s 3 s 3 e iδ 3 c c 3 s s 3 s 3 e iδ 3 s 3 c 3 0 e iλ 0 s s 3 c c 3 s 3 e iδ 3 c s 3 s c 3 s 3 e iδ 3 c 3 c e iλ 3 c ab cos ϑ ab s ab sin ϑ ab 0 ϑ ab π OSCILLATION PARAMETERS 0 δ 3, λ, λ 3 < π 3 Mixing Angles: ϑ, ϑ 3, ϑ 3 CPV Dirac Phase: δ 3 independent m kj m k m j : m, m 3 CPV Majorana Phases: λ, λ 3 L = processes
7 Three-Neutrino Mixing Ingredients C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 7/53 U = 0 0 c 3 0 s 3 e iδ 3 c s c 3 s s c 0 0 e iλ 0 0 s 3 c 3 s 3 e iδ 3 0 c e iλ 3 Solar ν e ν µ, ν τ VLBL Reactor ν e disappearance SNO, Borexino Super-Kamiokande GALLEX/GNO, SAGE Homestake, Kamiokande (KamLAND) ms = m ev sin ϑ S = sin ϑ 0.30
8 Three-Neutrino Mixing Ingredients C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 8/53 U = 0 0 c 3 0 s 3 e iδ 3 c s c 3 s s c 0 0 e iλ 0 0 s 3 c 3 s 3 e iδ 3 0 c e iλ 3 Atmospheric ν µ ν τ LBL Accelerator ν µ disappearance Super-Kamiokande Kamiokande, IMB MACRO, Soudan- ( KK, MINOS TK, NOνA ) ma m ev sin ϑ A = sin ϑ LBL Accelerator ν µ ν τ (OPERA)
9 Three-Neutrino Mixing Ingredients C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 9/53 U = 0 0 c 3 0 s 3 e iδ 3 c s c 3 s s c 0 0 e iλ 0 0 s 3 c 3 s 3 e iδ 3 0 c e iλ 3 LBL Accelerator ν µ ν e LBL Reactor ν e disappearance (TK, MINOS, NOνA) ( Daya Bay, RENO Double Chooz ma m ev ) sin ϑ 3 0.0
10 Mass Ordering C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 /53 m ν e ν µ ν τ m ν 3 ν m SOL ν m ATM m ATM ν m SOL ν Normal Ordering m 3 > m 3 > 0 ν 3 Inverted Ordering m 3 < m 3 < 0 absolute scale is not determined by neutrino oscillation data
11 Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing: Sterile Neutrinos C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 /53 m. ν 5 ν 4. m SBL ν s ν s ev σ had [nb] 30 0 ALEPH DELPHI L3 OPAL average measurements, error bars increased by factor ν 3ν 4ν ν 3 ν ν m ATM m SOL ν e ν µ ν τ.5 3 ev ev E cm [GeV] N LEP ν active =.9840 ± Terminology: means: a ev-scale sterile neutrino a ev-scale massive neutrino which is mainly sterile
12 Sterile Neutrinos from Physics Beyond the SM Neutrinos are special in the Standard Model: the only neutral fermions Active left-handed neutrinos can mix with non-sm singlet fermions often called right-handed neutrinos Light left-handed anti-ν R are light sterile neutrinos ν c R ν sl (left-handed) Sterile means no standard model interactions [Pontecorvo, Sov. Phys. JETP 6 (968) 984] Active neutrinos (ν e, ν µ, ν τ ) can oscillate into light sterile neutrinos (ν s ) Observables: Disappearance of active neutrinos (neutral current deficit) Indirect evidence through combined fit of data (current indication) Short-baseline anomalies + 3ν-mixing: m m 3 m 4... ν ν ν 3 ν 4... ν e ν µ ν τ ν s... C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 /53
13 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 3/53 Here I consider sterile neutrinos with mass scale ev in light of short-baseline Reactor Anomaly, Gallium Anomaly, LSND. Other possibilities (not incompatible): Very light sterile neutrinos with mass scale ev: important for solar neutrino phenomenology [de Holanda, Smirnov, PRD 69 (004) 300; PRD 83 (0) 30] [Das, Pulido, Picariello, PRD 79 (009) 0730] Recent Daya Bay constraints for 3 m ev [PRL 3 (04) 480] Heavy sterile neutrinos with mass scale ev: could be Warm Dark Matter [Asaka, Blanchet, Shaposhnikov, PLB 63 (005) 5; Asaka, Shaposhnikov, PLB 60 (005) 7; Asaka, Shaposhnikov, Kusenko, PLB 638 (006) 40; Asaka, Laine, Shaposhnikov, JHEP 0606 (006) 053, JHEP 070 (007) 09] [Reviews: Kusenko, Phys. Rept. 48 (009) ; Boyarsky, Ruchayskiy, Shaposhnikov, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 59 (009) 9; Boyarsky, Iakubovskyi, Ruchayskiy, Phys. Dark Univ. (0) 36; Drewes, IJMPE, (03) 33009]
14 Four-Neutrino Schemes: +, 3+ and +3 m ν 4 m ν m m m m ν m ATM m SOL ν 4 ν 4 ν 3 m SOL ν 3 ν m ATM ν m ATM ν m SOL ν ν 3 m SBL m SBL m SBL m SBL m SBL m SBL ν 3 ν m SOL ν ν 4 m ATM ν m ATM ν m SOL m ATM m SOL ν 4 ν 4 ν ν 3 ν ν C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 4/53
15 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 5/53 + Four-Neutrino Schemes m ν 4 m ν m ATM ν 3 m SOL ν m SBL m SBL m SOL ν ν m ATM ν 4 ν 3 After LSND (995) + was preferred to 3+, because of the 3+ appearance-disappearance tension [Okada, Yasuda, IJMPA (997) 3669; Bilenky, CG, Grimus, EPJC (998) 47] This is not a perturbation of 3-ν Mixing = Large active sterile oscillations for solar or atmospheric neutrinos!
16 + Schemes are Strongly Disfavored C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 6/53 50 χ solar + KamLAND solar solar (pre SNO salt) global solar + KamLAND χ PG χ PC atmospheric + 99% CL ( dof) atm + KK + SBL 99% CL Solar: Matter Effects + SNO NC η s η s Atmospheric: Matter Effects d µ η s = U s + U s = U s3 + U s4 99% CL: { ηs < 0.5 (Solar + KamLAND) η s > 0.75 (Atmospheric + KK) [Maltoni, Schwetz, Tortola, Valle, New J. Phys. 6 (004) ]
17 3+ and +3 Four-Neutrino Schemes m m m ν 4 ν 4 ν 3 msol matm ν matm msol ν m ν ν ν 3 m SBL m SBL m SBL m SBL ν 3 ν m SOL m ATM ν m ATM ν m SOL ν 4 ν 4 ν ν Perturbation of 3-ν Mixing: U e4, U µ4, U τ4 U s4 +3 schemes are disfavored by cosmology (ΛCDM): 3 m k 0. ev [Planck, Astron. Astrophys. 594 (06) A3 (arxiv: )] k= C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 7/53
18 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 8/53 Effective 3+ SBL Oscillation Probabilities Appearance (α β) ( ) m P SBL ( ) sin ϑ ν ( ) αβ sin 4 L α ν β 4E Disappearance ( ) m P SBL ( ) sin ϑ ν ( ) αα sin 4 L α ν α 4E sin ϑ αβ = 4 U α4 U β4 sin ϑ αα = 4 U α4 ( U α4 ) U e U e U e3 U e4 U µ U µ U µ3 U µ4 U = U τ U τ U τ3 U τ4 U s U s U s3 U s4 SBL 6 mixing angles 3 Dirac CP phases 3 Majorana CP phases CP violation is not observable in SBL experiments! Observable in LBL accelerator exp. sensitive to matm [de Gouvea et al, PRD 9 (05) , PRD 9 (05) 0730, arxiv: ; Palazzo et al, PRD 9 (05) 07307, PLB 757 (06) 4; Kayser et al, JHEP 5 (05) 039, JHEP 6 (06) ] and solar exp. sensitive to msol [Long, Li, CG, PRD 87, 3004 (03) 3004]
19 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 9/53 Common Parameterization of 4 4 Mixing Matrix U = [ W 34 R 4 W 4 R 3 W 3 R ] ( ) diag, e iλ, e iλ 3, e iλ 4 c c 3c 4 s c 3c 4 c 4s 3e iδ 3 s 4e iδ c 4s 4 0 e iλ 0 0 = c 4c 4s 34e iδ e iλ 3 0 c 4c 4c e iλ 4 U e4 = sin ϑ 4 sin ϑ ee = 4 U e4 ( U e4 ) = sin ϑ 4 U µ4 = cos ϑ 4 sin ϑ 4 sin ϑ 4 sin ϑ µµ = 4 U µ4 ( U µ4 ) sin ϑ 4
20 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 0/53 LSND [PRL 75 (995) 650; PRC 54 (996) 685; PRL 77 (996) 308; PRD 64 (00) 007] ν µ ν e 0 MeV E 5.8 MeV Well-known and pure source of ν µ p + target π + at rest µ + + ν µ 800 MeV µ + at rest e + + ν e + ν µ ν e + p n + e + Well-known detection process of ν e 3.8σ excess L 30 m m SBL 0. ev m ATM But signal not seen by KARMEN at L 8 m with the same method [PRD 65 (00) 00]
21 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 /53 MiniBooNE L 54 m ν µ ν e [PRL (009) 80] 00 MeV E 3 GeV ν µ ν e [PRL (03) 680] LSND signal LSND signal Purpose: check LSND signal. Different L and E. Similar L/E (oscillations). No money, no Near Detector. LSND signal: E > 475 MeV. Agreement with LSND signal? Low-energy anomaly MicroBooNE Pragmatic Approach: E > 475 MeV.
22 Gallium Anomaly C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 /53 Gallium Radioactive Source Experiments: GALLEX and SAGE ν e Sources: e + 5 Cr 5 V + ν e e + 37 Ar 37 Cl + ν e E 0.75 MeV E 0.8 MeV Test of Solar ν e Detection: ν e + 7 Ga 7 Ge + e R =N exp N cal GALLEX SAGE Cr Cr R = 0.84 ± 0.05 L GALLEX =.9 m GALLEX SAGE Cr Ar L SAGE = 0.6 m m SBL ev m ATM.9σ deficit [SAGE, PRC 73 (006) ; PRC 80 (009) 05807; Laveder et al, Nucl.Phys.Proc.Suppl. 68 (007) 344, MPLA (007) 499, PRD 78 (008) , PRC 83 (0) ] 3 He + 7 Ga 7 Ge + 3 H cross section measurement [Frekers et al., PLB 706 (0) 34]
23 Reactor Electron Antineutrino Anomaly C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 3/53 [Mention et al, PRD 83 (0) ] New reactor ν e fluxes [Mueller et al, PRC 83 (0) 05465; Huber, PRC 84 (0) 0467] R = N exp N cal Bugey 3 Bugey 4 Chooz Daya Bay Double Chooz Gosgen ILL Krasnoyarsk Nucifer 3 L [m].8σ deficit Palo Verde RENO Rovno88 R = ± 0.04 Rovno9 SRP
24 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 4/53 P ν e νe Bugey 4 Rovno9 E 4MeV sin ϑ ee = 0. m 4 = 0. ev m 4 = 0.5 ev m 4 =.0 ev Rovno88 Bugey 3 Gosgen ILL 3 L [m] Krasnoyarsk SRP Nucifer R DC DB DC R DB m SBL 0.5 ev m ATM SBL oscillations are averaged at the Daya Bay, RENO, and Double Chooz near detectors = no spectral distortion
25 E ( (Data - MC) / MC χ i ) Reactor Antineutrino 5 MeV Bump 5000 E (Data - MC) / MC Data / Predicted 0.5 MeV.4..0 Data No oscillation Reactor flux uncertainty Total systematic uncertainty Best fit: sin θ Prompt Energy (MeV) Prompt Energy Visible Energy (MeV) 4 [RENO, arxiv: ] [Double Chooz, arxiv: ] [Daya Bay, arxiv: ] Cannot be explained by neutrino oscillations (SBL oscillations are averaged in Double Chooz, Daya Bay, RENO). It is likely due to theoretical miscalculation of the spectrum. 3% effect on total flux, but if it is an excess it increases the anomaly! No post-bump complete calculation of the neutrino fluxes. Saclay-Huber flux calculation uncertainty is about.5%. = Entries / Ratio to Prediction (Huber + Mueller) contribution χ Integrated Prompt Energy (MeV) Increasing the flux uncertainty is a game that one can play, but there are only guesses, e.g. about 5%. [Hayes and Vogel, 06] Increasing the flux uncertainty decreases the statistical significance of the anomaly, but more anomaly is allowed in combined fits with other data! At the moment it is better to consider the calculated flux and uncertainties in order to predict the signal that must be tested in new experiments. C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 5/ Local p-value ( MeV windows)
26 ε C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 6/53 NEOS [PRL 8 (07) 80 (arxiv:6.0534)] Events /day/0 kev Data/Prediction Data/Prediction (a) (b) Prompt Energy [MeV] Data signal (ON-OFF) Data background (OFF) MC 3ν (H-M-V) MC 3ν (Daya Bay) NEOS/H-M-V Systematic total Neutrino Energy [MeV] (c) NEOS/Daya Prompt BayEnergy [MeV] Systematic total.0 (.73 ev, 0.050) (.3 ev, 0.4) Prompt Energy [MeV] 3 Hanbit Nuclear Power Complex in Yeong-gwang, Korea. Thermal power of.8 GW. Detector: a ton of Gd-loaded liquid scintillator in a gallery approximately 4 m from the reactor core. The measured antineutrino event rate is 976 per day with a signal to background ratio of about.
27 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 7/53 NEOS Spectrum 90% CL 95% CL 99% CL [ev ] m 4 3 sin ϑ ee Best Fits: m4 =.7 ev sin θ 4 = 0.05 m4 =.3 ev sin θ 4 = 0.04 χ no osc. χ min = 6.5 χ distribution:.σ anomaly NEOS Monte Carlo:.σ anomaly
28 Global ν e and ν e Disappearance [Gariazzo, CG, Laveder, Li, JHEP 706 (07) 35 (arxiv: )] ν edis σ σ 3σ KARMEN+LSND ν e C [Conrad, Shaevitz, PRD 85 (0) 0307] [CG, Laveder, PLB 706 (0) 0] [ev ] σ Reactors Gallium ν ec Sun TK Solar ν e + KamLAND ν e [Li et al, PRD 80 (009) 3007, PRD 86 (0) 304] [Palazzo, PRD 83 (0) 303, PRD 85 (0) 07730] m 4 TK Near Detector ν e disappearance [TK, PRD 9 (05) 05] χ NO /NDF NO = 4./ 3.3σ anom. sin ϑ ee Best Fit: m 4 =.7 ev L osc 4 = 4πE sin ϑ ee = U e4 = 0.07 m4 χ min /NDF = 63.0/74 GoF = 7% In agreement with Dentler, Hernandez-Cabezudo, Kopp, Maltoni, Schwetz, arxiv: C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 8/53
29 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 9/53 Tritium Beta-Decay: 3 H 3 He + e + ν e Q = M3 H M3 He m e = 8.58 kev dγ dt = (cosϑ C G F ) π 3 M F (E) p E K (T ) K (T ) Q T = k U ek (Q T ) m k θ(q T m k) m 4 m,,3 ( U e4 ) (Q T ) m β θ(q T m β) + U e4 (Q T ) m 4 θ(q T m 4) K(T) Q 3 mβ = U ek mk k= Q m 4 T Q m β
30 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 30/53 Mainz and Troitsk Limit on m 4 m 4 m 4 m,,3 = m 4 m 4 m m 4 [Kraus, Singer, Valerius, Weinheimer, EPJC 73 (03) 33] [Belesev et al, JPG 4 (04) 0500]
31 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 3/53 Global ν e and ν e Disappearance + β Decay [Gariazzo, CG, Laveder, Li, JHEP 706 (07) 35 (arxiv: )] ν edis+β 3σ σ σ 3σ ν edis β Best Fit: m 4 =.7 ev sin ϑ ee = U e4 = 0.07 [ev ] m 4 cm Losc 4 7 m at 3σ E [MeV] sin ϑ ee 0.3 at 3σ sin ϑ ee
32 The Race for ν e and ν e Disappearance C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 3/53 3 CeSOX shape (95% CL) CeSOX rate (95% CL) CeSOX rate+shape (95% CL) KATRIN (90% CL) ν edis+β σ σ 3σ 3 DANSS (yr, 95% CL) Neutrino 4 (yr, 95% CL) PROSPECT phase (3yr, 3σ) PROSPECT phase (3yr, 3σ) SoLiD phase (yr, 95% CL) SoLiD phase (3yr, 3σ) STEREO (yr, 95% CL) ν edis+β σ σ 3σ [ev ] m 4 [ev ] m sin ϑ ee sin ϑ ee CeSOX (Gran Sasso, Italy) 44 Ce ν e BOREXINO: L 5-m [Vivier@TAUP05] KATRIN (Karlsruhe, Germany) 3 H ν e [Drexlin@NOW06] DANSS (Kalinin, Russia) L -m [arxiv: ] Neutrino-4 (RIAR, Russia) L 6-m [JETP (05) 578] PROSPECT (ORNL, USA) L 7-m [arxiv:5.00] SoLid (SCK-CEN, Belgium) L 5-8m [arxiv: ] STEREO (ILL, France) L 8-m [arxiv: ]
33 ν µ ν e and ν µ ν e Appearance 99% CL LSND MiniBooNE KARMEN NOMAD BNL E776 ICARUS OPERA [ev ] m 4 ν µ ν e 90% CL 95% CL 99% CL 3 sin ϑ eµ C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 33/53
34 ν µ and ν µ Disappearance [ev ] m 4 99% CL CDHSW: νµ (984) CCFR: νµ (984) ATM: νµ + νµ SciBooNE MiniBooNE: νµ (0) SciBooNE MiniBooNE: νµ (0) IceCube: νµ + νµ (06) MINOS: νµ CC+NC (06) MINOS&MINOS+ (07) 3 sin ϑ µµ C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 34/53
35 [ev ] m 4 3+ Appearance-Disappearance Tension ν e DIS sin ϑ ee 4 U e4 3σ ν e Dis ν µ Dis Dis App ν µ ν e APP ν µ DIS sin ϑ µµ 4 U µ4 sin ϑ eµ = 4 U e4 U µ4 4 sin ϑ ee sin ϑ µµ [Okada, Yasuda, IJMPA (997) 3669; Bilenky, CG, Grimus, EPJC (998) 47] 4 3 sin ϑ eµ PrGlo6A σ σ 3σ ν µ ν e is quadratically suppressed! PrGlo6A = 06 data except MINOS and [Gariazzo, CG, Laveder, Li, JHEP 706 (07) 35] IceCube χ NO /NDF NO = 48.3/3 6.4σ anom. Best Fit: m 4 =.6 ev U e4 = 0.06 U m4 = 0.03 χ min /NDF = 6.0/44 GoF = 0% χ PG /NDF PG = 3.8/ GoF PG = 5% Similar tension in 3+, 3+3,..., 3+N s [CG, Zavanin, MPLA 3 (05) ] C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 35/53
36 Effects of MINOS and IceCube 3σ PrGlo6A PrGlo6A + MINOS PrGlo6A + IceCube PrGlo6A + MINOS + IceCube = PrGlo6B m 4 [ev ] 3σ MINOS IceCube sin ϑ µµ IceCube effect in agreement with Collin, Arguelles, Conrad, Shaevitz, PRL 7 (06) 80 Best Fit: m 4 =.6 ev U e4 = U µ4 = 0.0 χ min /NDF = 530.3/59 GoF = 36% χ PG /NDF PG = 4.7/ GoF PG = 9.7% More tension! C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 36/53
37 Effects of NEOS C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 37/53 3σ NEOS m 4 [ev ] 3σ PrGlo6B PrGlo7A sin ϑ ee Best Fit: m 4 =.7 ev U e4 = 0.00 U µ4 = 0.05 χ min /NDF = 595./579 GoF = 3% χ PG /NDF PG = 7./ GoF PG =.7% More tension!
38 New Bound from MINOS & MINOS+ [arxiv: ] ν µ mode POT MINOS POT MINOS+ 4 (ev ) m MINOS & MINOS+ data 90% C.L. MINOS 90% C.L. IceCube 90% C.L. Super-K 90% C.L. CDHS 90% C.L. CCFR 90% C.L. SciBooNE + MiniBooNE 90% C.L. Gariazzo et al. (06) 90% C.L ν µ mode 3 POT MINOS POT MINOS+ sin (θ 4 ) 4 (ev ) m 3 MINOS & MINOS+ data 90% C.L % C.L. Sensitivity ( σ and σ) 3 sin (θ 4 ) C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 38/53
39 Effects of MINOS & MINOS+ C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 39/53 3σ MINOS & MINOS+ m 4 [ev ] 3σ PrGlo7A PrGlo7B sin ϑ µµ Best Fit: m4 =.7 ev U e4 = 0.0 U µ4 = 0.0 χ min /NDF = 608.9/65 GoF = 56% χ PG /NDF PG =.9/ GoF PG = 0.43% More tension! The MINOS & MINOS+ bound disfavors the LSND ν µ ν e signal.
40 New Dedicated Experiments ( ) ν e ( ) ν e PrGlo7B PrGlo7B σ σ 3σ σ σ 3σ m 4 [ev ] m 4 [ev ] DANSS (yr, 95% CL) Neutrino 4 (yr, 95% CL) PROSPECT phase (3yr, 3σ) PROSPECT phase (3yr, 3σ) SoLiD phase (yr, 95% CL) SoLiD phase (3yr, 3σ) STEREO (yr, 95% CL) 3 CeSOX shape (95% CL) CeSOX rate (95% CL) CeSOX rate+shape (95% CL) KATRIN (90% CL) 3 sin ϑ ee sin ϑ ee C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 40/53
41 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 4/53 ( ) ν µ ( ) ν e SBN (3yr, 3σ) nuprism (3σ) JSNS (3σ) PrGlo7B σ σ 3σ ( ) ν µ ( ) ν µ [ev ] [ev ] m 4 m 4 PrGlo7B σ σ 3σ 4 3 SBN (3yr, 3σ) KPipe (3yr, 3σ) 3 sin ϑ eµ sin ϑ µµ
42 Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 4/ As 0 + β 76 3Ge β β 0 + Effective Majorana Neutrino Mass: m ββ = k 76 34Se U ek m k
43 Two-Neutrino Double-β Decay: L = 0 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 43/53 N (A, Z) N (A, Z + ) + e + e + ν e + ν e (T ν / ) = G ν M ν Ï Ù second order weak interaction process in the Standard Model Ï Ù Neutrinoless Double-β Decay: L = N (A, Z) N (A, Z + ) + e + e (T 0ν / ) = G 0ν M 0ν m ββ effective Majorana mass m ββ = Uek m k k Í Ñ Í Ï Ï Ù Ù
44 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 44/53 f(t) Ge νββ T [MeV] 0νββ Q =.039MeV
45 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 45/53 Effective Majorana Neutrino Mass m ββ = k U ek m k complex U ek possible cancellations m ββ = U e m + U e e iα m + U e3 e iα 3 m 3 α = λ α 3 = (λ 3 δ 3 ) Im[m ββ ] m ββ U e3m 3 Im[m ββ ] α 3 m ββ = 0 U em α 3 U e3m 3 U em U em α Re[m ββ ] α U em Re[mββ ]
46 Predictions of 3ν-Mixing Paradigm mββ = Ue m + Ue e iα m + Ue3 e iα3 m3 3ν Normal Ordering 3ν Inverted Ordering σ σ 3σ σ σ 3σ [ev] [ev] Uek mk Uek mk Ue m Ue m 3 Ue m Ue3 m3 3 Ue3 m3 Ue m Lightest mass: m 4 [ev] Lightest mass: m3 [ev] 90% C.L. UPPER LIMIT 90% C.L. UPPER LIMIT 3ν Normal Ordering (+,+) (+, ) (,+) (, ) σ σ 3σ CPV Lightest mass: m [ev] mββ [ev] [ev] mββ 3 3ν Inverted Ordering (+,+) (+, ) (,+) (, ) σ σ 3σ CPV Lightest mass: m3 [ev] C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 46/53
47 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 47/53 3+ Mixing m ββ = U e m + U e e iα m + U e3 e iα 3 m 3 + U e4 e iα 4 m 4 χ PrGlo7B 99.73% 99% 95.45% 90% 68.7% (4) m ββ [ev] m (k) ββ = U ek m k m m 4 m (4) ββ U e4 m 4 warning: possible cancellation with m (3ν) ββ [Barry, Rodejohann, Zhang, JHEP 07 (0) 09] [Li, Liu, PLB 706 (0) 406] [Rodejohann, JPG 39 (0) 4008] [Girardi, Meroni, Petcov, JHEP 3 (03) 46] [CG, Zavanin, JHEP 07 (05) 7]
48 Normal 3ν Ordering ν4 Inverted 3ν Ordering σ σ 3σ σ σ 3σ Ue m Ue4 m4 [ev] [ev] Ue4 m4 Uek mk Uek mk ν4 σ σ 3σ σ σ 3σ Ue m Ue m Ue3 m3 3 3 Ue3 m3 Ue m Lightest mass: m 4 [ev] 3ν (3σ) 3+ (3σ) [ev] KamLAND Zen, PRL 7 (06) % C.L. UPPER LIMIT [ev] mββ [ev] m3 Inverted 3ν Ordering KamLAND Zen, PRL 7 (06) % C.L. UPPER LIMIT mββ Lightest mass: Normal 3ν Ordering 3ν (3σ) 3+ (3σ) Lightest mass: m [ev] 4 3 Lightest mass: m3 [ev] C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 48/53
49 Daya Bay Reactor Fuel Evolution [Daya Bay, PRL 8 (07) 580 (arxiv:704.08)] Fission fraction (%) Reactor ν e flux produced by the β decays of the fission products of 35 U, 38 U, 39 Pu, 4 Pu. Effective fission fractions: F 35, F 38, F 39, F U 39 Pu 38 U 4 Pu Others Burn-up (MWD/TU) Cross section per fission: σ f = F k σ f,k k=35,38,39,4 σ f,k = de ν φ k (E ν ) σ(e ν ) σ f / σ f SH OSC C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 49/53 F 39
50 σ39 [ 43 cm / fission] Daya Bay Huber model w/ 68% C.L. σ38 = (. ±. 0) 43 σ4 = (6. 04 ± 0. 60) 43 C.L 68% 95% 99.7% σ35 [ 43 cm / fission] 9 χ Best fit: mainly suppression of σ f,35 Equal fluxes suppression: χ /NDF = 7.9/ disfavored at.8σ Equal fluxes suppression corresponds to SBL oscillations, but theoretical flux uncertainties must be taken into account χ σ f,39 / σf,39 SH σ f,35 / σ f,35 SH σ σ 3σ χ With theoretical flux uncertainties: Daya Bay χ min NDF GoF 35 U % OSC % MC: OSC disfavored at.6σ [CG, X.P. Ji, M. Laveder, Y.F. Li, B.R. Littlejohn, arxiv: ] C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 50/53
51 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 5/53 Fuel Fractions of All Reactor Experiments F i SRP 4 SRP 8 Krasnoyarsk99 34 Krasnoyarsk94 57 Krasnoyarsk87 9 Krasnoyarsk87 33 ILL Nucifer Daya Bay 0.5 Gosgen 38 Rovno88 I Rovno88 S Rovno88 S Rovno9 Daya Bay 0.74 Rovno88 I Palo Verde Daya Bay 0.87 Gosgen 46 Daya Bay 0.99 RENO Rovno88 S Daya Bay 0.3 Gosgen 65 Daya Bay 0.3 Bugey 3 95 Bugey 3 40 Bugey 3 5 Bugey 4 Daya Bay 0.33 Daya Bay Double Chooz F 35 F 38 F 39 F 4 Chooz
52 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 5/53 All Reactors χ min NDF GoF 35 U % OSC % σ f / σ f th OSC MC: 35 U disfavored at.7σ L [m] 3 Bugey 4 Bugey 3 5 Rovno9 Rovno88 I Rovno88 I Rovno88 S Rovno88 S SRP 8 SRP 4 Rovno88 S Krasnoyarsk87 33 Krasnoyarsk99 34 Gosgen 38 Bugey 3 40 Gosgen 46 Krasnoyarsk94 57 Gosgen 65 Krasnoyarsk87 9 Bugey 3 95 RENO Double Chooz Daya Bay Palo Verde Chooz Nucifer ILL
53 C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Oscillation Anomalies and Light Sterile Neutrinos Roma Tre Nov 07 53/53 Conclusions Exciting indications of sterile neutrinos (new physics!) at the ev scale: LSND ν µ ν e signal (caveat: single experimental signal). Gallium νe disappearance (caveat: overestimated detector efficiency?). Reactor νe disappearance (caveat: flux calculation dependence). The MINOS & MINOS+ bound disfavors the LSND ν µ ν e signal. Vigorous experimental program to check conclusively in a few years: ν e and ν e disappearance with reactors and radioactive sources. νµ ν e transitions with accelerator neutrinos. νµ disappearance with accelerator neutrinos. Independent tests through effect of m 4 in β-decay and ββ 0ν -decay. Cosmology: strong tension with N eff = and m 4 ev. It may be solved by a non-standard cosmological mechanism. Possibilities for the next years: Reactor and source experiments ν e and ν e observe SBL oscillations: big excitement and explosion of the field. Otherwise: still marginal interest to check the LSND appearance signal. In any case the possibility of the existence of sterile neutrinos related to New Physics beyond the Standard Model at different mass scales will continue to be studied (e.g kev sterile neutrinos).
Oscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing. Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Oscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing CNNP07 9 October 07 /3 Oscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy CNNP07 Conference on Neutrino and Nuclear Physics Catania,
More informationSterile Neutrinos. Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Sterile Neutrinos PPC07 6 May 07 /5 Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy XI International Conference on Interconnections between Particle Physics and Cosmology Corpus Christi, Texas,
More informationStatus of Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti
Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy EPS-HEP 07 07 European Physical Society Conference on High Energy Physics Venezia, Italy, 5- July 07 C. Giunti Status of Light Sterile
More informationOscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing (Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos) Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Oscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing Moriond EW 07 4 March 07 /3 Oscillations Beyond Three-Neutrino Mixing (Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos) Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy Moriond Electroweak
More informationStatus of the Sterile Neutrino(s) Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Status of the Sterile Neutrino(s) LNGS 7 September 07 /40 Status of the Sterile Neutrino(s) Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy Recent Developments in Neutrino Physics and Astrophysics th Anniversary
More informationSterile Neutrino Searches: Experiment and Theory Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino
C. Giunti Sterile Neutrino Searches Tau06 Sep 06 /3 Sterile Neutrino Searches: Experiment and Theory Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino Tau06 4th International Workshop on Tau Lepton Physics 9-3 September
More informationC. Giunti Sterile Neutrino Mixing NOW Sep /25
Sterile Neutrino Mixing NOW and in the Next Years Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino NOW 06 Neutrino Oscillation Workshop 4- September 06 Otranto, Lecce, Italy C. Giunti Sterile Neutrino Mixing NOW 06
More informationStatus of Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos EPS-HEP 05 3 July 05 /5 Status of Light Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino and Dipartimento di Fisica, Università di Torino giunti@to.infn.it
More informationSterile Neutrinos in July 2010
Sterile Neutrinos in July 0 Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino Presidenza INFN, Roma, 19 July 0 Collaboration with Marco Laveder (Padova University) C. Giunti Sterile Neutrinos in July 0 Presidenza INFN,
More informationCritical Review on Neutrino Anomalies. Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Review on Neutrino Anomalies Neutrinos: the Quest for a New Physics Scale 7 March 07 /49 Critical Review on Neutrino Anomalies Carlo Giunti INFN, Torino, Italy Neutrinos: the Quest for a New
More informationCarlo Giunti. CERN Particle and Astro-Particle Physics Seminar. work in collaboration with Mario Acero Marco Laveder Walter Winter
Very-Short-BaseLine Electron Neutrino Disappearance Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Università di Torino mailto://giunti@to.infn.it Neutrino Unbound: http://www.nu.to.infn.it
More informationSterile neutrinos. Stéphane Lavignac (IPhT Saclay)
Sterile neutrinos Stéphane Lavignac (IPhT Saclay) introduction active-sterile mixing and oscillations cosmological constraints experimental situation and fits implications for beta and double beta decays
More informationNeutrino Masses in Cosmology, Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay and Direct Neutrino Masses Carlo Giunti
Neutrino Masses in Cosmology, Neutrinoless Double-Beta Decay and Direct Neutrino Masses Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Università di Torino mailto://giunti@to.infn.it
More informationShort-Baseline Neutrino Anomalies Carlo Giunti. Selected Puzzles in Particle Physics Laboratori Nazionali di Frascati December 2016
C. Giunti SBL Neutrino Anomalies Selected Puzzles in Particle Physics LNF Dec 06 /67 Short-Baseline Neutrino Anomalies Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino giunti@to.infn.it Neutrino Unbound: http://www.nu.to.infn.it
More informationStatus of Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti
Status of Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Università di Torino mailto://giunti@to.infn.it Neutrino Unbound: http://www.nu.to.infn.it NOW 0, Neutrino
More informationNeutrino Oscillation Measurements, Past and Present. Art McDonald Queen s University And SNOLAB
Neutrino Oscillation Measurements, Past and Present Art McDonald Queen s University And SNOLAB Early Neutrino Oscillation History -1940 s to 1960 s: - Neutrino oscillations were proposed by Pontecorvo
More informationNeutrino Mass: Overview of ββ 0ν, Cosmology and Direct Measurements Carlo Giunti
Neutrino Mass: Overview of ββ 0ν, Cosmology and Direct Measurements Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Università di Torino mailto://giunti@to.infn.it Neutrino Unbound:
More informationStefano Gariazzo. Light sterile neutrino: the 2018 status. IFIC, Valencia (ES) CSIC Universitat de Valencia
Stefano Gariazzo IFIC, Valencia (ES) CSIC Universitat de Valencia gariazzo@ific.uv.es http://ific.uv.es/~gariazzo/ Light sterile neutrino: the 08 status The Magnificent CEνNS, Chicago, 03//08 Neutrino
More informationev-scale Sterile Neutrinos
ev-scale Sterile Neutrinos Carlo Giunti 1 and Thierry Lasserre 2 1 Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare (INFN), Sezione di Torino, Via P. Giuria 1, I 10125 Torino, Italy; email: carlo.giunti@to.infn.it
More informationImpact of light sterile!s in LBL experiments "
Xmas Theory Workshop Bari, 22/12/14 Impact of light sterile!s in LBL experiments " Work done in collaboration with L. Klop (Master Thesis at MPI) (now PhD student @ GRAPPA Institute, Amsterdam) Antonio
More informationTwo hot issues in neutrino physics
Bari Xmas Workshop /1/011 Two hot issues in neutrino physics Antonio Palazzo Excellence Cluster Universe - TUM 1 Outline! - Introduction - The evidence of! 13 >0 - Hints of new light sterile neutrinos
More informationNeutrino Physics II. Neutrino Phenomenology. Arcadi Santamaria. TAE 2014, Benasque, September 19, IFIC/Univ. València
Neutrino Physics II Neutrino Phenomenology Arcadi Santamaria IFIC/Univ. València TAE 2014, Benasque, September 19, 2014 Neutrino Physics II Outline 1 Neutrino oscillations phenomenology Solar neutrinos
More informationReactor anomaly and searches of sterile neutrinos in experiments at very short baseline
Reactor anomaly and searches of sterile neutrinos in experiments at very short baseline G. MENTION CEA Saclay Irfu / SPP Workshop Inνisibles 13 July 17 th, 2013 Content Is the standard 3 neutrino mixing
More informationPhenomenological Status of Neutrino Mixing
Phenomenological Status of Neutrino Mixing Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Università di Torino mailto://giunti@to.infn.it Neutrino Unbound: http://www.nu.to.infn.it
More informationThe reactor antineutrino anomaly & experimental status of anomalies beyond 3 flavors
The reactor antineutrino anomaly & experimental status of anomalies beyond 3 flavors G. Mention CEA Saclay / Irfu / SPP Rencontres IPhT-SPP, 24 janvier 2012 Overview List of anomalies: LSND MB, anti- Gallium
More informationStatus and prospects of neutrino oscillations
Status and prospects of neutrino oscillations S. Bilenky JINR(Dubna)TRIUMF June 10, 2017 The award of the 2015 Nobel Prize to T. Kajita and A. McDonald for the discovery of neutrino oscillations, which
More informationSNOW Global fits to neutrino oscillation data. Thomas Schwetz SISSA, Trieste
SNOW 26 Global fits to neutrino oscillation data Thomas Schwetz SISSA, Trieste based on work in collaboration with M. Maltoni, M.A. Tortola, and J.W.F. Valle [hep-ph/3913, hep-ph/45172] T.S. is supported
More informationSun Yat-Sen University, 135 Xingang Xi Road, Guangzhou, Guangdong, , China
Sun Yat-Sen University, 135 Xingang Xi Road, Guangzhou, Guangdong, 510275, China E-mail: lingjj5@mail.sysu.edu.cn The basic theory and experimental hints for light sterile neutrinos at ev 2 mass scale
More informationAnalysis of Neutrino Oscillation experiments
Analysis of Neutrino Oscillation experiments Mario Andrés Acero Ortega Università degli Studi di Torino, LAPTH - Université de Savoie Second Year - Seminar Torino, Italy January 15th, 2008 Tutor: Carlo
More informationRecent Discoveries in Neutrino Oscillation Physics & Prospects for the Future
Recent Discoveries in Neutrino Oscillation Physics & Prospects for the Future Karsten M. Heeger Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 SNO φ ES SNO φ CC SNO φ NC SSM φ NC 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 6
More informationNeutrino Experiments: Lecture 2 M. Shaevitz Columbia University
Neutrino Experiments: Lecture 2 M. Shaevitz Columbia University 1 Outline 2 Lecture 1: Experimental Neutrino Physics Neutrino Physics and Interactions Neutrino Mass Experiments Neutrino Sources/Beams and
More informationNEUTRINO OSCILLATIONS AND STERILE NEUTRINO C. Giunti
ˆ ˆŠ Œ ˆ ˆ Œ ƒ Ÿ 2015.. 46.. 2 NEUTRINO OSCILLATIONS AND STERILE NEUTRINO C. Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, Torino, Italy We review the status of three-neutrino mixing and the results of global analyses
More informationHint of CPT Violation in Short-Baseline Electron Neutrino Disappearance
Journal of Physics: Conference Series 335 (011) 01054 doi:10.1088/174-6596/335/1/01054 Hint of CPT Violation in Short-Baseline Electron Neutrino Disappearance Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and
More informationThe Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly
The Reactor Antineutrino Anomaly M. Fechner, G. Mention, T. Lasserre, M. Cribier, Th. Mueller D. Lhuillier, A. Letourneau, CEA / Irfu arxiv:1101.2755 [hep-ex] Introduction New spectra calculations presented
More informationShort baseline neutrino oscillation experiments at nuclear reactors
Short baseline neutrino oscillation experiments at nuclear reactors Christian Buck, MPIK Heidelberg Erice School, Sicily Sept, 17th 2017 Neutrino oscillations = 3 2 1 3 2 1 3 2 1 3 2 1 ν ν ν ν ν ν τ τ
More informationNEUTRINOS II The Sequel
NEUTRINOS II The Sequel More About Neutrinos Ed Kearns Boston University NEPPSR V - 2006 August 18, 2006 Ed Kearns Boston University NEPPSR 2006 1 There is something unusual about this neutrino talk compared
More informationNeutrinos in Supernova Evolution and Nucleosynthesis
Neutrinos in Supernova Evolution and Nucleosynthesis Gabriel Martínez Pinedo The origin of cosmic elements: Past and Present Achievements, Future Challenges, Barcelona, June 12 15, 2013 M.-R. Wu, T. Fischer,
More informationUnbound Neutrino Roadmaps. MARCO LAVEDER Università di Padova e INFN NOW September 2006
Unbound Neutrino Roadmaps MARCO LAVEDER Università di Padova e INFN NOW 2006-11 September 2006 Experimental Data : 2006 Experiment Observable (# Data) Measured/SM Chlorine Average Rate (1) [CC]=0.30 ±
More informationNeutrino Basics. m 2 [ev 2 ] tan 2 θ. Reference: The Standard Model and Beyond, CRC Press. Paul Langacker (IAS) LSND 90/99% SuperK 90/99% MINOS K2K
Neutrino Basics CDHSW m 2 [ev 2 ] 10 0 10 3 10 6 10 9 KARMEN2 Cl 95% NOMAD MiniBooNE Ga 95% Bugey CHOOZ ν X ν µ ν τ ν τ NOMAD all solar 95% SNO 95% CHORUS NOMAD CHORUS LSND 90/99% SuperK 90/99% MINOS K2K
More informationSterile neutrino oscillations
Sterile neutrino oscillations after first MiniBooNE results GDR Neutrino, APC Paris, 22 June 2007 Thomas Schwetz CERN T. Schwetz, GDR Neutrino, Paris, 22 June 2007 p.1 Outline Introduction to the LSND
More informationNeutrino Physics: Lecture 12
Neutrino Physics: Lecture 12 Sterile neutrinos Amol Dighe Department of Theoretical Physics Tata Institute of Fundamental Research Apr 5, 2010 Outline 1 Short baseline experiments and LSND anomaly 2 Adding
More informationSensitivity to sterile ν mixings at a ν Factory --Side business of a ν Factory --
Sensitivity to sterile ν mixings at a ν Factory --Side business of a ν Factory -- Osamu Yasuda Tokyo Metropolitan University 009-1-18 @ Miami009 1 1. Introduction. Light sterile neutrinos 3. Summary 1.
More informationParticle Physics: Neutrinos part II
Particle Physics: Neutrinos part II José I. Crespo-Anadón Week 9: April 1, 2017 Columbia University Science Honors Program Course Policies Attendance Up to four absences Send email notifications of all
More informationSolar and atmospheric ν s
Solar and atmospheric ν s Masato SHIOZAWA Kamioka Observatory, Institute for Cosmic Ray Research, U of Tokyo, and Kamioka Satellite, Kavli Institute for the Physics and Mathematics of the Universe (WPI),
More informationOn indications for sterile neutrinos at the ev scale. Invisibles 14 workshop, July 2014, Paris Thomas Schwetz
On indications for sterile neutrinos at the ev scale Invisibles 14 workshop, 14-18 July 014, Paris Thomas Schwetz 1 Anomalies at the E/L ~ ev scale Reactor anomaly (νe disappearance) Gallium anomaly (νe
More informationParticle Physics: Neutrinos part II
Particle Physics: Neutrinos part II José I. Crespo-Anadón Week 9: November 18, 2017 Columbia University Science Honors Program 3 evidences for 3 neutrinos 2 3 neutrinos: 3 charged leptons Neutrinos are
More informationMiniBooNE, LSND, and Future Very-Short Baseline Experiments
1 MiniBooNE, LSND, and Future Very-Short Baseline Experiments Mike Shaevitz - Columbia University BLV2011 - September, 2011 - Gatlinburg, Tennessee Neutrino Oscillation Summary 2! µ "! Sterile "! e New
More informationNeutrinos as a Unique Probe: cm
Neutrinos as a Unique Probe: 10 33 10 +28 cm Particle Physics νn, µn, en scattering: existence/properties of quarks, QCD Weak decays (n pe ν e, µ e ν µ ν e ): Fermi theory, parity violation, quark mixing
More informationThe Effect of Cancellation in Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay
The Effect of Cancellation in Neutrinoless Double Beta Decay Manimala Mitra IPPP, Durham University July 24, 204 SUSY 204, Manchester arxiv:30.628, Manimala Mitra, Silvia Pascoli, Steven Wong Manimala
More informationThe Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment
The Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment Ming-chung Chu The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong On behalf of the Daya Bay Collaboration Partial support: CUHK VC Discretionary Fund, RGC CUHK3/CRF/10R
More informationNeutrino Physics. Carlo Giunti
Neutrino Physics Carlo Giunti INFN, Sezione di Torino, and Dipartimento di Fisica Teorica, Università di Torino mailto://giunti@to.infn.it Neutrino Unbound: http://www.nu.to.infn.it CERN, 12 15 May 2009
More informationOverview of Reactor Neutrino
Overview of Reactor Neutrino Chan-Fai (Steven) Wong, Wei Wang Sun Yat-Sen University 22 September 2016 The 14th International Workshop on Tau Lepton Physics Many thanks to Jia Jie Ling, Liang Jian Wen
More information- Future Prospects in Oscillation Physics -
Measuring θ 13 and the Search for Leptonic CP Violation - Future Prospects in Oscillation Physics - Karsten M. Heeger Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory ν e flux θ 13 =? P ee, (4 MeV) 1/r 2 Evidence
More informationNeutrino Anomalies & CEνNS
Neutrino Anomalies & CEνNS André de Gouvêa University PIRE Workshop, COFI February 6 7, 2017 Something Funny Happened on the Way to the 21st Century ν Flavor Oscillations Neutrino oscillation experiments
More informationNeutrino Oscillation Physics
Experimental Neutrino Oscillation Physics XL International Meeting on Fundamental Physics Pau Novella CIEMAT 1 Overview Neutrino Oscillation physics Measuring the oscillation The first generation The precision
More informationNeutrino Oscillations
Neutrino Oscillations Elisa Bernardini Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron DESY (Zeuthen) Suggested reading: C. Giunti and C.W. Kim, Fundamentals of Neutrino Physics and Astrophysics, Oxford University Press
More information1 Neutrinos. 1.1 Introduction
1 Neutrinos 1.1 Introduction It was a desperate attempt to rescue energy and angular momentum conservation in beta decay when Wolfgang Pauli postulated the existence of a new elusive particle, the neutrino.
More informationUpdated three-neutrino oscillation parameters from global fits
Updated three-neutrino oscillation parameters from fits (Based on arxiv:14.74) Mariam Tórtola IFIC, Universitat de València/CSIC 37th International Conference on High Energy Physics 3th July 214, Valencia.
More informationPrecise Determination of the 235 U Reactor Antineutrino Cross Section per Fission Carlo Giunti
C. Giunti Determination of the 235 U Reactor Antineutrino Cross Section per Fission AAP 2016 2 Dec 2016 1/10 Precise Determination of the 235 U Reactor Antineutrino Cross Section per Fission Carlo Giunti
More informationProspects of Reactor ν Oscillation Experiments
Prospects of Reactor ν Oscillation Experiments F.Suekane RCNS, Tohoku Univ. Erice School 3/09/009 1 Contents * Motivation * Physics of Neutrino Oscillation * Accessible Parameters of Reactor Neutrinos
More informationLatest Results from MINOS and MINOS+ Will Flanagan University of Texas on behalf of the MINOS+ Collaboration
Latest Results from MINOS and MINOS+ Will Flanagan University of Texas on behalf of the MINOS+ Collaboration Outline Overview of the Main Injector Neutrino Oscillation Search Detector Exciting physics
More informationNeutrino Oscillations
Neutrino Oscillations Heidi Schellman June 6, 2000 Lots of help from Janet Conrad Charge mass,mev tandard Model of Elementary Particles 3 Generations of Fermions Force Carriers Q u a r k s u d 2/3 2/3
More informationNeutrino Experiments: Lecture 3 M. Shaevitz Columbia University
Neutrino Experiments: Lecture 3 M. Shaevitz Columbia University 1 Outline 2 Lecture 1: Experimental Neutrino Physics Neutrino Physics and Interactions Neutrino Mass Experiments Neutrino Sources/Beams and
More informationPoS(ICRC2017)1024. First Result of NEOS Experiment. Kim Siyeon. Affiliation:Chung-Ang University. On behalf of NEOS Collaboration
Affiliation:Chung-Ang University On behalf of NEOS Collaboration E-mail: siyeon@cau.ac.kr Neutrino Experiment for Oscillation at Short baseline (NEOS) targeted the search of singlet neutrinos as natural
More informationThe future of neutrino physics (at accelerators)
Mauro Mezzetto, Istituto Nazionale Fisica Nucleare, Padova The future of neutrino physics (at accelerators) Present Status Concepts, strategies, challenges The two players: Dune and Hyper-Kamiokande Conclusions
More informationNeutrino oscillation experiments: Recent results and implications
Title transparency Neutrino oscillation experiments: Recent results and implications W. Hampel MPI Kernphysik Heidelberg Motivation for talk On the way from the Standard Model to String Theory: appropriate
More informationReactor Neutrino Oscillation Experiments: Status and Prospects
6! 5! 4! 1 2! 3!! Reactor Neutrino Oscillation Experiments: Status and Prospects Survival Probability 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 20 4! 15 Karsten M. Heeger University of Wisconsin Data - BG - Geo & e 99.73% C.L.
More informationNeutrinos in Nuclear Physics
Neutrinos in Nuclear Physics R. D. McKeown Jefferson Lab, Newport News, VA, USA Department of Physics, College of William and Mary, Williamsburg, VA, USA DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.3204/desy-proc-2014-04/305
More informationOn Minimal Models with Light Sterile Neutrinos
On Minimal Models with Light Sterile Neutrinos Pilar Hernández University of Valencia/IFIC Donini, López-Pavón, PH, Maltoni arxiv:1106.0064 Donini, López-Pavón, PH, Maltoni, Schwetz arxiv:1205.5230 SM
More informationReview of νe Appearance Oscillation Experiments
Review of νe Appearance Oscillation Experiments PIC 2013 The XXXIII International Symposium on Physics in Collision IHEP, Beijing, P. R. China 03-07 September 2013. Vittorio Paolone University of Pittsburgh
More informationSterile Neutrinos. Patrick Huber. Center for Neutrino Physics Virginia Tech
Sterile Neutrinos Patrick Huber Center for Neutrino Physics Virginia Tech XIII Workshop on Electron-Nucleus Scattering June 23-27, 2014, Marciana Marina, Isola d Elba, Italy P. Huber p. 1 Outline The reactor
More informationMarch 30, 01 Lecture 5 of 6 @ ORICL Philosophical Society Yuri Kamyshkov/ University of Tennessee email: kamyshkov@utk.edu 1. Concept/misconception of mass in Special Relativity (March,9). and n Oscillations:
More informationSterile neutrinos: to be or not to be?
Sterile neutrinos: to be or not to be? Joachim Kopp (University of Mainz) June 9, 2015 @ WIN 2015, Heidelberg Joachim Kopp Sterile neutrinos: to be or not to be? 1 Outline 1 Sterile Neutrinos 2 Oscillation
More informationNeutrinos & Large Extra Dimensions. Renata Zukanovich Funchal Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil
Neutrinos & Large Extra Dimensions Renata Zukanovich Funchal Universidade de São Paulo, Brazil What is ν? Workshop June 26, 2012 ν Masses & Mixings Majorana CP Violating phases solar atmospheric accelerator
More informationNeutrino Oscillations And Sterile Neutrinos
Neutrino Oscillations And Sterile Neutrinos Keshava Prasad Gubbi University of Bonn s6nagubb@uni-bonn.de May 27, 2016 Keshava Prasad Gubbi (Uni Bonn) Neutrino Oscillations,Sterile Neutrinos May 27, 2016
More informationNeutrino oscillation phenomenology
Neutrino oscillation phenomenology Tokyo Metropolitan University Osamu Yasuda INO-KEK meeting 7 November 007@KEK Contents 1. Introduction. Future long baseline experiments 3. Deviation from the standard
More informationLong baseline experiments
Mauro Mezzetto, Istituto Nazionale Fisica Nucleare, Padova Long baseline experiments Present Status Concepts, strategies, challenges The two players: Dune and Hyper-Kamiokande Conclusions M. Mezzetto,
More informationSterile neutrinos at future long-baseline experiments
Davide Meloni, Dip. Fisica Roma Tre & INFN sez. Roma Tre, Friday 12, NOW 2008 1 Introduction Sterile neutrinos today 2 Current limits on new mixing angles The question of the parameterization Current allowed
More informationNeutrinos: Three-Flavor Effects in Sparse and Dense Matter
Neutrinos: Three-Flavor Effects in Sparse and Dense Matter Tommy Ohlsson tommy@theophys.kth.se Royal Institute of Technology (KTH) & Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences (KVA) Stockholm, Sweden Neutrinos
More informationChart of Elementary Particles
Chart of Elementary Particles Chart of Elementary Particles Better Chart! Better Chart! As of today: Oscillation of 3 massive active neutrinos is clearly the dominant effect: If neutrinos have mass: For
More informationGrand Unification Theories
Grand Unification Theories After the success of the unified theroy of electroweak interactions it was natural to ask if strong interactions are united with the weak and em ones. The greater strength of
More informationNeutrino physics. Evgeny Akhmedov. Max-Planck-Institut für Kernphysik, Heidelberg & Kurchatov Institute, Moscow
Neutrino physics Experimental results and future Evgeny Akhmedov Max-Planck-Institut für Kernphysik, Heidelberg & Kurchatov Institute, Moscow Evgeny Akhmedov Mainz U. Graduate School Meeting Bullay, Oct.
More informationNeutrino mixing II. Can ν e ν µ ν τ? If this happens:
Can ν e ν µ ν τ? If this happens: Neutrino mixing II neutrinos have mass (though there are some subtleties involving the MSW mechanism) physics beyond the (perturbative) Standard Model participates Outline:
More informationStefano Gariazzo. Light sterile neutrinos with pseudoscalar interactions in cosmology. Based on [JCAP 08 (2016) 067] University and INFN, Torino
Stefano Gariazzo University and INFN, Torino gariazzo@to.infn.it http://personalpages.to.infn.it/~gariazzo/ Light sterile neutrinos with pseudoscalar interactions in cosmology Based on [JCAP 08 (2016)
More informationNeutrinos. Thanks to Ian Blockland and Randy Sobie for these slides. spin particle with no electric charge; weak isospin partners of charged leptons
Neutrinos Thanks to Ian Blockland and Randy Sobie for these slides spin particle with no electric charge; weak isospin partners of charged leptons observed in 193, in 1962 and in the 199s neutrino physics
More informationThe ultimate measurement?
Reactor neutrinos θ13 The ultimate measurement? Pau Novella CNRS/APC 1 Overview Neutrino oscillations and the last mixing angle Reactor neutrinos as a probe to θ13 Unrevealing θ13 with reactor neutrino
More informationPROSPECT: Precision Reactor Oscillation and SPECTrum Experiment
PROSPECT: Precision Reactor Oscillation and SPECTrum Experiment Penn Neutrino Seminar November 20, 2015 1 Outline 1. Introduction to neutrinos and neutrino anomalies 2. PROSPECT short baseline reactor
More informationIntroduction to Neutrino Physics
Introduction to Neutrino Physics Tommy Ohlsson tommy@theophys.kth.se Royal Institute of Technology (KTH) Stockholm Center for Physics, Astronomy, and Biotechnology Stockholm, Sweden Abisko, Norrbotten,
More informationWhy neutrinos? Patrick Huber. Center for Neutrino Physics at Virginia Tech. KURF Users Meeting June 7, 2013, Virginia Tech. P. Huber VT-CNP p.
Why neutrinos? Patrick Huber Center for Neutrino Physics at Virginia Tech KURF Users Meeting June 7, 2013, Virginia Tech P. Huber VT-CNP p. 1 Neutrinos are massive so what? Neutrinos in the Standard Model
More informationarxiv: v1 [hep-ph] 15 Apr 2019
International Journal of Modern Physics A c World Scientific Publishing Company arxiv:1904.07108v1 [hep-ph] 15 Apr 2019 Roles of sterile neutrinos in particle physics and cosmology Sin Kyu Kang School
More informationExotic Charges, Multicomponent Dark Matter and Light Sterile Neutrinos
Exotic Charges, Multicomponent and Light Sterile Neutrinos Julian Heeck Max-Planck-Institut für Kernphysik, Heidelberg 2.10.2012 based on J.H., He Zhang, arxiv:1210.xxxx. Sterile Neutrinos Hints for ev
More informationNeutrinos and Cosmos. Hitoshi Murayama (Berkeley) Texas Conference at Stanford Dec 17, 2004
Neutrinos and Cosmos Hitoshi Murayama (Berkeley) Texas Conference at Stanford Dec 17, 2004 Outline A Little Historical Perspective Interpretation of Data & Seven Questions Matter Anti-Matter Asymmetry
More informationNeutrino properties: nature, mass & CP violation
Neutrino properties: nature, mass & CP violation I. Schienbein LPSC prepared together with P. Serpico (LAPTH) and A. Wingerter (LPSC) Kick-off meeting, 2/0/202, Annecy Facts of life with neutrinos Neutrino
More informationThe Short Baseline Neutrino Program at Fermilab
Yale University E-mail: serhan.tufanli@cern.ch The Short-Baseline Neutrino (SBN) program at Fermilab is a short-baseline neutrino experiment with the main goal of performing definitive search for neutrino
More informationNeutrino History ... and some lessons learned
2009 Neutrino Summer School Neutrino History accelerator, atmospheric, reactor and solar experiments... and some lessons learned Karsten M. Heeger University of Wisconsin History of Neutrino Physics -
More informationFlavor Models with Sterile Neutrinos. NuFact 11 Geneva, Aug, He Zhang
Flavor Models with Sterile Neutrinos NuFact 11 Geneva, Aug, 2011 Contents: Sterile neutrinos in ν-osc. and 0νββ decays Mechanisms for light sterile neutrino masses Flavor symmetry with sterile neutrinos
More information1. Neutrino Oscillations
Neutrino oscillations and masses 1. Neutrino oscillations 2. Atmospheric neutrinos 3. Solar neutrinos, MSW effect 4. Reactor neutrinos 5. Accelerator neutrinos 6. Neutrino masses, double beta decay 1.
More informationParticle Physics: Neutrinos part I
Particle Physics: Neutrinos part I José I. Crespo-Anadón Week 8: November 10, 2017 Columbia University Science Honors Program Course policies Attendance record counts Up to four absences Lateness or leaving
More informationRecent Discoveries in Neutrino Physics
Recent Discoveries in Neutrino Physics Experiments with Reactor Antineutrinos Karsten Heeger http://neutrino.physics.wisc.edu/ Karsten Heeger, Univ. of Wisconsin NUSS, July 13, 2009 Standard Model and
More informationThe Hunt for Sterile Neutrinos. H. Ray, University of Florida
The Hunt for Sterile Neutrinos 1 Particle Physics is Over!..finding the Higgs arguably the most important discovery in more than a generation has left physicists without a clear roadmap of where to go
More information