BAO errors from past / future surveys. Reid et al. 2015, arxiv:

Transcription

1 BAO errors from past / future surveys Reid et al. 2015, arxiv:

2 Dark Energy Survey (DES) New wide-field camera on the 4m Blanco telescope Survey started, with first year of data in hand Ω = 5,000deg 2 multi-colour optical imaging (g,r,i,z) with link to IR data from VISTA hemisphere survey 300,000,000 galaxies Aim is to constrain dark energy using 4 probes LSS/BAO, weak lensing, supernovae cluster number density Redshifts based on photometry weak radial measurements weak redshift-space distortions See also: Pan-STARRS, VST-VISTA, SkyMapper

3 eboss / SDSS-IV The new cosmology project with SDSS Use the Sloan telescope and MOS to observe to higher redshift Basic parameters Ω = 1,500deg2 7,500deg2 300, <z<0.9 LRGs (direct BAO) 200, <z<1.0 ELGs (direct BAO) 600, <z<2.2 QSOs (direct BAO) 60,000 QSOs (BAO from Ly-α forest) Distance measurements 0.9% at z=0.8 (LRGs) 1.8% at z=0.9 (ELGs) 2.0% at z=1.5 (QSOs) 1.1% at z=2.5 (Ly-α forest, inc. BOSS) Survey started 2014, lasting 6 years

4 eboss quasar targets Myers et al. 2015; arxiv:

5 DESI Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) New fibre-fed MOS for Mayall just passed DOE CD-2, on course for 2019 start STFC funding through PPRP (PI: WJP) provided buy-in for 3 UK institutes (Durham, Ports, UCL, +5 scientists including 2 at IoA) Durham providing fibre system UCL providing optical corrector DESI will observe Ω =14,000deg 2 ~20,000,000 galaxies (direct BAO) ~10,000,000 low redshift (z<0.5) galaxies ~600,000 quasars (BAO from Ly-α forest) Cosmic variance limited to z ~ 1.4 Also WEAVE (WHT, 2018 start) and 4MOST (VISTA, 2021 start) but fewer fibres, so less optimized for cosmological applications

6 MOS on 10m-telescope New fibre-fed spectroscopes proposed for 10m telescopes Hobby-Eberly (HETDEX) Subaru (PFS) Different baseline strategies HETDEX 420deg 2 Ly-alpha emitters 800,000 galaxies 1.9<z<3.5 Greig, Komatsu & Wyithe, 2012, arxiv: PFS 1400deg 2 ELGs 3,000,000 galaxies 0.6<z<2.4 Ellis et al., 2012, arxiv:

7 The Euclid surveys M2 mission in ESA cosmic visions program Wide survey: 15,000deg2 4 passes over sky NIR Photometry Y, J, H 24mag, 5σ point source NIR slitless spectroscopy red: μm (0.9<z<1.8 Hα) ergcm-2s-1 3.5σ line flux 3 dispersion directions 1 broad waveband 0.9<z<1.8 ~25M galaxies wide-band visible image for WL Deep survey: 40deg2 48 dithers 12 passes, as for wide survey additional blue spectra: μm dispersion directions for 12 passes >10deg apart

8 Euclid cosmology summary RSD + WL BAO + WL

9 Euclid astrophysics Wide survey 15,000 deg 2 YJH AB =24 would take 680 years with VISTA Deep survey 40 deg 2 YJH AB =26 would take 72 years with VISTA Table by Jarle Brinchmann

10 BOSS CMASS DR9 galaxy clustering BOSS CMASS galaxies at z~0.57 Total effective volume V eff = 2.2 Gpc 3 Anderson et al. 2012; arxiv:

11 Predicted Euclid galaxy clustering Redshift slice 0.9 < z < 1.1 Total effective volume (of Euclid) V eff = 57.4 Gpc 3 Similar leap forwards for DESI Future emphasis on systematics!

12 Worrying about astrophysics Ross et al. 2014, MNRAS 437, 1109

13 Getting the statistical analysis correct Given a set of mocks, we can form three possible estimates of the errors: 1. From the individual likelihood surface from each mock 2. From the distribution of recovered measurements from the set of mocks 3. From the distribution of a set of mocks not used to calculate the covariance matrix Naïve expectation: these should all agree! The estimates are biased in subtly different ways given errors in the covariance matrix Percival et al. 2013: arxiv:

14 Fast mock catalogues with L-PICOLA New method produced by PhD Student Cullan Howlett ( ) Start with COLA: splitting 2LPT out from EoM T[ res ] + T [D1 ] 1 + T [D2 ] 2 d2 X dx +H T [X] = 2 d d +r =0 Planar parallelization Lightcones on the fly Used to create low redshift mocks for the SDSS Main Galaxy Sample Enabled BAO, RSD measurements at low redshift Code public on Github: Howlett et al. 2015; arxiv: , Howlett et al. 2014; arxiv: , Ross et al. 2014; arxiv:

15 Summary of (selected) future surveys Survey start date No. of gals / 10 6 redshift range area / deg 2 DES <z< eboss <z< DESI <z< DESI:Bright <z< Euclid <z< Forthcoming surveys extremely exciting, but will require methodology & simulation development to reach statistical limit