Doing science with multi-model ensembles

Size: px
Start display at page:

Download "Doing science with multi-model ensembles"

Transcription

1 Doing science with multi-model ensembles Gerald A. Meehl National Center for Atmospheric Research Biological and Energy Research Regional and Global Climate Modeling Program

2 Why use a multi-model ensemble average? A multi-model average often out-performs any individual model compared to observations. --Demonstrated for mean climate (Gleckler et al., 2008; Reichler and Kim, 2008) --Detection and attribution (Zhang et al., 2007) --Statistics of variability (Pierce et al., 2009) --Some systematic biases (i.e., evident in most or all models) can be readily identified in multimodel averages (Knutti et al., 2010) Multivariate metric for mean climate simulation (Reichler and Kim, 2008) Multi-model average Individual models Better simulation

3 Best practice for analysis of multi-model ensembles (Knutti et al., 2010: Good Practice Guidance Paper on Assessing and Combining Multi Model Climate Projections, IPCC) How do you produce a multi-model average when there are multiple ensemble members of different sizes for each model? 1. The default is to take all models in multi-model ensemble, and either use one realization from each model, or average the ensemble members from each individual model, and then average those together But I just want to use the best models in my multi-model average how do I define what the best models are? Model ranking depends on the metrics applied different metrics give different rankings 2. A subset of models (from which a multi-model average can be computed) can be taken from the total collection of models if a physical reason can be supplied to justify the choice of which models are in the subset 3. New methods are being developed to weight models (given that many models are not independent see Ben Sanderson and Reto Knutti talks Thursday) 4. Emergent constraints can provide guidance 5. Comparison to observations should also take into account uncertainty in observations (see Ben Santer talk Thursday)

4 Model simulations in CMIP5 have improved compared to previous CMIP phases Model ranking and fidelity across CMIP generations using only temperature and precipitation (Knutti et al., 2013, GRL) Most models are strongly tied to their predecessors, and some also exchange ideas and code with other models, thus supporting an earlier hypothesis that the models in the new ensemble are neither independent of each other nor independent of the earlier generation. Multi-model mean Multi-model median Better simulation Geophysical Research Letters Volume 40, Issue 6, pages , 26 MAR 2013 DOI: /grl

5 Model weighting based on model independence and skill (Sanderson and Wehner, 2016; Sanderson, Knutti, Caldwell, 2016)

6 emergent constraints can be used in a multi-model context to quantify relevant processes for climate system response (find a metric in the climate system that incorporates a feedback and a temperature response) best models from this metric Snow-albedo feedback and the seasonal cycle, compared to snow-albedo feedback and global warming --warming of springtime temperature divided by reduction of land surface albedo, x axis --warming from increasing CO2 divided by reduction of land surface albedo, y axis) (Hall and Qu, 2006, GRL)

7 A traditional multi-model result from the IPCC AR5 (CMIP5 models) IPCC AR5 Fig. SPM.7 (multi-model average using a single realization from each model, and 5-95% (+/ standard deviation) uncertainty ranges

8 A subset of 5 models selected based on agreement with recent observed average sea ice thickness and trends of sea ice extent IPCC AR5 Fig. SPM.7 (five-model average using a single realization from each model, and model minimum-maximum uncertainty ranges)

9 IPCC AR5 Chapter 9, Fig. 9.8 What about the early-2000s hiatus? Models reproduce observed temperature trends over many decades, including the more rapid warming since the mid- 20th century and the cooling immediately following large volcanic eruptions (very high confidence). Early 21 st century global mean surface temperature slowdown : 0.04 ºC/decade : 0.11 ºC/decade Chapter 9, Fig. 9.8 WGI AR5 Final Draft 07 June

10 Using CMIP5 multi-model ensemble averages to attribute Human influence on the warming climate to anthropogenic system is clear forcings IPCC AR5 Figure SPM.6 It is extremely likely that human influence has been the dominant cause of the observed warming since the mid-20th century. Figure SPM.6 WGI AR5 Final Draft 07 June

11 The time evolution of the observed climate system is a combination of externallyforced response and internally generated climate variability Dominant pattern of internally-generated variability from control runs (left) and observed IPO pattern (right): (Meehl, Hu, Santer and Xie, 2016, Nature Climate Change) A five model ensemble with single forcings shows patterns and time evolution of response Sulfate aerosols: GHGs:

12 Recent slow down in global surface temperature increase the early-2000s slowdown ( , negative phase of the Interdecadal Pacific Oscillation, IPO) is characterized by a trend that is significantly less than the previous positive IPO period from (Fyfe et al., 2016, Nature Clim. Chg)

13 A multi-model ensemble average removes internally-generated variability ( noise ) and leaves the externally-forced response But how does internally generated decadal climate variability, in the single realization we have for the observations, combine with the externally forced response to produce what we have observed? We are interested in understanding the sources and processes that produce the climate noise, and the interplay with the externally forced response (from GHGs, volcanoes, etc.); relevant for decadal climate prediction Can we use the CMIP5 multimodel data set to quantify the contribution of the Interdecadal Pacific Oscillation to GMST epoch trends? Positive IPO Negative IPO Positive IPO Negative IPO (Meehl, Hu, Santer and Xie, 2016, Nature Climate Change)

14 Observed trends Externally forced trend (CMIP5 multi-model ensemble) IPO-adjusted trend 71% 25% initial pulse 75% 27% 25% IPO contribution to difference between median values of Positive IPO Negative IPO Positive IPO Negative IPO forced trend and observed trend How much could the IPO contribute to GMST trends? --Compute distribution of decadal GMST trends for IPO positive and negative phases in 1100 year control run --adjust externally forced trends from CMIP5 multi-model mean with IPO-related trends --compare IPO-adjusted GMST trends with observed GMST trends (Meehl, Hu, Santer and Xie, 2016, Nature Climate Change)

15 Temperatures have flatlined over the past 15 years and to my knowledge, not a single climate model ever predicted that a pause in global warming would ever occur. --Senator James Inhofe (R-Okla.) in U.S. Senate hearing on the Obama Climate Action Plan on January 16, 2014 (quoted in Eos, January 28, 2014)

16 Some CMIP5 uninitialized models actually simulated the slowdown Tend to be characterized by a negative phase of the IPO internally generated variability in those model simulations happened to sync with observed internally generated variability Total: 262 possible simulations slowdown: slowdown: slowdown: slowdown: slowdown: : 1 Slowdown as observed from : 10 members out of 262 possible realizations (Meehl et al., 2014, Nature Climate Change)

17 Larger increasing trends of Antarctic sea ice since 2000 associated with negative IPO phase, deeper Amundsen Sea Low, stronger northward surface winds in the Pacific sector Multi-model ensemble mean shows Antarctic sea ice decreases But ten of the model ensemble members simulate the global surface warming slowdown and also simulate negative IPO phase with increasing Antarctic sea ice Antarctic sea ice anomalies traced to SST and precipitation anomalies in eastern equatorial Pacific with negative IPO phase in specified convective heating anomaly climate model experiment (Meehl et al., July, 2016, Nature Geoscience)

18 Larger increasing trends of Antarctic sea ice since 2000 associated with negative IPO phase, deeper Amundsen Sea Low, stronger northward surface winds in the Pacific sector Multi-model ensemble mean shows Antarctic sea ice decreases But ten of the model ensemble members simulate the global surface warming slowdown and also simulate negative IPO phase with increasing Antarctic sea ice Antarctic sea ice anomalies traced to SST and precipitation anomalies in eastern equatorial Pacific with negative IPO phase in specified convective heating anomaly climate model experiment (Meehl et al., July, 2016, Nature Geoscience)

19 Depicting uncertainty in a CMIP5 multi-model ensemble (IPCC AR5, Fig. SPM.8) Stippling indicates multi-model mean is more than two standard deviations of natural internal variability in 20-yr means; hatching indicates multi-model mean is less than one standard deviation of natural internal variability in 20-yr means, and where at least 90% of models agree on the sign of change Number of models

20 The new field of decadal climate prediction seeks to use climate models initialized with observations to predict the time evolution of the statistics of regional climate over the near term (i.e. the next 10 years) by predicting the interplay between internal variability and response to increasing GHGs Initialized hindcasts/predictions specified in CMIP5 for the first time (ten year hindcasts initialized for every year starting in 1960) Can decadal climate variability processes and mechanisms, if properly initialized, provide increased prediction skill of the time evolution of regional climate in the near-term?

21 IPCC AR assessed temperature range is less than from uninitialized projections in part due to results from initialized decadal predictions in CMIP5 Uninitialized Figure 11.9a from IPCC AR5, ch 11 Initialized Figure 11.9b from IPCC AR5, ch 11 Assessed Temperature change Figure 11.25b from IPCC AR5, ch 11

22 Initialized CMIP5 simulations better simulate the mid- 1970s shift to the positive IPO phase, and the early-2000s hiatus negative IPO (5 year average, prediction for years 3-7) compared to free-running simulations (16 models; Stippling: multi-model ensemble mean +/- 2 standard deviations warmer/colder than observations as in Smith et al., 2012) lower left numbers: pattern correlation (area-mean removed)/ RMSE upper right: global T (monte carlo test: 1000 year CCSM4 control run, calculated pattern correlations of 100,000 random patterns, 95th percentile is a pattern correlation of 0.59) (Meehl and Teng, GRL, 2013)

23 CMIP5 multi-model data are very useful for climate science research But single models available in the CMIP5 data set are still useful to study processes

24 Using a single model (CCSM4) to address the hypothesis that offequatorial ocean heat content in the tropical western Pacific can provide the conditions for ENSO events to trigger a decadal timescale IPO transition (Meehl, Hu, Teng, 2016, Nature Communications)

25 Niño3.4 Previous IPO shifts showed qualitative agreement between initialized hindcasts and observations An El Niño could trigger an IPO transition to positive (mid-1970s) or a La Niña to IPO negative (late 1990s) after buildup of off-equatorial heat content anomalies in the western Pacific Predictions with CCSM4 initialized in 2013 show qualitative agreement, with above normal Niño3.4 SSTs in (Meehl, Hu, Teng, 2016, Nature Communications) With the build-up of off-equatorial western Pacific heat content, this could trigger a transition to the positive phase of the IPO and larger rates of global warming

26

27 CCSM4 prediction initialized in 2013 indicates a positive phase of the IPO for 3-7 year average This is quite different from persistence ( persisted to ) And is different from uninitialized projection for (Meehl et al., 2016, Nature Communications)

28 Predicted rate of global warming from 2013 initial year greater than during early-2000s slowdown and greater than uninitialized: Observed : +0.08±0.05 C/decade Predicted : +0.22±0.13 C/decade Uninitialized : +0.14±0.12 C/decade (Meehl et al., 2016, Nature Communications)

29 Summary 1. Multi-model ensemble average usually outperforms any single model, and averages out internal variability to focus on forced response 2. To produce a multi-model average when there are multiple ensemble members of different sizes for each model: take all models in multi-model ensemble, and either use one realization from each model, or average the ensemble members from each individual model, and then average those together 3. Model ranking depends on the metrics applied different metrics give different rankings 4. A subset of models (from which a multi-model average can be computed) can be taken from the total collection of models if a physical reason can be supplied to justify the choice of which models are in the subset 5. New methods are being developed to weight models (given that many models are not independent see Ben Sanderson and Reto Knutti talks Thursday) 6. Emergent constraints can provide guidance 7. Comparison to observations should also take into account uncertainty in observations (see Ben Santer talk Thursday) 8. Single models available in the CMIP5 data set are still useful to study processes

30

31 emergent constraints can be used in a multi-model context to quantify relevant processes for climate system response (find a metric in the climate system that incorporates a feedback and a temperature response) best models from this metric Snow-albedo feedback and the seasonal cycle, compared to snow-albedo feedback and global warming --warming of springtime temperature divided by reduction of land surface albedo, x axis --warming from increasing CO2 divided by reduction of land surface albedo, y axis) (Hall and Qu, 2006, GRL)

32 A traditional multi-model result from the IPCC AR5 (CMIP5 models) IPCC AR5 Fig. SPM.7 (multi-model average using a single realization from each model, and 5-95% (+/ standard deviation) uncertainty ranges

Initialized decadal climate predictions focusing on the Pacific Gerald Meehl

Initialized decadal climate predictions focusing on the Pacific Gerald Meehl Initialized decadal climate predictions focusing on the Pacific Gerald Meehl National Center for Atmospheric Research Boulder Colorado Following Zhang, Wallace and Battisti (1997) the Interdecadal Pacific

More information

Which Climate Model is Best?

Which Climate Model is Best? Which Climate Model is Best? Ben Santer Program for Climate Model Diagnosis and Intercomparison Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA 94550 Adapting for an Uncertain Climate: Preparing

More information

Climate model simulations of the observed early-2000s hiatus of global warming

Climate model simulations of the observed early-2000s hiatus of global warming Climate model simulations of the observed early-2000s hiatus of global warming Gerald A. Meehl 1, Haiyan Teng 1, and Julie M. Arblaster 1,2 1. National Center for Atmospheric Research, Boulder, CO 2. CAWCR,

More information

Explaining Changes in Extremes and Decadal Climate Fluctuations

Explaining Changes in Extremes and Decadal Climate Fluctuations Explaining Changes in Extremes and Decadal Climate Fluctuations Gerald A. Meehl Julie Arblaster, Claudia Tebaldi, Aixue Hu, Ben Santer Explaining changes implies attributing those changes to some cause

More information

1.Decadal prediction ( ) 2. Longer term (to 2100 and beyond)

1.Decadal prediction ( ) 2. Longer term (to 2100 and beyond) Coordinated climate change experiments (formulated by WGCM and AIMES) to be run for assessment in IPCC AR5 Two classes of models to address two time frames and two sets of science questions: 1.Decadal

More information

Tropical Pacific modula;ons of global climate

Tropical Pacific modula;ons of global climate Tropical Pacific modula;ons of global climate Shang- Ping Xie 1 & Yu Kosaka 2 1 Scripps Inst of Oceanogr, UCSD; 2 Univ of Tokyo Develop seasonal and spa

More information

Case studies for initialized decadal hindcasts and predictions for the Pacific region

Case studies for initialized decadal hindcasts and predictions for the Pacific region GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS, VOL. 39,, doi:10.1029/2012gl053423, 2012 Case studies for initialized decadal hindcasts and predictions for the Pacific region Gerald A. Meehl 1 and Haiyan Teng 1 Received

More information

Antarctic sea-ice expansion between 2000 and 2014 driven by tropical Pacific decadal climate variability

Antarctic sea-ice expansion between 2000 and 2014 driven by tropical Pacific decadal climate variability Antarctic sea-ice expansion between 2000 and 2014 driven by tropical Pacific decadal climate variability Gerald A. Meehl 1, Julie M. Arblaster 1,2, Cecilia M. Bitz 3, Christine T.Y. Chung 4, and Haiyan

More information

Why the hiatus in global mean surface temperature trends in the last decade?

Why the hiatus in global mean surface temperature trends in the last decade? Why the hiatus in global mean surface temperature trends in the last decade? G. Bala Divecha Center for Climate Change Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore (Email: gbala@caos.iisc.ernet.in) On 27 September

More information

Transformational Climate Science. The future of climate change research following the IPCC Fifth Assessment Report

Transformational Climate Science. The future of climate change research following the IPCC Fifth Assessment Report Transformational Climate Science The future of climate change research following the IPCC Fifth Assessment Report www.exeter.ac.uk/climate2014 Working Group I The challenge of climate change #climate2014

More information

The Climate System and Climate Models. Gerald A. Meehl National Center for Atmospheric Research Boulder, Colorado

The Climate System and Climate Models. Gerald A. Meehl National Center for Atmospheric Research Boulder, Colorado The Climate System and Climate Models Gerald A. Meehl National Center for Atmospheric Research Boulder, Colorado The climate system includes all components of the physical earth system that affect weather

More information

WATER SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY BOARD. Proceedings of a Workshop. Monday, July 25 th, 2pm EDT

WATER SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY BOARD. Proceedings of a Workshop. Monday, July 25 th, 2pm EDT Frontiers in Decadal WATER SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY BOARD Climate Variability: Proceedings of a Workshop Monday, July 25 th, 2pm EDT Gerald A. Meehl National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) Organizing

More information

Recent Climate History - The Instrumental Era.

Recent Climate History - The Instrumental Era. 2002 Recent Climate History - The Instrumental Era. Figure 1. Reconstructed surface temperature record. Strong warming in the first and late part of the century. El Ninos and major volcanic eruptions are

More information

Is CESM the best Earth System Model? Reto Knutti Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science ETH Zurich, Switzerland

Is CESM the best Earth System Model? Reto Knutti Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science ETH Zurich, Switzerland Is CESM the best Earth System Model? Reto Knutti Institute for Atmospheric and Climate Science ETH Zurich, Switzerland reto.knutti@env.ethz.ch Is CESM the best Earth System Model? Yes Is CESM the best

More information

Regional forecast quality of CMIP5 multimodel decadal climate predictions

Regional forecast quality of CMIP5 multimodel decadal climate predictions Regional forecast quality of CMIP5 multimodel decadal climate predictions F. J. Doblas-Reyes ICREA & IC3, Barcelona, Spain V. Guemas (IC3, Météo-France), J. García-Serrano (IPSL), L.R.L. Rodrigues, M.

More information

An Introduction to Coupled Models of the Atmosphere Ocean System

An Introduction to Coupled Models of the Atmosphere Ocean System An Introduction to Coupled Models of the Atmosphere Ocean System Jonathon S. Wright jswright@tsinghua.edu.cn Atmosphere Ocean Coupling 1. Important to climate on a wide range of time scales Diurnal to

More information

Moving from Global to Regional Projections of Climate Change

Moving from Global to Regional Projections of Climate Change Moving from Global to Regional Projections of Climate Change Mat Collins College of Engineering, Mathematics and Physical Sciences, University of Exeter, UK Yann Arthus-Bertrand / Altitude Joint Met Office

More information

Chapter outline. Reference 12/13/2016

Chapter outline. Reference 12/13/2016 Chapter 2. observation CC EST 5103 Climate Change Science Rezaul Karim Environmental Science & Technology Jessore University of science & Technology Chapter outline Temperature in the instrumental record

More information

Patterns and impacts of ocean warming and heat uptake

Patterns and impacts of ocean warming and heat uptake Patterns and impacts of ocean warming and heat uptake Shang-Ping Xie Scripps Inst of Oceanography, UCSD Ocean warming & circulation change Ocean heat uptake & meridional overturning circulation Global

More information

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE OUTLOOK BRIEFING. December 22, 2017 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE OUTLOOK BRIEFING. December 22, 2017 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region ALASKA REGION CLIMATE OUTLOOK BRIEFING December 22, 2017 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region Today s Outline Feature of the month: Autumn sea ice near Alaska Climate Forecast Basics Climate

More information

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION

SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION DOI: 1.138/NCLIMATE216 Recent intensification of wind-driven circulation in the Pacific and the ongoing warming hiatus (a) Observed wind trends 6N N 2N 2S S 6S 6E 12E 18E 12W

More information

Detection and attribution, forced changes, natural variability, signal and noise, ensembles

Detection and attribution, forced changes, natural variability, signal and noise, ensembles ETH Zurich Reto Knutti Detection and attribution, forced changes, natural variability, signal and noise, ensembles Reto Knutti, IAC ETH What s wrong with this presentation? For the next two decades, a

More information

Climate Variability Natural and Anthropogenic

Climate Variability Natural and Anthropogenic Climate Variability Natural and Anthropogenic Jim Renwick NIWA Climate Research j.renwick@niwa.co.nz Climate equilibrium and climate forcings Natural forcings Anthropogenic forcings Feedbacks Natural variability

More information

(1) Arctic Sea Ice Predictability,

(1) Arctic Sea Ice Predictability, (1) Arctic Sea Ice Predictability, (2) It s Long-term Loss and Implications for Ocean Conditions Marika Holland, NCAR With contributions from: David Bailey, Alex Jahn, Jennifer Kay, Laura Landrum, Steve

More information

Different impacts of Northern, Tropical and Southern volcanic eruptions on the tropical Pacific SST in the last millennium

Different impacts of Northern, Tropical and Southern volcanic eruptions on the tropical Pacific SST in the last millennium Different impacts of Northern, Tropical and Southern volcanic eruptions on the tropical Pacific SST in the last millennium Meng Zuo, Wenmin Man, Tianjun Zhou Email: zuomeng@lasg.iap.ac.cn Sixth WMO International

More information

Climate Variability and Change Past, Present and Future An Overview

Climate Variability and Change Past, Present and Future An Overview Climate Variability and Change Past, Present and Future An Overview Dr Jim Salinger National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research Auckland, New Zealand INTERNATIONAL WORKSHOP ON REDUCING VULNERABILITY

More information

Predicting climate extreme events in a user-driven context

Predicting climate extreme events in a user-driven context www.bsc.es Oslo, 6 October 2015 Predicting climate extreme events in a user-driven context Francisco J. Doblas-Reyes BSC Earth Sciences Department BSC Earth Sciences Department What Environmental forecasting

More information

Interpre'ng Model Results

Interpre'ng Model Results Interpre'ng Model Results Clara Deser Na'onal Center for Atmospheric Research Boulder, CO CESM Tutorial, 12 August 2016 Interpre'ng Model Results 1) What kind of model? 2) What kind of simula'on? 3) What

More information

Understanding Global Environmental Trends and Projections. Ants Leetmaa Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory Princeton, NJ 08542

Understanding Global Environmental Trends and Projections. Ants Leetmaa Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory Princeton, NJ 08542 Understanding Global Environmental Trends and Projections Ants Leetmaa Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory Princeton, NJ 08542 Climate Scenarios Used for Attribution Studies of Climate Variability and

More information

Was the Amazon Drought of 2005 Human-Caused? Peter Cox Met Office Chair in Climate System Dynamics. Outline

Was the Amazon Drought of 2005 Human-Caused? Peter Cox Met Office Chair in Climate System Dynamics. Outline Was the Amazon Drought of 2005 Human-Caused? Peter Cox Met Office Chair in Climate System Dynamics With thanks to : Phil Harris, Chris Huntingford, Chris Jones, Richard Betts, Matthew Collins, Jose Marengo,

More information

The use of marine data for attribution of climate change and constraining climate predictions

The use of marine data for attribution of climate change and constraining climate predictions The use of marine data for attribution of climate change and constraining climate predictions Peter Stott, Climar III, Thursday 8 May 2008 The use of marine data to: Quantify the contribution of human

More information

the 2 past three decades

the 2 past three decades SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION DOI: 10.1038/NCLIMATE2840 Atlantic-induced 1 pan-tropical climate change over the 2 past three decades 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 POP simulation forced by the Atlantic-induced atmospheric

More information

The Formation of Precipitation Anomaly Patterns during the Developing and Decaying Phases of ENSO

The Formation of Precipitation Anomaly Patterns during the Developing and Decaying Phases of ENSO ATMOSPHERIC AND OCEANIC SCIENCE LETTERS, 2010, VOL. 3, NO. 1, 25 30 The Formation of Precipitation Anomaly Patterns during the Developing and Decaying Phases of ENSO HU Kai-Ming and HUANG Gang State Key

More information

Seasonal to decadal climate prediction: filling the gap between weather forecasts and climate projections

Seasonal to decadal climate prediction: filling the gap between weather forecasts and climate projections Seasonal to decadal climate prediction: filling the gap between weather forecasts and climate projections Doug Smith Walter Orr Roberts memorial lecture, 9 th June 2015 Contents Motivation Practical issues

More information

Detection and Attribution of Climate Change

Detection and Attribution of Climate Change Detection and Attribution of Climate Change What is D&A? Global Mean Temperature Extreme Event Attribution Geert Jan van Oldenborgh, Sjoukje Philip (KNMI) Definitions Detection: demonstrating that climate

More information

Historical Changes in Climate

Historical Changes in Climate Historical Changes in Climate Medieval Warm Period (MWP) Little Ice Age (LIA) Lamb, 1969 Hunters in the snow by Pieter Bruegel, 1565 Retreat of the Rhone Glacier shown by comparing the drawing from 1750

More information

lecture 11 El Niño/Southern Oscillation (ENSO) Part II

lecture 11 El Niño/Southern Oscillation (ENSO) Part II lecture 11 El Niño/Southern Oscillation (ENSO) Part II SYSTEM MEMORY: OCEANIC WAVE PROPAGATION ASYMMETRY BETWEEN THE ATMOSPHERE AND OCEAN The atmosphere and ocean are not symmetrical in their responses

More information

Added-value from initialization in skilful predictions of North Atlantic multi-decadal variability

Added-value from initialization in skilful predictions of North Atlantic multi-decadal variability Added-value from initialization in skilful predictions of North Atlantic multi-decadal variability J. García-Serrano #, V. Guemas &, F. J. Doblas-Reyes * Climate Forecasting Unit (CFU) at Institut Català

More information

Impact of global warming on ENSO clearer now than ever before

Impact of global warming on ENSO clearer now than ever before Impact of global warming on ENSO clearer now than ever before Scott Power, François Delage, Christine Chung ENSO in a warmer climate Guayaquil, Ecuador October 2018 Outline Projected changes in El Niño-driven

More information

How Do We Know That Human Activities Have Influenced Global Climate?

How Do We Know That Human Activities Have Influenced Global Climate? How Do We Know That Human Activities Have Influenced Global Climate? Ben Santer Program for Climate Model Diagnosis and Intercomparison Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, Livermore, CA 94550 Email:

More information

Lecture 8: Natural Climate Variability

Lecture 8: Natural Climate Variability Lecture 8: Natural Climate Variability Extratropics: PNA, NAO, AM (aka. AO), SAM Tropics: MJO Coupled A-O Variability: ENSO Decadal Variability: PDO, AMO Unforced vs. Forced Variability We often distinguish

More information

La Niña impacts on global seasonal weather anomalies: The OLR perspective. Andrew Chiodi and Ed Harrison

La Niña impacts on global seasonal weather anomalies: The OLR perspective. Andrew Chiodi and Ed Harrison La Niña impacts on global seasonal weather anomalies: The OLR perspective Andrew Chiodi and Ed Harrison Outline Motivation Impacts of the El Nino- Southern Oscillation (ENSO) on seasonal weather anomalies

More information

CMIP3/CMIP5 differences: Scenario (SRESA1B vs RCP4.5) Ensemble mean Tas responses: CMIP3 = 2.8 K CMIP5 = 1.9 K CMIP5 higher average resolution

CMIP3/CMIP5 differences: Scenario (SRESA1B vs RCP4.5) Ensemble mean Tas responses: CMIP3 = 2.8 K CMIP5 = 1.9 K CMIP5 higher average resolution CMIP3/CMIP5 differences: Scenario (SRESA1B vs RCP4.5) Ensemble mean Tas responses: CMIP3 = 2.8 K CMIP5 = 1.9 K CMIP5 higher average resolution Several `high-top models in CMIP5 Key question What are

More information

How can we explain possible human contribution to weather events?

How can we explain possible human contribution to weather events? WMO-IPCC Tokyo workshop for weather presenters, November 11, 2015 How can we explain possible human contribution to weather events? Masahiro Watanabe Atmosphere and Ocean Research Institute University

More information

Land Surface Sea Ice Land Ice. (from Our Changing Planet)

Land Surface Sea Ice Land Ice. (from Our Changing Planet) Lecture 5: Land Surface and Cryosphere (Outline) Land Surface Sea Ice Land Ice (from Our Changing Planet) Earth s s Climate System Solar forcing Atmosphere Ocean Land Solid Earth Energy, Water, and Biochemistry

More information

Earth s Climate System. Surface Albedo. Climate Roles of Land Surface. Lecture 5: Land Surface and Cryosphere (Outline) Land Surface Sea Ice Land Ice

Earth s Climate System. Surface Albedo. Climate Roles of Land Surface. Lecture 5: Land Surface and Cryosphere (Outline) Land Surface Sea Ice Land Ice Lecture 5: Land Surface and Cryosphere (Outline) Earth s Climate System Solar forcing Land Surface Sea Ice Land Ice Atmosphere Ocean Land Solid Earth Energy, Water, and Biochemistry Cycles (from Our Changing

More information

Predictability of the duration of La Niña

Predictability of the duration of La Niña Predictability of the duration of La Niña Pedro DiNezio University of Texas Institute for Geophysics (UTIG) CESM Winter Meeting February 9, 2016 Collaborators: C. Deser 1 and Y. Okumura 2 1 NCAR, 2 UTIG

More information

Presentation Overview. Southwestern Climate: Past, present and future. Global Energy Balance. What is climate?

Presentation Overview. Southwestern Climate: Past, present and future. Global Energy Balance. What is climate? Southwestern Climate: Past, present and future Mike Crimmins Climate Science Extension Specialist Dept. of Soil, Water, & Env. Science & Arizona Cooperative Extension The University of Arizona Presentation

More information

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE FORECAST BRIEFING. January 23, 2015 Rick Thoman ESSD Climate Services

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE FORECAST BRIEFING. January 23, 2015 Rick Thoman ESSD Climate Services ALASKA REGION CLIMATE FORECAST BRIEFING January 23, 2015 Rick Thoman ESSD Climate Services Today Climate Forecast Basics Review of recent climate forecasts and conditions CPC Forecasts and observations

More information

Get the Picture: Climate Models

Get the Picture: Climate Models Students will review scientific infographics to test their understanding of the role, contribution, and limitations of climate models in helping us understand Earth s past, present, and future climate

More information

SPECIAL PROJECT PROGRESS REPORT

SPECIAL PROJECT PROGRESS REPORT SPECIAL PROJECT PROGRESS REPORT Progress Reports should be 2 to 10 pages in length, depending on importance of the project. All the following mandatory information needs to be provided. Reporting year

More information

Will a warmer world change Queensland s rainfall?

Will a warmer world change Queensland s rainfall? Will a warmer world change Queensland s rainfall? Nicholas P. Klingaman National Centre for Atmospheric Science-Climate Walker Institute for Climate System Research University of Reading The Walker-QCCCE

More information

Projections of 21st century Arctic sea ice loss. Alexandra Jahn University of Colorado Boulder

Projections of 21st century Arctic sea ice loss. Alexandra Jahn University of Colorado Boulder Projections of 21st century Arctic sea ice loss Alexandra Jahn University of Colorado Boulder Outline Sea ice projections/ensembles 101 How is Arctic sea ice projected to change in the 21 st century? State

More information

Interpretation of Outputs from Numerical Prediction System

Interpretation of Outputs from Numerical Prediction System Interpretation of Outputs from Numerical Prediction System Hiroshi OHNO Tokyo Climate Center (TCC)/ Climate Prediction Division of Japan Meteorological Agency (JMA) Procedure of Seasonal Forecast (1) 1.

More information

The Stratospheric Link Between the Sun and Climate

The Stratospheric Link Between the Sun and Climate The Stratospheric Link Between the Sun and Climate The Stratospheric Link Between the Sun and Climate Mark P. Baldwin Northwest Research Associates, USA SORCE, 27 October 2004 Overview Climatology of the

More information

Climate Forecast Applications Network (CFAN)

Climate Forecast Applications Network (CFAN) Forecast of 2018 Atlantic Hurricane Activity April 5, 2018 Summary CFAN s inaugural April seasonal forecast for Atlantic tropical cyclone activity is based on systematic interactions among ENSO, stratospheric

More information

PMIP3/CMIP5 Last Millennium Model Simulation Effort

PMIP3/CMIP5 Last Millennium Model Simulation Effort PMIP3/CMIP5 Last Millennium Model Simulation Effort Bette Otto-Bliesner and Steven Phipps National Center for Atmospheric Research, Boulder, Colorado University of New South Wales, Sydney Outline Background

More information

Initialization Shock in CCSM4 Decadal Prediction Experiments

Initialization Shock in CCSM4 Decadal Prediction Experiments Initialization Shock in CCSM4 Decadal Prediction Experiments Haiyan Teng, Gerald A. Meehl, Grant Branstator, Stephen Yeager, Alicia Karspeck National Center for Atmospheric Research, Boulder, USA Introduction

More information

Haiyan Teng. Curriculum Vita

Haiyan Teng. Curriculum Vita Haiyan Teng Curriculum Vita Climate Change Research Section (CCR) Climate and Global Dynamics Division (CGD) National Center for Atmospheric Research 1850 Table Mesa Dr, Boulder, CO 80305 Tel: (303)497-1728

More information

Assessment of the Earth s Energy and Sea Level Changes

Assessment of the Earth s Energy and Sea Level Changes Assessment of the Earth s Energy and Sea Level Changes John A. Church1, Ma0hew D. Palmer2 and Susan Wijffels1 1CSIRO Oceans and Atmosphere, Hobart, Australia 2Met Office Hadley Centre, Exeter, United Kingdom

More information

HURRICANES AND CLIMATE

HURRICANES AND CLIMATE HURRICANES AND CLIMATE CURRENT CHALLENGES Gabriel A. Vecchi NOAA/GFDL, Princeton, NJ Image: NASA. GOALS Document changes in hurricane statistics, with as little inhomogeneity as possible and quantified

More information

Ocean-Atmosphere Interactions and El Niño Lisa Goddard

Ocean-Atmosphere Interactions and El Niño Lisa Goddard Ocean-Atmosphere Interactions and El Niño Lisa Goddard Advanced Training Institute on Climatic Variability and Food Security 2002 July 9, 2002 Coupled Behavior in tropical Pacific SST Winds Upper Ocean

More information

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE FORECAST BRIEFING. October 27, 2017 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE FORECAST BRIEFING. October 27, 2017 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region ALASKA REGION CLIMATE FORECAST BRIEFING October 27, 2017 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region Today Feature of the month: West Pacific Typhoons Climate Forecast Basics Climate System Review

More information

THE RELATION AMONG SEA ICE, SURFACE TEMPERATURE, AND ATMOSPHERIC CIRCULATION IN SIMULATIONS OF FUTURE CLIMATE

THE RELATION AMONG SEA ICE, SURFACE TEMPERATURE, AND ATMOSPHERIC CIRCULATION IN SIMULATIONS OF FUTURE CLIMATE THE RELATION AMONG SEA ICE, SURFACE TEMPERATURE, AND ATMOSPHERIC CIRCULATION IN SIMULATIONS OF FUTURE CLIMATE Bitz, C. M., Polar Science Center, University of Washington, U.S.A. Introduction Observations

More information

Supplementary Figure 1 Trends of annual mean maximum ocean mixed layer depth. Trends from uninitialized simulations (a) and assimilation simulation

Supplementary Figure 1 Trends of annual mean maximum ocean mixed layer depth. Trends from uninitialized simulations (a) and assimilation simulation Supplementary Figure 1 Trends of annual mean maximum ocean mixed layer depth. Trends from uninitialized simulations (a) and assimilation simulation (b) from 1970-1995 (units: m yr -1 ). The dots show grids

More information

Advancing decadal-scale climate prediction in the North Atlantic Sector Noel Keenlyside

Advancing decadal-scale climate prediction in the North Atlantic Sector Noel Keenlyside Advancing decadal-scale climate prediction in the North Atlantic Sector Noel Keenlyside M. Latif, J. Jungclaus, L. Kornblueh, E. Roeckner, V. Semenov & W. Park IPCC, 2007 How warm will be the next decade?

More information

ENSO Cycle: Recent Evolution, Current Status and Predictions. Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP July 26, 2004

ENSO Cycle: Recent Evolution, Current Status and Predictions. Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP July 26, 2004 ENSO Cycle: Recent Evolution, Current Status and Predictions Update prepared by Climate Prediction Center / NCEP July 26, 2004 Outline Overview Recent Evolution and Current Conditions Oceanic NiZo Index

More information

Supplementary Figure 1 Observed change in wind and vertical motion. Anomalies are regime differences between periods and obtained

Supplementary Figure 1 Observed change in wind and vertical motion. Anomalies are regime differences between periods and obtained Supplementary Figure 1 Observed change in wind and vertical motion. Anomalies are regime differences between periods 1999 2013 and 1979 1998 obtained from ERA-interim. Vectors are horizontal wind at 850

More information

Decadal prediction using a recent series of MIROC global climate models

Decadal prediction using a recent series of MIROC global climate models PICES2011 @ Khabarovsk (20 October 2011) Decadal prediction using a recent series of MIROC global climate models Takashi Mochizuki (JAMSTEC, Japan) M. Kimoto, Y. Chikamoto, M. Watanabe, M. Mori (AORI,

More information

Assessing recent declines in Upper Rio Grande River runoff efficiency from a paleoclimate perspective

Assessing recent declines in Upper Rio Grande River runoff efficiency from a paleoclimate perspective Assessing recent declines in Upper Rio Grande River runoff efficiency from a paleoclimate perspective Flavio Lehner, Andrew Wood Eugene Wahl Dagmar Llewellyn, Douglas Blatchford NCAR Research Applications

More information

Malawi. General Climate. UNDP Climate Change Country Profiles. C. McSweeney 1, M. New 1,2 and G. Lizcano 1

Malawi. General Climate. UNDP Climate Change Country Profiles. C. McSweeney 1, M. New 1,2 and G. Lizcano 1 UNDP Climate Change Country Profiles Malawi C. McSweeney 1, M. New 1,2 and G. Lizcano 1 1. School of Geography and Environment, University of Oxford. 2. Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research http://country-profiles.geog.ox.ac.uk

More information

ENSO Amplitude Change in Observation and Coupled Models

ENSO Amplitude Change in Observation and Coupled Models ADVANCES IN ATMOSPHERIC SCIENCES, VOL. 25, NO. 3, 28, 361 366 ENSO Amplitude Change in Observation and Coupled Models ZHANG Qiong 1 (Ü ), GUAN Yue 1,3 (' ff), and YANG Haijun 2 (fl ) 1 State Key Laboratory

More information

The North Atlantic Oscillation: Climatic Significance and Environmental Impact

The North Atlantic Oscillation: Climatic Significance and Environmental Impact 1 The North Atlantic Oscillation: Climatic Significance and Environmental Impact James W. Hurrell National Center for Atmospheric Research Climate and Global Dynamics Division, Climate Analysis Section

More information

Solar variability and Climate Change

Solar variability and Climate Change Solar variability and Climate Change Ulrich Cubasch Freie Universität, Berlin Joint work with Fidel Gonzalez-Rouco, Tom Crowley, Gabi Hegerl, Stefanie Legutke, Jürg Luterbacher, Ulrich Schlese, Hans von

More information

The scientific basis for climate change projections: History, Status, Unsolved problems

The scientific basis for climate change projections: History, Status, Unsolved problems The scientific basis for climate change projections: History, Status, Unsolved problems Isaac Held, Princeton, Feb 2008 Katrina-like storm spontaneously generated in atmospheric model Regions projected

More information

Climate Variability. Andy Hoell - Earth and Environmental Systems II 13 April 2011

Climate Variability. Andy Hoell - Earth and Environmental Systems II 13 April 2011 Climate Variability Andy Hoell - andrew_hoell@uml.edu Earth and Environmental Systems II 13 April 2011 The Earth System Earth is made of several components that individually change throughout time, interact

More information

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE OUTLOOK BRIEFING. June 22, 2018 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE OUTLOOK BRIEFING. June 22, 2018 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region ALASKA REGION CLIMATE OUTLOOK BRIEFING June 22, 2018 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region Today s Outline Feature of the month: Ocean Warmth Headed into Summer Climate Forecast Basics Climate

More information

Climate Modeling Dr. Jehangir Ashraf Awan Pakistan Meteorological Department

Climate Modeling Dr. Jehangir Ashraf Awan Pakistan Meteorological Department Climate Modeling Dr. Jehangir Ashraf Awan Pakistan Meteorological Department Source: Slides partially taken from A. Pier Siebesma, KNMI & TU Delft Key Questions What is a climate model? What types of climate

More information

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE OUTLOOK BRIEFING. July 20, 2018 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE OUTLOOK BRIEFING. July 20, 2018 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region ALASKA REGION CLIMATE OUTLOOK BRIEFING July 20, 2018 Rick Thoman National Weather Service Alaska Region Today s Outline Feature of the month: 2018 Wildfire Season Update Climate Forecast Basics Climate

More information

Forced and internal variability of tropical cyclone track density in the western North Pacific

Forced and internal variability of tropical cyclone track density in the western North Pacific Forced and internal variability of tropical cyclone track density in the western North Pacific Wei Mei 1 Shang-Ping Xie 1, Ming Zhao 2 & Yuqing Wang 3 Climate Variability and Change and Paleoclimate Working

More information

Mechanisms Contributing to the Warming Hole and the Consequent U.S. East West Differential of Heat Extremes

Mechanisms Contributing to the Warming Hole and the Consequent U.S. East West Differential of Heat Extremes 6394 J O U R N A L O F C L I M A T E VOLUME 25 Mechanisms Contributing to the Warming Hole and the Consequent U.S. East West Differential of Heat Extremes GERALD A. MEEHL National Center for Atmospheric

More information

Climate Modeling and Downscaling

Climate Modeling and Downscaling Climate Modeling and Downscaling Types of climate-change experiments: a preview 1) What-if sensitivity experiments increase the optically active gases and aerosols according to an assumed scenario, and

More information

Winter Forecast for GPC Tokyo. Shotaro TANAKA Tokyo Climate Center (TCC) Japan Meteorological Agency (JMA)

Winter Forecast for GPC Tokyo. Shotaro TANAKA Tokyo Climate Center (TCC) Japan Meteorological Agency (JMA) Winter Forecast for 2013 2014 GPC Tokyo Shotaro TANAKA Tokyo Climate Center (TCC) Japan Meteorological Agency (JMA) NEACOF 5, October 29 November 1, 2013 1 Outline 1. Numerical prediction 2. Interannual

More information

AMERICAN METEOROLOGICAL SOCIETY

AMERICAN METEOROLOGICAL SOCIETY AMERICAN METEOROLOGICAL SOCIETY Journal of Climate EARLY ONLINE RELEASE This is a preliminary PDF of the author-produced manuscript that has been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication. Since it is

More information

European temperatures prior to the 20 th century fundamentally a consequence of unforced variability? (Bengtsson et al., 2006)

European temperatures prior to the 20 th century fundamentally a consequence of unforced variability? (Bengtsson et al., 2006) 01-12-2000 1 European temperatures prior to the 20 th century fundamentally a consequence of unforced variability? (Bengtsson et al., 2006) Not really (Hegerl, Luterbacher et al. 2011 NGeo) Observations

More information

Externally forced and internal variability in multi-decadal climate evolution

Externally forced and internal variability in multi-decadal climate evolution Externally forced and internal variability in multi-decadal climate evolution During the last 150 years, the increasing atmospheric concentration of anthropogenic greenhouse gases has been the main driver

More information

Lecture 28: Observed Climate Variability and Change

Lecture 28: Observed Climate Variability and Change Lecture 28: Observed Climate Variability and Change 1. Introduction This chapter focuses on 6 questions - Has the climate warmed? Has the climate become wetter? Are the atmosphere/ocean circulations changing?

More information

Operational event attribution

Operational event attribution Operational event attribution Peter Stott, NCAR, 26 January, 2009 August 2003 Events July 2007 January 2009 January 2009 Is global warming slowing down? Arctic Sea Ice Climatesafety.org climatesafety.org

More information

Quantifying Weather and Climate Impacts on Health in Developing Countries (QWeCI)

Quantifying Weather and Climate Impacts on Health in Developing Countries (QWeCI) Quantifying Weather and Climate Impacts on Health in Developing Countries (QWeCI) Science Talk QWeCI is funded by the European Commission s Seventh Framework Research Programme under the grant agreement

More information

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE FORECAST BRIEFING. December 15, 2014 Rick Thoman NWS Alaska Region ESSD Climate Services

ALASKA REGION CLIMATE FORECAST BRIEFING. December 15, 2014 Rick Thoman NWS Alaska Region ESSD Climate Services ALASKA REGION CLIMATE FORECAST BRIEFING December 15, 2014 Rick Thoman NWS Alaska Region ESSD Climate Services Today Climate Forecast Basics Review of recent climate forecasts and conditions CPC Forecasts

More information

THE PACIFIC DECADAL OSCILLATION, REVISITED. Matt Newman, Mike Alexander, and Dima Smirnov CIRES/University of Colorado and NOAA/ESRL/PSD

THE PACIFIC DECADAL OSCILLATION, REVISITED. Matt Newman, Mike Alexander, and Dima Smirnov CIRES/University of Colorado and NOAA/ESRL/PSD THE PACIFIC DECADAL OSCILLATION, REVISITED Matt Newman, Mike Alexander, and Dima Smirnov CIRES/University of Colorado and NOAA/ESRL/PSD PDO and ENSO ENSO forces remote changes in global oceans via the

More information

Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis

Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis Climate Change 2007: The Physical Science Basis Working Group I Contribution to the IPCC Fourth Assessment Report Presented by R.K. Pachauri, IPCC Chair and Bubu Jallow, WG 1 Vice Chair Nairobi, 6 February

More information

Suriname. General Climate. Recent Climate Trends. UNDP Climate Change Country Profiles. Temperature. C. McSweeney 1, M. New 1,2 and G.

Suriname. General Climate. Recent Climate Trends. UNDP Climate Change Country Profiles. Temperature. C. McSweeney 1, M. New 1,2 and G. UNDP Climate Change Country Profiles Suriname C. McSweeney 1, M. New 1,2 and G. Lizcano 1 1. School of Geography and Environment, University of Oxford. 2. Tyndall Centre for Climate Change Research http://country-profiles.geog.ox.ac.uk

More information

Effects of Black Carbon on Temperature Lapse Rates

Effects of Black Carbon on Temperature Lapse Rates Effects of Black Carbon on Temperature Lapse Rates Joyce E. Penner 1 Minghuai Wang 1, Akshay Kumar 1, Leon Rotstayn 2, Ben Santer 1 University of Michigan, 2 CSIRO, 3 LLNL Thanks to Warren Washington and

More information

Antarctic sea ice changes natural or anthropogenic? Will Hobbs

Antarctic sea ice changes natural or anthropogenic? Will Hobbs Antarctic sea ice changes natural or anthropogenic? Will Hobbs When is a trend not a trend? Antarctic sea ice trends are significant (compared to our 35-year record), but are they significant compared

More information

Decadal modulation of global surface temperature by internal climate variability

Decadal modulation of global surface temperature by internal climate variability SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION DOI: 10.1038/NCLIMATE2605 Decadal modulation of global surface temperature by internal climate variability 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28

More information

Fossil coral snapshots of ENSO and tropical Pacific climate over the late Holocene

Fossil coral snapshots of ENSO and tropical Pacific climate over the late Holocene Fossil coral snapshots of ENSO and tropical Pacific climate over the late Holocene Kim Cobb Georgia Inst. of Technology Chris Charles Scripps Inst of Oceanography Larry Edwards Hai Cheng University of

More information

Impacts of Climate on the Corn Belt

Impacts of Climate on the Corn Belt Impacts of Climate on the Corn Belt Great Lakes Crop Summit 2015 2015 Evelyn Browning Garriss Conclusions Climate change is not linear. It ebbs and flows. Recent polar volcano eruptions created a cool

More information

Arctic sea ice in IPCC climate scenarios in view of the 2007 record low sea ice event A comment by Ralf Döscher, Michael Karcher and Frank Kauker

Arctic sea ice in IPCC climate scenarios in view of the 2007 record low sea ice event A comment by Ralf Döscher, Michael Karcher and Frank Kauker Arctic sea ice in IPCC climate scenarios in view of the 2007 record low sea ice event A comment by Ralf Döscher, Michael Karcher and Frank Kauker Fig. 1: Arctic September sea ice extent in observations

More information

NSF Expeditions in Computing. Understanding Climate Change: A Data Driven Approach. Vipin Kumar University of Minnesota

NSF Expeditions in Computing. Understanding Climate Change: A Data Driven Approach. Vipin Kumar University of Minnesota NSF Expeditions in Computing Understanding Climate Change: A Data Driven Approach Vipin Kumar University of Minnesota kumar@cs.umn.edu www.cs.umn.edu/~kumar Vipin Kumar UCC Aug 15, 2011 Climate Change:

More information